Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Cheluvaraya Swamy vs The Divisional Manager The National on 14 January, 2011

Author: Subhash B.Adi

Bench: Subhash B.Adi

IN M.F.A.5380/ 2008

,,,W,..m...'.,,, ,",;,,,,,,,,.,,§,W_v,

1N THE Iiii(}}*E CC.) UR'? OF KA.R.NA'l'A}{A EXT 'fT73{\?~JC};"xIT.()Ri£
I)E\"E'E%iI) T1138 'I'E'II9Z 1:3" DAY OI? J;'\NU.17\RY 201 E
I3E'§'{9'C)I{Ei

m 1; Ei()?\?'BL1£ E'.«'§R.J{.§.E€S'I'I(fi}Zi"l 31.18;--task-»-1' £2e1_;;x'1':>«:..'   ;_. A' 

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL N0.5.38b';52(§.G8._ Z
C W _ ._ _ _, .

M1scEL1..ANEcUs FIRST  5339,/2oo~8  ' ' --~ . A' " 
5394/'__;_£;';),§l_2_§ %    %

}33E'I'\?v'1+3I~11\.€ :

1.

E5=:L:§:'i"'~gs:%:'%;}%:I\:'v: ~

1. r-%.'' V»: g C11e.1'L,1\r21x":.13-'21 Swanlyy _ 1 8/0 E:-:1t':€: Si3'":g1':.1ppa ' .

Aged a1:>0u.E. 5} years _ ' N3"3a1;1;:z1.2;é.V 'V W / 0 C11?ga.e'i'L1t';1:*2:;, Sw.a3.::1y..,_ ' ' Aged 2-:113€o_V1T1E-f_~'~1!6 ye:;?i:">3_ B(>:"_§:}. 2.1 re AI"</ at. iw}'ii1b%J'21V'1:1:::I§Lrpp 9 HiUj1€1Y1T('IC1Ll I-3:331.' E'3'i»<ia1'c§Ti__ E'ii'<)b1.i Ra1n1a1s}21'g.:1rz1 v'Ifai1.1§:<.A " " "

I3:11'}gza.I'@.1_feA 1".)is1,1i§(*.1}_ ' .. ;'\I.>};»ELLAN*}*S _{}E-3y SariR.C}3<1::md1;:9i':§:.E1g:j}#.::-11&'V_ Aciié fez' L-£'WV}7(:'I'S N91 AdVS~} °~,x1~zA M..F.;1,,$:38-9A}'2Qos A .__Sm'£'.. .I}Z;:1L1".:1V_11*V:2=41, 3,-*e.'3:'s W / 0? 11:1' $.69 C.Thc11.1v2'1t'21_} 1.1 u , L_'_K.'u1T:V1"'. ii:,:S1,.a1'13:.1. E3 ye-7;:1.r:s ' _ I7}_.f(': I,a€'.c:*. C,7}1e}1..1v21:"£1_}' L1 Sri. I'3tE:'."{.1'£.i]".£-Ti1"z.; 53. },_»'C.'€1§'S'5 fa; E-2m> fiEsi1.'1;_::11"e.-':.}':1:m.
S%m'i} E£02'::":sI:u':1:':';s».z,. rléii }«'€."£'?£:':=% E} ;' <3 Lam: (7%1i:z2:;.z.s=;w'z1':2"1}?
AH are R/at f"i£lb?,)E'1I1E7£k11f}})(* H.iU'.é3iIT1&1{i'1J I¥3'()::st. Eiciadéi Hobli E22111'121r'12'1gz':1'22 'F.2=:111Iex:..
E?§aa:r1g211r7z'e Di::e1.1*ittt:.
Appe1};z1'11. N0. 2 .siI'1ce minor' Rcrptd. E3}; her 1'11{;>t}1é;%r/:21pp€:IIa11't'. Nofi .. AE¥'I'EE'IE,i;;'\,V.§';<ETA' {By Sri. R.C§121m11'21$11£2ka11', Acix.-2 R31' Lawyfis Net' V "

IN M.F.A.5394-/2008 ~ E3 E"1'VVE'fiN:

D.Sure$h Sfo I)0r:£da Sidda1a.E1 Ageci abom. 27 years R;'a.t. NO.5/ 1.. E.'\fIa1'L.I.E..11i I\f;'}.e1y2.1 91-" .E\/Iaixl Reeld, S}1ixrz1:121haa,3'h'~.._ . _4 V E?>:~,mga}oa'e A 560 010. _ if 3 .. APPE£LLAN'F {By Sri. R.Cllancl1'e1$h(i%k2i1',V.1'xd*s.. :'fr){* 'L_21W§§<3i~s Advss.) AN I):
3 . Th Diviai <3z'1';1.§ ~«§.'y_'fé53;§f'12i§§:C''.1'.''' -. __ --

'I.'h.e 211.i.Q1§.a]. {1'1St;.1éé;;.:;.gté%-- Cg... Lt,C1., DO; 11, 0.64. '§..211'b21g,h "Roéici Misssi()11 "Q.UE1'{1 , Saé.}';.i C£--3rI1'1pI<-;?x E%;z?11"1gg1I(>r<:? 4. 560 05?.

.vv'Sti'1iE'; CRaz.£}1i'1z1 H """ "

""5! c1":v1.§é1{€ésvh{a=':1I'a I'-f(>11eneecIs v._[-N0".29'7E',"4:"F"~.E3.}c3c7k, §..O'?" Main Read E9.2ije1_§'i'1.;§:liga1i§=. E3e111g21§.()1't: -- 2360 E) i O. .. I%'.E€SI?>C)N{)I£E\E"FS .~ ~ A {Common in 22411 (hf: ;e1.p§)c:%.2[11.<.s) < Sri.AES};iiris-;h1'121$sw:;1.11'1y. Adv. for R2 in .1\!i.F.A.538O /' 2008 ' ';3;ji.1A:N,Kris}?1"12;s5wa1'1'1y. Adv. for R1 in §\/1,I<" .A.:'3389 / 2008 E3,_C?fScr€r("h:1ra131a R210. Acixa {hr R1 1:"; M.Iiz'-\.53E}4/2008) E':/1.}-?".f';.E3f38€}f'i?,C}{}€*:3 is §i1&%{i L.z;<zd(=i:' S€<'"iim'§ E'?3{"£} {bf M'\:' AC'? ~4..';1:;;;,s:-:'::'~::;~::-. the K; z.:s::Ig;x";'1e2'2:f £:':I1('I zaiwalti cizméci ®?".C)9»2G0-II» p2:$.:3;ed in ifvfixiii: ?\§:>$4E3Ei4/2(){}2 {)1} the? iilét <.}§K_}':.,:€.L<,{t?, {'30:.:rt <3? ;"f3:12aEE éfazzxlstéfa E\fE<:tmE::<:*.r, E'*..zE:'E(LT"E.'. §:32s;.:":;§:.:§c.3:°<;?g E§{'f{? E" £19 §}€iE"Uj; 2i:]1z;w'§:1;;§ am: <éF.3_.%:*;t:
in peEit'.i0n {hr and See:§iir1§g C111"lET£1'1('ff;?H1€?111 of <:c)1'r3pz:-.1'1&§ai.io11.
<':c">1':11:)ta11&'saEicm i'vi.F.£'\.§I389/2()O8 is filetil L.£."i'id€E' St::vf.i01'1 .1 7'Z?»{l] of Ac'? 21g:;2.i.1'1si ihe jL1(1gI'I":t?I'1i and a_w2,1rd <iz2m::(1 {}'?'.{)S"3.200<1» p21.~}:s<:'d in 530.442-3:2 f 2002 r..:m. the {£16 <i2f'"LJ11c1g<e, C('m1't. of $1":321iiV'"£.Téiz.;;~;§:?::5.

Member'. EX/fAC'1". i3aE1gEiI(}?€?, SCTCTE---LE}. ;j)a1"t1.y £i11O\Vi'I":§§"'1.§3§i;'.__(7Ii;El;I}. pf.',I',iE.i0I'1 fox' competlsszxtiolrt 2111:} ;5see§«;it1g; e:'1h;;ii1c'er:1€%:.z€;~ _'{;-f ' c()111pe3n SE1f.i(I31'1.

M.E*'.A.5394,/'2()O8 is; f1'1ed L1r'1ci€r[.Se(%t;§O1:

ag21i'1'1s§. {Em jucigmem, and 2m='a1'd C§21iI¥;'«(j§ U7:U9.i2£~0(3--"1_ pa.s~*'sL"c%(flA"i.;j1 MVC N04494,/2002 on me Iiic c"sf:;}L,1.c1g€; *--CG1.1:"1. ()f7' -.$,Z'1'f1£iH.CIEi'.L,1$§€S. ~ Member, é\/IACT. B.:11'1ga.ic)1'e, SC?'/'1L."._i--"*C.3.., {321I'£:'iy 21.11c)t»ari;1'gg_"'i=.1<1§3=t:Iaim=f pet 11.10 11 for c.'.01'1'1pe:nsa1.i.03'1 2-md '» éfseeki rag " . _ _eiA1TE1i1}'1<§;311'1c.r1I. 0f c:()Ir1p<313:~3at.i()1'1.
Thisé Appe23.1S c011'1.ing"' «r»i'1.,i1*31.' ji:hi.:.; day, £116: Court. deiixrereécl {he f<>11cm-'i.1'1g;;: J B n M ?~.,_ V M.I«?_A.N0.5;38O}f'.LSiO081._is of the d€C€'dSi?d son C.SV1I1'i*éSi'1T.' v *£§he A"j"i:'£i'g,§1'1'1e£11. and :51wa::d in M.\',{1.No.éi95§4/2OOi2,~. "'c¥.21ie§¥V..ff.§3.20O4 on the me of MACT, Ba1'1ga10r'e. .A.N<)~._538§}'/.S';LOO8 21g.:1i:1s'i' the juc1gr11Cni. and Vezxzg-'21.rci._':i13é. §?.N'0A;iH»9.2.,!«2OO2, C121i1'1'12:1'I1i.s a1'€ ffhi'. wife and one mii'1m'" » .c'i';i_1V<f1< :'«::-nEd._ p21:'c:n%;:ss of the dec:ea.se:d C§1eEu.varaju. M.¥¥'..;'i.§'€t5.53E%;1j;' 13}; Eihe i11_}1.,1.r<-rd ('t121in'1an1 vi7:._. IT).SuresI'1. ' Sign c)i; 4 VSi(idz1iaE'1. 2:1gz?u'1'1si. the ;'2zdg11'1e:'1€ a:'1«:§ 2';1WE}.'{C1 in /2002. In 211} i'1"aese (.T£-1536355. 1'.h&:1'e is iI1()1'dir1.ai.e delay ~-:5-{' £1221}-as in £°i1.i.1'1;__: {kw a;:)})€:a1Es;. "I"h_<'>i.:g;'}'1 the ('.£'.i1,1EEé{;"f 3<;1"1.r:.wm is " ~ :;;'V:<.,§%i' Ts;z1E.i:::fa1<71{>1'};. 1'1<>wc:x:'a:=:1 c:{.>I"1:éé(:icfir'i1'1gg £316 :'2w2':1z"<:E p:ix.s;;s~;<:%<i E1}; l'.§1{.' 'i.'§"£§*i>:..1:'?:e;1L E' Eégzéi €.§":.23.i {E36 :,%<:m'1;.':<::'1s;;«1.1Em': 2-1w;'1:"<:1:;%{:'E Ea} E'§";.&-% Cie:p£.::'1<:§2a;r:1.1.5-:; 0§t}:1e (ie<':e21se(§ 2=1;)pe2=21"s to be (311 1t,1\>.:'€r side, €311.13! 0:1 the g1'01.1;r1ci of (iekziy, they shm.11{"1 I101 be cicézlied oi' 1eg§i4ir112;u'e c:0n'11)ez'1:~:s21{.1011 'imv2'«2:1'(is 1:335 of cit%;3ex1c§t:3:1<:3;-* ar1c'I in ('cmsici€:mi'.i.():1 oi' t:ha%., ibr the p€1'i()(i 0i"(ie1a3,«', the c"rIe1.i1'1'm1:1ILs: c0111t§ ¥3éf_;§It%';"§.' iI1'(@1'es1'. on 'ihfl m1E12'1:'1<?c:d cr<>1"1'1pe.r;s21iio11. if VV (.:o1'1tes1'.i11g; resp<)I'zcim11, is 2-:€n»*e<;1 ztmd are filed In $11656 srirc1,1ms1.:21'1cc:3.[' £36121}! is_(:o:'1cir.mc€§. A

2. E':"1so1111' as (:Iai11'1a;r1E,.€-3 1'n"-,E\/i;]E'.A.N'Gs,538012008 are c:o11<?ernec§. they are the }3atréi1i.:s of ;:.}1.c%"«:§€Cé2ised. The i.nc.0n.1e of the deceasmi em"-.'n in 2002...i.s§_i;21.ke.1"1ubatf'«I?.s.'EV-$0.00/-- per anm.m1 i.e.. Rs.1,250/ « §,f.~_er 1}.'1'0_15..L1j1 --wfziéh, i_rV1A._1i"1}_k"op'i1'1io1"1, 0:11 'the lower side. I.)a:'.Ey wa§§CS:._c4.;';1.1[c§" :'1c;1. T'h"_es: t'.}?g2:i3 R380/--, if Rs.80/- per day iI']C.?i)1i1t? {Bf E.}:c}'.V<*1.{f{§c>21St:.;i"rigs--':a:§<.en. the :é§air.n.ar1t.s wmzlcfi be en1Ii.t§e.d for Rs.2».18,'U0O/ ~ ,.€:.(S'wVzé.119cis loss of ciepc1'1c1e11(:y 21$ agzxinst vf~Zs.E..2C;;.O'{3G./-- iV.cI'.;., V_V231V(Vi'di1i ();1211 Rs.96,000/~ a\.r'<?1' and above >i:11a I'v.Vc:c)'i11:I3f:h5se1{Ji£31';.' 'a7/fy'v':a1'::§céci lay the 'Fri§:>u11a1. H()'A=-'"('3*\~"€I". fer 1h':;=i-3 22.11:-<;::::1jt. A Lilé"~«C1::3.lifr}£E1'1ES are not <3I1t.E£}e,d for ir1E'emsE. £61' 23 pzstrioci of 123 1A t-iggysiv' ~ 'A : EfIS('>fa1f §.\;'L1:"_A.i\E().5389/2()()8 is c(>:'1<;:c-twmci, C1a_imar"1.1,5 __ :«1ré._vl£1i'é%, aéhilci z»:m<:§ ;32n"&3:1%'.:'~; {bf mt: c:ieé(:<:z~.L<5'<:?(:§, Yiley eszre fmu" in

-. _ ':3'a;1.;"'1'T1Ir3<4.*,:'. Th2? iU{",{)II'1€;' E.;1E.<x%r1 E _£3£}C%/-- pffl" :'1'1():':i'.f.'1 ancé 1.,/'I; 'P 11! "{'i€;i€1§'{,é£T"i.§€}E': $5 ;'éfiW;=.:":. E fizjzéé :j*.'<;:":": in 2i{}{}i§';. {"513 <"is::{t€=2;*:.s.+3<-:'s{'i';'%.=, £:'2£?<m2<% g 5' ;%'%"'"'f';,...?

. kw; * ii;

' ' hzxeéa cczuld. mit hm.-'e Ejcéeafi %;:1:3a:1 R5s.i?.._5I~*C!Of-- per 2.11<>nt.h. E':in<:::. Lhii cIain1am::~; are wife. s:~.§1i§d and 1.)a1*::.n¥;s of the {1er:.eas:~:c£1., dedmtiion wouid bf? '1,/43' i.e.. c:12'1ir112;>..'ms_4. z'2'r:~. <:mt.it'1ed for Rss.3.f:S?,2OCif-- as agg2«:i1'3si. Rs.1.?0,0GO/~ 1,06 Rs.1,9'7.2C!0,/~ <>v'er1* anal 2-1'i;><)_\_;<:< the <'r0:n;;><;%1'1.s21tion 2-'1w3.1'cEeci by the 'i"ribu:'§.a1 wit.§1 iI}.t€1'€?:~'5i'J'"1._h'éi1'(%E)I'1. I"'i()wex.-'e;'._ {he {:%Eaimzm'i':+; are not t'%I11.ii§e<i for i1'1_t,.--c:1V'63stf enhan<7er:.1 c0mpe1':s:';a1.ion fa): 21 ;3€z*i0d (.")f_§ C]E1:f'3%.H' " "

4. ?v1.F.A.E\?o.5394/2008 is byV4ithés",_c:1air1i§1~;1A11;=Uv'1iQ '--~Ei:é;:3V s=msE21ir1ecE {'1'a<:t:u1'e of ieft. hun1c¥rL1é§'*~. with "~1fE1(}i?,_1:E_: xliérvé palsyfi depressed fraciture of t1E1S'8J *'Q_o11e:2iiicE' f:"£*a,<:'Vte-fie of iéft. maxilla. I--E9. was acir11i"t.i'.r:d to the h.ospiE':.a1!_{)11 '1".§i'e' ::3_:_1tT'c: : l?f*E1(I{',i(1€11'{, and was di£~sC.hz1rg,{ed on ?,x;}?9~.<1f§3*~.L'1'_h_¢ "W-3'L.i:2d <:7ert:ifi(:at.e and I13x.P1O =;s:s:'--.t.E";<:3_ Lii:sé'i~':: _ri'.ss14::::1.ii:.;_1r;;. _' }?Jx.P13 are the bifis for having Spent 1I1<)n<éy_ i.Qwa'1*dé;'» 't.r¢.2it;§"1ié:fii. '*1Xs..{-'.18 elm} P19 are 21180 I1":e:dicaE;'1"'<:?§:()r{iS.=.EX.'E521 V' x-1'2ay. C(JI1SiC1€?1"§I1g the 11at.u're of ii'1'_';Az,;:;*§,?"=;1i1df"alsétq the cii%'iE§é1'1:?e of d0(':i:<3r - PW14, who has stateztd t'h_2_1iV,V,_if1{::"§f'§:§ ej§s:;}:3_;.iit,y at 259% {.0 '1.}_'"1€ 1,.1pper Iimb and 15% to the x>szk1{}1£:L__fI)<>{1:.,; ific; '{"ribL1r1a1 has <:21i(:::112a1£.r3{i Elhfft 1088 c:>i'i.1'1C.0me due: to
-'..__ti§sa1bi1i't'.§; ;;1fi- -F"€4$aWr_'321Z¥0()i; --; Lowardss p::2i'1.1 Elfid s.~;ui'£'€:rit1g R.ss:2.O¢00O/~ . g12.fi;1I*<§<:2(§: R:s,l,?'E.E3()O/~ ¥;0wa'1"(§5s me?<:ii<?a1 (:?}~;I,')€;?I1.S€?5'5I Rs=;, 5'f;3{){);'~ %:>wa;'d:<~; f:,z.£.L.u'e rm-:::Tli<1£1i !';:'iXp€E':'.1"1f-:§«£;','5_S. Smite éiirltr 'I'1'ib::1'1.21.} 21:3? 21w21:'::i.e:d ;"m§,.-° {".O*£"§'1§fJ§ifi"§E§&?2'€.i{}§"i mwa-1:"{is§ a:':>§':'s,.~*€:§='z,1r'2:?<?E mzur°;153'i1mi:é:'7:'i. 2-::'?.§E 2.21,E:s3:'1::§:22:'1E, <:E'1:1::"g&%s 2:;":<i '§.E)"%3-'€:i1'."(,§Eié iélssé,-3% :12? fEfl{'.'{§IE'"i€ A (3 ._ dt,1riz3g 1.2i1'c§ up p€1'§()c¥ and £035 (f:ff.'2:1iL.11'@ iI1c::c;>n'1:', the i11C0n1e of 'the (r1a.i1'm11'1i: i.2.:ke:.1'1 at Rs. % .5-{)0/-- per mm"1.t.§';, T21.k%.1}g [ht-?:s<3 Cifif£lIT1{i5IE1I'1('€'$ im{> ('f()I'1:I-,'sidf31"E1i1011, the <?1:«}.in1a1'1i4 e1V1v1,i:,]é'd for g;§{)b:z:1 e1'1h2311<?cm1c?r1I {sf can1p€1'1:ss£1':'.i(m of R53. i5.OOQ';7>;4.,t:;\..:-;:;i"5;;11'1£1 ab:)\='e the {T(}I'I]pf31'1S2T1'[i()3'1 £1w2=:1"c"i€c:§ by {he 'i'rib1._m..:1v1_'''axf§i.%1 ixlmrésiV' ' 1'.}f1.er£3:0n. f"¥<>wev€r. for {$126. <=,I11'1a:1{'ed <i';t)1:11:)§?:i:3:i£'iioii» 'the.c3V;1'iVi2;}a1'j1' zmt er1'n'iEec% for [ma i1iiic':r€es.;t: for fa, {)t?1TiD€1"{)f"}.231 V(ié§,f_v-'é3;V "

KNM/'