Karnataka High Court
Miss Pressy Pinto vs Mr Rony Maxim Pinto on 12 September, 2008
Equivalent citations: AIR 2009 KARNATAKA 157
Author: Manjula Chellur
Bench: Manjula Chellur
TEE PHGH C.OLs'RT QF KARNATAKA} BAZ'€{}AL{)RE , DATED T§fiS 123* mix' 0;? SEPTEMBER 29:3?' ~ : "[j , PRESEEQT Item BQ3*§'BLE*Z mas, §US"I'ICE :s»§A:>s::,mA.':i:§ §::;:;::;{"' ' ;2.3®---
T'}fiI€ Hi")N'BLE misc. ms? _£&.PPEA'L zf';§;';';t34j9::':;2,e@?{?P' s:T_$i€:; BEETEEJESEN E's:§SS PRESS? ?E~E'E{?¥- _ ' Em }_.:§'E'E§ E'.-_£}'{§§S ?:;{:-:';{'s;?> .. _ ' ?§E\E'E"{j} 2r'_2__LI..§ Keg, G£}R3;§}LT§B5s%._ " "
:,:3:;G:?:»i;' iéfsfifiiizi ':xu:.L31f__?a::s'E' ' :a,J::.&.E-§{;*T;;$:T[:f;;ze=3»§: 5*z'£s::><::?"*~..'_A '_ ;%?§'E£n§_.. :3-.Z'«§'§' 53:; 353%;
_.:'%J'*~§§3 :
' _i Ram' a<:,%$,Xm PENTQ s:i-3, L;;;;'E §..€}{}E'S"Pi'~IT{} _ §:»?g;g2:\:'£%:»ms':1;x2a:§ Aasm .;%B£11%{,'%'§' :33 ':'E.S * FR;/5; SEZEQEJEERA ifT:(;>'"£'T;§{}E§ A Bfiffigig " " :»V:;a;~::%;;x;;:":RE '§;%:N.z;'§:
Ema
2 :xsi§<:'._m:~£cY AE'€"}T()E€'&' ?§}~;"§§; S%'r€3?L§TE LQEES P§i'€"I€3 AA ' BTCFE zaéazga 3AB§;:%,{} ?€:s$T QFFECE .. i§¢"ELLAY A'? Mii,?"'§'f"R:iIi S{f§§.»':§'€2'§TE GE? {}E°%x1;%"f€§ ?{}S'L5e.E. €f€}§Ef; Z34 &: SC 6.539}, In {he saici EEA, 324.592 by znakixxg rafareme £9 {ha éisscifaion sf AEw"§H®':~E'Y SE%z'AE'v{'i' Vs. CHG'%?'RA,?v£\£A ER 2939 1"4s.;;§»:"Lj:z§;é - .. V ieamaei Szzége hem ihai the REA. %%;§u§d '$3 §'fifii§':'i£iii'E&§:':§§.
2. 'E226 {swig $13: Eeai Ea that ffiiszzg 0fvrn§.sc~i:§%'a:2e:>';zs-I::;§;3§:z§_E>¢§é%s:
éhis {Yam £2: 'i%rée;f gm zmécsg':
E3 & Si? §?L='2G§i§ azama is; at '$33?
szgaéxasz {ha &;:s:;;a§§a:§%i iwrain a1m%.f§he :'éZ3gé'ei§T"'E"z's"*;..'i':?:E:5£f:;'»§.'V €3.i§_Z§3€ Eé '§§£"5{.s::%s:s$e{% %§j; the 2a§3p€}.3;3fl€51'€$§%f:d€§1i. fizeréféfgg' ':5; 'ea =::a::nwr:eé 53.314502 in '9Ji€'€%' 4f§§¢§i{3n éff V_$E#'t%'Si3§§;?-L'éé§':'f.3§1 Act. 'xlflaezrz {ha éeczree in fhfi $§3;i;§:"'vfi15:iEAA~--:§z1;::<1¢' Qizazilééigégé fiiizzg miscellanemzs apgeaig ihfzi wméid be maéniaingbie €22 viexér <3? t%%:é_§:%§>r~§;'je:z'\;f&i:is;',$z":1V:'V":;~,f:'" fizéga an cazéési Qccfisifiii ii:
Rm, 32%-2, V 2 ' _"'E1§,3§:-giiszgs 2§5;"'?:%_9%_§s2:' Enéiarg g§§€i3$$S'§.=f§§'i sac; }§3§ aiaé 5:) £59 954,, *:::.e;,« ._{_f>réer 43 Rifles :s. & 2 {:5 gm CBC. ;°isEa*-=:a2:*§§ gm $28 --§:{::f;%::>s@ Vaé£7§3";;"'--_;$:V"%;§§3Eé§'1g ma abéfisfi mafia? ii": 3%.: fégééi §3*?::'§§;<:,"c%:é3:-'in:
Z-§<:s;:i:§{2fi 295 :31' $26 Egaéiazz Saaasggieié 5&3: méiig as I.2m§::i': ?:°z§c¢éa,::'§: in ssfiiagiiéas $3.535," its 223:}; 83.8% _ " * Eééfzm aha zxgsrécg Euége in «man shsfa $5 a:£2§I§ei%%§e%§; 32%;»; §i*<;s;.:.::€:é§;:g gfiigfi §aE<:;:., as :33&z'§.y as may he, {he fmm :2? 3 :*a:g:;§a;° Sui: acwgxéiztag is ':%z::: gym-'igiezzg as?' $13 iffézséc as? <,".?§V§.§ Fiacééuia 3.9%, ii: w§3.%::-%} {E33 gmiiiancr fez: grsbaéss ax' Eeiéesrs sf adminisiraéézm ag 3:322 case may '£223., s§2;:.§§ ha Eééii >T g:§§§§§f§i§ mi: '£223 §'!$§'S€3E§ §§.:§1{3 E133 spmzzzrssé ii} ep§3:':a5;;€:~~i:§:§§:. _' L" gmzzé giaafi 35:: figs $::%'m{',:an%f' '.'§;§§ 'e':,,?*?"'é;' yméizzg £2? fém szsciéan ma%::sfé'z iiézmjf $333.;"€2£€'§;é;I3§:'%;*%'§£""§2§: agzgiésaéian far gm}: csf pssbais $1" iegisrg sf aéi::_:§§€§s£;";::%§9§é'§;:A £i'_32§?§Iif~§§i§s'§ '§.'h§:V " $77 saéé ::t§p§.%caE§9§'a Wszgki 3u:Qmgz£::a§.§§i_€§;:m E3. he %;::gu'}'a;z'"'é:%;:§'E? as aaniamgigaieé under £236 ;3":2:}*4;%$§»:}:3§ $5 V,Va:"i"7.§£='<L.§ Egfifififiaiifiréi' {Z':;:s:%::.5E%: §az:*ih».3«;=;' §0§}3":::1§t:*s ééaai $1,.-€21 fiiéé gsafiisg 4' ';:.%f1ir:%:°zéa!__t§é A«§§:a*§§_V€a§<;$ 32:: ffsfm {sf péaizziifi' 32:21:: ;3:":3"@;;%s car' é.€%:€:%:2és%:?aé.%§f:%: am? ihés §3az'2i§* Exgéza ssgzgsgssz 3;}:-3 V{V'%§.ii;V:Ef:V§_'?§'§?E'{}'§5:3§§§'{%§' 1:fi§i{{:$§ stzf ai£m§§:;és1::*.2:§:7=§:f3 éahgii %";a:;@:z*:é flag éésfésaéézsfii; ._ V " .V ;'§££;§%{§:3L 399 {3f?;iF:.:":'- .F':.%:é »-a="eé;::§.&; ag zmaierr ':>=i.§§§e1§=§§§ frffim a§'§%;*§ 9?' §}§Si!°'i£§ .}z;§g€.»=.Ev&r}»* 'é~*>2°z§:':§i izgads 'av~---§;--'-fiéirécz §§:€§g$ E35: 'afififféizf :33" {E32 §2¥Z>W€E'§=; ' * --. _ hafabyf agzifafiad 21335:: ézézn sizaié Z13: m%}_;§@a:2: £9 gggggaé is '£33 §3ié_2:§3:"€;', <%:,:;'.%j'éz2~acw:*t§;1r:2:;:s:% iésiiéz §s'Qv%siez2;§ 9?? $25 ffids ef ' ' Eféiééi szfipiiztafiifi 15$ sgagsealsatf' ";+'% §3§3:§af; z*$a:;.§.§zzg $1? ihg a%>:>"s.:@: sastéiazé sareagéd girrzgyégx égzééazzzéss £333: <:%3"'é:.':r j ":*r;ae.:§.e:_ 3 .§}é%§::%{;: Ezgégs ::§a:%$:* §%z;~; pz°s:2i_~=":is;§£r§:.§ £2? irzgééaiz 2C§§f:é;S§,:-fiS?駀}fi 534:: u gizéié §$ s;:3%"::§m:: $9 3§°§Zéf$§§ $23 Big}: C5333? E1': 2¥.é;=;T§i"a:§.,<'§%"?;{:é' Wéiiz 5&3 '§}*§"£%'€é=:é§{?f§;% of :23: $3426 sf {:§:'s'.§§. ?*;9:;.::{§:2:*:f: a§2§§i::a%3§§-3 K: 3;§§3i:':?3;§S. Szzstiém §€}4 waés as ufiéefz ** 'C}§'§§"31"'S; fmm xvéziaéa apgzmé Em,-{E} Pm a§;:e::.:sZ:" sézafi Eis-3 fmm Eh: §%2E%<:aw§::g ifiiéiiifi, am? 33%;: gag {}§}E€§3fi3¥§;§%> --. . :::§§:r::3§%§,:' §}%1'€'.3""»*"§§€.?§ in fiaszz bed}: sf iézis {:€;>{3;Ei5 35 21}; giiafgj L" fer {its time Eétzizzg in fififfiéif %;'1':::sm as a§E;%:c2* "J.?.'§é:3i'ii 5, -.
{if} an aréer under Saéciizen .33»-_..»T'x: _ . 2 {ffa} gm eras? ::§:c£a2f.<S@.;f£§s;n {yr f~;::::.:'is;:»1z*§ E33, féfiifiifig Eaavs {<2 §§3Sfii§3€$ :3 gtsiz'-:;§""$§:e :a;:£?;3z1?:_ :°é:f+'::°:'zi:a:.% ii: ' Smiian 9? cs: §2, as iirw azase may 42;;
{3} aa azéaz u:z;i_;:é4"~$:::;::§:ér: §§;"' -,_ , {E2} gm £:s:'€§&§' z2:1§%sr":;z:} <:;§ iéaég Coiie §mpesi:a;;;:3 fine c>:*"&i:*::.iAé:2g'é§;%3._3:*;'<:si 5;: géazérc:-mien. $3 $2: s:é*2?é.§ §2"=_k{§:%««.Q§';§:2jg*§ez'§;£;:z~'<:3:'2:é:;§% --§;'§?;i»:1:f;;_is;%;:s;;E2 :::s§23.s:' <2: i§<:é:@:§'£:§$;;.--%}:=é'-- 32:2'; %;§:_::_s;;%§a;~;;; *':ff 5;: _;i@{,:1{3::<s2[j . % '}a:€§; 'c:';«:is:%é:§'. Vgéizagivfi' 335$? miss; §7:°<;m é-'a:'E*2%s:;%2 mg aipge-éisi is <::apra;s:«i§ ~-aéfizcmé mies;
?f@V§{§£:i €323; Eiiusgitvgfieési ssiéaéi iii: agaifigé zany; a':--:°éa§' §§$a;:§§E:; .. {£3213-::: {$3 '$3125: an 351% giyumi Eftgzgi nae Qfiiifii', 53:" gm. wgiaa'
- Sag? mymsfit <:«fé"*Ea:=;s a:§°:.<>':m:,, :>a.:g%:§ '£53 éaazzs 22%;: zamziasn 7 {-Zn} ghaéi iii": farm an}; ::s:é:"s:§§:z" ii?
" .__g.;3g%:%aE"_*vi:3:;i-afiééxis Ssgiien 2% {if £326 Eéimitz §a=i2:r§"§ag~;:= flag':
§9§5:?*-I. '.T}§'§"'i' Fifi,» §§=i%;:§::r$ E §:c IE zsfiaé §§ 飧'§€§f:T:f{'2 »&
3.: 5-i§§£&§§ §*§*e§2§ z's§f{§%.=-§*§,a%:'"; ag::§:<::s§ *E*;;aE§ f hm " f§}§{}§%"§E'§g €:§:.§z':z'§ émiiziz 532;: ;§"§'::wx§:;%{>;:§ :3? s':;:<;§;'{;::§ Eiéfié, §agm::§j§;;« {;§} 33:": {3«§{I§i'E' :52/zéeg" yagés 2%} €}§"§;i';1§' E-FEE :':':§::.:m%§2g; ;:
§§§3§§ :5; 3:5 §?§'§S;I'-fiiifé E3 éiic €Tp'§'iE§}@1' {g*.:s::;::§:':w€:
we Zi£% afiszé mscazsga,-:**§_,»* 3:"; mfsé" E3 é:E::': éeiiézéiiafi iifiiifif §"%§§?*~§:'»a';§£), {3} if}? ~_ u 55:. 2 and ;z§:~:{% fisfméiéea "i::*é::*:'" %,§§'§{§i':§" a:;%3»:-§:::::. { 3%} :3? Sag. 2 {sf 3222 f,T'3'€f7 {:3} an {}§"逫'I' ziizzim Ruia 2 9f Oféaz' XXX!' an agpéiezaiéim (fig: 3 case agsarz $23 §3;§§:a==:'.:3?;} f::3::_.§x{:_; " erderis set asiée fize égismésgaaé sf 3 §uii: V "
{am} an eréazg mafia: Rififi E g}: Rzgis '.?"é;f ' XXKEEZ yaéagéiag an §p§E.§ea§:§0fi gas as as ifiéigsni gyersigngj " A. ». .
€C=}{K?'iX} V V _ V ._ {$2} carzisfs in §:1ta2p§€:3d¢§;1S::§;§£é:r:§r:.r ¥;u%§ g% of Risk 6 e::~'.'éff,};'ds1" :sg;.*;aI<::'«:'2é; 1' " "
{Q} an crder uzzé§é:' Rs,§i¢ '27v {sf (Ems?
xtéfivzziz . "
{f} _;-:21' %,EIE:<T§€1' g§{:.-£3: 2:'; R213: 2';
' 'A -- .1 @353' 2:3 <:::~;2$§;«'§::":%:<;§<;
* {S} ':1;§=;4§5¢:f.[§;i;--§;g.' fer Rifle 4 of ifiréer EL; " {:3 gzdeggri ,.§e§§é1ai'ande; Ruia .19 6f ifiiréar 2:3; " i"a~.:%;.:im£:.§ gumar me :2; Q5 Gym §{I.,I fie _ re§;:»é§%Ea:"_,.;::.§:.:g;:<;3eaE;
33.:' i'm ardatr 335$? 313$ 23 53' R211: 335%} $3' {:'?§"§§"E' M u mnzanéézzg a sass? %5.='ha:'c gm gggéeaé iémuéd ' 56 {mm 32% éacrae af the xépgaiéaés Cmm;
u 1 {xxx} ' " :'_%2:}§z: eyésr urséag' R353 4% GE' {Ewes .I'{L'%:"EE ggzzfifig an agzgsiésaiiafl fez' re2:i€:%:,*"
~'"a afiaécéz zsgadg 3% %,§ZE£§£E'Z EEC?
aiéew' the §31E'fi€S ii} ieaé €*a»'§€§<:.3rif:£:s3 aaé {hen f;°a3E§§; §3r9:.;:'3:e;é %§ fiffifiiféiliafiz {ha Ezisifigriistzzi éfiarssing £2; éismissing €336 mi: RS Ei2<e":2Viész°?::'ii:.%js,%. be As pm' sub»~sz:a:..{1=$) sf sac. 2 "ce3*£¥e2"§" 3§S{"§ €115-EEEES fermzfi éxp;'e§;§i€:-:3 3:13: decisisn cf 3 :.::i'sri§ Cam': wkich is 2:0: 3-i:%a*c:--'s§:¢. '£33153 5:;-a: <-2 t}V1=:2--_}{F', SC. takes me fafm ef as: miginaé Sui; aii {ha §§f'-3§A1 %.;--.§;:z;§:e"
pmceeésd with anfi 3:6 aiiimaie restafiféieggid 537' 321%:
$1" distxzissirzg {he suit. "fix: figaai deai$i_<21;¢f.3 'cggataééé ':§%aA:i¢1; §3§:;€ai3';§21g Ea issues ef pmbaie 9:' Eetiefs" éi$i?;}T?.3'.1if£{S§'€Ibfi€.'§§i'3IV3.'VVlliifiifkaffiijv' reguéis in farm sf 3 éeisree if the-«:.afs€ sf .E§w "
5. En Qiigésj w::§:'{15s_,, i:__*Vv;Zr€:;e sf ste'e§iéa;V?;%"55 cf Endian Succsgsiazz graé fiié €§7cfz:2iAii:;:ns :'%:f;*:*;°a*:':§3<§~'i§i:";§b<21-faiii: cgniesiazi mama' fig: .§'»';'S§'){§%:€ 33? :5 §€€§§§0§'ivV§0E°'§}f{3§'§&£;3V{Bf"§€:iE£i"§T$"'i3.§§§ii'§ii*;i§S§E"&§i£§I% %::e»::::>me3 3 szééf magi E23' vzifizaaz arzf sga:s;::i{%?.._2§f¥ ':%:::._a§;;%;:é%.§jEia§§ 'in': £3': ascardanga vséiéz fizz: §E'€E'v'%$§£}3'é§ _ . in {sf {Tf-c:;<§_%--; sf i7I'i&:i§ Fgésaéagfsz B3; vézms sf g:z§==se<:Eé:::s;:: g2} {:25 §ac?.'.§s>zz: Viéé. Qfiiar Rzfig E, such §.T:§I'§i£Si$(§ mafia: againsi fshe {srdefs ix: asigfiaé V' é:£f§gs;:éa sf prabaée or ifi'€"{€iE"%; ef adsnézzisimééfin has Ea be icritasfiéas Ragga: Agpeai. $5 aireaéjg siaisé akeva, afzm" rsfazfiéng fig Ehe ggéaxésiegs V of fiaa Kamataka Sam": Fee and Sasits Vaiuatima Asa 'u_fE§i€«'§;1sL§€:_%;: Bvézaszsh af {his Cam: in A.N"§'HC}N':' S"=§é':'§é. "3 case has saifi haw _; ,&)' V " . '?L?{:érz2 {as has :9 be gafi an a ca:=q2{es'£ed mafia: fieyiaixxing 'ée issaazica af .V _§;€:$f§%f§ :3? 3{im.é::1is€ra:i01'2 <32" prafigée. Eé-fianaxxar aaz accasim: mass {:3