Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S Digital Global Soft Ltd on 19 September, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
2'é§?§'§fi=2€E"--%E§ z.z:'.i%ie>,z':
M.) €f,'§'I"{)1" E?.§i3f}&Ei§'£:E£I",:'E <32": §.§'E€;"' EEK? =% 53:2 %'..hr;? x"€-?a*<1>1'<§. E'-Z*s»..-':?1"1 <;}%.E3:3.%u?' 2::.m%:'1<§.2'1':s:::'1E §;'1i'm<:ius:7§:1;=;:;" S%M§"}mE§f:?{f'§.§(I}§§. .34; 9%'fE§e<:§.§.m':.1._15E§»:"%;'::};';%% {:5 {he s'{aE.:,:éé% §t::<}{i:E»; E'é*m":2 €3"L{)€§,2{}{3f£:L "'E'i.*~-he-:.:3;- :'";<;>M Effi.§f{3§?§;§}'€§f€7.§.'i'i}é? <4:p€:"2':1§'4fE<};<":. E-'<Z*e;;t:>:;': 2-z{1t<7:::'{iiz.':gf K3 €E'":~:Eff .:';§.I'EZ 'a7?Z"::{3E?(i§ >.§i§£';{,:%,'i$%{}i";.;Vihfif. E1Sl=E§éTE,%S":§f;f€f wzzszg ;":<}'§' m'1.i§éE:::{i {:2 $3.16 s3;ii»:3.V_ ;'<1--f:.:i:r§_. '"E'°VE1€<.'<3i*z§V£:¥r"§::é%{ss«;$c§' by :"§"'_:.::>, ;'5:s;ses$§:':g ,s"m§.}1m"§V_§,;: wgfssig,a%.r';%o§:e'<és.:1ss a=:ri:E-- vv§')Ai.'€j;é:.E{§]§.%IT3:2i§_ is ihzsé mi.€%ré%s«'-fig: <35 Eiiészé §"€;%v€i£'1':.£€%; "SE19 '-iT<3§;t{.g1'§§%e:::sé1;f;:":{::f xarzaiss j1.:s1§f§.€:ii in €:x€1'z:3§s§E:':g_{ hiss :*&wi:s§€.}§:2a3 1}'%;é':*is:§i€'f"'E{>:§*..f«?v§*}%.{7E}' x:~a:;'~_:E,e{i in him. aé (':0ffi:§1':E_§i'.e£§«-- :~?§;é;t'.r.'E<m::: é3'I'§"{}§' in i:1é::ér§}:>.:'§1"1g§ '§hemE'bm'3. E§€":€_ 7.E'2'--'i'i<3;,2.5_ W§;£.h Eh? &;a.i.:i {}:'*€..E€i';:1'.:_ <13.-= VE:?€::'.{><'>rHi :2i';.V"§ .?f::&*'--3:%:31:°.:'f:c{i C<):4::"z$&§ 55):" '%:h.::*: E:?;E-3f:%€;"f5{%S5£i'.'é;*. :s;::§'}§}{3r_i:é::{,§ §.hs:% iz:'1'§">::§;:'i&:€E <'::"£.§m'.
_ v §:: :f%::§? Eig;§E":£.'. (>37 'f§*;€ i.'2%a:i.:&:~, ;{%_i"E{i§ :§2?%z:§.Z ::<31':'a.<:::1€§<ms=; ihg-3 é--§;{é:;a$%;::1:':«§.§é駫 {_;v:::::~7§'§:§::'1 GE" éaw i,E2;:I:%;, 2"zz'§:'4:»€=. 523:" {f(}E'E§}§§{f§€3?§"§{i'§TEGEE in E.I§i::%=.~; 32 $3/* '-.V..:E;;§§._"EvL)'V§§«24:'§.§;§:z_,:",, ::::.:'§:)--:4s;{3s'::E§<:::': {2} 1':'12":§a;e':5e:e :3'? <>E:>2:1.:' 'iE':a€,: 8
" 2%-"?:azZ.E':s:>:' Size {.>z'(;§a,>2" ;;:?:;$s;:2{z' Egg ¥"E'2e:= Liigés :"§:z§.f'zz}:'z'§;; _§;z'z.:i3'2§f; (.f3'"€?{§§§" 5'53 EEK? :'.2..¥?2:i}E.£f'3Z" §;~:z'§0E E';j;;.f;_ :.z,%izg; ?::;§7 fa.-§;5 +- €§{?{§££{?{é?€f €255" %<;=:2:'*::ras.= mm' <"<:2:::sg'%5;:.:<e;'z_iEgg rasgjzfiéfi zs;.é3"':;=«?:': {Z25 t',ESf§{_-?SSé3¢';' §"sz;2s zwzi <*E:iz:'.;*:"ze*{:z'.b?E£:c%_S5155?'<2.::'%{,::::§§"VEr': zifzé? r{:?i,z,::'r'z:s k;'%'£g«?e:i zaizfigér §"E'2c,> g/;:.;.:";}c':r£"a=%¥:i. :;?,¥:¢f:f:isee £.§_{ 'g.;<;z.1.§e:" _{§::s_§ia??fi Ss3{7§.'z'<:::'2 §:7§£¥ Q_f"2""I'2e:% z'§{:§' :14; :.:«*i.Ez'§€'?" ' V ' A ' €31. €E}z1pi.&:';" E? 5.}? £E'3::% 1-1-"-':<:*§é"~«.g;:§<:.::2VV§:%'Ts 1%:£"E[§':' C{,:H€-,"¢.%;'.*?..1?.<.'s:'1 a-md E%2ét<;:{:w=.ry ca? '£"'ax, Se€:£.i:i:e----._ §'>'}{} ':_'§6€:¥3:E?=, 1.36%}?-'f; '{i<3::i:,:ati%;..i.G;;2 aé S-;:~%Z}%..'i1'z:.',é', 1-tmcji €§{§'é;-'J-}..E'1{'?€:? §i}2i};*:E"E€:I'1L SET'(i3.i{€J=E"§.V E32 :9 i?*§€{:i.é;'*<5::1 'E§§ _§n*e::n;'§{ie:%s5; f:}r £.i:=:<i§2..1€r§.§<3:'i 0'? fax ;€E= .:5{"§§.:";f<7i;%"'i:.;:T:f 3£.§é.'r._ §{;3_z'§:31i.:%§ §'zz3e:1{$:%;. E§&«:7t:i=:m EQ9 Q? ihéé Exiié ;3='::'=i':-i3'é.;:;§€:s:V;7a;::*e:%(?§::4"§2'>:'"%.:';§; {.§fii{i{:i{5'§€fi?{§. E3, §"€'7é.1{§S m'1€i€i:°: ,5 E}'§2:' V)' A. u . V' E; n " _.{2'.eci {mi gbn ;";'2r.;::'i.e% in ::;:?<:<.>r"{Lé':::._:j2,{x;:V :,€.%s'§I?':2 '.§E'z'e;a;§*Zf}ra?g;{}i;::§; ;):'a>a2§si0n5 Q; §.§E§5§ §;%'2':2_;3fE"e:I.>r éi3.E"'af.§J;}{V2'i£ff is} 352:? {.Tesz.§'.':*<:z§. C§=:}Z)'€f'i'F'§§'§'Ee:??'2II ..;<;?"s::§Z ?§,'€"s3?{z':~e2§€§ as '5{.:""'g}::g;;'z3e?:":§' 3;" §'5z:< am. §3<?Z'2.4z.§;' (:5? s"E':s: V' " §'3£f,:":§{1'§2": ;;;*'7;?":<};2'2'.%r}: z,:.:;":{,>s;e> z'm?5}§'s'2a.> §.§'"2.:~,> {Ee{E:;{7§:'.<m wgzzs V'"K.«.3}E<fEéf§e3?T_" .{}§"~:§§'§.%? {.::4a.%;':»::=3r Q?" 5.32:? E§é:'ifL£§"§f§;, 0.? :35" 553%? 525* rzigf 532,22 <'324z.x:':a3:* rig?' ;2:'::é_}s::":"§; 213:" 53;" :"§sg> z.m§§,- §':{:§ (i€:1 <53? 53? iégg $§';.:::;¥;>§'s{>E{§r:%?, 5:5: {.'{"i,f§{? _??2z'.3§:§ E39, C \ \
-< a<<.3§? 'xx ; %2x~'i"'s