Karnataka High Court
Shivanagouda Paitl vs The Chief Engineer (V) on 10 April, 2008
Author: N.K.Patil
Bench: N.K.Patil
ce ti fe = o Cy « es ie bt hie Doped oo Ba i a S tei ey 7 hf oe : Sb: 4 | ms ii fie aioe re me 8 taf aia Py an ee i * OE fey te * te wee a _ #E t ia ch wo. & ' ae * > we ey Li a. aa ix] bs 4 bed yd «ef : lh ss nin fee wo aa ea i) nA as ang os "Be red on ww ei a ae : on ha m fb EH ony et. at if, o nf fr te a 8 OE ie to eat i i ag Ot * * wo bg ES " Co. HS G og @ bees a int " 3 ot at RM bs iy a eet 03 at of ee - an So a et 7 uy rl i et I ee be of ne 2 py wie ted fe} bo 2 egy "f eS me & fe we ES fs . fay a Py a ft C so 7 : toe ied a ee phe i 2 fa & ined ' F fod a Es S 4 o as sf boa] ape a me Gf fe Ss op al a <s fal mos }HOM YVWIWADIYY am Dnmn pads wun Fe ee ag tag oe aan She MEE AEDS eee We oe ah te te wn > ghey Ea =
iz} Es an 4 fai} ra a ree jeu * any "ana ADVEH K. GUPTA, Ca Ph r oe a ele By EP d H A e praying a bearing < 4 Brticles a order dated Nahe Y i Ei ba mY a ra a 4 x ry td a y 44 /& ay * ior & * fo ty ow remy era aged Pi, s a wo ap ty Ta Bes app RET Caan end » aren ny » = . "
te " ef, el Al ia ae * gy avg gg gt iG ed ~ed dd tm Ry "ed en u 3 2 o Bd fey 4s det a eh hal Roy Ge cae hd fa » fs a Cy ha mo, Ga BY te 2 oc ral £3 ky ye eon £ 8 & a 6 & 2 &@ « PB &® 2 & BS BG t ad é . o 2 - a a i. anc oe ee. ti Prd et hd | Be a eo ob oo 4 a bd ess mM: OG ie "rf 43 op} rt i Pa i i eo] et ee | es Or im) Wo ay "o CP ed G . A ai Sg ao © i os om Bort GQ by a do a men - EY. @ & he m Pal ed me ft 4o Ft i ay . a 4a wl a oe a G8 ee OB mat ig rs ye. 2 oh ; ny gj fy ped e 4 Ole sed "ooo . hy re "any ra BS ia 7 " red 3 gS ce hha 4 dudt + 5 ies Cs fe rf , 4 ped 4 2) eit ik Ha ba oy % op n Oc ee 3 Boom oo ge & eo ee 4) ns ny uu re ee ed nr, re! sf 18 qo OM ao n> . Aes un 82 a a ari *s yey al e: a bd ped _ 44 q : ae ak = : " Sa Cc tt ape ~ - -- =? : f Boog yg 4 4 8 & Bg x me gt : " i er. a et a . . 4 3 'af ap e Bo Boe Go. 8 ea & 4 4 & § 8 £2 2 g a Pg a on a ee eee ae tg nS ee a oe pop te eo Be ke rr a nr ns mes . ey a oe eae a o ec oo 8 mf 2 aed FS ee me gen "ys eH 2 he a 3 a4 a Pe - ha fens 3 et ae i) ro r oy j ope Oe. ke 'i aa "bt " i ra cn 5 © a aN sd a 4400 ey i M os 2 44 eo ; ; ns) 3 in 3 " : yd ™ "log en i a i f Aad : at nq i i ci ra y Pr _ "ri Ojo oa 8 g pe. ee ee G ha mod "rd i Pa 3 po Be 4 Gas : vt rd lo 43 a ee O43 b a) " oe OB "4 oy ee o 4 mM rl £3 a, fe yo ae mB Fg oa rd 4 Gy 4h a © ba, Wes te . a, ify is ce od 5 hy 3 atte fr "oe ee Lae Cy ae Q i. a ory dud! dd a 3 bj 3 cue on 7 6 eb a a a, Ly nm od CG gh. . a rie a ay ty v4 ref Pe a a ns . Cy owe vo AR Sep ed ee ftom "& ao ae ne + 3s bw 45 vd ci gs o a ay il "| cy 3 a aan ' i. a . aye a ES. ree ' ay 8 a aa At i th ts ba ~ oe, mS ty a me sod 5.4 8 a a a . a . i 3 fons in a 7 Eo heb oe _ ta en) ace e SN Bg 5 Bo eg ® fe a fou vl Ba re fe * te 7 sl my S ts ge BP Sy ies = " oe mh oh -- rd a "4 a ej 3 hg Ea oa wh - Lyd a at 4 cd ., ~e4 a is ao OR Ey 2 aR Ss 2 2 2 i ae ay cond ' es 4 Eg nek ca doo A 3 ta m4 6 8 op ie 4 2 ty WAL TEEPE OA OT Ge SE YADYY OA OS OH SY PYADMY AO DOOD HOH OME ADIOS 40 DANO HOM OAM 40 ENNIO HO wt oe Pog ~ @ SG tm -« @& GU a 8 @ # ir 2 = YY = mn & & pa oo sae "4 we . aa a 44 ey a i ig hy aa it it 4a Sd pe ea ord ap] he ce Be nt F oof nd 4 Sa a a | cl 4a = a ar qo.
'rd ey: a Seg hed ved a fy = im fyi] a ab apd send in aft a 4 es : a Ba "™ a : th tc en Ole E fad re hed an 4 3 Pa) Pe "ll ra Ba rn i ce fr ; i ee ae wy fat & a a | ri iG oF pa a : e rn ae 4 i. "= & = aq a i ne moor a es | ay } u , oe Soo oa ow & & & fo og » 2 goo Go gy a rt a ees - tt. Be = : i o ca Cy Pat ie hd in ay oft g u " a ' ag < f it a a oan . "4 3 nn 4d iy <I ne ge oF "f 44 i ha ta rt 6 Fy EO sy. 7G ao eo © = as . ee ee a mm ct eB "4 "
; Ee 3 as ne :
a ge i fae da aw ee - f hal ce ad 4d at a oS 6 8 «a 9 ns en an re ; gs rn rn 2
- i 16 fe Bs u "sy a 3 fe wood Sal g r is . coe 4 he ao 3 C7 _ " eo SG ogy om de BE Ho es @ w F go f FB ne te Haj i. 33 ; " Boe ca , 4 og rs a oj bd at mn a 8 3 i ce er ae a go oy oe 2 & oO & e Pp Bot tH td us 4 od S&F oop os a yO 2 ot Sow fe 4 to, ee ee hy 2 Eh ES & ay u a » Ser "dl gE Bg a 'a eS ie . roe : | 4 a a el a re : a Tn? ce a . Sirs fe ey ns <n re a, ce es nn.) bor ti hed hea fa aa be bad Y Ww ed tl 2 og iti 44 ie ie gq i a fo ap ea ny iF reg % c4 wd ff it & a) a i an * é a i ; vay fe ":
a ; oy ay dt -- * ges. a3 bed med > a 'tA 4S an 2. Ue wm Se Foe & Me 4 i i et ad 4 Q i ¥ a a ve ~ i in . ' rie "t mt a i ; ae 5 8 bes enced 34 4 4 ad Cu : ms cf : a nt i 4 df a = geod 4 ats poof mn 'a ws qe : oF vod 4 a *y ie " ol rs i ag a A as ey oe 7 a oF re Ee oe 4 - 7 re a 8 a eon 7 & m / ee Be 4.8 5a.4 ied Cd Eh HOIH YNYLY NAY AO DNs edu wuiwiwarenr BA UR A ie Cen ee ee ee -
Eft) a "Ty . : a i ee Es g 2 2 3 Sys oS 5S ee Be "A re ee) fr oe Pas be bd Cy Pe 4 ik oe ae a we ee, re) o 4 ing 4d 4a Cy ed , e : ee od " . weak a uo op Bos bp 0 g " &# fi BM A x cp ht o Boy os . a od a Ge TO tog HB om om goo i a i al ul r Roo a + 43 a bs ot . 8 MG had bed rl : as "a 4d c rt o & toe Boar 7 @ 6 as 6 gq & NS ® gent oS e " ~ s tg a wi in i 3 " wi = a re eee ee ee <n oc te - my ea i & i if, a 3 a Mo om 8 aed Sy a, vend oe ey ae re ud . Ae ee 45 . 3 a ins aa ao & Boe ony or} o a ea a3 tie & 2 ig A ay i ca ed a pp i ved ee ee = es wed <p a 4 ran 1 ie ee: eB om Ey os u a he a ve 2 Bu ges * 4 3 ia ia "
mt rs a t 3 fa; an eg if 4 hud if as i a a Pst eg = iy ; 5 Ms rs fs r =) ® u Bh mf a Ji rd = ha ' ' ws a a a a my 4 oo [a he . it os rr eg ™ 'v a ot re 7 : SWS oh rf -] ey we] ee & ve ef, AS is HOHE OW WEAN GO EMO Oka BAR IETADIWA GA OES EO DAITIETRIMEE 2 OO WOH SI SOO ac ene WAINEr a ERAT OU ae bg ce ce al fe 0G os a ee eee . 4 a roel shui.
os, Lae : . ao a a a fe Sa ti , ey "i i hose gt 25 Ad Be $2 44 . as as ii + re a rad ra ey tc hot wa ea ohne fia, eo a a & Fo Hed "oT # oon e af ra) La hel 2 dhucd te po s ip = ce:
ee dal * a3 Et ie a EB a iy.
4 iv) te) St its Eos Lo | OER WEIR AN eee ees Fs ae Fee "@ oS ne ced Gog a a "oe OMG 2 . a "ke a a a 3 _ deol 'Go 2 a BE yi ny Ks) cad ed we' a ee a foes le at Eat 1 ce . a me ifs 2 Q te 2 8 -e " whine Ae oe Ai ao eo "4 a :
. a ooo & a is oh, : 4 ce ce ts oid a "Fi a ted ; i ; es eo i Bs eo ord li La a aa a ey 2 ag ia _ a "
fw a 430 4 @ woe * fe gy 4 od f io uy eR ; a ONY ee vol a ae ES qe AP st ot ae az pe me fey mo 7 . Psa oe ee aR de i iv i> Gee a & . . bats Ba Yt ie a 4 i [a ee co eo nh: pn "4 a Bia we fet re we 4B "et My 4 ai % vi Sod 3 i re he ed ted ie "a mt 44 us o ae.
oped cS da Ma i ir Pa ey ad fy a ad od me oa ae are hey + i ae gk ea mt il an] , S fhe. ya oe w cog eo fy Bees po FES ~ 44 <2 a eek eae oe eee ee Oral and nm of the 2 | For given & SS aSORL A LS * artiy t iener gf petit fe i the third +h Fane ae "iMG 2 ms « nit RE F ' mn gs ui be a e ey a appeliate = ae tr Lies ance * * :
aie a Ao oe G 43 ne * pay the 7 .
a Lg mth . aon DEON ERE WEA EA Ec EWA OOOO LE RE OO HOE OMENS 40 PMN HO CMW ELY NAY 40 LANOD HOI