Karnataka High Court
M/S Karnataka Plywoods vs The Government Of Karnataka on 7 December, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, H.S.Kempanna
. ot scan? we * . . ilies wh me . a a aes . ays : : " _ : serie ye : Mh . age . * Con . . w Pe, . . Ra a i Pes . iy ; . ase ae . : ue Ub; bead , pad ad ey . . . so ee be . . j on : Seog ot reba, £08, ne : ; oe go : Beencek " i nat feel code aoe i bag just She od eo Seg) . Fe e% oe Paes ne wont gi ' egal} : q Leal oa : - tho g cy ' : . dal Bes oat at " - gy eet oe be 2 -- oe jena Ps te Fepo5t a nag seta "cash fs a é 7" ae oe tae # Sgn pit, =, Soon +x & ae 6 ge > pe ~ Mew Kien Bao hak owed geod ro Per S "f . og , Sh Pe Bok sf yy oa otc set : sgn the fy Taot wo Pag aa ope he Pon ce : oe gol 'oseeed tpatiesd Page oe : es ner - sig ona : ae es bos ve Ey Ee bal ; eooge aS oe pean . IY . oe % & est aye ag oe <a oe a & Ag : weed Hye iy Ry fea han - od & Beageeng fosad, sodas amy . * a okt feud oh segs nes tod Bees eds gone wha , Sas eed all eatin, von wena : . . on gen Pay" igs fpseaal® gms ine " At pa baked ) -- oO ee par fog gee # sg Sh q Sopot : . ea ae oes Ber te od . sep pty fetay fy mas Bons ne at wey EL Eas wots, Saatenl HH ® Lael Spy 's boll beBeg 3 Taal Jest aed bated ne fad . * 2 oa 1 PR PhO . Pils aie is eg a ba Os - me 2 : hdea fe 4 Es doped poet > ve Fat Se a fea "gaara . Sila 4 ee ae ee a : Cova jeg pif bet ; ae ar eee . ged | Sigg ff EA ee Seger ate 33 foo Tobey Bek aa _ a hog Jessel . . : dawegd . . - a | a AME we Met WM sche | a ah tall ci 4 Pian M ee fl E " . ° . . wee By . : . pee onan? : . Soe . . . ae sige - aa oe . oF : eee tet gay ; Ps, . . fest : . = . feos oe as 8 De " fey : Pe . : : etki . et . ton e3 : . ' bedag . fee a : fede} * cathy Bed? ae " : : he vac ae o ee see hae geo . ; : " ed . : s an : ae ° ° ee : "a eas, . - . Bereess ~ Bee : . a 2 uale - . : : &, » astral . ol wo. . : . . ae a q Fes, Sa ' . ae . » & dark geod a ne "spe i . . . ee _ = iP a nee " oo 7 ae a ph i fee 8 ey Ae Ee " ry ay HR OE - Se we fae pa : aod a AS Ey) So 4. ey s spitbad eae ays sed : " as whe * ' . aie PS Pony yer} Oat Fale) ran ee ed Bel 7 . . sa ea ae) joked gw A bed fg det 3 " . - *s wieed wes " ie ey sth - Pees sept Ld ah ge eq US eager Bal 193 a a ee woe a A, rn : . gd on. ne . a we gh wi ° na weed , : i gee . . , byt pond ad : . de es a i . seen 0 RES Wd a i . gene Bs ws Rd: - Ss . eed ac . . iret yee ane god & apthook @ sheak ek . . pets a . ee 2 ay : , i gs i Keo 2B gt Sy = yas! Soo Ses Pa : Sta ee pees hd fsa pkg Nog iad Ft hy . st sorts, Bat &. - _ ee: wom Bite pel " sete} oy spose Pug ert whee 5g a os en i : ao) "og ae 3 Ba ae ug © oon -- 5 poy x ee via e ioe CH gad gens : gy PAR ded a) a SES ky "Si gh gee» a " 8 Bayo" Biba} fetta Bhs gemg pe GRY Lit Bee ws aesand : OO HOM WOIVLIVNEVE JO LUNGS HOI VOIVLVYNEVY 40 LUND HOIH WNVLVNYV 40 LUNOD HOIN WIVEVNYeN 40 AunOD HOI VOVIVNEVH dO LENOD Ht SN wey a flag ee : Bah ok as, out pag Pe ae beet davadl 2 eq Bond opoi 9 En ys fag wl gal A bs i a a ea ky i Epoih ki 5 sgl legs ae i " gags, par Seed 94,5 4a hes fe oe YAO HOIN WOMYNEY JO LUNGS HDIN WIVIVNEVS JO LUNOD HOIH WIVIVNUVE AO LUNOD HOIN VNVEVNYY) 40 LUNOD HOINVNVLYNUVN dO LINOD Ze ot Fale Bot, t found ee & 98 ee ca 2 4 Papas ential esr oagsmse f ma ent iol wag ge 09 HOIH VOIVIYNYVH JO LUNOS HOIM VYVIVNUYY JO LUNG? HOI VVLVNYVN dO LUND HOIN WIVLVNYW dO NOD HOD WOVIVNYYH dO LUMO He fo ys ford Bo : a HNO HOI VAVIVNEV dO LYNOD HOIH WIVLYNAVN AO LNMOD HOI VWVIVNUYH JO LUNOD HON WVLYNYWN do NOD HOIHWNVIVNYVN JO LENO? gd o er : - ers es ae eS « a oS Se a a io: 1 a apoetl ast E: the aged Pye ws "a ty rot Ua ae ge ba ~ : . : ost ee "Gnesi ae oo 7 - : : ee : . wig * a Rat adbenat a wk Ty ost : ay i "ad gabe Sup. ge =a & es Re ; wa Bg jel ae et . : i aging L 5 my wa jesse as en st eyed "tg Shot ee 'bad Dae yaya : g pol i wee ita feed i lead we sel Sit dug a re Salt a pe Rog "endl 2 tind es yoo wpd dog ai soca ie pate] Ege! x pet ghee a ' i vd Ay eatith ; i" : ane ' a a es % bet j ss OS gait a * ney a wel . Sno} wes " " aged : peng a 2 west B Sect " oa . a am Jccol ce pos : , ep OS-AISIE WOINVEYNGYS 3O LENOO HOIM VIVIVNNYR dO LANOS HSIH VNVEYNUYN JO LUNOO HDIH WIVLVNYVH 4O LUA0Dd HOU WHYVIVNYo JO LYNOD Hi A, ve : rh . vded GE gern, "Se 'oats Beak er a . Braga 1s ; . oe 7 - ee : a "ES : . ue ay hea HE fo . : TARE oss ee : wee eet a Saag . 5 "en . , & Re Spe * at ag - q co " . plies ® : : , - gg OR . . Uke Be . * . 2 g aod belo ; ; . wn Sens rs oes o > . . ra na . ' a ged asad g . gran py cytes : mo Lea? nest . bded Pied Bead : wd . . i a Pe a oe ot . we Thad Euaget : inti ay an oe. ws ; a Moe panda, ary Pace ty vt 3 al nie - iy esi . be as Fy Pooh ee pan . Lost ° : , i Rast He H . e , bie} BS . 1 Seta x a Fi é eh Y Pers we 4 ; vag oo Sat Bead : ain , ePg gd Kd = a = a a nee ce oes i ae el wy = we x eis one py, es Bt Bad eed : Pe op & s et ¥ "E gey aeett . ae Dded sal ag ie a a' on By ; ' ae ug e ied % bhg ee som we ae om } 4 nga Rad dal Pa ee . : Sey Be om are Teast gre . janes no one fo ala 1 nt ae shed i es ee . Py, pes 2 cae ate Res . EE de Pye" aoe we us) booed aes ae . sss ak ' a s . . BAS gat a ae tee ae . " sen fod ares, 4 # e aie "Beane ae . . os, i ise SS al a ons a 'eas pst fe A yin £ oe Saad" ied OY Sreseung Eo ema og 'began ag Big Lea ly Gehy gall Le meu : iNOS HOI WIVLVNYVH dO LUND HOW WAIVLYNUVH JO LUNOD HOI WVLVNYY dO LNNOD HOIN ivi NAWOt 40.4NNOD HOLAVAVIVNGYS JO LAND I .
ped a % wt am | a <* a ae i. ap Bg Rea ' " or ae ie . i a as = a ie ce Fa at . a +r PES Ne] ee >Re ; ra © oa Sapp a = oe Sy "ws ae ba cl > 3 a) G te ome a yo # : ty ited 3 abs E gS o ie am & 2 "gf git oe oe Frog Bey, aon tet ta, | me iw, Se Ae *3 | a = - au oe 2 = is fee x = hi me yy x ia y ea fee OB "Te eg. nS 2k Pas a sa _ EP hy : ay a } § , wee He oa Rerse pie crests.
ieee eet Te pistes! Die g pa 're a aa apes ; ie ay ad : ae bay a Sy gos s > Bayne me rer ee! te ek oy io sf ® i 7 a ot e " a VNVIVNNYN AO LUNGS HON VORVLVNNYN dO LHMOD HSIH tetany, yaed spldiog Sag : plik al etarccee™ YOO HOI VOVLYNG VS dO GUNOS HOI VAVLYNYVH 40 UNOS HSIN PIVLIVNNVD AO LUNGS HOI VNWIVNUYN jo LUMO HOIMVNVLYNYYN AO LUND | . sal ged poems _ , . / « ge pss . . ae? or ood . bot "Boe ue . - ce ee abel . . Fed a ged _ Fr af . : toa ' : . a i, [eit os at at F : fons, 2 .
oes ef : wd a ce) a gihbenaiy ety a3 .
iad .
ged
-
ag 7S .
gent Bi fe a , one S Qh 4 fee go ee. :
wage ee | : -
ss : a gaye ee jel ade MS th we et og bec pag eed sf eos df gibt : i pe mw) gest Yeo] ety _ . hed, * 'eign oat ae ca ea 4 gna i a st oe seal * fet -
a4 os ; ; :
goreg al age . erg rg . ;
lee wa ee :
io wt hated . woe Hye R ms gored . wo weld <r, gga i: wn pte sa se "
Subd : gabe . hot an BH Fe :
ie foe Leg me fede wat Be tegen ;
- oe ged ; :
bang Bish Koused heel . . ey wea, $ ged ew ee res a ages a Be Inked 4g 2 'be at . is fe pao whe hay ii et Bot glo or pert in fy ee ney :
YOO HOI WOMIVNYVA JO LUNGS HOIK YWULVNUVA dO LUNOD HOIM VOYLYNEVH JO LUNOD HOI VIVLVNAVH 40 LINO HOINVAVLYNYVY JC LUNOD ua aed Asst OO HOI VOWLIYNGYA JO LUNOD HON VAVINNYYS dO LENOD HOIN WIYIVNEYN dO DINGS HOIN VNVLYNUY dO awnoD HOI VONUYN YY IO LNOD 4 assis ase pees ek ACaE GaP Bok LO % py aco "
Lead a Beg £ hy . gps " . a a ca : a yoo an Bel el : seal aes . A : 'boot a . "Sie, Sak, . :
iy: ce coe . wads oe ' os vo, 7 ey ea . : . i ie # . . ka Bg bat : . ° o . ge gad sha! : . Oe ES od
- - : : edt & gag . .
Laid . : ' ac : . enon bog . . 'gh seal "et "atl Bak : as} .
. sien aes . :
me Sey age oe 8 eel Bonny t ne a eo Ml mm | oped es Hod cane yh a ke HNO HOIN WVIVNUYS AO NOD HOI VONVIV NAY AO LUNGS HOIH aS see] ae #2 my st a ' esd 4 *s ngs 4 a gs aed a ay e fe oul ee . se al 3 pthed Bolg Se te Bg, ded! i * eS 4 Sheet :
% oe nog of Pe ae toh pe fy % Seg Sane ae gd ego z 4 . 2 bond 2 pred eee * we & ' ie Bs go dct ee a get wy = ball ie apd 'peal gebed if satis #3 sporty oe us Egurd wp A af Se ual . we we a bee ue ogee ved oi ae syn so pee asta Se en . an J eae & sae i Sot goed ae ef : . anad ie ee fet eet ee x on uM sibel ee . Pieese e% al hat is os + ped ; & duck ree 3 sot re es a - ee pad " ae athe a + gg ual we of , apap . i.
mon . id .
ee £9 de o .
Based : . "ee 8% Be as get dusk i" paaak > vot hema set - ue WIVLINUYH 2D LUNOD HOIN VAVIVNEYA 20 LUiOD HDIVHVLVNYVH 4O LYNOD ated eam & i a yotfinetion da .Kernetelkea ¢ : hee y HM COURT OF KARMATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH it executed between the tor of Povaets (GLI, ~ manent of Karnat supplied is fixed by fon 20.03.1981 publish:
i, itreapective of any other document providing for supply of timber other forest lin the rul at tion. The Gove % we ith ¢ OURT OF KARNATAKAHIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH C foreat produce at te ee ne Ba Ba ! ee 1 ve galt aw Rs Px god peg, su a pul a sree, of, we pel a * es ae a ash og hed "a , ae ae ae os pide : beat 'dga* fiescdl Breast Saal J 7 Pie, a on not . eeong Ryne: nasi ae me dees sero ie Ebed fend . oe oe . poe % asd a A ' . Fan . : wakes ony 4 z : gs * ecm . kag : ' oR eae) Soni aut Sra Mace a py . hoesk a ° pou = Pa ies es sy * sd stheast ra ae aye re Pe wed te hat Sat ee ee el , & sat poh ae x ~ cbt eo oa wat . a oe) 0 sped : ee eet a ere "eat Lares Dee gettncey . ° ts ge ams as i Ses = Be -- ; 1 eisooned ppg pot ao ee ge 7 ge :
he Ran ie . oy sagen ay ed Bae or i Sa, ee we rs 3a gad a ied Se geod ae aerenad a feo : _ wee wad on ed x & sgeeg oe a ie oS soba ro we we ah ' Fue es Be - : sagen pes sang us : : ' LA hae _ sgt : oe, <ofit jeg = : . . he? wae Hes a dea ey . oo aad ¢ x . % ined 8%
- ha aa . . a ea ee a : . ar Re " . e 'i *e rats Pil as ; : : a Pee sof ¢ . : fe A "a as pd oe ' vo ae Be a a god . cnt aie yet a beads q a Les 4 to pied sethed fit) nes bee Bae , asst ot ened a ool ; Bal vst oa 4 . ee . " ey ah sed . wed : - g 3 . o gS a ; is : 'og e :
bal ws . re . as . . 8 col a on Ee ed - Sod Xe ren se a on oa aed od ea ms es a sat ue . . : " " shed et og Fe af aol Sh ¥ ; . : feat ak hod ia" adeets? of pry by het . ohne Be sal gectag pa we 'eh sh aor . . are wag 3 Boy, "hia ae - us ' . Send ey gant Seng ged a, ke ; ip - Po" woe a seed Pe bog eae sgt ge "4 . a or : : 8 Sea 'af eae a eI ent tg : sjoo8 a 6 a Bok fe sdheoait . . . Bee ee 1a see ay ue a ihe Pe, ee Ey) pe a : Pod de a a ava peng c fre, ae ggossd Rae tees Yoana spot & " Sa oy site : aad eX pus god - awd wi . weg ; i o i a > : oe Ce beg ot 2% & a ee : we. ee . " ast seestie ae Bel Seok . ° Pes ' ee * yee em & Sy " eno IS - ge me : Lat Pea mo a : ey gut sol = a ae ws ug Be : chet : od soon Sonal wr ont & i) ho ee . pw . > ae ha ® ent a agate el ea oy oe ee ~~ sae r st sotly Ses ; 2 oped i fhe ees of i unt . . ph sae ae & a "4 oem oat ; sign a 8 ae eed a > # we ord Senet .
3 £ 2 ant lp . ss e : spond So * ee eh a "press "gpl ia Neigh ra eS . . £m seg es gue & , . :
eo Se S au gh = oy seg 4 Seat hs siege Bs & oeg ° * ae Nad ios Borie Ee: be wat Seahed cack ° ae :
JO HSIN VWOVIYNYVA gO LEMOS HOIN YVIVNYYS dO LENO HOI YOWUYNYVH JO LYNOS HOI WORVLIYNEYH JO Peles) HOM WONMLY NY JO LYNGS HE got 2 i ge o Bad had ee sgecoh .
% » Speke nag & A "ay ses feats ve ba ay Be ine doh oe got is ee Pe patina estan whet © os Py dled a Beta pov peng on ves e ae gost sheet 'badlud ead Soh ee abet he bet ee ae se C "s ' pore E eo é = ee 2, She es aegrd Seal ae oil Aes a "ed YNOO HOI VOVINNSYS dO LUNOS HOI WOVEN! dO LNAOS HOIN VAVINNUY dO LYNOo HOI VAVIIVNUVH 40 aUNOD HOH VALINE YS 3O LUNG space aoe gon t BG gras) ed 5, inched aii aoa 7 peg 4 = bd 4 ae ah be) oS given best Oy a s & Ge HOT WANLIV SRO LOD HOIN VOIVLYNEYH JO LENO HOIN YNVLVNYYY JO LUNOD HON WNVLYNYON IO ay 10D HOIK YNVINNEYS dO LYUNOD HE "Ee :
oe eee Slits hte aes Pea gad Basa Sehad $4 Lae Seas 25 es i g Sas! tinal ees = el Absit ipa 7 el ag 3s yah | spgred shot Ei Jntent Le : - a one ae ee Gest 2 : Foc ef £ pes Ga aging ea Sond 2%, ried oe bia Be ' Sel BSy geal ae: ssid a " Ewe cy ponds \ ose aang re PUP SE, See Sadat Aue oe le Lams se med rn i ay Taha Rows
-
es 2 vad ah ee a 4 sea * port od Sai a ati "pet en 4 AGS HON VVEVNUVN AO LHNOS HEH VOIVAYNEYS dO UNOS HOI YN ELYNEYH 2O 2SNO9 HOI YVEYNEV AO iunoo HOI YING YS AO LENOD a a ai fo, & ere a Se Ww et o we aes a ABS bs as i my des oll a os fed soit tes - s ; er ond @ ae "dust sey» a has see . i o a te Heal wed ah od badge few fra ts ae es, ee : sep © ae oy 2 ae Pt CA i fies etna ag « ees fag a ged enn er) as ae: ea hed Ee a ait & " a s oe # at oe Pat eget seg, a Seas Aud 23 3 ee nid or % a oe pa "ee i Teotleg Bull te pn "Ae & a bo faa ; .
a es a serteay Sas fh wae gee 98 gs ' ee aah ago Ce sora ae aol a ae) _ u a :
Baas aging bd Epos fe * | _ yp : * ope as Se ooh ie - ie Sant dane gonad sn a ' gecnl | cee eet .
x od suk Hey Rages fle ah i = g = ;
a ol Sean iS a at ; # nigh aed gus | os vag wind fost . ey "fea! Shad OO HSIN VNVEVNUON 4O LINO HOI VYVIVNEYN dO LUNOD HOI VIVEVNUVN 4O LYNOD HOI WWLYNEYD JO LUNOD HOIN WNVLYNUYH JO LUND WE ne ae a oe bed dud Eden 4, ko oy ' ee hi . be , ey ae # Aa DA i. canal ay we cr. es a & ee det gn oa a a ae ae et PS <ge Sng Seek ; . fesh : bot : ie Sod wil 'he dd aes . : = : a Et hast ee '3 re ee sail Be : bet i Set al Sine 'all 2 ae : he 4) a veel Fi nad ied ak ae . * : wa Bek veygrlh eo ae Baal et jos? .
- wong 4 Saat vse "i at bed es zs s pe 28 Spat pad postal Re ged, soe se . BS ut * vant ee ised ee sah 5, oe en ee : » 1 a ae oe ok od bee we Saal Bg sad leat os ged . Sug dred og Nd 24 bee ie i rel * ee es a ae: pod woe ga a a ee Peery bed ws &y oe ¥ ae nes ope ve rn 2 ee if gogell el had . ays gated pe ee ae - ae eel BA ce) ae r sag ahd ae peony as wots Ped yet hd ae gould eee apshonde Pho feah ade Ea) a sed vad ms eet "bok ; we oa 'a af ool = ed at ay vd nh a a a wi es a a 4 bg as fel ae pred eee he an i' we + bal = Host "she wheal i . ; B, : bee At whe | es sree est est 3 . eas . "ek ie ha gist ee ' ap * a . . ue ped bee " bo} a sent aaa er rt shed . oo og 'yl ; Sa te s) ce hegeel 4 a + Del z gee rs st abt, ae oo - a | a ha a = . : Bs SBE - ~ x wae te aoa ag ay "ES apd ' : BAY Fronts . ee et heat iad Fges Boe SP ed "aad? * wy 5 ot . ' ol fat A " he a ae on ue Pie 4% } "pes e ma «ee vol a hed foe ef du 6 s Sop oy dnd Rast fed and tag Bay pak ar ' ' & as . an span © shat ae ; : ay Ge ee a oa Bed hel a et . : he . a aes gd Feu & = bet a agg . aa Sea . : sae ae 24 ial % ei us ve er oe a 2 i re a oe ® es :
Bat 2 Avid, e . . Pe 'igh sa a os ee goed oe pon 25 . ae ne . Ey Soa bet oa sg Rage A ae "ee . . os ee er agebo i, ae a3 Peal & ae PS dint we bog st ag on shed sen es 4 a a mp Ee me . . _ iN ca we bh eam ba Ne Da akg . vo : = a dbrag pees cans Sieong A eel oe a Bot . . Pah Ee: = ~ s wet Fe a Be? , , . es Teall See tad ey ay os ee . ; aa = = to! 'odes! ae "aon : . Shed Rl s% & a pe, Baka asa ; Higens spstlan heal a oo eS e e a a ond ee - oh Lge a as fs & ee " es ; be feo as el Be, Sue ws sont av wee a we : . a} # el a) * doe '5 Looe . oy ed get 6h igegieh ua or] y fra , . x om " aaa faa pe 4 i 0 pat shee ~ Fig: ae : Pe = had € ' a e 4 apne et hud a ued ua ae as - ie a ty : Pal aL? ag ae jewel 'id ey ct nt brie 4. Bed i :
eed Sof i , Bees etn, tye .
aH oy a aa oe . * - -
hed fala ay vs ee a. ; we ee a Pa i be sept feha . piles, ; tol " a5 0 oth a my? u : Me : . Ses pa $ . . . . ae goin b ; . we ; yeived as e * 59 | A nn] ay ae we ee wehian 'Boe! Eo ud oe ee ao . ; gl Py ay ~ sy A Ae Mahe pa gReeg 83 ce Faas Ee sexed ang peg Seley ae yobes ed yeti Ban sasgeeeg Ag | wi . : Seat ag "p * og OO as got eh a "Ry ve 235, is e shor x Re " . , "aay a Po as ® we i a es a 4 ding : q Sok yond RE 4 oe greta a acting spel z eee apebad ? St aut aS ht a eit Sead has? ie as heed yah! Hod hy aa . . . : .
HOS HOIW VOWIVNEVN dO LENOD HDI VIVIVNEVN dO LYNOD HOIM YUVIVNYVN 40 LENO HOIH WHVLVNUY) 10 JUNOD HDINVNVIVNAVA dO LINOO = we :
gs?ane) .
* Byes" or a Se we oy ' :
_pitoeds 7 :
Hee Ie pas ays ek seats ea chow tae yea pee aes ae weed vag agi : ay o rd t Ae Ba wed a ee heed .
ol pid ats 8 ae oh, oe4 2s eae Bop dthy By thed est a vee "as a ae Sete et sn ee at aS paged > Asad Fug od red ied Bed Mast EG owe el " ~ bet Res ey ed at i oth Sot et bad oe cae Race oe papa e 2 Be Pal ogee ibn wy aged Se sl ies re oe » eh se oe 7 Song Boost ae Seas gn Gal sped Ga SH SOV NYO 2O GENOS HOIK a segs ial r dn Saeed} ss Ee as el oe "
: oh pees Pa es
- ¥ Sb spring Yedeeus 'net : hud spot det £ cand Sond st ey peek srg peo pated Le Tebised $y aa Bree: payed 8 Na aphosh Shas He sesh He Re
-
ca is pha et se Fal Pe go joa ood i si huast & Pais pda ue see fer gra OM ae es ae sed Sos oe ot oe gmt ea 'hess Book BS ay ae a * Py ey 'fo eoltel Silk WHVLVNEVO dO LENO) HOH : 2 as 2 : Gee % 2 7 en tick fod ats aged Bad ay a Psy, e Seat ee am, ke Ew Seat pa «ae Sed a &3 Bini Bed :
A seeed ged -
=H af yarn seat ue a at a weet paul dove peel ie ~ tad :
sping oo abed .
: 4% «Sake Bet & - eed oe . ' . . aa we hg . :
gos : . . an, Rad woos : ;
Yeaek ;
Lae pged eee ae ws a oot od ' fe oe) i a x oer grad Hed
-- .
+ ook a a ;
as axink vo Pr Be ee 'bea ge Fy ~ VRVIYN Val dO LENO HOI WAVEVNao a Lund Ol VAIN NAW dO LENOS HE . 7 , Raa . ae Ses
- ae @ oo mo oes spied , a el ; , ne e : . : Oe ea ay fey Bie, Way dood o . ko fh Pty 4 Pg os, fest ee ee ie oH : E :
elt : ar ee eat spend Ae ee Rey, Bing a ey # wee Me Sect gt . ae Seat oe " vee . Begs aan : mo : : eat ae : . t if eect ete "
. . Pea Pyag Bong Sand : as Fay dE Hed ¥ : . Se, ey , : een "
he : . ood : ag ' ater wpa " . he good %
- pe: xd ey . vile cane aah £ a eng s gegen) bg i » Resa ceed Bae) . gh ye . . : a wa ad BB, Beery Pe , . oe Opals * Sos : feat UR 3 : deere cee By : . Me ao es he ron BS bes Js Booey ei : Body Fh . . ae Roa nt a "st : on ES B it Pa eS ee : soon -_ "hag! -- : Faget . ' ry es, as . 8 tey, oo ~ . Prebines "
"haat ety Ma shes ie -- ate a ee el! yee ah 2, : Sahl ee, ee ot ag ues oe - ey i oe Bead Te ae seh Bs & os : S se wat sate fis, Xie Eden Sah, . . ake . ak ta oe ey ae ok Oe ig : . Yee igtitnd sy ed canes ceed ee os . aoe . Thea EN a eS ' Bess a gy ot ty dad ws cs ee OS ' oS BB "Ej vox ata wun = $ . oped word Sad pe i he Be Fay et foe : = ees Hee aE ar . . ae Sein, vg hy . : es Bean! ane aie a, Se - os roe % wy es i afd . ig ohn es "bond Sod oe roe 5 ee Sevegl Ea wens : -", os . ek Pes ° self nat ee : . . ad es Xe oa z booting a . Ber ig en . . en, oa bm -, ee . . . Brekud Sag even She ny - , 1 Sige gy! z ss : : . . e > 'erg . Bye igs es ec . : : seed gt 5 os ise - ke Coat es . Pe, - he Nas ieee Sa is Saas Sead! aoe. es aio Smee a gat ge ' "4 PR a rue on ae Saat 5? SM Fy & wil ae . ° ae . aa ' pra Bad te ce) 2 ny, Hasan sued Gm, ee tye cal iy ae ad ae i ee ' wy, "sole Boon i ee Pes ae worker f at arr oe hy oe E a Be sage 5 Se cae a3 . es eas Beet ee go sage Be " oe , oe oh ei Peed py ak eg en . pe et - ft : fey 5 i ie hong is poet Sad tas? a gnodt q . nea ost se 2 oe a an od . & ain wath Bes, a oa : . mk shod tee a 08, cy . ere Ps . :
Pa Reach 3, 7 "a ee i fy MM 's ey .
85 Sncheg bated " , oy , Ae . ot " . . "
a Fda bs, 'Sg ft 6 i be Sy ss , a4 . fed J Rd on Son aan : 3 rs ree ee ge es as 2% Em ged ono a Si : od ptodd 'haw 'ba faa A Pe egy ml : : Sag "feet tet eC x ee . pet cl ea dost ae Lap 2S : ed Rg isk ae on gaed " onan of awd oS a: a nn 5 . eat Sea ay a we 4 a set as a : Beye & ba! on ia, ae ce us ded inst Ped sy od vs : oadiad e deed ad Bae:
er ae . pes gs sheet ded a aes a a ha aw ve oa ath a 2s od o bos ae : ag a Set we ge a. one 3 one Bs & ag Spud * i> / ee a . oda as Ee aed Sg eh * #3 eed eid a ae :
ge grtlvad reese ; foxy 2 poll Pei | patty wabsnd! ae ve py ea dev so bol ; : ay : cre a3 Heid jail . dest Sige be ost ath oak eo ass Bg ai " . ~ 2 et <4 ge ; pod peat wed spond' : gee % Feng : geek eo pee : oT pat ais os yet fade et jos : wy ah age pegs hae #2 ae bos pel apant d - ypu ae oe ea Sov vet : ae eS a : : deed a Be . Ge . ons pee a, ng of sage oped hal oy & . wet . . gaged Sf as ce dead es Pa sped oe a . a a a = et z ae ae ie EE ao ery 8 Pe sages z a) sold spt ae ke apetioadl Beas nia Soe Ee "al a ; . ; eS ed s soc shed : ° sat ad ea enti § dod an ' . . . 25 o an a 2 ees . se pu doh ; es ae bed fray yee ood bo : i. be ge "a mf ae 3 i : a BY me " ee ea isd oe ef Laat Aad i ded 5 pleok ae . . sad pa Bee ay a $e a pas "feck act - BS . ae! ey " i 3 ze eo Saga . : ae .
i eget si 96) e% ; . . ae ct fost ees ee as ep ae ot . : aneng Sond Sas en a s a% Pa haat : . ae and oy ay a ao Sash a> hae a . ; a wees a othe aS, eh gos ae if . + gost » we Be ¥ enti € ee ° bee oss oa Py Py oes oa _ , - Bey ue 23 Sup ed eet a ae a 3 . Kt ee ya Ag a faa qa & tou soe Fc . cr " afibed get et haat a wea Se : re ars we 7" pak _ sg oe host ted oe hwnd oe ogg de at ue > ay ee Ae ae a ., . : ay Aa of Re" ® ge Bas u ( Cae iat q gS hex ae : 2 et ail ee pales 5 nee : aaa ae, . Bnd ae , BE oe % x. ' sant ibe a1 eb, "a . ese, ee oh aphid ane ae oda a ee y a . . ws oP wees ea & S Bed ef. : ae . meres Host wee "i ay peek aye & Bog Bevo .
i) ey os a « pay & aes fe) peed es oa gage i er Nl # aati Hoe agin segs ey 2 a . A thea 8 qe i she 4 5 ages we a' apse Shes a re :
ae rang Be ee a the sone a : ; Gnas a eee Se Kos big wer ey e : - - ae a eh, het thee ar aye ere aa . :
ee | Py he a a wil Pee eth Ae . a tpl Bald Seok es eee ee é "se ye wes Pa 'i 4 # "ei Be gelley ae oe es : aot ve MDie YOUN) dO 2ENOS NOUN VONINNGYS gO LENO HOR VEVIVNUYN 2O LEMOS HOI VAVIVNE Yo) JO LuN09 MON YOViVNUYA sO OANOS HE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARMATAKA HIGH 5 "etvont ~ « ay F a en heed 4 rc po si a Beda somone ee er 5 a ay Seg ae Beant i i he fo a ae a ae vs gest as saat ges a st gest Bas ed a ea : i BG Eee ee Sabor th "re F ey Yel z ee en : . pal s ze hued : el wdbak oa a ait nl : : . Suey * Fig Bewst eas Be wel ge wed eet Q "st ool penal - a a ne ' dyad de pea' hag Bes a Sad toad a . rns | wom ad ne fey i hed x obs . 2 grt % , bok pe A 4 aN & eet to al et eyed te! ¢ a ee ie we = Baal Bat SY oe = ae Re 3p Be me Re oa oe, = a & # oe get aa a & sh baad Sg a soul Bey, eae v2 2 Bee a et . : . é dent as wy mh es ed a Sel at See . 1 gitgenad wd 2 gy an skid Bish apy oe 4 Bene a £4 wal : eee te ae 2 oS "bs Nhe : as i) a : af ges pa ind Aa " ey ee me . : i3 aeee F Bang Beet ee @ abag oe pak ee as aay re st a iond at . see Bae ae oy a - ve re ° Sok os . poling "aad o Hee . so a adevet ee ead ee vn si. ee - . ogee 7 ee re Ren an Seay " pol Eason Ee sae ee sf ae pa af gabe} eo ae fal Bais sf wet wast ~~ aban beat a oa Snifist 'po eee , . at Teg Bod £5, syd Best . cbsab an #5 seg See hes 2 sv . * ke ae bes * nd a en 7 - 2 eg ig ate * wad teed ae dank os ey fad Be &. pos pan Bes a ey iol . a es 8 a soot ed er : Bs abe ds bit ao Bad . wes a, Fog ot sprygal at ooo : ae . ye ee ad Hest : ee oy oon 5 ras : as ae ' £3 i a ee . me . 4 . ca pede 8 i, re: gotiess goad sega wis a ee ae "al i a wy " ait : se mt ay 8 ee : A. : © el ra ot . om : : Boag Dae Boe Bord . . . se pieded ape ron Fabia eee : - Bae fagk ie "ea & o : ah a . py a3 a4 fon "Sh oe é Sok ¥ ope S hed sed a, . ° " wo x =o patie . " , . o io 5 Fe oo Ns 3 ; ; ote feet a -- , . Lg - . . wen he Be 2s i) es Be ee a "es oy x a . adored Sek a ee ae Ava » 8 . . eee Bead yy eo pepe eh ee a OS et pened an vA i ar Se eT) . oe , Bag oa He . i Suit ~ und Ethie vad! Best ee - : ne Ba # Soa = ae aan : 4 : ae on & ese * a : 7 bt : ca ae Ae Ss 20% a Se oo foe Sy ay ae a od ee # . Nad e oe ig ol oe , % : , a ol im "ie sing ig a a es 'tet "-- wont a eg seal wey ane a ae cant 4 , - , : Boy sy ted ent . ee got es Oe . . halba 2 el ent agli ase a oe . ; Bae shee a ee etek seer pea pet os . esd ' a faa fs Bey pe ae bes . . - gt - ae 2 apes wd 5 he . ae . geal pegeg os ae 'at , Sood re Rdog sing 'ef gated eel >a ag ee ion . asl ae "te 3 be "4 ts 4 A Bo vos . a be ed i aa ay pe ggenmand Sod " on B a oe re 2 & as el ns) a joo. bet # . es ey 'She Pa 5 =e " go ant 2 aR had Sah eq 4& a " oe se re 2 vt ob feed io et ae ae serge fa Rs : pag aye % ed oe seal at io ye bs = fal . how » Sree? fy Shane Bag * "ae " : a a Pe 5 Yet we ot Po " ah oe Se eat al he Bod ayhneg 2 op e% ee BA a gout a bel a a : : bud a abs a os aed Be : "ge ae aie & ee) hea ; ay ee & : hal . J gs ! ee : ca bai Ms x Bess we Bot sel RS atte a ghd . 's oi pa rs i we s & oul Ld Say ey eS oot ne hs 02 HOI WOAIVAVNEVS JO UNOS HOI VVLYNE YD dO LENOD HOIN WONLVNUYA JO JANOS HOI VORWIYNGY dO aunod MON VXSLVNGYS dO LENOS HE re segs a 2s ie seth pepagh HOS HOM VOIVIVNYVE JO JOO HOI VOIVIVNEVA dO LUNOD HOIN TWIVLVNGYH JO LYNOS HOI WIVEVNYVN 40 iyAeD HSIN VAY NUYS gO LUNOO ie"
sed a ' ' py ray
- bps st a : a 2 ss 4 we) a SS dont i "pt ghea he god a I 4 oe an Ast Bie Pi yi ae ea a os, Phy SS pe Be Po 'po a ; :
2h oe gslug os ee ee ae a ane ae est ae At eee
-
seat - axed sore as oe i, Ye A Re ee Sad spot wail ae pnt gl sek peeked a " abe Subs OD HSIN VHVLVNUVH JO LUNOD HOI WIVLVNUVN dO LUNOD HDI WIVLYNUVN dO LUNGS HSIN VHVIVNY WH dO LENO} HOM VOIAVNGVR dG LENO Ki tol a that bigest « "end HNO HOI VOVIVNaYS JO LenOD HOIK VOAIVLVNEV IO JYNOD HOI VVIVNYV dO LENOD HOIH VHVIVNE YD 40 NOD HOI VIVLVNAVH JO LUND NGH COURT OF KARNATAKAHIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARMATAKA HiGt COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH © sae these narteailers sine to collect. the °s ou ede NGS HOI VVINNYYY dO LENO HDIN VNVINNEYH 36 LYNOS HOM YNVIVNUYN JO LYNG HOH Beak oe, ' f ie pag oft ay SEH pod ie a aera Saat s geht dog, #
-
pepe i Bet os a "
oD bls enh a gest grt Saba oe ret sf is Pak Ae -fivet 2 8 # a ged Bn bea x i ag Pe oe Ha sepa 'gt ms 4 ¥ dl ae gs Ast ted PS) < gen od gee # ged ed Bo u z # 8 i is Xs eo BAS ee ag pth yee a4 ip bso 4 4 VIVNUYH JO LUNOD HOI WIVEVNEYN JO LNNOD HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HGP i 'i HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH OO:
JRY OF MARNMATAKA HEGH COURT OF KARNATAKA if the plainti wstion of 'granting ~ ents being i. granted by
- id thet the ole! sade iy paid to the pisintiff i is public at sere, 2, we are of the we mee 16, in these cirot 2 a jumice to the case would be met by setting aside the we Of the Trial Court anc rer Ment ane, ce Tass paca somo ce ae a i' 7 oon a z god Food i . died ade so ® sgheedt cia wont « yang a onan, 2 Iya "Sheet ey oc on ha beet seogsag % Pa) By pdt a3 Sgt <peges EA Si a a g vs eons of bel ee -
puget ak a © cae . AA ang 5 "ar weg est gore gout pone Sire "
Sted =n HMOD HIN VOWAIVARYS 2O LNOS HDIH SIVLYNE Yo dO LHNOD HOI YOWINNUY) JO LNOS HOIN VRVLY NNO Te LYNOD HOINWIVIVNYYN dO LUNOD ge, 2s Pehedi aS ey "ig g sid Set si ay oined ele as OO HOT WOIVIYNEY dO UNO HOI VV LYNG JO LANOS HOM YNVLVNEV JO DINOS HOI VAVLVNE YH IO.LNNOD HDIE POLY NEWS 2 LAO |e [= rare JUDGE ape sail Petnge i.
a
-
me) HAG HOI WYN JO LYNOD HOI YOIVAVNYTH dO LUNOD HEIN WNVEVNUVY dO LUNGS HOM WNVLYNYYN 30 LYUNOD HOLVIVIVNYYH dO LUNG