Karnataka High Court
Smt Kumari V vs Madesh B N on 18 March, 2011
Author: K.Govindarajulu
Bench: K.Govindarajulu
EN" 'i"'E"iE HICEH COUYI' OF ¥<L1'-XRi\§A'FAE£A AT BANGALORE
§)£\.'I"EI) 'I'I"§iS Tiwifil 1.8?" I323? OF ?*z1z'-XRCH 201 "I
B F3 F0 R E
"E"I~?{'E H0N*BL,_1?; Exziffi JUSTICE K GOv1NI3ARAJ::'§1;U«' --- '7 ' 4
Mm 1\EO.2230 OF 200'; {EVIV} , ~ .-- . jj..
BEl'i"WEEE\§:
sm' mmgmz V W'/O SRINEVA-SA, AGED ABOU1" :34 Y'I:".AR5:3§ RESIDING A51' 3330.69.
gm CROSS, 3m.> MAIN, V V MEI LAYOU1'. ' BAGALAGUN'1'§::. BANGA:.0r{E_i. ' " L. _ 2:; ..;§Ii§%:2Ig:;..zxN"r {BY SR1 H I>AvANA§:;}?'Lz.:N'£3RA':§E:i.fij.:*1f°%;«.;;*a£:;xr.v}- «. 2 AND:
2. 1\«1ADESIrIi3.I\E'. » S/C) R IQACEARAJLE, , = R/AT No.4. R1J_§R:«:sH1wx;IeA 'Ev~E§.I,;-'-::Y1X:'"' <:£««£:K£<ABANA';;f;xR;a, " _ ' BA;\:«:;;ALO¥aE: ::.5§s.Qu9_G. " .....
<>x-Véazga OF '1?§1§a "JI:?:HI$£';LE§ B11:AR;N {E V.Nc>..1<A;02 ;2v.:V~? 3.46.
v.2\.-1;' '.§'§--iEiZ N;«:i:_w 1N:3:;:w§:sS:JRAN{:E:
é;:{33a«:.1.4r.zs;:~:'§' :,.I:v::'1*£e:,:>§ 'V "
. .?'4"{'3'.,«:1:4'?; {E-CEPAE, €T(}AI'g'II%'.'£,Pl}'{, IE '>'3:",.«»::';«.:}E'=<,.. E%2A:£«%A§{ S'I'RE;iI€:"I.'; V ';»i§;E521'xs{AN':'1>»«t;2;;,I:«':§
-- L. ._ 'A '~ .:aA§~::<;;.A.:_J<:§*{:%: 55€§{}22. ' " §)V'{~.'.'}'£:.:iE{.'3-;$ir N:;:»,é%:2 E €:§€}{),:'3Z ;<:5;<:a;s<§£3§;' , = REESE-"{3?~!?)EEF*$'E'f§ " 1 . .fE'§'.:" E'§%1;,E&§,S§"£§¥;§£AE{, Agzv. :?<:>§z E~';:£: '".f7::: ;3rm:€ ?.;.h.e ;:§§s;a§3iEE§L:'y 8Llf§€f?€i§ tat: .E--*Efi§~§ 2:1
3. IE}.$f.IZ'"E-3..1'1£7.€ Cs:>mp21n},r has; f"iIe:'.d 0bje£_rt.i£3:1s_. Cifljnifid ihe: claim of the C2}£1iI1'l'c}.11'i'., {tall Lipfifl the pet'.i{..i0m2r to pi':3§/*'€_i'E.g_ 1'mpaC1.. F:,::'t:§":¢3::' c:0m.t*.11ci 't'.hai, £136 ctiaml is c%Xg1gg<::;";2,i'.ed'."-;§:i':321€}----- ~ £13? s:1i5smi.s:.sa1 0!' the crréaim ai;);:Ei<:21i.ic>zL ' Thé'. ciaim 0f1;.h<~:- peiit'éa1i§::r 1a--r1 tE. .,{hf;f in M\x"C,E'7'£3/2006 are joi11E13§._}i'e;1rd, A21 comrfi,:jr:"':._;}1ward is passed.
5' The <:1a1manE '1'11' Vpreferred app-ea}, 811$ Court, vide 'C'}'.'i"'C§§3'I' d.tjLv7}V4. Z§Oi G : hgsvV-ciiéééfiissed the Said appeal' '--£,;ez%rf1'e<fii'-.a,tiv(tét-€;tE--- for ¥;h€: Clztimelm: {',(}1'1i€I'1d that in the fae::ut3<__ {:f t7i1_e:V':7:;1':'s.:;:"'_.'~'the pesitivcr evidence of PW} ;B.E{:£'1§:ie1'i'§L'~iss ¥;.heii:" has sustaizled iI'1jL1I"'it3S and that three i11j'u:7i<--::~: "£:¥_}:"C4A §,fFi€V'UElS injuries. $136111. R.s.:?;5§O(30f~ for £1? 2z_z£:?¥ps:,\2"7ta:.£§%;ar1 Q {:c;ni.1'nu€d her denézai t:rea?£.ms3r1i.. Z{lai:r11'.ez' _ {<3} it "'--sh;e--._'iisaasséi' e:11§>§0y€éd EES 3; miiixr" in Ei'i'§'.EfX-H§ factsry at §'s:.ss§:z3z.*a:§t'}1..;::11:* 21:16 was paid {he salary 31' Rs.2,9{)O,f~ pm. " . {Hz s;».;:::a;u:::. ef eurcigiérxli: she itéé ihmwm 022%, :3? ha? erz":pk3y§:1€:3"{,. Dz: EKe'§21£§Ei: as; Es/Eu 53:13:"
i"*'3**~ iCiO{'fi'.{}'i' has ::z§7;i.:'1e£i 1'i.I;;1';:»i11;:__§ ;_3;a.i1. di.i'fE<'L.1§iy '£10 ssié. in H16 Iridizili £91181, i.1'121't"Ji1ity to §i'fi: H16 kit. iiiacéez and the 1'esi.I."i.C1.ioI1. m{JV€;1}<~:r1i. Sf 'tile lfifii K1186. Thff: cio(:E.0r d1'S21I:)'i.1i.iy at 2.5% {£3 the \2vh<>1e bedy. The C1'Of3S -7 is 119 the effffeci. that {ha report is giv'e_:yb}r 14hc§'€iO{:1;§_r, lfrrsjip the c1.a1'.I11a.'1'1L E«"L1;'1c1io11aI di.se1bi1ii,j;f_ €:4C}r1--<04f':':nra_:ié:§.T f with tihe injtxry re;f1eCt'.ed in 3'167,W'{)U1'1Ci'..LY(§f{,.ifi{YaI.€.l'_'_AS'{)"C{511i"§' is of the {'.€)i1Sidf3i"Cd opini:>n,V {he '1{'ribL1na1 ought to have £,a}§s:~::1 :r1()VA£j;r.;#..V¢v'V§A't"vtxhc._§is2{i)£iii}»%HI.éa,fi%Lc:»r and awardeci ..~3sui{.abEy :.14'r1ci<A:1*Vt;'i'--:€'}1_<§:21';_(:1 z2"g_f"€é}1'I1iI]§§ czapacity. It being not <:E0:'1e Cgimrt is egnitied for €I'1h€1I'1C€?f1T.i€I1€','VA{if.vCC31"i'}£pEi§-lféiifiOT} under the head of £033 of e3.;:'11.ing <f2zp21::i't,y; _ a'C(;i'df:*i'1t iS of the year 2006., The wagf-3 AVCf"§vE1i1TI'£(f'C"¥'f' per month. So the COL1E"i'.
";1sse:é:,S 53saihe'dis21biI1f.'[y"':£{. 10%. age of the injuzfed is 33 "'j,§ear3;"E19126.:1»3i;Ii.1;.ip}i€::' influx applicabie is ':6', Si} 21 ssunl of Rs'.55§680_f?é §;_? }321}*a1b§e under 1,116 head cf £033 of €;%£1Fi".si£1g§ '.<.ij£1§)21.£'.i§',}=', "$711.6 §:»€{.:i1.E0:1€1' biéirlg 21 pf'_'E'S{}1'.i €:€;mi}3g fmrzz 3; '~Aéfi2>.m.i'§'"1.~,§a f2:§:z}.§.§j,-* 153 1"'é3,£E£-';c"t.€c:i., in View 01" the diS<:Gn1f0:"§. SHE §'1a$ '"'€.:) ;;:a:':'3! am by E.iSiI1§._§ U516.' imiiam 'é{';.i1€i., $315'. E1213 :0 s'L1ff€:§' $0 22 (52 2311121 C3f'"Rs.10,G{)Of-- is awaitied Z.EI"id€I' the head 01" aII::€.:1i_jE_,it3S. '"I"'hc-3 (:1aima.1:1E. is <:%1'1.tiE1€:<:i I132" 21 $1111': of Rs.65,680.£'+V irlimiest at 6% pa. fF{)I1".i t.h<;*, date G§peE.ii1'(>3f': 11:3 dep--.;;;si1,, ' ' 'V'. zkgapezil if-3 aiiewed 2:c:<::3r*di13g1;a. - . kg _ XE ..
GH