Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 4]

Karnataka High Court

Management Of Tractors And Farm ... vs Tafe Employees Union (R) on 18 March, 2011

Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh

Bench: Huluvadi G.Ramesh

f»)

E

[N 'Fl'-11%: HIGH C()UR'T 019 .I{A_RNA"l'AKA AT
BANGALORE ,,

I)A'"l"I{ZI) THIS '_I'HI:T. 'l8TH DAY ()1? ?}'I'A.I2¢ClF1_§2:(/:3':-i}; -:A 

"B I%Z¥*'()RiF3

-'m1<: H0N':;m: MR..IU S"i"IC'E  vA;'x)1;{;%.A1§!;_»§ 

W'RIT :>E'rm0N N().3:1335;2oo4 '»;1;w wlmf I5'E".l"'I":l"=;'l.'A{'}1v\"_V  $

N().2789())'2()E§§(L-RES}. k   
B1%;'rxv_£:EN  .%

1. MAN AG-EA/EBNT 6 ifr§_;xTC':*if%;) 'x:;§V:_,.:%?§€'i)V FARM
E§QLTIP.IVIEE$€_T     
ENG1'NIf;,ER__h\I_G IifL.A:S'__§f.1C.S"&;.' TQ()'L ROOM I)'E\/{SIN

;?L€')"1"  E  :F;iAi3'3:E'NEJJJSTRAL AREA
f)_()I§vi3,5\B;"a..5'{3 1. ;2<3~:é
REP BY ITS'S.fi£NE'€)R"fiENERAL MANAGER

(j'\k:'(§'iTZ_¢.KS.f) MR. 'E{_.'jL. _'};)IX1T '.P'EET'£TI()NEZR IN"

. % F  WP NC}.31335'/()4
 ".:.'§R§;z«'=«,.§f'1T'{1).i§"E§«ANED E*";'=\R_N1 EQ§El.P%\:iEZNTS mi)
& VA  {fT'§'«iA_{Z'.Tf{)RSA E)'['V'ES[{)N}
- "  _I-""1.,;(_':r%',Ff'15~.-'A (f}~~..i,
 .E<iI;é\;:EI)_.145V313?-$'II3£fS'_FR_I_A L AREA
_  E)f}Di3_;1'={8ALLAPURAr 5561 233
"*BANGALQRH
IRKEF' BY 1v1%;w RAE/IASLFBEQAMAN§\%_E.A.N§

 "  E)EPE.E'W <3E::xz£§2:m.:M _axz1Azx:A£;1%.~:§g_
 &%--':<1<:>¢ ,«PEZ'fETE{i}NEi£i{{_E.?\é

V'  x   §<1:§;r:.}::s:;:$$<>{f:;msa;a:>vs;

WP ;'\i'{i}.7£?%§§€§!€_iz'§



t..e

 1§:I\rI.PL(})YEEES' UN£'{'7)N :;jjR)

REP BY {rs SE(TTf{E;TARY

Nc::.24_ 'Ix/iiA.I3BU'¢'ANTH}"

G.K,\?.K. P(}S'"F

CHEKKA B()E\:£V1'ASANI)I€;X

Y'ELAI~¥AE\EK;~'x ; - '.  q     .
BANG;i\L--()R£~; ~ :s(»<%>c>e5   2   

RgSi?()NI>%{a%N'r  '   

{By Sm M C NARA.s1_;..é{HA_N.,  3:   t 
Sri K B NARA&';«,r~JAs§§v*'Arv1}a-A1:»v;--»..§€(>:< C:/:2.) 

THESE WRIT ;i£33*'§1*!LCs3x;%s .}{__E{13j"».:E%"1}_,.._EI3 UNDER
ARTICLE 226__ OF  COE:£S"1"iTU~T§{)N OF {NDEA
PRAYING TO'-QU'_AS§;H'  A w%;;..R:3 31:3'. 7n§x2(}{)£$' EN so
FAR AS 1? *R_i:uEEs;.():?'azxsic WAGES AND

sCAL.rE:s," % . _ 5;  IJEARVNESS AL_L0w'ANC1~;1
 331?? ,fsLL()'\=VA3\fCE._
ADVANCES AN'{f)f._RE.G'E£l;.AR.liZAT}ON CJF' CONTRACT
LABOURL.A'%1'_1TEEvi*.I\i'{)S.';1 TO '2 AND THE: FINDINGS ON
A£)E}§.TI'(«)N"21:§_, .EE§SLJ.E-S "1. ANI.) 2 IN m.Nc)s.93/2(:u3<> AND

 V.   AE\3E'€}&i}{_,R A§'€D M RESPECTEVELY.

 W'RE"[' PE;TIiTE()NS COMING QN ma

1' J-E~}éi:a~.a._§é;%E1<§%?;A;L;   1"é*}i_§s gm: TE-{E €<:}':;r'm MAEBE. THE;

 F<3L:g:>3;9:é\:@:

tegi
%"



KM

ORDER

1:: {E}('3:'~;{'3- rm} 13e.tit%<'>:§s. the <:'3r&<3:.' eiziied 7'.fS ;3{}A€{)§1"%-{'>%T I11:ius11"ia1l T§"'é'{}L1:i:'1§._ B;111gz1E<>1'é:, pzisitzii' 'i'x'1.1.El}.E\§0'5_,:9'3.;'f?(i){}€J.'ails} 45! E999 are qL1<:.:sti<>n¢:d by the §\«'I2111z1gc_;1"ii:.13t..

2. O2"; pizrzzszil 0f_té'1f: iz1§131':ght;.ri_ éniéizfl" passed, it is $6611 §;E§€*""~.a-?(:3r:kV:1£"'e:": <31" me TAPE, that beih the iiisgrzzies by I%ln1pE.0yee5; LE__iV1i.(3}3:':,»V' }1;;:e;"--13e?é:_:i_'. c()_f§:;._§c1£:i"%:'<f:--"'%3y the Tribugml 211.16 £1W£13'(3:'VV(i«:1"£:i§CiTA?;5,2{§§4 has 211l.<:m/i_n'g '£'h<3 E'4':3f':Zi"t3f1Ct3 in part. Tim T--z'ébun_;1 §' c:<:'..>n.teI.1£ima of {he UI"1i(>I."l. {hat :he1f;:--..i,§-_; <3>c.§3£c)ité:1ii§{'311"::>f"éE*z<: (3II}pk'3}-'(if£:3.'S" werkézag u11<:En:ér {he §;<;~ii{1";1<§%fié';:" v'"a:~:11<;E that away are r11{.m.: in mamber :;:<3nTapznf<:<i In 'pa:mi:1.1.3::3<:z:*g;:§\g'3y€,<:rs-; w<:>1'ki:'ég u§:d:3:r the EX/igzm-1g4::1"r2e:1t. E2: Ha:-izzzzi.

2;;/A The ?vh1m1g:3:11e.n£ haze; I"i':S%I"ii.2[.€3{§ its ;11'g;:zm:':ni' twrfgiy wiih respect {<3 p<>i.r1.t ?\2'u.24~ of the zzw-a1'<_i pzxsszsecgi by t}*1.<:V. ';'i"7~¥f'f§}isI;_11:2i :'ég;::'dir'1g 12: §g;_'L':i.::ri:%;:tior1 s:'1f<;<":t1irz1<:.t labour and ihséir . I1 is the c:>11t<::n.ti<.m of the k=:a'11':'1ed s¢11.i.L>{_ <;:(>:::i$ é§"z:ppé}:}r1f'1.g 1:: " .

:01' ' the i'£§£i1]a1gi3I}3%§31'It. ':.h.2:t., tha=:a':3 is am §2_i_9(>:}:3z' 1';:1;§;:sj::<:§:;1:;%{m "vizif 6-viaiefica, much kiss the C(}{}{I'£t{i§ (}'}7S 21I1Ci i,§3__t1i "»'\z"'VV()I"1<;.'I'i§€£VI'ftV'"§"iE1;§'€ not"

been exz1min£~:d:._ the "E'3':ibzu:1;1E ,11;;1's=i;§'nIj§'L.;}1'<)ceaiEe£! "to pass; the zlward 022 the bzzssis (3? the :.<_:t)nt'e:it§'()::__s;.LTr:1n;is::'iiw__by the Union to absorb them Eb}-"«¢_f% }:§ng§_mg: .x:é21g:é§':' .it'i3.;:___;f;i:itL1:"c3 0?' work being carrhsd out .:'t.i'};5,. the 4Céfiar:':u:.Er;31's', ':13. gs-i1'de:.1ir:g., bui}<,iing c<.>11stz1r;LI¢:ti<>:1fé:i;::C_§.;'§:::z1E }}£i_'iF}EiI1fg i:ic:.. which Cél'i'I'it3£i DUI on da}/'£0 £1212}? %,a2:si:s= §:1nd ":if_h'§52:"§.--~C()LI§d not ham: been gm f3,X€Ci3[€d. bf; {he pe§?'nf;2i1;a:r1i' i?iI"i[17_§('3§¥§§£:S <':=f' the PK/Ii'£I'1£Egi;Zi'!1€i1E? Since ii doe.:'~; ;a<>t '1:1'<\z{3i*;<3 mun_Li'f:1ct'L1i'E.ng ;1c.ti_vity. As; Such, the Ltiaim of the:
L?z'§.%r}§: %._t:ha-:t'"- fi"1f31'€3 %:é.W;;3>i;,3};<:>i.%;1i$02 zmci {hay éi.i."éi w::a1fk§:1g 0;; {I16 ' V§":i£u'§:h'1.ng:V{:2;§:m{):--.be E1él{3t3§}{<;i§i., " §3'cH:<_>:zi':':;L_ £316. E:':;::"2'z.:%:a§ <:<>L2:2:s:3.E 2i§}§':?{3;§§'§.§Eg§ fem' iE.":s'.~'. E5é2é<.:;2 hm; f:5é§§'3E'}'E§Z§'%;f£«§' iizzmgéz %;e§;*§.'1s <'>ii§ez" :%a'E<:e haw: §>a:~:§2 :'3i'1[.§""LESic'3d $0 the «;:<.mt;*;1<:t(_'n; {he w<)rE<s::r:; wcxrking under Ems: C{)I1{I'£%i3IOI' EH78 -mi) <'>1m=::'21té:1§; an {ha rr1zu:hi:*;:21'y 1'eg;:i::3tE}i*. _;-111d t.%1e:1'é: is :3;'x;;>I<3it2,1£.%.e;az_1 a1'1e:I r:";.c>:'<:: i3L'I§"i1b{3.%' of <:(:»I1'{;';1ctE§'__ _ w<_>rkiz1g them the p:=::'1nz::":c=3.n1 é3II"%pICI}:€€3_f3$; x§--'iir7ié;'i:1g':.1i§2ri£:zt {ha-' ' §\»'1z111z1gé:111c3nt.
6. On pemsézzl 0'f'.~--:1¥j1e iz1;§2{ig--1i ¢:¥. V€:v.(;;>.r:1 ii'%'sA na:>ét.ic¢3d ighai, the iZ€3I}'£I'E1{3t'('"}.E".'€ much iess;: the'-v'¢§ze.31'k_I}§£:I:1"»V¥'iI723f}\:§:"a§I hinder the c<mtra<:t0r l1;1w;:';"r<)t 'beer3_ e:§z:r.u3ne:i;"' '!%i-cfxxé»-'<2§:e::', to z:s;c:e.r£.:1ir1 as; to what is the): r1z:ET_L-ii"e_:. cf'"%E1.:i %€{,:Lsf.§{' ]E?€Ef;f1::'»:Cé§i§'I"iC(1 amt by the workers wiurkiirzg 'LEI1_{}'.A('§E ._E§1'CfVVC§)I1EIf§iC'§§}i' 31')-if, whether Eh.€:1'<: is :1 need fer z;boliti.e'§':a, of tile (3()Vi'§'i.if.2':lC€_. fz1b(}-Lit? and 21130 to find out xvhether {hem "+':'xpI.0it:;Ii.o';<1 .<)'f""'.L.Ehe vmr'k<:rs; wfirking iiftdiitt' {ha c0:z£:;:<;:t.g_>:" V-.§}":{:f"M.;i§2z1gen3en1 in dischztzgéng their razguieu"

V' _ :'z:1'{.:;i'e. «:3-E7. w<_:;"§<, Ehéé'2:'{_5éf:{:"2;1e:te;}1*5; am: {he u;;<:s:'I~:m:::1: wa.>1fi«:ir1g them ' Ezzéiie. j ;«.,E§é§:I;:a:;:}':':i_r1:3& be§'<_>1_'<3 {E23 Tt"ibL1n2:E. ,.=»»,- fla-

1

1 .~ §"§1:3 ;?:r:3..:':1§%§a:: am. '*3:-"§"§i€:§'3 that: '?2'%b'::22z:E ;i:§m::<;::=ds::<:§ in §§:§€::;.««::::s:E:z:% 232$ §_s;:;$z,::2 is: £'3E"3§:;,~" bazseai (:2: 353:: <3vé.<;§:i:z<:s.3 E.«:':{ in by fiitecz iim"

6

Eflailléigelééfilli witzzcsscs, wit}1ua:i' :.;1.1hja:3<:£i1':;:,i:_' {be c:<')11trar::o:'5s zmci the w:§1°E_<n1<2:2 w<>1"1<;i1'1g Lm<§er them i'(_n* 53X;-}.I"§iii1éiIi("3i1 _' 233;:-;:h[~..1css ::1'::'>s.~;~cxe1mi:1.21{iuz1 :0 gt.) by the :«;::«,-1r'1<§ 0%.' the L§~::i<_3I1.f in<:id<:nt.aI_ £i§§p&3{3tS~i imvéz bear: t;1k<::13_~mI.(>4 c:{'1:isid'{é3"TaVj{i<'>§i' thjcgz V Txfibzmzgi witiwut §:;<:siI1g into the I1é'i.a":"i,1I7t:"..{¥A{ ti1é'~:;C£iyit}?"tgf131"iwS_ bzimg {:£,i1."I'it'3d out by each of thG.vL4§£i~:)_rkmé1;»._;md_izivfhzis }5i"(')Ce-e:dedVV on the basis; of pr':::.<;z»:1np:.i.;)11 i0";3i'1*1*§«.,_{r;;{: a%"--:;1._ c<>:2cE:Vz'&:i.<j)h, aithough rm <_)the:.:" eviciemsc is; addL1ccd depict that {ha W(.)i'kIYi€1"1 11a1xf~c"':T 3;} <}'isa:E:a;=ge<i"w 1j§:'V1L'«.V"'».'£.5(_'_)_IT.:§< in Em: _pr0duci'i(.m 21a:Eivi.ties.
H'{5:'2cVé:'§;.,_v H.) :";E1a\-'£:3 's«:_:._§"ficie--r1t r:':z1:eri.21i ev§<,Eenc:::- 0:1. .z'e<:<>:'<:i and :0 ';::'1'i.23:3 :':€,_ :1--. fu:~V:4i"--..c€'}:":bIu$£.<":n. as I'€:g;2m'E:~»; point N<.>.2?,4 wE1<:?§E':::=::'_';:hc::':3 i-:»;_;i'11'<:c:Li 'i"m" rc=:ga:i;:ri_:s:22tic>n OE" <:ont'1'a::{ iubnutx the ma,i:{'::z' i$;. :2;=.._;f1'1'iA:E;_t.::<.§ :0 {has E:1c§L1s:;i':*i2:} T;'.ébLn12'1§ and i.iba.:'iy is give:":
Egti'-'.E_i::<:"g3§i';°?:.é¢a: ;"£33 gzciétzw thczig' if3'«'i.€;i€313C€3. The ;1waz2°d 0f the "i"§'i§iu:2;i*-IA §5~: §~;:f?;. :1-::§i.d@ €)I"i§}=" {'0 tilt: ::>s:.E::n: of fin:;ii§":g :'<:¢<_>:i1;i€c% in .%'::":;~*;§;"-:':::c:' 5).?' ;'3a§21'£. N{"}.17_?"x~'3;( §*§::*m31~=e:', £1 £5; s':<;3.::c:iE<::s:;;<: is'; s;;:5;g {E223 Tribu.:mi shall ;:»:"r;3<:c:ed to §T)2iSS orda-:1' as *;}.I1§§9%E:~¥§§€/Etlle pg'_>int:4 0?' 'X. 1'cf::1'c:t:c<: mzxxz r"{:ié..z.'1*e.<'I {cm only in 1'€.s}3{:<:t. oi"§_mir1: Acc<'>1'c1iz:§;E3~'. §,x~:.tiiim3>; 21:1: a%.E1§>".?§?é{,i' <iap;;:11't..;« '. Bkp