Helen E Joseph vs M/O Defence on 24 September, 2019

[Cites 3, Cited by 0]

Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai

Helen E Joseph vs M/O Defence on 24 September, 2019

i  QANe 22013

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
MUMBAI BENCH, CAMP AT NAGPUR

'ORIGIN AL APPLIC ATION No.2 2119/2015

Dated this Tuesday, the 24" of September, 2019
"CORAM: DR. BHAGW. AN SAHAL, MEMBER (ADMINISTRATIV ) 2

Sint. Helen Elphic Joseph, aged about 62 years, retired as Sr. Steno -

in the office of AGAW (A), Ambajhari, R o 7faf?, Vasant Vilar,
Khadgaon Road, Wadi, Nagpur 440 023, - se Applicant
{By Advocate Shri B.Lahir{) . mos

VERSUS _

|. Union of Indis, throegh, The Secr etary, Ministry y of Defence,
South Block, New Dethi 110 011,

2. The Director Gene eral, Directorate of General of "Aeronautic suality
Assurance, HE Block, New Delhi TG OL,
3. The Principal CDA ( Pensions), Civ il Draupadi Ghat,

Allahabad 211 014,

4, The Director, A.O: AL Wi }-Ambajhari, oe
Nagpur 446 021. - Respondents
(By Advocate Shri R.G. Agrawal) .

Order reserved on 22.08.2019
Order pronounced on 24.09.2019

ORDER

Smt. Helen FE. Joseph, retired Senior Stenographer from office of | Aeronautical vality Assurance Wing (A), Ambatnari, Nagpur filed this OA on 28,94.2015. She has sought quashing and setting 'aside. of corrigendum issued on 20.01.2015 toe her pension. payment ¥ tn { ~ o = Tw - ~ Principal Controller Or De fen ACCGUNES i 3 nnd oo PT doeye a F Phas = = a (Pensions), Caval Draupadignat, ALlananad ad * x = g eon 3 = XS 4 he & m3 Mek te te "4 b ae EI cs 7 % ; Ad ay res oc . 5 oy 44 ' } oe wet * = 4D 2 ° iD i if D 4 w toy a Mm a oO fe . og) Co $e eG s © ri 0 MO Ge ig ao 2. & Go a YG acy. os § 6 6 8 o 5 Ba Di Ie a 4 w 'be ' % ty coed xo eo ia 3 w O34 - "4, % ai {fy S, ' 3 43 a ee & " aad La G3 e Chi on ord G a i "Ks ot ae he ad " i i ky . . a ag. 3 v2 ® Mo & * u 2 ws mo ae als % 3&5 : bf o nee r om G . mn 2 iw ot 0 m% a O ye Gs ed 9 mew po BB a ae eG cp BO Bom cs i in oe RB a & Cy , 4 t ' Se ) = ¢ d wy a oy bed 43 a ns W " +3 ie w " 44 hs s : os : oO %) vet "4 c ™ "ny a a © He ei am "- aes oe £5 wed wee oe oO a yet O45 ey © ai ny n Fs a beac t 6 3 a ea ue oot woe 8.3 Ps 2 4 ed a op Bo io wt OS os a ce a "a ta a My c yo ay a, Fog ct Oo tp 8 ° " Aa) ot @ A rae Q th o s 4 [ry an ys ae t ier a . wef es < @ rt vat 33 Os my ao OS cn In uo ot wos 3 : Bs a 4 - es = - e ww os me © OG a . 6 ™ $4 oO "s ~ 1 be eh rd un i 3 % 4) % a a ae wn a Ra " Me a : 4 te wo 43 t ie tO 2 ' u ms ~ ved vd "eo og 6 & y : eo aes pe a ji . . we $e " tty eee! te oy Bo gs a en a Pe oe fe mh @ Dp mB « tha : on 4 + a € ~ ne : tt C3 a mt el a tM cs us aed ors he o eG vest "Ht & } BA a od on ved Oo . GQ x oy v4 6 a c a ™ tn "

sod Lf 6h ag ae , ry ba a et mn ¢r | th aoe A - %, lave! i el 4 its -} a a * a 4 "es ey ws, a a | os rs: € sy 3 oy iXs 4 i 2 co Pe oi iW oo G3 "ef 4 Led a e 3 oy oy ; . Dy ag a 3 ® v4 i} G - co 3 a3 my Dy Ly @ Sr Ms ye 6 4 AQ & NS 3 a 7 = OS Ls «3 re oy Boor @ vs " 3 3 G Se vf a , ons a a mS Chg an co MS aa 7) 6 6 Oh 4 * ext 5 mot ® rye O vai 4 ™ % G 4 ri oj at " oD i (3 Ww ; ' 4 na a i ts vy @ a at 4 a ea we ng * 4 eS be oy g eee Set ts a jet om oF CY ao a wy , --o o4 aN = i iF se and My Nd o 43 % ; en cn ee ; "ag feng cd Q tis * x gorg <4 4 C4 et is . 7t ~, Oe oO it om $4 £ red , ik tf . rc cm aby . ; . th ey ewe fs cs : aa og y * rd 5 * OO vw a : :

rhe i o ay ¢ : - : ' 5 4 44 i ise " , je . ry a eo 7] 4 : te ed 0 2 33 e 6 ore, oh . el, 4a ee] 3 Zw ih Lae a py . & i. ; ct ~S ™ ai ot P * =f ee £ a ot oy Oo Gel Sy aR" Oy = oy a o> LG a . ay Sof om w : 3 oe Y 1S 20 rm O21) u ;

+ OA og 3 .

= Le) ss a n MF a ; a a Poet a co A? a '4 & GR BO Ee Oa 4 . 7 oF her re fy Net :

ae gd : " ' 3 de iS ea . P "4 ry tS OG + © ae . 4? $. os be Ts + 0 cs G Me . 4 Q @ ee rd BoB. BoD QO OR ut Boo C4 & Oo @ a i SA : : ~ O 40 a , & o ts mm Eas ms rs o 4 eat sd iy Le 4 S "gs BS ES i " ge. 7 we ot 5 ~ a Sb oe as if bs } : eee es GP ' hoe iz oO . we eam ei s 8 St ibs *s ts , ei} eh . ag Bs 2 G st i vs Q By et "4 wo OQ ks 4 ts . cane a) eed . ta A mt 4 rsh) ™ v3 G4 oO LS th * CO « it} a8 4 te. cS Ba, Cy a wD mn fe co » . ~ os of ch © ay @ a sen ms "4 we) et ao hon w oD ne re nas a ™ 2 ; BoM Sy ; Soa OR © O wv ts an ; :

fee Lat ne a eri "pe . . a ord oe - re ty c : fs pe een Ue ¢ oy % BU . O, to & 7 oe age f OP: ' é wo, EB o es ~ fea as t ~ a é aS gs 2 " td "ed #4 oO te oe «hs - ia i " 4 "sy rae i ea c re 4 % ry "ed cL Os i ta ett tony mh i % rhe bet £4 ices ce} 6, . * % re UW 3 ay +3 ee $$ ota e by a we wo r 2 . 4. te iit ; eH © Z4 4) o +3 oo Say om Mt i gh os os Qo id 3) aon i casi @ oe rept oF a on ot ord Med " oO 7 wes e o , . 4 2 Fe) i" et : mS as ; a 8 4 ) a, on 3 5 vt on a wy S 4 @ th e 4 a Be a Ge Shed «@ ro ee ° Ds " wt " " a @ 4 BS a A Oo 4 ; a a Deg OS aed : : : ape. am = oe os 6 a ia @ wy Eh on oo. Be & 6 a og § Oo Bw OF ED oy : 43 inj - £5 a : C rn a iB gud: : xo 4 FEL "Bed . i] , 5 1 .

- eS a, vel a ' ee ee ona 4 Gio no oH bb oO qo. a we wa s oo , on pg OM 6S * a Qa oe oy y ¥ 43 Fe a ny a ha Pe fee mu ~ Se OD NG . hat oO 43 43 8 are 2 Q pS , 'peed anos ae Ow aw Og go GG o iD ie > ed f opt - we, oy od & r . * 4 nt il . et ie) bey ch % CD . ' D be MA o ie t ir L : : > * oO Oo ce ed 4A 5 ' Bet Oo OP os oe OB a . at GG a '3 tt ag (La oe hc Dg an . oO ; cs nd ho wh, fea an Bo G oe Oo 6 os a S oh 8 oo- os ! Of © 4 " a rs) set , .@ Bs OR bo sed : OE od G oD os Go 43 'ON a @ OO Bo mw &. < . a a @ oO fF 6 % DoT a Gt dD a 5 ore @ 2 rH " s x & " id es w ec po. RB Oo 6 Cs z : , 4 ° GR. :

i 3 j iy Sr @ rm MO UD Be Go OY Fy el Pte 8B a = = 204 128, ~ Z, ate OANo "eh j hed oO. UD "3 4 was vy 2 ns NM, ay he a e i ° < ae Ss re) wy a bf ed eo OLB w@ mn Sel cS @ Sa So 2 ! Pg ® Ged a «3 ty ne : S 43 unt ra) iG Bed Bs . veh sed a ceed 2 ne o.

De ry ee co £ Dy . 8 os a red he a 3 ord o} i i "ag G "G ka Oy cS rt 43 Bio gs 43 rio Bo cs 4 6B gwd or Me ed ed ron wy 8 eed in a by 8 i wy oy iy ip fad i fa wt te ba wy 4s A 003 a a Co . 4 = mS a 3 _ G : U3 oO * 3 rnd weg " Oe 3 a ' fed. mo ogy Co vt oxy ie ~ os ep or $23 cs Si wa @ seed £3 iQ v a * wo ER oe Hg & DP Oo CH gp ER gag Go es Pe ag ey Wf Gy Be gp ee ee , a Hoe td th a SS 4 us e v et wes oO an TO. " O i eo ip er ah "ed ba rz) O49 Does 2 A at Nt hae a e { wpe i G an rea wos "kD g} ay o% . ord ie a 5.4 and rt "

X my A RK ron "4 rm] Goo Ww Cored og Fo ot oy Swe v a , ji ; as ty lS a io a ted Bo gb aS Co oy "s , oy Bg i ha sped ny rt br cy ) ot " * m4 5 OW 3 ts "5 on 5 bed M4 oO G4 @ 3 ; tex ord " . ' o * ¢ ' a _ " oy qc ocd oeear Oo ee a i 3 @ iv 4 . Gi Be ce Qo a £ ved ~ Xe ¥ 93] ~ C4 a . ia bef : eed 5 im av} Che : c re ne "4 cs + ' wd "£3 { oF wet ; oa , vs "4 $24 " oF y wef OM ma 1 al AS os 3.4 ee 5 "e th . v Q @ a cers - ~ © wc eet 25 | Bet "4, a 13 iy 4 red iy 4 et oh on th q ee 4 Be Oe gs ad cs mM FD gy me y z Ae a rs a5 4 "rt ci 3 _ wD cost mo an ne i me a } ; 8 o as ie Bo Ng 6 5 8 a a ® rr er & . moo. : ea L a . . + : : ,

2) a a " tS mS a "4 " a 3 & Qi a ro ge

i) oo - set: me w s , : ~ bel } > ~ : peed A vd : oA : on ee nt 4 @ 4 send wv w i * i wf ce ma 4) %} rad i) rae es : gs . ved in sh a 4 Es Y % oo oy ay a of 43 a a G ceed o a) e 5 as ) a :

ay we ot ip E-4 ee O 64 fe ey . A " Gel Gg it Se ¢ , : : 2 wa wv ' " ; BA og mY O cs a ch a a tO po MS 8 o a a ¥ 4 ' 3 tj | a « we : ns Wn Go Qs i boy by RE me ~ ~ 9 SF 3 to set aw a " $e = ra ee "hap c 5-3 $3 44 O a c i a @ ibe - G ~ C

5 4 am oO ~ veh tS ed eed Bogs gm. f ; > 6 G rs o 0 Sy og gt & e e pugn:

¢ S er Up Ss » Me a4 gy 4b CF 3 @ rot ws {3 wy 4 a as tf @ Q a od y i et Pos) tel 0 SS x od n @ % : 8 Oy 2 & TW ed GO & a OH 4.1 © A & x Qe Oo seh Me 'OLS iO t "yy te OA NOE wy ft Cy

8) on

3) ae @ $24 ® G Ch «nt GY to Pi ref on off & ris) Ch 45 4 $4 "Mb ef 8 13] Y rot hd 4 ved £3 eh, 2 fa Loo i o oe 4 ok b eS ow Ve Hn sok"

cn wp aa te?

4 Gs AB oped J avd Ud iB co pot 4 cy od > C2 ont to ©

i) Oh Gs ve 0 Ca te) ee @ bg 43 o we « * < Contentions of the parties

3.

"rd i ot ce ey @ te weed, oped ot & CN ct ) 43

3. vy Nee athe RQ a Res z so So ee 2 on a Y 4 : 4 By. ' $4 @ * if 43 it uy tS ty Get og as cao SO a ved 0 ° @ Em Aa 4 end ai M ow a im . eer nk are @ : O i Ww aw At 43 4 ") ot 4 td 3 3 em @ o ee @ ° 3 as sed wo & de 4 we £3 co a * 4 "

ee O de oy Es é " Dard i 3 ie es ee o ca iw 8 ey al 4D i a n>) a 8 ce fa £35 ¢ 7 5 oy Gg} :

™, ey age i) a QB w ' ; "eg rae ww bs 4 SS eh 4 £ 3 a i ® © o A a . 43 a beg 48 4 Moe 4 " *s fat © % Oh, wrt ws q wm 43 2 - eh ut 2 43 a i be of i a3 O baa oO . GO w ~ ae wed S "i a ss wl re . st gg @ +3 a 8 Ho am OG tn t ww 6 t be 43 © weet 3 C tel a Oe oe 3 « G rd a Shed ey 43 i Ae KS @ O Mi ' bz j a (3 o re) © oo : ry | og ra Aa . we 4 ps4: wy " - Co 4 t te Fa bg 44 "4 we O a @ a as D i c ° @ iG "4 Bs Co ead sen} ee 2 q eg x f £ -3 th "

é oy é HG 5 So ye fh § #8 . jo a 4 es be 7 ne ea ( a n fu bo Fo Boge 2 of Be yw BG p £3 "4 . " 4 is 2 oe . o * 3 MS S ah a 5 M4 i "a 4 "i "eA . ag oO : 6 we, uy a ° < "4 wid 4 4 , . 3 . iD ry bt ' he hed nm , q - Uy C3 $3 3 ~ " o im oH Bo wy t

-

£ © % ru mis ay ex om } .

~ Now o As

--

a be ¥ " : "e ws ti ¢ om. a wy 4 « io SA at . . {T3 ia ot im e 4 . 5 wo O a C6 * 4 ; a MM o < hd v n a Dp @ w "" me Oy 3 oF @ wed 14 ee 2 ra 6 2 od 4) a we r ha wa . © ry eed ced 4 4 wee vee a £3 © ti DS «of we wp ra £F foes g 3 od rt Dp vs yy . oe ¢ ved <3 oe oe c end e . he, ip - x x : a a4 st C4 " weed we CO. ooh uy rt Bs 8 - 4 i ord Sei m, (8 4 ved D i ify wed "€ vos <i 4 (! 2 4 : - 4 ' Sef By by a uw WD G & ; @ 4 t ° ) Fr ;

m4 a $4 os ae toc @ HD G * O'S . " @ G 4s yp Bo tm fF oe CR a re GC & Ww OM ox eS 6 . O Oo @ SG 0 4 ow 44 "3 eh opt ha ord ard wD cing a On 3 a) 43 rf a A i | 5 'g Qo > be oe a GH n 2 Saw 2 SG 8 yO OA ma oe 8 6 2 ml o 4 4 ry Se ies a xy CS w ord 43 5 w et 6% 5 Ly Ma m4 4 TG ee ee oA 4 ha rhe « a' geod oo a GA No Zily gen ;

+e Ary ayised Y Lot ny Cer wet 4 "3S DD ey B-

gh ves ch ES:

i eed and Bay S UntaLe BY j e me iQ nb oO ve fxj 4 wey svi ond co ise xed od B a a hel

2) 1oS «i RRASt Mate ITER 3 s acd 4 mm ba @ me ted Ad "rh eh ef, wi oy E State of Punjab. and Others Vs. aS LL Rafig Masih (sup

3) wo a ae ot et Rukmani Ms. M4 @ ° iS f ' 20.06.2 'on Vs.. The Secretary to the Government » Ramanujam Gg OA Ne2119/s ey ge im @ 44 HG "5 iS pe et + * j jot ES a bd Gy v 2 : Ss a ; yy 2 ' oe 7 mo in CG. a3 7 0 O WJ AN ct m nS ny. if a x : iO uu Oo o © & 7 ; fs) a9) cS re Sed ve 3 aD Bo be mo oo * € " et SG.

os a 4G -- O 4 ¢ cae ow 8 ") eg ~ oh che od . re) r OF . ws . Co of o ee Se) 4 . Se SD eee ee ee 3G yo te fo i @ ~ als og og UF "i dg oS G CO eo & x ce net ok a oot a oe in 3 Bay a4 CP eed sees a ey oe wD oe A ra mee as poo te ; eo: a: rf ., : f 4 oe @ 4 4 ONY : nie LO 30) . go e- ; i rs ; if C3 C3 & 2 ~ hd WD ial ip ae ' te i . ; 4 a 5 cp iB ¢ hs ra ' . : ve get } ao BA oo Me ~ w ved ed aL bd : mh tA G we ey 4 ee | AEs tye a ey > En rR ce Kb we : ° : 3 a ange ued py. : pha . '{ ; c us Oe Oa a Z bs) G 7 : ~ ® 7 i m4 Co ® . th : x . wt b> f tS oo . 7 a ey : a j . ASD © BOS "4 + Me : , Eons . % ; Rb an Bom BR Be ew om SB et gm Og Bm S o wo PB ee a "So BOB. 3 a 0 os a Eg es oO . 9 CFs Bou BR KF BG Tg © in as mH ae rod ' foo! "4 ~ :

OR Bg cg § 8 sy Og a S mo a Be ao@ 7 § 2 FS xn 4 ee ee) ne & Fy it ad 4 eng ged . 4 Ss 4 ¥ : 2 a = a cat ee 1 a o a a om ee ON £4 ko be, 8 on C2 Wh be, a .. My o i) 4 , a} 4D ot a4 : ne . ry "4 < 4 4 --3 . oO ; ua ce rs @ a {ep Qa c & © . ty ¥ ng, . we ' : ee qs 2 we Sy 3. ae ok .

HD OO St @ v A gy 3 Ke G cs 3 o 4g mt Peeps oo ME i 4 at eA ped : "A a oO wo os ks 2 w Py, Bs 5 OD ae ee 5 TO RR a 7 BO @ f nt Be aos : 4 iS), he : 5 e C4 Qa " ert "4 = bey 4 re, a as a * x : . » ht . 6 wy C iS : : ig re Go ty 5 OO ay & wD aS o oa 5 aed Ee fe ge Pg any mf. bey ay. af SO a no oe vd . Ch Ss. ed a : aed es © @ 8 ££. 9 42 ~ 5 o 8 4 a BS ay ® i OD Og <j G ~ , gS r4 A w se Mo ED i . OQ. Zio Go 4 Bel eh ey 6 iD wv x ei @ a yw oy fet: tA so by et QB ny . mS t be ved ery : oO Loy : tA mis) ot wv Oh; 3 gy ard vy AS ' a4 ag . a * : 4 Qo i : re Ee hs el Se @ Oy, ed 4 O ee ot G Go. e 2) me a bs ; Q 42 ba ie * e) ba 4 oi " ; me + f 1 aan ot ton m4 wD mass 43 eh 4 ¢ : Sy co sed 34 4 a eed 4 A « aD oO + pd tg poet ty 9g) a "% : Gh . ' DQ. cin o ni cf ~ ce . coed . a a mo Mo ns © Bo ' o 4 bs gy bog aed oO rt % G So ao G4 wy a ah op os Tne 06) C3 a ©

- i seb oh) ; : GB wt ¢ 4 a fy } {2 3 2 ra © . uy Z a a3 Ad $33 ee : ' $4 ge Bh IG 7 a 8 rs a tS tet MN tg wm ORD SS 4 S g@ eB mo © ge , - og ah reg of : St oa _

43) rl wed fe oe a mn on =) a Spe Se $B C > ent uss 'st Soe Ca ee 3. Oh ~ Oo OS oe ard mt Uy a ee =. " 4g £3 ex Ee tho mm + oe = x ° . $4 ie) 42 44 6 'hd 2 mn a yen a o Cy a Sie @ Cy g st a) mp A ed Hoo w oo: 8 ae ' a SS . e a eo wh tt Ly wy bed et 73 ey iM ea mS & Che My rg ee : : ¢£ ' ; ' . : | .

@ @ os i 3 ~ : # ot gk Ba bp O OY i i os M4 ep ord 6 eons oo e wy so. @ ty ak Gay ca) 4 4 wn oO ci v4 @? Med mS w =f i 44 mo She Li a Zz od 2 AEP. Up sed, te & "xt mo OE +3 4 "O uy BO = So ra wa a vet 43 . G BS oa: mn @ at Reo ah oy = o mG . oF are} oo bus be oe é So ag rd ne set . m 4 al es 4 i 2 a mh ue a 2 mn Pe, et ts vee nn ee et ' Ho Bg Gx 3 Boa & 2 og oa 8 8 © 8S pe Rd ae oo Sg ow oe Ke ei CO of Go 5 fra e axcpt a ce) Me ett & ma ™ 4d 4 "4 cS M Bee a rs ' SR ee v be th oo 2 eC 3 rv o ra} be iy ct pod weg OP : oa ee ' 3° D me bp pe BE Ka : sa oe one oS an a ; 4 " Ae whe. ayed x op| ur : Sg £3 : oe eo; bod a tt ces) . ae 4 Coos or Oo pa - poo os oA Pa: ; ck 4 . ed we res ace ey. - he wo i ced Mo gt : ort vo Sa te owe en ¢ oO rt ey PSS ae Ba Ps oe , a4 ee : & a ' AS fo oe A " Sy 7 ED + MS * - : ae . ; be! t ras a ' » 5 ¢ g PRO . 3) Me Be ae , . ' . no Ry 3 oe o o oe o ee a ya NY 43 . ord . L cS re : : hei . t a 4 oe " i ¢.

: Ben . ry, ip +f om ' tye4 and 7 4. : . Gro et ; 5 i OM : c weed ' or " ¢ . . ' r wo bd a id Wa 42 " 9 neh) a v a 32 Be Bs gee * ' Oe "Oo Oo, et Se £ Os an oO mo & cay o. "4 Ds Go. 7*# ip 4, o 2 Be a BD gg a Bw OS e 8 (3 . "4 Co ma - Ct rei 4 "a yo ved C3 4} o a' aon a s) C "es 4 ye ant ' "4 ees 3 { | : f ob: oe oo ne q : . 4 . ¢ or) Lo) 4 44 a cS im me B * "¢ Sa oO cy : a & o Ss xD i ES 8 tba ey a G a € | a id a Bhs gy ; Wo. Sa 2 '> . ' G3 ae aed 4 rs os 44 % bd aye Sd SO at e4.

CH Doon 3 re a oa » Poo oe ' % oe a ip ont R o wy > "ol 43 a sa ~ te 12 A a * £ 4 e i D = a tah, @ 8 wot . , * penn 7 * . ° hi 4 ed oo ord ef es rst Be ti uh Wo 1g 3 7 oi we gy as Wp et wa OG eet a ert wy * ae : ed Oo. » Oo C . mm : : y + ° CG ? " =, : £ a - Qa . ot 7 o em "4 te et 2B Ea a. ae e co Me Gy Don :

o : Sao ery us a rl oe et ea © a & a) oO ® <4 ee C3 % OD. G ) CG es y 0) el * o 4 et 4 14.4 4 « » oo oR yy e fe 6.5 te 4 Sa os o @ Ho GB ley Ps Se, e a y "A Q ze ts . a s Bs Gy oC i "et 7 ay Q oe e " & po te O ff TD BD 8 2 's) Gs rs . t~ He Us nS 4 aw 44 wy Ls Oy oN Oo ph . CG ry} wed os 3 w wn "ch C3, a * : wy ued A m wood OD ite) sh Bef ® hed e 6 md ce 4 i i us be Q

4 & Go Oo. 9 - oO Pa) Nee cs a) ie a ao a a ned @ 4 @ 3) 9 eG Oo 8 B&B O MO Be mH Gg ££ wp H § BS 8 eB 8B Dm BGS a OA Notts o a Q os tt aa aD BE . wf nD e . 1 . cee . a . po ot < va A . sos ' ae bain ~ < 3 Co * : re Aud it 2 fe oO ed £4 . 6 oo eNy ued oO C3 CS vind co O mp be C : o oH we oe 43 a O C5 a < sed ty re G 3 yet Co $3 co . roe "2 'net ' u ? my ita 4 G3 a : " . teed a e soee ef rs t 4-4 @ a : i co o ve " 0 8 Cd @ art ai pt ed: oe ret

a) td - oS fa . "4 z i NS Gy eS 5 a ts re bd 44 a4 wt b> eg ea jet Q : 5S +4 ha

-- t 5 Q = 43 mm i oe oo : a " fs Po 5 Cy u3 4 . 4 ey $4 "3 : a ie vet w Y : rey >) wd s. % led F * an Cy whew te : hi nped Sg wD feats : "t ms ws : aed Cy , uy 43. " o 2 : gS x q eo iS S- @ os} ad wo mes i a 4 43 oO @ rer Mo ad de _ 2 cf gy Bo BB . * Boo ge se Mbt oe woe es pe if} ee 36) rs si wD wy "cd Po Go 3 a Oo 3 C BR ct + wed oO 5 - £3 : 4 ue) es + a 4 = a coe s CX re avd Lead AX . 4 2 B08 ee a ; a & 6 3 B® " ed 5 * qt ed m4 5 a ao © & e OEY es 45 y - rs . * A red be, ms i Sd i 4 ° vy eh eh - wn v4 "re ms ~4 O oy pa i & GC 5 os a Pn Cc es i ee 43 os 5 2d } eg GS o oO O ' + ne o a) D 4 @ bl o oo Oy : cy a3 ee ; se a oO 3 os ; re ag er ty we hs 4 '> n rs 2 et o a 4 ge Co oe. O Ue nf wd th it r o oO Q OM ws : . 6 OQ ' Cho Shy "4 wped wed ong iB os O u ut i . ce 5 Y oy ow = ; ; / fis _ FB 1 a. ¢ > a fs ae rm ao +e ehh & Ra £3 ce G Sh, 0 $d (s cM fa 2p OB Ot 3 me : es nee ~2 4 5 yoo a ped 7 2 : ; sa Gg. ; PE gy ce PG uy oe OD pe 4 re o had ay wd '4 , Oo Q se a a . Ss oe "3 vee} Lye} ot hf Q ry GS sod ° ra) ef Q oe aa ny > 'Ay a oo 4 a eof . 3 C} th a ry SS bat cont tes : 4 a ; i Q Le wed cA. t be , a x ~ Eat a) set 5 oO , Co. 1 a 3 ie 3 ie ° 7 oe c a v 2 BP ed ed 4g t ms ea es " ; Ps | gQ a sf * 4 - . Es ot a cid mG ® oe 4A a f OU" € Oo @ & ns ee 4 * ) i gd v ma wh mo $5 RS Pa 4 - gp ord ehed ~ de ee na red Yon i> vst ¥ :

BS oo EE a Oo. pgs gy O - me BR de SK ord a) 8 Pa O ® AA, ved: Ses m2 CS 2 5 ort is hed " wo wed e a} a $4 1 @ Gh ESS ay Hs ra mo fe $a ne my pa he cy :

by RE ah - im v 3 3 ie e OMS a Pa Q ! "4 2 . bee . 7: aL * ho hig © 4 ® @ : cet 7 v : ocd . eo ha "ch 3 to bed Pe ba oy " 42 3 o 6°35 @ bp od om Ba BB he © ~ 3 i » Doo a By a @ wy wm & 4 oO ed ES ° ry o bel @ tg Oy Oe CD fe Re mn oy o My a a Gy 4 aot we " & H @ = r S } 5 3 a a Waar ed ed mB teers SPT 2 Bey SS8s ft 119/20 "

OAN2 wt f Bad eS OS * AB R Bow.

% sy wet passed on % «3, 3{k} ne a @ oe eB 3 wD oO hy O w@ 4 od Sa bo ay bes ie} a.

oO oN 'GS @ 4 t "3 Ft cord D> oj a tea 7 tay S&S FES wk ae:

z "WAS A See Le a 2 be we fy we

6) wd ue @ G ef G3 oO m Cnh of co on Mo ey 57 ed we w@ w eae] G B nd As "rl a id it ts q ed Sa tS ¥ ety ae Ne € Wi tag ted 3 fae oA Le Su ~ Peay JF om:

Poe ee f.

Apex"

igh Court Of:

dct AY q 4 Co OF of Punjab and Maryana and others Vs. Jdagdev_ D. ct tS % Co oh hed . yore a2 om - ° : vn a nw iD ' 4) O zi d a Pe SO a : mt Bly i c aS . ct rod fo 44 my B i bt con : es y ed, ted oF . >

5 : 3 . _ de G oe 3 oo ed wh dQ rE a é a 6 e a4 o oO

- [ te . $-4 ; a z a Bo ord a at 54) oO ved 45 i . @ & dhe = ard ° > - ey a G w 4 4 44 a 42 CB : w 4t ce sd re) 6 BE ow / po? pe ' ° . :

OANG ZUG! . oy fe ae i : n ix 43 th 04 . th # yl rt : 4 . co . fa : G * ai ee w c * rs a & QB eC a wo Q 3 DB od cl. e a Bos eae : ep Be Sy ee Be gt oo O og 0 Foo og OP &s oa: & aS £5 ord oo v a oot " bt 43 a oe Bebo Ag es "e io r : ;

t S g & be cy $3 : th 6 "oe © : 2 sigh 4 om.

hd "wn tal ao oo 4a" on "

8 wk Oo 4 ie) 4 ~ -- og i er hes £3 t oO / : Ed ed Oo wey LOU es BR AT pa S Qb8)> G XN rr Tr ce EL ".~ u te Me a * . wy $4 + 2 rh Bop 8B 2 p FS ey 86 4» B2 ge # To 8 § 2 8 oy sk Oo. Oo & % v3 a +4 o . Os o a cy Bh gy o oe 3 Ba eT ® ' fe OM TH Ws Be Oo Gg sa ch a $5 or '4 m8 OQ 9 et a 3 . a) aaa Chi Me OG vod Se 4. + f : @ os é : ee a eI C5 A oe i se MS in D sa cee fa v ~ 6 0 "4 ci reg wg ae ee v oi Pi . vot 'd 3 rm ts Ww She nr 4 id oo } "3 ya go a a - ~ : " a mp «s @ 2 BB oO:

; + a She O co 4 . : G / ae 43 Cyt wn <4 an gt "4 , 4 43 ha Sa OE net a oe. : FR we 4 } ci 42 } UF * mag BG ) a we iH wee As et _ Oo i L Oy no oad ae Sa ¥ 4, ted BR Be oe M4 Bg oR | ae Oo Ree u Oo eg 4 m . : . Me

- we 5 * a 'S gt : oN . & . 2 ' non SB & Bg B a reported in 2016 STPL 7638 SC decided } ts, fee 3 S Mi * x a / ; om @ a wee a hg cs os os ; Oo '3 bel as *) oe ch % Z rc @ ret pe -£} . C4 ard i : ! a th wr ot 3 A Fae os A bed QB Be a a r iD $4 w LG ard ae 4a Q 3 fos a ws ra a ves " - te a , wed up OP a bed od. v vel om og Good a OS Bo oo PF gs eo BY gg 2 e@ to Be y w ' | po am 6 Bd oni o y a b tl PEC 2 i de mem a e $ i Bo ® Bord ,

5 5 my ted SS Oy wy * my . yt of 2 8 Soe & €@ Oo & ND Be Oo on 29.07.2016. nvit @ ¥ oy o 3 im).

IY, th h a Singh, ame the » ", x "4 : $. oy ~ 4 io na 4 a Cy hd $4 hea 64 ~ i mm ww = Ba ~ , are) Oo & o3 Sy rd ce 1 4-4 o Bis he © i + iy " $ ap we 8 oO te os oo "3 na © ol oy wh eR A n) #3 i O 4 G £s ca a3 rf M4 ® vet M a ss Q o4 a a4 2 Ss 'it Ci, 2 , 2? 4a Ss @ C mH bo : a O Qy BoB Op gy ee A <f %) : 3 ved os oo ut Tt * : et q @ cj 44 . oC vif zm "ek ~ & Ba ae co Se i wf p al

- 4 bp td o cee op} : EY ay G o ee 4 mn na OQ 4 st in OD ny i es n 5 ry D LW i © wy oo ng ard % 8 o te Oo wo. ye > ee re D oo 6B D ah $4 i ie . By g 2 44 gy. OD is) ot v ee) 3 4 hay Woo yy eet 6g Es i Q ci , ' u in ny QO 3 cC Oh, aad ~ % co mt i { iy 4 £3 oe : %, 4 = ; 0 a % in te) J ' o - @ 6 Es ry " at 9) qo cg end cant tht cs : hy oh . . . ba «ged ~" . <2. :

os ad : $35 og da ee w G cd $4 B we et a se . ed va a a ya mS ® wor} 4 £3 G ng o Gay Sa, ™ 0 ' 7 u me eo oe a i} ut 3 ar o Oo! 7 7 ee gy AY @ ved ' . Te .

O : oO, as 8 ha "gaed m4 ° a : 6 1 B WB a & 6 & Oo py eed art oy rho ag OU B Mg Qe os OO YW RB gg o % Og o C & is] ot a fe fa) 5S rea 5 ; $4 . a & , Ct ei 2 @ Bios a bef ond cs Ly a 3 bee Se o ord GO oO fe iD ip ge a ed ved 43 ip O i 7 we wef | 4) y Oe sof a 4 rd go re 4 . oe Q 2) re 4 3 6 q ye ts Fa oe ss és b ooo ; a 9 p isa @ eB a o od ved cs od - . at aged Q 7 AS et hd 4) Q mG t mo i : a i "

gy . oe % 4 ct eZ « e a plo: bd oe @ rn . oe "4 ' et fd or ct "ef o) wd /& os @ no ba) Y 3 4 . cae 3 no '. Q Gt % £3 Bu . 44 c>.. cs oO. ® od 4 Y a, 5 a hy ip .

oO gar mT e e « o rs oO i . Ss G 3-4 4 / » g 4 cs .. a 43 "ee 3 B es, 3a tot Go a oO gd ard HQ O a t a 4 A 4 | t 4 wh Ry geo} GQ wf 13 A > Oy i " 9 © oS MO a iS Q ood ue @ a © fete w " G "3 a 44 43 wa yb. gt a 4 sj h4 % i ch = ES + gec 3 re rm ON z 14 4 ™ G ih ce "ef i 3 ip ae "re $2 A led 's) et tet ten

1) a 45 i ha a w iE raed re rie ie ik wy ELS I .ey phn A Ae ~ we 3fe}.ea High Court of Punjab and Harayana Vs. a oD) ic ea 1 oe OS , ; a bi i j va 4 . 44 oA $4 Bd Ue i a Sie AE . 5 a © a Bork ol G- = 0D cs c i a bn, : - , - wed Ad 4 hee woe, a "o. a \ S Ce ge BE SB 8 GO Go - fo 8 _@ SG 8 BR Mtg rk i 43 ot cs a " o£? & Bo OF i te Oo, 8 % mt ge fe, eS Ce . we mo Oo 8 i mort tf sy oO " ane my to Moy OF 6 + a _ @ wo gee i ra 53 ag Sos wo OG end © a ee) 5 oO fF om ox A a eo gg Ok Ge 8 US GE Gog eg EM ort a cs By 6 fa od o © . oa Shed Sat ark =i 0D ¢ co NS . a wed oh oC ay ray es o @ ra Bes 4) or S Os ~ iS - wn a ws % a €5 Q tt no Oo AD a, i © O " @ "es 3 Os +s ria a ce Se oO. bY 8 2 2 8 gp ™ 4 @ Be Be GS 8 y 4.2 3 dL. ; . a! 2 4-4 my ane ee _ fe a eo, * vd oi } 9) B ro % cy o " " ae 42 ON . om oy oO at ata 3 " Fs % Ss _ i ot Q 4 sa 43 i ~ SS a - ea ; ue ' org fo et ® 8 = 43 " G ct te my ~ Oe . 4 we hs Es wy od @ 3g rho ore "4 as ae wnt OM a c Pe wee wo =e m4 " O% og, . eo ~~ 8 © OQ: ey . ey Ld a Ms a if , Oi Cy a Pas ne 5 " a vt tr ke > ed B os ve : om cs oi f Ds cps re on a: ne wa ¥ : ba DB QD ao net a wad a on rd . wy 4 3 m4 eny 43 De @ ed ie Nat &G . @& Bo 2 ot Oo 4 os G : co an we o 3 ae Bo A 43 O° th 4 foe cy fox £ a (ove & mm ct ? ' co) Ma oe 53 A vod cry a i cs > Pe of aw . be ie bed od . . 2 pop 8 2 8 4 3.8 Do Bg a" 6 ee a . © ; ae 8D a 3 43 HM & DO :

P he a) co 6 , bo 4, C3 rv, Os; % ro @ uw aa : SS a) © 2 ity te 5 4 oo cD . 6 8 BP oO# BOO ae ms ~ mS a © yeh DG & ™ wt OG 4 oi wn OO oo Ss ' % = AN a OO s og od oi a MM Eg 43 : ® » . ¢ { 3 % % oa a6 th = C3 ee $f 2 GS : a oe aa Le wp ia ES ; . ma i - e z in 4 es So de i. Sh iS ri wo od @) a os i. < o 3 my a O er ~ : 43 ved wd 6 a) < ne a i we c oan wd Po Ty. v B a 4 . . r . ; ret oo 4 : : wo I of ni rae Che, fy sa oe) $e a .¥ cD 43 rst > oe o : me. G al & a : cee a : fe 1 , ® J i HE ao aS O:

" 3 Of OB mm " a Oo 3 oS a - a '@ a Me op ti ogg go «ws % oe . De oe om om a os oe ' eB aa o on ws "6 od rd > foes o o os ay a4 oo Ls red 4 4 3 4 ce 8 ~ weep "e4 ' ey oe % os it CG eyed oy "4 + nga « oe ms} oF Sey « t- "ch Oy @ ee 4 hea vot bo fe 8 Big oD:

ved " WY o n hd 6 cd 9 ew OE * 4 c i bea 3 o oni , Se HG B_ 00 €2) wh me os nn ne oe + BO ge gg Ro C Boy ro oh SEM "4 3 ) a 4 « Q) iL 3 vag ey a Q eR MS Co : i : % a sd . ay sped o 4 6 he / oO ; fo " "> " aa ct rast ' 3 . a seh 2 cf a "3 ve " Qh, nw 3 & ee. a a ri Oo A dS O° & '®t Boe dg - Mo Eh OR BO op a 3 a ~ & 8 SS 8 @ Go Be

" 4 3 OA ort nf QB BO BK i Dh eho 4 ae n eg a) ; . C " : us 4 65 cs eg tel : be 3 ; S 2 8 Bb #8 Oy we BB Be € § 6G HO Che $4 @ fas ' c 3 O re G & e o "3 Cy et Cho SB a uy te mS. oy i - 4} a ele ag al £5 os a e D Ch id rye "f. a bed 4 44 NS oe Fey ao iS ti ved gS ao @ es 2 43 wh z QO fe ee co 3 Go oo yy Se os fe < O Mo as M4 Py gy ee O BS we o a O S oh & O "G pe '4 $4 She 3 oO Q c a ha ot % " a m e a ond by O° By + ss g} © i) Ao iD 'i © " ws i] 4, 5 : a be me OD ord 4 2 ' wv a : C yood, ' MM eae a i @ Me ay . 6% a. ag CopAsts BO ka w "i . os + nl e eed 2 te) 33 i @ 44 Oo apd ui : . rn rl + 4A y + = ings bap: 0 vO woe es wd oO é 4 é oy wD wv ye o «4: ea 4a ma « b ; to 3 > Me ot } 4 ee es : : : x o 2 ad 3 ont (3 ost G3 iB $4 ed i ad ws rm wa rey ce " + a " : 3 4} ' © uf G ed bf 4 "4 OQ w en <> 1s At rpg ae Psy 5 mH "s o m " oy oy ~ 4b s er C " 4 wD go 2 @ bt 4 p @ ' a ge a Bow Dy Go om OG a m Og om & r pe 43° of " Ped zed : = a FL, 4 ths cas uv @ ed o wd @ ot . ;

Gy cl Tg % fw i . f | apt teh ~ rj : a a " S. 3 Boe OF Bm G. Do et ef 2 ee AR got 4A DH i " Boy 5 r : : a - 4. ye uo 4 a vi { at CF 4 a oS sof os es v wd "ait a - oa co ha vs A go wc 3 Pt "| 0 ee a 8 o @ mg 3 ey " & oO LI 3 . as <4 o a w 3 A gS SO Mog 8 2 ut Boo 2 & oo 4g sy ye ae rs 5 ~ ct MM 4 3 5 8 € «a 8 @ ~ og" By, 8 ma 5 5 rn ey ae sire . 44 : mt Lo mn or a ee Qh 2 OF oO Ss n 4d os 4 ~ no & eo @ 6 os Q Bo; O @ 'e 2 mest Re Gy 3 ge Oo ee) Oo. 7 % bt < fa, toe * Me veq se "3 a ot i * AS x a .

ha Med ie) Ch ees:

Woo el, em hGH te a a ye is cS ao © m4 Oy, i cha as 4B os mo @ 6 4d Dy ths Leet weed ict) hed $3. oO 4 32 a x a) at ie Se "ch K D os a = 3) SO oe cot " cod "y ot . cs fo 4 9 8 o wD i ws 4 a fs «6 Gd 4 . ee 4 S co @ wy a 3 A > é 4 Gg o 2 8 > Oe u : - bl CO : © , c c ee t » OO 5 a GOR wv p © Og ars 6% a & eo. & 3 M Roe mn & 4 , Bo - 6 Pe ao Se fs "4 : © u a Q we Set 43 % " mat 2 o 4 re eyo i am 'i vot a, © a) os ge rho ed me ED 8 Go o€ eo 8 Qa * Om % 5, Oe B « O os Cs $3 od 4 om * : mp 0. _. 1 | ved ess 5 iD O . Co C5 63 ord oO wo 4 oS es s <4 od 4 . a .

ad ed 3 vars on c QD uy x4 ee * a " orf oO :

an wy a a Ud Lt et 4 * : 3 e me thd of "cs ed : con : 3 i os ' ; 2 3 c3 an a a sy w u ao" re G 8 a ~ 5 oS Os s ° 9 Qo. sed BS + GB , Qo fet & i 44 . S 8 c 5 " oO © 3 A an o Oo 6B oa © oS 8 mH Se ih ' a a a i 4 ity So ae v4 rq Cd > & ry by 2 -. ay . 43 wo ved $ Od oe A ~ . i oS ae eS 'J a ar a 4 8 te a » & ® n go G A week Pay « eo os ret a "2 3D i OD f- 2 1. G fet god 43 o vt vk re ve 1 3 CD Cha . . tbe ". u ' o a hed eo 4 aa} @ 4 4 4 ne 12 4 a feo ch t Q 3 zo ae mS yd es of @ ct . 2 as Be yh OO ' 0) G ha _P rece 4 a . oA J Q G e 3 aS u ey on > ob aoa o te nD if po be wv ' @ w . eo FD w a4 es a 3 ne a Q, o Ss o fo mn pon mn 8 eee Ry ee K oo % 43 io ® to ( ue 4. w® G Os o G ea os ab . OM t ; ~ * 0 Q Os eg po & : SOE Bos « ip of 4 w weet Qo. a a . iG res a3 NA eS wl 4) i 4 ty 2 w ' app $. i ct - oy ; by ba , el

3) ay a a M4 sed ian Oe 4 a a . cD @ 4 «3 6) 4 a} Oy wi i ve a ec '. ~ 2 GO ok 0 . fe Meet a ve m3 a 4 ed Me at ord ws a Pd * go OS vet iff a <P DB © u 44 iD a OR oY oo 8 a & e ep 8 oo oO mo ts a8 o is Oe OG r3 oO, & 2 MeO a OR r , O. % ws ae Oo 2 CO fs & a a ® 5 4 eh it ot wm ne ae 4 is) I is ne a é G hs a °C} Gh 3 tsa a 1 by a3 eG a O Me io ae » @ "A 4 oe cS . o i 44 rt ayef ed 3 v 4 : 43 ~ 4% cee gt is 3 rr as} = ee ped peed "be th i) @ ~ £f3 gt Ww Be, MM ' ® G D sx ef, ° 2, a a 73 . ved ne oa yD id 19 og ot ma a 025 og 4 ret 43 - iD es : re 4 on . ra a > @ wd fi ¢ $8) 2 > O ee, ay ok t3 Q : 4 iH bet re) 0% eg we Ms ; oy cd Sa e iG 3 ag ne ard * : ite) a S eg wy eB 4 v ' Bt be us O ua ; ia my 5 :

A 4 i % 5} omy, i oseed . aa 1 4a ig Oy : 3 a 4 o eo! 43 v4 : 4 q) + + ro) "pon : GS wy ~, Ab. set im "Ch . it hs 4 cd gh 4 Ww Ly . o fa} aged mt Ry ip of geod © Ne iC Cy oS QD 2 a ' a an be 44 3 4 Bo 43 19) : cn O Aa, o As 2 3 6 © oO re $3 u 16 srt I kak gate TAF wk ed we

i) wv Ta mye OL oh ord rt @ ea ar] She ver ct aged fu thd O Q spd th ed 2 ed LS C2 > the amount of pay, pension, revising .

gratuity, ete 2 commuted pension;

of amount total xecovery of Rs.31,408/-.

in resulting id bed ap 44 amt Nat et Eee Pas 'aah on s m "et Q 4d re QD "3 at £e) $4 Reward Be dae AR afc).

@ J 45 iy apd! 4 45 So Lend oo o ord ced) te vy @ $4 ied el oy Py "9 (a ot i tet W 3 eged yet ct we @ Ba cs

39) Pe dan.

4 wy 1% oo ou 8 wo. GM HD HB SB Sou ® i @ op ed @ i co OG 3 we i my 2 3 > fe } a v mS a a aoe . ot & We "ZS oO "4 a] od ho wd Sha 4 ri fi "4 a set 3 ct uo . 3 4 re XX « ; - o 3 ot at Z wy ot o 8 & cd it O oO aA we Ms & i} ct b> re % * veh * s. age NY ed Go tt " re a 4 te ¥ on ed wi on, sed 4 A" eet ed wn . " Pa apd Ht S 2 So, t) iB o4 oO rod i OY "4 i 4 5 co 3 Lo ip Sd us _ ad vel t, 3 hg 3 SS + 7 Me A = © ee wo Bh 2 9 & ; 8 Ot of Bo tH Ce FS an er | ba "% * + -- , ae < < : a he . ff & @ tt «3 on the a) aD es @ ro AO u @ y go: wD Sa a £3 ord w S é oo et 'a wo 5 ms C3 ted cf bel ae iy th Pal 4 An ' oo. ip byt . g a) . jc o vd 12 > Gs O ae OD oo @ mB ng ae ~ Oy ti wy ce ca cl et 43 be a o io a 'p z ce iy Pa p a £3 ca a Ad 3 ; of pg 2h? $4 is) a ron] a sy . : 5 wD pt 44 ns $3 UG Yd Ht 2 O § TH QM. 7 uy ay © rhea Bs ' tL ed , . ba O mi tet OQ 7 o a5 : ' : 423 33 % "ot Dp 1G & ted _ Ms ra} aa Py 23 ny C4 . D G4 ay "4 Ao GG So. 7 Oy ek 43 ° rd £25 . uy OG mo o 5 +8 3 : wo GH Q A yp % ; 5 i, : . ; a : "ek - hi oe ' . é ct te va tf 2 lw a 4 wo "4 3 cE % © 0 a W 3 * mt © a ae rd ch QO BM - 4 8 eg et ie a oe) "3 ee "me i vad ned i 0B S45 cy i tong Oh c tJ 4 ey $4 oe Co 4 got £3 y hd i Co O tia vel 3 ' " O & we C3 Co] 4 TDs nt oN Ma ay ae -e4 } M4 ced 4 . 4 'O o C3 ™ £O} te c we u 4 haf AS : 4- o rz if © uy 4 oA . @ 4 ot & a is Oo ry a tbs £43 a Pes fe ON as * fs Moet od - S C fc cs a) wi t wn re ; t et { ' . uy 3 4 3 te ra bo bo woe 8 eo ge Ba cp Ma wo OS . " @ wv 4 cp a et % o c m ®t ah ' te ; cg 4 dt ON ' Ad 43 a Ad D oe aa wt ' ith wy he bes 4 a G ry c eS 4 : red ot mS Co Ga ay 43 ref et Ww "tS % ° O . vend ri ° 4 we wo , MoS _ 4} Mary ior . cl wd. OO OL UA m4 ut rol Oo. v a i co. eS ot a eo Sed 3 4 . 4 be o on a oO Sef bos "3 a G BO ow w 3 ta m8 wp © "yy O 44 O ~ re) he4 MY ' fo . @ * SS ans et {3 5 e ny o im O } ad A ~ # Eg ped 2 * od © ' Oo. . £2 O oo x 2 co ma 3 ae) nt + ae e 4 4c ch & «i Q 5 in sd a (i { Ce Ch - rt vo ee 4 {fy . a aH rd - ed fs 5 a + ™ poo el S 5} , ch e 3 Co i @ cs yo wy oS 0 . oo B . ed 5 a oc = 2 . Q o 6 gb 4 & © eo GC eG 2 OC el 8 GO a m @ Oo ~ £9 © © BB q ' ist QB ord [o- + Lo its) ry C3 wv As he eed al 2 : " v4 GM en . " 5 e666 6U!lUUCUE OD v4 a me by ork ® + A, vet bean 4. aa ty os RB od oy o hy 43 : uy we aged a gd a G ws as ' ig ie ' 3 ! ~ "4 ' ne w a Bed o ot ae i> ef BS to wo eo DO MoO " boo mi MM i oe Oe > rd i oH ord Yet 3 @ de Ae ° . 7 s 201 is 7 a OA No. 20 ae G on ie w@ . ~ © cA Ma QO $4 oO 43 Ae " ny @ @ KE, a ur . | "y Ba un wy 43 aa) send 64 * of uy Ad ae eet ad a3 hy 4 4 . "4 3 ry wy £3 {4 b> ix Sew é 3 O cS $3 QD be 3 : . , i " 4 os wn 43 4) oy " o3 ad 3 me, KS ved gE ©) a S £3 & rise 6 _ wo 4 + i) of x f a re we a tf + 65 - ut et & 4 $+ wt 2 f 3 3 YY *, oy . Ch o> & OG Ow ~ as " & om th Oe i nn . 4 CH 4 7 gt vyet me O fd on nm he La 4.4 ut 3 Dy ' . aM 4 - vA hed CR 54 . . x a a ka a, an re i > : " (he "4 be wy o a ; "3 ef, a os wy . nd ct a bt BM we 8 | 9 a Cog wo sg Bo a Ms @ Bp 6g 4 (8 oe Od Mo Bg Q oa i Sy 4 ct 2) €: [oO Ha og pe 4 a Oo Be Bed is: «c ed 7 re bd ie) ry g Ch o A ae es "

oe a c K ec ot te 64 " B bE ~ us e oy Y . 13 43 Be OG fed 4 Go ved ' bt a 3 _ Os st eo GO a 44 uy es @ © i ct > > hey 4 xed hs es a 2 se 0 & MM & wD a 4 "4 aS mo 4 : my - <4 Le % "a ord - Og ' 4 '4 "es Oo O04 ra eS oe Met . i 3 3 N iff 0 ns 4 ' my ot BY OM 8p zs # f Oy BO iy a AS 4 Me 3 " t MN = 4 is Le es * ad v ny D CB Ns we B 5 8S anes . Q BoM SO iS) Ssh Oe Ts ed "3 ae . OG 2 "5 > "3 @ BY 8 go oe my BP eB eo ow BR foe 0 "

G % 2 . 3 ed mt is ; iG ee ; . cs) hs ae ke QO ne G 'i i a So bo £ od e oN 3 $4 B 43 a Ba a Oo o as 3 wd "4 i @

- QD $ | ' ha ' @ rs G s ae) "ed ee cd a 13 Se os Lo " oD oe f fy % , 3 aa aged aw : 43 cS £ go. 4 a 8 oo a :

Sed 4 th C3 ws eo Be " £3 . peed ip ae' i w an Ad 4 E " £ . = ~, { ; 2D cod me ah if.

44 os st | : ~ "4 re oy nyel ob. . ap aw cm i? Cj $4 4-4 et qt C3 vo od ah wht hy wt j ré2) h oy eo G -} ox xed 3 a wa Baa Ce. wm eae 4 iy se 5 3 the} wf od haa E+ 3 rd ee so 2 a Og MY ee cp UM 4s ri 4 rh Z . a me ay tat 43 cs A? iD ba ~e} eo 0 G > ated o i rey ! rh vr @ ~ cH : ~ med ng 43 oy x Pans Nt ira we 4 * 4 f - (2 er > red wa vet e ' aid td @ cd . e ~ ay a oy, J J ord, im Qs ¢$3 cs) CBY i j ® | a ri ' et EE Bo cw om Yet GE as SS os ao % 2 O 6 8 es a: % 63 ex! anf MA O or eC a) m Y bs oy ey oO "rd (3 rd st es OG Qa ' ' mt 4 A @ So " ~ " gS mn g Pt KG, u 43 oe vf od $4 a 4 "17 th. be i 3 "fs "3 " "v4 3 Oh * rt if £3 mo i} © i ay TF) 43 4d md ot 42 webs Os on a 3 « ' "3 Be ai rd ci ua: z . gS ha oy is 4 GO a 9 7 ha © oO O gS S is: 0 ie oO GB w e: By "ne iB Ou vy rt i 43 8) ) aN t3- ro rf mG & AG et mn CG ft 4 OA "4 'f.

we end ood @ ¥& 43 topo

i) au a «ag w @ O . ocd ' Oo ip or aheg pt arte of <3 or et O Sg ap | w yh E-4 CE 4 cae) "

Cod ao "< rd a G ao 3 aed io O2 i th]

4.3 aS ka i gt sna ef 43 ard '4 7 ee ed 3 ot "y AN TAY MA oe ® sed and ng 3 s re 7 * x Me ea 4 A 4 4.5 i > o> Ot a OA Ne.2hl ra o% 43 ro oR g Doe x bend uF yee. . 5 oe ts Y ee D z z o BOR @ "

iW 3 of ~ o $e . 5 ; ~ a . 3 ed is fi os fa a e ie "3 orf % a B wy ° 3 3 G Py os Bo hs "rt a oO Ht agy Oo Be q MB yp Ort rd og 6 o " To & . 8 Fe oo 8 Bo ct ot jet Sh 0 * fF t "sy is) 8 rea o soot a cof a3 hs - rm 43 4 Su3 o he i uw od oO sD ti G ; ane B 8 . :

a cK a3 Ay fa sy As ths ws ~ be a "4 es wh O tn oS ts ry , ¢ fe . Sy TS ie "4 ay G Oy os 3 mi O 23 m4 me uy e : 6 m ed "sf at at a Ci bi rps a4 us § "rf OO " c) it q) fis or} rp ed ct og Ug m go ® > B . = i B 4 . 4 "en an $3 os os "3 Oo . @ we og . & GS &8 4 » 2 Go fg 8% " ge } bey r aed w ; eo ns . a thy § . . D nt ny i : i g ig i 2 G hy tes we WD G Q a : 8 ms aD = $4 » 4 f i oO $4 o i 43 Oy 2, fy ba 4 , a ved ay E 4 yd v3 : " 74 a 3 o my Q bes oe te oN By Q A a we @ ad ~ gz a vt a re ty wy Sel Lo he mn g " 3 # wd we G £3 ra © mH 4 cs 0) mt : 5 4a * ~ 8 oa os ct OQ > i rf re ca g € va 5% t | a a3 a4 f.2 3-4 Ls se} ed ny sed e Cy: ea g @ bys i whed & ci C Ae ape +e , 4 oe aed ad a 43 C a ec 43 sy . a OS ¢ w e 6 # i in @ wy fe . rea a oe Py By & ie " 3 bas & gE a fa s » mt a a , % : gi yy dio ae ms wp a 8 oy voy } 4d bh o 4 ns an ba a ' ify eo eof ¥? ed 1 Jf a . in a % "rt MO G bs a 1G sy vet Ps 6 6 G 3, © ; CF ao a uy x nce! Qo Hi wb mS mn 4 & ~ Q wd a O ae < & rf oO a . @ wf tH a 4 gO OG SB 8B fg 8 FZ £m» ®& ts 0 9 2 @ . 2 . a = B 8 8 wy g wu ea bs x "4 cS Me eo OS g o © 4) a q . o OG t rT eo se 54] "rf a ve x : 5a Pi i Oo ' Xs : o +S am tes ee re ; a a ce (4 se - Se ey Cs 4 43 i re "

wg is oO es wo "A 4 gy i oo "4 oo th . ay x wed B re oN ee or} be ee @ <i Son iy ct i vt 0G at 5 " a @ C} Lo ¥ iy it "rt te = ae we be te rf i ' wo tis) ef * " a ~ ? wl . > , w ved : 5 Go H wn 44 oe 3 64 oR in tr Sn mrs "A "3 % 8 Go we © G3 . Bo i> 5 je Et 43 a by w" 3 tnt vf G SA Oh M4 ra 4 rd oO } Ae ire "Th Ces VQ £3 ~ crf a * ca rg a GO oe « 2 A 86 3 a ot z «s OQ ® sg rs B a "hot rd Og 2B 3 £3, GS > A ped Q 4 --s, rf Ch ¢ 3 hh geod Q 2, & 43 ty Neape de ae ! 18] '4 4 ; i Lf a : P a 5 6 oy - e ) yp wo 4 hy C3 thee AS "| is a a vel mt SO uy te rd Oo Dy © hf © ay roe cy £3 oy 2) + a4 hy wed ry uy 4 uy ct "a we nH C3 + a dG 3 0 & ms aw gs v ip o GO BO a ® OG if | 6 OO of. a 3 $3 uy hve e 4 . eyed Go C3 OA NG.

gt oA ved 2 hee Bp wy wy + > oy mH om] sod O ¥ a M4 yp i "

aS a te ree) iG fot ow Hy G f iXa he o

a) ee a xa ran aged et 3 3 wr a ig ed id $4 ek "4 4 g hs is) weed a4 A cay cD oo gM oF oy 14 at Cd rN AL at or MRS mas end ig xe} 7 tt a ner bh Court of ig.

#H sc 460 decided on Chandi Prasad Unniyali (7) 5 civil Appeal No.3500 of 2006 decided on © aS jab and Haryana and others Vs. Jagdev Singh and others Vs. State of Uttarakhand and others 99.07.2016 45 reported in gp 2012 Pun Ln .

ort wy ek

2) > gt eed oe bee ved .

"

Fang ie c ay be if a} 4 if} HH Y A oe e ae' ¥ State of Punjab and others Vs. Raft (White Washer), = OF case.

Masih ted 43 re fed vet ge 3 io mG , EA Ve $4 44 wy oe 5 wh oD : . i> 4 oO S ws Sb ES

8) a 4 "3 w 4 eo gy i oO ™ oe Oo as oF it ea toy ig : a ae Sh 33 od G3 a 44 ke ob u% os a M4 bed 43 ds ~ a mM ah ao, Ne b om i ce hu 4d i a oy Se oy pany ey ax 3 a Yas, ry oot ea ee = vend ves ht iS . one o m3 os a ; t i : . ey 4G dy @ oO . Ds @ © OQ 6 a re an 4 ra Og ith ; co ort 4 co a & Uy vet YO c's a i v3 3 mn Bo tp vd ve = t ' oy : ord & fo Mg cs oy ge a mY SP oo @ wf Th aged ody cnt os a aot eo ref 3 4 rol pkey 43 «3 oO @ £ is cs . & cs w a Fes 4 wa Oy oo 4 * ay yo MO OO w So Bo™ ms GM .

"rd ae at "~ th a) AR they qi # rd + Sox ise) 5 "5 4, My " Se wes ce tet ct 4 1 *s 44 vet a " Tr q) 5 of os Oo ; o ww "es ry "4 arf Bot " e bs a ont B 43 ba : ia HS, ; m (cs ° poe oe £ "8% ¢ 8 e Bog oo 4 SG . ae Sa keg " é 2 4 * ed At $2 Oo. 6 Be a s) : , ' wv " . cS . * Soy 6. 4 Q es iH v @ ws ip . wt "4 @ e me o. by, * Qed ¢ ce wn . ' ed ¢ 4d tr oa 2 AR ws . ' ay ka a4 oF} wo 43 . 'D 4 ao C3 rat eas s wy K 3 Ls Oo aye w oO Ct fet AS i193 At { 4 ret a 2 o- cart * '4 thet en es in cs e oa ral ~ a a * 5 CG As 44 ted A eS « 3 MS @ nS ot : u Ly '3 'ts 43 3 re 4) © 2 Ud cs eg a Go 4 Ot Qo a) B vee £ A eee i. . ee 3 . i '. au ed i. they - to Co "eh i ~ Do * wh ee wo gD poy Bt DS @ CG pp a 3 Ht 2 6) " rn i iD i. ye r Dp a . WG sol 5 ied 6:4 wh el a o #4 + 0 4 i KG " 4 a ie a r ; ea 4 aod rd Pe 'y £43 as at ay 5 ' 4 wD ; tu "4 ued $4 os LS it O . 8S ce a fe, 44 @ a A a se oO ad - + 5 S ¢ ~ ; g Gg DY ; iB 4D a Sa @ + o : Le aed ¥ y " a . aes "

uy Oa a bo 4 , i , pa ge: +5 ted * fs cor 3 3 ei a ra et Ad kes md a th os ket ms @ itt vind het rot iG uw a) : ce ms vy * & wef 4 a ray m uf @ = re %, 3 "e 6 a hos es $3 a css , @ ; @ * gC "a + *, tp vad Ba ae es G , by oth t) 4} wy oo AS «3 44 the be, i yi ; 3 } eee a 4 . LS 4 G . rs a ih «5 + oe , ra ¢ Gs bt 4 Aaa % 3 © O , cs id ae fe ce 9 Ss we es we ag BO a . v4 Lg 4 uf i> 43 G2, o = "v4 me © O oe i cS G st co ty oy 3 ca) <e) @ bed bet Pa me OD ; os wd wo cs) re w ol 4! a & g me Ag ie Th gd Os 4 fe > 10) ft ce 43 AS - t a 44 e 6 $4 a O ks a By @ os os 4} ke ge 4 ' eo 8s gg eo os o oa §F @ GF Oo aw Ot 4 4 . CG YE Dp i Oo ' rat Oe 'ed " Go : os o v it a £3 w fa 03 a s Ba % @ cs M4 Ba oe uF OM 4 Ba '5 iw 3 eed bi ec pet od Pm, iC Qu by 5 be AD 3 oss fa 28) 3 ~ Boob adations ve ' OA No upg na oO 9 . BG "~~ ® : «st --e a oy. * 4 43 ve a sy * ' re be a SS Go 4 Oo i r eB wD wo ey w a G4 ged a em ® a 4 mn oe & a ns "Be sa ut 2) 5 3 : Gd wD Ls dd rt 4 o 6 ~~ Ot B 457 a oP ode 6 72 mn ee 43 4 ® ; A BM 4 ( 5 Ae w oe -- : - aa @. : ne kD @ ca tS ok cn © ved w ot m He a O ad ot erm [on : vit ae & @ Sq (s 8 Cha . ved bes oO : a , xe, O Sed "eg: , FP es a fis] . vd ee : B68 Pr Oy, ~ go 2g oe | ae 4 res Hes & oy a : ™ MO " _ ved "et Sh £ 1% ae ot wd a + i} v4 43 uM 1 Ot oy oS a) ip 2 4. rt aad f saa a : A % ae ia x4 ' . G Oo " :

we € © 6 6 % GB yo & « 7 - 2 8 a cs * a C3, word , . ' "3 ga Gh . ro tt Oy Co ip 4 we uy in me ia a = y BS 3 oO o gs ® es 3 3

0) no @ ve He ved C Q ce 43 a 4 » et a os "ed oe w ba rd +3 a O 0 co Fe a : oe w@ gD agg ; , mgd eo GO is 5 ?d @ 8.

riya wef st : $3 os ry & a a " a * ae on bes *z oD D my pod ned - 44 bed bed . is 2 : . go - o fel. / J 2s we, 4 Ss 4 ced ey ip 9 w Ch om rd xt it ih @ it a 13 " % Hel Ss wy oe, 4 ed, rt Bh m a iis: " 6 | ~ : 9 e "ed & 42 i : ey mm os 4 a>. hoy 5 a . e th po Sy re bi yh an co wed tied gat ' 42 \ iN ard hi "

ar fox? eg a : $) Q) re bey on "4 t o. . , : a : is p a < os oe De © to o ie as eS 3 4 fe 4 a % Dh O i. ass) go 3 10 ot - : Q q 13 o + o p- G 4 "

Bay % aged pee ie 43 ~ i we . - 38 6 2 a7 4 Be 8 ek 8 > a BS . nm iB & u 45 3 G i} bj. ' ee @ a) yd : ao ax ¢ oe "S he ae a " uD sod rd al oC gs ia : 4 vhs 4 by a me CS oF Bo a : © a on weed ©. w Qo ' ' D oy « " o D. go @ no , sn OR a a = Cos SO fy ot Rei cog OG "4 CN t ie rH % iy "B ct Quy 4 @ e 5 to s Mm © @ 43 * " ry ay ca : hs es as sent O "5 o vate 4 Roe a BM oe m BO Om BG Mga A + Bo oe Cc we : c - wet yy : 2 $3 Yt ied ~ ay geod aed ' 44 re ved it

8. 8 ogy ® GH ee D Hoy G8 g¢ PB | ' . Po ay 4 ;. oO g . & oo. AD he 44 "1 Py , " ~ mm : | 44 -- o : 3 4 cpt oO Oh ved Q w ™ ' ea " 3 & hy aon mn q Wo: a '4 fy ed od ae ay Go a | Oy « Do oo & Ci w SE a gy I, BY eo ed @ my gs Oo rg Aha tet AB me a BS Oo aed a 3 ~ a ort yo Ad cf $d * wegen id . = gS wes ry . Ch wer} oe i y q " 0 ei ub wu? me poe m . Oo -~ tt) & Bs Py : oe . a YQ o ih 2. oO 8 wos 5 4 ie 2 | uF + o e. i. Cog od UB el Ul Sl DB BS Oo om Ba 8 Bod "4 Go a Go $s LO a " : :

2 3 201 3

a fo 2 E197 N * OA Col.

SA oh S Map B.J.Akkara fratd.) , 6 rs) vee CS ee ord 6 ved On Oo os A wet cd Fete nes Ra ke i A a mm ;

bw, en > wm 4 he oe ake

-AYr TAS Oe a Aad und $3 ped tv o on Aes wd v Q wy 5 2 | Saitai) ¥ reWwaT 4 Menber (Administrative) -

a & Bh + e (Dy i

--~ ¢ e :

Decision ie

8.

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai

Helen E Joseph vs M/O Defence on 24 September, 2019