The Divisional Controller K S R T C vs K B Dhruvakumar @ Kiran on 12 December, 2008

[Cites 1, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

The Divisional Controller K S R T C vs K B Dhruvakumar @ Kiran on 12 December, 2008

Bench: L.Narayana Swamy

{EVE THE HEGH £382??? OF ICAEQNATAKA AT BANG£iLC}}§E DATED THIS THE ::2'm my G1? §)£§€T1E?s.:§'BER 2£?f§§\f "'L--«_:T:'4 PRESENT THE HGNBLE §:1R,JEIS'£'I{':};? V;::§<;?;§>;a;,§:§<j§éz:3;s':

AND' THE HQ§\§'B,L.E§ L§5..§}§s?;§<§;§§£'ANA aﬁvgmy 1\£i§$CELLAl'€EQUS FEES'? .é§.F?,E'§§VL 1;; ci;E»ézé?5.pA-(£9? 29:35 {M'J} T115 [)ix;isi<::11a£_1t;'E§}:i:;:';;V}3é£' ' ' K,.S,E¢T,C, V iﬁangaiore C': E Him _$L_119 f }v1i1j " ~ 9.3; its Chi€ff--.L::éw z:::;'£::'::'g::;>d ' ~ _' % . . . APPELLRNT {By Sﬁz. E"§:1:3f£2.%:%i1; Advucate) 1 K;-B. ' iT§if::iL:s*$;§{:;::§:ar K3313 f £9 S.K;.' --"?;3:--3j3a"sub1'a112ar1}'a A}-'¢r Aggsii 29 y:é~ia1'$ .V N0. ;';;§1}Zi.8, A.-T: St:re::t:t .. AAS:ira:;§.§a.§3at11a * 2€£2:i::.1t:i;ss"e1 Di:-.st;::*it:::

° :%>§mg Agama:

" = -i1£1:"£1E:1"i{3¥',i{11€fx¥£'i §:I§j:>:r, $9.9 .1, 'C' I..a§-$2.1:

-- :;;.1':.2dg&K {8i',}:§":i§} and Mesﬁzbaz', MAST, Sri:*a:1gapaE31a '-«.{¥1€::'.€:i:1;«1:f"t.£:§ " I-§"efa:'z"€d ta as ﬁﬁébzmal' far Sh{}3{"'€i} in MVC '[_'_"'?s§ {;;§"'='§5/i£f3€§1 dated 2€>,€}3,2@€}S are :--::~m;~a:«-3; éﬁiéii ' -'iT'*::_i*ié;:.1$m2§:1a%3i<%: and §';ez::{:& Cz}:*p0ration ha ;'3x*a§--'mi ii} 36:: asfgie P4 11 (E11133, Bazlnimaxatapa Mysore 3 'Thé Bray;-zth Manager Natiunal If1SL1I'.€;%.I}.CC {ff-0. Ltd, RV, Read, Ma.ndya " -

i?E§SP€}'ND.ff:i*~.'T8'A V. V {By S1"'i/Smt: Kama} 5% Bilarzm éxgivecétés :1 T A' R-2 & R-3 arc: s€rvi~::§)"--__ ' * . A "

This MFA £3 fikizi uiider S§3:?i:i,»91::'V 3f?_3{ ;kf['s! Aet agaizigi, the Judgment; and Av;ardV.dat«E}f;i: '.2'£3;g.'_.3 'paﬁseci in MVC Na. ?46/2961. 012--'£:h€"_ﬁ§€ cf £315: AC£Ci1.j_'~-Qiviﬁ Judge {S1'.BI'L} 32; Membczr, MA(_Zf'F,,. '=SI"iifé;=1gaa.paU1Va, _ a1&*a1'difig co1npe:1sati01*; of Rs. E3,é§,é}0C)/ am :31 Vii"ii:é::*vE:".§§f:a_t."8F',!§g. ;::;g..---

This ,1*;2I:F*:i,. :;:§;----.£{;:~ "'ff}i£,*'£fi&'€é_1";g ®:'<1€:}i$5 mas dag; GQPALAGCQJDA J; rj1.::_Iiv§:r€:_d;" that f§0ii0w§I1g:~ Ajfﬁggamgy?

This Is€is§ée§a§2.cf'$L:S'§t'§:'s'i3' Appaa} 13 ﬁiecl ¥.1j,:' $.16: Eﬁivigimxai {'ft}:"1t1*:)§V};::%;,' 1¥§::3.1":33V.'t:lxi<Va;V______f.S';t;a;f:{~: Read '?12=mssp{>rt C0}'°};}€;}i'8iiG§ii {_'t:€1"$:;:af:e:f'A 3f§:§§'fI.T€:€i 2:0 as '€1{3:";§9:'at;iQ1f:' far si1ar¥:.} an ééhcé *m;:z,1%:E..T- €E'1S83:i€.}1'} awardrsd Em; the Add}. {E31235} 3 Eihf: jzjiigifzﬁrgt. 5% award passsrgi Eta; the 'i':*ii32.m3l urgigtzg v'a':*i:?:us $'9u-Izds.

2. '.I'}1e:'e is {:0 meted far 2,23 13:1: a<i¥é:r£T ti} 132$ fagﬁza. _%;}fi.§;€ Cass: as $§":§~: Tzfguizal in she ~.._u§§:;:;p:2g:1@§§;' 'vi1i'€i§1?:é1it: has' &}ab<;a:'a1:e23§; E'€3f€§'I'€€§ ta 311:5:";';¢<":z:$:-$23;jfacitsn and 'éegafi axsiﬁexzcez an :'€:<::3§'{L .3. }1ea1'€'§_, *_-}.€a1if'1:;&;i' V' feii €316 apgsaﬁamt a3 W533 as iiﬁarnedi'(_"1G:_>;::1é€i3}f~.;}r"tE:.::éwszrfé §3*I§Ei£{}fE,ﬁ3;",S. 4, -the app€:}§a11£i $L1{:=mit€:.€::1 {ﬁat gzahiezrirrr in q'£1e;§§Eit3:"i i":-%é%€§}v€d in the aes:i:i€::1%: as the ﬁzitiiztsgs "z*:'3:::a"2r{fi€':§¢. £3"; E113 criminal proceadéngﬁ ix} fxharein it is heid that the £§I"ii?'€€§' sf the x?&%3i€;};:5"§mf:§::*i*sz:§ 2:{§"ia;)pea} against ma guzigmazzi <2? csmréctiexz éfzii se1§;ene;:%§:ié:§$d Giﬁrﬁ'.-.2{}{'}5v pggszseéi E2}-F ihe iearnecé Adgié. i£%4_{1C§"';*€a,?<}3/2863, azgshareiﬁ €316 appeliate Seam'. an :'e- _V azﬁprécigticm 5;? §Z::%;:::i.$ and eviziétizee an £'€:::<:;r:1 $13.3 iéeki @323?' the 'ssfhiéie E}€.a:"§z}g r%3:g:§stz*a.ti@:1 Na.;«:a €}9-"£}¥€366% is not gmzaéyed in $316 a<::.{:ic£$§:i:.. Na Sue}: aC<:it§€::"1€; has bﬁéiiil telzeia }f}§a€3E3., 'Ph€:z'ef0:'e, the: T:'i§:;1;;1::3i slrzmgiii 119$: hasnst rc:e::z}:*d€c} f.,'i"};:;"3"f:3Zi'.if.'.'§§¢"{{:1g af .530: 031 the ::03*:i§:'1ti<>1.;$ image 3%.}; :*eg;a:'«:§é3f;'g ;"af$%i" '-aia:-:1? E1€fg}igE':§E? ziréziing «:1? fix: t:}§.'i'8:1<.ii.::g _§£€2':i{i§¢f'- 'E'.heV .f1:{:ae:lVi:11g {Sf '1t37§ * T1fi};;z_1:2;-3} arid rm: zahvgwe CQ%i}:§.';;fg_fx:if1liE;f{1SV" '~TiVs:_f$L: :& ;§%3:gard§:1g if}{3C'%5£}"£'!3}'1C€""L czxf accidaiii. aI1%§."":::§1& 5:;;.j§.zr§; ;§§§a:$;t;a§;1€d by the appeiiami is €~;:*z*;;_m:r:>z3;5§,,_ 33131111331911 is f:2s:*':§i"14:-24:1 hf»; thfi _ }}:;L:;3é;'é%i IE1*J€S'£i§g8ti0ﬂ Qfﬁcez' in Vﬁhgwg their there is no 1"':sg}2'ge;{*,:{:=e<_:§.f::1'}y_§i;:é§;;;1t§_:V'Ee§ 'E';%:f£V5~§i*«'..;;¥_g;"§t,;s_'m:'VV::;,*zf the afifcmiézzg v€h;i.{:}:=*: 0f the CQ;*pQrﬁii;Q:9:. _ "E"i:§éAi?é'§'%:§i*{:.;.':LV"'1.133 _£§ndiz1gs rezrerrcied by the '.i'3*i?:::11z}g,}.;'0:1 jahé' .V€:€f¥1f1V_%tkas%1i';{§'=:_1$ 'ésgue £539.} is errer:e:;1_1$ and an V "S:%id it has agrxswﬁmd E313 comientious iSf_éTe,}ii:? 'E'?! §:_a&:%js':,?::* 9:" the giaimazzi awardirgg €:GI}1pE§}$z'~1fiGI"1 i.;;fzde,:* ""«vazf§:}i:-5:5.' heaéis }{€?i{fpiBg 10<3'??fe digabiﬁnmxlt at 2¥§,"§}T2 8% §E}'£L$£'€S'§ is exarbitaxzt far the mass}:

%:.}ff;;:;E.iTTI"j:::":'.E':.'i'{;:..:11ai Exam 3223?: dedutztsai 1 X8?!' 3111011111: '§=0Waz*d$ }€'_3{'Z~§S"'{"}f €i€§)€E"i1.€§€1"}C}-'. '§'E1€r<:-:f<§:'€, Iaarnad Clgunsei S{lb1}{l§iTS that:

Em qma3;1t,z._1:}:1 of C<3mp€;:1$a.tio:1 3 ?a:*£1€éd ' on {E16 higher side; 'i'}?;€:*€f<}1'::, {ha 1€£:1:'11»z2{% Cmxzassl has alte:'n:at1v€1}, '$¢::;:;17;1;'f._$_"'.;_1__as A M ("ha '$81116 maxi 13¢ ${:a.1e»::1 c:§<:>w11 bv deductiiag 1[3vI.d,.A4_ét£Zi9--iii1§T ?3i3€1-« .. award just arm} reaganable: c01npe11%s_ati0.1iA. fib§5'TT,f£=...{i1€i-if'§=*§.£*:g .f:}1s':"?: impL1g1ed judg;1€1"1!: by ailoszv-i:z":'g-..__tuhisV"agjpaal T. t}§1:'vs : L. "10u1"r. dam net a-:::::6pE: the cast: Eélﬁii 319» Vehicle in question did Izatz'-§§§*:c§1é1(=: ';E:<3 é§fe?i§1e1'_zt.;A H 5, Thrs Laa;*§1<§d ifazlgéﬁgté V ¥::§£2 7beh:a.3;§' sf ma i1"1jure;<:1 hag 5<:§_11g§}.:1§_:' .ff€if%:::€¢_4'4V3f:'§;%§:'VVe:"{iV£>';1§,<--:§:<{Ei:1g §"l*'1a¥: {E26 Trimma} :§::<}c%_1§1:::11tTar§; arszgi Gm} &v:§<"%€11{:e z:i:{;¢u:;}{;§§'§§é':I'f}'..:§é;*i§;fEC§(:s: 'oi: i:'e:<:<3r{E ;::2a1'*t:%€:uia1"}y E3331 -- FER, Exﬁﬁ - 4E>s:,?4 - EMS-5' Repoﬁ. 133$ régjzigigg ;};Tf3.{Z€}E'€§$*.(§.;~': E315 iinciifzg Q1' fact an 'rhét =::0:1t€:"1':5:0L:s 2333.16 336,1 ?1e*:Tr_3diijg _§;i':"3.zgtT«.V1:1'§%ei*--..:f1{:ci{¥€:nt teak" 1313.06 {:11 {ha faéial dag; an

3.CCO{§£iEZ'«ﬁ}f1;€§;{?§:?}.. ﬁzfiii zzegiigemt <:'h'ii§?iﬂg 0%' E336 <:£fe:":s;i::1g vehécirs. ' I1€:'€f<3I4é:;... "":§1€:' said £':I1{!§ng GE' fact 13 baseéré (>3: pi'G§§€E' Va;%p:réC};3t,§i<}Ii Gf lﬁgai észétiﬁiéctét 01": rﬁéaazti. '§'}'1é: $833518 1% n€i.{iE'3a$:* %E:§'§7€}Ii§i{)L1$ <32' &:'1'{>:'* ii: law agiii §a41:'%I;':§3z' p}a£:i1'1g :'~::1ia:'1<:€ 1:991':

V' §:_:::gm::m in éihe: a§3§3£3:e2,§ 53.3%: by {lift C:::r§®1*a.ti€3:1 ifatzziﬁﬁl nésﬁti " \m/ *C}"\.

bf: apgsliaé iii} the C2386 0:1 Eixami and $361. asiqiéi Ehtf férﬁiiiigg Qf fact. }'€{',€}1'{1€€1 bf; trhét '§':'iE3u:3ai 931 the: r::m';%::e:"2i:%<m3 %ss;,.§1:i<%»-.4§f§:?_.vf:h T136 T'1*ib:._::':3}. was §'°:::<?;3...:i:*:::{§ 114:: <§ef;:§r3:2i1*2§ {he <:<:::1;:%%::':'$::?:%*,Vij5::1j§ isitﬁfi' rim 'B33325 of lags} e¥ie:%e:'1<:& am I'ﬁ{TTGE'{i §I3f3V{§u}'.'é§ ;é};':3i;':3aI:t.'' '' Thézrsfara, ha f:.1r%:,%*;,<:r $:T;1331}i%:é"L4L.jcixat !;3£:§:_-- "-7'§':*§?:i%.;r:a£ has mzzzxzziéteei st-izrimis ermgf '@112 j fz§§:i'L§ "§1:»::£ 110:1 £:@:':$i€£€:*at:i0:1 :2? x:i{;::1:":':1:=:1'";:I'r%f1r:;§«§%V §?§2X.P5r ~ saiagég. €8F"$§C9;§.{3; wE'1i<:h;'~iS':%.:?§V§:;e§: to $1913; tizatz 11$ wag ea2':1.2'I:1g 3 1:3é>:*:°':}"3 ami wmkigag as Saieszxsam Pvt. Liigﬁ Ea;";ga}9r§=:.

T§1E:I'E3f{}I'€§ a éaisé.é§:;§§é§ce:'2';€:;"1'1:A Q? :::<3:'::pe::$ea_%i{:»::.

'i%?:if;h 14@*§l%§f::11{:€: 32:} iiitti ahavs saéié msai iegal €7:::§j:tﬁ::'§:iQI:;.*.§, 's;:zt;«.§fi5'2iz%ge aa:'§:f1.:§§§;" axaznizisﬁ as is {E} §¥E:€;t4§':§:~?::" 213:8 .%E:'2(ﬁr;g {sf fast I'E?£Q}'{}€{% 011 V <:.:i>:;~E::i:':£:"E.:32,13 iS§§'é;I€ £359.}; is 2»'3T:§at.e{i 'éhat }:i.:":'_:0':m't$ ts §I"Z'9I}%;':ﬂ'£i$ filidifigﬁ am": EZTGE" ii} $3396 ?

éﬁ; 'E'7:':&: Eiah-iiity .fast:a;'1:=xi {men {:33 £Ci{2>:'[email protected]§.ie:1 on 'me ::0m£:'3t}.<}1:s §SS3..E€ N052 is lagai 3114 tgaiid E' arid V {iii} %&?h€I1";t::* {3:}:1:g'}<:::":$22§é.<;;': 211%. 'iifiii in the {:Za13;::::a3'":f §:.:.§m*£=::3; $3}: $315: '.F1"'i7£;>:.1§.'§€%:3.__u§$. §?%§'i"

?;é'1:é highsiz' Sisieii ?

{iv} W%'":a'§ azvaéxi '9' 192 '$33 1";:«3§~2'<: <::»':;z'%:§"u1§}? i::s<:§é;§~:_;;§:':€§§ .f?{.E":e%=:_ {é§;2*;é;7§.§:'§;{;%r,=2' ;m<"1"

1'€:.as<:>11$ :"€:{::>;'{£€d 'mfg :'_%';<'av ...'VE";*§§::'::.,*s;:::'3;g:V§_.3'VL_:'--s$§i:¥:§ :*é::'f£§:1'{2z1{:;: €19 t§E'1&:

:}':';%.§*:'::~:} :*s;:<:<31*:§ gézazés: I1: i'.)'£;1I' <:Gsf:f::~:i§3.,€;:'é':{:E ¥'i€:1¥', mad I'fE§:':3()}"}S §'€<t(){)Z"{§§"E(i 1:3 E:.h£i 0:1 iiité qu€:$f;:;(>1'1 Qzf 1's33%z amé iii}:-°: :;%2'%V€;' sf {I16 é}ff&:1{i3'.§:;g igéiiitréiii', ﬁaigzg 3 :;LaE..uf:i{}}*}=" 'i':"§.§;u:'3;e3} aarhicﬁz is _"€3"1f: €§E7igi37é,ﬁ~. a:.:thg}:é1§§;' in €X€E'{:§:;'§z€f £235 3:3 cgrigiixai ;§':§:::*«issii<:§:i£;;'::,_A~-a:"::iA §_:>mi%é3r""a;;é;31y§:1g ms: 2:'.:é2"1<*:i ::»:}z'13ci.<}:.1s}§.-»' :0 $16:

fa5c*':;_:_§ Lfef iéigai svicizfincs <31": ;:'€€:@:'d _pa1'"?icmia:'1§g ' '»....x";9;x§.Pé',' E34'; @3113 ::'ig',E1'd§,r-" rez:Q1"e:§&::}z a fzzzgiixig af _fa:::1't }1<3§{Ei2":g

-. jv.?:3.j;:aE:, the aégééiazit; fliéﬁk piacfz <31": the {am} dag' {hm ts} mzsh aild ':»:%g1iAg*\3::.fA.:l;'i2ri:";g 0?' £316 <)ﬂ"€1';zdéng ¥€1'1iCI€ sf ?t.}m C:0I"f.}{}1"€it.i(}§} by its; §1f_§vaI*. We are rim. §§}"§1pI"€SS€d ik§}{}I'l 111516 SE1bII}iSSiGﬂ '$533; {$25. '~E.zsf:;§33';e:1 C{"}!;:I1$€I for the Elzarparaiﬁism wth I'€f€}"€3}(?$ E10 thza j11{i§"11€:2i. in {:l1'.3.;X¢E'§G,41 g2e95 agﬂd am $%§£t*z.:::E"a' bmzzgixt. is any zxotisa far the :'€8.:'.§(}¥1 that thé: 'qEj':f§§'§2;:§:';3§..V§1i{1 1'1f:::€... 2 take "Ema cz;:";si<:1erat:io::z E116 c::1i"§:."g1§1";ai__ p1fr3.<:¢fz:{i'iT:1gAS '=z.»1$=. E53: ata§.um:"§ Tzibzinal ;'e{;u§;m:'1 ii} .i3T1%:i;€p€r:£{i§_::'1tT}§;' s::;é;:éi:54_%t$ _§i11iH€1_V"L. 2'm(} mzqzairaci ta} :*€<;%:§z~c§ ightz-3 f'i;}'~:iiz':u§' fag; §§:t:- ciﬁztarztiazzg $32.15 ami arrive at a grregéegzf-:r';_Et<};;;1-§£12;;§:é$1}?_' Ti"i§C)?._EI1éi}. has did 50 in Ehﬁi i1';Séa:'1t are gzrzaéﬁia in acitaszpt 'ihé 115% :f:V2':'i~*.:;:VV :EétZ'i§Z'Ti}Ei{§ €i{>;::"}s€£ fax' {1(}:*p<::'a.£i{}:"V;' $518 ::a§;>r{:saici 311$} §";1s:é;s'2%E. am} the zxgahaziag' __ '§'1';e3;*€fs::::*s:, the Eirszt €§"z:$S{§.ef;2 £3 §iﬁ§§§§'-"€i'{3{§

8." "'T;'§t";a uS';é(*2€Vf} Z:"§%1 !§';:,:e§I5i:>.:1 is alga: :'€é;L2;%:'€:{i ti: ha z§;:3.swT{:;;*2f:t_:% V.§e;§f§:i:1_;:' Gf {ha 1"e$§:;€;21<%e:::*{.-slgjlnant. aim agééiﬁﬁi, ﬁ.".}€f £:':€m=:9};;a}s'sf:a§%:*1~.f0:é§'%}':e §%>iT1<m2i:A:g reasegxz H. iéé §:i':,§£§$§3L:£&é fact mat. er:-:2 aeccnizxz: {if Eiha a_{:Ci€.i::nt.5 E1313 =..€ii;é:§Lz2§3§":€...«s"a1s:fa:«2:%:'2s*::::i g*i€sz€:v;,:$ i_21juzy am: :31": §..h::: ':3:a2T$is tﬁf §;%';{a ..¢._32zi:ié::'§<:t: :1? $316: {ia>c:@r, fétze 553263 '€_§'::;gt= the ::Ea:71';:a:'1fiT has A $Fs;z.::;té3;iI1€{£ I{.}i}% par:§:£::1€:'2§;: ::£§:s;aE;}.ié::2::<;:':{,. 1: is I'8}{fV8;E3.§'. {:3 siaéﬁ at gjaragapéz 5: Q1' i'.E'}:3 izfzapugsxsii §1.1<.ig;:':2ez1§':.:~«~~--.

gigaxai in his &:2si:;i<:*:;'1<:$ that Ehﬁ :*§-rg:;§:':'£. hag ééf t%';:::__§'§;2iV::z.f.3};:':§ *s:a::_ 2 {f€éf§}§'3§{t§.€:§f£ éfmzgéaeii 21mg; {£123 ségafigt i§?L.:1*::1:}s::.* 'S3§3;1f.§:%{§__ é';-It,§__L;;éé3§§iS= was {'3G!.Zi§}§fif.£3§f€ igismzagezti, H6: lizag sf;;2i:.i::d *-mat. :"§§:§::;:'2<2if }:1is3:~"; ' L» $:_;f'§"$:'£~':€:§ §;:":3'u:"ie:s {£3 his waist. $E<;.i1ﬁ£"'f3_':};::; ?.;;§'1€'2:2:i:'*;'}§1T1?»:T<¥:fid Egg was taken emf}. gmﬁsd to §}':::*, :%.11§t;;:;::%:es_'£:2E;.%ré. i'::e7's::$%:;;1if:e{i ths gains:

fa his waiséz ﬁe _fu1"%;h6r $ta~?;.€{3 L'v%,ffi;:£?; _11";%::~ .A/§i§%§%5_'_.S{1ffE':1'€€i itjﬁfﬁ'?/é; ;}€:3':1";a3:a1*:i diSa§3ﬂiI:§'" :0 12;é:§'éy~_Ei;'E{:?:e1' 7:§£>j<i}-='.'. pan:-$31 if {he abave evidsxizzzaiz <11? :1+§ia::€;i{}g§" wﬁéiitii ' Ems 1'€:11a3T:*3€{§ '£{:2i;a}Ej; u:':1Ch;a.§€,:3g€d, <:tii:i;é;;% E35' sééifi ..'£'.§?:éi'. {:§ai;'1:a}':t'. Wag 'E3'e;a't.€<;i as i::pa.t.isj1".:i: i331z:.if;'. Eat":731133'*»§;§£:c<}:I;é'"Ei§§£3% tiisablecl £9 €:a2':T1 §§:;",:§;t.§3i1}g fzﬁxf __d<i:%11g 311}? 331); am {$13 atiézﬁr Ezamig he §}é%;S""€;€}"{§§f3§E*1f£5; {}§;"3'a{}f;h€I"'$ tE";r:;"a:g1';<;:L;.'i: his fiifs ff}? aii his };§€e:;¥.:~_.:§ Evian f«:3§*&::'E.iijm1{i%:':g {tails of the Hamre; tha irhamces E22? 'ware gigs CQ§'£}§}}€II€}}*" 1'"{i}€:§ gut. A3 E10 i}::€ as$é.$é:f;1é23:. --2:;f Vésaxiégpéizasatésm in §'€S§;*€C§;, Qf the i1':_§::I"€:§

-- Vv L'-..V'::Eai:11éf;3£ w:3 §2'2I1§;%::*T:3:E'1a desisicn 3%' the Herfbié: S21 T . C'; "t. ._ V. . J p1'*ez21e 311$ 7"TAT..,,?3?"1;§1e caéa €313?' .§.D.}~%?aftangz20E'§ vs' M/3' Pas? Corzfmi ffrzézlazj ; --. Qfhers :"epQrt&& in AL? 19§5 SS 755. 1%? para \«+/ 9 01" its gmi@1'1e:1§.111 the Seiiii cabs, thﬁ Hgzfbia 311?, :.§i§§:ﬁ:,{}3:§1€.' E335 ebsﬁrved as 1111:1551':

"Broadly siaaakéxzg, Whﬂéi _§'§<i:';g§ §;;'1"'a,;§'3é}iﬁ:§.-- AV , T c:<3:inp6i1sa.t.iG;"; pagfaﬁie is 3 _vi<:ti ;i:; ax': ;;;é_::§:iA{iv:::3t:v5*:.4."

the: damagﬁs Eaavsi in 1:36a2.§§§53€f:SSs:::i' 232:5":

pacazzéiary :ja.:<}:1age§ a3T;§§... xl'~$};>>:%§:ia£ .' "<:§ie;;3::§:§§a':s, P&C:.:ni_a:r}; t:ia:1'1ag€s é:~:-ré:~{$1336;f::}f:i.:§?i»:, "£i}i_1.»:f visstgixn. has :;<:'i;uai§§.i i:1c:_1;';*e«:§ 311:1 wlrgfiarjiig z=2}1"e.--~ﬁé;§;;;Egl_%: 0:' ix-:i:;§,§ {3E3.}CEi.§e'¥;{€i{i t§i:'::1i:é§ :I1§$i'f;iri_}i:u '2¥fi1é:1"ea$ 2"3,€;>I":» pe::*:u:1%9rj;~{§%:;;r:§§<f§S";~;i;§'s§; 'iéjggaa é§;}1icEi"a1'€ i:"1<:a§;ai:1s ef bang c3.i{':'L11ai;i£}';t:s. Ia':

<:.~1:*<:i<e1f ' ;I(}1Zi{'3€§3'{S pe91:1'u'a;'j;

r:%a31:;:ig$$._:1i;§§: _'i;1f:;<:3s§1»:1;éTA-~:::§gg€:n$z=:s i§§{fE,§I'Z"f3{.i EE}; tht: <:§giI:1a:ﬁ.:«..4§ ZE}é{3;."3;{"VL'-i_#Z',_f§"£§TJ€_iL?;TE'1{§a_"§'iE{3€; {ii} 103$ Sf €:a1'°2':.i§'1g s::s§f.T;lf;z'1'§*::§;*.%:T up "i,e::s.._ €1:.3'z€ of tééai; {iii} {:3.:%1€1' :1';e:§;'.63'ia§ E}{}E'}~§,"§fit{"f{1f€'1i§§§'};' dazzzzagsg £113}; i.'§'§{f}E3.{§£'3 {3} <_£::m1ag{--:$ _f:';;' ":;:3'<%;:*:;1!.ia§ 'éiiifafstf §}.§"3}"S§{?a§ '$h{}{Tfk'§ gzaiz: a:':=:fi $1:f'§%::*%3':g a;}'§"'?<:*<.«;2&§;-j' S'g:§ffe3:'ecE 0:1' likaiy 'S3 be $L3;ff€I'%Ef."§ in §1EI11Z'€; AA a:'§;<a:::;3g€:$ Eli} Ciilllyéfiﬁaiﬁ far iiiie EGSS Bf '31_1§%;I}i?.§€S <3? ﬁfe: sséﬁzﬁcka ma}: imrlmia 5; eza:*i.<":.tj; a::;.f jmati;€':'s. $1.63,, 011 aﬁfjﬁliiif £31" _iE"};}i,.E§'}' t;£":£=: €:}a§m;:m?. "z1:a§; mi}? bi? ablée Edi} Waéiig rm: 0:' 33:1; {iii} {§;a1E}é3.g€S far £§'1<:: icsss {sf €::»:§";€€i'at§:31: :31' lifa, $.61, :22": a::::@uI'2t. :3}? \'m/ i:";ju":*§: iihéi: zéamlxal iazzgézviigf 0? the cm:$::%:*13ed $§':z<}1'i;zi2*;:@é; {$5} iz:<:(::'3v€::i*;Lf':§:.zv3{{;:~:3L" }';£~23*€E$§':ip, dis<:<:~:a12f{;1"t, {Ei$ap§3<>i;";'{:ﬁ2::t--2T':?=5 'fi'21.i§?:?i'é*1i+"<>'£*:' aﬁiri :33€:'a'1¥:*a3 Si'}f"'f:"':SS in H562,"

Fzimixaz", in $315: case 0? .Ba3a%,;é::§s?*<,:;§ﬂ vs, .;i":.3.T'§,§? §§:v5§?" ?§'€§€ZI:?"{€€§ in 15;? 393:?" Kﬁﬁ 2399 :rx:};m:{ 3:: para 3 ef the Said gu{Eg111:«:z';'§. as;«z;:1§i:::A':' -- if "if 4§5>§%&E.féic>:.;-V:;f§aﬁ:i£§§i ;13@ ;i'{t'3E§€i}1'ﬁ{'1 ~ 33 i1':§§ess:.E:V 3:; '§€:;§js<}f:e;i._iﬁ§::ﬁ"%{'25:' €»3.::€:i{§::§"§.I: Cazéitg if; iiafiﬁiéi i.}?:§ £}.'§'s§.: 2:121:32: €3:1:i€av<>:;z' £10 gi':1I%:%_a"§3i1" __§::i<33'3{i:§,, 3%} far as nmna}--' can E}<::3;;1" éa:r1<i Si} ﬁiéﬁlrié gaézsd {hit daz?;ze2.g$, "

§-zxslgﬁiamt if C8131'? in §h€ Caﬁfi ef Riféﬁkaiesfz 2.129.? Qﬂ'2£3"'S reparteé in ;2§Q£': AQJ 3743 it is G1ZZéS€Z"i?€€§ at pzéfa <3 $3?' aha gizaiigxxlaikéi as '£'iI'.i{§€§':

V _ 'R553 3 :*<--::su§€.: €31" azzzpuiaiigm, 131:: ci§,~:i::1a;':i; haai ?>€é:_: E{"€}}:§{%I'5£Ti 3 01%" 18, H6 re: uéreg the heir} {sf :;:"§._:€{:.E":€:3 &'*éff3?E'£ fa}? *s::a£i«;§11g. He has EJ609136 Lmﬁti " "far 3:1}? 3:151:51 05 133311113} x5«:ark'. As hii W83 czagﬁer 8.

m/ $2' Iaaiiar aiising 1:133:23} werk, 'the azrapxxtaiémi 01' }":i$_ Eeﬁ; Eag %:ekm»* K1166, has :'%=;z1=:i.€:*té{i E11111: 2.111533. for E-zimcl <3!" 1:§1a:m,:aE wzérk. Be bag In} Cfi'£IC{%ii{}}"}'L" «' . A' Sxzch (322363? iii. is '$536.33 sézitiztai t}12«;%.E: thtzi 6{:@:';Q:i1i§: a"~§§1»:;iVL"

§'1,i3::i:ft':§i";I 1&1} <1i$a':}i};i"E'.§s" Wifi haw: {:0 «E33 5§I'€,3§f£:":e:V5¥" 291:; iiatalg swan tkmugh Size pk};-*'%;2i§ie2i <%iTss%';_§1iz§:'.= it; *_:1t3t 198 £162' Efi'€£}L" n u A V A I}fi¥;is9;iQ:1 Be:;<:.E'; };z:i4:gi3}k:::"i1.L._:§f f'g';hiV3S= : I;§:}A1;2;z#Vt in {he case cf ikfamsimha Murfizg 22.5;-1} _"1'f;2.e.44VA':£$;§':::fzag&?, M/'s.G*r*éen€::z§ frzgurance Co.E;ta7. ;---- .51':iié.g;aE:>;;rg¥".:2:3§::§"c§2's{:fher reported in 1&2? 2384 Kﬁffv ;§?4'?3:{f,¢%3S§{:f;«5€E»._:é':t ]j:sa§'é 16 Q? '€?;<i j'1§{ig'§Tfi€fi""£§i. as u11<:it:1':

" V. _T}":& 'U5:-Q E.,3i'§.$;§' ;:1i';€i 'T£*i}:31,:113;.15, in haéily i:a-.§m"'§; esfgfséatsf ._J?%%?T}";i§e aSI:a::$s=.i:T:g z::<3:;11;3€1+1$a!;:;<m, shimici 'sake » :i'r:t,a é3.¢=::€:.:2:;:i"§ fail reievazziz Cir::mnstm"1c€s, m*iée::f1<:€ .E@g;a} f§;~1ji:';€f:'i;..:;i€s; g0va:r:'1§:'1g qtiaxiﬁﬁcafiaxa {if <:?<;:s1;1":;3€3?1$;a7§i<A:41'2¢ §¥'13::'t}:1€1", iihc-zjg have 33:} appraach the isszze Q? a%za1'<i%1'1g ${}1:z1pez:s3ti:m Q3} tize .Ea:'ga%1' " A;:~zt::}fspé%b€i¥&$ Qf 311:"-::%:i{:&$? fi{'§L1i§}' arid gaod '-._zV:i:mé<::£t:31{;& arm €:s'r::E':&w :€{:.i111:{:a§iti@s in the ___€1::€:i$i<::1'3 1'11a}§§$:$g¢ Thaze s1:10uki be, zmaéiya E3191'; 0:: the par: :3-f £216 Triibzizzala a11€E C {. 512$ §:>:3$$Ess$i:;z"1 af <2m:'s 0:-Km b€z»:"1}«' i$ Elm: _§'2:z':~:t. §33";<1§§__;{:3i::v:'?<_"§{i'L:--._ -1~ V2:1}§.2ahki <:~§ 211} hazman :'ig1"1§_.:~3, ;:;1ai'_...§i,E;_1;§.{;VV ' --.::.-3&3 _ ;:.><7:ssass§iv:>§z am: <)'s2:=§';<:::':§%T:i;3 a:*&: <:xt.t:§;S§€;!_:::§~:'<:i__'%}';V;.:§ }:n*i:':z':a§*§=' ';:ig%":'i;., 'e;:;h§Es': a i213"::%i1'2g "'s:{:s::i:_;:ié:::';.:;¢2;t§{>;:;'V "

'£f:{x1il}«* i:'3_;'u§*i€s. Eﬁiigiiijgx £11} :V1,_:"f§--~ t.e:"§:':§: €.§'§3ai:i::%{.'; ;:1--$. Va {'}€}"}E'i§'E1t§QI};1§7}1§{t.21 s::"1'i,i:%<%:; a'v%E:vE§«f§i1zj1ua;{*2i." t:§?A_qq?£§*§:1:1aé§;§€:$. '§"}'1r:3 :§1:1s::«1_1nt 0:' da:1':£gé;é::s ¥a_§%§$:$;§a{3:§:<§§*{%3::g £.c§ g:"§é1V§:.}; uf iI'1j1E£""§€S. E}&§}':'fi'e{:é§;i:§:7€;}.::l* as a é'i?'f}ﬁS€{3}.1€:1'1{3€ 45;?' fg:zG{iiE§§ %2s:i'£}W: it i'f£";:*e€ ::::>2"1::fgé._a.::_vsi ' VE::x;-;s?$ mi' €:§3;'1'1i:':g 3.31%} £a1':1iV:;ge:%.;3$:'7§,$:%$ in pa}; a€;h€:r$ ;f<):I: av}*;3;if?'a§§}:;2%?§éé;€3--ha 35;-*--»:.":s,1Es::1"":'.';'a:f,«sT91' i'::E2'113&*:Léf a::'3<;§ {iii} 1935 $1' :fE§I11iv:iV':;2§{§:§L;15j: _'p§<§:as1.2§*:é:s-2 a:s;'1<i j{}y:~3 Qf 5 iiviizg. C'}.'1a::>ug'E':-- :1' Eizggézésggiiéisz ts; ﬁqtiiéﬁéiif I£}i}:'Ef:':}; §§?i?}.'}..1'E£§1§}f§aE§'1'~f?§"£.iff€§'§ﬁg, agmizy Eﬂlii p&rsv:.:1":;%l " '~ viii-¢SJf;j§:_?:*"1;""§'wf"_8;V.'§7'§L'i1§_§T}9 ¥i}*3::'%:.v---«------.;« .;"i'£:.»L1§3.a3$ am'! {TZim::*?::~; s§'::}u§:1 ' ;:::»é17§<f:..v_£:§f:'«.h':;z:ﬁ;€$t. fzéliii S€L§"i€}1.}.S a$:.€1€Z£1}.}ii {:22 aw£i'€§ .{§2%;:::9;¥g:5_§:';EsV.,_>3::%'_"far 33 :::{>':'1s:§; sax': CQ::2;§am$ai'»s: $25:

1033. {>5 {_*:i_23'§.:1g a1'}:;'§ ﬁazzzifzg $11m,§1{i aé€q1:a§'S:::":}js: 33:? £::.:>:21;3:>::'2s;a£:€::'%. 'E'}'i€1*ef<3§"%; tzﬁziiaf ~ {:é}:<:.$§:"}€:*i;z";g {§€:pF§"é!§?.iii0}}, "£216 'E'riE:e:_::'1a3s am": {T':{:u:*i::s;

"?.$}5§<§'£.":E{% E33355 <§L16.r€2ga:'z§ :0 {he gI'av§i§f amé tésgess

-.é}f {iap:'§;vaJ:i<>n as wag Liza ciegréae {Bf awa1'€:':e$s <31?' ziepmzatigm, It is {:I~:i-i:<ﬁi§ in avezaréiizlg aiamagtéa in g3€:1*-89:13.1 i.1:jur}f caseg, the &:f{}EZi}.§3€§"§E:§'::1f 11 :332va3':;%<;és:i M £1}; the ffimzrt. $%1{'za,2i£i 13:3 azbsiargiiai, it sixozagg";1§§:%.-if:., be, ﬁ'i€:§'€i1f{ {.G}§ﬁ'ﬂ {§a;::1ag:z=.$."

2%.': pam 29 in '$116 33311:: }1_:e:§g111e:1i'. thgi B§-:*i1";cr7i'1'-«$23373.§;";3_g§§¢ti«'tE'1:::

ﬁbservatieris ef Fitzkd, J. 1z;1a€ir3.7i':i_: Ehé'.c'z51;-';e Of Saunih Western Railway Cc>., (?z81?é;%4 QBD¥z:«{>T;5% Wm reacis thus: . ' Yea t::a}f}:1'::s§: ;3u.£'f" iﬁiaiigav 1 agaiii into his '_V_r,;;:::V}ifs'it.i%f;;:"'i1V._, b3§i§._Vjy;*£.:$§;:'*::i2_1s{. brizzg §;:::s2.1:' .z'€é§SG§j;4$a_I::;1:é £%G§§ii§;<§§*2'~-- "E1633; zmwii 355:1; :::'1;-$f:f"j§1§i?é;fa'S "3;-'.:Vj:<?:r.§ii':';%C':1';~~%"3:§:a$; 313$ is 'i';h€t a::11f;.._§}Qs;:3sié§é:z ._c'<'>:x':§3$1"1sa€i<:z11 331': be':

g;;'2zss:2i§ v._{T."§'1€EI'1fiEE€i' sszgéi; agam fiii' :13, _ ¥:>:.i.""3';:m~*-::3','- tf:i&:9€3§'e:*ﬁ; miéiif is gve him 3:13} ;1§::$a§:§§§§,' ::--:-2;--<36 z~;1::'l far 3.3;}. E.-Ea has ::1{}:":<~: ;"?;§_;c;2 %§'I't:1';g;"*--._%}$ has $uff<i:f€d a 'i«¥I'£§}i'§g 21$. 'ifhﬁ _ 'z-§*:_;3;i2tE4fé"'* s:i€:fe:"1::§a:2':<3 a;:§<::i jmu 1.32.15? §;a}{r:: i:ar€_é::":_ §g:?e Ezim Eu}! fair <"::"::::1§;2en$aE.§<):1 far V i:%1a?; i2§f};1ie::}: hf: hag; sz_1ff::3'f::i?' '?1":<i ssazigi fi§:1:;"Ei:':g gf' fair: is, 9;': 'E3163 iéagis 0f €:?{§§!€3€i. ::22§§::{£€:;;z:€:'A <31' ébf, §.}<><t%:Q:'. The <i:;;€:{.0r Ems: s€.::1i:6:{£ §}"3,8£€ il}§lE}f'€{§ V ' <é§:3_i£§::'a'§"1¥¢ 1123.3 S::ﬁ"(+::"*e::€% }E)i}% §;':§:'::na1f1€:1'3$ Emai {i§$ab£éi:1'3€§1t, agizéi m/ 1§ he hag bﬁcmm: the dead w@»<:e::'l. Thﬁfﬁfﬂiﬁ, 31¢ <t0:11p:3:1sa'£ia1'1 awa:'ded by the '£'r§bzma.E in '("116 imp:.1gz"1e<:i J"u£1g1:z1$;1'E 1"1~:=,_a:::i not he i1}.£:a1'f@ree:£ with, 'Thz: c<}:1{::.tz'1tTi0z1 Lzrgétd 0:1 t3€:}15:}:f--»;:§if_:€";3f;e €§e.'3rpg1*a'€ie:>:1 that ii; is an tbs Eaigher Sidﬁ (1fQf};I1€}'£f',4':§:.'2€V§?,§:(:f§:}3*§€é;1 " by us far ihe I'€§3.${}."E'1 tihat théz T:*§'E3L:z1a3;'i'1a:;s3A<:{}-_:111;1ii;'i§€:;:3 Qé;-€:§?§m;:3 eI*r{>z' E51 13:»? E1": 11%}? aiicepting E:x:.P5 °:~gt3§ii1§g !;I":;?r,f. it is' 3, gﬁﬂiiilfiﬁ de<::.1:ner;f. in the {:iaim ;;;<a§i~E._i,;3r:. V' *7%TT:"1:"': 'lfﬁiﬁpéillaéiit has" :":§€:a1'i§r siatad that, as 911 t_%2§:.v.:ia£:?:V'é£'V iéé"wa% war}_{fi11g as $3363 man, in 3upp<:2r'€ ' evidenca, he has ;3:'o{§Lza::e:{§ EX.§P5:1J':f§bi§11€ .:V3 (_V',*'.a'1':::'Vj*a.;,:'»::ep'c.e€§. the same fer the :'e:aS(n':i not exailximed the empiayaz", C€?.'T§iﬁCa§Z€. In we abstmca :;§"'t}1§.:f_., }§E":f)u1d net have 1'e<:0rded {ha finciing of 'vfa(:% "hQ1{ii}g§I?g is not 31 gsmxzina decument. f?}§i€?€fG§T§;; »§a;idh xf"11':€%h:g is vit3Ea£i@d 121 £95.52. Hangs, that pa:jr!;::'5<;é;j3T_<3:fT. is ;*equi:'ed :3 be iatarfered with by this ' '-...s{_',{>u1'£ '1_,_:_§': {3eIf_ 42 Rule '22, 33 appiyizag the r:1e:::i$§<::s11 sf ivihéw ..SupreI:_1 ¢":.C,gL1:'1: in Delhi Electric Suppijg ijzxciertaking Vs. 3:*:vm rﬁporfrmti 1;: AIR 2999 SC: 43. But we :10 110?;

l«u.,, f3I'{}§3QS€ to C18 it as thfft reapendent did 110?: {E16 1;}"V1€: :2 '<:?T:fczs$ ebjectiar; in this casssz. The dedu(:tio11 of M requimai in in}L1:'€::i Case that futm'<~: E335; Qf L..i£}{3£%"E>.. V' 9» that has ham'; dens 13:3; thﬁ '¥'1'ibL111;§iJl»AA»Vifs§:A4p;:ffgC%i}§ _.: vaiiczé, '§'h€r€:f{)re, it does 119% fjc§:'._:v.i1":t<it1*f6%1;*éi1f;i§: :%;v1 Comm. in 0111* view, havizlg jzlzét :1=§£.u§Lg i11ji.}I'i€S Susfaizaed by tiara €iai1n3i§:§_"':fi:a.i?V. 01'ga::1 minis, 0:": accotmt. ef_;x?hic§f1._21§aj ~::11}<3yment in his marital Therefere, the cGIz1p€::r;s;a§i<)11 by this T1":ib1_z11a3 is aész) }'Ei{}}.ii1i%:ﬂ _'3I'h_6: Hzﬁpfsa} is demici <3? H}€1'i'{T., Hﬁﬂﬂﬁ, the gamé is €Eisi?1i3S;é(§} Sd/-1 Judge safa Ivdge

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court