S Vasudeva B Com B L vs The Government Of Karnataka on 25 August, 2008

[Cites 2, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

S Vasudeva B Com B L vs The Government Of Karnataka on 25 August, 2008

13 THE HIGH COURT OF KARHATAIKA AT 

nxmn mm 1113. 251* mm or mans?   _

Pﬁﬁi'

Tm: nownm am. I-.13. 1cnm"1r _ ,1 "  

AND

ma Honrnm xn.Jus'nca__v.aﬁ1-gm  i; N

Writ Petition no.11g7 

Between:

1.

S.Va-sudcva, B.j_C<3-1;_t1. B.'L'.V."' '  V
Advocate "  I  2: 

Residing at No.'78f] 2;  _  '
Sushcclaﬁcwad;  V 
Doddamavam, %  A .
Bangalore  004. '-

  " ...Pis1'I'i'I'IONER

  'S.VVs3.::§11,.~1<:w;z_§; party-in-- person)

The Ggzﬁicmmcnt Of Kamataka,
'F.3r_ its Chief Secretary,

ii  .Vid1_sana Soudha,

Secmtaxy to the Wm,

Government of Karnatam,
Vidhana Soudha, Viihana Vescdhi,
Bangalore.

 



Union of India,

By its Secretary,

Miznistzy of Law av. Pm*liamcntary Aﬁairs,
C.G.O. Complex,

New Dc-.}}:1:i~1 10 001.

Clontrolicr and Auditor Gcncxal of India, A  H  '
New Dem-110 om.  '-

B.S.Yeddyu;rappa,  .  
115-Shikaripura Assembly V gézitucnéy, V
Age: Major, .  '
Shimoga District,
Shimoga.

Laxman   '  *
O3~At;'nani liaai-._mb§y 'Coﬁaiitiwncy,
 P--.i{,,VTaiu3;:' ' ~
Belgaum   _ __  

 Kagc.

  Ag¢;'«:M§iQ:, _. ..... ..

A £)14~I€,aQ*«'.m€1 "ﬂsascmhly Constituency,
 ' Vllgar i{,4H., "£.'aiuk: Athmi,
 Bc}gnaui--.Di9tiv'(:t,
'Bcigau1n.* A5:

Ailidlp  Mahalmg' appa,

'   Age:Maj<>r,
.. A'G~b~.Raiba-.g (SC) Asacmbly Constitucncy,
* _ Nidguxaxii, Taluk: Raibag,
   District,

Abhay Patil,
Age: Major,
12, Bcﬁaum, Dakshin Assembly Ooaxmkuency,

 



10.

11.

I2.

'  . A895'.-'Maj0r»
" .17--Saundatti Yellamma Asstaably Constituency,

  15.

25, Hmum Basavan Gaﬂi,

Belgaum.

Sanjay B. E'-"atil,
Age: Major, 1  '
13-Belgatnn Rural As%bly_Ce)nstiti'macy,
17, 18, 19, Such Building,   " V V
Adarash N-agar, Mahadevpur, '

Vadagaon, _.

Bclgaum.

Pmhalad Remand, -

Age: Major,  V  --  "  L .V 
14--Khanap11r~vAs:~s¢mhl5r  V _  A
Zadnavaga,4.P¢;st5Hc3>baL 'I'a111k_a: 

Marihal   
Age: M1§jb'I',~. "T-I   
15-Ki:£t%Jr_AsS6II:h._ 
Farm H¢use.'Bai1aa£honaa1--R¢~ad,
Kittur, Tank: Bailahbzagal, " '
Bclgauxa District, 
Bclsaum  .4 

     '  .....   

 le6~Bai1§19ﬁgal.Asscmbly Constituency,

'Parvathi Nfilaya, Belgaum Road,
BaﬁhongaL4j';'8c}gaum District,
 '

 Vishwmxath Chmdrashckar,

3138] 3, Rampur Sim, Saundatti,

 " "Bclgaum District,

Bclgaum.

Govind M. Kmjol,
A8'? M9301'. ' é

 



16.

I7.

18.

19-Mudhol (SC) Aascmly Constituency.
KHB Colony, Mudhoi'I'ak1k,

Bagalkot District,   A
Bagalkot.  

Siddu Savadi,
Age: Major,  
20-Tedml Assembly Cons ' 

# Maigur Road, Jamkwhandi,   '
Bagalkot District, '  
Bagalkot.

Kulkarni Shrikaxith Subbiaog'
21-damkhalélﬁi Assemmy. Constituency,
#SBIColsoI-'zy,  T.  
Murugegh" __
Ase: Major, .     
22-Bilgi Asagmbly (3o13,sti1;;~' y,
# Inraza Mwchu11aI,'Taluk: Bilagi,
 .....

.' Pattaaashctty, Agc':.VVMajG.r';--._ Qfinﬂadami Assembly Constituency, at Badami, _ ' Bagalkpt'1:)isuict, " V' Begancot "€_ihax'éz1ﬁmath Vkanua Céhandmshckharayya, " Age: Major, 24-Bagalkot Assembly Constituency, # 'I'.P.No.25/4, W.No. 1 1, Near Kasturimath, Extension Area, Bagalkot District, Bagalkot.

21. Doddanuouda G Patil, j 2S~Hungund Asmmbly Constituency, _ ' Near Basavcshwar Circle likah ' ' 'T l-iungund Taiuk, kalkot District. Bagaikot. ' _

22. Bcllubi Sangappa Kaﬁappa, Age: Major, . ' _4 28-Basavan Bagewadit§ss;cx:1h1ys.j_C'4:xIat'2me:;cy, # Kolhar Post, Basavan Bagewsstii Bijapur 13istrict,.. _ ' Bijapur. 2 L.

23. Appasahcb '(ﬁﬁspiiﬁ v'Pa'f,ta§1ashetti. 30-Bijapur' City A' ' 3embly<.C0naiit:mncy, #Sh&stIiN8i;-ézag Bijapm' District; -» ' '- B1_]9.pu:r'. * ' '

24. Katakdhond Vittlmai ﬁhohdiba. Age; Major, ' '-

' 3:3.%7N'agsa;t}:2»an (SC) Aaaambbr Constituency, , Wart}. N9.-17',n.§ndi, ': aé§bhouma mm" gouda, Asa: Majc~=.:..i'~= Q 32~I:;di.Asscmbly Constituency, Kacheﬁ 'Road, indi, ' ., Bagapm' District, ' Btsaxaur.

. 'Bhusanur Rmcﬁzt Balappa, " - "Age: Major, 33~Sindag' Assembly Constituency, mm Post, Devammg Sindagi Taluk, (1 'Z8.

Bijapur District.

Bijapur.

Doddappagouda Shtvahngapm Goad Patti} Na:-ibol, Age: Major, , ' 35-Jc-.varg1' Assembly Naribol, Jcvargi Taluk, Jcvargi.

Naxasbaha Nayak, , ' ._ Age: Major, A 36--Shompur (S'i'jI_ Assem1:«ly_ Constétu¢i1cy;"* " ' Kodckal, Shox'apur..Tah;_1k, V ' Sboiaimr. V' Sunil Vallyayur.

A83: _ 42--Chincl1oli" ' L Cmmtzitucncy, M1G.3&, Knsvcozajny; " % MSK Mil} VVRO-ad,' Gulbarga District; . ' " V Gunaaraa. ' .' Revuwaik Bglambi," """ "

% »Aa§c=_ i'-ﬂaien», (SC) Asmmbky Constituency, 'I<oni1a1"-Mada' Bel§§1ngi,_ Taluk, Gu1i:»arga !3i;-étrict.

Cfhgndiaéhelmr Patil Rcvcsox', A.se='Ma.ior.

. '44-Gumarga Dakahin Assemhiy Constituency, ' I4ﬂ;.No.E-3, 175 Adarah, ' ....1F.vi:c:dica1 Hail Super Market, Gulbarga District, Gulbarga.

Basavaraj Patil Attu-1',

33.

34. Age: major, =4'?--BasavakaIyanAssemb1y Constituency, Vidyashreac Colony, Basavakalyan Taluk, Bidar District, Bidar.

Pmbhu Chavan, Asa major.

S2-Aurad (SC) '(lo-n$ﬁtIien;cy; " ~ ._ Bonthiﬁzanda, Aumd '!'_aiuk,'--_ Bidar District, < Manappa Vaj_ia1,_ . * V Age: Majorg," _ 57, Lingsu~g1n"'l(_SiC'») Assenihﬁr. Constituency, RIO 11:'-Ink.

Cruibsrrga Pxatap Géitnda "

Agc:VMajor, " '-

59, (ST) Assembly Constituency, ' _ Rig 'Near c2~;;vemmw;t'xi2za School Maald, . Lings1:_r Ta}, ~--,, District, R3;¢m_:r..&V' - "

I13! Mzmzavalli, Major, "

62«Gm1gs;.aawati Assmbly Constituency, ' Camp, Gangawati, ~ Kogspal District, Bishanna G , Age: Mqior, 63-Yeihurga Assembly Constituency, ggaz Itagi, Taiuk: Yclbnxaga, ' Bagalkot District,

39.

40. 4'1 .' * ._'_'4:3§ 'tﬁgscmbly Constituency, Bagalkot.

Ramanna S.Lam&ni, 58¢ M6301'. A 3 * 65-Shirahatti (SC) Assembly Oonstitue:_1cj'v, Kundrahalli, Taluk: Shirahatti,_ ._ Garlag District, ' Gadag.

Bidamr Shxishailappa Va§:ru]_s3'ak_shapp8',~-- _ Age: Major, ~ E, } _ 66-Gadag Assembly Constituexjcy; R.S.No.178, P1omo.23,,-M . '- 1 .V Marsha Read, L Kalakappa Gu1m%h£mﬁappa.'E}andi, Age: M..ajcvr,.._ f. "f:.; 67-Ran. Assembly.' Vanashme N533}?-;s,¢'R9n __ Gajaendragad (53); "R01£_l Gadaga '' * * H. ?~!9;98 1 Near Vetnﬁngnzy Hospita}, Namgund, . Jj" Patil Mlmcnkoppa, 'Major, ' 6'.9~Navalgun¢i Assembly Constimcncy, % wavazgund, Dlaaxwad District, Dhalwasd.

A1143.

Chikkanagoucira Siddamagouda Ishwaragouda, .-

R WW

45. Age: Major, 79-Kundgol Assembly Constituency, Adaragunchi, Hubli Taluk, Hubli, Socma Ashoka Maauti, _ Age: Major, 71--Dl1aIwad Assembly Constitt1imc5',_ "

Uppinabetagcri, Talukz _ -- _ " -» .. _ _ Vecrabhmmppa Ha1aharav:',_ T V 72«-Hubli«~ Dhs;=t£"ax:i>VéEas1_iS¢;') Asaéenihly Qcznstitlzcncy, Girani Chawl,'-..4***a';jCxosa, 'Kanava-gti (Road, Hubli. > Jagadi~.§h"Shs:{ﬁ3r, '79?

Age: Majon. " % % 73«Hubli~Dharwad§€'c1§!;"ai Constituency, 30[39/1',a_M&dhu.*.a Estate, Cross, Nagashetﬁkﬁplmz K.caiaw&ap'ur--Hnbh', Hub};-L\ha1wadeCentIa1. ' L...7«i¢.HuhlieDhaiwad«Wcst Assembly . V (bnsﬁmcncy, Colony R , ._ Hcgc, " Major, " = Assembly Comwuency, " P0: Bamor'I'a1uk, ' " Sinai-581 403, Kannada D1s1:nc' ' t, V.S.Patil, Ase= Major.

8 1 -Ycilapux Assambly Constituency, gwwﬂf

50.

51.

52. At an PO: Nilkcshi. 'l'a}uk:Simi, Yeﬁapur.

Udaai Channabaaappa Mahal%nmjppa,__ j. ' Age: Major, "

82-Hangal Assembly Consﬁuzcncy, _ ' Hangal.

Basavaraj Bommai, . Age: Major, -~ 83~Shjggacm Ase;'mnb1y.h "

No.52, I Hubli, Shiggaon. ~ * NChl'u.~3k3.'!.};i',;;

ham Maj0r._ % 84-Have1"'{SC}A' f'znb!y£§oria:§tit11cncy, C/0. V' V' Aswini Nagar, 1-! cmas, I-favgrni. 'V .. ' .' ..... .. \\ . fa' V5393? Major» Asﬁﬁmbly Consﬁucncy, {ii ¢ ' Vﬁhgm, Taluk:

Diatricty . Havftlﬁ, _ Ag¢:'*Major, "87~R'anjbennur Asscmbiy Constituency, Nina: Police quarters, Rotary School Road, " v Ranilacnnur, Dist:-éct: Hawzri, Ranibemmr.

B. Chandra Naik, Age: Major, _ J' ;

E :raMwA,.»-»-~""""""""'

57.

58.

88-1-Iadagﬁ (SC) Assembly Gonstitucncy, Advi Malianakri, V (PO), Hadagli Taluk, Hadagli. I K.Ncmaraj Naik, ' _ Age: Major ' sq,-:.. :5 rug uecal :..:.: ' Asaemb Constituency, A' _ S/0. Kaaahya Nazik, . " " V Hospet Taluk, ' Hagaxibommanahaui. _ j Anand Age: Ma5or;.y% % 90--Vijayana.gar. ligmbly Constitmrgncy, S/o.

Kzisbssxarajcndifa 12¢.-m,~ Vijayanagara, 'I'.H.AStuvcst1 B.a_:bu~,» Agc«:.{:Major, "

w 'I Ti H ..... .. " msﬁ , . Near Rmiway Quarters, _ Bcllmy, " Kaazrwli.' « ms.

Age' Majer» ' ';32+_Sim:guppa (ST) Assembly Ctmstimency, '~ A _ " Tckkaiakota Town, "5.5if?'-i§uPP9~ ..._§.Smm'mnmu, " V , Age: Ma_§or, 93-Bellary (ST) Assembly Constituency, 2"' Cross, Devi Hagar, Club Read, Bellary Taxuk, . .

61.

62.

63.

64. Bella:-y.

Gali Somasckar Roddy. A _' Age: Major, j; ' 94-Bclhry Cﬁy Assembly Ctmsti .e:nc5_r, "

Ashok Hagar, Havambhovi, _ Siruguppa Road, ' Bﬂagcndra, . ' A86: Major, ._ 1 .. "

96-Kuhﬁ (SI) Assembly Conatiinéncy, " V H.No.: 26, War<i.No.18,~~ _ jy - _ A, "

1'' Cross Nch.m.«C0lon3.?. Bcilnlyy 'ThippesWamy;».. M , Age: Major,__ "*I:.; 98--C.t.1allakcfcL'{-SD' Ct_?IlstitiI=€*.!1¢y, Katappana Hatti, '_l'own, Ci . luma _ M.C!zand11ifip;§, ' ~ Majarr A V' . 102-Vﬂoialkczm Constinlcncy, . Nagaza, _ s:a<imn:._Reaa.1._ % Chitzaduéga.

Age: Major, _ ' 1.04-Hximpanahani Assmbly Constitucncy, Ashfuk Nagar, Avaxnbhavi, . Road. Bcllary.

ﬂavangerc.

"i3.P.Hax1s' h, Age: Major, 105-Hatihar Assembly Constituency, S/0 Basavanag0Wda.P E

4.,WW,w

73. '74.

75. #5. 'V 1 13-Shimoga Assembly Gonsﬁtuaacy. _ Jayalaxmi, Malleswara Nagara, Slmnoga.

Rﬂalapm, Age: Major, V I 1 16-Sarah Assembly (?onstit*-leaarpy, H.No.29, I-iaxatalu Village &' I-losanagar Taiuk, Shimoga, . Ase: Major. _ 1 17--Sagax Asscmbhr C;onatiti1t:13;:3z;*-._ Sagar Age: Major,' "~ _ _ . 1 18-B?yndo'or. Gonsﬁmency, Vmayaim. " < . ="

Yojana Nagma, Yudthem Byndocrr, Kizndaptxr Taluk, B}'nﬁwr-

' Shctty, .1 19~Kuni£apuia"Assembly Constituency, H.N'O.28, Post: Haladi, Kundap'u:ra«--"I'a1uk, T_ Udupi.

» AK.'RaghVt'1pathy Bhat, ' --..iige'::_.=Major, 3_,20--Ud1zpi Awembly Consmtlﬁtcncy, _ H.n:o.s-32, Karamballi, V H Gurupmsad Rajachmya Mag, 3 "T8.

Udupi-576102.

Lalaji R. Mention, .1 mar 7'9.

81. Age: Major, I21-Kapu Assembly Constituency, H.No.5--1S7-+3, Sri Rama Nivm, Ramanagaxa, Padu Village, Udupi-574 1 ()6.

D.N.Jee:varaja, Age: Major, 123-S1-ingeriAsscmbly Comti _' .r,_ Dwaramakki, B.H.Kaiméxa Poait, ' , . N j@ma Taluizg _ ;

Chikkamagalur. A M.P.Kuzna1aswe:221y;_' --

Age: Major, .

124-Mudigett (~'$C)""Goet:sﬁtuenc3*, Mckanai1ga:i¢;Iéj;V' a Gs-Post, Mudigc_n:'I'ahiic;._~ _ ' C.'I'.Ravi, . . ._ Age: Major, V * * 1,25: Constittmncy, 'V " S[d;..C.E;'Thimmc Gowda, Ghi2kmag}t1r:S?7 101. stzmg 11 I):.S.*,' ' ,Age: Majoaf, :' 4." ' * 126--_Tan'i£exc Assembly Cosnsﬁuency, "«.D9ram3lu Villagc as Post, Taluk, lv3.C.Nagcsh, " Age: Major, 129-Tiptzur Assembly Cotmuwucncy, S/o. B.S.Chandrashekariah, 3% ﬂ_--*MW__Wm____,,,w...,_m. ,..

85. K.R.E'.xtm1sion, Tiptur. S.Shi-Vanna Sogadu, Age: Major, A f} 132--'I'u3nkur City Assembly Constitfuen.cy' S/o. Late Siddalingaiah, . Swamy Printers, Chikkpct, 'I'u1nkur.

Bﬁuresh Gowda, __ ._ 133-Tumkur Rina! Assembly Cbnaﬁnnency, __ S/0 Bettaiah, " I Tumkur.

Age:Majo_r, * . j 145-Kcﬂgr' F" id (S.C::)'-Asgemhly Constituency, No.72, 9*3!,_Cmss'Road', _ ' Dr. Ambedkar Oak;-ny', ' 3 Vcngansandm-, Road, %%%%% .. .. _ K9'-'ﬁr Gbid

87. Agc:--.+Majo:§f~ .. 149-Ma1ur_1§;3semhIy Conatitucncy, 54%: Cross, sth Block, Rajajiivagar, Bangakmc. 4 hiainr. "

ath, Age: Ma_§or, " 150-Yemmnka Ass¢m&y Consﬁtincmzy, No. 14, Singanayalcmahaﬁy, V Yclahanka Hobli, Bangalore North Taluk, Yelahanka.

89.

91. Malleahwaram ; A Vﬁgc;-: Ma._jo1*,_ N.S.Nandicaha Roddy, Age: Major, 110.151, K.R.PuraAssc::nbly -I' -- ' ' Gownshxm Nilaya, Bangalom-560033', T. Bangalore.

Shobha Karandlajc.

Age: Major, V " :4 153-Ycahvanthapum - _ Emhly No.18, 1-1 Floor, La3rbut,_~, Crescent Road, High G:ma.m1s,' "

Bangaiorc, _ _ , Ycshva11thapi.1Ia.}B' V . "

M.SrinivasV,_V Age:

154-R hW Assembty Con:-uinacncy, x~zo.s,4th Crtxsss,' % Jayaaagamwcst, Rajamjcshwaxiﬁagm". "

Amcmbly Constituency, 1 "'N0;'i8, Saizvaj Nilaiya, fie.'-i':-mac Colony, She"'ttyh:41l1i,- West, P.()., ¢ I-3mga.Aore;-560015, '£)r.--A§.$7t1vvath Namyan (LN. W157-Malleshwaﬁ Assembly Constituency, No.9?/2, 4* Main, 1 1"' Cross, Bangalore.

94.

95.

97. Katta Subramanya Naidu, Age: Major, I58--Hebbal Assembly Constituency... !9¥o.46/'9, 69* 'A' Main, RMV Layouii, S.Raghu, Age: Major, 161-C.V.Raman Hangar {SC} Assembly Coustituency",~.__ " j No.250(New No.1 1 1}, Bangalore -75. ' Snzcsh Kum&r.S_;b' V . = "" "

Age: Major, .

165-Ra3?aJ'iu% Assémhlﬂianstituancy. No.17$9}8, Rbad, V Ramnmhanapgm, -- Dr. D. 4 Age=Ma.-ior."m_ '- l69~_§:Chir.'.kpet Aasenably consmucncy, " _ Cr69$;1'i)aknagar, V Jayanagar Extension, /.

éaﬁsubm' . m' 'géjra L.A.. M£.*gb1*,-. 4-"

1'7O~--Bm'a;_va3.'%1di Assembly Constituency, .V " No.%3so;.--1== A Main Road, Gizinagar, M3301':

I71-Padmanabha Nwra Assembly Constituency, No.84/A, 52, 'rm Cross, 76: Block, Banagiri Hagar, Bhavani Layout, Banashankari 3'" Stage _ iMMMM#_dWW,,,, T

100. 3.01.

102.

»&c= M.aj«:~.r.*, Bangalorc -87'.

B.N.Vijaya Kumar, Age: Major, _ A I73--Jayanagar Assembly Constituency" T ~ ' 330.301, 10*' A Main, 3"' Block, Jayanagar, Bangalore «l 1.

Aravmd Limbavah, _ « 1'?4~Mahadcvap1n' (SC) assembly ﬁjonsmucncy, 'Renuka Nilaya", No.6, 9_'§ C1fo&3s;, u 1 .. HAL 3"'Stagc, ﬂew Tippsano'-.I§_< % ' Mahadcvapwfa, ?l[_ ' ' ' '

-,:::;: "

Am Major, . ;

175~-Bomma:; : ' _Constitucncy, House No'. 1'?O, BcgurMain,_'Road,. 4 _ l"?6~Bai:ga}Dic:Sauth Assembly Constituency, Age:"~Major, " Nd-..196;' 24% 1511: Main Road,

-470.

A . Naxayaiaaswamy, '~1_7"i' Assembly Comtituency, ' A;,D.Colony, 12"1ward, Hosur Bagilu, % Town, '4 Anckal.

R305.

J.Krishna Palcmar, Age: Major, 20 202-Mangakm: City North Assmabny consumcméy, ' .j ' I).No.4--3--298/ 12, Palemar, Kodialguttu East, V _ Bejai Church Cross, Road, "

Mangabn: «O4.

106. N Jiogish Bhat, Agc: Major, 203-Manﬂre City South Assembly Const£t.t3cnc5r,V""' * 4-3-4061 1?, Shri léwaakshi, -_ V . Behind S.D.M. Law Mangalon:-3. . '

107. Mallika Pmaacaa, * ' A89! Maia!" ' Ra "

'Kous?hubha?VT5Bolvé§9r Kasaba, vinagegpugtury D".vK.V-,_ ' Mangal<'m:.._ --

108. Angara S., -.

Age; -. _ v 20T?f{Su!.lia {SC} Constituency, " "Dasar1aIL'a_.§s_, I-louse, Village, Doddathom Post, 'V%:'*'%'199- A}5PW~?h19' iﬁétiﬁanl. A86: Majér.

'-208-Maalikcmi Assembly Constrixacncy, Estate, PO. Box No.15, §mq1a;»ur~571251. 1 BW-- 11 m.

"Age: Major, " 209-Vimjpet $5 Constituency, 23/232, Wood Land Son, Marts Compound Road, E -'ﬂ'

-

Madikcrc Taluk, Madikene.

111. S.A.Ramadass, V T Age: Major: A. 216--~Kr5shnanja Assembly Cqnsﬁmencyg Narayan Rao, 1063/77A, ' 'V V 1" Main 6"' Cmss, VidyamnyapL;I'am, Mysore-570 O08. _

112. H.S.Shankarlingc Gcnavriaag _ Ase: Major.

2 17-(lhagja .Asscmbiy'v»C4;:ns£ittpc11¢y, AV " "

No.85, Sahukar Kuvcmpu Nag'ar,;f_ 9 . "

113. Sri Baiachandra°"Roa Age: 41yéa;-s . .

S[o,. Ran": Jamkiholi, R/was NSF Gucsivﬂpusyvz, Byaxi Kataﬁokak, "" "

'F, 3.V14. Gowda Naak- ' , . 31: yee.' , S/o. K,Ni:1ik, Rjat: A1'r:ke:c(Post}, A ' _ ' lkﬁaﬁurga Tduk, Anwd Vﬁsnotikm', Age: 28 years, S/o Vaaant Asnotikar, R/at: House R0705, M.G.R-sad, Near NGO Han, Karwar, a 2 1 16.

117. 1 18.

1 I9.

Uttara Kannada District Sri Jaggcsh, Aged about 45 years, 1 Sin. Shivalingaiah, Mayasandra Village, Tumvcktrc Taluk, 'f'un3.kur District. Sri Jﬂamsimha Age: 61 years, » V S/o. Sri R.L..}alappa, -. Tubagere, Taiuk, 7 Bangalore Ru:a!,nI)i.€itI'is;:t. _, Umesh Vig.nw5.'" ' n Va'?-.h:';'-{a1tiV, ..,,, _ _ ' Age: Major, ' ._ 07-Hukietcxi Aascmbby Ctrnstituency, Bellad H11k:l_K¢=_r'.i, Belgalim £)istxic't,.'f-~ % * 138.41% hugli (2onst:tu' ency, >%ﬁ1gmunngugwuungHoh§, x~_:e1m_ %an%ga2amuk, 7 % k V .uRESPONDENTS Karecldy, (hvcmmcnt Advocate for R1 & R2) V "'*i"¥'liS Writ Petition is ﬁled under Articles 226 & 227 of the lﬂcmstitution of India pxaying to direct the R1 not to release the funds for the R5 tc R119 to tour towards the travel cost, boarding drawn the money from the consolidated funds of thgé;-.Statx:

and to account for it.

c. a direction to the 2434 respondent not in to mspondents-S to 119 b mspondcnts which will be held the month and of August _ _ _ V d. a direction to the 3*' "ts '¢'>£;'nda'c:i;' an and invesﬁgation in the by thc e. a to conduct an enquiry, invcst:i§9$u':.n,V and mis-spending of the tax paygrg and misused by the respondents _ < _ ' them in aoeoxdancc with law and L' --tj::con:l$ pertaining to decision taken by the H <3 ':4 , main gzicvaacc of the pctitiaucr is that the tax thoﬁcy is misspcnt and misused causing public injury.

3. Originally, this maﬁa: came ﬁx admission on ""22.8.Z()O8 on which date Sri Basavaraj Kamddy, learned _'a x 25 Government Advocate took notice on behalf of the and 2. On instructions ﬁom resmi"2dent€§'-1 2,:f} time Govcmment Advocate produced a written by the Secretaay to and Administrative Reforms, ezheeexgst gr dgnggaéim for the 3th American Kannada T held at Chicago. V V' . V' 'V

4. In of the Honftakz Chief Minister Wivlinistcrs viz., respondent no.5-Horfblc no. 18-I-lo;n'ble Minister for Industries, , mspgmgmz x§¢.é;6§Hon1»1e Minister for Health.

no§72»;ion§bI1¢"'hainistcr for Power, mspondcnt 110.87- ~§'6£.:P§oush1g, respondent no.90-Hoxfble Minister 'jar Rural Development and respondent 110.94- _ _f_¥~r!q1i"t;Vic Mitxieter ﬁn' Excise, we do not see the 11% of other 5 Ieepenﬁeﬁts, who are elected as members of Legislative Assembly. ' In our considered opinion, we do not see any meg' ality pmpoaed part3m' "patina by the Hon'hie Chief Minister and the Vfiouncil of Ministers in the aibxeaaid oonfexenee xepmaen-ting the <:i%> Government. As none of other MLAS 'B partactl' 'patod in the coxlfcrence by spendirxgpu-bli;' icif tbs: u b State Ex«~chequcr, We do not see any petitioner. Therefore, ﬁnding the .. "me:-if and" V lega} contention, same is dismissed. % ¢ j Chieffustice Sd/--

WP/_" Iudge

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

S Vasudeva B Com B L vs The Government Of Karnataka on 25 August, 2008