Meenakshi vs The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd on 18 November, 2010

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Meenakshi vs The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd on 18 November, 2010

Bench: B.Manohar

EN THEE HIGH CC} {§'¥j¥£" {I}? .KA.RNA'§'AE{A,
CI.F{C{}1T E?3EZN(.',H 5%"? {}{J.I_.-§€3z'\.§4€(}A
If)A"E"'E'I} Ti-{IE5 '§'EEE 38"' {DAY C329' E\T{}VE3E\«"EE',%§§R 

ESEFORE

'_£"'E--ii§ E«~1<3N'E3:,,E, MR.J'{JS'I'I{fEl E3,Mzf§.N{}%:i;*--&§§'~  % T' '

M. F'. A. .N().,§3488;?2{3§8{1§d'%;f} [1    *   '  

EBEEWEEN:

MEENAKESHI
:3/0 AMBANNA

AGED 24 YEARS,  ..    V
R/G HNO. 105, z:A§1R' N;:gs':;A_:i2:, 

aiazgpwm, GL?LBARC§A.v:'     APPELE.-AE~lT

5&3? SK;;'"§_»:§:éééf;§A(;;;:R--m'i':'§;;z§I)v. mg
SR? ASE~i'{}}€..V_1?A'i"'iE.,3"AIf}X?,_';
AM):

E, _7'i3P§_EA.(}E%EE'?€T§fA§, _:1\§Sm2;AN{:i~: CO. gm.

% "  _ '§"'%»£R'*(}§;35{}E'i' ms 11)1'ﬁF§E3Ei}'i'sEzix_§; Rx-iA1'§Cui§E<ZR§
 r I:w€.§§,{:§:>:'x/{3:?:;E:}<§ :3'? §1'LO(>R
  '§f}P}7?", E¥:'ZE=1'?g'§ *'Q'"§5Ei_)7E:.§§_NA S<3:;;;>:~§A,
';:»§;r;..:3?xI §<<z%...:3',~;:;:a;é:T,§3AR<:g§..

-'..':i>":°'°"~»¢
'K



2, PRAVEEN K'UMA.E'{ JA'l'}9iAI'%§
S/€33 l\rI.I_)1NA.KA.R

A@§<::3;MA;J©R.

cycc; OWNER OF' me: vI::H1<:L:«:
?€O*E{§&~20--_EVﬁ~5U5,

R/O JP-3E'Jv'AN2{.iRAN; <:>§>p.<;0v;'. 
JR. COLLEZGE, Eii_RIYA§3}{j='x ' 

'"I'Q;UDUPI.   

{BY SR:SANJAYMJos1Lm¥f::3.{§ Riajﬁ E .  V. 
I\§O'FiCEi TS R2; :3 E-{ELI} $U?§§E'ECiEN"'§T__  
v/{>::3*:1255;:'a/10}   

'Ems MFA IS F%£:§£«::> '-%:,I;f:1i.: §i":r--v::'f,'_:":":.A;1:';<:--:'_:*:'Q1':~s 1:/ram OF

M{)'I'{)§'?;. VEHIEELEES  Aé?T.E_':'V.?§3Ai§"i?§"{§  MOIDIFY THE

JUE')G'EVIEN'I'E_" '%;a3Ts:'g;} '1AxI;r.A§21:5"VA:'pAssEi::> BY 65%: HI

AE}I)£fiF§{§N';~ki;»v_V <f%§y¥'§:g '=;§m?:»C}é"'{S§z.:3,a\1.} _A?xI£) i'v'EAC'£l
<;TE;:,£3;xR*<:;A':5:'%a%:"ar;:=»§<:>,§3':;:.;23$?'

 f2'His§';;2?:9*:?:1»éz'_,A:S{:5<;M;Na (TEN E<'c:}§§ H'E:A§€§'NG '§'HES

 -  _ '::>.:=%§2 f..§i;i:I~--£ET; sci: R?'---§.§EE,iVP:REZi} m:r::: §%'<>:,:mmzx:<3;

JU_§GMEE\?T

 _s%§§;ﬁ%=;3};_§;é1§':i. $.55; %;h:;: {.E§€::§.§E'§'}.:'.::¥.§-3.:-»g 'ijgzéiiigg :'2<>3;': :~:;e:'a:is5fi€:é:E w:iE',h

 *i}';ti% }1:{Li;_;::za:'1E'. amzé ;zWaz:"{i <:E;.:.':;€{.§  E{;?~2i}{}";-7" ggasgses-:e:i in

A  {Z f'%i':'3£»§32{}{ Z?' 33;' §"fE':é;*: EEE ;'3":d:ii§;é€;::':;::?; ijﬁivii. e_§':;,:d.g___§&,'-

ff .' '-/
g 



-1
s

{$:°.£'f):':.} 2.-3_mi§ E'vi<3t;<.>:' A{:<::§<ié:'1i'.s iiiaimsa 'F:*i':3:.maE {'§:h§:x
'E'1*_ib :m2'~.zE' 5&3"? sh 01*'t:} C%'E.i§b2':'1§"§.'§2'l-'E f"i}.e<i *ihi.<5; :;3..p;'}€a} :'»;€§;-:§<;i:':;;;

E61' <31'";ha3'1{:é:n'1£s:':'2'£. {}f Eiiw. {"?{}E"ﬁ§}{?I"iSEl'{.i{,3E'L
2. "FI§:é: Ei;-;1<?:i;.:'»:s :>fi:1"1c? {",'.aE"5E-? 2:11?  fiélizwv:-5;:

O21 30«O&%~200<3 at zxbcauﬁ. 5.30 p.::}f_ ?;':1<r;§2':{§I%21§m.2m'%__ '

was; p:°0<:<-zeciingjzg t'c>warci:a=; K-;.(}D'V(i§H3E1Z.1S"'~vH'€)S'§[§:?'E,v__:{}1}§.b§il§j§§é}¥'

when ghc r€:21Ch€d I'E€;E£1i" §\i.'Iz1.i12:A::1sE':.iV-- Vi£i}E:5:.§Vl£§;1'1CE'i:"';*.213

I\!_Ea.E1e"r:1dra S<i:0:'p1i<> Jeep b%§:*2gi*i:1gg§ :'égi.s%i:eﬁ.i<::§ N<:».E{A--

2E}/MD--5C%5 cause 'i:'; "~..21 ."séig'h  in 21 :'asE'1. and

:1&'*§,_{3i§;§&?:1Ei.Z%}}EéE'1.i;'1§3?i",Q-131d"-...d;;!-Siieéi a;__;iz1:insei: i;h€ <éL2:z.i1n.21z1¥;;
{R25 '€13 vv..w%1%t:h.';V. iihéé ,.<?E2;ir29:;1.11i; he'-1:9 :%~;:2s€.2zi:':€:d i:'2';'u:*i<'::s3.

§1m';§z£%{E§;:i:e§yQ" .. _sa{Ef;E:% '§2»-*2-z:+; :=;§1§fi;<':d in Eiihrj {}(':v<:ér*:'1n:e:1I:,

V' E*r§.§>s:;pi$§.;;:A§¢, .4 €j§.:;;P:3a:*;ga_ far :'a.sk_:':'.1g_;: §E}::é~sE: .:¢;§d éjm-':ai:n";r3::1£;

" ."{.E*:%:":_:f«:%;%":"§2%.%_;iX_  ﬁ,?'£':1§.E% :.:s§1§fE:es;§ iii} E?§2z.s;1::asE2xarz1:'a E~E:>:~:;pi€;2:': 21:5:

{Z«:.§E?f3a;;? $21" 'far Em"?:.E'§.<2:;* ?;1.'€'?f¢3;§.§TZ"§.€?3?'}'{'. A<é{t<>r<Ei:w {(72 €:E2<;%

"  '<:Z;a.§_m2::i5;i., ssshs wzzgs ii'1§}2§'€.i€::E"£'€', E'm:r_:': 30~§:E§~2GGEi ii}

 Ef§9§~2€}{}€>2 Shir: E'22:s:,~;< <.'.{_}'§'3§,€i'i'E{'§€i3{i i:E':;';:§'   '=£%£{T3§'ki}'§§.;§ 2.:



i'?i}(}k in '%£'.IiZ}ﬁ7\7az":12:;'f:%s "E'1<:>$i.ei9 G:,'z2ba~11fg;a ezrzgé  2?:

S£1L':Ii:'};' of §{:ss.4fE3Q€}/3 pm. i'f}L:e: ii} the 2:_c:<:%£c.E€;:.1s_':f,4; .$t'z:§;1':'a92§s

=;'55L'iff€;'?§'€rC§ permazxssrzrﬁi _i:1_§1,11'i<~_->3 azfzati E12159; -5,-.:Vp€:tf;'E; L. §'2:1§;£: 7

21.:1<1m.1:1*;. i.€)\-'v'2iI'{iS iihﬁ :1"::3s:ii<%2i'1 €iX§)€Eii'1€ﬁ{.L;i§,3'{*,_ 2«1;i1'1€i.__us:2'<.>.§§E*1iVf"c§:'°

<7:<::11pe1.':sat.i<m <)§"Rs.?§9C),GOQ/1,  V'

:3' In ;31.:rs4;:,zar:_ceé to £316: i'1.<;'E'i';~<?_s3r £sés'L:»:jd i::§j;rV"'£':*éwE;i':;,:r12:_E

the ﬁrssi. 1**<-:sp<}z1de:'1f;.  <,:=1>m§~:-:*~ .§>"f'7. {E1116 "s:'<;*:'hi_s:§.1.r;%..~'%*<:3main€d
ex__pa1ri,e:. The smrimd 'V:43::3;5:<>vi<E€§e1r:ii=v§_::.e§L:rm: 1:: the <:ia.im

pe§;iE:i<>:1 fii€ci_ 0bj;ec_:t:§<:j::1s  €§i*éLjE'T1j,f41iE*1~:;;§'-§;.'}'1i3 .:w"(§%:*'r1r:é;2:1?;'s5; macie in

ihe ?Q§.22i:n_ ";§é=;%f;ii;_§v€;rf: '«e3;:"1{i ..ai=;so ciezzxmsd 21:43: 2353}: zmd
n<3;_§ii§__.§e;%§1i._ §:'Ef:fiy§1'1g;j 'icy? €;h"'r;>._ Si':<>rp=§o Jeep by 1§t;s:: (§.1"iw:§', 'i:he:

:¢:a:<;;§'<i<':~:g';s:, .':':a:~§' ..:._a['z»:a-'=::2 lgjiaetie' E?"L.:.Fi;E;"m;3;1 1",hs3~ sC§Z'§';f<:'.X" {>5 "5."%s€:

V' <E§;j<§};' (€153 3'}.€§'il._§3()SS€:?$$ z-1. vaiiii and %:éff<:%<:%i:iV€: <:irivi:1g Eigitezjigsﬁ:

 .é_1$ _{_}i§'} :3'? fE':z&*. ::?2E.'.€.'.i{i€;*,1i¥§;.. ami aisszzs (T{'}§'1J{'(fI'§{§i"f{§: 3122?.

Ehé" {jf€~§I§§"i_'§3€i%1'1EE%EE§,§{}Z§ €_",'EE.-'¢.i§21{','d E3}; E'".I"2<*: <'6E2fai::":;3;mi: is me

 V' %;::;5,:>jI.°'i.3.i£ffe:.:2*i., E-§em:a;*.. he s-;:«2'?{:tr:*;:;i'E:'i',s;=.=.<£ éjiaz:-:1 the E%€:?(Zi{}§".§.{§.

A7?fa=%s}?g§}:>:'2:t£s::Tz*:T E3 :'*:{_}2'' 'E.§;--::%3§€:-3 'it; E322}? 2:m§,2' i,?{}E'§"E_§f}Ef§'}§§EE?;§l§€I}.i'Z améi

tr.-5;

"'.-N
mjmw
« f"



s2«3<.':ug11: .f*:_"n=:* §§:i_s2s::.'1is:;:saE <:>:f the (:32-aim p::~n1i;.i{m as 21gai.€r.i'::s:" '::._h<:*;

;9e:«é~:f=o:':«:i :'<;?%s§;>{>:'1<:i{-%:';i..

4, <31'; the ba1si:~3 of {Riff pie22:cii1'1;;:S of i',§'1é_":*}i)a:f*i:ie3':$',--. iii.-v.--€-3.' ~

'E":*i"bLma§ has-; f:*21_med the foiigswi:';;g;..issL::é:§:  " 

6 1)' 1»-'i--'71e:'h.ez' the p(3Z.it.ie:ie;'  f§?"€? U€?.g:**.  : 
:3G~O8--2005 sin? ' «.__.g3'1c>z,:?'i2-15:?' Qp   {'53 
V.G,V{/om€n.'S ?":£}§§z'"v:3:._lV'V'z'<?<:1d,V"  at
5.30 p. m,  {:'ha,»i' 'iii; é:fj:.iz'zd;;'(i ';S'c(§}}:1i§7
§3€{i!'{TEg  1<*.a:'z":e fram
z',s4%'c13r::r;rs}1i:.A'i,r*é::i--gj:;:  ;'iif§}:I_';c'§}_'}", giriv-e32" of

 """   Q2356?  {he Uefzicie in 5;
' ?'.'éS>;L'w?':"{.§%'iC§ ?'?L€§§'?'iQ'{;f§"é§. :'s'2.a:':z:z.>r' fé£I""§d. €§{£§¥§"i€(§
' fa ' _ zi:} . z;,:..2f2£{:r§z s%?'fz.{é :;usi.o:.i3:.£>§Z.
 'i.Y'?§.:?;£.zr{.ésf'?"~. ' "
  {§i}a "..:§§?s;«*§';g%€:'E':.«:%r° {Em 3':-?sp0r:i££%z'2i No.2 pr<)a;es
A   3.32.6 {i:°£.Us:%:" 53,?" 5,335? (g{'}'?:?:2s:§iI:§; Eﬁé?§'§§{,"§E?
 T~*a4§>a$ 52:3: ?a.:::ai<:€ 212;; ::(z§:';:E 5zr'2z:.{ s-:jgj'22s::"§:se'3
géréving §i{fé??"§$£.' as 0:": 35:3 51:13:? Qj"

5152:: £535-3;": 5. 'P

 



(3
{iii} Ex-E--'}'z£ei:'f'1s;=r file pe€.'ii:'i{2r'ze:' is e??'2i.§::'ie{i for

cGz'r'1}3e:'1.;s:a:ion? {f 530, :0 :,:,=i':(,z£ is the

€§Z.£€,II"1EiZ.i!'?'Z Qf CGI'?'Zjf)eE?!'lS(1EI'iO§"i '? c:me':i

{flu} E/W261: award G!" orcier'?

5' 1:': <}:'{i:=ér to 5sub5~3ta_z1i".ia'i;:e> 1161' {7fZ155€§ i:'h<3--'..';:i21:§n1,é"£x"if  

e:x21ImTned i':€1'Sf;"tif  P.\-R3,}. 2»u1€i"'z11s3<}"_< <:é§=:a§11:i.n<§c1--.}{>f:3:

D1",Si:ida1":;h. Ch.§I1{ZhC3I§ as  

d€}€:'LiII1E.':I1'iZS as E;<'P.I ':10 Ex,P,»§;--M» T113 '::%<f:i::s:»211_E_i 19i:%s;j3£}'r1d&%nt, V

has {gm e:'s<;.:1mir1ed ;,::':<2y xx;i~i.:;i{éss::§;'€;%;,\"-Efgsxwevééf 'they ha.v"»:=:

admif:['é:<::d" ?Li1**;.:~.é.% _v t:h€*§ V1x'3';:'£':.ij2ci:'a_ S{:«:3'rp§<> Jéiep i$ {',€}V€'.'.§'E"3€i by

the §:2$;,1;'a-raw' §;;{}'§i§:.t~3_:i    ~ «. 

5.  'V'§.'E?:c:-=2 <:E2§;ir.r.1a::?;. in may §3videz7:<:€: E12153 €Ee:%p<>s;e<:i thaé.

. (Sam '£19 vss;i:§: '*~:f2;:s?s§1 arm :ae§g;§_ige:1:1.i: {'§i"ii-'§IEg;§ 0%' é;h<2 S<:0E";>E<>

;.E'éa::_;;;, 9€:§':2,;3'»--.::.{:;§é"i{ien: héezﬁ Ea.-2;E«;e:'z ;:a3:a-ice. 'l'%::;: E"<i>E§<::=:~: heave

:*:=:g§£;2;i.:é':f§%:i§' 3 {'.'&1S{';'% &i§;f;&1iE'%f-.i?i1 i:Ez<-5 {§§"'§i="€Z° (sf ihe s~;=;ais:,§ vehiziié.

., E"E§%_i'i1_s=:{i E}{*ff{,"}E'€;?E iZ§'1é':'. §7<m:*i E:a:~;; E,"}€3€?§'1 §2'1za;:'§§.€:z,§ ase; E1-KP, 1 

é';£:2'i.§§'§sé<§ <i%:};>3; :3? ithrié :.:<>:§:':;;>Ea.§.:'zE: ?;2=z:e: Eswégz :":12;::°E--»:€t<'§ £15.;


\



ms

 M21}. Thiié P<:r1i»:?e Eiave f'i};»2£i -;:i123zrg<:": ssZr1eé::-.=:i. 22:g2:iz1.3i: '£:hs--%
<:.i:*ive;" 0E" :;'h<;-7% J<%(:p in q1zef<::~3i:i<:}:<':: wh.§s;7éI': has §3€::%1'1 '£"I12iiI'k<i'?{i

 EX.P.8 and iélti: r'e_pc}:'t af 33:119. I'sz'E<:2E.<fnr '2-"ehi<i:£e _§'i£3$'§}_§€i4%i§€)£"

E12155 bee}: rna;.rke{i as E§<;P.§}. Cm '1'..E1<;~. §_321:4;€:si:--.a:)f'f;'E-géj ~

{i=r::z<:z,1mem;s.? the 'E_'r'ibu1'1.aI heid i411at._c1:1€;: _'?;4<}'*§.I{':T:§;V »:r'2i's:h.g2u':§i V'

:1eg_§iig_._§e;:1t, drivirzg af 1318 Jeézp ?3y'a ;:i:s._A_'z:i1*}:v<;%j:f';  *fifE/':.c: g:.<;rz§'i'»:i._é9f:':i..

hag E.2zke1'1 §:>i.21.<7:&   ._  ._ 1
1?'. 'With mgg211*{i {ii} the q{:3.:3st:'u:":1 GE" t '{;':5{"§}.'I1p%;§31'"iS€ﬁ,'i(}§1§

?3'\>'sfm2~1:h:2 E)0<:i,01' hELS_. :fff;?}T'fI)S§jdH ;{:h'3:,iI ~§',I2¢3 ciainianii has;

SBL1S{.E1I§I1€C§ _?::Eé.'€:':3'§%}§1§:»*ax,?iI*:.g* "i-1:33 1: riessz
{3}§z1a:tsr.2{m..e{i. ' ':A,~*{32;2.::.*£ie:i.' ma Elhéi ifippﬁi' iip hi2;§<}W the

:'§g§':i:_ :';<>sst.:*i?;: WV
 {E33} a,.A_E ;2€:é»::~21€:'é':;i"£::z_§z;,1:j§z an ':..E:@ rigghiz :.:E':m;:1r§;
 -- %:i'f§._3E§?E 2§;§:)§.f§iii$§Q3"; zm 332$: 2*§§;%1i':, <_%§'"mzs-2%:

{cié .a ::*:.aE3'rass§<>1r": an th:*: a.:*:§.e:*::~§<>r as 399.1; <5? Ea?! 2.21:: 9:2'
_. h  E 2 E3

   2.:':~r:":; " _ 

-'*<
'''~::''-m'
{



3
((3) 21.1": ab=;'2':.si{>1': on §;§':&.*. {<)1'ea:1':11: and

{.¥.-'E em z.:b:*21.s;i<m on ihif ieﬁ: ssicie of 't._E";é=: iiiléfﬁk azzzi

Ia:':€<r'21t,&2:i injury <31': 211% 'righ.: iauéizock.

 "I";'m%=: c§::>c;t.<H* he'-is <3g3:z'1e%cE 1:.ha'z the iz'1_}fu:*i%;2.sg_{ {ax}-.:;ié'1?i  V'

are 0? gr'i<3v<>L1s.~; in :123.t:u:*e and (fi1[;.E3>.V{-_'*,»fi"i3':1jL}.I'i<;f'£':. ﬁ'£'§;Z vsirnpit:

in :r1a*€,z,.z_re. '§'E"§é3 dc:)c£.01" has; 3:15"-:.{3 dé;>pC-s_s;%<§ f'.%'1'z';i;'"?; fh€'E'€?'=i$§" 15:5)',

fI:a<:1:.u:'e of any of the b{):1t:as§:;:.rfik::i.g11::<3 $21idVAiTF;21Ef"i::2 &-ritzvsr 0f

the wmizicis. ii; is ciiffi&:':u:it. t<>s' <i:111éz:a{ %'§i%:.,h21r{i fiéaéi. On the
basis»; cf ihes §;':Vi{i€£1{EEi' aaf  ",1T3V<>€:i:'<:-yr? __',i.'riE31.maE 'Lai«a:i:1;g

inn: cV<>::«s2i:1é§;2f_e1't:i€3:;: 31:11::-7..Vp--2_1iﬁ ;2m<%E.v;+§:,1.f'£"et1*i15";ggs; m'1derg<)me by

€;.h<:+ {:Eé§.1Z2f:'::a3.n€. 21:1.{% ..;.:E:~:V§ié"T3;4__Ei7:;: _a'-3;%§'p:3:1{§i€:z.,1:"€: im:z:r':'s:€;E E33; ihér:

e:EL21i::':am:,'*--.}j:22.§a ax7<:2:';fvde:,«d-~'L' <:<>mp&é11s2?s.£:i<3:'}. «sf .E€sa'25.30Q_fw

'xv-'s.r'i,f§é.i'§.ii'f};_?;ii{'fZ't;j?:;':3?L at"i.%<:.¢3%...mt:<: {>5 ééﬁzis Elna.

V' 3 "i'§'2;:':-. .§:§a.§§":2:a:§'1i: b<«:2i:1g zzgggzémzezi £332 "é':h<:: £311-"'£1E'€.§ gxziggséezﬁ

  §:EE::?<§ §§'."§§S 2s;p;:m%a§ $<::a=.E§i:'é§; for

i': iiiizm<%e:':*;:?:1é'. {sf <":e:;m §3&:';s2;:§;iz;«:'2 K

5!"



9
104 Sri.§{_£*'*::1p£1s21ga.1' Pai:iE, I.<=:211"_:1@c,i <':<:s_.1r":s:;€=1 2:'s,;)_;;3ee;1.ri1'1g;,§

far thzzé ;=2.pp£::IIa.m c:r::3:'1i:€:n£ie:_% U'§E§L§'. tgha? (Ts?)EI1}}fi?E'1$EiiI§{,}'{'1

gm-*21:'<ie{i. by 7§,h{';'. '£':f1T§3 11:12-1.1 ifﬁ '{{.}€.} :11:>:22.§g<:%:: Wi§.§1<:ju4':,

i:'1i:{,> C:{.'3E'1.E§iCi€1'E}if.i{)i'1 'izirm _injuries :s1.:i§'e'1"e:i by f,§T13;?f ;e1ppé§'EE.:g1'if;--E'.,A ~

the Triburlal has:-; 31w:-z1'd:éci i13a_{i.eq_s_.ia.i Véf.?:ii:i§;.s%:i':1;i£i§<}r§_, V

"i'i"1c:: dc)<:>i.<>r has {.iep<3sed 'r3ei'()'rf:t  <?:<;1,1?§t  ::'£1ai*j'--~,ff.If:€%

i1'1j:1§"ie:%§.; €21} axxd {b} 2.1% of ;§;*'i~e§x,r(31zS" E1"; 1r'z_21mr'e:%_j';m:i'° 211s<}' 

.s3t,21i_<:>.d £12131. ::iue:% :10 their a{:=:'.éd.e:'1"{v,«_ s"%1.c: a:%<;:i'i(§...AA;'1cw§: 621%; 1:13;"

find emci 8"' éeeiih has' 'mAbe_f;ep1ai'{:.Lé§_¢£.,V% *E.'':. is; the case of

{he appesriiani; ::f:j:m; f,h€'ff'€ is"Sis3i}1;g§f:;;.;f€:;'I1&:;;":i. of 32.6: faazie, daze

£10 whiicih hé:~ .Ei2:.1VS§2;12:1<€§ "h;ja:%:. «:§es%;%'r1:e{i her and szsxzgiﬁi far
e>nha:1cé2i:1%:2'z":E: of "i'§':€%. ."é:Q'f;%.;3s:::1sa£:im"; by a.§Em.>vi:1gg§ 1':'h.i.s

a?s.;3§;<;;%é2} . L. .

  E   €22': E'3§§.£i§ <>%.?1€:%1""'E'1ar1:.?L Sr;;Sa;:_§21y §\Kf.a}<_}s;E1.£e iearmsié

  <%1=;;1,;C:':$§:'§«..g2f;;§ic:;%:i.:'z§;>; ;€'1:f;r i:E'::=: §E:°sst': :"es2=,p<_"::1{i<"-s.n"i: in $323.3: zizpgétéai

E1215 a;t<§:1§.<§:.=::sj{2{i thaiz §..2,=&<:.i:'1g izzia <:<3ns3§{§<:r2:Ei.E{>:'§ the

 §§1;:;:'§£::e;__ 3 ae;:,:s%§?:'2:§:1@{?,; 2,:;m:§ zihégr: paizzfg. amfé Sa;,:E'§?£%z*'i:1.g;§s

E




a.1:':£ie:"§_§c>r'1<:é by the {' IEiiI1'121'i'}§' 2;2,1'3d e:1}.s;<t> iihzs {:%X'p€'fI':U.i"§i,I£'€E:i'

:i;'1<:1.2r:**e:<i ':33: 3'1r'::r' .fa:>1" '£1316: £'m21t::11e-212%., £'E'1s3 y}iWE'f.E:E}_Lli7§'1VZ?.iE-  ;E2"z::§s

2:':'§3;'é1Z'{§€':{i'ji.1S1Z Eifid fa2'.::* <:c}mpe:1$a1f'.i<3.I': and i:%1é:~  z"1:::%£';_ "

iiabk-3 {:0 be inI':;e:"il:3*1"€v:i K.xsii.1/1 "£33;- ' 1:11.155'}i<1;:§':4'1'%3h;i.__%::i>.g.:;ffé"';11'1i§

S=3{)1,1ghi. far distnisssal of i4_h.@ -a1_ppr:.211'.--.A 

1.

2. I heave'-_->: <:e1:'£3i.'z.11Ey ;g<i;';_¢7"~..§;i1:"()%.'1g§i"1V_t,}5;«a:_ "';?§.:'"gfz.;11i:e:':i:s§"

€LdCi3."€E-§E§€£§ by the Eezufrlcid gt~:>--'L.=..§'i;=s.é.1'--~..f<>r t:hE:~:»3 p.p'e:§1.21,m": as '».¥€H as; 'i:.'h::*: first z'e$p£:i£;:ie:.riE.V,£;;3d _§[;v£:r:;Sé3.d Eiher orai and d<)<:mn<:é:T1{a:°3,f s*:%q'i{:§«_e1:"1{:-§_%3 fat. 23:: ?::y %;',E2'c:: ;;:sarTé.i€.:5. E8, '--.i;s;¥: v1'i{}i.':"'-ii)! {*i:{sg§'::i;<1:' ?;:.h.a€'. i:if;é;é appeHa':1%: 3?18..'r"§ s:;e_.:.,:«-¢;'éai.1':<=:é€.ziL.._§t:jv:42:°:r:s;'A§>'i:V..._":3€'3-8-2{){f:8 2:: 24-:b<)'ui E330 pm. zléfaér. I&?1'z;:E:21rss§:§*' .7'{;i{§§;a:. Riiamiiir ej:.ze: ta Ehéf' §'Ei$E'1. and ' :1€;.»:§'iig;§a:>,_';'":'é".% ;.'g.z°.i%;*§':'1g§ ('2? tihezz T\f§2iihiI'1{"§§.'£?£ S<7m'°g3i<} Jfféip %}<:%a1'i§'1;§ Rc%§g;i$é.2°sé::i%;§;'é. 'N<>..E{Aw2{}f'x§Ef}»~58E"> 'ﬁgs' éizis <i:"§"::'{:3:' zzmzi 'gfhér §_3*'<>£§<::@ h«g-:1»-*s:% Eiifﬁéfﬁ E'é%§__.§§;'%E;€;?3"€%{§ 2:. €2.25:-;<=:: ag:_§::§n:~;;E. %;."E":e=> {Eiéa--'€;%:" of " 't;;}*;€i";%§2;z§{i ve%1_i{_%Eé: 2m;§§_ £:E':21:';;<3 s:ah{1%<%E' ii}:-2-'~.s>:1 Eiﬁexig {En :.:'E:€> bz-zseisa; Gf She Pzzrléaréé 1"€*[.)()§'E. 1f'_h.€: "§7:'i.%32.1.r'1;:s..1 I22.-15'-T; E':e.1<:i "::.%'i'-(H %%m'% a.<:f:.i(}':";2a13_1€r 2:eg§ig:?:1c%cé is on the part of éhté <§.:i2E$;€1f"<3?E~ E:E';g:> I'xi12'1I"1§1";::3;I'a S€.t{}I"I'3i() Jeep, M. With ';_"<::g;21:*d {:0 the C{1.1éiI'EU.iH1..'()f =11:<):1i§:és;%::s;§i§Ti§§:": V <:_:<>,:1<::<:é:*;:'1e3*C1, from the e:vi<:ien(:e of I;:1é,<;% "i;)<)tii';r::f.--. $1: ..i;% s;:.i_;i%2::f E:§13:€. 'i.2*1e:"<':* is amly i21€<3:1'21f,c=ér:1--.§iQ*z::},1.11ci." .1113':.;1*1'€§s"'~{:i.j"'Enid [b}'' are in gr1?.evc31.i$ I'i21'E,z.1-Iffii 211151-"*i?r2é'--'§'1=ibu112:§"1¥:21s3 zmrmgied camper:$2H;.'i{>:_'1 <3? .R$.V?:[_i§',3Q,C'5;é% _w'.:?:'i£1§§"::.%: EiE},k;ii'1§§; inia aésrzsiiierzai ii<>:_1 . -- _:It1:;% §§3ai._1'.1 2::1V€i'~.L' $1,: E"£"éVr>1'1'1§_.;«2 1,: 3'1c§«:érgc>'r3e; iz1jur;i;es-1 S¥.},Si'.Ei.i§§'E§f{i'~b:§r",t}I€ <>Ea.i:13z1:1é. emci the s:<x'ps3:1diE:u:"e i1':<7:2.;::1°::*€:é:*E._ Lb}; mg-s. a2";3V;:u:=:E§'22:1iT.; E fi.2'1{E t'.hat, <?<>11:g:e11sa:i:.§<3:1 of E'%"§§,4§f3?._{}€.3.G ,1' ~ géixzrgzfiicai5f:.ow2?::*<is ;3e1§:1 ezmd 55-;uf§:3r§:':;;s :55: {(20 V' :":1§;%g1gg&2§ _ 7-. E--§e:'2<:*<:x Ehe:-% ap;.3<%EE21':':':,. is <é:':i1i§':§:"-réi fez' " .<:{3$';1 {€:1«_%'é2?;.1i:.£<i:::é ef Eisa. §_59G{){},/~ 'i:<>*=;w-wais f}£iii'1 ami Sz1§'§7:>;3'i'z:";§_.gss§'." '§'};ma.:;;E'": am: ap'g;€31'Ea:'2'£: haai p:'<:>{.iu<::<::<§ megizfégsai " V, '§;>;;_I;.E:§%§ iiiis:-:=. '§"ri'bm:2rzE has}; §'T:€.'}'§', E}£:%E§:év€<.E ;s;m3§c af f::E":.:'~? .mz::=d§{i:21E §:;E§Z$ z;a:':<:§ 221%-?;3;:*<£:%{.§ E'{s%;,£"'},3{3{}{},/7~ E;:<.}W2:::'{,§§; EE'}{",{'§§i',?2i§ 54$ i E f;?Xp€3I'1{iit'.L§3"ff.. I find i:IE":a.i'. that .ap_pe':1.121.r":€ is; :%;1i,ii:_1€:<§ Em' £'i'1f3di{?E;1:i <:%:<;:=<?n{iit.1,3:":;% {:0 firm: i;¥X§'IE'rI'ﬂi cf Rs.§2sC}30€}£}j--__. 'E316:

appz31i.21:1i; W215; i:1p.21'i.i<5::'1':; £232' 3:. ;:>:'-%ri<:»d caf 15 C12-1};Se_.'z.:Ié'{i_ ':%:I_1<:% is; 5:1'i",i1::1a>,{§ far Rs.5.000/~ icwzarcises :17e<i:;{:;:._i---- 21:§iie%id2§i';1: * (fhélfgﬁﬁa Furiiheas, cine ii} the_;&}f3{Tid{%I'3§.f,, i i"1:a{,»<':=i;é1i::1.zi.i:f(: V :;t:3:,1}.r:i 119$: wc>:tik for" 21 period of <)ri':i: I:i?:311t..E1, '-§ﬁ§f£.n<:«:: en'{;it}€<:i ft): <':e:m1p:%1'1$at:1'<m vo§_ F§s§.:1_.5'C}D_/~ .{;<mf2i_.r§ié§"%Iaj'$;$ cf"

i1E'}(?'.(T}I"£TI€f d:1:'i11g the iaici {.11};{3'€:"iI;T7if}';i. '-»__Sh.C £S'ai&;a5 <3:1t:2"{.1ee:i for e:*;e:)1npe11s:e1§:§(>:': of R35'; ".E'GJf}.Qf)/~ if<§vz?«.2f*¢»2:f5{E:+s 19333 of Euiztxrcr €;%21':"'ni:1g§ss a:1CI_ ::1-- SL§:n Qf i,{§v;i-%2";i"dS {1€}U.E'iShI'11€f1{, and {7{)f]§':E"_"'}r'E3:l§"i'{?-3~.§3h?i}'g€3-€§;.._ In 3}}. the: »::i2n'ma:1':: ES €t:'§fE;ii,i€:d far 'i'}*::"{ (30:11p<>:1é;::£.£,i<§§':---- (55 Rs.EEQ.O0Of~ 213 gxgzzirlsgé'. E'€:~5;.;}';?3;'£3G€3j~ 21:§v_zix£-*'21.:'{§<é<:E {by iiim "i':"iE>'L::'12:d. {E211} E342 'I'}1s:~. &1§)pf;'r&1I is aiiowed in £3213'? TEEQ? §'f1§§EVH:::-:?'§~§i '£25 éirmiikzd for iihéfi €:{}IZ1p€fI'1S2ii1i{):1 of Rs.60,GO{}'f; 21é§_T'23.g:;z~;i:1s~:'{._ 7 Rs7;.2:3l3G0/~ ax>var€i:::%«:i by t:.}1&é'i'ri1§1,1rié:}; 'i'}3e &311ha;'1~::<;%d wmpezj1s:2zi:.i<3§;--. Shaii <>a::é:f§,r i:"1I3e:"€s§f;aifw 1'.:he .rai;<:: 0f 8% pa' fr<)1*1'1 E%1é=,{i"21i,e €)1,CV"ff.3_i.1V'T§_;§V':€.)f éﬂaiﬂl peti'::§<:§I1 {iii t.1i1s> éiexiie ._ The f£rs3.t,"'2i¢ssp:::':i:€1£:rn€;: is«:?:§.3§r<t{ti.~::(%' ta e:iep»:§.s~;;-§"I. izhzs. e:":ha;n«;*.€;<"1_..a;§§f;c:};i-:1i'1;7_wii;};.i;i--w..a ;ie:53';'c:sc§_ sf 8 weeks {mm the Saigl .Z§?§;?'}§ §:i:.;3§:;';%'<..,. %

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court