Karnataka High Court
State Oa Karnataka vs Harischandra Prasad on 13 July, 2009
Author: Jawad Rahim
Bench: Jawad Rahim
mg' mg H§G%§ CGURT 9? §{&R?€;%TA%i{§""-'A.' "
CERCEEET 935:5}: 9:? DHARW ' DATES mzs THE 13TH §3;g§9'%:§:{§' ;_£;§;*~:,-:
8E§QREak"z . xi THE} HQN'8L«E1 Es£RyJfiE§é'§{§€L*E§ J}§2a:.z3:3vv.Rf;If§}%V§1§§:'VV S r::R:M;§~:AL Rgmsrgw ?_§~':":':9:'§g%ré ":;Q'2éé9;*;.2:::é9 BE'?'%é:'E2E§é; % ' E' 'V A' State 05 ., ' .
Rum} Paéicfi f;:g=:i9:2;~- V ' '
{E-aéag' Iii! PETE"E'i(}§'$ER
{By Sri. $1 3.: _;'?4i"{'f:G'E?}' 7
ANS: A ' V 3
Eiafiséjhaxldra ?fas§i§;
'~ By Jaya§:*a£{&--:;E:V
N££fif'£3}'&'€}3 A .
--,S:f.o *§':'~a$a&;,
14%,; a«.:_:;a::gavafig . V . , , RE1S§3{}N{}E;§'%'§' ' {By Szifi. Cfiiiafiéérlagiiakar Paétfig, ;%é.vo<:3i$} A. '§'I:£a' :<3:":z?m:i:;1a£ mvigimz p:§€i§3ZQ:1- is ffzaé "mfg 3%? E}??? =='%{}§ " {Z gigging is 322?: axide {£15 jzadgmtrgt 313$ amiss: géafisad ii?' Esamzeé if Aéfi}; Civii Jifige {$21 $11} $5; J§'§EE3'C, Qafizag, Iii} QRFS flrime :~2a,2?:s;2£3G8 fiaieé 4.1{§;;§€}i38w "§'§1i$ gmtiiiam Czsmmg an far adméssimjz ihig {:3}; the €::m:fi £ macié tine feiietzsingz OWL, "V €:§R§?ER Thfi State is in mvision against tbs aizéfizr iiaiéiszi 4.V?;~{},29{}8 in Crime: 'f%<3,2?3/88 gimzfiflg fizfefim cz:5s%z:>{¥.j,»* sf 3. gig E:1{§ica.i§eari:3.g Regn€%€§.E{A»3?/Pw§«25'73z S '' . V' 3 T116 matter is iistmi fer aiimésgéarg; M 'Q ,4 respenderm 2" Tha relevant facis 'Fm: respenziant méwad a:;*.*s."é§:>§,w}§£:?;é§'::£«;3:: :::1<:i.£éz"'s::<:§';Q:3; 45'? €3r'P.€i, §3€f#§r€A..§}.:e §?§'§;Vz*i,*?-:i'i,c:f:i<>2f1a3:_ fiagisfiaie Sfiéiiiing §'iT'"§a'.3.aSEf oi' '?zfi.a. Emsiica,«1*«;§::;%,€:t3:'§;?:$ <§'2,':;'é1'::g %QV€st§g:§'{3L:;3g: miaiifig "$9 <t*<)::;::3i_s§$i<)"2: 4?;-:9? ":}fi§":.§1gt<~:':; Vgianisisafiie u3':.ei§%1" éizéi §}}"0¥§§3i0§}E3'» 0f ?r}_;,_ 49%} 'a:::%";*5§ {sf 'éfiiéi L56 Pzwisatiégriz Act E§'?"i-"$5 in §L;e§3§t::1Ij"i" }:§L'§;AV{%E:-aim, he %"§$€3I';Y_"€{§ mat 13% W33 €iz_§}§=' z;*.@§3$ié?;.1::%:3{§ afiaiiiay $2" .:f;s:ig:z':1a§ €}§%2'Z}€§ §~ZaIi:;3i2C3::a;E2:§ra ?:*a$ad,' "'§7Ir§té«:_Si.a{e afipegad 'ska aggyéicaiégnfi but 32:: jufiaééfiiéanai . L'§%»§A3a§f::*;::'-,-.7:§a'i::% zmiéarémg €335 faci Ehai Em": azeizécéé: was gsrizsii fmm hig ' §3{;;$:<;€$§3L:3z§ smii my {cs}:-22$: 3%}§gc?iQn$ 'w<%3'% migsai :%}}x.m2:%§§ Ehszi " m3z:}:%i_{:§3i€?S;"€i€}£i. flggzéweé '{3}? ii, {Em Siaéfi is £12 mvisiazz. W {G ' pr";
3» '§'.'§":€~: i$z::.m7a.t:t::%; {2w:::v{::*:1m€.:::i. Pleadiir i3:;*3:1.1{§'"-i%§3:e;€i:§:;é;i, éhai the irizzi <::3u§"T S~3if:i',i€;>U.31}~" rsrreé g:*anti;7ég'"{t1is:i.éé;i§;"::2f ihé".
v<:f%1.i{r.1:: is the 1:°c:sp<;>:1z:¥c:11i. Wha Wa;-is Q:1§j;..--'a §€i1'EI%.il '}:}C:%?g'<:iY§_:3f attornfifg Eifiiiififl' .53: $136 0Wn€r.'TH.{~; ;~:.z2'i%é:,;:ei€.$ §§12;~.Jf: _§"::; §".§"..'if; é%1"§T§S{Ei1£l?EiV * {Elf afiy zapggiicatiegz {mm the :"€gi§i::';:.;5§:<Eu <:)W:ié:;: €31:-2 ff§(§%}€ES?T w:~.z;s~:
u11tefiabE€:, 4: The g;"m.1z1iisH_ ;i:'g§=;:.iv V__z";{;:$--i:=.;1ie;'€:'i;::4:§ariEy £33}, I': is nciécad that xx:%1:5é1%§ t}7i;e."i}€I"§i::§é'--5§%:::*.iéiée ::;fi":§.2f:<:m.~; fizdicaiagé, that §::w5sé%E§g;aii{;:: {§1=fE';cé1'._E:..3s fi:'.>":i' ressrtsd 3:; ;'>rm*i3i::s:;;$ cf fiegizfifi =.:f>T§"aR§'i1d'}7;;_fg:: ~;'Bf;~;;{%:£:i§£::§;";f%.<%§, whiah. emgégagfzg éhaic "{1} E'€§i§a?i_.f£i:v:4ia:;§ii:;g '2--'§.?E*§V:;ETf:';..3;§2.g {:x:;::.%.:a:'§;s:§§ ii} £3135; Ezwg fey: s':3*:x_e time:-. §::u€:i':ig ii: £b:*<:'€§ the iéireéétsr or 53.21}? {:a'£:.§'2.@:* e:»I§j'§':{:€:"' $mi:§;a:i§3-::;§___E:2y him in {big Efiéaizaff GE' %:.§::£: ifizisf ' K35' iiéiifiifié ..§s?31*Ci€:n or the smizhoriséii <)f¥°i<:=iz:* 3:' 31;}?
"§L'Té{3§¢i€T;€:"€}§§i£?:f;i"_' :13: bsiev: '€h:T:' :r~a1r:k sf 2: $1:'9--i.zmpe::t'{.::sr;. VV }fm1'v§*;a;r3 reafimaabie groumiis i%:3:° §;€::§1*ev;i:':g iézai ~. §§:{}}?' §€zf§<,~:";§};;has Cfliélfiliifififi gm {>fi1i<:r: zigai§;.;s;I £2123 5&2; réqaaixfi $315; Si.i{'.'§'E: ;:a*e1'°:§9:a £9 §}I'QCi%§.C€f fr}: " " isgspecziazx any captive a.1:';.ix:1ai} wiiii afiimai, azximai fifiiififig {mafia §?.'{}§§§1}C', 'a:::cu:*&{£ 'i;"£"{}§}E"i}*'} ggfificifiefi giant GE' pm? 0:" €i€If'"§'¥é'a,iii?'EE tiiiemesf; 23:: 2&3 <?':?;s:':3:§'e3§;, €1'?LE3'iG{i}-' 9:" gasgafisiang G3' 313:; Eifiéiiififiig §3'*€:i"B}ii or Gififif deczumeni gmfitfitti is him {:3}: rsquimfi :9 ha k:*:;:si '£33; hm: zmésr €533 p:'§>%;i$i{;z:s of this sic:
{is} SE0}; $13; vghicis <22" aziifiasji in ::sr:i:*;:* 22:; cggziséznzci samrch :33' :'_nq:,:iry :23: ~::§3:?;€:£' 1ia§.m:1 anti s::a2,:*<:~i': WV
6. «.
%§&n"~:'%s:};:~":.{_.' 4 a11:»; premises} Eand, vehicle Q1' vésgfiikiiz. ' 0«::<::'L1pzzt:ie:;:1 017 512031 ;><3rs-20:1,, and c:}_§L_e:if saarch erzgjzy baggage €31' =:3th:t:* ihizzggi' E:=._h§.:?sA p'33SSEéS$iO11." ' The Ez1v€$"iigai:i<;:a {"}fi:*:a::" §§§iS::__§1§§... {:'i'_3"i't:€:i€¥-:i, ":~;%_:;32%::i:: =::.--:fs ;i§€I{1){b) of Wfid Life {§:'I'é3'i€£f°"€iOIf1::.'.g5x(,?E,, §:§§if 7nagT,»a§;:%;~;:a:{:¢;: uzzéer C1:P.C, as fi§*'i{1€I§€3€fi §a~{:fii*§.}:6 seizxfirt «_Vi*€'piorf?§s::§3Vmi{,%:::€£ ms 453? {:;~.?.<;; Ef feif'¢;;::}ss:;~§.% ufldw: €:r.P,a ma §111'iS§iC§iO31a} Beziagistzaia Fziéag §:"°Q§3€r:jg as snvisagaé 11} S §r§Eg..::§f ihé: €f}:3:f};:~é} '§§"'i E§;§V§:'1if§"_€2.}:;'::5s€ af fhaii pfm»-'€i'§, {Em jizzifiéicfgwnai"M§5:gé$Eif:;:1t"::*.§Ea$ iéiiéirtn 3 {§<=:c.ési0:': £01" §"}I'fiS€;E'Va'{}:(3§}. {:5 figs yrsyaziyr 8_1'3€;§ '§'s:*:}$_.%.€£'~§.$";3s%{=c:*s$2az§? $0 givs its C't1i:§?%-".>z'.:.3I' "is; me ay;:é§is:* a:;'i;., A Vczstxémztiazz 0f the ?:'§%:&t€ '£113? 33:: fits: E2§I3S{3§;l{?{i as? E§§'§?1}5§f:.;;:£3£.{i3:)2'{".f;~(:%fi§;"i:6giS§€".§'2.u'i Qwzzer {ha '§,r5€f}1§C§€ trmiitfi 119?. have gs: '. not ianabie bszitausrr, flit: §:3v€s€3lg3€;i<>:1 Qfiicfiz' :?*;£3,n§; &3f %',e::a;é=, ma: Séffii any ragéert givizsig detaiis 0%' 'éihfi aswnsr <3? , i'L§};j€V'¥f-'S';§:'§{3§§i a.n:3 aim abmié 31:3 céaém. E?nd@1zhta{§§;;g {ham is an % ':i.T;§_%z.::;§ etiaim §"}€f{}1"'€ the ézzsiicéaé fviagistrateg 'E'h§: affiaségzi wag {>::2i3: ~ Vfmm figs E'"€S§0'i}€'.§€'Z}"£3 'z«%?§"ifi :25 Sfifiiqimg i,'E2S€€}{§}? far ami {>21 hshaéf 2:}? $315 mgifiézfi 9921123? erm €315: %;a:»1si$ £3?" fifizlézmé §~':3'w:::* af A§L{€}i'11£:}>' in 3:33 favmzr émfi zadsmz mam is my fLfif§'a?§_§i%'§{","i' " '7'<fi:;§-;, V€§."§;}:C§f;' was Séiizeiri from his §§{§$Sé:ss§_s:;:2.,_ E21 éfiéé'{.f1§T'{.'.E'ifi§v?§f;3EI}.€.ZiiE§;V' the (3~§'dfii}f impiigxsad stafiésrs from §1{}:"~§€g2.§§'iE"if€ji'§';{?Tii§.'§j:* £3: {;f}'a--§z%;a;~:;5;€ <:23§.ii::a,g far ;i§i€§i"f§fI'€13.€€. T7:1£:::té._f:::j€:, the. p::i:i§T:i:;é:_'3.' §";~:"§E.$;V Wa::5:<:§ timid ' Samt: is :"{:3'e{:%.§:a:i.
JUDGE Su%*