Karnataka High Court
Vishwanath vs The State Of Karnataka Rep By Its ... on 24 June, 2011
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
Bench: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
E-1% E'§'E-VEZEN : .....
' E THE EEEGH C{}Ui~%'.'E' {I}? E{z%E{N1¥£Z%E§fi:
€Z,7§§%C UET §§E{Z?'~3€IfEAi ESE" 'E}EEAE€:'§'€£":E} .E}A"§'EZE..} TEES TE-{E3 2<i§~'""'i 331%' ii}? JU ?'*»é§§ ESE E ?RESENT _%Vu T'?-§§I: §i{}N'E*§i.,EZ MR Jzgsfiééga': ASEEQK B, Bi?E\E§§3E;§§<§§l§ii§ : . ANS '_ V' V i[ % 'E"E§E E-%€i}N'E:3§.,E3 ':\riR;.JUS'§'ECE 2;] é} é:£;;:'§<:E§;x;fi3:%;i<§§:#:V' F. $¥RrrApPEAa?fi;289f2Q§é(LR"_'«V."" v 3 , V i;é3hv~:"211':a€',E': . ' =.. _ A§g;<;%r:i abwuii. 53 }'€::r5&a 2;» E,}a':':.5i.21"i::*5:§reL _ 1 Agsid abezzéi. 49 yétarsg "
Birth are ss{ms_5,~~ {:#_§} 2; = E;e1£",(~: E3:§.&;1:"u:'.¢.%~;*,-11"».§3'EEf;}fi.--.'_§}i}g:3§1§%;: _ A R/G H21:2§§&i§., i3?'E§é-;§;'l'.: H;?§.*J€?:*~§f§ :
3. .gmxanmgi?;' * éggaci :1b<)é;.:¥;' % 3f<§:':;:ff=:§7; ~- ' mw¢§¢a?m§gaj R,' {} '§§;&m<fih15}&;{T%g.;.>,?_.'%_:i . 'Z~§a:1g22§., v.,§f}§':=:Bé,';1 E~§2:'%.--*é-Eréa .giE:r:'}1.3'é. ?3 },7€3afi='§.;
_ EF§"'£_;;§ "%?§i_;3€;%:.:'s;.§ .E4§2:<} '§_f£%a1g;;ai,?;};
--__AE?i§'<i%£%§%:::§é:r.i', Efizbié, :36 f'€§;*€:2.;:.E'a. Eigsai, Ag;§@{§ .:3}}€_'1E,:§) "E? j_!€aE'f%.%. 2-¥;a;>: §§i*::«-"a E%2;a{} §':§1€;_;j§§f§, .A _ §€';,fé:'£':: ?v'Eai:hu:'z.: E:%':".2:::f:<::
V ' '~,§'"E§7£§}§§.
'$5 / <32 '%f'<?::':E«<;a::<:%:a;E"; {f%:asm{Es':.
§%';__f 23$ : §3232:":'{E': E~3;3':Ea?§<;':.::':{iE §§$a ?'€:%§%§:é%%z3&%:fi""."*:
aw"
'E'E';.Es3 '»%:"§'i€. 2.-1pp<;=::2l fiissiii 1..;.:1{:£@:" 8<::sr£:i:':n 4% <35 ?:.E':<:
'E{Zz«::*z'.:.;;;::'.z-ziizia E§§g§'; éfgurtg. f%<::'i,§ £962., pE'2§i:f§I"i§§ $3» Sfiifil ::1se;'__<i§t E".§1.<:?: €}E"{§E;'f§" dz-zmzi E8.§.i»Z{)G€.}% pa.:~3:e'-.aed 'E§jg i'.§'}€f*. E€E}f'§E{5{T§ $§2'1§_:§i<:: :§i.Z€.§§g€., in W.RN{:e.8652/2C3%2 zind <>r«:ie:r d2:1€:ed i2,2i.2€§€32 pa:-;5ss€:<:i by the E,;a:1{§ '§§ri~'E3;1j;:"i.;fiE;' marked as; Ar:::eé>s:ur€_L E0 the wréig: ;)@i:%z.:z::z:'1§ 2-.*=;u:?'":€i e.€;{'€{' '§'h.i5:; ;1pp<i:«.1E <':<3n1in;:g an fig;-r""E'1s;1:z*:if§1g;_§:'}§:i-5:' (E;/,1!-9';-*i"..V fishok B5 Hinchigeri «,§., <?§€E.§\n3:*si:§¥. {"113 §i3.3.£'<;2W'§:'§g-:
&B{E§fiENT . V 'Fhi5:'~; E-*:p§}€fE1§ is ciircéctéfld t,héé";>§4_:ifi::'. vfiiaéxiii i.891.2()G8 paessed E):',?::_4'.'?3i'.?T1€?.'?E.€2T§_'I'{Ifii3§:.V S§f£}§3;§€ in ¥Vi18652/ZGGZ, V V ',_ _,_ 2* b1*§§§f'ars thzzé: @116 Sn Bhisf;.e:§5h V§:::":1{i ¢';' §:?:;ééV1;$'3L.1I"iI1§__§ 4 &1{?'I"éES_-3 22 g§1.zz_3a€;2:ss: {r§:%n.H:;}I2bert:c1 215 96/2} Of §r"{a§21}§:i:§§ Eigareri Dis€;ri::i:§ om i€'£15.-3% fa*<2:V1V§':L«--..§§z2.::§1,~;§i§$}2i=%?i21Ea.p;32;. fikamztsh Cziucizifi €:§"J:.€ f";1t.E*;::§lr 'V <95 éiaéé' * =".€.T€%Sp{}§1{i€3§'§§l Nahfi, 5% 3525} E3. '§."'}';e2 :s.§3p€éE§21;i€ts3 V' iE'1_<3 Eeggzii §a:?p;'<:ésge:*:*g.a€;iw:5 95 $316;
1%C§{;%{'§€::§:;:é{if€§"«E?§_E::§fi'i1.ié'§h E%'E2a*:;. T §'_1€ §€E'iE%3€ W213 fez}? 21-': p€3'§{}€§ <72? :;A::j3:a::s:s:"' 'E'h€,= E'€*:g§E%§€.'§"§i?{§ §€?£ii':§€ff 6:2'-3:1:-;é<§ fig iigzitezfé i§}5E3é%a '"E""?2.;"@6 :»,f€fZiff%3 ggrmr *é,«:> §I.§"1.€3 %"3X§}§§f'jf stzé? 'i'}"§{"t ..sg}5;.*::*'§:':e{i, 'E'E"::i= §€;',".é£E'*..§{'f a:.r?a.:':;g;:%3:s2&%:':%: $52254; a~:\:§.::%:<:{E':>:i 5:2':
-. I K ' * -»7§--i§.E'>; Eéiféiifi §<;;'z'* 2;: §i,§'§"?',§"§é:?§* ?}€'."§"§<',.}{'§, <1}? iezix :£§f?E;%.E";%}. :%;§°.i §£x*..€ ii» E?;§s=;E"2tes&;E': Ef%'E':a%i f:%k%<.i §<':';n1": N<:,?I 'E'§':§% i;;_ms:i '.E."1'£'Emr':2:E, E3; ifs; m"{:E€;*.:1 {Ea-a§e<'E 25,2:.1E}?€§ rc;§:;?r<"tt::=é<:§ the E3'«:,>m1 N09?' "§"E:<i% §Ili;".§'1£}.3'3§ {tE':z.1.§k:%:'1;ge=.{i ':é2;a=: i"€;',_§€:€§"TiII31€.}E'1 e:7::"<.%€-3:" iii:
W,P.3:382;,r' ":;_<:»}73. '§'§";is§ {"i<;>'u:""z:, by as mm-:::;;~----étmgagi , 65%.} iv §_9'?E§ aiicswétd §§'1(iE iwii p<:%E,i£;1T<'::"1_., <g':z--:'§.:§,}=:§3€§--.:'?:;£f:t3 §"'Q§€;?{T'.§,§{}'E'} <;v:'<:ier amd re;':r1":27m£ie<:§=__ th;>: %?:1;i%'1:£%2j' "-i'<j'Vi:}j:<-§wV:.; .' 'E':'i§3:.1'r";a§. ';{'h_é: §,2a;:'1ci 'i'ri"En1::*:_;1§ E:>:.:,?a_iffI:: <}:E:C§{1E':i; Vega-1'%;:<-:§z:i 3&9. "2982, again r<;j:3ct'€:<§ 't'.hz~t :§"'@§::1:uN{';.'?; «:"§é": {i%'r12.:1'1é' <*:h21.§1<-:I1g€<i ii: in E-'a?§P..::'$'i€:§§'aCI_f;'i;&--'\E%E_§' .'§;."§f1é:~ ¥§;:1.nd '{'ribu:12:E's 0£"d€f:I" 'W218 qua-::=s2'1.<:=.c§ aim} ma tij.e1* :'j<:3:fi2incied by ihiis Thté 'I':*Ebm1aE }'#° Lg:-:2 §.j~":»..4u Court; 'by ..13.*.Q;§-». 4<}1i_ <é<3u_E<1 m:_>f:: H§v1'_fi'I}Ti'€f;§iiEii'.€3i§'.__ d;Es§;);;:) €;€5 0? "£316 r<~3.:i11anci@{§ }{§18;fi".(fE'7. {}'Z"; '21<:zf{3z::'.:7s1f:"a::f"'i7hEs- éieiziy in (:(3ns_=;tit'L§t.§ng 'fihe '§'::f:ibs,:.::a}..VV" %T;3 3,% i1'.5§§ {);$'é§{Tf_.1":§ v;(§§j1§.fi?{§ ':22.2OQ2, i;E:e '_E'§'.ibu:1a.i '_ j;;€:§_~r3::§:::§§%.€§,§ 2%§_§&t3§§.'I?f..,__E'_',_§'f_'1:{?v 2£§';s§3e.Hz:r1t::~2s' fai;E:c'1°'s~: ap;3};.§<:zs_i:i<m §Zi;:"":::s.E__' <:>§::Eup21:1<é§g i'§§§§Ei'.S. Ag§g'ri¢:%&2e.{i bjgi §.'}"3€f s.5g%{i"'V€;§'{i{%i':f'j'§E§:%V z:"§}§}<3."§ia'::'1£,$ £3265? W.P.8%§§2f2QG2. E"°éE<;"I. finciingifj my i:":§i:":*;1ié:y E3'; tiihs: "f':'.ib:.m21§°::3 €}E"{i{'fE', %;:E:g": "«."E:,ig';:;<'f*:«;:%<.E ;'%§ng;%§::e &1.:d;}_,_§j::é €§§f%I'§T:§S§.%;€:'?{§ {he :%:?i§:. pe:3i:?§..i0:'; ms; <>:'::§m: {iaiéaféi E§."_%..§,fE:G€}E%.
S} :3; §%,gg;;r§m-'<*::§ by 'ihah: 2:a%3:,>*v"{: €[:r§I'{"}€i?§1 E.E:s_s5: '§§=:;g_;;3E E'€?i}i}I"€i?S§£?§'E.1i.éiE'.E.V£i?E3« <3? B§$§'§iIl€$E'3 §S.h.;1E; é':"i§'€ in ;2:g:;;>@232§ E:»<:~2§"<,;;'e I§_4§.$:_s $€'(?k§§1§§ é,in<3 E§:3:1£Ti駧;_;s.3; QESEEEEE <3? E:'%:s:, E£~:2:::":1e:s{:€ S§:'é..;§'§!-:2 Ju{§g€'$ {é':':"i:::' zmzi mi: {§i,§.E'i.S3§Ti§I"i§_;_'§ 82? E;,E3;¢~._.4§;{;E.:_"i{V§i' '§'ri§3*a:z.:":_aE's3 <>:*{i{:>;r.
fig. 5:'3E"i i.'}i:1€:s'h K'Lz§ka'mi;; 'i'h€:?'_A EEi:'fi?£E';E='_f§€:':':«'Q§ '::j<>':3;}::..:§3駧 _ far i;E:::;% a;3p€:§}am::s $u§;m:z.:"f:::=-3"W-ii;'%*1'a;,f€. 'Ei§"i€jE'--- ;:an:'<j»::s >{3sf %E1<: app€~§1ar;d;s; aw: <::{}n':'1?11:19s:§..<;}: €;0'.£§é' _1§r1 t:fli«ié"§'a:€:iV§3:"d 9? rights; u1"1ir1t:§3:"§°1,2;}'g€dEy §?<§112.:311L H6 Submits §.i1;1f3~*f.E::é% §"'€rs}3§f_):1§1«§ii. haw: ]:'If3t}:'i.§'1€I""
<:h.21,1i<::":g€:(i: in {hi}: z'c~:=<.tQ;{"d {Bf r:ight'S p1*"<}<:6c:diI1gs; fer their '"ent;:'i<3s ssizmding in '£72:v«:;:;';::* cf ifhs: ag3}3i:E?§:1:i:'::E:§"i.:*; flies :*evem,:e a*€<::<>:"<:i;<»3¢ The éaéarniéd 'V'{3{}Eii'§S{'i§ V'E}"L{§}E}3§{;§5 izhaf. '::h<;> &c£€i:?'E.:?m1aE §§E§€',I'i{",'.§j éiozizi "*~{.i{'§Ie if*:'.:=a- §:»«ifv§i§:;%.%:..--da.%;e(i M} §.vE§5§§ EEE:-ifiq §3a:;<5<-"sari £31": {fig @%:i{§'~:~3:'::?.:;% ':;:r':' :'{;%<::>r<L €:2'zZ<;@:': §.h«:;% s;t:}:';§§<i§--:::."fiii vmw tizzit, ';;.:"§:1j22': §'°2;z<:§& Efiis:-:§1§e§;E"; E3E"::21'§ is; in pO:'i=%S{i'.EiS§{}§'i ::1§":{§ §.:':w;5é}3'zA:§§e;:éL. 5:2? 'é;':1<i §2§.E'§{iS ii": {§i3;€E".~1?;i€>E1. fié:-E 2§E;%<> %3ri:';gs €15; V' "'{'é:.§r §':m:i<':»z3 §[E1§:': Lamii '£"':.":i"b22n22.E's; :':':i¥:€2:"§::2 a:°{.§£::: <£22,€.a2<:% 3.5» 31,8": :2-%;s%i::"z§;é§:E:'1 E *::'§w §'€;"f':i€%'F}{)§'E€.'i%:?§Ei'L F'€{'3s;.Z% £5: 5 §3.:°{im:
E §:%.§~??* may; x §z §x. . s '5' i;;.h;;2J;' i"h:'-: «:§€3"i:2i'i4i{>:1 {>E""€.e.:12:.t':f <?<>:'1.§z.:.i:1a=2d in ${T{??il.i{.¥§'} 2{34g§ {:5 1322? %§;~:r§'1at"aE«:a: Lzmd §<1é%§<3:";n:se fi;<*.E",, E'>}3€§E §'iE':<7 5-Said g3..<é§' Em' :a;h{_>'ri:} 21'»; wizie é:'r.:':m.:;g}*: :8 §:'1<.*.§_u:.:ia?1¥g:h»%:? 21§>§>%3EEz::1£.&a .2.-ma? éiile sesiniiiezriy piazited §§::'$;<:s:'15~":;. ;"E~§€_ ;;2.§__S{:% E'°é?E£{§ (mi, izhit d;::=:f§:"_1::"i3'{3%:'1 cf "pr<>t'.:::z':f,<-3<i_.» .?.<:§f1vc;.:é€;7:' as <:<)m;:22.im-Ki in S<3cU'.e:m 2&5?) Si'I_'i:E'::::§...:e;z§§€§--_Agfi; p'£"€}'v"iS%§(Ti%1': $?;.;:€:es-'3 iiiéai: 23 '_p.rj:>€.§:{:§:a--逧' A.§.s§:1211'":t"'";3j::?{;;§1&; _§a; % {.{:'n.2:11t'. af emy Eand if he is E-1{._».<:<)'§":.%;i_i:;:§aréégu5%i§,I emd <tt11E§.iV2z:.ing it. pc:"$c>:12§'1'1-$5"fk>A:"«--V_2: 3:23; RBSS Tlhafl 12 years; pméor '€:¢é::--t}:h€:>: ;§p;x;£:f::€*éci.§,23,t:é,V; V '"21 Sgia. ieamrsd ASA %i_pp€??lfiE"I§}§ and 21 mibmiis §.I"::;:t §i£§<3§1* dmggased §af,h6:* 'W'€3I'f3.
fxaraasg :1:-9%/<~'::*% , a:=':;':§.'£.i'.'»'Ar;_s.'£1.;§.;r::;_';_é;:.,;:4,' {:};1€;*: Eauads in {;z:<:s.«;E.iG:.'1 '_ §}€5f.Ifi%§iI3;}.§"£§£ifi}',V "§'§'é':3r§:_§€}r«&x !:.hé3.:J 22:'? m:r:: é-3;1i:%éEe{§ £10 E35:
"é:::cis%2;§;:§{:§;v._,;#;;<--: £:7:7<=§-.§.€z:a::*i.s;§ g>j<}:?.:§;gj §:>y" éihe '§)§:€§;iE1 {§@§§§:§£:1?az":
«:'{c;ri'éi*;:fi:":€5{%;' §i:'} §'§e€:ii,§:3:': 2{8r%} of {E262 éeeziiri Aétix Ease i"s.1:'*':;%1<:':~ V._sub.::2i~%":s"§i'E7§.a'{: %.§'1€ Eami in qu£--3s;E§{>:': Wezé; 2'}:-3129:' :;*'e::~:;ié:& in " « : '':;Ei1§:': 312;: tax S2.::1iE §}€%5§£%§, ?;E";:z Eé?:2:*:3:?:§ £.:§.}:.m${":tE £232' 211% :"a=::-:;g}<.";§'"s{:§a;:::':€a' Ngssaa 3 3%; 35: ::§':.:_"i'::1i':'3§*é:s.=3 i§':2::%:. %E2.<;:>.}; {:'¢:-:ss;;s<}::<:i:ié:'":_§': §%§E§§~'§;
é?
a;}_§}e§Ea:nfi{..s in 21.115; '%i-"E1}'. ?\E<}':3s:,3<E§,: :'1<>'é;. é3*¥e:";_ é:E":.€: r::§;;:0:f;{E§:?.:§'1%. §"€{}&§.3 Mr; E} {tam <ti;is:~;pm:e i".'§3z::i'. ':;Eae:;z ;:2p§:>€E§<a.I':E.$* faihzzsr W225; in izawééii. §f3{}§SE§€3SS§{}§": as gm éfiée iiaftiéz sf §}as:sin§§ (3? ms jziéigzxzeizii {E E,ELE§59§,«j::5: £§€'--_' was in }}0S5:§€3'SSEG§"§ ~35 iihfi Ezmd. £2": ques£:ic>':a E333':*vi§':i;1:;2<:"'€}§"'*' : ' {the r€3gis€,€3*€d iEeass<;?: iififéfd. ~ E8, The Lewd 'f§°ibL1na1E's <): :";§.é.'::_z:£a¥;é:§ E§;6,«.§ :":=$t:3.°z;1im:31g file res_p<>1:de:1i; '{.{3 .5:f;fi§>:<};'IV:. in Bishmsh Bhatfs @3g;i£:;fj§1ii<3:.;V1';é"C.:§V*.V1'j§'i%§§=:..}A21:':§«§if:'q;;;-gfiséxien by dir:3ct.§ng_§:_"%£r:i:f%*:,:V:.'gm cf ?5§®GOf -
a:i1{': its alsse iii} not some
to a;: fi3:tc§vE§a1nt5; in any wzcxy,
{:'bVi{}§,3:.L§3};._E/'?,. 'i'ribuaa§";<s 0:"d€.r was an §:2€.e:;r:§::_e:>r§@:';._fiat: 1?::*€.<3rir;: {}3"C§.§3§' is §;%hE'Ei§'S saifigéaci {:0 7':i§1_1€ §°£f1é;E_4{}:;ts<>::1& cf E2352 p:°§>€:a:36:€§in_gf$. Tha final ::::€_.;:§;');:i:s:_%"~.E:aé{*§;:::'1::2 a,g2:.§:'::5§': §i_%SE*:E:<:Sh. Efiizzfi, ?&}{§ 'gig E,.§;§;, '§{:§'I;€;i'£5;§}}%3§i§&3.EEfi-SS herein "E'h@ ;E'a<:'::s {E11 Eigliiéi and §E"i€"§MZ7i{VIV§_i.E§ 1:1 'iha c.:»2,:4§€ :3? BE§2:ram122p§2: P%:€fz;1§3;3;1 Upgzéar "§§;z,:§};*:-2%] 213%? en§'§:°é*:E§,.-=' aiifllé-:=.:"{3:";%:',, E3, 31%;: {iiET:§.§EE§ii=3§.£},i"§{f§?§i§ 5:? 32¢-: <A:e:-2.5%": 511:2': .:'§<'>i;" 332:? Ezisgég. aégésé. 52:5, E? iii/is? 2s:g>;'::=3€E;3.:":i:ss' §£?§.E'§'E€i??:' 3:':2;sé;§ §;'."3,{} €f§.i§7§'i<'::,:§§':}r 3%.} in g;'2é§1§:i2'.zg;§ 'éhést §€?&.i-5%,'. {§£f€iE(,§ :°:%;_§;:%§;E,et1f<;é§.% in 1.955%; ii is; mséi Eé.f'.§§i.>E}'3£i.§3§&? is} 2¥§'.1§ EH3 dizzi ms'; gifii. 'é:E3;€: 2-:g§§r<-::é%n:{t§'1%:, <:%x€:a%:'3{i§:':;::; i;§1:s:*: Eéféiéfif? p:3:'§<>c§ E33; SEX }€"<;'.*2:¥;.§"'SE».3 E'€;',§:{i§§"§i€}'€,=:"§., 'I_'§3.e: <:5ffe<:E'; 9? moi':--:r€:gis':::*ai.ior2 sf an <>E.E'2_é%'zi:%w:?j--::é:., :":0mpu}sc>riiy :'€gi$t:<~;~'~.rabk;% d<3<t:..:mm1é: 8€.2:1rs:s-_=; 22..:':*i.h¢%Aj'£'e:::*.*§% asf ihés: appeik12H:sfBish£t&$%1. Bhzit. > £2, Yeiij a3'1<}i:%:1e=:r €ii&E'{?{JL§?'i-E;L,§:'Y§.'2i'iTi(3€§ ."e.'sf§/i%é\i7F;V {tonsiciered is %;:hai': E:i'1z::" '.iV:'f:' if-#'4£S}}£?{fil 0f wi'1;';ci1 the Ewase was-1.
subsiafiixig $1111}: Ce:>ndL1<:t
tihaii if the it uriii be few
dayg, If<:§g.:>$m'1§:';1<}nt.E1s ;;>r:i<>r 2:10 the
expiry? #3:? "But; in the §fiSi'c's1'3ii {3aS€€
ihaé <::;E'é:>:§2:§§:3§':;..,:33 yéairs prim is the E;*Xp§§T'}=' (if the "'E¢:*~'23;;sv§€, §%:riLE>£i_. '«A/'$1911. Eihegé {:;Z;i"<:%:::§31s:;i'21z:g::5es.a are Aa*-:s=:.2:.:1*::fi<3{%'--.ii: E}2£{I§i{§§'{}§3 53:' the $:.:'bmiss$i<>:1 §iZ%12%.fE. *;'h€:: §:123_i.h"e:* {:3re-.s§p<3:'1::E£%:§€; N{)§"§.2 ii} 3% 19225 misairig {mg}: 8 "*E%':<:% Eip§}E§E2%;f"§'E:'~.§ (33:85? b§:a':(}§.1"::%S 1'2Zi"h€f§' _ :3.§"i:2':.:'{§%3:;';t21bE{;%.
13. 1%"; d{}{T'L.§!'§Efj.'§'."§f:.S :.r=95§'::e2§.;<;e£::»:éT=.?§::' 2:::'€;% ;:e:'{3{§:,2.{':z%<§ $9 $;§'1{:}w é;§':2::€, §:E':<f: 2::*g_2§;::£<.EE2'::":€.:%;' f2?:§1_§'::;*:2* 122225; p;';:j';§:":;_;§ 2:::_'1}.;* Egg»-':'1§ E2 :§Ef.E};E'f% in >'i.§'1:=:*. jsféfféié' T§€%i33E3%, ii muigi 'gig: %'.2:%A;%:é é;.h:-53 E2:-3. %;?:rz.:&.a 3&3: E':2:2:es §*&%::%{2§%;=:<::§@{.% ham s§<§:1;;e:*wE':<%:r{:% 2':E""'{}1.§§'1€§ Eééiéfi.
é;,'§?2a:.i". W"§1{3'E1 $526: '~J'z-'£:%,E:%E E5} in 722% y€°éiE"§~'~'; Cf 'p<::}p%<:-3 '%.>a;e~::'{:a saying; izhat: the §'a;i:§':t:ar 0%' §.§1e;=: ri2s_:;p{§m§<~33'1":: E'~i~:3s-;;.2v was; §z:issS§':":gg, What 921:": he 1:}1"=:>§3aE3z1Ei;<sa€i_:';f¥':mi"--ijéis é:v飣é3:.1<:%:: is; $3121: ssamewhésyfi a.:"{>;1.:A:i:§§ § €§€§5g§:ifi{ .?$;i:;*'14}e:I:f {>5 tzézs ;"s3:§§3as:*§d€3§":i'. Nays-3.3 5.10 5 x>a:e:":'éi'::§:?:§s§é:1g§"- £8. Cr:;'nSid&u':i:":.g' £1311-3*r::§:§§:;3;:.:,:£e?;t..:t;::s' E;-':3 {E2656 €:i:<'<E:z:11.s'{.a.;f1;C«5:&;~ H "
(3.) "$36 £1021?ré:<'iis%ir:5£?i<3é1"Qf ¥;§';;§:V f2:'g1'W:§:::1e:1i stxtéindging the }{3;1${':_ fggerifiaii, {bi i:}1€' m1iE§¢é.§-mg §:>if ':,h,%€:"~£"zv;E,}::e}:° Qf r€[email protected]£: NOS' 3 "E0 5 §:t<3f;:, s<3:':{1<;V-":'%;;<,§{i*; 53:43 $1 iiéunéi E 965, {Q} " *':.§'_1.<.-2 ::<>:'1:§é§{aimi:1a:i<}:: <3? the wiéznes-«s-563:3 3.1:) 3:136 zégifegzézczsi. purpmisid €16; Zr':2é,:-'<:': $36.:-rii: €'?£€"3{f'i§§l{i'€§ if:
Q} "é'.E-".:{5 * ";E:'si a'ppeEEa:":E.'s §fEi3é11?v'&1§T'i3'§3€E§§E% 9? "$318 §{E§f2.s3<§s.;E<:: of i§":{'% Eané in qi.:s:a:;€£:i{;:':, as §'°:.1r.r::?.5§'a_zsr£§ in §7'::=7{::z fig}, Z