Karnataka High Court
The New India Insurance Co Ltd vs Channamma W/O Sharanappa Awari on 20 January, 2011
Bench: N.K.Patil, A.N.Venugopala Gowda
Ix)
94>
SA.?€C}1%§K-HJEA D,/'{,}. §H;'5§Rj5§,§'§;'%:}3E355: ;%%'1%§3§_1
;%{§E§ A§()3U'§' 24» '!EZA§7€E?3_4
R}.-%,T KU-ST,%{'.§§,
-':3E§'~£CE 33553 RE?' 3'1' RE, E23 "$0 RE} LEZ€}Ai
LQEPRE-E3E{"€TA»'%.TIXf'ELE§ (3? TEEE §}ECE_ZASE;£}
:3, SU1\:E':%f22'{}A§,A 13,/<3; SE§AR;z?xNA?Pfi Awsaagg
M235 ABGUT 29 YEARS, " «
REA?' Ku'SE'A<3I.
4; SAVETHRE am. S}{ARA?£APP;%.§:E¥AR€3_
mm ABCEUT .18 Ymgg, "
R/AT, E-<.'%;ES'I'AC}£.
gs":
EvI&LL£E€AR&UNz% B,:'<::: a;HAR.»*::%iA%§§g AEJQRI,
AGED AB{)U'§' 13 YEARESQ '
E;;%.'.E' KUSTAEEL
E€£Y}1,.ZK¢ K:'rT.UE2:_§ ;'
AQEE'. AND F:,%T£9'}Ef€'f§ ?'<?AE\:§E;"N{"}'E* 2<:*~;~<>:--i;N.;~
E~»§AE£YAL_R.f5A§1I; 'V .
D§aE'~;FBEE;E, §{£§}'€';?JA}~3.£¥ES'§1»58i«.325"'v_
:61
mgV $:az:?s::i;>.Is:AL,1";yw5J'A»:;E:R, .
N,va:2._§<.S.m1c;V:;.:x:::% S}§7LF"'*E.N;">?JR2%NCE FBND,
D§'\fI'S.EOI°~§AL
B13L<;A:.JM_ * ' .. '
N
- V ..RESPON]I}EN'?E§
{BY 'SE? <}u':?e:,£.2%;m R." ?w?eA:a;m,R: s%,L{}N{} vma SRE,L_/%X_Pv£AN 2':
E'»,»i~3i§JT'€Téa:'I}A_f€L A~mi_,_§__§?-{ER R1, R3--R:33, R6 _fia1'€:Z":' R"?--SEIR"v'E& R2
":;:,--s€:,%:*1*_*:?;::«:..A
%'§?:?::§AE_; 3% FELED uéazngg SEC'§'E{}E€ .i"f3{7;_} <2?
« "~v..££E~z%'§E'€S? THE. J:;;';;;<;:z:§:«::\:*§ ma §:W.z%RD BATES
E.E%'a;3.2€){}5.:?}€§-E§E§E3 EN ERIEVC N{}:2c3f?f2{}{}~'§i €f}E'~§ TIHE FELE 5;)?' '§'EiE
CE'xi'}"§;Y .fU§f}?}E {SR,§3E'\5.} AND MAST; K{}.P?_z%§.;-? 3§'=.5§z%RDlN{%
£3(}E%:§PE§'=§$._i%'§'§{}?*§ Q}? R:-§'€>,é%%%,8{"}G;'~ E?sf'§T3% ESFETERES'? 9;? 8% P.;'%M
E;'%'1"'E OF ;PE73'}"'?'§'EG;"'~E Tfigég §E;%_;§i$}":T§{}f'€ ;'%l'i§EE
»C?E,3§€;?..Ef:"§'EE'~E{} '§'HEZ APPELLAPET EEEZEEEN 'EYE §f§E?'OE%§'T THE EEA-3:I'g€§L
1"")
Ev? .F,;%.{3R{}8. f'§{3a34{} E2385 11%-'EE='°'§
BETEVEEN:
1.: CHAI"~E.éIV§}JL% W} G S%§;'%R;%E"§z%PP}': Z%Vs.r"}'§R§., fii}-E: 42 ':'EAE33_E§, QCC: H{f}i}$E}%{}L£} W{}:""€E{5 R,/{EV KUSHTAGI, TQ: KUSHTAKEE, 318?: KOFPAL.
E!) SLFMANGAL3 D/C}. SHé':§3A,N;§P?z§ AXEJARE, AGE: 19 EEAR, {3*€3€ZL': S'E'UDEjNT;. --_ H 4 V R31}, §{'{§E§H'E'A£}E, Ti}: KUSH'?;%{}§}
3. SAVET}:iRE Q;/<1 E}§HARAE'\E'AP?;i AWARE, 13:33; T58, = V V REP. 83" {}EJAEBE£3"~;, RES?GN7§3é,§E'E<€'§' NC}. 1: _ 4, ?v'§ALL§§<;ARJE,T;'\i S;§;aRsw;.IAPpA.A<;,a;A:2§, szrxrca DEAD V 5 _ QBJE2{Z'E(}E<$ {BY SR1. GU'RURA& R: Tzjaasggaai ,_¢;L<:;2n:.<:«'~15;s:fri-: 8RE.,LAX§%:EAi'€ T. 1\zE,_£1N'E"AGAN§,§:§'v'S§ " I ..
AND TEE :\::;€a; irgmég ;éx::§<s«_fé)'2"a:ég?»§%<f:aELvv«--::<;~'£533., KARWAR . ;B.:Z.«'%NCH§ 'E:.é;§Wf%_R; . _ ¥Ei?.Bi:'E'£":§._1\/iz":I'€[%,€f}--?3.E»:*'. . '- x Z - ;..RESPONE§E1N'%"
£83'SE'x/§"§'AE€UNA:».._____§i>%f;S%§PANDE.; z§§':/'C A.L{}N{} KW}:
,, .§;%:E§:AiV§.53£:?3?€'E£.xf3%.'E'Ei;'§;}£_, ADE-3;
f«:.ULE_: % 22'{§éE~:
6:'-H§[s§"v:.,zE:"Q:2;::>B EN :v::%*A ?~E{'};S8S2;'2{}S5 :5; FELES 355:} 1;: _ *{3'}%{}AiN$'ETE§E &'€JD{ERiE?i'N'§' 5:318 gwggg ::,::<:'E:: 2§§,;3.;:2{;@;5_ Rag, gab ZN swrj ?\;<}.24?;'2@:}4 (>12: "$.53 FELE GE?' $33 <Z:"v'§.'L;-. g:..;;;>a;*;§;; :_:i;§t,§:s:=;.; Am A5232, ?.¥5§AC'§} K{}??fisL P;~':R*F;{.,Y' 4 ;%§.-LO'9s.:'§?€{}. '"£"H§ CL?a.§i'a:'§ P€'"§§T§{f}f'=~é' FEER {f{}§vIPEI"€S;%.T}'{I}E\E fis§'~i;{} ' "E3EZEKEN{§V..--§ZN?§,%?JCEZi'v§.E.NT {E13 €Z{i}EvE§3E3?€S_fi{§I{3vf\I. _f??E~§£€ §?PE;§E4 .25:E'\'i} E':z§?;'3; %§33€€{};=':%, {Z<i}?%:I§E"J{} {ER F{7}Q E7E?~E;%§¢-
. TE-EES §L'v--"§'§} ,K.P,?%.T'fi, is ;'L';§§.';.L.E'ifERE';§ THE Fifiii-{}'i?&?'§§*i'{§:
K/'i s:"s:}§:"2pa:11},-=' am: am. in Ci§S§.}L2'§{3x '§h::% £22366 :3? Ehéf {::<:'>s$ <}E3j<i::t<:rs§ is i§?z.a%;, iha: dsiztezssééaii W213 ziggsrié :»{a§i)L:i E334 };<;%2:»::*':; 3}-'" _§i31"{}f{3E3§§§§}§"§ d§"iV€¥." in ms f'é'v'JKRT{3 and €Ei1'}:3§.£".:§} ?°%3,'?};.£'3%g'-- pm" ':{::*2'.s§ zfasas haie azzd heaithy prior :3 Elm ac<:.idm.'sL {En z::;:«:;7.<::§.f1:1§j"<1"§;' déiath of ihfj €§éf;'£'fifEféiS€{§3 five {fEEii1fi'}E3;t"3§;E§,/f€TE"€}E%S'§v'_{):§}§,{:CV§L{}§'S Eiérasizs are: léfldfif S:-::"i{3us.; s--s<.>c'ia§ Eiiféd :é3C<:=z':{§mi<:'. {EIES-§;.:'€:3_&s._:é.':«§ Eiééé aiécsased was this (2:33-' brésad. éarnez <>5;'[_€he fa:':.x§iy. ' 'Fi1S"v§"?.:'§§€ has figs: hfif fife pésflner, théi 'i;-hi'}'::§:"8'r: hE2§«'«:=*1n:E3§ iha Em,-'<3 and affec?_'i@1":., guzédance E§ZE5l*..V_S%,£§3T§3V{§':f'°§" iféf EE=5:_ir f.2i:i"ié'z:'" Taking aii thssé-3 é18p€CES firm} z:€):1:»;§§i€.:;'és.i,i<:s:3§ ii':::§:$:%A§;.V27&§ {jQn::§:rainéid ':9 file:
Cfiaim ::>€:2:i€:'.9:1_ El:1:"i.i:§:-SE" 4'Ef§:'€CE'i.xf'§%§9 §.;€§AE»~ %_;>.f the 's_"§«'§"v' Act against tbs imm:"2;§n+::€: "CGfE5.§pEif:§§f', :3'W:§<:*:" ofwzhe <>'§f%:m:§£r;g <;€':*;£<:§e and N¥'ifKSR?C.' r.£':'}§3Vf;'..f:'ii-CE :~:1é;Et€f gtame 11;} §.3::>:" {:<>r:$.%.dr31"at§.0:": befem ihe Tribfiizaiéé zmai fizhgj '?2f3f;;:,1n2':Z ai"t.€r €i'§):§>I'f5'Ci&3f;§{}§}. <3? {ha @223 a.né;"d<:A§:um€:::z»;:*f?--=V s:*<:23:§€;:{:e zmazi {}ih€:3i" rééimrant maieriai z3_*aZ'2:--é§é1§:%--E%5 §>%:. §'§§52j 23z%ééif{§§:{§ 9»: af :'§€?,'<§"€778QG;f"" %:2:i?;E'; i:":'z'<,%r€:S€ Ves?"%v"%f€s'v..::§;;*a§"~Vimam {"Eai.:f of pa3:'i?:i<3n iii? 'ibis 5231:: :35 fzzéé. :;'--{:a.Eéza§ii}:i§_:--._ }%gg;r:£<-3v:'ii:,i bf: iZ},i£%.§"§ZL3_}f'§1 ef ::<:r§f;§::n$a'ii{:»:r3 9::a*é2--r::§::~gi bj_;"€:E:<--": Trébzgnézi, 'i'h:=: ;2§;:%eE2::r'1?3~ir:ss:,:3¢{~t2;~ E233 §iiit& sihszz E7} 213 $223 fog' :"e3dL:<:i':"<:»:": azzci i'E":<«:: <;:r'<3:§s~3 :2E:;»%{5<::<:::'3 hazza iiiszii the
- 3 . _ cmsa <>b_§<3«::Ei{m .f%_>:" c:?:1§'"1é3§":Ciff§1€'§}E <35 <:c3H2p€zm21t§<>n, 4, We hzwst hsafd 331:? .§<%a.m:3d £<>unS€i'~.gzp§-ifaizizgg "lrssr £316: appeliarzi-%z2s1z§::.:" ané 1€3'€S:§"Z'§€£i C(}§ifi€€;'§"'é2§C)'}3%3'E1_%"i,i'l§§§vvV}§{§§7fVV <:z"<><::a;<:: {:i3je{:§{3r:<; fa}? <:<>:1:=;:i::i€ra§.E+:2 isngézh {§'§_ii1'§3€. A .
.5, Aficirr cazefué p€;r:_2$aE "a:»_§ imhpugnadj vfudgcmem anfi ax.-vaici' arzd G:he.t'2§*§ev=;%z::€;V« Vr:1'2:.f,€.r'%.?a¥'E_ £317: ;°€c{:srd, what smesges is Ehafig V311/1:: «:§§:<:V;s%f;-zsr3::§'._was""g;.geggi,yV*--gbGug 51 yfifafgy rza wariééng ag a ;tié'§?§';;T ' 'a%i€:i""&:awing 2}; saéarjg ef I ' ?6,'?7E[8,r"~« ifv'V'{;<$%z1puEs0r§* dsduczion :3?' €50/- :§v;aé"é$.j5;}:0fésé;i:,>'r:a.% "é::».1x--%s detfuctezi, {he rernaining amaunt Eésazéazs $1?-...%_6i?.§E";'~u €32.11: 9% whéehg if .§ff=:W1 £3 §€:du<;tt":d tim%§aré§$V.§>'€.rs0z'12%E axpszzsas {zf {he éeceagedfi {£353 a:z3<>ur:i '*%.3:'s:'>?:"i§3 Gui. {ca 35,338.56 risunaigé =33"? w !--.
=;?§§,.fl3*}'1? '-£%Z€ 658:3: if iii: :0 ea:-=£Ja:*£% ?'?Z$é,{}85§~f~ {?E:,jG3§:zE2xE '{I{}'%,iF£3;3'z'§.i~3 E083 2:}? £§s'5p€'":1"i{§€;'f§'i€j,i', mgaré zit} ihsé facis amé cércuzngizmseg 0? }3,h;'?':;t;:::<aé5:§ (E36332 ii 5?; is £%%}£é3;f'{§ ?5%G}€L}€"}{}f-- ?:.<}War:'iS E638 <35 'Vc%:>.?E.:5;<3r2:iL2n";y Eaésag of a:'=$'::a::<:=, E9535 0%." §{}¥€§ gmd ezféisiaiiii:-3: esmd .. =3 3, zgjgjg M5 ira:2ssp<::'§.a:z't}:2 2'°2;a.nr:'=,.re2.E é3>:g3:3x:§;a:%s. "?§:€ Swazi <:'e§r:§e_n__3a"::.§0:7; (tomes fa ?"8,2f§,{}é%z%-_fw as; azgziénsei %"é,4é,8{'?{§,f'-- aW£«2r'iié{i.:§3§/'izigze '§r£b:.:3::zai, The srahezncaé mzrn azzsaatzhzz <L'{}I§'£€E§ i{é:'--?E§.?%}J-2"8:'%;9"[-- . _' V , 9 3 avith §r§'C@f€SZ at 6% frcsm the date e:)f.,.p¢é.ii§{:§r: i.ii"E"-€§':ekiaie bzf reaiizariezz.
36:23" £226 :°e:asc>..:§$ ssi'.2'z.z':<":<% V;i§T§;«:§v€ f:£':a:* at: 62:} i§f§%51:":'§~ the"
_ » V 3? V «I appeflanzwinsurer is zzizsrnisseai sf crass Gbjsciimz is aiiowed 3:': 3 .
Tbs impugnggi }'2_1r:§g<:.rz: €}_:;%: fzE§.€f}3,2{}OI§ pémseé in MUG eiwarding £2 gum -sf frem the date of ;:3:"I,:Z%:E<::»n in add§*:i{>n E0 the Qoznpezé sé 4:i;ire1r§§ "'E'1"ébL::1aL {)0}: 23:?' af,E3€ €:r1.%:aria:.:5d cfimpensaiian 0f ?L?'9,284,.:'V»? zanzfiz pr<§pi}':*'i:%one:::{: interassz :*:;hal.E be: izzvsx-=~;'ia:*d in "CH %:E@,g:3' :;:a§;%:*:€: {sf ;:fL>s:$ <2§j@c%:{>:" in z»2..::5; ::a§;i{2§1a§§2:€:%§;'s<:Ef:::é%.;:£:€>€§ bazrgk" §<:>§':z*s g€::°i::§9<§:E «:35 {Ezra zs; rszéaéwezbée fer anathsr {£326 3.:é:a;:<3 '§'%?"§§;h gz pr::f%:£Sés:,-:52 :5 2a:.?Zthé:222::,-° ihs: §.::%e:"€.:;'§'. p::;*ia:}<"§iz::2z2i;.;:
A§*S'£;."'f:'Es';"~l'1;E1Z'§E§,T €1E'1'102}..;?"":§ Wééh é5,€3C§"?;E{'f€§ §IE'{i*Zff°€§§i Simfi 1"fi:€'3&E§{f'~€§ in i'a2-'{';:§_;f :2? {E35 fE§:_-;%i' cr<:::3$ :;':ebjs.~:?.z:::"' iffiffléiéjifaiffififi A {M/«A