Karnataka High Court
Hyderabad Karnataka Education Society vs The State Of Karnataka Ors on 25 February, 2012
Author: As Pachhapure
Bench: As Pachhapure
\\ -s flO 1X1 C" 'i)!h(.
'
SUiS 'OIS 5(lj,t) jo) "t)I) I
O1O ii ç()
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT GULBARGA
DATED THIS THE 25TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2012
PRESENT:
THE HON'I3LE MR. JUSTICE H.G, RAMESH
AND
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE AS PACHHAPURE
WRIT APPEAL No50O78 TO 50185 OF 2012jGMKSRj
C/w,
WRIT APPEAL Nos,50186, 50187, 50188, 50189 TO
50193 50194 TO 50218, 50219 TO 5Q23 50234 TO
50241 AND 50242 TO 50256 OF 20121GM4(SRJ
BETWEEN
r1ta(j tji1j iri
F 1i i I
Ji iL
IF Il'
I i ient PPELLNT
[C OMMON IN ALL THE APPEPJS'
AD
tc j
I
% \5)O J%i I'Cs i)1SO
'013' 01% ( J ) 19 1 -
' 't'4 -i.
It Ikput I tj r. " j'&it n (tic
and Reuj%tr11 ot Sock ii'----.
(ii ilbarga LhsL Ii L
Gull' iia.
\taPt Ih
S,c S kt Rc Id
FJ.auikuz
i
1
'i,'o
lid tl i0 it
\nnuponrna.
W/o fllnrdr Rc ku
Rio Rastaptu
Slialiaptu faluk.
"idigir Din
.nilbarg i
tall i' 'i d
Sin Ma bade' aç v Gnwda.
Rio. r.aigacligi IN alilnip'ir P'.t
Shatapirlal I'
Vadagin Disi n I
Gultiaiai
Manaurnta
Win .\flet- : Rei'fv Mi'l."ii.
oKI
'glant 'illia
Giilbarta U':--' -'
1
I (
S t 1' •l
i,•. g 1
Iah
jI.fl
g
•',, j-r ri
• a
z t'',it ').'....
i
A
Ii 1
c
• • .1
I,
'c
if)) % "
'i
I I C. ' (I t
'(Pin• 'qij.S 'I'S'' 1'
:'; iil"'-Z '%j • n I"
V/c' Mallai,a Gcnn.i.
R'o T€tnt"IsJ
Ibialnnipui Pc
hd 1)11 1 a. t
icl.iuj;1 Di'''
TI tlb.Irt.i
1
t i'll
Win. Basaunal.
R 1) E1.atIIklItd.
V adaQr' I 1uK ii 1 Di'u
(ulbaiga
Slianiainn..t
o.
R o Rastir "
Shah Iur 'iii
Yadcu1rj fljcijjj.
"rulbarga
£ imbcmn i
IA'u 1C)1'. t Nj tl'11 Ucidu:' 'II'
RIo. A' 1k' n 1W
6
d uil d'id
lb qa
%t, 3
p i •
I I
S't
!
4 l..p.IJ
ich.t 1' I' I, -- i'd
a'b ii*
'S. ' tJ.
C •
, ..c'
I I
ii --)
• i•'.
t
I ,I
(hi l ,
C
1, l •m 3;t:,%
a)1 ii
L 1
a. m. i di ,'i-- •:.(,. !4.fj i. :
•• •'L • ' L'"'?t! 1'
11
' :1( L1t3r11u;
'I•1 i
' •.'L .1 LI 1((' i,j)tc IPJ 0/N
V,.IU") I tjjP%fjP1jj'j •_)
ft )1II lVIJc
Jlim 1P'fl
l%T(j I"I' IIW)j TTIPBPU&
P (DON lIOT)UC
,nv £pp'v 1' flIt IPH C/cl
U(tqW1J% t
: r
flwqpn)
I(f 'VUW)I iIi2ti.i'_
,piw induipnp
9'raThsprA 0/N
kppaurjJTT1J 0/
IP N iWIfl1P$Pr .1U • (
1
rurj
i L)
• • 1 1
i" t.t')l 110' pr_
I TP"IUPflP')H °/N
4
•ihlu(t
t h'.%l'li n.s
'Ipu) U'113't'J r
t
I'--:( I I'1t t L%fl f_ I
.wIrnu c
'-IC! I COKaSIZOIT
cI)I;.'N "ITOh 0/ ci
31PU11%c)IUH '
1 P. Lt\O'? It ttcOs L 61CC'
'4iZl-It; thi (SI(I'gSl1isIfl
9'IQ'- c) rl/'sI SJk) 'V\
t
-'I.
k'%M$) jq j(.; O1%
c(i1% cuiss '' '1"4 'I'
')'IV ''
'0'' ''i (4' "I'
RkI'aranI.
o 4Tflfl II 1
Rn. I'ta%tnj)iir
Shahapux 'at ik
\adagiri 0'
( ,I!.'n.'.
-- .J.tgarlni
'u Ti a I jIij 1
No.8 1302 0.
in ar (JLIIII Bha Situ.!.
( albirg I dO
c;u1ban.
2' Shrnka
So. Ru1unana Kau4Ih.
I{atrilli(n
Tlolkiuidi P"•
Gutb4rLç* 'I ilLik Ui(J I )r.t' 'ci.
(rilharta
31 0 S.Rihin is ii
S, t 'sftiik MoaifltiPW 4 Si it.
H No.1 lb., Si,r--u.a t'
riI1u si. 1.1
Gulbartta.
3. %iuvapiisq p
S.' • Slu' '.:i• ..n; j.ti a' .
'O .4 ) '
I'n.. rZt,_;s
(1 1' i.., '1 4
eZ' I) r
._.'J. •ii•c,'•,
t
'M ,
• to •r.
)C I
. .4!
I 1%
• .5
I
1
6
\. (I'S I'fl I' (
"CuSS. %I)j%LI 4
c(uLa
.1s.
XN) s ¶o' 4 t (P4 - I
Aged 20', 'aT"
RIo Ratap U,
Shahapuna rLlIUk
I idagin I)u' tnc
triil)i 112.1
.'. A'4iuk RedcI
S u 1 siddr RniJ Ku k'an"
n
I 'B'ica
tktsai ecjiwaniaijai
SlialLiptu
Y-tcl€wIrI DI%uu'.
Gulb'uua
Sh.uaun Reddv
Sn 13 fltainanrn i
zlged 32 veai'.
R/c KodI ,adarn'L bk
(ulbarga Dhtnct.
Cu1baxga
: ShaJ4arappa
a M€Iltsl
'
ti
.4.geci JO 'eai s.
Wa Im&uIq.
ll)rahtlnj" .r Pn--.a
Shahai tir
\ dagi I stitt
(; ill uga
',% w'
1
c Kr
' 'tt ')
.4.
' ('g.S'iai' Ut -- -- ii'
'S Ic I t i
(ruin )t-I.
:%SliZ1.AJ3C ._K ; '
. Pts '
p a
jjj t ) ',r
i If.; ! .
'
. •
I''
p 1 '! • .. '
• .,
1
I •i( ...
j
) ij 1 T c ; 4
'..' t• .'Y( .1..rJ
.1--i'
1 H
t I IL
'3 ;'d(j iLiZt() •
II 1[lt%
• 't'!'tJj '
• I' " ,t is 1'tj
I •' \ •t'.•r) •%
'1')' ?'I 'eijujc --t
,,ipq1I)g)
• i 'wit' r vstqpj
TA 4'vTpJç ° N
4111" 4%O 4
•9J4\
n7tn'qp •n
'I lIiL[t!J t'in'qns
1OPiPTP 01)3
t
'n
' Vt) P"lV
tpe Ithuwq Oft,
VIflflTIPTs
I'nIvqjLuz) iTItiqfl
UL 0 ) ITUtSI Ij
.i!T1 ) •1TTTTI.'J )4P'a.liLi) II) (trio L'X TOld
sieaA 9: pan'
• c viinnj•a\ S ,
fl.tufl)I uIuv' Pt
4
Jflt)
t'tn ,
i' ajfli.•qjn
;" °J iit1 I %Lt 6110J0 ') PIbl
LU '3° 0°' WIT LVONH
tjtS.)L1)1' I 0/'.,
UV4N P' 'V
ti 9Z ctI).,N' Irt hUs ut-oltUs
si. 'nit)
t nI 6%1(K Rlfl' '_siot
9S1u'. ")I ',SI ' ih)'" '¼
I
• sit
.1• . t• '!1'it 't
' L'
,,JT J% /
• ' i' f ti
• L
''
it Lb
j.
i
t L ct •,' %%
I'.
%Ira:. gj
LI j: 1
Tf
L .C lPC
L
j•rst) 1'>.%)J
0t)
P.11. 11
% ';'qrT t;Ccjir
¶1sT-f "l
,j
I )fC ITS I%
Pt IV.I%rq •
1 'j ic • ijiiinr
'°d TuiT;ttLH
1jTIW'Ut.9 ) '0 'N
S PaA gf- I
" "Pd I'Pflh)Pitmij% 0/
vtiupipu saq 'j
v$n' line
I'aI kJ'V'S' iiqIt3tI;tc
I)IJf A ) N
'aTh) c
t'I)ltu?L Isi'iy '0! %
• .iIaUit.'• LI it
'ztwqp ri
a''-' ;(lIaItII.'.c
'r i j mdi' P4,
it tEll %Pfl
"ft Ct( n#
• ": • •'4'I'4's i Lj.IIL!l )
S
I pflfl$j 31'%.
t t)s'N 'rt::"r UZus
.:tnIuc tf'l (isl'
1
4 cios _sioc
'99tç'u )Zl'%4t s isI'.'Y %
R
9.
*
W
0 0
4s 15 isiil'(k ,0h6
5)1W'. 'OISS 91 R9-19\ qjuj..2Is.
'(,2fl23 % (' 1_4J to'fl"
S ugamma
t o wassrnuo'idi.
ged 32 . n1
t 'a
Hit' t
Ra'$€pU
Sinhap" raluk.
aI,st
)
T prt iii.
C,ntbarga.
'6 atthn
')/o n1 lrdnfla %J1'3
Assd2l!ear'.
R' RataPW.
slnhapui liluk,
'iradagin Dlstflrt.
(-uRn'S
W Sinulu
W/n imgha u . R.-'kh .Jdhit •1'
Agea 24 ycot.
14/ liecligI nadn
'iadgin tahik&Dt'UW
'hath irgi
•8 Ba',aV'aral
ChanCIUdi3
*" 2.1 3fl
R'c R'srqru
S)iiamW La ul
\idaglii ITs r c
.9. stcrar1(t"
0 rkxlcIlpp
1
S ('C %12
;4'9'y •'.
R/3 ?tll r
1
•
d ii
r il hi )
(ti i
44 Re k' 1
%/. n
3
\ 'c 1 r1
'4 L.,s 'I
;. t i
• .3 •'u' I'
' '
t a,. V...
"
.. c_I C.'.
1 • I
s .
'C
I0
tsr' I2('
%'(K,S "(1I4•
0IT iOIhS OiS9 ) )I '
)4' '
4fJ)II %I.'t; \ 'I_I; ( I
Snclevl,
V n MøI dl) Red i n wi u.
4gecl2 310_rb.
R/o Ifulnoc'
ilior 11)111 lai"k
Yndt alt' I t Ii I
(;idbar
i
1
II.'•t' :'•_
Sb. Satab Goth
Aged 35 e:u
R,o. Hadno i. Sb. apt U ik.
Yaclagh I t)isu ct,
(u1ha t ga
5 "ft(Lllflfll).
IV, o. Basavai al atigi
Aizcd 30i .us
RIo. Hacinorn Shurap a-
idauli 1 DPi n I.
flulbaran
6i Rctyapj.ctgu. nt..
SI . Sthda.ni Ii
Aged abo' t , l n--us
DarJ a tipur .1 L. i •t 4.., i
Shah tjir
YLdO1J )i tit'l
(fi)
ir vt U
of. R I
u,....: '--
ia.
' •(tIJ 1. j
U '
4. '. .r. ' t
j' s."A" ia .1 a '
I
: e c ii
t•j S
• ,4 _
I
.11 •
I
I •_ •1
II
(K) S 1% P( w '4) 4
i111S. ')I" u
1
4qs Itis i4)jL11 'I
()JiJ 9 '1 . I -'
09 Yenkanun i
In. Saiwbrcd'iv Math ri.
¼cd 51 'icic'
Kb KodLi
'Md *fl r Itik
C dl 41P¼ l)i '
(tuft,: ra
70. Pvvath Peddi.
s;o. ;urangcusta.
'gee 30 years.
R; T-Ttduoui
Shot aput 'c luP
I idagu i Djqtrg 1.
(r,tjbarncl
71 Siutbhadianima.
D o Shunt icdch.
.cd 34 V'i1.
R'o Radii Sedani lain'
C, dbarga DisI ii t
Guib.irga.
7) Rudiagoiid.
',/O "nnlf I- r ji 11
Aged 54veai-..
R'•' H'tdi our.
S otipn .ihk
\'A(ILITI )t'1'"
it'
& I
', u-:
U ti'iwi, L
1
.t ''.
i3 L P'
F Tic
1 'ipur i .1 k
r'r.
'I I £
•.I t1%%
f
'%T a at.. )t 1
".Io ti .qi. I ,. . !.
)
• P'"
.
1 . •'
'1
P
1:
4% b jS'I'C'' 501S6
nIS OI'' IS. i'I'4 21s.
0119 '', (P ' t Pt ' ci
Oki JcwaI4l Ro ci
('1 tit)arQa
C iandrasiici v
s.:n Sld'fdngdnvl tAh
kocai3ly 'r
ft/a. ETgiznoi.
Slim aput faluic.
Y.1tir I) ,i e1
Gidbn .
7. Sli.ii.tlwniina
W/o Rucinseoud R blai' Hi
%ged 14 1Cfli%
o. iladnuor
1
R
Shcripur raid
Vadgiri f)]%tri' t.
uib arc a.
"hannAnun i
14/c.PanHiiRcd'1 •a aw
Aged 2Myetin..
R Ha.cinoo
Siioiapur laduk
YadgiriD ci 'a.
C_mu aie.a.
' %in ( I
, Si .u.!cia •I• ljs'': ' :...1_
9%
rk LIii,IiC
1$ '"_
Shonir alii
\ain 1'
'' '.'•
' i:.
T
I ç
.t
.1
3% 1) Lii 4 a
S l%fl 1 aKr 1
i :t
I
•
£ •
13
sars ;sc rr uI%h.
'013'. ,OIt, '(1 ) 1' OI 4 '1%.
O2l' :r2 :. & %I)'_'
'"
) %mbraiin.
t• ('iiann tba'--ap
gtd Si Vt 11
Rio (rldclt%uior To i
I lalazrrd Posi.
S't hap ii i J k
Yad 1Q11 1 L)istnc (.
zitllntiitn.
si Sniticr,liekcii
S •t, t'lStI1(1tL%l1t bar
Aizc.d26 'u
R/o Masakanalh
Rarna%amucll a P04
Yidagui'l uk •ndt '' (1
Cu1hau,t.
4 r1aJ
Sb. g 1
Sidd nu4 nn a Kant. tilt
Iged 32 veal'
Rio ikil tin Cr
Y.uic'€tii -- I aluk ctjjla Di ri.
'ti %ui-e'4i.
' i"'
'
1
tks ii
8'
l,G. Isau'€';
(lILI1 I.'ti
.1' U
'" %icId a 314 Rek'
T
._t'
_
4 ' 'ii
I --I
I 'a • )
Ii
•i
'.,l.(. LL* c". q
1
•ji . •
t
I •
• ' •
L
I. IJI
it
..I . ,
S
it' ..
'4 ' isLCj' ir
'I . iT'. .
' ''
IL' '
(1 '1.. .J '
L '
I "> .J. -'
' --: \ Ii .iT •.• T, /%j
I' ( 1k( ia"
1
'I'i e
't'tt 's
''c
11 j
V"
1
•'t' 1 '(1 1.
jat t'J (UtP)a%
• II 4 c/p
PI"N ':1 ifl',
.• It i' %( j I'
i p')Iy
Wih1 'II) II sflj
i'd ii'(( Li)
%f( '9'P 'I" LITflPP
"d flhT'PU1U
TftPTflYUTPTj,) 'o/u
p .T'j 'lj4 epnotmt--rg o/jj
,]p)lt• ifl0P'lt3
'JiTiTj%' (
v*zrcjpi;
1 'C. 'S PIttI LITWP1?A
I'S( 'd TIIL'( rug
III' JTU1Jt
) 0 H
LI I(T)tii!ITS
'olq
"i' ru moqu paiy
''j)IIL"t(II %%I
ntnncpnz)
t 'I i I •Iifls
"'d liP tiCf4
ijt'tiUn:q 0 'H
't I)T11*T1LIRPPIS C) c
""Qt iflOqtpaøv
:i '' r3'C '. i: '%.'; t. in
'SI - tnIU •
(ii •IO% 'C',IO' IO'
"Si's' '.)clsSI %'$J%' 5
I-I
- 15
' sXJTh s5•I 'C ; 'OISb
i01s. ('Is%. itjw I'$. i)j')4 21%.
O"9 2" Ofl4 2 I & O_l' 2 6 1..
RIo Kodla.
Sedarn r•tluk
(zulflarça Dr--I
C ulbatp.
''6 Fr ut a
Aitd abow 2b e.iI
S'c I)uanl, RKiLU
R;c K'dl
Scdam laluk.
Gulbatrga I)Ii
Gull rnrga
9 Suntangala.
.ged about 38 'veu',
IWo. Ba'.avaral Mactarn.
Rio Kodla
Sect am 'think.
(Tulbarga Dist
(Thlbargd.
fltu trtJil)pa
Agt-d abo'i 2 ..M'.
S'o 'nhebf'c lit) 4l" ii
R o Kodla
Sedan ru&.
Gulbarizifli'
, ilba .,
:' i'i aL.1 ku
LC" 'L,Qt z1 'a
S,o S M.tlkinna
q C 'i i alia
\ ditjri .1 'v' •' . (Jr 'Iji .
It •. 1
.1 ' C)
Sit. "cIt.t '4..
' '
.x:i:.'-: . ' .
'i.h i'
tI'w
4 1
• .1"
I I
' •
IT
Hi It !tTI%.
I 31 'J
)bq.ST I
'/
•i ,t rn c
' ""1"j
T' Q7, II.'1
1 lfljj.4"rlj'., "
iflixp ji t'
'sI(] TTI$Vj Sb
4Iji ii 'P141 141.
j%(l.J itili 1111131(1
174
' 'T1°d eptI';7CT1P(PJ4ç
0
/ Q
' a -iovpos,
p'iupafv .o.
'iueqjn
"1(1 flU1'qfl
'F'Wi urpa
flIPO3T °/H
j1U.IWT 1i'irwcvg 'o/
'%niaa( f i; rnoq I"%
uvqojs tnpm'q,) 'oi
flaeqn)
• IU rurqjn
'I"I"L
131P03J 'a/H
?( 1 UJI L(i
(1 %
%j)' )1 jil iqit pa?v
ri
PPH "wa'qq
t1n'qjn)
• )S1U vurqn
l.IeI tUijIas
i'pn'q •'
j'il )I 1%. rctck It Il'I.%L'fl 0 C,
J )' ctJi 'V itt t..O' (1c.Cl'.
"i VDIO% WI I)$IUS XSith ..SlUs
)sIIlS Vjj ssl S,Oflt,j
9
'-%C' i• 11
''I..
-.
' I S
I .
iliji )
I--IQ ..
II )%3j(
J'
• ' • . '.tt)
1 )T iJ,(' •i.
':'
' 4.%j
'Li'!" i(J s
tL IJL 1 j' .1
)I.l • T
1
.1
' 4 i' %
ti 196HWÔN VA ia
• [.4 . :n. ' 'ja j;c
IcN s
4sI•
1' .JtJs.1IPTJ A$jTJ
'1 'aQwoJsaN
1--10 jI'fl ukI) t#.1C(flfl)
DLQ. ?JUI)J 11fl131 I. sauL' LL
'lb 04
C )'(d 'u/>j
aL'fjPCP(I) ( LIdI ii.'q uqc, o,'ç
%1t4\ ,$ lfl()CjL' iiA1'
•ITflhTL1II •II
'ji (IPla
, 11MO iifl1upr
'I OJ lilt j)LEPf3
qp'lnw?q,) '0 Ia
'I)flo3mTPPPlS 01%
'%.ak JA (4. iiiotpi patrj
.cppa AaI)L 'in& o
Pair qn
.k"'L ,tP3t1.L £
'(qi kia"y v o
'utkifluii& 'u;s
* 'j noqt paDy
"dLh'iuqeppL I!
)S(?q It') IflWPpPj
1
'fI'lQ
\ P309
4 It,.. ItCtjs tt bid"
sI& t-owc "ôj ÔSIO, 'NblO ',SlO'
9SI'J, "•)...I,sSl s_(k;c'..
4'-'
Is
'* \s 5(Xfl'C IWi/12 U '.. if 1sn
t'Is X'IS'. O''') I 'bfl(t)_L 'is..
--
I
-- --
( WA !o±.5P18Vfl
I Ihe Slain of Kantatak.' On
LT11UUQI1 1L I'Ccui',uu.
(, ('JW! '11t' St. 'tt'--
[3 jpu
l iflEtlk)1( Ut's
fbi Dt--j 'ii (t!l ' l C .h.J.c "I bit
and Dl'ti ci Reçtsli ii I 'n wilts
flulbaiga,
(nilfrirac.
Di. Siddanagouth.
S 'o MaUI? 1111111 c tilt
')rg• Prof d --'iirIstll cu
'C v (z lb€ i
k lix tn. .. RESPONDENTS
T3' Sn Manaentha H' 'Irk fl' ' ' 1<
'n. P ilas Kumni VI Ii .1 ..
IN W.A. O1J2:
11.l' ' iii.
S ' Sharni ip' l1
r Ri-ti Jolt I clnn mi
i its 31 C) if' (
.I of (€ itt ualca
' 's '4 1 1 a 1 a %Zt4 P.
-- r '. c
t' .i.r RESPONLkU
'fla,
S 1
h
31L"
. a'
NWA Nys 10169 193J12
11 .1
It'c i.),i js.. 'r
C q
f.
Ti .sc
I ..,i -
•1J' .1 . I
'9
k\%INr% I% i2('v 'l'I'h.
'OiS 'O1's' .4 ['0' ' ('I). - IS
0.l" 23 ;' i '4 s 'l' t'
On . Agriculturt awl So' kit Voikvi
R o. Raddc ach
iij •fflLLiLti,
Dist. Crulbatta
Shainbn Rtdth.
S!o. Bk açanna Macin
fltC Sfli tnt ". tkrt r' .41i. !
"
1 At
Rio. Kocik
flj Sedam
Dlv. En lb uga
Gulb.trga
SahehreiId
Sb. Slu is . ana' pa.
Ocr .\grl
a tfl.
1 & Di't 1tdgft
ft
I idgir
Ratnakar
5:c' 13a'--app.' Ki'ptii'h
.diccate itlan
R/o. T('\o4 (301 tic
4' Cr ss. M 13.Nag r.
C' ilbarga
C uhrti.
I I Ifl. I1c I•I
s %jtgJepc t!
(C' hut let
'
4 S i a;'
V
R.SPONDfl 1
I. n 1.r h •
i
1 Tr t
b ii'l i'l I •
TN WA. Nos 50194-218'12
I 1
t 1._•
. )
S
(j1
• ii
"."
w--,- ',
) i IL
I.)'). 3" I 'IL 'jiTlb1%
•
'•
I •, () (
.1 v uwdm ii.
1': •:It;(tJT%
• •
-nA
TI 1 L1 gCT(J i
11117h))T 0;)]
.. 1fl' flJTIIt 'N
lfllttfl)I iIt"CiTiElt
ipat I1flLiL9Ij)'j( "S
om dcii rutqc,
•TI$pT•j vlu sj bj
..) 'H
? flflflTTtJ 3O
.ni '°N itieduinn.
I))) 1flhiL'pfl'JAJ U/I
'I
seApt
• (SIC ? iti.
IIlflO) 0)]
)tups,T1% C)
'9""'! LTwdTiwN
1pp)]t PIPES o'ç
W1''u 01
i;•tt
'
1
j u'
tSn'ct )
I TtRqt'•h
--)EflIX% I Ut) êa)] ppiccj puTt
fill )Jt) •' ) I') ttut'gttaj .isiiclati
1
d Q . d'Z02. 'V it
. t'uh n.. 6iOS
i: rtiit)c 'H"! ti'Ilj SIl)% ,inc
9 Il' '3 Li S (X\
a
4
I g •t 1 1
iii. .ç.
I'
.: ; .! \J(qj
• I
j 4 ''V • •I' iS
1'
.1 -1'i
L."j.P_s Is'i
jt ' 1
"T-- h
Ii, .
T
•) ) 'uvt. . '
L"kI)'I,3 (iau-% '1%;
iSTj'3
i'?j
T 3p'
•L1I3\ :t '1 )U'%L'fl
J "' ',' 11' 11(C, OJ
rnupt PZEV-fl(
epno6uv'çj 0/5
_nJIJ) 1(lP.JtLS .1(1
.sp1p1s ITIIw
n4w luaqba t %Lcy
--a'pç 1P.U(%)l'%INjInUflhTs 0/H
%S1TJSflfl 19 tfl)jfl P) 3k)
itWd l)1)a aijjr UUcI o/g
IPfloWlm'rnq LI
lfiflWA
1)t'OH PUtU.wP1 1
'pjjç T)ILIPK . 'U
)Ji!Iti3Ut Z' S%3TIL%Llfl 1)()
loin'
av'jauqrpjaj u'iioimiu'ç Ut
L.iJ)e'ç 1;?j'tj Ib.Q 'I? bJ
flJIlO3I O,7j
'JLfl3%flUfJ .)J()
.mjno rrnd.iw
)H tIIk[1Te3jjjj1?j 1
'
S
'6PP.WllTlflWWII (4
j tc ctt(K V Ih tOs ttc (Tub.
IZ tGIU' toL p;IiJ, 1*cIii' ..SIUS
QIOS " ).,T 'si
In
'W Ih!I(' SOISo.
50fl7 iot,s. iflU jt qlI')4 'IS
fl2I) '23 3fl'U t 4. '02t2 '6 P
Mankai I .fl(Plt
13c hurt Ru 1 Mar (II
C,ulbalQa
(xull U
li% '%3.f)fl i
Mb 4 Ru
o uc
dia
lis Fri
0. : 11ou'wth
F !.Il\e ii 31 Sr1
Saruan1%1n Ii \eiLelI.
(zL1ILIIMt
idb tr i
2
(
Rudragoucla.
',/c. Stninkrapj flk)ti(Ia 1iii1
0'c Adccat
II. No.10 ii. Siidei t3.ultII'if.,
SinkaInL diii dl N ig ii
QuIb€ug€i Gulbarga
S. (urannadoud i
Sb. MaIIat sjon Ia [Mr uLu
0cc: 'each r
Rio. II No ._.4 ' 'L 'zø'i't' •
,l1l) irga Gtilbai .44.
I )• idcI.u1k gou 1
S a S' heb o c
0c L,1( I i I'
K 4i'
i,u- fli'n s .
iq. J'"ls•
D' ;i.
\% .3 t
Fj'_ ..r.1''*.. I
ii 14, p e v
f
1c.
R' 16
1' SI t1cQ.'.
I
t I.. '
I,, .. V
1
I
4 O1h $ 1$
•1 •$
S
I •;. I I •i
• . i:.. •' 4lI
:
I j) c
fle 1
j,(_
_ i (i
CF.' ( I
•Lfl a
J(f 'IN
.'L '1'''fl •.. l)i',
1'N l''T"1It
Inn T
TI'I)1
1
.PNI
s PiLI
, Ii
flOUL)1l1 1•'Urj ":
'Zig"' ,LGTi,
in! .iui ;p;c o,c
• wpa'g x'u.n'tj%Pqq'.. •
spvj SWj)fl\ IcTQ
.1 di ioqç, ki
Ji)OTIpnjJ /N
'T)IOIP%flOH 'P0
"
! 'I t
Lfl' "P'tU"fl • '0
Ifl)QUflj t(
iGipt j
'rnp"i •1'IQ
ejcJjoq
bi
1i. IIj,1
H "•'H
•Il flfl 1 rn.
I)!ITI1IN] IInI.).1%r.xpnnla •v,";
II •tLj%
T#i)1 j
atitL"iotj hj
1311 £ )oUpfl$ O'N
a.znhIn.)I1W%' .).)()
'IT T' P A. ipp iatlt PT% 0 /iti
--
• ". .t
1
''S '% '1. tt.i's tt
. •iJ.IJ
5
Rt 1-610' '61 6hJfl sSt'p. ...sioc
'VSL(I " )d %1 'L(kS' %
.24
jj
%o1g. 41JSS, ililVi fl;i ')I4 1'
5(YJ9 '' i';2'1 D41 %i4i
's( 1'
W WA Noa50219 233J12:
ibestatcolKarnatik.
Dept. ot Co operailvt.
1 S LI uhlnu.
L3v II 'cc t' ' '-
I3angal u c
1(4 IXpv4R.ct,iI.r i .. j in u it--
aI)(I RcgiMzar iii Sot n
GuIb*uga Th$rlt't
Shlvalthgappa.
S/n. Shantapp KnIa%ht tts.
Gee Dug, kt%.
•'u & Post: Deval (huhi.1gLpti'.
rq ?.fralpur
t)iqt (sUlbarg1.
(iulbarga
4 Ar aver ipp
sb SIiazi'ajp.t T(al,jit
)c B1snu
'a c Post De 'al "1tai1at..ii
Iq L'lpt 1t( 1 L''
Si iiripji
• J3. l. •
)t •r)IbUW%
R. n Dr"i1 I "Cu' 'fl')!
q b t Cr ii.
(tt II' Iu.'
C ate a
' I L
1
UPIn 114 53 '1'
K . B •i
R,'u r'a''L I ti, -
r
''a'i' t'P
III I.
.1 1 I
I4% -
VMV' 1sl12C" 501Xf%.
9
5n tR7.SotSS.fl1S N
1 ,0191 "18
ju:19 233 iO"l 211 & cofl 25' l_
0cc: Contractor.
R/o lkblnI
lq. C 1nttapUr
DIM Gulbaiga
'. shankar.
S )dfl2ctPP8 DCvdtdLF
Oa\gtl
Rb. Ifebbal.
Tq ChIttapUt
1)1st. (,vlbifla G.ifl'mga
tO. Sunita Rn anSIctddpct imbitIgi
Ocr Bu,hWS",
Rb. HJ4oM 1304/li, C,andhi rnZai
iiumnalrcid Road.
Gulbarge.
(u1barga.
11. jkshataSqJdn
Ocr HoucellOld
R/o. H. No 11495/6 11
Opp Appa house
(Jadtital C' k nv
Guthaq
2 Jay4ir"e S21jan
0cc Apr'..
R.o.b No 14)3 1. 11
Opr ,WP1110U5s
Cadutal 4. at )fl
(ntlFat..a
Sin' aJit thu Cit l'nut,alr.
'3,o ttuUhE'tl)1''l) V
( ) t0
1
, a S1.fl Nil t
I '%c lb 0P2
f,s l))3 t it ri
uI'ni' a
,T.ttcjiaL
.
-4,,..
.1 • 4 4
fl I It
•1 ,'
'I I I
1
a '. •ISVJ%.' Ig%
T'
q,
9
• I ).
. (
• '1 • .3 4T_
• I :' I
--'Z Tt't
1
Pt" Ce s•ic
1
La) % (jitlojiT'
I 'I 'Un') •1 iaq
:flfldj ti lu
'' :n '•.
'I•V (ittTItM '--iL\ ci 11%
("1 ' I ' P't I PL'N tJptJWl1J4 UsAR1
SLNSUNOJS3U '"
1'7urqpt
u$wqnr
1vih.\ P ILtUfl
•)Ltt)J-j N
1 id'j' cldo
I )ICbflo%Jflo)J
'-"inq .'o
n'Qvç ucKwy o/g
itiI n3fluP%a{
U73fl"jIIV)
• 11 3t:\ J'j't)
%flflfl "dcIi ddo
it fl'CBI- T\ 'I-I 0/H
••IIsjstJQ
• Ic)
urffi'ç a'ip
I1'(4( l
PWT1.(jTjfl,)
.11')) TIIL J %IUI?T4S •'I)1''
:]
ptOJk 1Pt)f 1)\ 90\ lOld
I.)T1jST1fl •.).()
• n'czioj flhI?fJ \i
. i.K: r(I "i' ;t- t- 3 : ()i(Ir
\iZ tuiti' ill (,SII)' XSII)'
9Si0 ' )J tj q \1
s5cn(rs h 12C ct5t)I$ó.
coin dflqR.cntR9 t&. cm n..'.
%)21 5tl...
Szi intapp ii
,Io. llarmnilh. 14 9 iii
C) 'c. Rn I Go'l. Sc rant
R/o. Ph N' lb \(.O( nk•fl
Okdy Cri 4'
%tda'n Rc id
Gulbaiga
o4
Aa
. bar
S tsha.
'4orn*Ji Ih ri" I
Ace ltoip.n!Iife
R/n.H %e.I 9 SrIdiR'ina'
Dhaniantri Colon).
I ust txr Ri (1
Gulbtu'ga.
Gulbarga.
Dr. cn,ltc cL g 1
S/c Sicinin ippi P ul
0cc Profe'or
R,o.HI%ol is SldJtfaEai
Dli in antri Colony,
Iii ,noo Wa.!.
(ulbrg
(ulbarga
7. Il*UitOcfltlWA .1% 1I
On, '½grnit.c
P/c, %lecrII3.
TQ Suitni' r
tjM'nc.Dlc.(lln 4
Un ga
fljjl
ir tiø h' Ii
)c %x' u''
qn itnc.
1,1; %i
F AJ'( . I
ha fl'tt,t
3 ifit. I
,' Si 'siia.t'
1)
' If '.. %.,c
t
' IC, J 1 .t? 1'
A xinr 'cv
t. ti 1)4
j
ZS -
% %(Kj% is l'('.inIs6.
5016 %OISS.,i)lSQ J)1 30194 'h
n10 234 ""
1
c & n232 :'n I'
:o Iolina Patti
Si Sn ic M 1(M)
.\iuiv'il' in
j1, H No I
PJ MacI 1 iii
R 'ii Dli,n a 1 a C c d'iis
Fu,u orl{'i'
Crulbanza
hiabU4d.
RESPONDENTS
(B Sit Man ntudr.i I'Cv'idv (c't •r R
a,' ' I 2
Sn P tbiaakai a I U in 'ni R a. Rn
WA &i,266I12:
The Suite of Knnatakn 1)1%
Tlnougli ft by ret in
Department at C n pc r. •" s.u me : -
M.S Building
BdntaIan
bavgalore "Its
the I)epul3 Rø ul%rnii 'ii r a ( 't,' . •
anclDistk R i', ( .. '(etc
(stLlbtrga.
Gilba ft
"dii iM I ç p I'ii S.
It. \laii ii i
:
1 11 N'' :
'i
'balud aft' Stat.'!.
ii 4
istilu€t'a.
P a'l'Iil'!i tji)sL• "id' trt'•'l
% 1' a' - 1
•gI) I •a. P1 a
) ci ft i
: (. f_.i c
£ • II•j- g
' r %' I,'
a .r
•
( I
--
.1'
c
4,:I .
• T
I.. • t
-•I. j'l (
Li '1 "J'. b
II '
'1 i '
I
Ta.,; A)
'
'' ft 1)
a I tilf I •
• LJ'I ' 1 -
: i il 3ifl)j
1% \1 1J "1w
• r'f 'S?%4Sf
t;Iat'(IIIfll iflipn'n',
3'1U )tlti LaLsJ
nn' I) uqa -
.naw rip '
"c £ ' RI' K IOljO/)I
• 11QLUUM TUTU )
qn psit
I ) LPCplrh
P 'H iOjf cqoi
1JC/9-tOX H
UPpI S ''t'tL
°/N
•f'l" I - . ovwq'u
flu qpç
1s2wc(pi)
PO)3 U )PflA) )l)OacL'
I A N o/u
liO).cIduurn tpump u' Ufluxu
•P3 lW4ji) Pi ltMjjil()
sUflupz LU I IPTfq
%)T1 S 191 • c i
.1B-')LL IXflfllOI -
9
t ' i i vu'i'q;ui .irqc,
viiuqpi i
eIwqfnr)
.UIOjO) -gil
I 'l\Ial 1(5 1 [0kJ{ °
B
• bE IJ\ lt'UiflM I LIMIJIPH I(%tflfl
3 9 V it tttt$ zk
s1 16W' tI 6SIfl' qsoçgIo
9S((K%' fli '-RI '
(akw
0
0
Qi \s5tsfl is 01S()
01c . M)I)S. iOISQ-I'fl. 501°-I 21%.
j(
3(1)19 '3 4,, fl & 024_ _S6 1:
1 Dnvaku Sis intl (an u
'
1 a't t K ' mu
Pint No 20 Ak ii I Whltl
Gull)arga
(ulbarg .. RESPONDENTS
IBSt' V' it' R i
in ti P.
K tin. Ntt ' '1 Chunk ii .V!' :--. -
% a.
fliese 1ii(
'P1
"
1 •li--'i '.iik: tt'i"ts 1 )71b
: •' C
Karnataka Hlu)ii I. nun At I. tiflfl 10 'i C ll(It'
J Ifli Dliii ( lii '
SI'itk Judg" p1' t' ii W l'S 420s 48 '19 486 I
I ikd 21 02 201? .. .S 11 dalrit Lii 0) 2012 intl iiii
order dated 2102.2012 IC otmiton Ordt
i )ir's%i-cl In
N .413208/ill V.P. T%o.84h94/1l dalecl )1.02.201.. 'i[
.o.8l.827/1 1 daiv. 1 02201" V.P No' S
1W), s469C) 11 "u'1
21022012 V.P Xo',b051580539'11 daici
l 21j)2fl'12 US.
3(fl
0
q 1'? c .ticd '1')? 2012 I Nci 4t?, 1 ., 1! 'lit' I
02.02.2(;12 and Vs I' No 80l7, %fll" 1
It',',tt11' iv
'2 2' ?
1Ilc%f 3in jspe1 )alIIu. ii \cli
H.G RASIfJ
' " -- i ' I
, 'l 'ltd Lii' n1k,tIi a
JUDGMENT
H4 RAIEPIL J. LQral):
lI1st clpI)(' us alt ii Ic. • liii d..Zdali 'lttilXLtY"4 t.jl ' (il cC ..I (. 2) - b a I u c 'u .
5 .k ii - " d 1h: .. - -
ito s F' r L • Li..? •d Ii • : ir. 'I . I 1 d 144L 'TL' Cii I'% Li . Ic I I ',_.'..c.l ' f i Ll 1 •' Cta.' (a 1. I 31 pci i!('...')i 6 jots. MUSS. "01s9 Pfl i01B 2!' O21Q Z '11 & fl212 2,1' 1' disposc il of t, dirt cling hearing of thc wil t petition, cxpecIitiousl. fliey %tibinIt thtt 111e5 Will HOt St Ck ctfl3 a 1$ un n i h 'fflt lit 1 aintil Sijt,11• ucigc.
• 111(3 further submit that the lrnpiuned order of tilt It arncd Singk Judge insofar as ii reldit s It staynw of ronduetlng 01 t'lcetuni of offie bearers ol the.
d.pIWlI1IIt Society may be stayed ifil the disp sal of the iirft petitions. Their %llbnus%ion is p1w. cr1 on rc cord 3 Having regard to the tarts ol the c' isv Wi i( (('p1 the join .,ubrnsslon mack 1,3 bc Ic arned coune1 on both side. s \rc ordingb thc Ii tpiwned orde. dci 1 2 )!20 2 'tolat I iii' 'nm.., I innilimet-ing csI H rflc'q off cillice. Lw ai 'i ol tic l' lLmf Set Itil t n tiv 1 11 l% ti 'i.. 1 Ii "n' r'- rpin.;. tla' r p j hi ic" 1 1 (''I t li fl', 1 f It ' r kS c iii ir 'iii Ti 1 ' '1 urea rLi ".'I fit)? 5 ( (jj ia I 4 lJni.rt r 3 ( . •s 9 • I ii I_i C ti jf •i t ' ,f(:. 1j%' i l I C I. -32- WAs 50078-185/12 ('1w. 50186, 50187, 50188. 50189-193, 50194-218, 50219-233. 50234-241 & 50242-256/12 the writ petitions relating to these writ appeals before the learned Single Judge on 28.02.2012. rrhe writ appeals are allowed in the above terms. In view of disposal of the writ appeals, the interlocutory applications filed for interim stay In all the appeals do not survive for consideration and they stand disposed of accordingly.
Appeals allowed.
Sd! JUDGE Ksm*