Gujarat High Court
SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION/6661/1998 on 13 May, 2010
Author: Ks Jhaveri
Bench: Ks Jhaveri
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?U??? B.?|?Pb).k V ?0 ??;?X?; ??J+ `c)???|>???P?l?Zx? ?+ ?Mp ??
?P?
? E?0L?4?? ?8 ? X ??7"A??X?5???e ?(2?? {??? +??? TW??G,';?;7?0 ~?>?? x?"@? P? y$?\?9??m?7H??TX T? %n??5 ??#4? ??tI Py-v,? ?t",?????> ? ??J??-?Q&$f+f ?`d ????6? m???l?.p???? T�U?o? ??: /N /3 ?],??.\.?W R#?`M`?#.?:???j Yu?,}&?YB??TH:^h sp?4? ?])? ?Y??H?^?/?= ??+??d*???R ???*EV26'?e ? ?? V?E!x?F?Y?`/DM?\????r�*j? ?6D?�?+???~??g? ?_ ?5N???7?? c.?q?X?x0 C?0??HS ?[?? ?? ????^ ??O: Ig?'????,???|???>sNZ?C?????Z?c??-_ ^.2???R?(??? .?(Q V? ??QZ??V|??=??Q:? 2????j?? v????L$ ?? ?? ?w5? ??? ?
?X)?? f EO7?q (n$S?? ??Q R?? Ry/H? q,H ??? >(?|P?T??[ vy+ ? ?/??LQ4???R?1?? C1?}h??�@?? ?kb: ???? ? V?? ??M? I???UZ??I[8?A?v? ?? xS???y???m?D?6????z oM??l???0?m6????~ o+z?~~ o '?YkU>???I???Z? ~???f? ??3?!? ??@|L?????&~]1??V??l?? ???# ?b?? w????DO_? ??V? "??{{c]Y7?n?G]=qe??A??c=????? ?z??5?<=?G??F?a">F?}? ?@????b??M?Z?2Y)??bz:??C?Z_?[X?S???1?? ???{??i ?/ z??n w??V ??7???zDR??H??G15?I ?????" ???x?Q??D?9??B?? ?>???"X+]Z?Op?D*=5U!>}to!? ?7??v,?C +p,G ??y?E hz t}gu{??m?????XX !?? =?? _E ?????? ??)?f ?/~?????jsA?? ??? L??;%?\?D? ?Z?R?v5??cP???Vw=?S????? ?!?? ?P?? nQ???? ???[?m???9? ? ??"?)??UvtBe+sT?�?�f?X )?B'???y?S 1??eX ? R #?"0?]2??'?: ? ?? ? ?{a?pH ?% ?`F? ?1? `n??q??K? ?? ??Scul?? ?? ? V?O ??o???'x ??3t_?K5k?j?,[? ??j??W ?i???]? PK 5t{ ��?7��PK � � �?U?<������������ ���styles.xml?ZKs?6 ??Wh?iO?(J?,??3i?L:??????
???? 8�hI??]� _ )?q::4 O??? ? ??4 =??????^?JD?&fQ?b*}!? ?LM ?z )?? ` ?fh??: ?F???? ??^?FX??;KV? ??Gtk??? m{? �?? +???v??hd?X,???? o OQ?e? ? ??%???e9O4*? ?`eo ??0?? K??Y ,??? ??-"? ?k k??? ? ?~?hDe?I|? ??#?? ?C? ???????^? P?/?$?gn v c? }?
o@???U??Db^?G?? %QiD?v?& �??G .?H?Zf??M? ? ?q??? ??????NQ I? ?Br???_???=??y? z?R??o? Q??? ? ?4 ?_`NV^??k?s??
> m? k???1Yu??
Ncw8? ?f ??? 6 ??,E??? ?[? q? ?#??l ?1J????.?4@?U?)?W? ?} ?
q ?%B< ??y ???1F?#??!S(-? ?P? ??*--9?6$ ? g . ?YU?n? ?l?b?????F?0????Dq ?.?? G?}??
? !C?�q? |xOT?"' ?? ? h?fc U?}?K???h c?-?$? ??p AE?D?J ? IY ? ??e??? ??Xu7uV??
% [l.? ?2?? ??Au?�e?4 ????\_ 9? 7K?U?JTk?$( *h?vI??mG?}?8?%[c?QW ?Z??/c?? %F? ?<7>??Q?g49?? ? ?= ??X?i?6M?'???l? ?
?????a ??[?h?R????? ?? ??S??A~ L???"???X? qR4??j� ????S?_?o?N??D? )~?
? u?l? ?frQl?.?????.???E??_ ??E? G? ????qX?Lb ????:?? ??+,j?y ~DI?uk?RS?*?U?Cm=?>?e?, ?1!n&V??c?TSQ?n?uY ???? ??j? ^?B s???? ?? ???X? N@'?|+?*? ???E?????enP??v^9?O??A5K?^U? X}? ?3?`6E{ ???b??q??N?( ?T?"? ?}H???YuN? ?K? ???N??R ???b4?y?m}w0i V??5? ?W? "??? ?ext ?W???` =E?&?? ?Vw ?bu_0!k Ls8F ?? ? ?~??~??y?3??1?| l= ?9Kk?R? ? ^????? ep;V?F ???}|R?O?b??|R?0\a? ?u?@ ?????0? ???
:KA!0?V?( ???7??R???l8 u3?U?* Pt??_?
f?Y?? ? ???V\????}? Np$5e???\ +?n\4'5 wAM?????S?qwm~~??U[`??? ?r?P?:*?_k?>? ?????? -? ????? PK V?P+? ��?'��PK �����?U? OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 aakar 2010-05-13T16:15:13 1 PT0S PK � � �?U?<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png?{eP?]?%??? ????i??? ?C ? i ??Np'xpk$??N 4?}x??a[5w?f??t?s ??Zk???PS@G!A???AWR?? ^?a``a? ???h Va`?'?d??}?Or?? ??>e?? %3??S? QE?? ??B3?8?P?oR??
C:?? ??? ??g? ?x? ?qhj?d ?O???O????:?3nJ? |?Dx??*?~??} x??fF?@A!']v? ?P? Y)r=?? ? ]3?u???0???P ]? ? ???}?? ? ???
6!StM?? ]?5WzJT?H\"M; ?,?;??f5YS?J>?B???i1p]uj?? zz?zP ?k??6J=.K???l?? ?^??Y????4?H:FnC ??H?j?D? ??.?s???]?z4 ???,S ? ???>?r??` ?>???$?X?h- K?4 ?? ??s[??2????ab: ??r&?=]???l$??#?=? ? ???? |#.^?0se?f $qO??l?~? ??? ?A??~?g?]P?????^&?P?? ?l?9??t.????a j?s?F8?g??M?w_?yD!-
T?? ??PLv9L??% ??D??? ? ?V???b??gk??C#f?
???XW?}?R? ??[?h? Q n?72lr?{?.?eR ?%Y ^(6B??n?i~???Le ?!?:???w ???p????! u 52?9???S?sg f]????' ? {??*?? ????P?;?m?p ???? ??1??T??]^????????HU??c?
??~?I1? M?)f?~???mC??4??W?")? B??r1a??^?2??~? ??
?i?? ????? p? ?|?T??, ???z?D ?[J???eeE%?M??????????MdD???ksz hh??+ m&N Wo4k? ??M????=? ^ t ?Yv?? ?[#)? s ??M? [Z?????k??? 41?p?????T2?R?9?)??Y ^Y? { ?B? ?E # 7??v?f?:^??`}?n??#?5 ,??5,q???&? ? t1? ???????Q?f?}?9??? S?B??3??Ct%?? x?>???$?j?A+ ???>H ??8?�???~M?? ?=? ???? ??Y ??#?T?H???v+??2Ly? ?/?v?L? ?? ? ?V? ?|?6?? ?4^?fO?V??qj ??h?%A?? o?\? ?? ???q???bHW?~??????. ?? Q?x ??? 7 9 ?$???}?&/0?ng?De? ??u?i3?? ???? ? ?$????@ u????O ?F ? n?D-j???1RG;?? ?, �e??,$?XP?Aw?Y??`??P?Y$.? ??z?Z I ??%;???CD ?#?fppmX?+:?5~??v?C? P)? ??? ??T?x??gy??1?B?e?S ?8?^?? ???Tw?? ?H??% C??5?j ?y?3??y87?zr1????"y???o ?p??l'?c??( \??V 3+|z??~?l ?V6?? ?gZBb?cZl? !L??_?p? ? ?T ??b ???G?P?@_9??9giY_#???I<>_F ?7?2I ?Y+?? ?-?`?'7-R R??#??Pd? ??p ???? !??}?j ??V?g_ N ?z@??Y6 ??B?G?vn? ? ? ?:?)???,?????? ?ZT?Lf?c? 7q?P| :> @?H?Fs?W?$ L??X???$??jKb?m+? h%???? P{HR????=??b ???B#??9]7$???? 9???Pr?J???{F?m8?|??+?*Qe?Sr??A??? ? *?? G???
c?%? ]??� N?? ??@HuI??e ?o?K?_O ?"b? ?E ?=?? A ??i ?$??}+z RoS???'?i@@p?~??? ?W??iW?w�bN??%?w@?E????>?)Hp= +????N??HE??V?Q?a??Q?J?bI??`M9??? o lC? ?=� ? ?t9p?U???Hz?r???m ?_]?[??f??s?5?jt???F??+? ?p {? \?;
?I3C"?p??? %?{7\E??_` ? ??s?# 0?,R??%?\w,?$?m + ?? x??? ???!~?q??u? ? [????%AG? Y?|S?f? K? ( ?z?'??H7~? ??bU?%4@E?z? ?C??I???? ? ??????>??l\,??lNh????) ?\ ? &D?? ?,?l?? ?? ?c 90???3?? 1? 7??=5T???? ?0?,L? ??% 3r??L? ?? ?Bs3? ??W ? ^?li?\J?@b~???>? ?W+R?n?n? zV?????9?? ??wY?" ??%?x~??EO??a?c??Qy?n??"\? ?o??& G?W|5?o?l L? j????? qC ?> ?]`?tl_5H?? 1?!2?:? ????? 2D UV?7|- d???DC '0 ?~?L%? ?????.
?x?{u?~?Dgsin" ??4[??6?}?F?B)?!?+P? 93?? ??W ???t?#?~ ??&6?b?? pf}?rYk?kR/7??9?A4?p??08?@ ???YH0 x ??Zw`??v(t+???;???R8a 9||?b d?D?e?j ?Mw?]c??? ??Z ? "KD?\ @}?{??Y?O ??S\(?ay >??? �h?}?b??? ? ? ?48??/wm O?OG??` ?? Q???~\???Z??R-?s?x???v??kWdd??R?!???l@9?l? ??4#???? ??>>.??K???`>p??k??n =???S??f?oD? ??r?? ?? 8[\J?M? ?n??!w}Fy&X?M ? ? r ?? ? ?a??b??6??7_??? ? ??? CC???*E ?!??? ??zT?? ??h?^fk(Io?? i??? s61??4?o?n????FCH*.??k(#??,?
m)v??p?3)9&X ?? @t ?5"@ p 4??3Z~}? ?h?&????? '?=4??
V^???m?s#?qH??% q? pl??? K?t(??`9?v? f ???[???Y?q6 ?? ? ? : ??@?? 4?t~-?`?_v ?<+'JF? ? ?A?_ ? | K?!?? b p??+8lY???? ~Dd???D-&z?rf?T??g ??|?yY?&s??n1???G????? ?Z?)S??Y J?p??qW,? ? ^2?x? ??h ?+?`?j ?y?? ?UZ ? C?;? ? 19P?xL?}e7?:?m? iBgR?)?l7? ?{\H??o?d????L? ] xi?I 3 ?? ??,??:$%??`?k?rWw 4.?0?7J?[S???? $? w: ,??l??P)T???B?*XT?qG?LP?w ?Ul| Z? ?X%?$>? g`0}??B1V?? )Q +d??)???z/? 18?J?b ??-?? ??wW~??/M?s?S???t d?7????T?, ?V!?@ p??(??.? ??W4??CH?9?l??p?G ?I ? ??/u%Y9 ???;??Y???????)y? &Q???? ???#?X ?"???Fr? G? ??k??:??[?\? i;??4??? ?&????(yl?xo >?? ? ? ?"?3V X???'t\ ? ne? ?W??A?JU???`(cl?? |q?j?:IQj??i? sY???%?TF? ??O?? ?!$ ?^? b??????rQ? ^?? #`3?K?c??a]??Fkq??? ?{f?yK?b~? B????9 ? +???? ????c? ?? Dc?/` }?? ?CX?e?S?1.??]?Zz'??I? ?3? ???? L? 3`"?v?2??V/z?*?O? s? ]? ?Dv?? k?&???? ?a?? ?Y? YY?+"v????1??_pa ? g?0o?~9?O?x?8? ?.? 3??4 ?{??>?p??`? ?:e c ?_? ? ?P~st>_ ?]?uQ???? M??N??L?g?%Nb*(\v??gWnb?+??F? ??XG ??'H?9???Y ?OX???t???{?iB?jS???+?$???+??v??? Gj q?? X?`???z%=3 ???ew?ja?D?#1? 8? W| +?9 D{???k/?[ ?Y??K|C? x?; ?V?x?6??Eb?/U?\ ?W?? Q? \?6??>??_??? +?5)]?-? ?? ? M5?? �?&?%?s`0 ?l{x??FtD45?;??[? ? % rU?t3?#????5?#? ?? ?~?}q?>??w?f6?Gb?k? ??H??j7 ?? ?�?RG AN ??\n7?S?s?5?? ' ???" g?X?:A?H??G?t?w?d?_p????:??"? d ?2x^Y?\ V/ >?6?b?_$??????j+???r o? K?~ }???m?:?? 54?p? d?w 4oA?;?IQ< ???`E?v? ? ??9????t?9G? ??$?`?Y?NiE?? ??6\ ?? ?a??m??,R???7?/?"?a?????_??En[?po?U? ?S :EvT /??? Xz~AQ??o^?-?? 0???] ???v??Q??v0?i j? p?7?h?N N? z???=?u?S+?*?%g??6????o???e?%??80l ?x9$?? ?; )?o?????7?VT? ?qU????=? ??e #??? ? ??>??-???? Q? ???t??7???? ??B??????N?7?[?#?Q? ?zW4J? ? .?h??n e? ??@ O???B X.;?*,???A? ?p??\???X ??3[??&q? ( ??? ?8*n??? ? P? =,?Z??'?ov5?x?QMs?"M???
J&?t????!?fI ?qB?W�?Se??5 ??!?B? ?V?D0 +?eV !?k? e?? ?/$P -I ??3?B???q1 ?= U=?Ueg88??^}T?og??? ?6??h??8???$?]!?R?Q' ?Q? ? e ??1? ]??H ] ?g??7 [RH?e?V??6?\i???PT??}*??: ?M? ?mI ?Yc ? ??.WH ?E?Q?`??? ??}ZP??`Ed ????hd??oh 2 ???/ ? i?D?ZCh???X?;??(J`X??eT?9??|?? ? ??g???a?fBg?g??*r??o? ?2 ?KAnt???8= q(?mLq? ?c?gq# %-??? ?M??_?? o? \?-?RO?vR???J ~3FBj?Jg +sG??? 07??2 ?? ??h??�x "D??????oW?* ??R??o ?I?H???lnhW? @??? [X1 ??5??d6u 2E???^C?,?[?~L??k?H A?e? ??\! @???0i"??2?? Y?????V? ?? ??#n#?????i K?"?b~?c?oDN???`? v??K???Y? ??P?b"? ?W? LP)?e??9q? {?e?e _?-??9??I?] ??g????Kk ZNj?V?f?@?,??3f?
????i??I$I|??????jR ?????? ?zPU?`?lY? d{-?O?y?N?*?m ;Qk ?'N ?t$?a.*Ut??v??P ??&/p??? w#? |? ?Af??k� [? ??? ??? ?U ?_ujg)?}?1??)?K?O ???(??w ??M? U?d?4 P~9?????V??B<:??Z ?9?!? ?Rq ?-???I]?E ?Cpn?\?"??Kl?? ? ?u?}: PD? 9Z ?4?(_?B ???Hke??? ??2?Cy???H?D?.?? ?????????9 +?e?|?U57???B?[ ?? ??S p? ??????"??r?t?? e?)????7??z? ?JRtM? ?Zu? ? G q_*? ?F???vN?|?E ?1????? 'l?!?[? M ????Z?0 ?x@[ Y?u2??? N2?{??%5?/??? )L??:, ?"?s?????}?? ?<\I2?S? ?B ????????j? ?????L�??}Q??J? b? ^Y@? a0 ?\ (b?Pv??\>? X E?tVu{GG?2k?/?5Sc?w? n???V?X?G>?
+? ?9?$??*???&LU? ???M??brJ??\??O? @{J > T{??&_???i@j?*[? ?\@?X 5!?g? ???B??$?2?EZ??e? ???:1^{(?N8?a? 2c@?&?4? ?d??AL?R *h??K [??`? JCN?jU ???1|:]?
"? ?? ?I`ht ? ????b?Z??=^p? ???u????J;?f}s??. ?+ s?FA q??c?L ?? N ? Z??6?? F"Rv|v ?TU .*8??^?j+:?;?@ $j( f??I (i ? 7??(JRTN??M?s_? ??@#? ?{???g?Y?!???-????? ????? +0r>?UH;HA2y??u?^?8?:?? ???v87V.?V???>zVv: e ??'??
f??y=&??1?? ??E,7" ?=?n???S?$???r??Q?<2? ? ??? ?7 G -??8X?d?ga???-?1???? $u?%r? K? ??: ?\? ?Df:???2??? G?e?Q aS??4,????? {A-y???i. nF ??K0X? ?r???e?? 4??,? �?jR??x? ??? 2G{~?????b!??C?@F?/??=?!??XJ??1) ?H?m??w ?oJ-??? z?~9 ??Q?? ??j? g?^? ^ ?(?r(I? ??f?r?@`?%8`?? ZU?z =???* ???????+?K! ??I?r\? ;?#7??q>9?q?Ls? ?v?X????8?Ih ?#???@Q#?x??h?-
?X?|?mfd>?, ?? V_?? } ?5 U ?@?? ? ?N?u' ??? ???c???S R? L 0 ???l??i?�PK ? ??|1�� 3��PK � � �?U?<������������ ���settings.xml?Y]s?: }??"?w?Gh?&?cH?MC ???7a/? Y??�??+?0 ????) ?G???9???e?O^A?�MS?RsN@x? bv??)??`?J"J |X???? K?+?<~?o UiI??L47?????Z??@S*??gg?#Z 2%u?? ?p_?4 ? ???5?y??F??,?? 1 ?v??Q pl6?]?i??? ??? 8x ?/ ds oSs??,?? ?? ?D?X2M?? Ir}?$ 3 ?Q??y???? ?? Fz5`v k&PB7?J? pG?'??.R_I ??a$A??? 8nD p?+aFz?]I? a??Ky2` H?? t??%??R>??tJDa?W? F`-EqV? $j?l??{Xm?? ?5?`r?T Top