Karnataka High Court
Smt S R Saritha vs The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd on 24 November, 2011
Author: N.K.Patil
Bench: N.K.Patil
__§_ Hi ":*:~§§: :~»::{;a {:§>m23%"' agg E{.§§E{?a§A'E:i':E{.r% 52;"? §e:ANs:;AmRE m;:'§::T> 'E'HEE~E% '§'§~§3'., aw EEEEY <3? §w%'{}Ef§:§v£E%E«:.§%; 2::,m_ yaaaam? ~%*<' émgammfigmaJmfimENfi§§§g ffy £a.f~§ E3 . .
"m§;a@NBLEnfiaJ§$mc§§:S§R§g?§§R$@_; *E §fi¥§N0.439? gaaggevg «.f= BEWEEN: 3 {*9 3' Smt. Sa:"i?:h;:1 W/0 Shia-f2;:$hamE@a1°;' = Aged abaui 23 y§:g::I;°$,§ V R§3.3:idiI1g at B1*21hn1a{_12:r21§;1aifi ' ' _ CwL!€ii%}§Eii{§*E?fiT{fi;§§ii3~;ig.3 " .
Kaflari§}£$::f£<EiL; _ ' Appésiigmifi
{E335 G ~ §'f<1'.:m 3 2% gmarié 21¢ Fi€§'V,}
Amfi: °,A. _}'.§
E' "§'fz*m: {}:'i#:*§.:§a2 E:::SU;:r-a:1{:{;% $3 Liffi.
4. 133,2 iidm' 22. E .
'A {Z%..'2?E'§';i;¥a.::r_:§r:=jt,_ f'i€a_izT;. E{{}2i{"§, ~"§%g§ywe;a E33; Ei;E2::;'a:'§::*:".
2% "%€>%?'{i'f'§'}:.j;:«E.fi§z}:E_i;r§':t':Ef.
§ 5 a.2?a§i;2::2 @212' AA '§E:'Eaj:}2: E%€::'~:=»;'§{i§_::§g Ei.2;'§£a%::12a;;;:%:W::"z;:4 :'%:2'::":':;_::'1_2zi.§asrs Fm:-;2_s E{<;12;:.:* "§';:":'E:,.:.E<; T<I§§E{§ §f}2Zsi~;§T'.1"i{'%'::. §{€E5§§}{}2'§»{§€?fiiElE%, {By JE§§"':§, $3', Hfigde ?'€E:i§.§<;}"é23;2}{§? .:'%i§v. f:'§_'_:";"'§i;i> }{',,_~ Eaéf §_.(;:r<.r.7 Pezrik ;'%:~2;s@<%§21i.%;%s;, fez" "
Tilsisz; MFA {iii-iii 'a};.I"i{§€iE' Se5e:7.é'.'£{}:<fs.. ¢ 3.. pmyingg' K} caii €03" I'E?€1{}}T'dS~3', :11é>;d:if§:..£1656'--_§i:e;ig:1'm:;i: amrii 2m»*a;::::§ in R:'§."'a.rC{L N<},3/2963 {i;i髧i3d'-._{}5%}.Gi.';?;C£={}5«.<é:j:"~f§§:'£>._ fiké (Bf téké-3:: Adgiia E'xf£A{'f§I Ci1£.;:}:abé&E§21'pz.::* T.'é}f;,-* iv"€%1}}'}Ei§'§1{?§§"i<{§ V' <:{}:z1p€::':$21€:i<>:': §'m:";;2 E?;s3fi5.3{3*€:§,u{3';f'p-- 'U3 3.:1{§."
2223:} e§2E1a:"::t€ i2":'Le:°<:%sii frcsm 60/&:"'g}x2a, is 8%.. 923, E '§_"§1is:3 MFA <::<3r:1«E.1é'g;?>;_' gm 2; ";}r::¥"w--_'Li2';z <Ai:nb§§ss:e§@'r: §l%1§ss {Ea}; fVE;§{g EATIL, «£3 {i€i§w::":;%:§. Hm'vf0§i{3:f*;'E':*:g:.5 x "§."'E":r1::e§ v--<":f1e1iunj:2m»t' 2:_:'.i$<3s am': 5;? the §i:2;31.:;:{23eci "§:§1';}r§1C:':_"'~j_£);dgm{§£1E: ami awaré; datsefi gm}: ,2.m ggmegg Ne. 3/2:383 9:: tbs {fie sf ihfi C§'%s§§_ &'a.:<i§;§~;.= {Sr5§3'*s}:~fabEV.2{.::d JMFS 2.-md §¥z§s33::":'b€-.13 Adifi, '_ IVE,;_1'~s;{§'"fl A{?E:§{7E§b::E«ia;§::§::: 'E'fn::=: "_§'r§%}:.2§.22'-ii E33; E33 §m.pz;gn<3{§ » =;{%;,:§§.&;_§2::§:*:.%§ :«:;:*':::'E_ 2;a:.2.r.:a§§'<§ §r'.=3:s.-as é§,E%£'Ei.§'{.§fi{§ 3322:': £22'? R:%=55?«3{}8;' --
" {>:"§.;§«i§%:?§;:~:':_'§: 'f?jé.'::E駧E&s :.%2'i%:Ea i:1§:§:§'a>,$E: %§?%/E; grxza; §:'°z':':i:: §:'§1{: iieiéis :35'*-.;}€'::g%::{>§'j:L'3'1}? izhat szégziifi 5:2? {,§s3:p<;::a=3*;i;., am Ei{'f€i2{}E,EE"E{'. {sf 3.32%? :1n'j§':.22:'%;éi§ijf{*E1;:,::4::%i..;::._:Z:':_e:=:é E:a§;" 3.131%? ::E.22§.::1a::':§. 22:55: :{<>22;{§ 'z:"'ai'§§{:
£§{f{?§'§§€?§1§. 'E'%:ié::"<:%.€'<3;"€r. 31%;': 22s,g.};3€:§.§;mé1 £2263 §E€f{i':{?E°:?§:?'-:=§§§Z«;':E§é'.{§_ is §_:2:°s;?sss¢?::?; i'.§'1§_:<s; ::'.i§}:§}€:f2fi 0:': '%;:§:.<i: g§::.":,>:.::'2<§ %;.h2:':? é.E:::% a§:.szmé:.2_§::': 3%"
{::'m1pe;:':'3.s§;2.%i.§:33": Eii2%?'E.i§"'€,§€€§ 'i%:r§f €319 "§"':°§E::.:;:z;::TE £3 i:"§::§§@§g:§&?;a% gzmé 1.26: :65; €'.E'iE1§€L§€:?d far <32": %:2::':<:e:;:m€:1':i. {}§ ciéxmpe;é$;f:.£:i.§f%§: "
2, E*'§:"§{-ii' fagtis {sf iihéé :':as+s<-3 5-121:"§Eé.:§"i«§;E':§;: 23_§;'§_}{%§f§:§31f}.'Ei' '~§J'8.§f% §t:a:.Ee and h-%2i.Eé.h§.-* §§:"'%.<}r ':10 _E:?1<:=: a:::::§.€E--@:r*:t, ""_'s«'/'T.§'."<}i;.Ii'iT§.'",§' i.§§i::§;$'--.. i;.bu§-3 §~3i{}r:;§d<, i;h{~: ET3:"iver mi' i;§?:2::.i '{3§i§€1:2z:£§;r%g ""':;§hi<f'2;€ due tat} rz-181': amai :':€g§§;ger¢ V:f"w-A_d1'§i;i::g . &;,s:s;ed eigéi§.:':s«"si: Ehfi app»r;'%E§2:::*ztfaéizaériggmé; a:§2;_§ ' the: a;:;§2é_=;E§smE'; E=:§i.iSi'<1iI"§€€§ §':':§iCi,:}s;s:'s;é :3f'°:r:?§;,,gf4'E1"sL" €6:f'n;.;.§:'-- 23;;-":--::§; éihssm 11$ :;'E3Z_ssab:i§§Tt}? to iihe»"E*:@:3,g§'g.,:3§. "'1£::,?3'?zE;"-.:§n(§ Ezzeég" 21:15: .§.5% iio the. w'n;>E=£%':,V_E;3<}:733.r; V hzgéi=;i§;-dafrgmga §:,:°e3.tmem. ii}? 21 gieréad 8? E5 {E22358 _21::€E_ Vii§v§:Vi'£§::€;E"%.?xE'n{:3'£fiZ 9:18 :':§:,zrg_;<3r}_-* emzzé impEa..ms 'é.5,:s.?;*::~c. SE19 °Eé2:;<~:; $pa>:::E :*€a:~s§:e11;'?:bEe 21z':§<";u.m':
€n:>%;w;..?é:z.r{i${misdfgzjrgéi :12:/:.§.:s:§zs.%a1:5%, étzémsézjgaizgiaa .:é€}:,:r§:'=%£?;§§':g;§ {£35351 .2:i:§:s:s':;:_Ve::'fz:.-.< ':::T§3a:rgé3$, {§§€%1Ei%}§§§§§€:ES§ <§§sés{:£s3":f2f€3:°':. '§"'E'.:ss: "' :;%;.p-%;;»@E§ :'§;._:?s ii: 2: g3<;&;iié<>§': £5; {£9 E263' w<>a"§§ s:'gE':<=: "%2%./'£.':S {§{}§..:'E§§ §':"2£:';_:*jj'.:if<} iirzaé ;:<:<':%;{§sé:':é,1 "E'2::<;i:z;',_{ zrgfi §'.'§3€§=;€: 2;é;§--%;§}f;E{Zf§ZS 312%? 22g3§_>€:E%22.:";_%. E'::»:::%2; §i§fi'.{§ <7:~E2:é::"§ §_}€f.§',§:§i{."§.E"%. :;§.:1{.%:::2:" :§é;é{i:%;;:':,::a "ESQ; as"
./K;
.., f.
$25? §s/5,3 33$'. ;2:g:gi£:':$%. "£3316:-,* €.'}%':s'E."a€',§",_, azzzi *£:§;'§%:? Ezra:-2-;u;:"<?:<' gisi' E:h<:% <f;§"§7:=t:s:<:§§n;g ::%::E§%Za:éE{;: '32:,-?.. E.é;~"%§4f_7§ zriaéfzzz g3iéi,é§:§;:>r:. E12153 ;:::{}3:'::_{%~._1,:;}
3):-3.§si;r€ 'éihe Céaglzérsa 'E'ri§3:,:;;.'122_i f1::é'§.' 13:31":sE{:§{;%§"a':.i<§r:*--«. a;:i:;§ _.__§i:. 'Sum éhe: T'r§§'3u.f:'1;I.:§ 2%.f£:<:::§" a$sse§35si11;_{ t.E1:%_ " {}'I7£'§§V*""£i;VV?§:{§ V' {§<>a::zm&:";?é.a.:*§: :';'3"J'E{f€';?§}{f{;"t anii {>ijh.:i%;f_ :"§§1éi?:§;:T:.§i_':. 1:EV35,§ 3:'§j7"§"i€"iE' "
zaxsgzéizibie gm :e{":<)§'d E22132; aiigswéffi E}-;€ };:§éf:é:1*;A.. §:':é3?:'if££3n;iz1 paréi. and am-*2::,;**i§:-zsgi §:<>mp€';f:§3z3.i;i<}3é--«{3f'fF{s(fi5£:§{}{;:,/'-- :§.:2§'aE»&é:"W go ciiffereszat. h§=:a<:§s "with 8% 'izgiiercsgi: 2-r<::%:;<: "§%:¥:":€:2 iiéziie sf V §3s3T:.§E:i<>:': iii}: the «:§.8:£:€ (:3 c§s::;;<}s<s_i_%_;_._."'-. _ -- ii iiiééi-e.--s;2;.{i--&if§@{i Efififé 'siaié €§Li&IE§'§3§E'E sf «:?9n1pé"§';5:=,«é:€t.§{}p:_ {E19 '§';f'?;_bz;:11aL the appaélizmf; %"_2_2:é5 E3'}'€if-ESE';fhE"§.§'f,§3{L: §%z:;_*, §:~:s:'.:af:%;4 3.33;):-393;: mg'-:«E<;§:'1§;,::f €::':.§":::--m<:€:3f:a€::":'£, " '~ _ gf..§;_{§:"::ap:;%::.§;1%.§0?:; ---------- -A "
" §€a:":':é:=:z:§; {3:'§:;:§':$e;%E :3._§::§;:'iar§:'s;g; far 'é,'§,<:":
" V, :f<:s~;--g3<}:'2£<=:§':%'.~§:';8:.2r::%:".
2:§}§'€§§a:f;:€:":if2.::§ §é:az"z1i:rd :::}:1%:";;%€:'i £:g}§:>:2:r§:':§ fa; éthe §:?.2fs%:. 3 ;%.'§"§',e'~é:* €f:€:I°€'? £1.13 §;3ez'z.:s:e:aE <3? €::§*.'::';'-=: j1,:€Eg§:1{"::'1§': :1}? ':;?r:@: {lI}§_.2:£m$ '.§':*iE:::..:.:';a:i? '§£»='EE£i§i é-fmé-:=.s*g;€s :3 "éifégfl: {E26 ::1pg3s;=:3,§2:::*£. E.r;;%23.?'.r31<?:m' i}:_">:" 21 p€:.1:°.§.0{i Q? E:% :%aj;;s§ E2';§3:?:§VV£'<;-233:" "azaéfi §i:':('::_.:.:*:"s2{i E'm;;;*e a:11<3:.:.z'1'z: '{{3w2z:*d:;:" §fi€3'::';.i;::21i €i?;2".."§:é-'f;'»Ti_:Ti~':€.;Z':'~VE" :&§,I'i{§ ssisz} u;'}_{i<3;°g<}:1€ €2,133 $:3_rg€:"};'. ".§'i:}§.%{=__ E;E.<,;€i.e:>:' {§i:<~3;:e:E}:§:*i;.y :35 15% "£0 i;h:'3 wh{}Ea:ff"'E:s{:d::. ".§_"'h;<:s .'E'1*i§::maE hag; §1{}€ 2;:%,are2.:*é6:(§ M§L::%;éi :"§égis<§:r2:j:%;§E/:~ ;"m:<3::':z'§i m2,1.-'a;"§$ {If{}flV€;?:y'£1i'i(7€f, r:»:'mr§s~:;Ir?:E11g §GQa§. ;i;:f£{£ 2-;2£;'€%;fifg_:;¥;;:.::%:, c§'1arg;é~:s3 ané <:§E$abiEi':,y 2s:1;f£4{i1 .:§Easr:§f<>:€§: ';f£§":«ii' ';:}hf€%"':sz§:>.;§<%i§21nt: is; mi"): in ea §_'s{;»§ii.£<:s:1 §.<1:=_ :':a:f::i§§i111i'a' E_éi:=5~, '*i1f%§*{3{E22f§i;:)ii due is the i§1jE.1i'iii'S S"L£S:§ii.2?:E,_I1€("L_1AV' 'i§7§:§EV Ti'§§G%1i.:};&1i _has :20: Eélkfifi zzié 'éhesss §°é3:E€:*J;m'{f fé3;{f'i1§§'E"r'3> V '»€:'1§:§'§E€;if:Si<i;é31°a.:§.{}:s1 v:%:.i.E€ 2m*a:'di_;':g€ {Tfi'}E'.§'i§}1€f1'§_§§1¥£i'Z'..§ am. _ V " "
€:'},._. §*§(:_%;i::§;«.._r€gg2sz{§ 1:9 ihfi fairmaaifii 22.$§}s:--*{:§:5&~; £3? iihéf: .nr:2:é_:"§:é::° .:%{%i"ci?:;§f%;':<:5':'ii é;a§'§_<wji%"V%»Is§% {§€3&E1"§ ii: p:"'{}§}{:'.f '£19 2i'§%-";%§}f{§ a $12.33*: 9%' ' i§{3§G€}{}"--,§5~ "£:::;::v;::"{§$ @2223': and 5:s:z;§E:*.:°é:z§§? E_{}5{}€}@;'-- " V, §f':i:a2,:;:_.r:is;9 :"§:€{;%§<:i:;:§ i"f}<;"§§}€fE'ESz'?*.E€% psjs' §"E"§%Z'i{§§{.'i2§§ %}§E§$,, {.;g:§§':"<;="<;%3222;::§ieg §':{3:.:2':E§.E:.§§3.g §<::<:<§ §:'fi.1'§€§ a:.f;i;:€:2;":<§;m§, :t%12;2rg;§<3:s:
U;-gw §3f:*$,.§?,{}{}§}__.f w E{>1%Jz§:'{i+.s' §<.>§eé:~3 <3? §:'2::>.{,;:1:@ {fEL::'i:'1§_.§ 3;:'§:;':_?;;:3":€:r1f; 9' §i}fif:"§(:2=i.i Rsxiiéfiéiéé/~ ;§}€":§" zzmzfih fag" :1: ;}€:*§<};§»~_{§ff_ 5 m<7:m'.h:-$9 §%.:-3;' §C24i'%G{3;'-- "§I(i§".-E/"*c'-'s,§"{§5%; Easssze -535 A'? :iE5:~;2:%.<}§>:';Ei"1<):"L :.§1:%m;:s§}§:'1@$:§s 2-ind §7<:s.'E}'}i2{3{}/u --2f;_§3?§%:;;:.:f;::i':+; "£<;:.c§;; V' {}f fm:a3;r£3 iz1<';~@:r::3 {§€s:ai%{}{}€},'w X X_'§. §:f "
Eéagé 2.2pp€:§1:1:':::;'{:E.2:i:':':;1_:';%: Ijc%_r1'E:i..€.¢E€::E 50:2' 5.. E:<::};z1/$5 {'.{}§"§"E_E}§;'?i'ESéE§.?;i{}I"§ £3»? R$.f29Er6"?,€EG,'-- 215% Véi-gai:1sE _"_E1?;é;;v8§,,E}4§'€;"}f a\2var<:§js:%€§ by ihéi '§'2'Eb:.ma,§. "=;'*7_§3';::r:f:1% 32.31 u9;:E:.gué5ié'::T:e%:ii; Gf "
R3,9€}j}7Q@j~ v;§i.h i::iQ:"€$':: ::;>:_{_.__ 96"7..'?/vE_:z ;:j;_.,a. E*.:~§«:Tj1:_ 513.1316: :2? p€:i'.1§E',§<:3':1 iifi '§i.h§3 {E21116 <3§f %2:>211§=.i§21€,§<;;:?:;.__ ?. E31 we améi <i.%:ire:é'e,:m$E:z1z1{?es sf Ehe :és'"'g;:%;'etr_§ $2E_§'}{3'.£é':;'...'=tE§"i{3 §.r:$E'.22.nE zzppézzzé §i§.6:§ by the z:g}._g*;%éE%.EE.gjsgf§E:, ;1§}i'{fi};;-s34:E«'§;r1 p2'::"i;, That §.mp:2§;§:1§-3<% j::&gm_a2::%:
L' ;;:;:s':}:i' _2?:'x: gizzéfiaé §'*1"% g§g1§m2?::'§;" 2§C%€:'» §3E:'LE:'iEé%€i{§ in EXEVC ?€3s:}_,§§jf2§;€%:§3._:>%1 €::Ew fiée 0? Elhi? {iivii éuiiggzi-3 {$§.§}a!2':,} a:';::§ (§?¢EF{ii_ A;1'=..§':{E Aéiaié §1!E£:{?'§1 fifiééiajéigbaiézrgpaggx €54; 'izaémééy V' * _ §*:.":._<'>a:.'%;§EEa:-:s'§ ,i "M. MM v""'"' , ii .-..-a '§'Eést=. 2:;;§3c§E2{::":'i: is; iif§'1"§'.§?.'§%f{§ 22:: <?{}§§E§}CE'1Sé§.§.i§E_1'1 {sf 1, E 9Es€EE§2{E{};' ~ 2318 2::-zja§3":sE<;':T R5,; , €35; 5{}{}j anha§'1<ta%:":§_s::~.:?:t: bejzgg Rs<;a<}{}?'?€3*(3;'~}%2>z§{2§:g E'E§i'§".§ '§.Ei:'E}€f.§;'&tf;?'3E." ' 8'?/o gm; 'E"r{>n": ikze {§a;::<;é :31' ;>:%%;i%§:E{}'::« A_ {£11 .;{:fiVé . _dVe::;*€«' <2'? :':;%3&i;<:zz§.i<m, E? 13%? r<ésspe:me:§.<»;%.n'§: M Ez'2Si§§':c3;* 1§s~;.c';.§:°é3::§és;i "é',-.<2 V{i?€'p<:S£§ me ::e:1%1a.nc<::§i <:{;§";1p€:':.é--:;rc1t.i{}::§""wi'§:§.:: i1};1Zg3;'ess€:.'"W££:h§:1 E",h§"'€€ urszséks fimn': f:.hc:'é ciazte €)§°§"é1{§:€fi§3i'i.':{§'§' 21'_.§?AQ.§jA')::~(;v'.£;'3"§'T_{E16 ~§u_d§§m€r:i'., Gm": of f:.h{:_ {V/§?5§E§1Eij§1{3€'3C§;"':§1ff?;Q.'§;§'TfifiEv.§3§iR;f:3.90,?®§f - 5@'% w:3::h fmfcg§{$§"*£.i::«r:a:}@ §.Tt:i'1::%:f<::.sE _' ssimél be §E'i'i--'§'?.§-3'§Z€C§ in a 1'€a£,%£>:";E.§«$é3¢:13.;'S<:§;é%z:§};:§_&é::§.. £101" 22. pe1"§3:>(§ £3? 3 j_.f€é"iI°8 :"€:2€w22E'}§eL'~--._V £75: é:.:5::":ff'§.f:€:* 5 §'aé2i§°5:g am% the: Ei§:i§;'{1£'?'fi£'.§L§'*E'§'.,'; a?i§2§}i'§*::.2:_;";?;', ;3.:-is +:=;m';§£Ee{£ §"j{} 2azE'{§":dr;2,w 'Q16 Z%E§§i€§§"'i'::f§.?, '%'7E:"§s 3.*€:;n2zji::.i:'1g {>5 éiéafi :i:'1§1;:§'2;::<%{§ __'2§:E:;:;;<ié:',2A:2'7gE';«.§3it§:«.j§§§is:>p§2:"é,§<3::2:é;s i:";i;e2'€5sE'; s:;';I1;:EE E39 .:°€"3E€;::§{:*£i ii: E":-§a*:§':L:_:" 5.11%" "%,§f:j;:*: .é:p§;2s::2E§;':;§3é:f:3Ea§:::a::"é §z:z:":%;éd§23.§'é:%E§; 572:': {§€fi§3={}:'=§§'i'. j <1:§"i:§i§:é..S}:::':3€: Eéjg tE":€% W :*:=%§::p§;<:'::':{§@:':%T. «» §EEf~f§§,%E"€Ei / x 23>'?
Rbx;-*""
wggm {3'§§§<T.*{? 3% <'Ei:'::%{:é:&%{§ 'Ex; {Er2,::>v 7i'.§'E€ ;2;2.a.>*e:s_§°{i a:%{::<::.*{i§z';.gg§f;=