Karnataka High Court
Rudru vs Gopal Shetty on 16 March, 2012
Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda
Bench: A.N.Venugopala Gowda
E {iii ?H€ HIGH CGQRT C}? KARNATAKA AT BA§\§G&i.§RE gags T%~éES THE 15*" ms: 0? MRCH, BEFGQE THE HGFXVBLE Em: 3:;sT:r::E $.91; vE§x:::§G§>;2:;.zé21:j:::§--2}%§z:;>;x "
M.§.A. %\§{}51683;'2C§: 3: .I.:2<é%§._\:;;"'--._ "I 4' BE"?WEE§\i: 'V RUDRU AGED £893? 415 'f'E}5:RS , W/GE RASHQ Pi3{33;§xR':" ' R/G. CHSWKGLA §'v'ETAK%-{I REIRZ VILLAGE KU§"<§D.«'~%PUR§X TALL%'r'<; AP?ELL§i\§T {gm 3 9: H . §:::&;é;;.%:s--;q "ii%%:«;:_:s:; ,:*a--::>2;, :; ANS: -------- . * ' E. Gem: ;ss~;E?7i*sfj-... _ _ SEQ 2iV§\:':;%;-%§\:;:.,;>P;: "
gags ;2..3€:2;§§' \a:,é;>.§.'L' :;<{:2D6E 3§£':i,$:i%LE' Hgugg ..«:5E§E;é.f1?UR.,é"?¥T3S"? 3;, vmagg
-.j._:<::,:;>§;-::: it};::.§a,%!s:>\,z:% ":;%;:;':,:§<; ' ":;§é":*§i_é:,*5?:'::::'a';;a ;§a2§;;RA%c§ fiil 2.33,, ix: . 9;; é<;;?§g'%%iC§%§3.?'i "%"G':I"'€E?;S A &;s:39g?::;%i§}~:::%3L:, ;:<a;§s::;:xpag%;s:a "'~.?\E§_;' §;3"-€«--;%jTE3 §:«~'?;%§\ii:H §'%*'§;i\§'~§;?aGE:'?;§ . R§S?f;3§$§E§'a§TS V' fiéy' ?Q{}?~§A€H§lg my, mg £22;
* -..s§.::3"{::E ":3 g: a:$9§§x;gE::> ::%;'E'?%~§} "F TEES §"'§?é32 ES FELEE} U/S 1?'3{1} GE: ?':'3'*£ ,$\CT :'3aGAE?\ES«"?.._T%'%E Ei3D€3EViEE'éT §§¥'\§EfZ'3 z'3C'€'§§\RE}* §flC?EE} 2C*.El,2§1§ PASSES ,}§f':§»._E¥'EX;'C ?:éG.333i,/2%;?,§ €35? "?§*"§E §3}ILE OF r'7"RESI§i§'3{§ §FF§CE'R;"-.§f",§§T TRACK C{';i.}RT, uaagpzg SEE%<I§'~é{3 EN%'i;é:5iCE'§'i"E'E<§':§f{7.____:
CS5? PE?%iS駧QFé, "§"E~%;'S ;'ix§>?E,£\L <:Qs«:,*§;x:a SN ?®2....,£:._a_§»%§s;§éé:2:%»2'=7fi;»«::S :2;-fs,'»:;,,_ YHE COLER? QELEVEREQ "°'{"£'§E FC¥LL§i"v'?§?£G: 4' -I EUQGMENT ' Bigsatigfieé w§t%§_ the V_a::%;%'a,r s7'V._»_v@as.§e§__by5 MACE; ifaimant has fiéeé this §'p.§§éaE ':~:Lr;-3€:f.»§'<;nu§'--é:1A:§é'a.a'§ement;
2. Res;3'a£}'§i--enfi:s €h.<3V'€;~ if':-.+:.:.:____ fquestioneé the imgugned e§wa;§%:§';
__ §~§éVa'::§-«..§h«? §eg{%';s.§<§ ieunsei an both séées afid §§F'LES€§ '€:2§rV:<§<:§:';§.
Srséy §'3'cv%..%is?:«'fs%" C@€'%S§G€§'8'Eié3f'1 Es; %§%1h§§§'i€§' ihgze E3.-§§--V:.:$%:..,j5é'i:s§'~:éa--§s%:abEe awarfi by téza ?4ACT?
-,§:5}§;':€§§a:y:2: E333 éemaeé ass ?¥*~.f~§, EXEEE? M ' ".. '2':"':§§%:f:§4§V=3§a§ €§r%.:i€%<:ai:e gémws Sasiairzéng 3? fsfiswéng " _ é':f§j§':;=--:"%.£:§*S:
X /ix 2* 2:
3
" Lefi irzi;:: is 3'%é'éi3§§€¥'E X iemfiernegs af ieft i:':g2;3§:*:a% rggien 2:a§:§2 §§§%"%§%..§§ mgmemanis. Eiway siwws s'.:9:2":;3*2:.;§:=z.§_£e_é §§aC*::.::*e ef irzferim éiibii :*am§.""
é. Qatar hag §e%:*; éxaaééééiefi'as??§%*=~3:§Q._§f%§'§2;s7 {3§§¥"§$§ ma? there is §é:mar':e:2ta '.;:i§é§§%£ity _~:$§ffaE~réé ':§§?V'-- §a:'i:i€:a2§ar iimb at 14%, T§;--§:§§€2,a§ ¥;2a'i;_Vi;§£é%E2:2VAV"1.%:§af'i:S {ha V germaaeai disabiiity sz.,:"§'%'f$:'e=2d;=§:*:' 2% ?.%§%é'::iév may at 13353.
1 we.m:;«;g%%%:;;s:9;:%;g%g: %35;aaa,«'- 9.3. has <:§mm%f:Le§'::-é;%:§§rV"?§§'éifié 3? assessmeizi sf 155$. ;3s§,r3e§§a;s% a§:;§z2:_~%S.3:&a:§ 59$ 3 {Zf3:"§§§€, cam fie expasteé'2:§9:35:39':'w?§:;jS'§?{3f'>«-..':§;:§§§ 33 €3%"¥ 18.:32.2§1§; $2": %:§é1e«.'ft§.:+:i:z:3;*2*:si;ar:£&s, {:28 33% ans i'€aS$¥'}8i'3§€ '<::%*:é§g:s3§:i§§<a: é9s§°e§£3'; the §'§3S;3§§'°§§E§"§§S haaza is gay 5% 33% a:;;é::';§:::';s%%%:g§'T1§¢::gzs;s:
sérmggrzi §-isaés L 13:: Ezsggeg} . gzzzj gzéfféréiég 25fi§§,i~ ' " ?~%§§%::§§ fixggaaeg 35 gg: 53% %E;-« K"""
gg§;é><° " ii: tgéé' §:x;.;'z£";*~~, .. »$.1;» Ensiderztaé €>(fi€I'"1S€E¥S: C§n2g€yar:s:e; attenéan: & %'?€}UF"§S§'T8é ééei: 1G_,,£}fii'3.,g'4~..' Loss Qf {stare eamérsgs:
345:; X :2 >1 :2; é ' L333 of §f1C€)f'f"}€ éurmg iaié eff peréaéz 45%} X 3 ._ ~:' H' L955 9? ame;':§':ie$ sf fife ' Totai in the resuit, t%%?§;."'-3§3£3.§ééz'%§.'V§S:':.§%.'§,§22'3.e'€% érémfiiafrtg The impugnefi 3::dgrT§e§2':/ is had entities! to with interest at 6% 3.5' f%e§.1jj¢V geiitian iéié 'E523 data sf V EP\VVe §$Vv"4::>':--'1<:§Vemé"Ii' Camgaay is graateii i:\:v$ mezzighg' ?"§ {ie3§a:éé't §§§3E'"éC€ Campensaiicm ammmt 'V '§%i§fé'*:f;_frz:£<éa"a.;af§ is €:.::$§:s; .j_gé£*'