Ananda Pai vs State Of Karnataka on 13 September, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 3]

Karnataka High Court

Ananda Pai vs State Of Karnataka on 13 September, 2011

Bench: V.Jagannathan

E3? 'E_"'P§}§i'; Eﬁifg-§€§ {Z€}?;E§{"E_' {E}? _E§J%_E{:_"£f':'§_'5%E{:'§_ Ki.' E'§;'§_E\§{E_£aL{§_R_E5Z E..}a;:.'i?"e::§ éihsé 3.3"? (E21,? $5 EB€;::s%:<:%:':<":':3e;2:* 2%} E :E§E:"i§?<}>E?;EZ:

E¢§{)E\E"BLE<i E14 Rd E} S'§."'ECE1 : ¥'.g}AG3%NNA'E7E-EAN CRUv'E§§'xEz§L AEBPEEAL N{}. 8263 / 2365 8El'E"V\? E15333 :

Ammda §3';s.L S,/'G I'~é§a§*e2.}-»'3;§';2?: E5'21§..; E';g;.§s;%<3; E}:'E)€}"1«,§'§?7'§3 jgm-'»:.r$; E5*':fi:;_p:'§§%%;,<;>§: 'EE21g§%12:[email protected]{ir2:: Riéfﬁf "3":'a~iEii'§-N.' " REiE§§§é?_§§Tc'i§}EiH§€'., E{<}1.:£§':;s:j "sf:E}Va3;§;{é.';

Kz:_::*'§§21i2:_'_F;a;EuE<;. " ' V. "

V V _ H _ ,.«Apps3i'§22;n§:

( By.' §r?f=if i vS&17§§:E§x;I:?§;§.§é_4§14$?§¢f:§.%§7$'2:'§{§_¥{>{:2i"£t3, E AN :7}: A M % j M "

S§'.EiE",€ {}'§'E{e1z";:-;ii_.,a§§éi*; » _ rszpt, b;:_.Sif:u?,é' P::_;_b_1§at--._E':iQseé::«:.t:_i:Qr :5 HighCataff.'V}*§'sV%.:ii§€§V§:ig:gs§;'§t§21:<z;g;a§{}z":x V " . ' ' ..}"{e$§3€md{::1i' Redietifgg E%.€,1{}§?i E {:35:";";i:1a.1_";%.g}_';";§:aE :E";Z.E@c.:% un::"i§-tr' 4§€3E{ZE§{§E73 iﬁ?-$2} GE "£:h_e: '{?z?.§'x{:-;:§;§;i_f§::;::=;§, '§1}'£E:':_§L§{'i§§§E3€1'i'E :i2:':;<:s:;% ééiiiiiéiiéé p22..§%§<-xi by .€ii§<.*:£: 'T'Ss=:»%Lsg.~«,V§v':e;:a:";:A'$»:X-§§}&:t<:ie1i ;Ez.;{ig;<»x Eiriupé _E.>%.$§,§.°:{':'§; Szizzgi, 3:"; Spﬁ. '1'T\E.>. i*"§2;'2€}{}2t, <t{;:":v§{:i':§::;§;:f iE"2;€: ;12.§}§}e§§a:1i:,~ 2i<:<i'z:~.%s:::§ Em" 'she ::sf§'<,-"émw: g},s'é,z;'sa; :2 <2? '§I§§{;'. EKC. ;»":<'%'::9 $88 .. A;::';<:§ $§::";_E..€:':':§%E:'§§.i§ E2332 ':5; z.::';:£s::°g§<} SE: L532' {}§.'E€;'i ya'-=33: zmd 'iii: °.§}é:;};*' §'i::@ G? E€;s:sw:'§,{I%G€};'-- ii)" iii} z.z:1<§i>:;1_:g<> SE, fag" €;§:::::: _..:n:>:'3":,3:E. 13;. '§'E3%:: §€;T*2:E.§'E'E€;":{§ i:r°§:;?1E ji.Ed§.§i;L 2.-ﬁietgf é'ip§;§!'t?§Tf§E'1'§iE'1.§3; t:_E*1<:: {-rvi£§{:m':£? 0;': r&%a:z}r(§§ %:<:3<:';§<;. ?E':§>. vima? tiiézzzéi. E':é1€t pm": " had pr@w;=,{§ its»; £72236: be:~,f'<>m;E 21$ :"€2':§<i::'12.:Is3E€% {E{§'11:'E:s'£«' ;f?.'.h~:-E §:v1?de1'1<:<;% of ?~*.W"¢9 {I(}E11§}§3§§1.&E1E. was-3 §"<>z;:2ai..E':i2-3'«;c~_ ':;~::*:€%m..b " {f':(';=:'£'Ob=:}2':;1Ei€f€§; by ihzs: {:';.~"i::3;e31{':s;r " ?§"s3.'v'é~3._§' 'av§§ii $. 'E'_h::%1:'e£"(::;fe? {3<}E"i'\2'i€IJ{Z§{}'Ii and $:§§i:;:§:':::e€0§1<;Wé«;§\

5. A-Saaiﬁing $29' ._jE::«.€igr.i:€:ij§ L" ~{:»_E V ':::{mvi(7§i{}z1, §€:ar:":€{i <:<>u:2s=se§ Shri S,Vishx&?a§.i{_;§':I§;éi.'{.;§z E25?f3:h;{§--appe1Ez1:1i. aygued H1211; i:h_s3 :::;'.i2:1 §";'Q1;':ft".<:3igfiV :'1{)7i,A._ gﬁréjpazfrly e;pp2"t>.<:iat:e:% the f.r'tVidf3I1(i€ ~{}I'i ~1'f€f:(7€}TCi*. f§3€F:€§ii1Sff?,:§ there are SC} many i'11i'i3m}?;it:i::ss "«r;:}i*::,s.:fs:':t:é1;>.'£,§.<3z"; ease :'ende:"é11g {he pr<)s:;€:{t:1'%;3<>I1 case: €§(§m.E3€.--§}a1§.

fiE1*.s§"?ﬁ." «§I§f}iE"v:ni{:y p<)En%.<-3:d 9235:, is %:.}12:§; in E;,E';€3 ' .{€<§;z1pi:~.:in%;.'~EX;--?--125 §'.§"i€§"€f is :30 Emémizérz of %;:he p§"'€s3s:§3<:e of ijéie ﬁyti'j_:a?§{:'ri<;:sss;€5s Em' i".E'EE? .inz;é'i{§£:é:'1i: 1,-*é;::H E"}.V%5E§,§ emd 2, '_E'}":9: :<;:~:@<?:'.ei:en:;% €E€'§%e:{t"£. :3 i;}}£i?i; z;:m-2 {',i'{}§'§'§}}§2?:§f31i 'iisaa ::}!'pma:*ri.%é:t::%3':

;m§:f%_« {§€::::~fg;}%i{: :E':2.%.E;_ $15: ::':2;m":<:f:$ 0? ?.§?"£'$.§ zmgé 2 23°51»: 228%,. f€}§§4h{f{3ﬁ:i:'§g§ ii': éizfizé <:<}:r::a;3'Ea§:f:"£i, 'ﬂit? §§:°«:}$<-;:<'.'a;,:é'.i{>:': sﬂsge e:§§s:§ :19': EE1'§§"§€if €:%'.'z.€: §}€'E'f'E.'f~S€.}'E'L v:.E1{> §:'j§;g3€<§ E" iif{i§E"E";§}§&:iiE"i'§,= '...£'\ '?. N<5§<;i:E§,r ii ;<30in€e.{i <':rui1 :"E?:a:£'. i:E':{7é ::?'v.§:%@§.':{.?:=: <2? ?3Q'J.§% <:§:<}:":;2pE22ET:':;-m"{: i'2:»3.s:; :'1{i>*i: bé3<;'iE"i <'%<>;"re:;2%3<a:°aE'.iii? E:;«}__: §3,W.:§.'E,_.é2::j2{.i 2 §:1:~.t:sz"s"n,.:c%%1 as. a<:<7:{}1"di2i1§g :0 1:15:23 vs::rs5i«:3z'1 ;_;§v;%j:'i"'"i:<§;_~ ahe £1{f€7:'Li:'E§£';d <>;{fe:re€} tha': 211mm.2_if11:.. gf Eérzis: }L','€3*C}:?§fj.'a_;"?" i:Ei:é {.7{)E"£1§3§Z1§I'1a;I'ﬂ1 and the <é<)mp§2:i:'; 2i'i;1i;§ ii«;i§'éA;é1* éﬁiiirzg §':EV":é§"--::.<V'§i;é:' amci eifter {:::31,:§:{{:£§1§.§" iihtﬁ». :'.E{§V€-6%? ggi}? _ E'V;§i1e"~.__V'{j:im1'p.121in.'§V é3,r;;)<:a*arii:t'e§1.§ wh€:rea.s;_.,..?.\/Vs;§,..§..VVV;gi§¢%_<:i"--f£f'.<:i.§' ::1':>€.AAs;f>:;%21k sf ihe-2 itaymplaizlarrxti E1a1vi:1g ' .«;}';r':1:g32:z:1*E, {mm the a,c:€u.:-:6-.51 a;1";a£:1., v;{;:V€}:a*';;*."«;<E§§§:rs:>:721i::iczrz bﬁitween P.Ws. 1 anti 9;;}.:-"; the zjfzther.

8. _'§7h.€:_ih~:§§ﬁ$\:%::'<:j::eiE<;?§ Ai:':'--2f;:m_pi:°0se{:uii0n C8.-S56 ﬁ;h3.'£: is :'€;:f€:r::€:':§:i ﬁt» §:{>1::1s;£%'E. ii}? {E33 appisﬁam, :3 t§':21i; it _: 1<>.€. iihe :%vid<3z1a:€ as E10 WE': ere the:

£t§:}':::}p§:2j;i_':":tVj% v«;z2:é"":*:::>.:'.t.a?i§v€:é;§t A{f{'.'i{}f{§§X"E§§; is ixha €:<>:z1pEa_iz1a:";E,5 %§1ég:. _ :;?;{}:":*:§::v§;j:;.i:?1E: W331: '{',§;p€:{E in Eb. <>f§§<?se :~m<:i i,E1<--§ §::0'%:':'p'§aE:}::':':€:5; aitszampzméésfé 23y £1319 a_<:<::z.:$e§E a:<1<:§ PfWS.E ami ésﬁaémz 'E5 'the g§<';%é§::€: ss:a£,i{33.": 2:::3.{1 §:?§§:'r@. if%2§1=. €,*:2z.<fs€: wa$ .2j'zv_;é§_.-,_,§"§";f=;§:%:%;*"{;%::i, 2¥Ei:%:*:3g2:es5 :?:ha>: vi-?,:;""s;i<>:2 £3? §3ﬁJ%?'é§;, "E e.mr:i $2 is i,§1ai.._, '§.}';<:: §3<}3:"<;r:e% 'i5J§;:'.i'€', E'Eé%,E':"§'1§"I'Z{}§1{?{§ mu iihéé <é§f1?<.':<: 2:3? ﬁhe {'*{.>::'2'}.}':é'§;::§313;;22.2, magi. %:E'::::.>:2*i:. f;;§"2:;': <::'::tz'§§:r§2?2é":?':'?: :21-"2=;:::<; g.-§é'w;fi':'; Eiﬁiiféfiiggg wiith aisﬁzsés' £%<)§:z,:Im-.*;:1é',:é: zméi §}.'f:?'é-:;,§ gems? 2 éiiti me? é1i€§i'3€.)E}'1pE1.E1}' '§',§'.£.ﬁ"f {tomp§;21§::2.a_§;"_aE: to 'iéie §::<,>i1§.<.t<:: s:=';ﬁ;4aE'é<,>1'L ---_,_ 9: i% is f'.hem 21r§§;:.:€:{.£ by {ha §<;éame:*r<i <;:<}z.1;I1.s3_g§, f?<;;>§'j; €f;E:1§3. .21pp<;%1Eza1>:1%'. tE2.ai. i:.h{=.r€-3 Was; :15: o<é<:;1ss§,c)n E'<>:5 7t".E'3"cé';;«:t§E'zs_f§3$€E=-taV' fiat}? bribe sf Z368/-- £15.} {,§".%f;'% c€i:n:§}'iTs1i11e2Tf2i:"E:cé*.e;,1:~$':%.1 'r':;%;><)7:"'iis5 of éihe {:<>r1c::<:%':"m:cE i;{_§:":'L::iV;1fE$ iizzgi '%};;$<~:-:3 by V {Em 'E'z::has§E«:ia:* on 33.1230} 3'§.s<3Ejf_21n£i"é;§3§:£ sairicﬁ i"€p{}E"§l-Si

3.-*e:%:i:?.§"3 have béiffié ma§f§{t"%.d 3% EZ;XS'.--Pj~V<§':1n<% PMS gglivéa .21 {2§€&1IE ithéi; to tha 2::::c1.:s<-id' !.'E§:,a%;*é'f%:j1"c_%-,. ' 'iiiiesstiagi of the ac€::us3<3::§ 21t,te::_:j3t_ingg fto <:{)m;31a1inaz":'i; {E068 no?

ariéw. E';/i§}:fé;:3v&:%:_ V, .5m> ':p_ér$<}r1._.--L2{j§z, §\f§§{ihE:1€31 §}'rS0u:2:a, had beiari _ £'<71é,§i;g_<V£ 'Eat-T.' viiiage Rzmgaiazipaﬁkﬁ and. :[Ei§§*_2.Vé:?*é;:f::>.§:§f¢;:§ 'she {f€,}.E1'3p§€:1iH'§. eigaizasi the é:,z.j%{7:i:;;?fs<5i{% '?;rf§§:}T::_.: ?§§é::§s:": ss1.z'ff§<:§e§":'z.Ey s3%s:;i'.abE§She{§, Eiréiiez" §fI":§S'E," <§i_';'::a:IzA§:n»:3§§é'g%:";_{::€:s-5, Eﬁfhst E'::'i2'2;l <::<}m'E: {tzmﬁci ggmfii E":e1vf;-V :f:<3;1xr'§::1i,c=€E'w 7'E.h<§- 2{§3§)eEE21z'1§. W21em ?:E:.<-3 ;§§"€-zaegzaitéz 5}?

2 §'§v1 '€';L:}'€;':V z::}":.23§:'1bez° <;:f iihe {E<)§"1'1§}§.€iiI"i;'i§":§ £3 zmi:

' VéS':,.2i§:;Ei_$§%$'£i E3;{_~':;r::s::{§ £"éif&iS{}§E£1§i}§é'f e:i:>uhi.: '§"§":$z°€:f{>':"i:, EEES.

" ~';é.é';é-;.§i;:":f:'i,::%*ij;___:>§":;'§_'3:V;7,§'; {2{}Eﬁ{§ 230:: ET:a¥:e.'§3§%§:§1 2i{.T{?{:"f§}'E',€{;§ E3}: éihtf §%;'f'é,'£«.§_°§'"i<';f§f§ '::£_fii;éE ":7 1,: :13 § ;§€n u a ii}. .A.:'.::)i.§'1»:%z' §;1'*<.';z':§1<_"E §T}'EEE'. E:?<.}w;2:r=::§ E:}§? 'ih §é;%2>g"3'::<%d {:<}':::'1$€&E 3%)? %:.i'1<:: appeE12:§:':. is; 3221:, it is §.§"3{': (,',2:"1-»'f;~':{'.i {,}"§'".'£1316:

2.::?<::::z::;<3<:% €.Emi: he? wzms .';?i.'_~i-'.»§:.{?{§ U} giw.-E §€},G{}j:'1r;;'~'-..' 3::h.§r §'~l.S.€. bui: the;-t aé;:<:us;~se:d a':21y' gax-*6: afmd ' waaé; F0? "E1318: semi; p:::_:*p{}s:-ge Eh;-it ::,§;I*:::.1..21{:EZ.:1.£séd §1;:{}V"a:§f'§"e.:f%?d 14%;. E ESQ/' -- "E10 Elhéf mmpie}_§.:"_;;:_':I1€:,_ "§'h<:%_s5 £221;:'1d ii'fa:§s:'é:::2~ 2&3: i:h<:. V 21C:a:;:use{§ in his 313 :.éA'5.§$'Vi":3_ §§{)%§",,':'§;'$139..{:§}§TEﬁY§'§1 the E'if0E"€SZ:iid {i€;%fem?r€ of ﬁaasse :'e21s<m.9 331:3; aisso 1T€;'g.yi.t§;§§'--.{}§'1 in AIR E9274 SC 228, '3;9%V<f:w:«1';'~:_;g::5;_ .g__3;:~a5;~;;:§¢§A:R }.993 SC 14693 ihe K°%f;1i"§'1§:d'"'§;E;%%Q.¢f%!2S:;€§f¢.j "f<>':' . Vi:V§V§(éﬁ 'éiﬁaééﬂazlt. argzzeci Eihgzii EEK: app€:i:1?:1:§: £55; :';.":;{'3'. aCq:;:1?'i:.::<?:<:£ ané hemtte, the §u€E;,§_m€':1€f"£:»f iihé: %L;i<3t.1--:*% b'?e§:>v; be S;-§€:".§', a_$id<=3. " E s£§.:1w»M.§E";§:: {)€:'E'1%'1<:a:" E:aa:1<.i the Siibiﬁiﬁﬁifjﬁi <3? iezzrned '{§§~é:>%:':2':f.:";:&i;;::=*:%':§:._Efkmiiag" Shyi {}¢§%JE.'t;?r€:€;I1.iV'z:ssz1 Eéaédéy fm' the S:.;:éi.<:% %§;§:;::§ ';.%:sé §3:°'<:3$e<:'a,:t.§<}:1 hazi b;;"{:2%;,:gh§'. Emmi-2 ilhéf g§a:§E%;€f»si§_'*::E:€ E';?;{Ti£i'i,§§§€;%d bi?f;Z€)E}€§ azié :"€a5:e<}::a§}§§: éiaubii. ;21':e:§ {E26 €i%'é{3i'§iiZf1{if€:% <2? R\?'si£?§ <:<:>:3":;:2§a§:z'::e::1é, E3 Eé§E,§§}§}{}'E°'EIéE{§ '$3? that': _..m;?:§'2.;1;e:;2:::" EL:::.E3'--§§ :»m{E m<;>:":%{.m':%:§*. 'i':E'::::-2 '.E'T.:;:3%22?§sss§§{ia:* §12:.<:% as éiéiiif §;;f}'i.§'§{f§ a:.ggj;::.§z':§a§. ifiiﬁ :;:e:%<::,:§54;:3:{:E_ :z'z{'}::" aha:-.1"{: 21:13; 4' ,v_;:2e:%:§*s'e€::': by :':;2§:*z2@ E_i!§.§~::h.2::%;%i3 §.}Z':'S<:a2;.3;3:2:: §°:;t+:.;§d§:'3;§§ 22;: v'@s=;%'é%<§ §:2'i:<==%.:'&?=:~.;€: ':0 i.2::E«:..§-== r§%v&:':ge ;::.g;1§3.':$€.. '£:h£- 2':-2::r<'*:m§€rd. Tkzéia p:'é:t65e:3<:e: :11? §5i"€ii":&,;,} 5m":{§ 2 in §§i€i? <é§':2§§:1E}e:' '€'E'1€?: {:?<>m;'}§z?;.i:T121:ziT: hag b€:é::i'"z s'-*:§;é'.e2b%§§s§'u:*::::£ 3.225% €.h<f- " :{V:fV'i§1;ii;j§'€ff:VE'Li(f?:»=' 3'E{}'iI£fS wéjre :+se§:c<3{§ in ?i,Ir"2<-'2 §}:'€:'S€f§'E:i',€? 0? Pﬁsﬁiﬁ. .S§i.;{V:f§"%"; {.Eéfe j'E.§.€1g§'1"1'2€EIﬁ. sf 'iizszé mlai. <it<)*a.':.:*'£: ciigtzéss :Tf:<;'§:V ':~i_»:_2;:§i1e=;2i_V £'".z"§;:=:3€°;::2'}: iii:§:'§.1f§.:1.i*£:j; 5554:} 23.5% to wa1f1i"a.:':i. in€:,e:*'f€::'::*:§?:€'E:i by t§{".zf_i;;~3 :{%'<:+{:r€,1;. E2" Having iihzzs i'1V¢a§:d 'i)_r_xf.}§i».s'tc1€55, i.E":e._AA?£3§§f3m; {:6 be {E(}I1i%§id€3I'€*€} is wha=.'€he31f--- §2f;_ }.{iv21:i"» :1;'s<§ ,;<,-;.21§<i 1:ha*a':; '{1h€% pr0ss<3<:'uii0:'1_ h4E;i:5: .b1*0§;ig§h't '1*:1£}§':1€jj--i.'§";<:V' ;,§;,1:7§£: of the 2i{1(T::,1-;*%€'{i "bag-Iond 211}. ':*<%'as :*:2'%__§')i£:«.:gi£}Vi133t.;'7' ' séaémpiézinariéi is =$'a..i<i.._i€:..,» 21 <:<}1:npEa§§1§ ;;§§v~9:11 by e:>n€ lviicifzaei ET¥'S<25I..:;::i;':'v--_ ihaéi Elhéi &'i,p§3€fﬁEi§":i' had bean £:1viiij%Eg{_§;r;g;m.iA:': %1?égai"'$€<:>'::€ qz:2ir:fyi.::2g. '"E"i2e §:v§e:§:":::<:<3 {YE Egg {.9 Eiha a%ffé%<:€, i'.i1a€:_s aiiaz' *«;Es;i'{4§:";gg; E:E";_:;~*: p12}_{:<;"~: pA:.3;;1<:~:~«z§21:éE:.'gs;232.5: €i§'re;=::':'.2k;:::'2 §§.§vé:%:1 $3}; "éiiléé 'E'.2?:E:2:ssii€i2"s_:1 ?;.hiE% i"€§}€}E:'{.vf%_ 3v«:<3:§"€ s_»;;.:':3:r::§E,E,e3£"§ 213; g):::2:' Ej2xs%s»§}M4 Ex; amsi éihﬁ " §;ms.:; ;§é3{::",i<>:': 2'€\f:2%2-zieé ihabi. nit: {.:<>§::p§e:z§m, w':c:2;§ Egiiggéeti by EEEE}? .L. §4i;=;z:g;"2;_§':a§};:E1§a5. 3:': §;2a{:':g. ¥iE%:z;?: :3»-'i<%:,:::t::> 3%" €E'":é:$€:é '§"E3::'* am,-'§{'i<:::3;<.te if E3',"'é£'=f,§$ £319 §%{.>mpE;.:i:22;z:1§; iss; éi:E';2:i; Elm z.2.<ir:i::.:s-geii <:ff::%:*<=t<i Rs" i .{}€}{};"-- EES Eririiﬁe 2mr;?;___ ?'.§'1€ <7<:}mp.Ea.§m;:£'1.'£: :"'::?E'1,::'3é-;t~d E10 2';2£?{:€:p§': é.E'.2:? ;'?§E3;.E'}'1§;Tf 2:21;?'s;f?:§*$§s§2:§%;é?%:: 'i§'h.€ c<'>z"§1pEa.:1:":21mi :'<-:%<%<3§<J€{i ihéé €E'"§%;='€:';E{}§;) a1:'3c:'17.g}:'1f{:E.':e t,h{>: €;'.}i}'v'€;3§{)}§. he f01,;};3:i i:<;:k: i*1s.<«>1:;€;~s .;:>f " «.§-?§3V.'i:i3O;L ark: V' « dem}.m.E§"::-ii::03"; and 'i:he:'<321E't{'€::.' E123 g3;ti>1" §;%:&? <'%cﬁ:5;%s.;'}Ev':1.E:'1i':°'::y;3s:d" *' in his <}ffic€r as pear E:<,?--1iZ.

£8. The preaerace (if .%_i{'A\.?Ef--.s=;» :;i,:*i'éi1VL['vi2;3"*»%:21ss ssp<)§<.i»:n ii«::) by the camp1a§.:1a.';1tg jig: :§f;';;':é§'@i;%'i(it3,:3,é;:§é, '§?:J'h€é:"'e22s {he evidiarzzta of I_3.W.1_.-wR.;:;n§§ha_1z1:i:}:e1dcgrséiﬁ not i11diC21%;:e 'tfhat the cazngzxia§.113;%';i;_EEC§:_E*j%Je,~::i "é:.h_é=: é_§'3__V§§;§{§p and i:h.e:m cihazikeéi ths ;1r:2<)1i3r1*L,'--E3xa;a€.,V' a&e:;7._Qi"C1iii';gg;"i~ii?§--Jv'. L the 'l"ahas1iidar did mm: :1-:.<%e§ve ':E:.z_: é:.'r1vé::}§,_0'§::._Eéaégi"did '§}_":<;é 'I'aZE2a1se;iE{ia1r i:ri<3{.E ta find <}2:£5g.z:;%:e ':{; "a,%;'i*::i?;,«.i_g__¢?;he:*e in ﬁlm é:v::'w<2:2r:>§3D Séiiﬁé? iés the ' ﬁ%2'.;s:i:3Ta'vf:._;i§-;=:M {sf 'Ei~"...';J§ﬂ2 E*?;2:_m_2z<éh21§1cir2: wirxai: ;a;I.ss;{> :'§a.y$ éiéigsi, §:h€ r§'21§'"§é£Si§{i'£i.f;: {Ed :::::sE;. Z"€f{'.€i'J€' the em»-'€.t1.<3p Eli}? ':..%':€-3 E-}_f§":{}1.Eﬁ'E, 'E'h::::=~",r-=6 éiijxa ;}§'€£sé3:":<:€: G? P,W$=E ;:I1{%; 2 §"€;'fE"1{§é5:§"€-ii {£0u§b1ifa.:E f§<i;§§:'_% {Em a§<>:°<3$2:§{i 93-*§{£&"::'1{::a>. an §*::t<é<>r:L if '§3,'i5Js~:" i. arzii 2 "£5.-'ﬁ':f€'3 §)§"€;':Si%§'3'ii w%1.€::.:2 'aiize f:i{:Cf?.§5f§€?{,'2 {:sf§é3:':::€.§ E ESE}; V is éiiie: é::<};%":":pE.::i§.%:':;?::":'§:, €239 Sziiﬁ 2s;%§::':5:s$s:%$ *a::{3a.1h:§ ::<':»'€: E'":;2§:.-1% {j§iﬁ{fE2"€f{§ n ' ¢;;::;t:a . V?

vesiih Hm Sag; ii}? §3.\2'»7.E«E «Cm ihisss :";1aE'.c:"§;2:E é:'if:S§}{?{"fi'., "E'Ew§"«;;':E§';;'6. i.§".1.{: .:-3:.,:§3:1'1§Ss§.£.0:'1 of €.E':9:. §€;¥21E'°ZTié.:f'.{§ c:<3:.:.:§.1s:3@I. for t:h<-2% a;j;a};s3E£::n€'. $2211: 1336:: §3:°<:%s<3<:%m:<3 £3? '§>.\?'»£'ss.E zmzi :2: in 211'}? <*.':'1e;j:.:;tz.'2_'§j;»:'?;*'{:i§ii_§"2§: {TOE"I'§§}§£1i.}'E8;E'?:E'. §$ {i<.>ub§:§"u§ {',21§°f§&'.$ ::*r"1<:::.'1_g:i*1 £:'§}_7_;f<%£-:.. E71 C<>m.i:'1g§ 3:'; Eh:-? mm§3§zii1':t'=.,:i1.s:a;.s::lE}iiiis -.;§::1':*-"<2G';'*: :z"=:;:§;é€;'i: ;:a.% %Zx,P-- 12 a:'1€E if is 22 'a';},-rp@w:*:'%:§,€:=.--z:; {?{)I§Ej}E£1§i'":'i.. ._if am?' 2 *2,»v€re p:*§%sse:1é.: durifgg '5.g»"'§?§'t'.I:":}.V."A§Zi§V)vV:(:f§f a(:c:u5~:~ed had <)'ffe::'e<§ Rs, 3 .-- _ .: :<:<1_2j;{1§}§2,:i':*2aim. the e::@r1'iE31a§n2m€5_ '%?"A3«-:7%.}5i1 tht': ;.<5am.€ in the E8; hé sf Bizéznappa Ji.rm,app:::

E\T{:;\gEa{1'a.:§; ._Q§"lV_§§§§%}"z-~:.a;§.'a§<:(;, :*<-3p<>:"'i.séd in AER £993 SS _ E_4é6'§3, .§_"%€}E<i'$;v. tﬁéifi. "wmire {he c{}r11;31.21_i;1i: 'Wé3.EE~3 21 §A:*£"§'i:[Z€'??'E'A €§'i}s;::;133;:<~éz§fii""prfsipzizwsci bsfme :--§:;:bm:i_§,t,f.11g £0 §'h::;% ' ;i3.§_:.§:'a;i:;:. é:2:1:.<L§ ':':§";£:'E% :20 :§*:s;':'{,%<3;z': {Ef i:E"_:€: §}:'§*.:f%§€'EE{f€'. {if E§i)E"I?;€': p&~::%_s;{3:j_2&;' e}r€»wi§;:':€s~;$<§&s in s§.z<?éh <':0mpia§I}::$ mt: " jg;3:f&:§;<:>.:";<.:%.-°: <72? €.%:<>s;{-'=, ::%}rcé»ax.r§§,:';€ssé;:%§3, 'z:§';a%:*<:':§'"{}§*{x, Ems; ':0 be _{§§;;E';5<;%E.§s:?--v {'~':<§ .

VE§%$ 3:: EE"::%; {:2::'~:~,:é;:: 9%" 2'::st.mc2iE §?;r{:§':.§m. f§{Z§;{"f{§ Vég. S:.5;E<5;, :_*<?:g3<':'§'€.{2{::§. ii": '§~E%?§ {:,,':§.'E4§E$§..J<{,.§'1 _'§33:'Ti §"€?§}7iE'"i§§ ::;}::":. %;E":{3: A§:;:'-92):; {'i<>L::"E' tie'-%<§:Z;<.2is3;<:m in :'1§R 1§§'?4; SC 2E8, £3. hm ':'§:3?{%'z:': §':a€{.% i['.h§:l'{a w§:;.E':<>":.1'z: gm. E:'1{i<;%;;3<:é::'2_{fE2:2: {'%<::*mE:3<)raa.i:Ean§ iiilc-% {,iiES'§,§.i'£'};{f}i'Ti§f' :3? :2: {T?{§I'i"i§}§Eii£'1é?.E'E§'. .s<;§:::>:.2%:i 330:. §}<jm;{f:f>.:'f:'s%;§}:§src{i s:-;uffi<:3;<5z'1'::' E0 fé1§3fE'.€E1 a <:E3£;1:"g;€: at}? E3»:'ib€:ry {if'..§3Q§}§f?'E;£ﬁ€'.?.'}i.--.535 7 §3rib<3:r3J., §%~s§§:><:%<:§z2}i3,-*' Whczri s;L:::ti3 <':{}:*1'£:E><>A;"21*é,§<:>iii' "{.§l:«Z3_FV.3;i'{'V}§%V be §_'}I."{'.§£Zh1{':€fd. :az.:1<§; éhe: <t:{>uré . _v€em: . 03:1'. to 'aSs§c§;?: " '$:%1E.a <tz}:zvi<:i:1ie:)z1 of the a{Tf<?E.ES€£§. _ 203 in iiae: §r1st211if; ' T;7z;1S~:€:,f':'» :3ﬂ«:)':;~ ~Qz7i"§}zf §.§f1<;=.:'s:r R 1'20 <te:)rr0b0ra.i.i0:1..9?-.i.§'1<3§_'evi:d€:;1t;:.¢"<5?..E'."v§?';;Q'Vby PTWS. 1 and 2 in I:1e1i:e1"§§:'1 VV_§T)3;i'*§;4i{;fi}.:a.}f§'v_v {Eton} the fact ihzzt. the p1*s3s@1.:.{Ei:%' ~9f'j;}P,Vi?;5;'--?_ "iz;m;1c§, 2 'ii2,:;':;éiVf ES tigoubéifm. Bu€;,, the g3:*<:~\se:2i%::J;t1a:}:1' ?r;i§iE~3{j.,§i&1.$ 'a?}{}fi. <3:<am.i1'1<:d the person Wm i;y'g)€d '£7£."2é'<. <?:::°=..":1t":p{-?,aizr.2;_=:;"~~i':: tE":e {>ffi<:e of the '§'ah.22s§Ed21r, A gEEi_§ix::?¢::-ggh §'1.i{§'i§"'¢£'VE"{':qU§§'€H1*3I"E?£i itfaai in €':V€Z"'}!' €?E'3;Si'"3.. ililéi "§';s;:f:*:szii*:«._ x¢:?'?'::> "_i.ype£§ éihésr €<}mp§3;i_;1_€, $§'2<>uki 2:Es;;@ be-. e;§z¢;'zmiIj:€{§; in 'abs §:'3sE:z:mE: <':a;<s§: E".:a2-':34: réjggigirii 1:18 ?:;EN:: :':a,?:1.:%'<-3_ '£:}f' §I§'i{;': ea!-'§{§€3::<:?<% sf §3i'i,-'$55.3 ezzmi 2 z-211$ §E§.«S§:° " ';:%r£i$€::";::§:. E}€:§I1§%; §°€:§::ie:'ad {§g;1.2'¥:3E::il:E far {E16 :"s€21${}:1$ _..;:2"§:>z:t§<>§':e<i €:;1'zfI_§&E°, éiae }}£"{}E£€?£iZ,§if.3§€"§;E 5?~;E§<1m§{i Eiaire :i'rx2::mim%:§ %i;§'2@ §:3::%.:*s:eo:2 wE':o E.3;*';:3:::z:%. iihéié {"i<'}E'E'}§;}E2i§1'EE 33:': <_§;*<:§{%:"

iiw: :é<;}:f:":;:ziz1ima.:z:'1"i" §2i.*s:£>; ii: Ehéf <'1<3E':;m:° {)5 {E1 9 a:_é<':z.1ss&%:.i Eézigvérzg"

t.:"i{:?:e:i E15,": {§§f:§E' ':32'§'E:>é3 <>§' § %{}@{},/'--, fk§}2_~:.:'§. §r<'m'1 §.'%irg% sgaiazi ::iefe:?:f:.=:::a=-?., éiiéer <i:%.£'f.{'3£.§S{ffd E':a:~;.; 2:?:§:'§:%<'3 if-3:112-1§,'&?{§ in h'iée;"'-*«é;§;i§§.€;::2'i ex_'pE2m21i:i<:»r1 't.E°*:3.L when Eat: W€?};'2ii zzrigi ;2<t;€%§ 'M ﬂifie <1{}n1p§.e:iI1ar2f. in his <:h2m1be1", :z1&%iiT1?.':€:"«§*,'7§z'i7..E _Ej"'{;*«;;.«§,?-::_;h.:§:'1'tVr.'i:2:*;'.}";:.a?a smjr P.W£2; E?;23.:":1.:';c§1a.I's.{1r.2ia vv;e:f:;% pi'£3S{;i'E'§€4 in i:'Ij'_;é:§":;:v§.'1.E:n2b€£;r €35 §;h<i <f:<;_mp§ai.:321m,. §~§e h;;1é;"'~«.;3§_E':§<3 :s'§£:2%;i::-':{i3Ti.%.: his; wrii'1;',en {;%XpE21:"221'[i=:)1'1 mat"; Vi.§;'i2:~§;g;£>: A'C<:{}'i,:--:'1§4i.:;1§i£1.A Szzreéé-£5: Vﬁgcrhar has'-5 given 5; repe.:;;"'i:_§::2. :f21*s.rQ:_:r _0--i' the..;1{f'éf::Sé:'{i*--£%1 ;:"<»3spe(:%;: {3f the ccmlpiaizzt, ::-3;-::.:i_1ci' ' ba ==;i§iv§3:35b§>'« e:?{r'1é:%' . M; 39} E'}"S::)'u;z;a'

22. CQ1i1$i{ié%1*i:-;:§;V .;<:':*;!"i'm'::_¢vide:1ce in E5; t{;t2:a.Eii4y§ it {:;m1";fai3t ?3_sr3. sé:1i--%fE i:_h2;at ..pr+:>$e:{:L:£:E(121 hag pmv<3d iés ztzise beyendé 21:5: Vr€21$<:1*:'21i;=1é"----:f1é'i:1§3€. as '{.he §.::%:~:«;*»£',§'._r.1.1<;r:":':~,,«-' 0%" P.'\7'».?I9 s;:2f?7€rs%L §:"<>:§:;».,$e;**::"'i'§{}u:~:é:' {ie§e.<_r{:s and; E2;i::k:§ {E{}E."§'€3b£}1"'€ii§{}I1 3:1 " '~ jQE1Ii°Ili{EiﬂEi.§'£§'éiifﬁi Ehzgié; re::r:i£:;'i:";;_; this: ii@s'£.iz;r2<3:§":y <3"? ' .?PE%f.j£é'v.d"'33"f§.{:::i§§é:.is ;;1,<i%a:3g}i:_ as-3 reEiaE>§e¢ 'i'%:<3:r€:'§'c>zr€, ihti {$121.1 *:.?:s:§:«.2ari; ii; ?.%'123@%: ggiveézz 'i'h{-3 %;@2'}:;é.f;?E of :7i@uE*3'i: in 'é:%:<-3 2§<':'{":--2_.§;§se<:'{§ ;:v:':§ 'aéfzsé '§:?z{:<? £2? §::<:§'; ea,-»'§{T%<i:§':<,*.e3 €';E'7§ ;'ea::<_§;*{§= "§'h€ {;%E}s<2i"2-%;:%:E<}:r: <5? iihé': izéaf. {:{":m'i:. magi; 'iihéif e:*ai{i<%z":<.:e 0? PF~ﬁ£I§ ~ §':é§z;%~,:._ %3<é%;t::'§ 2::<::§':"r:§i3:;>:*;21i:é;%::i E3?' §3.Ws=:;:.§ .:'sm<§ :2'; <:=::2:':m}%i; '%:;:3 gm :5 M _ 6

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court