Gujarat High Court
SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION/10583/2009 on 8 March, 2010
Author: S.J.Mukhopadhaya
Bench: S.J.Mukhopadhaya
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?ai ?8?, ?P Q!?B?=?v? &* ? A @??`???S??+k? :> ?? ?E?Sj&?C(b?K _T?h?/GP|? ???xRHNp?j? ??!???8???u? 2??d U? ? 5??0?1? ?Ox6}0?w &?|?QC? ?pm>:`R???? ??j? u?J?? ? ?? ? ? ?????*????TY?M??j?|7 ( ?U?@K?e ?| 0/? bF ??v 9'?�?O?????=b[??C?\6?? |, [?N??? a?+O? ?N6.?/??p\ vB OZu ?ua????!y?? / ?}\?2?~\C?~ $u v? ???????[ia??N}?F??F? ?wi ?*?U4??'rs (??= ?P(???;?l\e??P?
)W*? ?`Ci?xD? ?? ??G?w? ?_ ? Y<]? ?5?? }<3X$?y? ???? ???C ?? ???7)?/^ ?M???[???_??T?F-???? ?O??}???/8 G d? ???#?/)-< ."?R ???+)=K G??}x Nt??v?A???n?ow???_??]"BF]8L???{??dc ?a?!??�? ???? R ????6???MU; uQja?2d|?.??)T?oz??C?f?a????5?? py??^?? ?G? ???v? ?v???m??????* g??l??.?m?O o`?
? ?/n_:E ?}?lo]T??
?V v et?n{[?o7x? ?}�a??-?R??X?fc?ro? ???????xlMY(???y???m?x?x?0??>?{??I?(?]?�PH3??? JK9 k? ?bw??z??? ??? ?s?[,?E"i?"U??4"??? ?9???? 'Z???*W??! ?>7Suo???c(e5 QA|}Jqz??C ?????3?t? ?}?M??0? ?"? ??? 8 ? ? ~????A? P?/d$ ?\C? J?�?Co@ q???2"0k??Ax???r"M{B x?p?F?? ? ???97i???? ~?F ? ?3?B ?J ?t? ?Y?VT?W(%???? ??|???w? g??i?1#?c?< ??J ?e? g? ?h?? "'" rn #?(9??SLY ? ??~|??` T:?U?z?,Q? 2?F?` ? ?_~^??g ? ?3dD9?K?1:?+T$e?3JK?? ?1 ?c?9?4f?@?????(?[ s,?]?` ?,? boC ? % ? ?IW??@8?N???-1z? ??}?g? ?:?n??? ???oU? 4???e?? qh ? ?M* *?a?nf???iS??x ?4 ??????#U ??4o???N?? U?9?.1?FMQ??bn???|??A?H???z??1RZ0??P??????}?????Xq????;+o4R? ??w ??-??? ?)??f???????>9??>??0g? ?Fs???5 *?O;??i?Os? ry??? h`?@??R??xc)??t?6?u37U?. Pt? ?z???O?o= j.???Ut9 ? p?C?l? k?d?r?'ew??q?5* V?? w???O????? ?f?P???:gE?g???b??I?
OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 das 2010-03-09T17:42:59 1 PT0S PK � � �?ai<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png?zeT v&.?`??% 4?C8?{ @p????? ??? ? .?]? w{{o?;w? 5?? ???uk?O?B? $?!| ?VZ? ?
]Qq/AA13I Us?8?Dl"?????e??? ?
!'? )q2? S?GI? ?N????>???a 9 ? ? * ?M?A ????? ?Q? ? ? }?mj?? eG 333??L??1?]???xJ??Z[??$[7?.jh ??;???A U,K{BEo7? I?\6?[.?d? *?? ??f???Y? ? ??(????c+m:? [V7%?/?r7n<)?'??e ?=?Vv?~????"???]??t?u??&d? ??/??LHy?#?K+???Q?\? }???d???? w??-?~?` ?~?????? ???c? S?,NQ?P \ ?}y???L ?V?& ????V?T?UG{??????? ???;??`#???YF?2$??^??="]}?? Bd????u ?N??_?? +?hR??=?-g????? ?dYh ??n ?? aH8 C\?M4?8??:=S ??8)o\?Q ~?4n?I??m???v?~?=? ?K??}??N????J??? ?? ?E. ?�???6?,? ???o?^ 0y u6?? ??(?6db? ?!??????G??? {?B?D?C?5?(????-? ??C? ? W?=?k?'_CH?2 G???c??+?@ ?yo? ? ???9 R? ?gx??? ?O??s>DG??z w1?????0 ???|?a?C????? ??_X\wSR4|??k???? ?t ??9?? M;
9n??eJ?f`?8? ?R?;?????]&.-?s?D?? ce[ S????E??%?F?? ?hHA< &? ??%IM ????t???G?W?_??X? ??< A?? ?~7? n+][??|v??d?|X9 [?? ???\?*~?|@ ? ?9?0?5??x:� 7wh?y?? ??R?J? M??lJ?h??(????e +?[???? i? ???q_?W?kzv???R? xEp?{??$? ???????]? x?? ?? ???i6JJ?{ cP4??II2?? %(? ?V???]?C4zXB? R O!??C ??M ?A??? ?c? = ?)?[? ?)V ll?D??:?7 ?_? ??IY? ??L?F???p?R??v? x7?#?c???O?^??`?g:?m?? ???? t ?n [?c?gN/?? ? d r?a3??b??2?o?k?x'?U 9?B?Q2M C?|??5ymL?G ??J#?k ?j??m???? ?(ej?? @aN? ?h�? xf?O?? ??Q?^=?Q? ?4?? 3??D45?? ,?__f[???z`?@??G"]?5?MD?n?k>IE[?????Ad??2?V? `? ???? ????i]Kz?8:O_ ?, E^w??m???P;?e?P`?? ??k?? [?,T1h?z??x?fq%i?G????4-"?>Y^u�? o?t?k?? | ????&??z??/ ]? ? ?p? ?\lt??-?m!? ?@??/\A?)sb?I?Mmy ? -? MOe5)????H??^? _??????s????
? ??gc[? I ?,??t???`J cF?8?e???) ?T%??hYz? ?R{???O??po?~2} Aj4x�_?v???/G?\ 4 ?< N??? ) a??{??6?Kg??@q? E? V??w? ??nB?+??>P?n???+.K?V]H??
?R*:?????3W \??6?j?&??(?h?????t=E? ??? "C??? ???~?3K ?u9?f???T?
??.??F???
gFY\ ???~ ?vCDU]?+ M? T?=???????'0?2 ?-o5Y4 ?Y?3cf j? ?[??? -?=??hu:??U ?W?c?C?e ? ?\aT`yL??4D8?k??W?u???o???? ?,?? |I!?U A#Ic???(?1?#r?amI?Ae ?# M,X?)?? ?b? 9E?c?6 ??!= ?D'X ?g*?;.xS?.c?]We?(Zp ????=3, j:0n )??:?v??? ? ?N Ad??*?Q ^??z~q '1 ?????6??(?? ? :" ($`?g]? ??,?d?? I?!Au�! )> k Y+>??6Xff|Y?J ?A?O??-03o?EE# ?V??? ??�~]r??? ????pV?G!x> ? ?`??4A5"'? ?&J_YWB??H?qh ? ?? ??M?
p??g??? ?F?^?]n?w?? ??U ????S%O?
?9,oT?=???I?tT? ? ?+^??F?wb+MY? ??!H}? ? ?X??
??w?Gej +(0^m???78*?FJ??2~V??s??A ? =?????_?? ?|?eQ?" 8?????w?V1? ? ? 1?KXJZ ?p? ?3?iG$ ??b?pCk?? @?S????>??? @?/? ?IPUx , ? ??( ? .?? 7? ?s?] ?m ??Z?!?-??????
??M p @?`0?S???zr?? p$? " ??s?/??HQ??Y??w? ? ?FHv?ywS !Ad???/? ? W�3M6??rh ?0??"?N?ssK0??;??F ?_?y8?z�??,?J ?
?C??](??d??/ +??V?????N. ? mda?Y*?w?K! ? ? ???^???/C?t ?
s7?{?????,??E�d!?~? e??w??G??? _ u:C??Wy?E$?i ? ?_ KE???y??Q??S1-G?mX0M?P U ?4????$f! ?R ???5ey H-????? ?r?N?? r?? ?c? ?^? ??>?? ??(g????P?i?*?
?e?e V ??6E ??0??
.~?p?????M??? ?? m??>bpU3?-? z i?jgz???I?? dIc*9x?|????{?MpS?F?0?m??Cv?Y?J]?- ???>z ?5?5s?|W% ?Umc}!~????u? ??QN !/7?B?? `>?�?sj???4?4rUx????8? ??k?? ???p'K?? q??>+??4 ?^t?M?9?? ? ??U9 [??E,$F{ ??r)? 1?? ?v?�?tK1b?M7? a?V?N???|?5O??x6 8 ?c?( Xx?S2???>?? P? 'srv ?E?r ?=?]???a??-?g? 6?'???N?=?~?O?6A# >? |b? '??p ?nS??? ??>!?7U G3a? b??? 2? ?t5?H$ ??a%%?? ??X?q??G??�u???N??g87? X C?Qg\7??? #p ?`????P[1 ??w??Ayl?Ny ??uv?q`m??r??e???98???~v?;??%?N??g^?i ? ??>?" w?Q?9????-? ?q? ? ? ???A?4O??y?}???w?m???_X R?8V? ??o???N. o??Br? ??? )??L?1??? ??g????a�gv?U$?7?p?@ ?a??s??m ?H}?A?? F??v??? -h????;??n{???O?^?Z#g?9 ?$F?*??(?8?*?[ u :?????S$?
?Y???1?2?h? ?A???& 7y??M?T q????? ??6 ???O?3l?3EJ,????)?q? ~VN?K?(? ?? As ???R" H?O?L??$? _??? ?>8VN???? ????, ?/ ]ePs-?6E?? DT??- l ?@YO7k??J(??[J *35m??+m? ????s??c(U??? x??( ?\?d? q???N6??< ???7 ?X??(??6>? %i ? Q?]0FF? cE e??~d YZT ?;9???}????V??w? Jsi?D?? V ?B;??g%?P?? ??"?@a6?6Rx??; ? ? ?0b?sJ7 ?
? ~u?? ?
!% ? ?~???? ?Z>?X? 7| ? ?d???? ??/ ?r5 C~?,???Q; )N???b?? .?+?-?u? m?GC??? ?? ? ?x??}?q?L ??$ ??[? B?"? ?t??~???q9??? ??T ?-O?W?? ??!m!?L?r?cb?K??r ?B{ Vb? ?d8?h?I8e ???]?)&}qYH??! O? ;5?hBU?`?}/???"?@|E?A???N??* ?@ O???9?? !?m??? ???^?[]???? ??-???8??q?M ??h??m0?? E??t,?? ?p??t1i?O+?.&A???Y? : ??R[H ?? ??V?0 > G ?x??K ???(K�b?a{Z???Z@C8 x? ?Wwe?c j??�?$?'?z?? =?t 7qo??m ??\W??}? 1? #"E?U} ??V? {??GF? "?? ???,??? i]?1/? ??m"???!*??@}???5 ?a??F[ G?,Nu?|? Q ?I?)B?Q?, F`???)A?/? c?ud? ?6=}R??I??? ?; &Vn?? :???_?zt? ?VU???[=?M??? ??>|?K?vt?t??a; ?? #V?? L0?4???P ? fH{?o?\?&??? "?@?? ?l ?E????&?d ?D? &?[? ?0 ???@D??pY?? ??g??Q H (??gy? ?R @{???+?j?&?*s???, ??? y?6m?Q? ??!????^a90l ?? mE^? ?*??y??? #]?[????_oO?????
_ ??? F?????8i?zB?sF:=g?P#L?�? ?-?? ??? >'9}?>?W0? lcN?1 J??? ?m?`??v?dpzfl??:??? ? 9 ?.?.B?,? ?4??D???Q m?R 1 n ?;?5 $?DI;7??t? {R?i??5??\9 ?|???C?3!??+ ?C?us? K?4 e L[?+???y?1?o&??[BT ;q `?@p????aj??f?c?P??MM6*FPTl*?1xr?,7?+ ? ?` G !?=@ ?| '?@?]?y}?.?t9] ?�>kn?? ?HvA??Ub?g?]?mk ??;???9? +?< ?i????U??&?z`E ?y??V ??^? ?? ?_ E?s???? ]?R?C?? ???-{A?I??? Ge??? �???Lt?Z S????UD?_??;???i??>??? )??? SV _Wg????_d+?G??/?&???? sPy???v?$ ?Mhs/ ???8? ??M?? JO???cd_?c/q� ??d?uM ? n???5??G?3 :?D ?6/W+n.?n?,B?3[??:&R?????.v ?????{ ?DU7?QO6?;Z????f7??d?? ????O {&?aK?j???*?l??? t?e:k?+t???G??t g?!?kO? ?{?A??Xj??s?+???"/5? ? ?o? Z?[?c ?o? ?$ ?? ?/(?f\q?fx ? q ?_ ? ?\????OOR? ??b?2 F?_?R'?? p? ?qwX??: ?R??I]Y 1??YY Ynp? ???l?PX?$? S} 4B .? |?G+q W??y??8B/L$?v\ ?g? ?O?cT(Ez??.????U ? ??Xo?q=y< ???uG?A??$ }>M?v?Z? ?s?jQ??!z?"???T=? ???#? ( ?Ti???#20?s{_CkO?ckGt@o? sE ?-?????? ? ?Z???u!? y ??? e| 0L?? i&??? L???? ?c/jg?y9TY?#?? ?k??ZFW??!?zK ?u??x@ ??
i???S? ? ?F?% H' ?# ?8??._i? ?~y$?&?w?? ??Z ?f?t*x?=?M??:;?6?9?n@??LO?F ? M??h?? $& ?s???q? ???
e ~`?? ? ? < ?*??Y2wv {f?A?#?3)?@; Q?3??z? %?9??$!? # [? ? ??? d ? M?}?\Me??0W????y?? Ll?Q?;?X???@[[ ?|?`4#?J(S? ????? ?' c 7??=TF?Z?=???3?? K?B?E ?yj`??\A?j? )H c??? ??/??? '? ?.?x ????-?Fv !@ ? ?W?T? Y??`?I??N\x=? J;?Q .?> ? M??Os??5? 0QV???2xZ???dD_?v Q_??"?L{?F}1??# L.+7?0?M�A??G'I?, % B?"? ?W ?o?L?Nz??]ZR? ???_??qQEV?[?YV?? 89FX?^]' 38?J ?? ? &?? ??-?=????h?*??# ?? ???????~,??+??i ?lN4e?N?*?? F?+???
? Q?????�?4?T??qT>?>???D.? \V?#?D???4*?
7G?H|??vCE????Do??K?????yf?# ?&??]9?D8???7?\?'???"?1 ?Q??9??? ???? \?sPO l 3iB?5??V u?<; ??'? ??Z ? ? ???Q?8?iF ?M ?N?lmHY ???? ?D??? ?Y?T? Zg?N ?Z? ?? ,Z ??/@L??j8?b? B0?y ? | ?t?? u ?$?: ?A? ??R?p?>\C? ???~??7�p@p?6?ac ??1 ?nR??,i $@??\?s??dE?_9?2?a?5UO ;R?]/1P??J?"?m?? 3?? ?] ?? ?E?CZ?i:??Q "?? ??T????? ??! e ?V ? D ?? !sP??@c??+?Y? \?p1???P�? ??
?Y 9? n ,X?X ?K?? ??v]u?O ???? ?mB?I|?_A? d??3? ?G??V??]? �6 ?r M ?3? A0?C?Q?@- ?J a?? ? `?8KPy?? ???|K7???? y?;(??y`?`A??kP?M? ?8^??5???E?P???Vv?`{p?? ?C2?
?:h6???? ???|? ?? o?]?l ?? &1?}X?`???q????
fO3O>? ?j??4???d???z: }I?OY??J |5? ???E????W:Wq??(bk?r,? ?`?kPv??|Zb??j(?S?'?j??@Ykc??9P?? ???!a_?M! ???y ??qic? ??y?_K q?rr?&O???Aq???z?GK?! # (? ?Ox ? ???[,d?V ??Z??( F~?%. i?IbS???[]???. ? ? ???Y??:=?bf {g;??|? ????????|h??p+Lz??Uf ?P?T!f ? PK ?? e?,��e.��PK � � �?ai<������������ ���settings.xml?Y]s?: }??"?w?G??c :@J/ ?fn???od?G? ??d?$`Rb?S ?????sv??o?????T!?[?zZ?N@? ?bz?=?K?[? ?LB ? ? ?.) ?? z]????7?:?.?1 ?~u?rZ?U*?r???^X?P????????][???*???>?I8?�?ZN??^@? V??O?????W_Y?2?~??g?(? "c?I?` ?? ?|? /????? 6??[=????B{??????My e?.Lt ?e??0??03?CW?.+?a? ?t?{??y?Z- >??|� ? ?fLLAml0F? W?2?b{tDS?\? ? }?? ? ?? ?� l?*???;??r???;??Q?? ?^?Ds??M? ?/?? ?;R?R?Z8?U8?? S,??6 ]IR?]\ L? ??Zc??????e1??H?6?m??? R? m3_? ?~) ?QC??k ?(??9_?M?]??l?_@?? ? ?4i?g$? }&HQ c? &8:O?`?�???&? #???D ??? ? x? ?h ? c -KU?S 0???8?A?}???M-9?%???z? ? _Y;??:?.?K?D? O?? )?z? ?K???- :8ov?6?M?=V??F?1 QGa?B?1?N?C? s??? ]?j??YxQ?t?t-??[yt ?
!P? v?BAz?" ? |+ ? ? ???6 Z?]?6??}A?- ?EN?F ?? y?4;>|? . n?^?W:?? Gu??r{? ??e? S8??????n???~"|??J? ???w?1? ????x 7:?i ?r ?gIKe?/????c+???? ?!F?w???&m????;|D?b?N$?I6??W=aT???-? p~ ??d?q?{?? ?? ??R?0�9??~?,? r+????TA? ?? @G??sv??-Q]6?5 ??)?? it W??tC 5 h?w?U??nl?$1�? ?i ??)??el???J? ?*??? ? ???l9??? ?v ?D[L?? h?{)??:b"?i?? ?`?i/?g?t8Y??Q??=0?0 ?^?h? ???_a??x?a? 1S??J 7???% kP?-1?4k5?? V$(?9?!??r???*??d??Tb"v ? ??)s?l?M KM??b?I m ?A"5Q?>9????????]? ??�PK ?]?S? ��E ��PK � � �?ai<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ??? ]??S??X ??A ? ?k H??\??? ?? ?~]K??? ??&?ZF;?Nh??~?c ?L?B?)? ? 6 ??????m??j?D???m ?6??Y?b??A?, ?a?m 0_???\? ?,b?$?? ? ?R??? t??? ?z}h (:I?? ?"?u???15 S??"? ???? ?U B?w+ -;]*????T? \?qY?iU????l7�G???r? _H??D??F ojT?#???n9??;?Ik? .j^????? ?i"?O_? Iv ? ? ? ???r??? g Top