Karnataka High Court
Karnataka Government Insurance ... vs The Assistant Commisioner Of Central ... on 4 November, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
W 3 M
Enééa émmgmg iew <1}? S§E"E:'§€§ tax érziezafiia ms "'§€§":er&§
imgagafice §;;$%z:e3$"' with affieii fwm €:i§€}?l1§§¢2§ in $5.} far
39 the getéétéareer £2 QQEECEFHEG ;¥§ aséiravéregg. arbE§far*y,9
unreagaaafie and is 3%': agéée Em mder' Qated G?,€3:8_g';i?.£ 3'€3§?
Qfififififi $32 Cugmmg, Excége am §er1/riae "E'"a_;::::__ ;3§,'§;:§é,;:£--§é':,'§,._:"A.
Trébunai, Bangaéare in fiameaf §'s3@fS.".%1=f"_C?:52-{$5' §?i::.%éfir:§':.§;3g
ihe égafiez gm agma: %§:::fer€f:§e{E':?'.'!l2{f§{}£:>':§a'§$£:A":V2£grr£>§«{}.i'fii;::$:%_::V-'€i4t{g:§i§'i:4'&;_:
§s2:":&x:;r§»B gm éfiw aréar éaiééi'-.;@¢6.§£é'é.2{§$§ §:'{:§$:§,~g<§.,.;:3;3z.3:%2a --. '
T:"E§%.%_?é_&*§ £43395? E\é@.__S"?;'ééf_:;_:€§':¥.§g_ s:V§n€i.%%"n£%€ g.; ééfiie ezazier
dataé 29,i2w2C1{}E §a;s;V$Ter:iV:7§:': 'z%m;:2;2L:;:3.é~~%grgmxz; by we
fiazzmméggéaner afv'-Z":e:*"gt:"a~§"'E»><é:§se" §%p§:2é;a§;§)';7 Baségaéare védé
fi§'s:":ex:,j?f;§--EE'gré':i'§'é?,§a~3.gé':=--;:%;ié';---- észaiatéers sf' the préacigées 9?
natusaé §u§':§.r_,:é,_iEiegg§2'.§:;é§:_".%*%abEe Ea be §U§Sh€fi,
T..{§E€ iévialéféeaé Ceamsgé gggeayégég fa: {$38
IL::3é:«§_T%:%§TE:g%~A..Ae"&§ég-£2$25': ihe :";§:*a:;a§é§:" ésgugfi Livy' %;%":~s €3$':s'8mm§§"%§:
'A 2C}:i}§; vgézégéz raaéfi $5 as§':§§r:A
g§':.z:d§;.-bégsrgsag ;f%§c~.8§§?;"2Q@6~§e:'z;%<':€ Yax,» éaéefi :8?"
.
'g. », "C;;"{."asfar rm, 39;:/:2§§5 «S§rz;§€_T{5. _ siiéw Qefffi, gm :8"? §«._£*::e;?';zi:2e.:'4';E',i3?:}'-€§;~ V F.fX?G,255,f2f2QG6»C}:;",-4 €§92z'€:°::s?2e;?i :3? hfnsfsig Mfnfséry :32' F"§n:§:?C@ ' ' fiegartmamé sf R§e;%ves:é:;e' _ _ {C§z';z:r§§ §os3rg:f Sf E;s2<:§§e 3::§"'Cz;$:sm.s,? ' " "
"ggg * * Sfifef {f§mm5::;§§{m§:'$ $3' Ce:§$_;;3k'».EE'f,><s;r{$e {£i;'}_ _ V ifiief {:'a;??;??i$;s:s§:2£3:*§'~..;;>f €j:;§§?v;:r:f2.3* ':*3:_& C$::£";"$i"';5§;><s:§§e 53455} -. ..
£"amms§s;'g;n$:'§ :23? fierwzf-aw [T?§;§g';fif§.}._ " _ $§§'8€€€}i' Sens; Sf $<é';v;':i§ ?§xj,;»L,_fi!fa:?;?:ri5'i,§ §§f'§£'i"{}:'" {:?§;;2:;;.i§fj;';, {";i;£3;:s;;'w"' E;<<:';"$€§:..,E;2§9ei!igaz2Ce, $1353; 9955} V ~ V ; -
.§:;b.j ' figs%pfs'§g§§i£§§§5VV'9f'::.$'r:zéa,"e_E33: 9:": fee aoifecied by a._Pz,-séiisti '.f:z;;*€ff?C57§€'fgT--7;g:"'--._%xe!f?ff€ pasfermirzg S£"&E::£{"Gry f;;;2':*:£°Ea;*:i§; ,iz'._§:;':;€:}.€%=;_$5"»:5§7;'§er 5&6 ;§rGvE§:'m§ sf as faw ~~"*::--_,>jga:fa'3:':g ; "
§§:;'fi:i§§'3z:é, _ " " V' a.;*:.;:;:';<,L;5$r <.>;?"";?§"£ci:}e;"<e§g;":;';9:25fz{." aagéfzarifieg; ('51s, 3;; 1'ag;&;"7:::g»<_gafggéffsjisfi/sgé 52;? fair §aver;?:;":£z3f,} fiérfsrm " ;';£z'é3;§s":.._ f%;:;*3¢€g?s:§5,z'Q'u§§e5?, ézzzfficé? are géaéaséargz in 2 5é¢:*:V.€'a;s*e;'_"_v»--}"fz;é:§e f{,if?i7§58:"§S we ;Q€ff§ffl?€§ if? farms 9f A:~;§e§;'f;i: :'"&%'::3;é@:2;'3"§§éii§:;: asgégrzea' Ea Eham gmafgr we fan:
is?' ;§::é';";:;e;' 559;' <§:<§s'2?,§s"e§, 5&9 Regimsf ;%f§.ra»:?::@ §§§;in:':§5~:rz:§3 :1a;§@:'§€a;';'@s5 {fififisifl} azfifiérééks v>3;r:'2'E£a§::'C:"2 , " ::{;;V :'::;¥%£§s' 5:355 fififififfaiéfif? sf weighizsg arm' §'2*'?5§;§£.3i'i}"§§ _ =§:zS.:r:;mar2:s," 5&3 Qggzmgf ?',r3:";§;:@_r§ §f?1e'<:$s* {£'E"Q} ' §s3f:,;e;: fiéfiagg {:§s':"§f§:",a§e Es {fig vefiiaiegg 529:9 2 3»:
mg'.
Sffeiéfirfiie 9?" gsaéer:-:2 insgecég §:2z:f sggagsg aerzificaze fag' iwciiersg ar Exgfagive fiemrémem" §i?;'.§,S@C§§§ gag' ésszsgg a:"§ri:éf§::&Zs 3%" gaairaieasin sgiazggs .:"a;:§<; i?{§;'Cf\f§ §"'§:"?§f is: ierms af SQFGE/'i'§f0{?S 02' ifla refs:/an: fawszex Fee §$ pr6$<::";bea' :3 cfiargad me' $539 same :3 uiifmaéafy fi5»pos£:?@'a? £959 £35 {:?i3E/€:"f'2é'?'?E"f'E§" Tréagzgky, A dagjbf hag arisen Wheéfwr .9353? §CZ'§Vi§'f€§ ;3s"Q:»rE5i::'$55.._ éy & som;*@ig;':,fp:.sb:'i:": auzfgarfty r@Qufr€0'V.¢.._i::? ':i::%:--: grmrgfied wager a giamfe Cars 238 :fans:'c:5§r§'§f~. j';:%,3f gfsffii/555:??? 03' sewfcef £25' 573% gumase 2:3?" faaxgrgéf 3&5?-:*'§if§* " as fax:
2, ?;'?e 553% i?§§ was e;x:s2;;;?§:_:'e:§~§' '?7.§ne.Sfissfi-..{$"*::%T_' af zzfée 23:99; 5623:" {he a:::§s'v§§§§§:'V__;3::aff{3rmaj;<;?A'égx §?.§?5~.% ' §9v@;"§£g;3_,f;s;.3§i§:: a:;.;§f?a:'§{1é»2%$'«-..;;r:d&;-.. {£23 &E.2=.?f§i1§f&§5.f'3V?'? .332' 53%: am .55} £2323 rsaiagre ef gfapéésfery :3b§£g'§€§<?n§1.;A;?:%s'£b am Ea fie faffiifeaf in accardagfi-€:& w;'{f2 "sans, "?'fi:§ fee mifacéefi 5}! éfiem %'}:i'k*..g;?§:"§'?:%§"?E"3;é';".?:;§;' siégaff? a§§E:駧:'é;$ 53:; 5;'; $529 nature sf Cam,0:,z§':.~:::>:;"';: §c':vy:j_;::<3";;*é;* £523 ;:»r0v:"5z'ons of £1579 reievarzi" géafufe, z3:":c:':fs _.Q*€ér§@:S:£feé inm €523 Gmxernméni §7f'8§S:1£§f}";'--v.. §ifC5":3 :&C§"'§_v.{{*§,e*,." Es? pureiy is? gmfaiic fi?§":éE'3i'a?};f3f 3525; iii és.A_:,;:?a'e--r£*§i<en as mafidafsrv and siafigzéfoi'-V' f§;§_:;:;§_q;3; E'Zf:é'::.s" are mist Ir; me nafazzre §f sexwcga 'fa ' .;3;':;yf"~. gésffffésfzyiar s'rm';'zr;"a'a;af for any :§n3:'Q'e%a_:i:3::, '?"f7x9r:3f;o§;.%%, 3529'? $5: acééviiy gmrfsrmea' in/_--3 5m%e5;¢:é;g:;/;:;sb9;?::: "3:J:%s<:>ri€y gsnfler me provisiazmf :'::»:'.?-'§aw*:?'::;es" r:'i::--£°';G:':S€§€:.:€§ Qrevégian 3:' faxgbfe S@§"ir'£'7;Z'@ £23 3 §:%«§r5'*4%;% az'2::f_,'€*?2eref§re, 53$ sarvfgra fax 53 fevsabfg ' .s;:.;:'§2% ggfizxiiieg, = ."_'*§%i§e'*;»2?é:x€r, if 535?; aaffiaréégr §§rf::>.:'m§ 3 A:;:.gr:z§:ie:.=: _;e;,:;s*c;: 5'5; {E3 E2'; {ha flgfifffi Qf gfaégéary §c§s"2:'f£"§«" asinifi {fie rams is? ::zz::%'&:{a£<s:? far 5 C<*};'"§.§i§$f"a§§{}§"§ mi 5:; :°;'%§":§aj:a;;'& gf giagziagmrgw $69/isaxy, éfsen sir; gaggtf; §i§.§€S, " §e_.s"a/§«:?§ 53>: wasgifi bra feaxiafiie, if --{'f'?€ §£{?§'sg'fE"}»' V. ;,;;%é;.:f§:§§§<§:2 fafis z=w'i*§'2:;": 352$ 5;2;::2:;;é $5 3 §'§X§i5§€ gerazsce, 2 %§%%.ik% 2:
WW5", efi, fzaafe ma' ziéefrfi fa:';'n:a:"!a;;=.~:: {way fie géazisafi ascgrsfzszgfy', Sféwdi wrségn WEE? fafiaw.
E"
{Gautam 3f?3f§"§€?§§£"}{_§} C£}§'§?;'??i$S§3:I}£"}€f ffiervim 'f"g;%,f><}.f'
3. ,Q;@§'y'%?3§ gm Qaragragh f'~.Ea,2§. ii: fig gagb_e§%'E'§i§{jV--...§§éa$j__ _ flea gzaiufe 9? aiiiéviiy §&§"§G§'"§'E'E€§ by 'aha ;:;sa§é%:%::m-é§f~.%3"'f{sE§>g* Qagbiéa ifi%9;?§$€ and E: E3 u_§éa:"':a%<£'~:;': :*':?*e,.a'r':.;§ 3-%:§':*§;{V-..§§:;§T.' gigigzsry fzsnaiésrz ané ':%';§se*§*z§r&:..;__ ztééa '§*;é=:é':i@§§€:.§;:"t':é;=:';;iV,§%_%;: 'zéfgefsé far gerférmigég sagah aciévéiy E5 §§"é"'«%:§"é€.V;r2&Ea:';*:§;_§§'m:%§§:§E§:>;*y Eesgy as per the pr$v'§::.i;e}*:5 -9:3? 1-fc~§': e"~-..:'<5§.é"a.:ani siaiute am §%;e:'efQs*é,;"'§'§:-.gficfsseg §"§%;2E- f§§!% w%'€?t;E'§r*a"'E;%'s1e mésahief 23f ffiéfliififi tax amd t?§€5";*§f3{:._re; thaéka%*e :T:;;§%_.ééabéa :9 pay tam Thés has bees: _<::vem';2%.e€:'i fig %:~f<f::*§;».+*=2" autiaarétieg am C$§"¥"§i"}'§i%iEEEfi a ..,$$ré.g%;{:j;1~§ §.§€'$.:,f Eé::*g*-:-:%f,;%'$es"vEC@ i:a:><,i _ *5"§f:*'%é materéai er; gvemré éimfegag ma: Em E1-'Ee:@:* 2_,:a*:§laH:3i.2r'%.Ve£':;. fiyanaéx $5 §{§?:*'E""z3§:§%é fi%:.:@rnrs":&2z%c §5'E§E5§"§E'EC€ " €."}s:§;é":*_ime{:t we 33% §'3@§fi€%'§ éf regiszmééay: zmréeg $€€Zi"§$%"% 3 s§'§'{%':@ §f§§iE§'£:§E"E€§ mi? ififéfi sairyéag gr: Gamgraé Is'%S:%_é?"§?E€:?€ =4 am.
5' 4 <é$>\ 5 . 't§r:a,%gaE:éa $3 ia:<a%§& $a:*:.z§::"e§ §§'é";%;§é$§ ii? any gersaa, ... W; M 82,s§%::§S$ {FE{3E'E~§§f€ §%"ESLE?'3:'"E{.'E} gézége :33 323%; :€§$6{ "fhg gatéizéerzgr sg éitgageé Er: insurance Eugénefi firs yeggescéz 3%' the azeéééséag:
E'; awmeéj by me Qmsernmeni E€Qa§Err:e:;§§;.__ :2r:d Cemrnercéafi ggncemg:
fmazzséaé §r:te:"e§': am :;;e,éf:é:§eg fé:5z**""::%*3§§_3,$':;;s%g:s.::§§.%V :3? :sa;E";%<;_%": iiée £9-zé.:Anr;::e.n«:fj. 4%'-§3i'E. ".%§2g'fi.{§C€3{§ :""§'E®§"'%€'3i.
5, ";'"§'2e fiaverfzmeat "5{;s€_ '§r:d§a §;*i':f?§i3'g";€§@§ §€'.i'~;»' sf servica iax érgteraééa can ":£3~~e_ne:féé :{:s:;s._:"3§*'2-sg' v:.:Et%': e€'?ec: frag": 81,Q?.§.vV<»,f§<§k«"«;»;._Afifézé':?;::':>r§eré"-€az*r'g%i:?:§" an Gfineyai Insuramjg Bu$ér:e:€;§;_Eé the /_§€i"« §'é1T3.§"%'§.%.$'§;::-E?'{LG 333: sgenséce tax. _;5'; Sfe{:*-;AE;_:§%': ' {1} Q? 5333 Féiéargae am; 19% :é'::::'§:__; §;§g"' gergam gmzzéfiérzg Egxabée Sfifiiéfié Ea make am 7§:§g1:%.%azféztévéh./,,'»_%%.;w%?VV'-s'é§%3§;:"3%:%Gs"2 2%: am Cami? é §><=::é§e {L3%f§£§:: T%:é"'i:a:<.-.{i%§a:§ea§%e 3% @326 rgiaxgmi mini: sf éima wag §% 35 3:': 's!E?'E§€:§&S E3'? vghzgh the €vS%f@!"E"'é§'§"--=j é.§'E§-fééé" V' gézzgéiy sf €3Q¥€E'E'1E"??§§":§ Q? Karagiakg am €§§'§"§;§§'§g $3": iézg vunagouw Sgciém §'.?{<:f; 3?" the gfitérawae iacig 39% Ei%;£§U§ai€S. ma: téée vaizge G?" iaxabée gervicé rééatiss": tg gervérseg Q? §§E"E8E"3§ §§"§$:.EE'"8é":£€E pmzzideé is the §<;§§£'3i fisiéerg sézaéé be me EGEBE meméum affifiuféf §%a§§z_::~;ve;§_j:'a'..;9_7§%f{'s we paiiaty h@Ede:'s,
8. §§'§$§I}§i% af 3% afsresaéé flaw;
"§&?§&§ is maka an aggéésgiéan fa? 23$;éfiisfaéisgzwé'._a5§ ;:;a.%_r"fiisgjéézjggfg 5% Q? €338 Féséancfi Act am aégszz §aE%&d3'~%:.e '§":':aE<e_.*:'E':ei;:$é3;r%'f:é%2':: *~ sf S€l"'V§C€ tax 0:': the xzaiaze {i?'?V.V%a><:ab§e"-sééw%'t:ekecaévezfi §éi§"§i'°§g any iaiefzdar' :~§.§5§§%.h, .':3§'_:aL§:;g}V§E.;:a£*i:3.!«\=«:- is iiifle fieyzwaé gmremkzsent 3.:"W-..A:§%e¢':§:§5,52%;: -éead Wm Sectian 5% 9%' the act area a§"s§:g ":"..'3iEé7:;§_ er caugeé :3 be fgrgaisheé a re'E::..:'*;1i; m'~%:%:e §é*e*::.:;':f%bas:,: farm as reqasirefi amfier fieczécm: ?§ ::2f tE'f;e< §1<:i,~. "§*-E2;eref:3:"e, a ghsw aazgssa nmzizéée Came ':9 be Eé;:;A:é&;::§ z;*1Iai%'%':%'2-;;':;;§;:>§': :3 shazfig Céiéfifi 33 is #23,: {ax ghmsié mi
--V %e wag: mteresi aw genaiiyi ii"; yew'? fiiéaé, 3&9?
"_";CA§:"'éi~*§:fi€§N?E?E§i %;'E"3e*~; am ?§"":€ Sevammani: Qfgéfiégfiiififé and M g ...
giiéxgétgr £3? éfifiééffifiié 3? §E'§E'}«' §€I.%E:'€§'Z'"'§%"¥"%€?'§E zxehéaéfig arsé ihéraféra, may 5%: mi: gaxxemé under the ggraféige {ax and E3233; ssugééfz fm ésagpéng §f me g3r@C§aé§r;g§, fin zzengiéeratéon Q?' the saisj {}§§€Ci§£'}R$,, afitér Ea§<Eng_.v;*:{§§'::e*a_T'~~:}Vf me afgrasaéfi gmvisisns, ihe fissggséng Au*:?iQ§_E=%;'§,s ~ izémgz are imzfiézzed in Em bu3§,r:@S§...§f_ :ng:3%:.é%:'{:§:';V.3%*:ej a:"3_ §'EQ§d§§%§ €e§E3ir&i:§ar: ::r:§&2* §@{:t%9n3.3 "::~%"é$' E?f:§':§§f':arzai:e:?""":€'%_.i'i7;;.:
E38; ?§"§EFE§:{:§"€; thay §&<::§§?'§é&>._£€r§:%::é §.f}§fCé'§'.:§V'§§:"§§_'S--v--..E§f¥--';:38?' 2 L' Séiiéfifé 6% 0?' iha E'-"§:":a:_n£@ ;'l:_E;__._VV':'»vE§2'~_%;jgrr?%§"~:2f_;:§§E§f§r:a:§3n §'»§9,2;'9r'i«ST fiateé 28,§:'E_V:~fl:iT;.0,.§€<§f f.,Bl§3E4§'%;§%§':n e":W35 iraeatied as flame is} pay §$s1«'§_Ce iaééé"ué*§dé's':._"%_*§f:é €:a%§é§%:§rg: Q? genera? E:"z$urar%s::eg--' TE"?ée?f'é::. é::» 'V;'1§§"'---exémgtéen avaééame far ihe getétéoner '€;sf_ fa: *:V1%':;e4V:;;Ls;<::%.;r§§::$s é.§E"%§&§' me State Gmremment s.s*§%"gE»:;§';@s,* "§"§*:é's*:~%f;{:;§'e§, 35% flag %§*:;*@@ auiharétéas haw §§é":£i;,,;r:".:;'«3%;é«E°§*g;._ ?':£3_§é that 3% §§'§§§§e:3i"'§§E" fig Eéabie E33 3&3; igx ané" '§.;¢§,"@'3} s:;"?'_'*E£:2i§:'9e$%: wag agghsfi E: E3 if; §:?:%§ :.;@§2i&>:?:,. am §&&?°;¥'§8i'§ Ceasrsgaé far ihfi ..f§'séi'E"{'§«.{§r":{:E§' Cfifiififififi iézat {$28 55%' €%§"'§§§" E3 €§§"Y{§'5¥'}' is téée ' §%'~:::r§§a§§ £EE'{:E,§§§é"' am smkg far geiiéng agfia 3% we game. \S§ .
2%. :52 aarefagi gemsaé 3? t%¥:~:~ §§:G§"8$5§§ aézcuias séwwzs iha: wézat §$ €>€_€§%f§§§€$ Er; fiarggaagh 2 £3 aha aciévétéeg gaffirmed by gawreégnffgubiég auiheréiies ggnéer Ema arwigéan 0%" Eaw, W§'2§C§": are 3:: the nature sf s<;i:'z2§i§::e:€}~rfy abiégaiieng %fii§E§§§'E am za ba fu§fE§§@d in aficfirgfiamfa ~ U';
"'§"E:e fee C£;f=§§J€:Z%§§ by then": far §erf§:r.m_é_ng $:;7€ji9é E 9:': fcézei géaiagra 9? aémggméssry E3251; 2:23 ;.%_§r~étézé'._§é*::>};f;g§:;.é€'§. §%.i ':E'é§ §"8§8Ef§¥"'%f sfiawza a:":§' __§:--._ $5 €;§§Qe.g_Eté:§ £fi':v;"::s::s. the = L' fievgmmmé: treasury" Su::hV_.a{§é%sg%i::_» 53 §;:;:;:"zg_E§;_:é"2 ;>L2%3E§(: interest am 39;: is z;:*:3@:*'i--:»'«':Véé?<9.n".as~;. rfia'nV§a*:{;:fy am gtatumry funatsgn. it is E?z't§'é%S€3"'€aS¥§%'f5=. gmmg Es éfivéabéex Ensa:;"aé'%;c@_bQé'§'z<2e.§_$'*.§§'«:éé-€;__ 3 j:;@ver*eég:"2 azfflgt. Em fee is caiiecieé-. 5:3?' -§ésf§<>_%r':*:§_:§'§,..-~$ue::§"; ataiutary faggéctémg, W§"i'"¥:8§'E§%;i}§'e, é"i7_ ESv §a;f_3§.%fE:l;";E.'%' 3 :3?' 131% saéfi <:§:'é:z.§§aE* muaréfy '"~._a§p_§§éE3j;3%i*:§;;%i :%":'a§<e§_.«é': 22%;? dag: 2%? if a ggwrssraergi 5L§§§s€.}§?E'E'§§»i' §'"i:§E7"§iéV§"?'fF§S a §§E"»£§aZE' :1'éi'E§£§"§ fig §":€;*§Z E3: ma féazuie €52? §>%;:::i§a§'%;::*>:"g 'éigéiiééiy 33$ éthe $&§"z'§% ég unfiayiaken far 5
-- m::§é'::esJ--§%§%3éé wé én 'téze zéaiure :3?' gzazuzssry faa;"E§a;'=g,, ihgn 5~3?€,g'€§3. "fZi§':'§€'$;, Sfiiéfiaé éax agzntgagéé §e §€2.:%§§§e Eféd it §a§%§, wig"
wsifién aha ambit a %:;%xa%i€ gemse, '%"E":e:€?ere aacsrémg {G zéze ::érmEa;* gr; whiaé: :**eE§a;r:ce sg gggflfiijf the §£€EvE§'y' Qamaé 6?': $1; ihfi gjeiéiiener asizg. we iréguraaae fitézziftgx faiég zigétéwén that Qaragrapéz 3 am' {am wéihira the méachéef §f"§§é§'«'.'x%"§'€€ tax afié iax is ievéabiet Ehe iizrm au%§'2_<;':;§t§§i§"V-.['§*:éxg*{3. ~ CQ§'3{Z:j§'£'S§'§i§3s' heié ge am we 3:3 netigag any %:;:%:§:;&§:;:J::y%%k:::% {£3213 Qfdfif as:2%*§i§?n cgéig fa: §;*':€§r?e:"'an:€a }'%<:£;é%::§:T'§s§"§:;; géiié-ééééifa fig §ESE'¥E§SS€C§» Pré __