Karnataka High Court
Smt Selvi vs State Of Karnataka on 2 June, 2011
Author: Ram Mohan Reddy
Bench: Ram Mohan Reddy
\>=A"'vWi$' a mum» mv=w1:@ mm: mMm¢'weM.aMa:ww. WM,.f:?X""¢ 9.~.«%J?e.:i'W
%
"§§€§5§§ $§§§§ h-- 7
. ....- nu-m.r<I-UAIKA rub:-t coum" OF KARNATAKA HIGH co'
u 1-<1-t\.lI\
u t W W'; W J V
VILLAGE, YEIAHANKA HOBLI
BABGALORE 560 094
SR1 JAYAKAR S SHETIY
S/O.LA'I'E SHIVARAM SHETIY
AGED aacxrr 45 YEARS &- :
am ARCHANA JAYAKAR
wzoumrnxnn srmm _
AGED ABOUT :35 yams,
PE'm'IoNERs 3 .3. 4 %
JOIHT OWHER3; rz0.&35;'r1:9;%a;%44/+25/a
ow KHATA lEO.?f;1-9{B;AH€_JiIS.E ALI'$'I*--1'IO.OB
BAIMI 1.AYOU'r, 1E§f3DIG.E'\I-EQLIJ mamas
YELAIiANKA,H€)E3LI," 'a
SR1 A
s/0.MA1.AKAIAH%k >1 %
AGED as YEARS,» :
HO.1{_!,' 3 30.4413, aA1.a.n 1.AYOU'I'
» 1(Ol2¥ii}EEI_i'is_L_LJ v1LI.4..c3E
% 'HOBLI
smn
' _ 810.3% 3 IYENGAR
% k 30.44; 3,-1m caress, BALAJI LAYOUT
KODIGEHALLI VILLAGE
BAHGALC7RE 560 094
% % é % % Lsarr Y c mam.
wgcnr A cnmmmm
AGED ABOUT 47 'mans,
130.15. KHATHA H0581, BAL!1JI I.AYOU'I'
M
'I: 7} ;*-1'~':< 4 v;4'r:.':'~.>'m>4'rr\s an :'.:.-'
,$.w,--_'.,--»».-m.s»y:m~w/~»,»,<_««s..m.<x.*4xs~*~vv' » -'X%
;
3
KODIGEHALLI VILLAGE
YEIAIIANKA HOBLI
BANGALORE 560 094
8 SRIKJANARDI-IAN
S/OJCRISHHASWAMY
AGEDABCXJTSGYEARS, '
No.55/1-2.RO.10,SHAK'I'I A J
; BAI.MILAYoUT,KEB OFFICE 9
KODIGEHALLI vn.xA<32vnL:a'HA:c1<:=.Ho3L1%
: 9 snnnnaxsrmvmz
w/cm nmnmaznacmné _
AGEDAB<)tJT__'32'j;13:'EA,Ii':3,i_ k %
No.44/43, 1vr%;s,1s1:21z¢ "13?'..CROSS
KODIGE}'m!;LI::vm£AGE.>
YELA1~uxNKAHt::«1aLi%%A %
BAHGALORE 2:60
an 11--ut1l\I4\ l'u|Jl'l KJJUKI U?' KAKNATAKA
10 snrrigaanunmrrn
W/0-V"~flSWANA
4039 YEARS.
'--v.Ri'A§I';!{Ov.4, 13;' mm, 3w CROSS,
amm
% Konregagmjvhues
" YEI£%.l-IAHKA.-~HOBLI
=1: % wanmn
= T%w,zc>.2mRAsEGo'wDE ax
% i __"""AGE,D ABOUT 37 mans
T %y%:m;1, ammmmn,
, KODIGEHALLI VILLAGE
V 'Ym..A1~mNxA HOBLI
mncmoxzn sec: 094
%>"'\
\L/
} 5.1; ¢"_;&§,_. '§'}' \_;*.,»v;x--_r».;'ua~eu rm . \» ._ A
u\.2r1s..uUKt ur mumA
- I ;:,'«._j~' ' _- . I./3
3 nus: masmma
aanmwzm NORTH mnnmonnp)
YELAHANKA NEWTOWN
BANGALORE
[By an cmrrnpm, Sp1.GAJ
TI-ESE WRIT UNDER
ARTICLES 225 8: 227 or THE coH3'nm1'Io1%oF nmm
mama m czm. ma RELE.VAN'IfjRECQRl)S mom
'rriBms1=o1t13Erz'rg,~a;'_I?::. 5
x SMI' R vnsawnm -Efimfél
W/0 (3.3, I{UMA__R; " %
M - AGE_D?AB{E1JT 31YEARs,
A N033; 3, jPmL_3ANA'I'HA
"-.SW5MY"aHIi$Y,fi;-
13? c%RO8'$, LAYOUT,
Bn1"JGAIx_)ém; 09+.
' _ PRAKASH KUMAR,
''S"iQP.C."KUMAR,
' "fi.'GED"ABCXJT 45 YEARS,
§ T~ND.1='r; OM MAHESI-IWARI KRUPA,
" ..._"'4TH§CROS8, BAIAJI LAYOUT,
kJ 2 "W MA1H,KOI)IGEHALI.I,
A % LNEAR G.R.V. RESIDENCY Rom),
BANGALORE --- 560094.
N
.j\
"5 ;_,;£'~,_§j__; \-;'g5'4,;';'q--_rp.l\)~.-nx rsx c
. ..-m u uvunx I ur RAKNAIAKA HIGH
SRI. A. PRAKASH,
510 mm mnammx, %
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS, % ; '
HO.l60, NEW mum PUBLIC SCHOOL; =
BANGALORE -- 560094.
am. hi. SURESH k
szo s.MuRUaEéH,
AGED ABOUT 1'25 ' _4
No.5, cm caoss,
NEAR NEW TOWN PUBLIC: %
sax. ASLAM % % %
S/OIA1'EEF?..IC-5Ié.&N. ' 'a
AGED J'I""41-8'Y':E=AR3;*~.
arm moss,
BANGALORE .-- 560 %
3121. XBEE-RAl5P1fi:;.AV'PA'I TA.fi'IASHET'IY,
No.5/5, opP;'m9'.W¥k<k % j PUBLIC SCHOOL,
- As/0%
% AGED ABCFI_J'I'._52 mans,
'1HG-s xsr cnoss,
B31-An L§£'!CW_iT;'
R; Rmruxa,
% ~ -Lw,~'o_o. SRIKAHTACHARI,
% }'sGED"ABClJT 39 YEARS,
$T%Nt:1.43i2. 1'? A MAIN ROAD,
1!"'ft)R'OSS, B.a.1.A.JI uwcxrr,
we M.SRmNA ,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,
M
lk.l'.\.t'ru"\.l zrx oh:
10
11
% §BAH43AI-(>33 -
N0.13A, 673 MAIN, 6TH CROSS,
OPP. mazwron PUBLIC SCHOOL,
BANGALORE --- 560 cm.
Sm'. G. 'VIJAYALAKSHMI.
W/O GANGADHARAN, , T
AGEDABOUT41 YEARS, A k
160.213, gm (moss, BALAJI L
BARGAIDRE-560094.
SR1. V. MOI-IAR,
S10 mm NARAYANAAC A f
AGEDABCIJT4?'--YEARS;"~..'A %
3.30.43/5, 1-3? X '
1"CR035._.B~'-'i[&H';3AYQ.I-FT. %
SMT. % ;
w o mJmcm:~:H2mPPA%%T%T%% L
.4. 3:: ABOUT 51_YF;AR'$,
No.44/4, 4319., 13'?
xrr moss, mmn,
PETI'I'IONERS
(By KUMAR SUNGAY, A.dv.,}
91 %lsr%AmAoF KARNATAKA
fnmnnnnmnr or REVEHUE,
w ¢'~JHa';ASA 2-manna,
VV' --- 550 cm.
"=REPRESEH'1'ED BY rrs
~ =1=R1mcn=AL SECRETARY.
M
"X l_3§'\EI.1
\ K 3 «Wm =wrm.z waw am,m;tv:§*%m,§fi&%;'1a £""%.%€;::£"% €;.,}%Z§.3'£'fi§W" §r**;"l'M¢'-'3sfl1§'«§A.~'3'¢:§'§}€T&.E{.'fk E §€Z:§§'"§ §§€§1"i§D§§%'."§" §{g¢%iN.%"§"A§€»£'& MEG M Qfli
.-,..~..~. -M".
§§*?§§%:E§%§%Eg_§§ %
§§§<fi§:~;§;'%%
' % Effiiggfifig
W M*-*aié}%fi"wW%~ w:m.M*: mwwmé £3?' §§afx§'?i£"%£W",£%%Wk §""§%@%"¥ €7§€Z?¥.}R."¥" Q43' E€;é"»sz§§§M.&"§1€§§~€fls~, E~*E§fi§§~'E flffini
§§§§g<;§&f§,;=: a
3%: §g%:§5~§;?%;;:%§
ES
4+.
% §%§<%:?§§§§§:§§
$353: géag; $3
I
E? g $3
\.J"£ uvunt ur mnrmrmm HIGH czouszrcw KARNATAKA HIGH cot
12
3 THE THASILDAR
BANGALORE NORTH [ADDITIONAL]
YELAHANKA HEW TCJWN
BANGALORE
(By 311' CI-IITTAPPA, Sp1.GA)
THESE WRIT PETITIONS AREu..FIL_ED UNDER
a 227 or ran czcmsmunon can mom 1=12.m~.-v:c3'ro
CALL FOR RELEVANT' "RECORD..%_ FROM ma
RESPONDENTS, Em. L ' ' '.
1 3121 A % 3/0 ABBIREDEFY. AGED YEARS;
No.4,; 130.55; 2, V. ..... .. e % KQDIGEHALLI VILLAGE. T % SRI.°A. mmmqm KRISHNA, «$10 VEHUGOPAIA ACHAR, AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS, ' NO.
._'Té~_.130f"$2I U5, BALAJI LAYOUT, KOEDIGEHALLI VT g VILIAGE, YEIAHAKICA HOBLI, kk % ('BANGALORE - 550 094, 3 am'. VEGAHDHIMADHY, W! O S. VINAYGAM, V 'k _ . ..-.,.\. \.ll' mmmmm r-um-i comm or KARNATAKA HIGH coum 13 AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS, no.3, KI-IA.'IT-IA 30.4414, mm mvcnrr, xonranmm EfH.,,I4?\G13} " i % % YEIAHANKA HOBLI. BANGALORE - 560 094. sm. FARIDA BEGUM, W} O , AGED ABOUT 'H YEARS, 30.17, KHATI-IA No.22 BALAJI LAYOIJT, KODIGE_P.AI,I;1:i'\fi;i;&§f}E-,__ YELAHANKA HOBLI, A em:
w/o smvmmccmfi. '. % mama NO.A%4!{J/V'£?.19J_B,!__6.,. % VILLAGE, YELAHANKA HOBLi,f %
--- 094; LA
- AsR1.sm.
V" SIC' REDDY.
gags mums, Haas, H0.
531; 6.
KODEQEHAMJ VIIJAGE. % 'YVEIAIMVNKA HOBLI,
-550094.
_ ~_.8'£.4!'I';;IY(I1'I'I-II, Vfw/50 CHAHERA SHEKAR, % A knaznmanw 'mans, % 130.35, cue KI-IATHA 110.531/35. BAIAJI I...A.YOU'1', KOIJIGEHALLI vnman, YEIAI-{AREA HOBLI, BANGALORE - 560 094.!/yd:
'I, i,,_{ Fifi Lt 3- :' 1; ':4' i w u 2 'ur-
._.,-... 'fill .u..\.Wm.L. nlun wum Ur KARNATAKA HIGH cover or KARNATAKA. HI<§i'¥"'c:"ouR 'I 13 14 ICARRATAKA
- *DEP.&;R'FIs&ENTOF REVERUE, 15 KODIGEHALLI VILLAGE, YELAHANKA I-IOBLI, SR1. smmvas, 3/0 LATE SUBRAMANI, new ABOUT 45 YEARS, % No.3, KI-IA'I'I-IA No.53/02/03, xonrezmm VI£1.AC§E'; L YELAI-IANKAHOBLI, BANGLAORE _ L smv.
s/0 LATE AGED « No.5, xcz.53j2; KODIGEHRLLI. - .m¢:;g YEI.AI~iANxKA-HOB1J,% V ~--:s.c3:::c.*94;LA ; ...PET1TIORERS % - see 001.
REPRESENTED BYITS * ~ PRINCIPAL SECRETARY.
Lri ..w...., ..Wn. W swmmnm mean coum" or KARHATAKA HHGH COURT 0; KARNATAKA HIGH 4;; %r;:,n.»:-x~:w> IO 2 STATE OF KARNATAKA, Dspnmmm OF I-IOUSING AND II {ff DEVELOPMENT, vnmsa S(3lIDFA~,».._ BANGALORE - 560 001 j; * REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL ' SECRETARY. ' .
3 TI-IE'IHASILDAR, BANGALORE NOR'ITi(ADDIII€3I!£xL);-» YELAHANKA NEWWWH, _ BANGALORE. ' _ (By FILED UNDER ARTICLES 2.26 32?'? V'I'HE"£3_{3I€STITlTTIOH OF EHDIA PRAYIHG TOXCALL .FOR.VRELE4'¢-'ANT RECORDS FROM 'IHE RESF'OND'ENTS,'ETCA} »-
coming on for preliminary Court made: the foflowingz 9.3.13.3 . questions of law and that of fact ma.1-zing, with the consent of the coumel pctitiomta am clubbed, finally heard and ofby am. under, wk vi O! D O U I 52 I
-1 E 2 § 5::
LL 0 I--
D:
D O U I E I 4' 'E Z 5 u.0
'3:
D 0 U I 9 II S 'I I 5
5. 3
§ 3 .3 3 E 1'7 ' '" "" """
/ exemmng juriadjaotion under Scactionfs Karnatnkn Lani mmnue Act. 1954 ' upon the petitioner: to vacate.' poaaausiarn of immovable also to show-cause as to not be ngajrmt under by the learnod V stating that occupants.
harmed special Gou-srnment submit that thare has been a ._ " battle for pooaeaaion of the immovable finer a publi: purpose and in which 36.10134; 1994 is pending before: um Court filed by xhenafic1a.ry' of the ncqu'nition of the ixmnovnble properties, seeldxg delivery of possession of the said