Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
S Mallick vs Archoelogical Survey Of India on 16 August, 2023
VE TRIBUNA > rracy Reserved on 27.0 Pronounced a7 18.08.
CORAM:
HON RI YE MSPR CELE A ARERR LY YS AR SS & aay ry YAR RP Sh 2 & SRSA RA wR Vid AF yf x HON BLE MR. PRAMOD SUMAN DAS, MEMBER CA) NS .
Sri Sahadey Mallick, aged) about 37 years, Son of Late Mohan Mallick, At/POQ- Kairi, PS~ Pipit, Dist- Puri, at + present working as 3 casual labour, at Sub-Circle, Bhubaneswar, Dist. Rhurda.
ADDICAAL For the Applicant : My. 5.A.Singh, Counsel ~Versus-
1. Union of India, Represented through, the Secretary, Ministry of Culture, Govt. of India, Shastri Bhawan, Neew Delhi- TLNNL.
INrector General, Archaeological Survey of Indla, Janpath, New Deihj-110011.
ow Superintending Archaeologist, Archaeological Survey f incwa, P uratatwa Bhawan, AtfPO.-Samantrapur, Bhubaneswar, Dist- Khurda, Qdisha-751002.
woo Respondents Far the Respondents: Mr. A.C Deo, Counsel Pp ramod Kumar Das, Ld. Counsel for the app Heant Ras submitted that the apnlicant, Sri oy: eee 2 aF ein, Sh Aas THO y& under Section £9 of the AT Act TAaRS ye dated 22.06.2018 {A/S} wherein his representation dated {6. ID2OV praying for grant of the aforesaid benefits was considered, pursuant to the order passed by this Tribunal in OA 137 /2018, but rejected.
ae Ld. Counsel for the applicant in suppert of the aforesaid relief has submitted that the applicant has heen discharging the duty of a regi alar Greup-D employee since 2005 on casual basis. Ld. Counsel for the applicant submits that in accordance with the circ ular of the DoP&T dated 07.06.1988 (A/2) and the memorandum of s ettlement arrived at under Section 12(3} of the ID Act, 1947 made between the Management af Archasological Survey of India, Workers Union before the Assistant re ~ Labour Cormmissioner (Central) Bhubaneswar on 15.09.2011, the applicant, being similarly placed and senior to Some af the causal labourers, who were granted 1/30" pay scale, is entitled to the 1/30" pay 7 a ;
he gen few bet x _ mt a am a iy
-- on th fey pt "noe 4 es net "s ret oa fee a a os eed & or et © ae os peed mn, pao? be paw fe pes Fac 3 Maret. fore of - on eee ie pen aaeed a e "f oe wma oh: ea 2 ron . pe, te 4 5 ;
0, z "a ned need of "on pees re oF woe Pe) Be ; fete oe et, et nneney bana) ae We ahs "seein! ied nag cod wee At 4, sol :
we a vee ee hea "at Sew ye wit, 53 head rs wee bates ak Ss an <= 9 vot Ea beer eg 7% ryeng DP ta " Sa, Ss. ae sy, ve 4 gal ay aw # van oth, ae pred ye ook ' Foal ' aes % fon wen Nol on haere dood Read leat! uses tL ues me See:
oo por, seek aad wt : 'hed, a an em va rea rs "ad BS pres ye sere Nah a id fom wet "tg os ~ ae sree : Eg et a ;
ad boned deeet os iil Mowe "heat. band pa ad re heen oe wo of none a 6 ms '% nae Heed oy howe. acs Seae at z od oor oe Joa hot ws ty dent m peat Spee re on pa yan fod ed een ee as yon pen wee £ coe pen , 5 ¢ Seni son Nop raed aes ; ¢ Lend tree. z Nine on s aac pete, hen ong woes a3 a) Lt San pee, wey os fees ; oe: on he 43 ek inate Cd 7 we . i ae S07 Me is weet ae oe, wee fit ow ee a . * ped, P 4 oO poe fs mn = os Pan ama ' poeces Lat aan pon ee " qeeed 14 a, tt we nj ' baa oad eek on LS a oe $s.
ced yr gt Fi m3 . pan vem pee rm, Sant ah ft --~ eet Chee we on Bk ay rood .
Se rte cee' 'adh #5 ' od a ote oa Ses open "eX tet ad whl, tok nn a Se 'oft a gon Sen rn fom, Lend Nae. on ae fren peren os, Coe pan m, Faas ' or nets ne hoe ae) ay yes ' 2 deed papi vm - wee Lopes Me, "a en Coe pan oo pan iss Sones , on wes ae od sim ea pan a, re, . a aes pete ra he 4 pa fos' cal Pes eet aac head wn, "8 & - 43 "3 dn o te Boon! CA a as v4 ge ton ead tees pak oon aren ¢ pooh pore ' et ae 5 eben che oad "rer Daas titty nee raat "pen pee aa on ne apt wired, > as on as as aes i ree we, rn ad 's "en? seed oe re es 3 ert oe ned Eada nen $ 4 ae, /p, aes og prey ts Paved, oon rs Rael fe ne £3 oy oo, 'enna yn fey, shoes " { ww on 4 we eee i:
bE ee Cat ad fede ios - id wee * Foy oS wy "aes os :
* Fog) wea is, Loe re pees ee ey eet we n3 ; wooed: ow, es ° tad syed Paco 'ed ee, : oe we ¢ yet Rank Fen 'nad? bass $ ro ie ce pene my pas bone mm " aes ~ on bs woeee, we, ci cael he. TA oo wren ea) ee pet hen A eg om 4 vi = a ee SB fee <3 ; t oy os ones woees ra 29) eee At ht Oe ts ee Poe] ae ", ler cheat Le pe os 3 on od frvuerd Ae ae prank oe pee Sank wordy ogre ene Sani? ait ae ears aon, ane eeeen, Seah papas oe QP Soead en bed: vt Pod 3 'iad not! epee fe yan . aca 4 oe tip Naser? food veer Sie Pid fs is 2 oh oa ae net , 4, ; 4 aan ee Foal tia Pa eo 'nol ay A, no Sad oa foc me in * deh Nader Aeodt fey ? a fty "e en Psa 1M 'ned ' kw. Neat ES tos end 3h were Eee Mined a3 gees %, ve, weeee 'ng fics a ay [aw : owed veh bees 'at . ' A vt tht on, San Fos Y SS verns y + oA 2 7 ors ee a oy ones &. nine, he. rereny, ree, nah fet "heat pon 4 ye Cae na oe Soe. poet penn, ge oe ny ; tee aad ees! Ly oe 4 al ingees we raed sy nal ue on ~~ ae oe £4 eae x oneme we ; stp % bod as fo ca i C eooe te ~ ree iy, deed ws 3 fs aes cond
-- yok 0% "oe aft ae o, As ra en poet a. wie ceed "be Sette" Fh ty mm:
eS ann' wee, x tty hig, A Ss & owed by { Hoth i i % ral} x Wd y OT} oN we ner ( > me 2002 ' Pas GN SEES Ved tops ros Seidl 4:
hes wees ot i re, nk 4 fETt bs ee y PYo Tata Hay x & Hast Oi La duatie Ne £ "3 * BS yning bs statis. [bis alsa oe Sips al x Pa os f anne ae 1 oe Oe fh 'att thy oo artes se dated My "hed pees ees ee Leese mm, anal dead yee fan, Des oa pret rOTY >
i) oy :
fa TmHenupesk 3 é A der oo tin, pore 4 2 3 x o & eparec un commieted 240 dr stv} ae "x bes Does t ee Ly Bd pee ae now oe & * oe 4, sede 2 he eee ae Ky PETE ARE "
Ss h
-
Me * HY 2019 disposed of the a Pox = ier, ha ilicat Q ne e ?
3 vide order dated 2 2S De.
ts. ore a tted that the prayer made ak i Rie m y a?
ginal apy fo y & Sey ara-2 = r@ order RE fs Ne:5
¢ to have been engaged on of $ Sey t are sot of this reads as unde ite He CVHESH Ue?
-
UE sul ' ourt of Or Whi learned Tribunal in p as under:
~ wy { ye at i a:
it x Hon'ble High Sigil send go f seek : os eared.
pat : - 3 cS es gs oS | g2 2 e : ° t det Ay bea et , we OS. ~ eo Pond LE tes wheat ee car i Pea 7. es ay eae' bers Diy patil ae ue ws ear' ' hes ea os a pon pe = Ea ees Res Bee py Be Z fo Tod heed nga pe ES Sao ae mS i COD * mee ripen aoe gS I tep penne eid, bee oe rs Bs ee eS Be 5 ers . é ms 2 hy 20 A ie Tek np ta UA ne teen G2 bea & 2 tk fi te : pon a ee ee abe g -
" Ee, - fa ., we me a pean ooo z 2 op BY "ag gpa ioe = z wi Ee BO 2 ae. ee Da a SE AOS Co. St 0 ED fe 2 fe eng Tt p70 weet eee, Sd i
--a--< is XE wes OOM ad ; a : fe wea gt * ee $ bans ee aa ee mS eos Be DA ny aA < j "a me = back Ls Sng ad : aan re ft Sec fete 7 Bek fe OES rot, £ fot gett pms EN Oy ¢ me tee S Ft ome yo Pad yee 050 aa pen. B ye ru, we ee ST Oe Bes RA < Smee tons TO cs ok 5a es cad wee to rg ~ eo me z 4 "ee 3 bd 3 a Pome on Ya, 4 4 aaah ted 1 ae a, Be he BSS BS ne 5 ay fo Set ae % as LS as Bind pe Se nf lel proce SO ar is Urhe tga ~ ee fn icon co ma rmme Sapene eet a ¢ Sm Or ap OR Roo @ a nS a ae oy het Fabs mo, @ BOS fe aS ie we ty . 'a os my fn, a ees my Neel ¥ ; wh ee fo = sai eet "as wm, by TD ae ot 'Sot Fahne bee he ay i z it ee wrens ote ay Wh pn fe Od vey ty pomn C0 oe aed ; be *t ye 'a ee te y wie Sa ag " j S oe nant es apes Og ESS a en oe Bt sod oe he nt a on yon. Swe kg te, Bh So on. : BERL BEE g FER OS we wi Oe TD -_ as . me - sane, one ye LS eens be fos, HE eg "2 ime oN ay UR re See om a OF oo. to £ x2 in 3 ted let a a 19 i <img ne a ede eee ec ee es fax ed q f LE TR or Reacad tg Ee pe ge ES Tn Se ae one a, 8 os Be ae a , po GD tee og ay . os OR aS Be G3 ee. ae 6 Fs bag Pet HO fad re Pca ro os we : ;
Bas et Ey A ee ae, we AU Se Oo tan Pr webee a. 4 aad we oe. wn & a fe we oe. on wor pan a ~ Jaws > Ea) os gee . ise oe © Aad: Pr ey kone, gen "he? betes Ma Nesey Meteo brn poe wa nae a aa ay arere Secon, pee wy en . . eed wat. aod And acnes tad pee fo ty + at, = ceed ove aod vn os bet go Fon' wane _ oe in. cet ai. tere A fo fos on ben yt fh mal aoe, ore : a fet eteess t ; Pe nn % a z ' a woe deed eee Bead aad Fabs ios yd Cs Fase <a Pet oa ow ewe mae fot, 5 weed ei paw e Se aceadl Bega , gs wets end t ian BY ed Lest ba ee "ae + hone TE OR meat tft an me oe weet tts tet Gn * ONG re a, pot we aA a3 an ap bans fa _ a ie £8 f Ar gk aa a B eines , > may, Fae] "aes band a Sees Tes Cts he vee tO fs yerer at of, 'ak 'on hoe eel ns 'the ee ahead fo CS b ces wien a 6S nyt Wy ay na heed a inane need B ee pean, ee hd eres ° gut teen bn jit apa ~~ mers ope shot ot We poe Oe aa 'eel 'ot ws im Aa = Gog ert "uel soot fi fest inae4 eae heed yon a we nd a Aree?
Fees SAE ay 07 oO bee ied hort cD von Sandan ee ah sd Nat peed vee oo mes ¥ 5 * % oh. pees aad we sf wien anaes ed es L 'nat Nah irs 4 Hot As H oe BO ee a 2 bet Co aeons, WOE coed wn AREA SA ~ aes Lae o x vor Irene gre "nee a oe ons ad em oo aot posed owed i * fon, wea on es ated Sten oon, _ ™~ ret cn $ Sen ee ew ras 'Seat Sash ed lass fe Mae ome ee Te ae G2 eb "hee + we het fee ' dood. a5 fom os we fs ns ms % Sond Son pa " my te te oe " basa Me awed Gs re ra) ify ae j wae he fot ees Face : 4 ths read 5 et gen "sinc oo bret s, wt gon Fant phous Son Pate, gr Rent ms ae gen sat Par: 5 Nannie . Nad whee? pans Dae c coaatl vaacl te. tents ty Poms er we ; Aeok A eb or -- ss ae " ' nf, Soap 5 a he my, rape po wet yon 2385 ps bet th pe "ema a ee posts 5 roy eheed, So ogga é we ba oneal we ~~ on Sax ote mG ae . Pan wend 6 lone cas Phe we borne ¥ aed K, nen yer ~~ on tone. oe 'eat. ppceds pa pen Poel 5 wee nypen peewee, Least * heed a Fe iied ni ", a ieee! patos, aad eed "Aer renee " oS oko as we pee pate Ts ee ts £%, if ~~ oes * 43 > Oa ad ty horns ee tahoe ace ~ aS Pare pew : % " we Le Os Paes one. peel Low ab od Cae et "at we ae pentane foe ome nt le ae ot re as J ta a Vere? .
baa we4 ht Shins, bon eee eee CT teed, noe and besa' nn EP 43 at * yy Re Fac' anny 4 pe ve tha peed, 'na 3 wa Ban? 4 ~ LO rand se geek me joa ; loos a pond view as 4 "
Es a5 Ge den oe Mea con good ts heb * Cy ten foes raed oe * ay es tut cm o3 43 iy 'cot pet's Ky aod ane Bak "hat pon oe7 ae fad + , Faeat 4 on Y ee laa canes ned taadiacen Neg wns, tf LP mp Pood pete, ee ween hb eS pe nf eon, % "3 agg = oad nan we ode peed ea rat tA essa A thew, "3 «and 7 a a LE Zoe S B ns @ % race Se fp OD Poa we sg. , sheet tt ae ES th aagl erent, aad > Be od , os waged, : be Aro tfo 1 pei teen th ehog Cor a 7A * aoe heel as Pad xd Sed + ot pe . pete Ss oS wes shed en greed, bas .
' yee oh Pa eet Pe whe. ae ae en rn, laps He ry 4 ns Red new anil ceaadl ad res we A ori ' 2 2 "ne a os * ms Sear yen Me oy oot ve whee noe hap, shed : 4 soni ded 2 ime Sea we a4 be o, et pt veer ea bens Gy wr bocee fon ood ee z ae * fad 3 face. it en 2 ba] fae) Pod ee od rr, - sheet roaes ecasd boos > wn : $ were 4 ee we LE oe id a </n: pe es oS & oe th, ie nts on ; Paes cook ad Ye bac weno when, speed ee eon: 4 root veh . psa ceee : ; bw. ey Sad we £ bead ers Poe. gee ; Ae oe, . oa on ns # . cl Tee th £08 ors Tat gen ad eet ae a 4 Chae cane eal? add ea ed tat bec new ~ % hae! er GF +p aa fees Sot sone ee ee wes. eet os ew ae eben mi 4% FE pee Sat pee pas ye geal , pa pesos wee ieee we a tate, 4 dae neeee, ies, oe Siptes, 505 y a eh. nt E we ren von LG me yes ie 'dee é : ¢ . vit aw , Fapea, ned Z "S ; peneos ; o S ; ¢ Saw oo. ace cia wate ree te rae we. pees aed Poa. are wee, ome bea , oe cea be pe yer ed foo kd ee iad Sod fake, foo Soup oon a pees ss pees var on ass Fees Bie ot oe one a oo eee) Bote RS pre bene Sotaee si na oF oe at Se et Sowa, ee o god ioe x . ; wey 'egigh 4 + we, ies Saal or tes os bee he & " hy BK are oa feos Reed nee baa 'intl pose « 4 Me "fi ed "abt Sah. oad, yeeee, a ee on ay hen "ee ees r ay a inn bags 33 oe. teen: es Lion 5 ob ae pened Pia ieee: 'ot Pehy i. "hert haat Sat ¥ hes 8 eet on ; Saas! dpa Paks oo a "
A a an B & _) ' me kD , ie om ; ie Fst sehen co tos on, Sea thas be rgtrn on, ort S ras " 4 we, Mees wat io om es ree beard Py A on ens & peat whe ee xa on ; Seda Bs a7 et shot 'tall ne, ict ha Sree " me, ee wees. <n "ak ot pote, ep ' ead foood "nae? "Eg sged nee pases . ea ay" ty :
& beet Ses sea oA cot wien tom, wpe von Ad 43 ab Xe se ae a on feos <i foee ° es bs x ted oben ae es ¢ % Sons op ad any "hee ah ron nS : cheb er wee cl nthe na Y po oe: cic £3 , arc wats a yn ne Le "aes ak vent fey wn Bai aoe hk hep bug anky i) a, how ba he in 256 on 'at KEE 'net fev nh, "ened "a vee, z ay creed wher ata yes we "hd 7 ef ped: Peed . LE nel aed "gl wn Se tanh ed ates were LF; peosd ad 7 bee Be, when Lean oe Pa sak fie wn x ny few % Wwe Poa of beet * ead moe. . 'ned aes lenaal ae . toot oe " + Len Ps bag oof 43 %& oe aye er, nas tt on ioe ea ad ba Son ms mm "3 ie beh "yt, cad oy om : ' pa ee ee fad $ een re, ae a3 as nog z Sl fon teed Bet ~ pec epecrs Sat Lord faot 2 peoes Raceal fone pone $55, Fs, aan tts ca pad, & songs pats pres ie . x: wane : wht. qo LE bod on Laoad ih a3 one pen ve oe hee on eee Beas Sinn' paiees sees Seed 'sad: foot age ms Pia Sine! we waved thee$ 5 Meng 45 ae onan Sood Mites g py * 5 hed ww eed * Po a Yi pa ees Wh te Ka ae , oo fe oni Eaaaad o Red Ge we we wots we ia: me shteds 'ah. sak -- : vey aa Paves Syme Fea om, seer wen: ~ bent poet en od woe ieand ' *. % weed oo ipttwnl ens Aa, . a4 a roe bad Se Bo week * B cased wees fons nd open on wo: Sar ; ae res Lhe ; ' ov net ond. fe dat Oh we oor oe test. bt 9 ogee i tnt Kees 2, oy cea wines, cn ¢ yee roooh %, ae 34 os Boa) ah te ee HE we pa ves oF get Se A os pad wi, we yon or oo hed: ' fact ae bod Faget gon ee, fen aeeet wet teen pan @ : bos Piet re 5 yen wren posaed oe "4 4 Pad fg waees 3 if Le . é nk Fane bs en ae bey Py tad poe iat sere oak wer Meads Son fren ers gs oe wn ney io Brees pn z Lae . Bes gos o Se oe, angst 'e ros peri om 'te : deed Cadi, Brad oe yen we Eooead a (aes tines peel rh weet ra ty Se on, "ew ', ie eo, Z ws £3 axl . "
oe beatae, nan feoraal oe ae! a " Re on ad oe fon Be *. its, geen, esd th. w Pad bee 2 bon & eases on tote tag pei ween oe % Ane, Oe paaced yen wy el saree S yer thy he oy eect Eee ye "eat See? Seed Ae Lael " eae yee we ied aig : feet "at £ 4 xe oe : ve See 4 eodey a poe whe reek be, wet heen ba gore ; ' 43 So a Seat $s Aeaes oe aseagl oy igen aad Pm, BS Ard i pee wy aa cane oo aes eZ es pn Tod toe a oes * ed en pow on a - ad ~~, Ceaaal pone "abet wa we fay, é a Sara ath toe wee ' Yeah aoe bcc peas we ot 4 frees, paw Saad ee Poss] y pen, pan Eee ons wy . as -- * Qe acoaes ad, '0 " pea, mek eek To 'att nee ay xe pre, Cheek ' pare ase - od ", See per oo 2% 'Ae 3 cae ae Sone ie ; 'me? siete, Ay Ot ere, es 'ead Post Ne ¢. _ res tee vas Oe Sad fet ee ", ty Sine LS & tae me iS yoy " ee yee on Nn Laat 'ate wgrne ea ey oat ag) be pats as ry, paces pies oD olen oon hea od ay tap % sheet i bos 2 " 4 ; ay to ee fe SA " ¢ 5, Pi het oioes Sons we Os uk KS Peet bod Raed st ye ac con) eal tS pe beet ge ee fags Sod a4 y Swe ae] 4 we, ect ae ee sree Sena, woe wae " en. ¥ wited. x ome? pond 4 vee pecs SE ar) y 3 woh Bai oy syn She an Shae 4 eee pee: "e% % Hare, we Pang) vm, ' ' Ces + ah, pas on Se when, i abr oa Nee bods vot ae eo nae abo Clad Tal Pied oe on bed on Ssacd ". oS Cat Pd pers on Bint pen oe ' oo for . , pad penn frm, ' eaem "ie pia Packie ay a oe a Pee ee tee 5 po oo has Sphle! sine. deat eas " Ps oe om rnd wea tere on a3 . 'remy * pore Cod ort leet . wen ee oy ane Be bin Sa pate pee w E kane rae te fs ok, wee 4 we a a ow. ? yh s of , SS pas Sood bet they. 'sind > aeee, gg ans $eccp GuEOSON oon " ee Fo at gree - aca' ' : Sonne MEA a : oe oy gene a ' ns pon, rated i % Nat t nopee oo, ro, fons Se een oo fe orn oad ott ae be cones bes ad hires "eee! os i Eapcuce sete tan poe: Ont ' ae e ~ we boot 4 ch rae " net ay ti * fen he Mint per ond Fh ined seh ve Pag one Ee ba ~, " inh; ane wn, Long pon ae if ms Le pane tos aad eel a oct % , Net" ' 83 oh we "eed ' gra ne pacers ees ef 'nai $54 SRG ae, } as, a ¢ een ce went fen = ra a a oa a 4 ak is pe Tat pees, ee * . sa ew bane oe. Sal oy, Sat pes weeded a peat et " v fees re L0%, hoot aes yer at ealeaid yen ee, ee arene, 'a ap beeet, ry g; see. Lo piers Nad a) 2 ae peg ey , ot - 'od we 2 f 7 a < "4 S i ' wae x ee ee oe - win " es ab when tid Sone x toe rae a 8 es a a fae ity ay on p ae pad on oh oo ban GA rd oe ~~ os reed se a, fone feat os vat oo 'rat ve te Feed Fs Se is yo os i amet 7 a wae sie acs nh, eee Bion fen, ane, Eacead soeee, wee, cand were "ah sepen Pal oo ne saat) ee Es "ns bes, pony me shod wove Vaaaad hod vee "adh sent wn ie! poor ss fs "S Yo es st Pe 3 wes = : ow ok hen OM oa ay ovaed 2 + ise Em 7 wns Rae oe Seed -- Bak be aa, yr, oo as ; ond 'at "nat . os eereeteny > Sahoo borane' Lf shee wo TLS ee at ot an "sol +4 Sowa, td fags os :
Bical "nad bid weet ee vee te ~~ 2 fe?
wa : = aed path ~~ ed pee get og free, a verre i. eee Ce Py, ded ange tags one hovbe, et soc, rend "f et oe, wen pas canal' te a pas . rer, oy) aaa' ba os ireleas fen pe Se! pe aed oye ee wt ord, ms ave' + pe fom, sen, reeen we, on ~s aa weedy
- Ran oS os i LA sheet . rm 'eat one fi Pad Janet wy + pet ee, we rs om » gas) : ' Pi tor Pty fees ote, rg?
= Cat Ao Se oy, raped beiheic , tn , ws a mae apie "ee rine 4 Ain hs : 'Arcd Nee Hen o Net hrebe, ; A L Set ©. agers fen, Se, 'eat 'eet 5 yr sa etn WG qe yrece. LA re weno: rie ce or 8 we eas de be eee * as ee Sen Pah rey Shy ter wee et nenet eee ae ha bees see mo ane,
o) pent ore pad nbs £4 cn en "
foe oP a heen iw ee wpe & ates shed ut eee Si rere foot vent on a o ae) ad oo fad "a, eetews ay 'del fwd en ps Ae * fee, yen" vin ' en ernst, va aa on pees yess roa ee x as 3 1 baka Seitz ~ esen pause, Seeeel wo ree) are ter baal wt pene, ae + free plea toad "aA oh. ood Fes .