Karnataka High Court
Syed Sadiq vs G Thippaiah S/O Jogappa on 31 October, 2011
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda
Bench: B.Sreenivase Gowda
T .§£§ Efiflfifififififi
ifié' '§'§§E Efififi QQEEERT §F "
§£¥§'E§ 35E-£I§ THE 333"? fififi' §F $Ci'f§'§BER§ 2&1 3
§3'}E*Z§3'{}RZE§
'EE§E E§$}'§*ELE S JEESTECE §.SREE§§§i?'§SE fififififfifi
zsmxa, 2%. E33} $1? 2&3}. gm}
: ' ,
§v1.F£.&.I\§$$g 1132 ME 1133.§O§§' _
EN §iF.§s mgwzexa; " & A V'
EE'§.°"iE%E§'§
3513:} sA:_>§Q _
gm. 593.31g 35¢'; @ SY"Ei'§}~,.E3E-i€§E*L%, ..
;'%,GE§ 25 YiEZ,;=XR$, * * - 1 * "
Rgg, G,<,?%%§;>;:§§:?~3_5:3§*;:;s*§_ .E"2;:;'>-.é5g;£':::,V' "
CE*§E'§'§%V;'§E}UEEé1V;%T'g.V-- 5';?i;? 5Q':-._ _ -
. 5§§3}3§€Z§;i',£'xNT
_ . {By SEE. E%§2;:m:?>:.:'; Q-:z*;x2: .s7':?V7§f:
SRE, §;:a:.::;:;1%~.::::..sa _§*<_.5 £aE}E?"",§
'
9. " -__{:'Q'"§"§}§E.Ef>§¥>.%?i;§Eaéé5
Siifi gs:.:;:;a;>§fza§
§%:§;'%»§O3E§,
{::'%._%:"ira§'E:,:i:; $2? 2:'§2_;2:';'z*::§R~':'§;:;§Ems:
V' " Ei§§:}EE%;fi'*=§€} §~%';Ei{}.?€€},§*§f§;§€§;"?~§%i?;§§§~2fi?
"E{ {E 3%M.E'%:'§;*E.§€:.§€:"x.E'*§:%§'%.:'%§JEJE, §"§.55:§§€z%.§, §{}$"%f',
'A {iE"'§§'1'E21%E}{§§??;{}§: 'E}'%;1.E§ E4;
' {FEE-72'$E€}E'£2%.§; £'=gE;'*af§3;5':{§E%ZE1?.§
§,h'%E§'Z.'§§§IE §?€§L}§;-K §f'3$€§§§;f'%§'*€{f.§{i {if} Ef§'Ei}__.
Ef}§'=f'i.i$§{}§'~§.,€%.§.x {}§'I§?'§{}E%3, ?%z'E..E':r'§.§<~Z {f§}§;E§3E...§~ZZ*i..
_ {gm E 'ag,"g.x ;;s_,;'=.-- - -<s;u;..\-,.. . -"-9'
EEAIEV;-'%f'€g%{i§E2}-~EE?Z [~ 5?{} {REE 5
. Dd 2% E38?-}{}?€ET} EiZ?\E'§E%
£55; Sr?" £73 £1 E%Ef:§%:'E.'§-'§£*1§€'.g'%§y'§§'%. Eifié}, Aiffiiip E*='{}§¥i $.52,
R3 ?*§{}'E'§C§%I E'3§S?E§N;';§§§i.} 'Jv'§'§.'§"'E§
':"';--1'13 'i"«gEE-'2'~'a FEL£:ZEj} UXS :?3g: 3 0%' IvE"x£' 1-"a{':'E" ;f3a;:;;2.4;'§x;§'§'
-'§"-M: JU'§}G?vEEiZE'~E'f m~£_:3 A2mR:;> E13A'E"E¥-Li} 233: Liza :9 Z¥:?'Af:'>Se.£E';EZ%
ER' E'€E'éfC @252. :::;?;*2:a;_z> {EN mi: FELES GE?' £~"R§'E'"\3'%:§if§?%z*x;§;.§._' _
&Z_fE}€%E3 {Sm.>N,; 5;: mm' 3'aI}E}E'§'§if}i\;;«'-ii. g-.,;§.2:;s<:f_¥f;_*
Ci'--§':":":s%.z»:.:>%:3:<zGA. ;~>§ap:s':;:' AELOWENQE *1':-fie: {*§;A.§ET§%§~,E3'E£?§'§"f'§0:xE -« V. '
EKBEE {i{}I?s/'§E53E}I.'€E':;'%'§'§{}E'J ;a.r~::.;> S§€E§2%€:H'€'{f2"-E§i'€E--§,:'§1'?~E€T;§%;§:¥f§._§%:l\é*EX03
€{}MPEif%§S;'%.'§"§GN=
XE'? E%§§*',A. 1 };33fg$3. E
BET _::::;;_;:.
SUHAEL,
:3/9. JAE\*§£i%U .%§.§H££§15.E.2A'f§:'P\v13:r'E..:é'1;"%i.,E""<: $5.25;
ASEEEE 23 ¥"E:AE{S, x ..
R,/G. E;:E{3§}'§E?*;€?;E'3 2 _ _
C;-{m2;;;;':3 Liifififig' ';:*';>»_:%':2'* >53 3 ~---- ., '
fig} E7 E3
3 _§ {raga Sr; :3 ¢::3§é;a:az§'::§:}g 2':.E}"&-', 5;:
_ :~3;;2?2;;; §:zE;.:Ejz;"'¥?€f\'£1{§xE€.EREEEYGE
5 ~ V "5;-. '§'E"§E'§?%§'>:%Eg%£1"§,
1.3 ;:;;§§ eh-:a:%{:2xa';>2:>;aM <::£;;2%:%£~:§§ {>:§? "E"Rj§€C'E'{}E1{'E"'.E%j7aEE;EiZE<i .. §i%EJ;'>:§€§N'{; E'€E'i{}, 1'=éf{}a§{A. :é;s;':*~&~:2 2 9-25}. V "'-W9. B{mg:2é:za£»<;'KA_z~;;';%E---351%:& 3---:;g.§§;a:,, ;»>{:;:*s-":1 ' ' -- --«i::s~::':'2%;::,;L§§%:{;,r: "_§_:za:::,'a:;%:; my-'§:=;';:>r~§;z:,. :%v:;:m<::;:2q ?f'*~i§"E"'§{§-31'} §E'\£E}§;'1 §.§'a?;§{E;E€g%f\;?{fE%: {$8. §._3§§3w EEEEEE-E%«I{}?€§%.§T, {}§7'?§siTE%I.;
75%'? E1? Eio {,i{}'§'*a/i§}'§.;Et=:X.., §'%.§{.:v{;'%..7I%s'§.z%mE"-§'5%.§.."} E51? E _§€{'§'%Fz§C3; §}i2'€5'&?*€{}'§fZE{§C ~ :'33'17€} {K} E .
. ,, §-4{E%2S§.1'{}§\§Ef}§'ZN"E'$ Eiifiy $23.. E3 C .?3§§§%Z'§"'§§z'i§'{;*iE'v'§§': E§2'%€:}; §X,E'}"v": §'{}E-TE R229 R. .1 ?~J(}'§'E{I E3 §}§Si§5}§*§§'«§E§'E::§'} "*2,-"2f§"§.'§"-'EE '§"§"§ES §%'.'E§?é% EEEL-E*:-Ki} '€558 55.353} {}§*"' I'~z§"'»:" 3&3'? S'?
"§'E~*£E€l JU'iI}G'MIEZE\lT' {ENE} €%'%§fjX.RE} E'}.5¥',§'E-E-§}:23, E E :20 3; Q _4E?%§i§gS£§_I} EN FJEVC §\E®'§:18/2€}EO SN "§'§"§EZ §3'§E,E¥{Z GTE? TEEEE §EiNE_i_.}Rj "E§.§V§£; 32333;: .;aN£;> {§J1"¢E, AE}§}E'F£QE'€'AL rvzgc'?-, Ci-»::i;?:r:2;:1>V:' _ §>iA_R'§'z;**y ;a:,,mw;N<> ':*m-';. <::.gm2 E?3ES'E'§'§f§GiZ'€'-.. '§E'<>:'2,; CGM§3E€?%SAC'E'§GN §§Ni§} siigskzzxcw §£IxEE§.;?%;E*?\;¥i"iE§E§i_§v?E§;§'é7E5 4- _{}*T§"*' C C? §'E%:§'§ §£%.T§ .
"fE:£.3.s;s3 £1§}§}€':£fl$ c<:s_m':.§:;:§;<}:';. f{>§'V__€}';%z;§s;%':"ss. §§iu?:i;*vs§'ay;:.' {7i<:»m"ig {§€§§"v'€?§°€;f{i '::%":£,=: :§"€>2§<}w§:.§T§§:«-.._V °V£§B§§§§§5 _g%s$V__VT§:E§'$$¥&: 'V«:f§E?_1i§"s;s;;"'« arésirzg am: 05 3:
{",?€}i'E}E"§1:Q§ET§._'§_E;iCX§§-g:f?§'3E7%I :EZ¥§fi1*«_{:§'1Eif§Ef{3E}f1 ::i'§?§.?'EH'{§;S Q? Elhfif "Fr:¥'m:}::a§§ 13323:; 336: h%:_a§*<73; '§:V:;ggéf!:,hs::;";;{im:i:i.€:i a.::";.€§ d.§5_;p{}s:;sé af finzfiijg _ bf; si:*<.>::1§'§1€};:"1_--§§,§dgg:f;":&éz:€;.4 §?{_§':'~é:',E2§%"':=§2§h1<:<;% £25 €;E{}§}'w"$IE§é?§"§{f€3 §;3;§"*€'.:i€s§§ :*';*:1?'e:,-*=::§':'°@:s;'_§; is as ijféay é,:--4%§=éj_ §%;%'§'<%:°a"€:§E is 3?: éhéi €::§a.Em §€':;ii::?<}§: b<:§<}§°€: 4:13:26
-- V ._ '§"E"§'§'z,.2.:":;:§«;_ '§'§'§%;'fE"§"t is; :29 {E§$§}L:.i::% r&é§;:2:*£§'§:;g§ §}""§§E.§E'i%;%f.§ ,<e;'::.;§;§'42?:E.§'":€:{.§ bf; :::*1;23:Zm2i§2i. mzezzi §:**2:§§§<? :»'.2,.<%<?:§{§{;%:';'§ 3%;
Mt {_><'.*:;"uz'2"a%§:§ <33": .E_4§,{}2.2{}{}E% :::E:.:a:-2» iii'; .:":;z%E": a:1<.§ E'i€?§§§§g§¥;%E3§. szirissmgg <3»? 'E':'2~:«:fE.{,>:"-«'§"';'a':E:33' §}{?2i?iEE§§ i'"Et§;§§%§'§IIf&iiZi€fi}1'E 'F'\E+:}¢ E{E§--E%§;'"§'-é?.§2E£§--§%22{} hj; E":;e-2 {.§:'i¥t?§' zmii E§23§<}i§i§..y sf 4;
E{SE'{'§'€L2, Ehe: a:>:';E§; ;3aim'. §I§'E23;'£' z%;%m:«;s.§.:'1é:; f{."§1€'"'--« zrm' <:£>:3s;§;§€z"a.%;.is:}z'1 in i;':'*:<*: 2-ippsai is:
W'E:€:':E1€F Q'i1E:E"3;§'.'ii3§}1 :3? {E9132p«s:%'::%ésa;::1E{:j:§». "
2m*21:"d§%:§ by §E%:a:=; "E":"i%}a.m2:i is jubsi. §:7.§,fi'{.;§"E:}i°'€%}:fM3?{3%'~ GE' iiaesg ii: ixaii §{}§" s::1_E";21§':<:s:ms3:f;1:'?' .. " ' V ' 4%. Ai'3i,€:§ ?.:<-?;i:"é:2§; 'Eh? Eé:=a:'_m-.=%::§ C';}L:§:V;'-3&3 §'<i$rv_ ?{::¥1'a:": ';}2":;='riii~:é;éé"- arggi §3:'3~§*:.::4;§m§;j§ {he j::d§§§:*:&§1€:: ;#;':<:§;:"'§":--1w:;_r:§;"sgféfiifiz if£§'i_ii'1a§g E am :3»? {he 's;£€"a,%,-Y t%1zr:»{.fh~:==; <:{:§:1;}é;'::§*:é:;;3i.£'€2;2 21Wa:9d€;%€Ii by é:h§=:
y§1°§bi§E1€§,§VES--.EEK}? é;::':f£E Fit;-i-E'§§i}Zi':23'i}§{?§ ii ég an $239 §0w{:r Siée a;:é'e:'E '£:}1<:{3"§'§:.riV{:r<:%':':§;%;.Ess..§t§e::§:;:é\.«{v€{E £10 be €:':1haz:q:€§'§. Es§§*','é;§ :33 1 ;2i'§3-§_,,':' mfg §&14§£2§}%B »:3;;» '"?E.1'§3 :;':};}2*%;;§;:;:3;2:m', 1:1 §:§3:Z:=3 éféifiéfi §T:a{§ :=;:':,§5:;1'i:.::§:1§:<§ §§."§.§'L§§'I§€S ii} H :9? zéghé, §7€tE':.'::::* a::1{§. iE":.%s--_:; Z'§j:F§"§'. Efiggg 31$ 2a.:':*:;}":.:§;5:*é.€€.': :a::..§'":.{§; E26": :'%i.§$§',€z§IE€i?€j§. i§':_§':.:§°;; :}%m§* E:*::f§'. :.:;;;g:s§*:.2:'° arzzz. * ::§:)::-:'§<::€: E§3;.ES§;é:E§€E.é?{§; srafiezi. é;:*€:a§::§:§3':'2':. :.:«,§EA;€::': by E32": 2§'§"€f:
€":'?f§.{§.€:'}f"§§ fréém ':v<§':,z.3:":{i i:€:':*€.§i€i{:é23;.§,:;? E2§;.E3'~%§§ {§§és<i§":2::°§;{::* {:21:'{"§i=; E23»; E12? d§&:~;2:2§}.1EE§§,§z {'::é2'°'§:§§§<':;::§.<:t E233 E?' 312.. :>g:--:'2::§;' §'§%§::s:i: :
N, .x><s.<%§»%'>§%.
5:"
E23»; E3--2E§;5% :»2;:'3<:§ é.m§}g}{}§°§{>{'§ ?:::»}4-' {}§'§:'i§ €,'.','%="f§.{f§i??E'§€;'.€;'i". cs? i:'§':<:* :%Ea§m;:.::$%;:' zmié <'§<,§<%%:<'}:* é-:*::?<z.a:':'1%n<%{iZ 313 §'3":2iF E am;§ é E"€j?€i%§'l1§;?{"f§i§¥§":3:a/fb EBW 4 E12: §'~€2:§<:::*~;'_r;-E":; §Eé:i:':$ E:§§E."§"E.€;T*.{.'§ in Ezisig am->i.<£s:':_':<:%e: E'E1::f;, %:;§:£% <t12%.§:":1z'u%:é E235; ;~es:.::f'*:%"e:"<:{.§ dE$;::%_3§§§€.:g5 5;? 2;:§'~f'zE; is ::;3;>€::" Eimb 21:25.3 8§% E10 izm-*c%r i1?§:';'§ié' '5i.:§31€ '§':"§b:.::'m1 Eigass :Z?{}§'1Si{§€f§'%I:{§ E:.hs::é {§§:~is«21E3iE%E.}? :¢.*;s~'-zészfé, 'Wh§f}§{'i ?.:~<.>a:§§; 93$. 39%, 6* {i{;z";:S§.{§@::*§::§; am_;}':,:§".:?;$;f§:?:.;j3 <}f 2f_§{s___§E".%E'. {:§:'.§ta:-'?:'. L §!i"ij'éZ§"§{fS f§E,§$§.'.§'i§§}%§;?€§ by iha-,%'-._€:E2:én1;:§':§._ R;<:fl?§§QOGf~ 2.11%-"8;?E'€§€'?€§ by iZ§'§fi '§':*'i§";'s;1;«:-::}.:§.E_§::<;:m;z§:1f§é"'--§};:?;;;:': ._£iE7id sszzffikzring is §a.§S%;: 2;z::€.? -ptgv'€j§»;_}e%'fi.;£:E";<:E::*:=:"--.%5~; :'15{3ws~}:#V<:2:};":a: Em" {':§EhE,iE"2{?€5£'IE€§1i1 Lifééififf is htsié '2 V V. 'T "F. _{ {'LE;i.§_§:";.a§§'é2._$s£2:,:a3 E;r€2:.%'€::zi 31$; i:':a§}aE;§'§3:'1.€: feikz" m:*::":Ef%":$ in .<§i§§§'%::':=:_::':§,..1*:::é$:g>§*E.a§:+; aérzai EMS :.§:'2»:?§s;i::"g-:zj<§'§'";€~3: <'>;T}:':':':";./'§*£:i.:::;'2m$ an '272T§§§.{T§i_.§§§ ' {Z<i>:":$%:Ea%:*§:'2§;§ E,E':§:= 3%-:::':§;% es: sa;u:fs*: €35 R$:?i3;{E{}{};'-- is §Ei'%fiEE§E'{ié%{§ E;mz;2:a.:f§'§;s; :"2*.:${ié<*/25': gazzai §.§';{é%<§:*::¥;;:%£ V. 5s<::'=;§ ss:.:{"%E:2 a*{>'z'::€e%§z22:'z{t:éé5 3'}{}':.:§'iE§E'E.E}Eé?f§?§:. agzazé §i§§§;§l€;?§1{E£?:.E'E.'E, {.:E':z.a'gg'<:-$5 :;:;;;:21é:";s:sé §€:%;,§§E9{§{}{§;'~ &E."i%£é?;§"'€§:€;':{§ %::}; 3 E': E} 2: :2 32% 1 9 "§"mz;2:':f<: §i}E:%é'«:é 9? maazrrizas §}i'{§-E~?:§1'§{?:{..'.§i':.§f:3s E33. f;%§§€}{}{E;'--
vi} '§"<.}2:é:;;:':?;s5 {>1§"22;I§::;r;;'1i§:'.i::=:s«; E'€;;=:s;« ?E>g{}{}{};'~ ax-'§2T}% '"E.'<éwz.1:'{:Es:s E<>:%;s:s 0%" fa..2t:.,::raa hi:<;:e:.>mt-*: R§§.4.,€3 E. .»§«{;_'_'{;{g:;
"E'm',.:;i§ Ra; " ~ C{}E§§p<';':"§"'§§§E?a%i..i{T§.IiE ;;s*:_z..»*2=:r{§z=:{i by '§"§f§e '§'§"i%::2.:;:'1a.E --" 9 ?'a£§s:§§'E.§{3§':2:%_E 5::*;::":g;}%?:':s4~:aé£z>:T: .. E€:5g;_, -1 $4. The {1§2i§§"§1£%IE§l is; g?';§,§;1§€4E<=:{i"*._i'i:r E.'-s,V:*E ' m2:{3§ei§i§i§'§E1'§é:E {:<>:2:g3@::':$2:i:é<>;2 0%' Rsaéé ; 4%? § §{}§';'..--_ A iifh ' -;:;:::s}1' "bit 9:311 mieii 9?? 'E0 §~%$.zii~¢5{}..,QG@;' 9 :.y§";==h. .i-1;"::'.<-§:?::?§'s~3i'i:._ ':»1§7"E3% pas fmm Ehe +::>:"2§£E--.":'.E':3A 'ézzsfiiié 9? :°ez3;¥;§§;;::1i1?{3;L d2z"f{.€ ax? '{:§'é1§§,:'1é;§:':-E}*S§'.
mm; $1325 2&5;§;._i4g§¥E¥fC"«If§'&;'i4;'?f2§E8} E. '§.f'§:§é __:':§:a-'2i:",é*:':i;?:.Ei....hzzié s':,a;§3'i:;:§m&{§ 'E."y;>é:~3 :":<>m§;<:»1;'m§ V gfiggght: §%;:z":}z.§.r, *§:':%..{':§.:_.::'fi: 3:)?' éiibiaf f§'*z%,<.t"§?::§"€= {:3}?
-( §:%1'§{§{§E&% $E1:z=:i§f%; 'f§%§§2:; 2mg": .§E'{§1.:§;:éK §:1§:.§2"§€:%:I§ 5:a:..:.::%€.2:ém:::f§ am:
*.,.i:2*é33:i,::ts::;:?€':%;: "{.::1§:a°::3; 332:5" _%';.§m 22.1%? :%vi€iz::':1i: .f3"{TE.EEE {:.§${§:?§2§f§§€ af:a.I°§E %% 'g3§'1a;}"§::§;:;ss; §i:2:A E3' 22:'? E412 E7' 23% éiéseabiiéigf VA u aj:}rE.§§§{;:22:>:,.:;% Ex, 513 23%' ><:~:";;z§; E32235-; E§»><; E3' §'?:§ z:3':<§ §:3§}{:':;'%:'<*r<§ 335;' :>%;*;T2.E %:%':;"::%;€:=.:"':<%§% ii}? EEK: {..':E2:.E:z':;2::zé'. 2::§:{§. {§.e:>:::§,::':s§° E3 :2:e3:~:~s='::%::e-;::*ss£;i*<?E E3; :?1':a;: '§7§°§E3:.z:':::2:.§. §'€:sia,1:°:*r 5,23' §§'E_'§i,£§'.?§€ff_% égééaé 'E:1::: _:.*:::,:s:;£. Ea;-,w:'% E;:sec:: ':..::'::'§z:*.:' §"£"€'&-%fELET§'§€;'i§1'i gzmi az':
.'é$:»::ié;i. $5? :2: §}§;?f'§{L"3{.§ 32" 8 §§f:é:}n"£'Ez.3 3:15? %.;§";s;?r<3,§':>z'€: sgzmz <2? §4?;5s§;Zn&{}@{§*/°-- ifi 2:zs%Ja§':,§:::>{i: t.<}"w;11'<§s §{T§~i-ES-3 «:3»? §n<:{3ms:% :%:3;fi:.'§§__{ Eaigi up }}€':;E'.§.€}{§ as; 2*;g§:1.§:T:3§: §.:'§.,8Qi}/'-- z:a¥2:1*;:.?;.e<;i» 'E"§*ibu magi A $3 C{}i'1E%.i{§€3FiE1g iiha e:£§s§21*::»:?E§§§[Mé§i;::':,:::§'*«A%3}i"' giviéfiféaf'. mad an 23..m{;~z::1i:: :ii${:{3r:§f<3rE:T.a:::i :.§::?:;:2_g>;3::1::§:§s $38' ?L§;3"§{§€?§'§_§{} in hriss '£":;:é,1.::*a": Eff:-'r "swim é§7_E§.::,;.j;§,}§Q§f-- is; {:i'Wé1f{§€'{3§ ;'f,{;€;x=<;11:%.;:§V--_V Ea§;_:e:.;§" '€25 '=g:n}_¢3:::§t3;€ss 21$ ag2:.:i}::$'i: Rs. 1 5,,.*3»®-Q_;:' _! 5 'x75.--'a%;£fz";3§\'é"?€i"'§3':}?'-.'C§'"i§i3' "E';*i?:)'é.ma§5 28*" fiéékéf'«{?§3,iE"§"1£:;§5;EV:§EE, i'i.§§§{§ £'£§}{}%§'i 22 }*{-rays and éhfi m:1§.§;i§;%1ie:" éép;§§b:_%;?;§3'E€"§:{:9'Eris ag_f»;€:: ggjrzmp is; $8, E}{}(:i.::>§ irzase "-.,s'§'z§:.e39.€fi %..:;§1e:":;=: is; {i§§zzb%..E§"§;.'}T-V 3:23 '§irsf1E3. 'E"§:er€§%}r:% E: ifé é;2,;€;.§ 2:::;ééE_' §;r;%:{;.§_3§j<.;;" §'{f% %::22§{z:% §'°u:'3<:'{:§{}§3;:E {§isab:T§§E';jg 22%; 25?{§9'§3n Sara;-._§£3&;_%;>~ ~=':;§j'.:§:i,:%$,:.zré:% §§"E€jf{}EE§€ w0§§<;$ iééié, Ea; E%$,E.§:%Q?§}§$,f'« "§§2;:%;;f§,E%4-f.T%€}/M X 2§":§z;5« 5 "22 X E8: emzi 'E? E3 2?1%,¥e1:*{§{3{1 225; ' E. X» gizaafazriéfiéi "by" $526: 'y§*§'Ed§}L§E'i£E§, E2
23. {iia'::':§i£§{ié;"%:":_;.j; 3 §':m_::::.2:"%:s:: s5z,:1s=,'§;=:é:':e:{§ E}? ihe <:E:2:§::":2::':'€.
2z:_'2e:'§ E32?:_:'~;-;ae~::§ 95'": €;.E':e: s:%:=*§.:.§éia§":<%<i gr}? "EEK? <i;:T><:i{::' Rae. E *:"§§£}{}{§;" «-- :53 2::2-';:::"e:i{3<i é:z}'aa.?3;§'{%&2; §":;:%:'z,:;:'a? :':?.é:%d;§{%2;:§ €iI'>{'§§iiETE'EE%%{:E'~j%'
22. 'E"h1.§;<~;~;, fizz? {%E2;.i:1":2z:m*:. is; <:::':::.§E:§a:{i fer £121'; i"a}E§é;;$;'i§1g {'i{}§3'§ ;:;<-32'} §~sa.€:i{m :
's,-fii} °'E'{>W:5:;"'{3,;;; §,'}£§i1:E «ii; Stiiféiérilzg '-- 3 i_§<;:} 'l'::3va,?2:z*::§:+; :T;f1.{:':§§.%{t:;s§ 61. __ __ ; VV §;1a:§d:=:m;a,E expgiases 5%:-v;,'< 1 g;'}Q,.;_0{>_{f<_{ 4' ' X} 'E'{>war::é&s E213-s'e:-i; {:%E"»2i:g_{t{::m%:,~~A , .
§}'Li_'E°i3'E§,-Vi Eaizi up p§»_:§§':<}<i "RS- _ xi} "E_{)1x;;"mjs:. §.E>8S {§}ff:&i§'§1€§1'E*"€:?§'€i=3i~RE?;. <£G9C%§€3f-- xii} 3» ""§'§i:W2::=;i--§; §«:}.S_§i:'_%__ £;s2i'"_ E::'é;.z1«:fs H » ._§§":i£,ft(::3g31~:*3 ' ' ._ E?;:':=;aE.,89,%G@;'~» afiii} _1'E'é:3s:z1;r€£s fzgimfés :z:.€={§i::a£ " ' Ei:*«<.:§)1'<:..%i'"::~?s.€;%§ EES' E§§QQ®;'--
, _ ' '§'<:25{z1§ RS» @~,323$*{¥G,X--
{is :31 pezzgzi ii ()3: ;:§;_z::1fii<3:E.- "i'}j,7 T§.}€;$;:T§'f£b%,§.E'iE§.§"' ., 3, i2,3€3G€};'~ f%;sL."§s;§:%:.V€:i_§{:a._:'vf;.;i;.§ ::<i>m§;@::'2_$z:%';ic::': E g2€f,%3éf}€}€3j --
" :Z.§§,--._V%A <:~E§:é:":a2?:.:3"E: is; :3§§:§é":E€;*.{i E3233" 22:§{§fi:§»:}:1a;§ :::<}:§:;}§%§'::%22:§:'§an {.135 E §2€l€}{}€};'~ ::ax'E§:i'i: §§'E'§'.€';'f§T'{'f;'%'s'§', 22:: 933%; gag. Ef:2:}§~::; §';E%:{% {:§;2,E1.z:;% ijéf ::;':Eaim §'.}{i?§Z§'§,'§{}I§'E zéléfz aiize gézfifzaé G? i ;:2%.Eé$;2:E'ia:1_= gig}.
mi ?a\' , -' .4 .
;§€§§§§'i «'2xz.:e.? A 5' ;3é:'::°i<.:*«{i iitzf '§:'3 jf€;'?2fi.E"S E-'v'§§§'"§ 2?: z*%§§§'"§é. $2?" <'};}f:§<1}:: gféifsr E'E":é-Em is :'&:':a:%<,,>2s' '§,§":.€;=_-":§:' <§<:p<>s%i§,s§ f:'<>:":f: mime: 2:5: é;%z:":€: EifEi{§§ *«&:§%:§:ci.raxa* i:':%*;€.:"€:se'=;*=';:' §§§:ri<}€§_§.::2;zE§3: zzmi El'.E**;:;': r€<1::z':;?a§:2_iz':,_s§ zmzim.::'i. 2:;£§;§1 p:"€:;p<2:*%:E{:=::;'-:é.s: EE'Ti§;i€;'f§."€fS:§§. fig §§E'{§{?:§'€T'.€§ 3:23 §:»é:: %:°s3§s;*z%;-xiii"i.:j};---€'i':';:§_:* fzw<}:,2:"1, Ni} €}¥"{i{':§" 22$ :5} €t€}S3E5;5 . 3 ' 23:35 ,, .,,,...........,..','....mm,..ww.».w/,,---=»--,»~.»=».