Karnataka High Court
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co Ltd vs B H Lokesh on 1 September, 2010
Author: L.Narayana Swamy
Bench: L.Narayana Swamy
3: EEE ffifivfi QOEJR'? Q5' K§£§A':f2%.m 3:? Ealmakgafia
§A"FiE3 ms 7% 35*? my 5%' SE-F"FEfx§BER, 2{;::g<:2
BEF@R§
THE I-{Q1-mm &.fi.»,-.I'U$'§EQE L.§€§R§Y$£§$§ T _% ~ J
mm. as. 1a"r94g2m:gfiu_;§% %
ézifi X -
mamas nmzawmggmg
gfiéai 33$;
Nazifififig Qaaifi '§.'°g*}7"$31fii"'§
E35, "
gay $r:.§é;§e:g2m}:, §.¢.i~..»+;
V' " ..... .. V
V' 'fsgati 2? gaiam g
. _ "31 av " if-§.é£:1;m;_%thm3.3.ra
3:3 réwfifig Anm§; Layauég
2*§'ag&:: §Eti51'za§i§ Egalsra-5% §§€a.
Sezytmnl, figara Pfifit,
Bafiafimrg-$60 fifiég £2 $§§§BEE%""i"§
{By Sr'ifJ'zahv§a:LatE1 S, 311:5 , 2%? far E1
Rag aazwcié
'V 'A ' ,:i'55,"1?f&a£';1$V.1mr* Raadg
WA fiiafi miss 1?'3{3;} af Eeri'? mt agafirzst £2533:
juégmaizt and award fiaiadz 1&4.f30§?' pafififiii
Pia. Slfiéfgfi an thaa fiis of rim Efifigfifiéi, ;§13dg$g£:"3fa2.,rt
af Smafi Céausmg fifimkr, Egfifili, Mse'a*rs§s3it23;f;--._}§_z's'&4¢:§
Bwalara, {$?£';(3?Z.E'§~ar.1fi}, awzirfiixg a $$m.§§'f};213$.§§¥£'§ rgf.
Rs.1,39,Gm! - with fiitfifflfitl @ 6% pa fmm--.4':t£1g:__;§:a;i::: _<;:§;E'
mtifien fill fiapasiz.
W' 55
:
B.1r§*Lomah;
Sis} I-£a21u&r:thar.a:,<zap*p;&,
Agw akzufiwyéam, ~
R} or 33.28; A.z1gaéiE;aaymu'£--,.f_= __
Eiagmetfiifii, V " 1
Eazgaicsrev-;Q=%; ,"A?P'ELL§.R'E'
{By Srifvxg S; ' fsévsi
...........................
1, Ezmtzram Cs; Lt:§B§ '$.13 13'?-9~.;§§;5*C&a$$:§E .- % 325.
2;
bkiaaghsgig figfi E\a飥;3fi5x$@'sem§g §¢,:'%?;. EV Crafis, AA ;?.?_*'?3== § H38 Layaut _ Sségtmr-1% Rgma Fag 'fiazgalara-55&T%% mREe$?«3f¥§E§%'T$ "(By an; §. h5 .a&m:~azs fgr RE? K-53 wfimfim éisgaazésfi with} K 5&2': fim 'gzfs i'?'3{1§ af ms fig: agaimt fhfi jufiwanz arid awafé éatéfi: i$:%a§$I:.°}'?" pnasgw; Ho.83$3.f2fl@5 032 the: 516 cf the QB? éfigii a.§'i.:.§ge% ';5i,_".i9::2z;.:r',:
ef fiafi Causm, iviamfiaszg E:€fi£--T} Bangalare, {$C18E*i.§a.§{}}, mtg? aékarizg petifjmn far mmpamatimn sad sfiaakitg aamjgaemgafigna 'fims 19E'fi.'3% am 1:: 9:1 fer tha mar: écfivgrmi the ffififii Jmmmmfifi 3fi3§~fw'€' % I*4'§".§ I€a.13'?*§4[ aggeflmzt - Imam-ems campmy sxkiih.t§§,?&.A駀§§;§-'§Vi'§'5§§Qfi'? is fflfié by the awmfi datefi 28,$4.ia9e*? §e31<::;2m5 $32 rm fik $2 the 3%? 3 fifiufi af smalé mmsm;
..... .«EsIiempn1itax1 'flaw? {§C€I~I--EC¥}, tfm haipzgégmfi §'::;égms22i 322:}; awarfig the has grsanhefi mmwmafifin mi" Esa3:,3'§}fi§'§§- « §~§:.*t:'£:'i§:§&z*mt 3.: §% gar szzizium,
3. fim clafm wfiémn wag fileé. %y firm izgémfi gamma gating that, he sufitafimég izzjmgz' in $133 aafiiéfiarzt K f'ji*:»s;'--.2' $33 mkfifi 2% an 25;' 8;' 2% at await fiflfi am, whm': Em was grsagaiig W Evmirz Raad, Ja}*aI%ara;
xmpmwisnt 5&1 was d:r~fi51rg 1% gzzéiar rwén-gang 39,33»-31--~y»5??§ in high 'A ané zmligant mmnsw' daaém :::au.s& ixfiuxy ta hia irwd; far afzmést 2.3 fiays, afar has revealfi all thoae amfiifient and thmveafcar ha mafia a :as*'.'ps:é*:*':V~--}.§§}?3, Earlist-::: E3 the §.mc:i'ém3y%1';_§§§_=.x4 }'%§ ;§§fi;émésnr ix: ¥a;sani11 amszi mr:1:x13g Esefifiéfig' «- yams """ rm he has; fiat? after " imgpizai aw';
L W ahigm m mzaga Efizmézg §-game. fix Vasanth is 3 :"3£§§3.;':§E' af tfim §z:_;'=..2;,zw3;g the mama af w'Es§.gI1m§ it ifi giatmi fig? he wag
-aw-$r%d2g as a Supew» 'at air: 'gsganih 3{2§3.éifg' V " Qsnwasmmg he Emfi ken Sara: {'3 éayarwgma an game war}: a:::& he fiiifiifiififid :3?' thfi aficécifixzt: 'ay {II Msmr Cyséa Imritg E%a.£§£~€i31~3:'«£7fi??§9 Tim mmgéamt wag maéa ma 1?; %§ 2%$ aftar izgéigrafi mgairzefi hig aaazzscaizxua. 'Elm mmggiaigsrmt E; smfiafi that the i:g§¥..':z*ad is miafive. ':7 x V 1A-fit 9 stamé fiat aha .2 £3 tiigx s2j:1§E:3§%és:r; tn him" m am;@ia.iz"i'£:-
pmvidirg the: numfiwr cf' '?"?'§vL4L't;;:vVi;;§g;«s:a*,.a'» fig?" " ' figs ham mm pmficx $3 the 333.r§j:'I1'§1:£:'.:hggf:2%%'; "_ve%23Zc% §€a.'??§ mm: 23:: Ekm .&¢6id¢fi§§:..yj§§5euQ§ mm: 1:. has raw:-mé? amtfi in fim c~am§Eéi11t=:§*:a;.t $3"£é'f" tim ififfiflfieifiifilifi tége iziémfi has symz. fim cfizk 2'33: éewaeé A_ in __ <:rf<:a$s 't'<":zc.:_£m.iEr2a'é:32az°,; § "£213 mmgiaimrzt Q;v?$3i.;§é$.X35txLl':'I$f an ayawimwg is; that amiiiszat, E 'A wriixciws afimai. the améfiaamt agstfi afher {Em _'améz+ie::.vi:£ mt shag?" 'aha awiésnt aw? %::a:> ihfi gvciém m :19: sefieé. tim agenaing vahixafga in my V. pffmezrxaeg-5". in aha clam giitfziam thfi énjamfi gags éifitg ha » %&:z':§m um:;armmimm§ haezzwg Em éié mes: mwré ziw amiciant ape: % 1:123 ycséécmfi Thgrafsrag fix izzjufaé. Egg rm: siwam €335 aszncidmzt spat. E: £3 11%? aim: ¢it%2§§19:§:*€;fn§. ' gr fim skates}: eitiwr fium. _ fisn at eamglamt as pa: E331. _. .. --« 3.3 per Ex.?2§ Sketch 33 Egg' EXLES deubfiui r§ £3 13&r.»E-:-:_:?3;7"';.i*::<é am:-ma' is gaxszgms, them§nr T ¢s:a§g%m sui: iém ssmfi fizz Eha {a3m§1aizi:..._§?'..; ;i;s".V_<§§?;;:; ?~§é3*§:t:¢:§: 3.3 E33 $2' fiéfifiw Fmm very rm: dag: araé alwmh haw iawn g_1%i:?§%;$:§§i' én£ fiat 'aha has 3, * §% 532* 23% Emmfifiafizg weéght in am amsnw af an Efihaiffif fix ¢Em,ma' 22%;.
mama} ffir 23$ rfiwzzdsant »-~ that; if the apgwfiarzt fiififiiiifi 'aha V R V V' fihm': he miiici have 9%. E': is §:;r?;§mr Ssmpany :73 33:3': 3.
firm mm ia 213%: cimlkzzgazh "K in am airsamzancsm tha sxmmfzssifizia mafia aylhnt warm': amepiaé.
P2. :2 is further aunm:-mi ;m{%2;;§:i:
saw fimi: pmduimd by £h2zTV'fi:e:'fi§;§;§E=;§a;"
case siwt mam mairztaizafi 'i%'i§2:'&§%§"Zj§#:*,é1e3 it fig that '@115 $n'é'Ei§t.m'y sf RTE; on 2315;' 2% rzamr Byatarayazmg_u'z'%, awe whmlér [ME fa%n}§ Vand ameptfié wiwst hm is am 'shgé aszcsiémzt him at Eyaiarayarmgmrag it is 2;.' aefif tfzc imrstar afisaig ané ma: submimé & b§r i§;m§ 'E? '£315 enhy nmfia 'icry 'the éagsiar in 'i?}:%_¢§3% sifmt maintaéfaefi arid ii is. aim Emtiaai _ «jfifiyammyaxzapurafi in . it has: Ema izmafim 3.3 "Jay E-Isa Ema sfiatafi tlfmtg E3 azistaérgeé at 3*-*1 [ Blbak, Jayamgars Eiczw it £3 mfifiiifiiifid as §a§? ( Elock isrmerted'? gmmar impartamt mm tg as mama. thai: "fiyatarayaisapzzra * E: fig $§.%:f:.3;a€mz§ in Eflsrflti Bargalam fin 'aim basis sf tha ariaim mtitiasn it £3 aiti.m%d En Smith i:$--. .- ;; 5 The g t has a shim as if ha has sustaizzed ix; tfie a;:::::i%:i§é:§i'g,§ South Bangalaare. as yam' Ex.P§3..;, £15 ' Semi}: § ffi. Th: saw Tfze date and fifi 6:? the a£~g:i"ar1t is > in E3133.
3. an hehafi' %¢i':2m judgflmt mfm-ac: by M was Km figrzasrai frwasrmcs ¢ampaa§"";:m£s' _ ' am ézsafikeri wfimh §$ hnié $c;;.§a ::§§:_ V' "
* afiove a®erw*§mn :E zgmfie with Izczwwiwgfi fiat there Ems ban §§>af,£ef c:a$& whmfifi fafifi saéms haw A. mafia mm ting giaimg Tfifimiai azfisé V faim imgiicafiefis am saga $3: $21: imsrmsak fifm Ca';.1z*Z§ ix: aegfirai sufih mam? hag fmznd that a 53$ aasidezri £3 gwn 3. farm arfiiiie mégm aapgamm azzamidserzt a fits: ve§nic§g. En fagtg in am af V the casaa éacificé $5 this $231131": :31":
:2.3.2m9, in ma s¢e§9§2g2§aa flauri Emfi aatzaaimn ix: mlim nbamwfism as 11% false came V' fled befim the 'E'?ri'bm:&§_;az1.z_i a.§$é» g£=$sa=*;-5"' % dirwimz ta tiw .3 themelvm an aé;:::-;_f££:2 it t}:;.=§;i,; pemasn is aftcwefi ts a'£;%§§s;.% this-2 law and mazes szzpgfisairzg _V
9. . ':m«~F%§2a4 §§§fap:§2?;:2m?; éabfi;
9)' 51' Gerierai f §£ flammifig it is Eifilé as: gara .5: mfg ?mtE1 aicim, in 3% _V as {Em Qfifififi 53:' is aw wig: wmmfi myéfmm hy 1:123 t as par EXPE ixxfiwtea flffit {£15 S flt fefi finm tiw brmiflk my: wfi suafaizwé in§u2'*7wa fimi fig Esdgfl hug afim' fix aiigeéi amfient the émimmt mm; up with a fififigrent aiexjg anfi mafia: {Em saifi Q § £125 szziazzzfsasiam §f the "§ ii?
appaaiiarxtk mmwaé 'aha? 3. faffie has Yawn mafia has 'ta fie Wifimut any azsmmi timughig fiwm tkxifig fiw fiasi téfisat» fhs '*-'...-V%:'.f§: " 4' m'a*sa&Z@ as a pillizmfg 'it: "
vehicia in qumtimgg ev5g3:;. 7aa ' Qfiflifiiltfi ef the aim' .§5.$@?§1fe:if§;¢"
the ciafssmrzi: fiaesidfi mmgamatiézrfi T . ; ._ '3T:3$13:§aI1s:fi aamgany. Fc2$.£2*;:§ as ii;
is iifit 'éfiasaafhaa ban quzaastizan af .... to 1:§1e ._ zzzsgzi m « 3%' mm rgwsnm in gm awe Qf fiarfiz fifmt Kmmmka V; :5 Cfiumbmf amé $31523; it is hgiwfi 'V " mnclusissm mar Eaim fifim fiifi that a éastsr wig mt aka 3. gégmmm V' 321 a fima mi' gays? mrszzzilmmfszg mmathxm whim}; $3 rm: wrfig Efirghiéait Ew}; %ta'i:%:Ymh$e$ heyanfi gha shafisw af §.m.2'§:
that film izzgairéga austafizfmé wag mt am awazmt mf 33:? wmfimiar fiflfifififlig fimt °< being 39, the fiiaiar fimégiézztg fiiakamaa Tfibmxal anfi gm Efgh 83:13:. gwra ji£8fif16§; in 3.35% awmfi. Tine s?%a¥€*F? : ' cztf the Matar Rmidefim § ;};§;§.z:;:;& arfi Ema": stanég §a%:=.§.ai:§£§§i' 'A :1. 1 have heard §;e&%%{LL;xa~gu;ma:gkk%as? gm kk la;-zarnfi Gamma} fer m¢%%kLg§§a:Lag;¢.% $2' '£233 rwpmzdezztsn
12. 12:1 ta suyra, it ia figaubgfefi, ciaimmzi: tlzaii: $5 in tbs 'amia"ent anfl $15 mafmfmi yiaoad &f§:"$«;3:L*'z:éV'i.'.3;$:;%,:?té;%f:5 fir Exfifzig Efia daszmr has 33.5% sézwéi, Tim mam flaw':
at am earfiast gmifli sf timfi mxci it :23 mam shmt as 333;? {$3.3 fiwm the mats? "',.,.,.«. §yci3." 'E' ifipwxw jixdmgzzf; anfi awfird gufikra fram ' infmztgr' mg mmmt fie mzatamt aé. £53, I ham gang fizmugjl fits {£3 afiii ma A. judgnt ysasseé by 1% Tréfimml 'fix ayyeai 351% $3' < the insuraam cempany in mg ?$¢,13?§#{2€:$§§'..V§§ E4, in vim: mi' {he aamm elm ' :31: in WAQ §$§1*?~l§§,_£ ..§§i"--%A§rz:k:f,:"._3ie'--:. ' with 25%: r.:sfEs.§§8fifl;'~ 2 Ammznt in d$@§'§.t é_'s" apgzzaikzit - ixmuranm £«{:m:;g%xa;§;::_§g'g m Q-2 1»-mi 5::
K? M. an ;--
ti»: