Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
Hemanta Kumar Behera vs M/O Railways on 10 August, 2023
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
3% cK
COPTACK GENCH, COTTAE
GAN. 2600/0005 1 of 2021
PD eceses ete es : ae TP pages ae wees aga ek one Xs.
Reserved on G4 06,2023 rrarncimeced oan ¢¢
CORAM:
{SVATIET RAPD OCe ARALTYES IIAP AR PAG Barr AY
HON ELE MR. PRAMOG KUMAR DAS MEMBER iA}
ori Hamanta Kurrar Behera, aged about-35 years, §/o. Samanath
Beher a at present working as junior Ragincer (O/ Mech}, Hess
Leco Shed, Vishakhapatnam un dor Sr. DME (Senior Divisional
Mechanical Engineer}, {Diesel}, Diesel Loco Shed, Vishakapatnam,
residence At- OTM Colony, Qr.No. AfS4, Choudwar, Dist-Cuttack,
Resa oot
. Applicant
Par the Applicant: Mr, B. Mohapatra, Counsel
-Versus-
i. Union of India, represented through its' General Manager, East
Coast Railway, Rail Sadan, Chandrasekharpur, Bhubaneswar,
Dist- Rhurda, PIN-?5 1017,
2, The Principal Chief Personne! Officer, East Coast Railway, Rail
Sadan, Chandrasekharpur, Bhubaneswar, Dist-Nhurda, PIN-
. <8
3. The Senior Divisional Railway Manager (Personnel), Kast Coast
Raihvay, Waltter Division, Vishakhapatnam, PIN-530020.
The Olvisional Personnel Officer, O/o the Oivisional Railway
Manavert( P)/Khurda, East Coast Raihvay, Khurda Road Division,
At/PO-Jatmi, Dist-Khurda, PIN-752050.
GAN SY GOUSE piss
z PEM Soojoeteaaer Ghose pent
ty OE ae ¢ SSSR Fersannes
Auspo] Jatal, Dist- -Khurda,
ow hespondents
adents: Me. MUR Mohanty, Counsel
ORDER
Pramod Kumar Das, Member (A) According to Ld. Counsel for che applicant. vide memorandum & BY +} dated 02.05.2019, approval of the competent autharity was conveyed for temporary transfer af 35 non-gavetted vacant revenue posts of Diesel Shed /VSKP to be operated In Memu Shed /Rhurda upte a periad of one year or sanction of posts for Memu Shed, Nhurda, whichever is earlier. Vide letter dated 10.06.2019, it was decided to call for the option from the willing staffs fram Electrical, Mechanical Department of Waltair, Khurda, Sambalpur Division, which was directed to be circulated among the staff to submit their option on or before O8.07.2019 vide letter dated 24.06.2019. The applicant, whe was working as [E (0/Mech) in the O/o Sr, DME (Diesel) Diese! Loco Shed, Waltier, submitted his option along with other. The DRO, ECoR, KUR, requested vide letter dated 12.12.2019 to DRM, Waltair to spare the applicant along with 18 others for screening test scheduled to be held py the SY. De OL} BOR X> K cLYR AEN SPL Ay gg the willingness and Feu * trapeher of af the applivant along with five athers for the! my aft Memu Shed, was withdrawn to accommodate RRB empanelled candidate at Memu Shed. The applicant submitted representation against such withdrawal on 1LO6. 2029, which was rejected wie speaking order dated 19.11.2020 agerieved by the aforesaid decision, the applicant has Aled this OA under Section 19 of the AT Act, 1985 inter alla praying to fa) quash/set-aside the withdrawal order of Respondent No.4 vide GNce order No. P/Riect{OP)/MEMU/Q4/2020 dtd 26.05.2020 under Ammesure-A/?, {by to Set asite/quash the speaking order no.
Sr. DPO/Stal AV OA423/20/KRB/Elect(G) ded. = 19.11.2620 -- of Respondent nad under Annexure-A/9, {c} te direct the Respondents ts uphold the arder No. P/ElectlOP)/Memu/O1/20 dt. 24.408, 2020 so as te transfer of the applicant from Waltler division for posting at MEMU FY Shed, Khurda under SrDEECOPS, Khurda for operation and rn, % shes oe "
Lee Bs toy : th ot wn $4 bg 'eos at ee aa if ee tof ae Bs aft " ae ten ee ae $0 an poe Rone baad ed cans 'eat no pat vn. je oad OS oe, Tn tere fev a te po topree tad "ee ee nad gS os a re a pet "fp 7 yok sent #3 3 % pies oe pee we 'home ve 3 a4 oS a we, thee, wy Lonad Le te ty HM es % con pon {3 £00, i e ' pon oe ers, Mn pares. re fn ~ cont es ne a He po KE aes ; pe oy ae ae mo ped ag os a forte oa ey i i oa pes pees beating pot. seine: sens gon ead Pe rad oe Sox on vgs Bore bins een: peed ee poet tad = ae aed a ted. Ay a4 wenn os wate, pea Ieee. pany Fs oe 4 $l x 'e het we ey ied ons eet we bee : sae Mee tana ps seed ood ee ad 'fe hg a nae a3 a oe ae 'anes es ae = 5 as eed ood het a en rae 3 oe a oe : ae a me ne re ole : ore i at seen ed he on ot bases os re ant ce ee" ee eae ee ond sated eo ie on, a oa ms bok * 34 des $ * neat pay WS ig pins fete, yee. Pe at Led oo essa : coat sid oh $0 oo Foc dood Lone wee beef penne, aoe £% 3 aoe rae a waa oar peek . Mee, peers a8) ipa: s aetna £5 ns 5 oe Ep:
" wee inet pe on eon ; or, aed os $e bites ae ab Baw. pte oy ees ne iene Sento, on aia Faster! oes: Samed , te L es "ae wie fot pool a onl oo 'seat os bet tet e oo eet fea anes 7 ; road Ke et: Paes wed, Feocl t oo a Ey Pa ecb ay BS ne g TA ao het ines ad a 'a. hee: is . 00) Ya Koos my pan * % thy uF ie oer vers a ain pes. poe "at tte Sees at, ee ' cel teh BFS Led pees ay} oa Se ae : gon oe Si fy oA 'ies, fox hd pn pons os eR hee ee Foes iced ra Hot "pon wenn fun, vi ; me 8 si ates. gee, ret Bock oe et ' Soo, Loe on < tok ad ioe f3 a Mo pees Peer yeti Shades. Pees oo "S teed pee vee whore 2 Fy ee wD By ay pe S det wane pet: nee "aah ad Rad Tega Dae. gk at: acl uy os " : Ae p pt Geek sm, Mines rae 7 coat ine we yn nel ere" Fagaa wey, hoe asealh ee oud, wa oS aad ere ee, att. Hone ete Snead ; lope See. Stee, c en ne panes rd a4 on woh bee Ant Lom pees ae ieead 3 Ce Fang = oa t a7 at oe ee é wore eal 5 a Mr og om a " foe 3 het pees pa pein oe, os 3 bee Ro Bed we in a 3 ce jes ; oo os cad if : pad a ; ro i © 5 eee ae "
we we a ie "y doen va aed ee "3 m4 a pe:
poerr ast ire ee et pars ors Ae Se Folk fy Pied pone peace oes fy wet wapes pers ead tes 5 coe nel ee sons) ioc pen a eA ped par bead aa pp' hoe Bs ee aeeee ' ie x an bg é See j = a A ret en ws ene aA os pees eae: be bad seeeet Ai ton ° wepen Eo shoal vet eat weet ay t eed . eet, ak oS £ aS ie toot i tet eed wane ed * 74 Geen? ae on Bact bmeey ne Goes kes hes, showt te 4 rn ut The ns a3, hed: At wen, ken' we a "yy Sho when ee 'ae 3 on Pon at £ see pe pa * soas erate Fog fe oe rnd ire bet ie 'eee te bee eee ven eee 5 bid wae % peed we res veda wh: fd he pe Gs tL raed werk, KE ak me ro ys : £3 a3 oe yet ae one cA , "bet B :
yer pai tee ad Fad fe hiea ms am Bs a) * we ny Ae booed wy . few Sow wet Dhed wer gn oe ™, bead peo sheen & Ge Gs , fod om, hers oe wen 3 wen ret ieee wheat reves oo hoot « i" ofa het S a "dood nage. "tee f pa nee : XE oy wy weeny asad ote, 43 ieee os at, tetas! tot on ' " get 'ea. as Pe ; "hat ee " Monee pan psoas baad aa +f% cad Fed fd ret Sune on a : bet ben x thee 3 Lt not re 5 Vea 4 coed Seat Sd hot gen rts web tet ee oy ees eee. she, os Om as "ee yee: dee ee ~ anges od, aa pn Fas Sane fee. eae en Bis ae peed ae bond oe re pion a3 o, my ty ' a3 eae a ae pats ot we ie fen be ? wd Tas "ee bee bose ae Paes aa nana pars Or, ; aoa ; pes wes fh we Cane Fer; ' 'nai tees oe. i ", Frees Pa pen * Ka send we ion oe aa Sob sen ach feet, ae peed a3 pet : cam ean Os Lh Qe uy Cx asa cad Jeo yi pe gn Ss "os bee ae ined : ; 5 HE Pea ~ Sees sa ox pee on woe oD re ' we eet 4 ro oe, ey bed o ee 3 i 3 en ae oe wee. eee Prony) ee fo ane oy panes Face} od 4 aod 'seg woe ae ye ae 'eit on OG & fi pas £% ot ¢ She eta Naab Rs aad ere seit pont 'eae Cy ea ' sey fac tad poce roa my or Be we : S43 a i iad i poe fad rag ref ee) i ee ited Vieni poked tS Ce fais oe = 5 fee 3 a ia se oe S oe Jerre. wy om, ae re, o i, end A rane fd ak % oe feeb pe bod a Ses Nt one seed "eat pe,
2 sped ae fae gs oie oe ld wae tA deed te a on, of Geel cane shat hss wod wn ots 4 Sat ion Bs shoal ape ae ope, Sed pod 5 sate a) orbit oy ben Wr, Bs " a 44 ~ bag bee pean of a pad biel pose 7 ae pan 1 pa he a "a ' oe Gy Seba a Mw Oy wee os, tet ae 2 oot ed ce : pevcced Pae oes, ta one pars eee. od we yee yee ee ae ft oot ee gee Des, ire, ay idl oS Rees: wo ined wg Spa? Beet Nesp pe es se ' best ped Boss ve deat ines 223 te, eh : ' ae: < oe 4 Foogt oo eS ie EE hoe ~~ CS ee inet omen By cae) a, noe oe eet ee: a * Saas, a, bal *~, pete, et ere pon po pe} oe este oad epee ge 5 ae a Rey Sa ee. ae pe tyre a5 ete % focand "ae fy a3 eed 4 wee, Seat ee Ie 'al babies wert Ee went ee, rae a Kadlee, yan, 23 ye, 5 Sone stag z paid een uy Beene ' oad vas fon pate ; OG we sone: eet bog en gt inane aa 5 boa os ed en het toy em PL, ad to Sad aged tt x oF, iio aes pier ~ ood eee: ey Drea" " ie Pasa idsad atl gat * pam sant bacco! See ae "SoA "en ad aad oe fas ahine, ty > yok Eacoos iow) pode cal ae arta nd, eo eran: vane a3 pA tr ie me pace hebed fad on boa Py chet ep fe tee deus she oo i" a, So Pet bees pos rs tae ob Be $ : sind 'oat a oh, as we co ee fo ie Te res thet = wh ~ ow, raped x pet m, at Po pagood Gy ioe oe, al Fes Nese: ers 2K an beter Sinha aes we ifs : an ae po. weds ™ % ' - ta Ess te oo, Fo 05 oy ag anes Saori chet to: .
ea' fe. aes wes ree isa Pood ", oa Pans "aa ae *. Peon Sa spn saat :
i, p ~ % ia £3 ee fi % ae °% eed age beard Ns 7 tert om, eal goes ox pee bow. ms % 53 de. Sere 2s 4 . oe yer we esrir, Boe en pe vm ott ee we, DL ncoet inne barre. pte, Ly ca Bee poe pane yw gee, By Yok re? wad fens hod nal road vanee Z nod = ve = rae pass a eos a am it ana we. a oe, mee fon yes ss on i Ly & vo nevee a moos, 6 % "as "ete ee B yt fat fee i bite + fie wee:
fia ae "nah hes as # nee or, me, : whee, ne e vm ne een wean. Ne om. on, ~ boob pa fea a A 'eet deed ees a a oe "e as me at aad toot ah . an a eid ge . fee 5 is besa oy wit og song peel venes sien Sere, ned? yi ¢ Nae ae) aang * om os rie) cs tp ewe & of reac aod es es ok i ; he: cS 4 pee % % 2 wen pm el en pa esod irae} bes 4 en ae ei ws ens wee " tC Ming ool re oa ped x ae eed pees, WG bow. ee fas ten a nt aad ne eos one had as " * het yn wet ee pare oe shea af Ba pan baie, be a <tee aft past ~ ay a " * "i xe : ea deed bers oes aes 'sett iat ea gon, Eat se wy Fain oid oe athe: ' Saat Me, pen nnn cae ha t , etn " wt med ven ad anes, posses ereed Ps CF Sows, Lael woe. esa nat ad eed Pa] biked o- Eons z yee ° ~ wen ot oe ee Saal pa ooh way cont eee pee ne a oad 4 A ne, pos 7, a bse a5 2% "3 ws bert, "Mone, ae ie x Lae pay a 23 Ne eed * Ss va mn oy a * eed ne eet venee bok Lo gy , yy ee ty ta ih <r vn rs Book oa pees aad ne 7 he F a 3 tod oe roe : me, 5, hed ae The "es wore," oe ps ns on pean ct bese epee pone ren ss elon pened am me pate) "ay Rae . ks ex | wy fans bes 'a aeee he a te! A wet be ; a S : :
See ae Be oe oe ay pea ga vee we papael sea pe : * % we as as me x a " ro = "oe od 53 pas ; eres eed yee ber ed fee ap er aes, 7 neo ~, ny See . res peers we " rae 3 poet + ow Se heed oo % ohio i oe re bs peu a an ae wae pooet ad as vere! eee ié yee peeves ragn he va poe ead pm, vn he te oes ee oa oh ps4 ae ol ws 4 tor Ab . yt ww aa a C3 (naa, wee hs "ore a Li ew Pa ween see on dont eae ae paey EE pene weeee ey 3 Caeed ae teaeny toe is yo ts ty wei 7, wows te een, ae ae a ee . coal S < tet ~ oon ot ior 'ne pare te a ; rm pan rey 2 i' 2 Ss yor , om, ot ry oe a aie wa Eyre be [oe ee 0) ae oe if ;
ape, Dem ee "sd Sod ys 5 panes ae het oe pees sais janes oy won os . Ay . : ; Fo he an * Sed -- UK yw pes aA Gs ny tS nee om loa sepa as sce or = 23 A w ina ke =s 6 ras! = m & ea a tn om shot oe eS won pet new, ' oa ~ c%, chee aoe yon oad eaets oped bara! Eee tae oy Pot fooe he eg, : 4 tod 'oh ° verk, Sy. wry, ceaed peers wey Pe aenacd Poss cag ws ook Ae we ee bese ; Bh i 'ad % ee oe oieo £ Re < os hee meer wees 4 ewes Ok pan ae Pity baa ~ feos or Eon et fewer ed wee et ot Lae ae a re sa ? ae a ome nt cme, oe ae * wrreh wet ne a a A, Soe Reoad a, poten at * aoend based vr yee Nteit, a , re ibe! ' are, ar pat ie fh an ous va Fes ps At ' bag eed aera we "ad wr tu weet Peal ad 'aloo? wee a ae 23 wea é ae oo £ er % ; a & re oe 'tat ad feaal etre, Moen Sa ie fae ft ond roy oD we "rod ee r a3 ' * , 8s 7 Daal vs, Me en "seid wtewe ner, rent ae (sed Ye 3 Pome) nA rd . gree, " Coe a bed ft " FA as yet oo " car eats Lad ayer + ae J sit Ga evioee, deh bewe yee ent ay a: ~ co on, aed ee eect on ay po] od Loe od sane wet tn, pee * Ye peat o% ee aa pon et ae sone ewes ne ages ' pe = us : tt rs GS ea a Se ia ry . my where, ama] Rocce we, ran "neil we we wey aon of we ed fen os oo oe oa a Fae a ood aa pon Deer ome renee, pa aac need at! 4 frat ce fon G Fas s ded ae so x "S ae g ™ ue Pepe. aes Fes) pon we soe, par . x hg io Pans oe Po ae oe ae ws ot Fi ra w mene St 6 wy a wee a ied o Sotee ns ek wood on =z fad tent laa aed we dees bees ers ea .
ae wes ca ted at taad: howd: we vad =" panes ~*~, Ls robs, aan : om me ~~ ret bes toring a meres x Read ded a Feed See Soa - by Daoaed Soft wey ifs heseed fa, Ieee os hood a ro o aoe Paes Fees Whee ekg ES feed ps mr yee, LF Sox we cas oe ar be ve, o met " "*, ae 3 's ee ws aaa' 4 ss a ee o wn os ee a 3 8D yee vet tend aad cars name 44 2% hove sti a faened 'et a sboet a Bes a ad pss 43 ta = a ae ont oy 7 fs we, yer a : ww vow, aad eat be yee ' vag 4 tf} Feats, =, Go Saw aaa won poet . ae pboaw of one ° eens ns As wer t a Ite as ifs baie ot ~~ ~~ poms, oy, es ey oot toe 'pon " ? = whee pas 7 ' wheat ee, ad Fe Pea "4 wos ais 1, wey Ls we tee * rab, , we wet axel " "et ~ Vs tS wae Irae, pore oe ad Seanad Sac' yn oa ie " pie oo oe 'ad oe Coeacd tt ie a os 4 mm wa 43 ee oS fe os ty tome Kom on fans as ey as ; m ee: AY at va a, $ nan yor Sos a . coo pee banad "ark 'ad A we Cay Saeed abet Z bok cae) py sre on, ye Lag ian ie: Fong res oanal a dead " ep, oe Lonel sgh cad cae pe Peasy Soo whe a Maharashtra State Roarl Transport Corporation & Ors. Vs. Rajendra Bhimrag Mandve and Ors, : 2/2000, Since, ene ES Memau Shed?
yt oer we os cs 5 eon) we rs wee.
'nee, we Paced e ae:
no ne wae vee, ook wee pte 'hen Yr vos are ose £ 'r bes pense yes o ve es ese:
nye oe ie temporary t said post. The respondents allows:
and choose manner. which is as as Apex Court in the case of Dinesh Kumar Kashyap & Ors. Vs. SE Railway & Ors. MANU SSCS:
& that the withdrawal of the order wherein he was selected to jain in aN Memu Shed was dene arbitrarily, which is not sustainable, he Aas placed decision of the Hon"ble Apes court in the se of UOT & Drs. Vs. Pradip Kumar Kedia & Ors, MANU /SCy compliance of the natural justice before withdrawal af the selects: been taken as one of the srounds. Accerdingly, La. Counsel for the applicant has prayed fur the rellef claimed in the GA, ft yeah ea heed ye. A , ; ~ ;
o na = & on 2 oe fee ge i pas s ne ne 4 ary % i Ie es > oad " Babi : . . an, om sv pans pa Sage a basi fee an eg ° tonne oa a wre "ad ~ os om ened one 2% cue ty 'wee os fa Pes ona, ace Kans G3 wees wes pees hee pate, ps ne 'et pesen, " Fad re, pees J ee " aed. Fant . ee ea ioe a on , hood 4 bee ais as hap ind ae shad ay Ayo, tad yee Fad feos pon ot ney oe SAP. * bassod " hesb ws pene, beeen wg beard xa Le Lng at ned wiped ELS 5 oy wet t Ys ve va ae a wos i oS ay os "5 Nad rarer, a ied aye (sec Lo 2: Sati fos a, Pasi ra ' od bes baead ead 'nad im e re 24 r we cael fee ea my pa "pes bet my Eee a 2% bey Se pon Po ape os, on Se = om os fed fa reg : bead ae Py, Bor pa aft oon ww ps oy tS Z rors chewed ot is oe oy s on a ms woot ed va lo Be oy, a seo fa ~n iesaed ten . ee pon el a = hen re ay hes as weer: oo, re aot anh, a ; 1 coped, baa "a ae ae od ft 'bit Poa ores a8 yee p rete % aePs + it yer im a ; s aa wan ped Hf "nah Fat 6 Faan Be, My a a re ; RA "ae had ag ke SL rey ad) "ot are ai, o~ he ht we eer. Aros Ds Fonead boas . Sos: ss, wee ee ~~ eanee sone Pad aS ma 2 hed 'a dead oa Soe, ree See "ft 7 Meee, aS oo ton 23 tra oy : way "inet % oroe i fing, Foy on oN a ae Foe lan At : foe pee oe, a yen 7m ; Le ny %3 : ' pon ie a he ia aed wer ue wn par aot tad feed a Hie bast x redee Su a Sone, era Faagl Pee vane ea on, 'dt ween: we oe % nae need nee neon af bow aot ake "vat rg nee het ' "net fete ek Sys 'eu os seen, ee chest ns * weer yrre 45. Selena eaeee i ree ree " me wy Noa sagen tae on a aad foot "epi Ld neon des aa wm % ea Root "ae "3 gs ' ity, me mney can mm aes ee anees Poa pen 'ant ead vn, ~ ms "5 ss a & od uae Pei hb an . neo aa The ined hed be faa pea Noet ; Cad "rt peas fey we tad Res of pede tr oft ', et pe . Tae as apeets § pan z fn Pe anaes aft rt ifs whed et a Pea on pas pent ore or Exess tpned % 7 ee Sex we ' oe ° ben ve an os va eed bet; ne oS wed far pores es one St Pye, vane' re ste - wn. ae nt F; wren, ' wok ee Ps tal ~g ae oe pane aa nbn, ee) ae aa Seen. aa Lperes, oes tee Fon] > gee eee Paar Jehgeed, or ° a vee Seal ran a y ft ee is Lf kf. an "ey ae cod peas ead wee " te we ns Coed a pa ay a ae si ba ee oie a "3 ge on pa oon ooh yen mt ter sae se yoy caer edeet pa tent a on few, oe, Renta, we x ceed oe Pony fee pene Samy " fond Pa We ee Yeree whe as Nah x eee. : ret laoaad foe om yee een, ae "= panne ae oe es ae & oe red seed: poe > res Li pa pas te par FS ae : eng fae 5 peed we pa o, wees "se ~ pen ieee 3 faey we m : ws f Pas ek m; Sand Pes, fm, a, 14, Se ory tot 4 "t Dead ~ " Tae fs cea sted ot ween bees who ros or ramet inal dened bee Fae pened Js Po GS pons rl "ne * sae het beet oe peooe we tee? Seetad yon, . he ~~ paren g on Bs Fae pe J wen, iad $3 ey ee wee pa See "3 ay shen iene, ret oS ved ion z eee be. % . Pa en Set dag: we wt gg ws at t "eel Yoder vee os ee ne won 7 by fee veg es ss as a ne aes a ae . aes tn pd ;
fe ue Lys el Pal pm ee "of yy ofS we yes om dud wee isd aoe hy, Me pant xa "3 sees wioe, iad poe oo vives news "ws ~ hee er baa pan book we panes id ae) oe tetece a a : ae teh . *. ie tee yen o on brore , La . ae Aeasid, cox ; e at a weed wheat ~ ons '4 ny its whe ae ons yore ee ie ra fort oS B Ye meee . ms im me 1 os on a Pas beck tm eed = ms ony ses Sa Z = be ee me re ; a ne oes . ' x or :
ee " eens oot ae now, jon yaeee hs ny en a + pans wee See fas) ee x Lp 'we os 2 vend a - ee pas wed = fe oS Cy sree howe, vered a ee aig oD Pog ua fain, ome ners: pas <0, wes a, 'ead es enpee, 'i ela ae . . Pied a ¢ £ ae] 2 % 'a pais we Pye a fs po hers, ay 2 Sad oe "eel 'act Le focba feet pered weer if 6 tft he Cae Vs Sad Let Pens wet pe wey pei wre oy By "2 fea a a bs oe a ae oe fra mt me me ? sy we Epeee oa ~~ x pan; " " aa, pa ~ * bead Ys ne AS ween wget net Cr eat pene, ° wedes nee. Pa few Ps ? wn fey bora re hot se x ron ye, a4 Saal ak roe ot race poles pel te oe Sens es Ps ag er the mm oe pavers rag gee Sort ¢ ' hs pean oS Bc . sted! baased ne Swe, az va "nett Serv ead og ten ie oe ~ W i Oud ss an ht " * bw . ey ¥ 43 one we ory . a wen tak a ~ Pat oye Pa oft free pa a sane , bad ay toed fy feet weet, went $ ee eee Sa neal hel rs Fagg th 7 bed taped, Fons acsd wm, = fe ead ot ONS sorte, Ys fie Sok Pood a ae peered, pn ie) pet rie 6% ised sheet * oad me w% pon ' whet oy £8 ware a re sed! ~ we jes we * od neo Ay ees Nib oe & SS Nat tt Ss fe Fes pa ; va "ai, on wise woe nhs ae Laon fet tent or :
pan Ls eed, jos, gs °. i Lonee' bead $ lomed + is oni lt en a4 on 'aagith et tty ES Sahat a ot tye wrt net fat Zz 'ad a we . jets, va 4.4 fn roeed tes van . 4 rk Nes Sak.
'od ee bows i hid " oe om, a orn met deed Bt syn 5 Z ' i sen a oo, th 4 ea pad Ay : oh ead toe. piped, Ce seo heck [a3 As Sat copes: oe pee bee fe, BS aa ra Vogt aa xa on 'oat te 'inh = yee tated mm we Ben hy 'eda nal" wee won Se ood 33 oo wer aA "ad Pant ' cagmast a ** my S caietain ' af ad wre, es oes bod nae ore " tat mana, ie eos . 3 ra im 5x04 ree. tore sent ie 'ned vod pon, te Fangs weet sb oe. + we aad pn ¥ a aeeee, oe " td ty ", we oe 7 wi hese a pene. : oe SAiay aw ah ne Sted . eee fink ae eek on deel as Peed . SS Fk tg cenes 'aint a Bre +e, "sy oe fed, ; fae ae > noe ord Ser, tf en ciated we wn:
Sad Gon " ap {3 ms ae i e ot tet er he * yet pan es ae yee wt ete ens Ltt Tia a Lf LS pret Poa tat yee, 3 £ bees wer wae ee com pen. z ik Peas ete wi 2 ean we few, ech wees pan oe oe Po om prorg we sae Pomed, ae on Past ote pen Posi oe ad pe a aad . pe ae, feet on Ae rnd boa ae Eel ' a ans weed cored 'acah tS Lg ve semen Lahey, 4, ve ea as, i adhe oy is a ton ood my ad pe 1G tna oom sot sco . = uA aS 'ob oe oe Taw baa oh Lh £5 oes aon wa eed z eae sheet yee bee P ge ee "at vg ites rae) ton weree SOE pe a4 en the bee gn z el ny ws aint ay io 3 oy Se ? thas me we oo % pad ma an a mA ye ye ges 'n "0 Shen ad ; é " ; ' re, se op whens bees eter, 3 ws th wn ben ee eed £3 ns genes Bete, H v eed dnd Look pt ie Bee fanad a pam) tS won, os ase it] By tf a3 ay teh fet ted os, ist @ as at Paved. ~ 'eek ie pars cod mee. Pon poe hone, ns eee. ws awry, mS aoe bee pea a y wees oi ee Ra sane ce ir ts loci at me cad oa es "
- 6 it 3 OSES &, Sod Saas ane os, it poses he yin wee eneen "et eel paaue . peas pon ous oe aes wa if: Taw ge = ee eine #35 pon ae Py sete ee fey oo BA ° pee: bose oes vs 5 oe oe aoe eo - or a ee fete att, rete, ¥ tS 5a: Lenaad iS fee, rey oe Se enn 4 £3 ent :
por at, tet: ors the 'Meet ras pan wet we os ny bi ce : ioe oct bronng ea on Ese' SS ad Sow eee, ne es: EK Faces Le ', aS £5 $ * ao sti tenn bos ee es tance re pebit Sah iy te af 3 pat es < ee pe oe af Nahe AA, ¥ ae, Rena' SABe pan woe on pee pos Aavied, : fae e077 ; "ea? Oe int po a tnaas re Ce pe Sones Thana, a "9 * Raced ee ¥ * at te oe ~ - es a 25 45 m, " a '. oo ey a oe pe # et ie see ae C2 nea is ate) oe x were Saas yu tee eae Seb .
hab ee Sh pans monn, bas Tew '4 eed % hd te oe wnere ' ad os, Fovi or] a3 ie a " 4 Bp Ee were 2 fod op yan weer - Set ,, ye, weg FS it "ye Eu soot: pee bed as vs oe oe bust Le Pas eee reel * Be ks uses aS eet oe oe a shel , CS ot pers wet Te ee pat) maa ei jo oS on pan "
vee ee. ne nee ate idee? i ass aoa oe S tae AAA Fone' a = oe "e. a fo: veene re tn, snow Ke bead ae "ey Shs 5 paaG £e "re, % £5 an noe heed oe 43 yee Star cos "et ed baer ws ee vie were loa eaprd. toy . oa os ee % ae tas oe ae gee GF z s vn voeee.
oe "oe we wbnk ex & TG bia Pied m4 yt det we pee "nah an a oe ae pe yn, coe . : Leap? o ae} oot Ss Ww "Aad sort we We '7 9) fens wh en See pee o on fete. pe cee Bone : CS sleet ; Bode in j ad rats poy tot aay ' ares;
wed i ' ae f aot 'endl aon ao "ae ; te ra os ee Wee ane, na Land' Shea, a ce a5 Se bowed 4 4 a i he git yeh . gee ee fo pon feed ieee LS 'ste, gas 'aod, he * fae, eed ve we cae Pieced hee 3 bees oe aed warns , 4 3 a nee Ye te van ae at aie Lh oe ' abe: Paes whe Pi 5 My ore ort rae, RoRd ef pore ¥ 4 oo Sot sn wee ea ie pom mrs oe " ray --
ie be me S a he ea ke eee base ae, pee Pee aes aes on SS. hoot pee, oa) .
ae Ce oS oe se oA fee 5 Bina hg oat "£5 os ot Goa Pan bares ee "S x chee chee ote, bom * pers rand a0 aod om al jak bang pe Pah re haw eae ; pon, po a3 an ™ oo tock oS bed ae a wen vee fon oe oe apee, me % oS ae pati, re poet £4 ae a 4 ped anne ve Carr oe Shed we tanned $ Ge Ths boa hee $3 pt Faned pa "
hy tet Pah paar Bey bet one wee 'na wn at 2h, aes Oo ce ny oak £3 rae = * Seen ge J Fi ey Pe Sav = 2 pes om 7 Sn! $i ae fee Wha eee:
Sede pa ey bet Nhe rip tf vee bs od & x wet Fa on pars : oe on mn "oe oe wee, 4 bef tt oh Reet Fuad pte, cord Stet ey raed feed 'a peancd he Leni tat ab re rsa me 'pow . pa va ppeers 2 aes. woe ened os * arses Ae nen Fisted ee er Vg oe he anes, hat webee, eee wan ie aes a 5 Looe wood, awe vo ; rey ; sere ap fey ees Sood rage wees aoe Bek deve z ", ae ye ae pee cewd pan ate: aor on es ae A beaaed oo acl apn: nee wy rane: hone brad ie t en ts ae ee oe at; See! ad ' oy e ane deve. 'net! we ey at pa poser heath foto 3 eee re, * saad a we sy Ue nod we ad eis Nek ee et on, road = teh, An dew ee ¢ rai ced Tok ee Fond ated. wen ae 'nae ee i Oh r tad Beat Paes eae od weedy ' pee. Bx '<i te ? ea gs ne 3" : ees ¢ ia re:
ane " book Seat Bs how. ay 'tage pene Feaat ce ¢ m pede 9 rm ey ay ak eed 'sat a "3 ~~ foaad poor waged: * ae ae "nat eeaacd a3 pe set Saal " 43 2 Soe M3 tS on, te weg: ned on 2 rd foe 7 4 5
-~, "seat pekes, pened ag Peed pans pee, Load ah Ls one Sat wa " fowl par Pate deed ps ; eet "3 wont ° last ad "en win, eo nat ove 25 on, Sad were, ead ae baad ed att rine ape ree '& Se ons pon i, Aare Ms, ", me a ana ra "es Ea oe Ye "sat os a Sou me a a mm he cal ee ea "het oS odes 'ae ce ox 1 ad Be) os 2 is jes be or to o 'od ; oy we g Foal ' A ay oe pa Boas fe a ra * poss bee "et om Nae ae or i Las 4 taal 4 wo, hoe vrs ne hed LA a os ay bed "A Pa psd "ae 'nets bul bx i) 4 ay We fas BS casa ay of. o, God a "3 pees ™~ Ae d Sanh ass 4 ne on re pened, ay pea vn peer ~ bes eet or ja i 'pt ot, oy Sx me ones y pe hesaaed f rt peas cae : whoa ot wees ea ns pone ws Shea as hone, bene sherk . too om ee % a wy vin whe a ta a) a "y Te cae pen . on aes . : 3 eri oe H Pa shot fh m Sb ted ~ pes se whee * rd = td hee "tows oo 'ad Raat ma od we SS ao i poe we sae pee a, owe Past oo: 2 & 5 BB BB 2» B BS 8 BB B&B | & se pane mes 3 oes New, ice) a, Sek 'inn mw a A z oo a rod ae oe a fat ld A ay a3 'at Foal . ues, ve " 4 eae ra 4 2. ¢ A uft on rea x very ist SS yes he sy wen ree on ye ih ge cam & 3 wanes bet % Z ing thes - aah: tn "3 ty ied nee dail ; Beow "Aaet we » io y grew a 4 « rae 3 sete z oe me eet ne ou wy a nen "on fo me mes 2% ms "ee oe, Hod fon rion went ae = . we boo oi is 2 Ba owt ad Ca es as e oo specie ree ao ioe rye oes ' ' ve : 4 he on 4a 2 ne a wa + tad ker Ee on sec ws fea 4 te Be poboe, eo bok wee, oad on ven fed ay pas a baa Bh ee on, " ert eee wy fea ren ote toed. el Pea aes ay oboe veeet en ww A es noted, vee anne esd wes s: cael . ae nee chon 43 £g ree Seed gl eee oot og pens dead 'fs val pent rae rr Kn ae ie 1 oe ae ? ae "wt een a rr, hen 43 ve "ait woe peo ot viet z "aA ye o yet kod aa ' ieanad cr sad pars he aah a nee ttt we a we ree RS mm fs oa oe a a, aod on mane £%5 wee on em Lape a, we aes Need: . fetes KY A : en ot oe, on, rs ay ; as GS 4 eee an bees eevee £5 pes, om ee, z ded ~ wb , Pree yoy t a fro, ad tered od eee. wee, pans ; geek. Poa' ee, al whit ce 4s . 7 vet 3 ~ eps ian ane ne ; . wv: "eS . dent And inet ihe, wan, 4 . a3 weer, a we we st , Sts pene 'ew eat ene dead pad. ened 2 po Ecad oat. ; > ee pees on es ea ms s + Noe pa 4d oped fl, " aeanes pee aa sal yo ben ¢ , : wer lent 3 chy on Fast poe se os when bead ees 'see erred pg pace ican het oe wet wnat on, al ad hood ia rae ThE wh + et eee beet oy Fas poten fax Mage ret * +. ngs Sat. Pa 4 'we a: "
a pees om, aes os Hose * wy ko we Le een oa not . pane pod oe par, ee net fever, ges we, me ' 7 inet teat sry we wpe 'nad aap aw, tn oe aoe, J speed ~ ae ee Soa A wt one on, sees ey Aon, 25 res Sates peer ay. Fa £r8 is saat vork ae Pee os ae fo poe, peers + Ee oe eo Mey 4 in See U oa is aed ? 4 walenet bea pee, iy: rod shook preg jet Sf "at = nad one i, Z pean Fad : ; . a ay ayer * ook . we ed an, Sead % 'set ai eee g tet * Ay red ana nomad, Me "ea har £ ene. poe, "at ren, pe a one, 'aot pa on an 5 lat been, ew ' on reo yew Se a One a bow oe aed woe nies oe Sy coe 3 Saunt ; - we pened, wn bensos wah ye eke aaa " ine wie og og es, 4 She er a, gro ae eS pornos a ty Pa oun iene eed Food po fee naa pt . Se rd we sae "se n. err ~~. ated a a4 gee ae) aaa fon - a 'aoe, of; peta ba if fone Soot : :
oe bee, Peed i Bh ' % bad 'ewe :, heed dees wd shar cad un ron "- ees Aoact tS teed pa tae pot when pants ae paced. "nh aS wv pan en as et ot Le "dee ' pan Ms re std 2 ees 4 Nat sane fr, fen é on aad ° siete 'ta ta y, , sen ~ we, * ae * pond ned 63a ae on, £3 wane Pur peas ee "4 ot Soest Kons % Ler ont 'eee 0 "ied ve Wk: wey ph tA he pan ; o ay we ¥ 4 . in be verte, ~ wheat caer me Looe . ted hit wane, wares. foe, peowe, Press ro ae ar : oy nee 4 nal Lasachy g zo Sead a i han . hoe est rea vd, a ew re s ao oe, paws 'ee? 3 aed oon ihe pos ai rr pe olivih ? a5 oS is nen 3 tae yee on wn aa) nell AY Ain, a) aad na? pas y ih 2a Fe a oy aS ace, Fons As Sa? poms nn, pond any wd aan Se a oped ?
on ive ees, 3 ge see + ree os wey OS pee pers loa' Let Ps wn ereee, ¥ pee hee Soon, prea ww feng te z sa dg' = wr) alan: re ae ened Sed 'tee h, th op. £ nen pee apes en, box nad wi z cies Se ye ° ven F3 dood rel i ne re bess low Dee 'he ae howd iy fee ee pao ad os z4 % "eet at ay ae ew , ' Sead aie Le feet ty , "Ae 4 z pee Gs , Paras eee set te coma on radia he shoe! ne et Os on, gen re hs ae) ee Bee my long 'aa Tare ioaaaad ~. eee, joe, er Sead ee Los on, ve Fae on oy aus ra) ake we eee na owe boon, ia me gee, ee re, he pte, ao ceewt Ww nd es any pe Pad Ban rows epee ae pa ion On, hed re Lo sa te S 4 4 poo fee pee oot deat "s face, eth betog sped Sova ro Wh pa o, peed yes peed Soon w at oe, freed shed ents wy we me 43 "elt peed ae rae) Me, per we Sone v Pad Pans Lara aa ae bac alee ne et cd eg we, r, ere. OS Rs wedes Ae oad bed reales 4 ead a pw be a aS waar feet wer penn oe, oe. poe ey Peres at poner Treen aoe at a3 Pos re es yh ot ads My cas pears . pen on "et wer ns ag 7 Sone, aoe sf Yet ron wet ed 'nigtt pean oon Sead Food tee nea ws, ae Reed rer wes aed Pek, ee eed ps Ten 24 aa eae ree. ay pa reer as a, at ape tf es dot pees "A pad nn hood ea 4 2 : Pe, ; ted oped Bs 8 es ia Be aid es em: Pass and posted iy the unit to which he had gone on temporary transfer. The matter falls exchasively within the domain of the autharigy concerned ta decide who she yuld be posted where and at right of (ye applicant Nas Oeen infringed or Nis interest has Peer adversely affected by the order Impugned in this OA. 7 have gone through the decisions relied on by the learned counsel for the applicant and find that those decisions have no application to the present facts VO Case, ree & areal circumstances of 6 The conceptual facts and clreumstances of the matter lead te the only conchasion that this OA is devoid of any merit and is iiable to be dismissed, which is accordingly dismissed. Ne costs.
MEMB oe ue ABS