The Commissioner Income Tax vs M/S United Breweries Ltd on 15 October, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 6]

Karnataka High Court

The Commissioner Income Tax vs M/S United Breweries Ltd on 15 October, 2011

Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath

W

R
'§

@£THE%§Q%§€§SR?Iﬁ:Kﬁ§%§T%K§é?§§éN$§L@%§

Bﬁ:"§'"E§ "§"E~%E§ Tééi 15*" mar' Q5: GCFGBEQ. 2a>:;;v:. 'j<«..»_T'~'--_

?RESE§?

mg HQ§\§'3LE $22?" }u§?_§£E_§3:,:<:;:€/§ﬁ;'s2-:'_';V.    

QNS

ma HGF€'%LE rv:m:3$T*:f*:::3f.;E  R;%:£H«s,é§;ﬁ§::{:§§*;:?f;~§'-'V 

?""""€

A. ._$'Ev.2&§§
§E?WEEN: V' " ' 2

3, mg saivmgsimE;fz"€:+¥.j§§»,§<::}:>»%:E-":*A:><"
€kR,BL}EL§f§?~é':"§., _'* 1    
Qi5EEf\§S<.;.9;'€>.ﬂ»€§_,'__--.'_ ~ '
8A§*s3§;%LiQRf£";~_  %

2, WEASSTT.{:i:=:§§-:%;:%;=;i§;§:§§Eéé; "
GE £E'\;.f«{VZi,}i'»/EE--'"FTV.:5;Z>ii.,{j .  " 
£E§"~éTRf?>».;_ '£:g§;<;:aE~».'::=, 

Bg;5\£?':E€Z5,£xLC}FZ.;;ER V ..  .',&@@§§%msx:'€

 f 'V V'  1535?:-S3}; E'§{VL¥;V';3:'E!§§£§§;':VE:é\€VgEg'¥' ;:5@vGC;-;§"E ma
 Srfé'-»?*{f§V,%f.,SES«Ej§,5fs.€:%*§,ﬁx§ﬁ, A§'\.!'GCAE°E}

Mjg§€;s»s:'*2f§§' é%~§1r::§R:E§ 173,;

 44.__"-ﬁsa,'m_;__%::":"i§";:§m §'v'§i'%§_f%"§; magg.
% 5».,§';z.§-.:'{;§,a;:m§:®;E,

mR§SP§%BENT

  {';:::%§;§$§$;a§x?s~m§A§1ﬁ§?s--:§g2;!2:¢ 3;; &$::-:§§§«: ;°a;Eé§ 1
 _3,;«€ ;<;,§*v§,::§§.w§am;-2§~»;;s§m@§ £%§%.i{3€;5*J§"§§}  ,, ~



;:~<2:<a

"E'§"2%§ ETA ﬁg fééeé unéer Sﬁiiiﬁfé 2§G--;% 9;' Eﬁzkcit, .;%,;%:i
gréaérzg safe af wées" dated 2?'«{%2»2$G9 Qa§g.»;»é:§, in
E€"ﬁa,E'~£§,%6=i%,fBa§:g,i:*%§§§ faér Em ﬁageggmeai year ;§T91<_'?.;'e*£E_§'~'.?i_:,

grayéng is fafmuiaie 'aha §:,:§$%anEEa£ aguegtégggg'.{:§$.§.ai;z:{
giataé §§'%%¥"§§?'§§ aiisw im agmai argﬁ get a*sé=f,'§--€:_ §iﬁE£"--..:'%;3<?f'j«i=Ii§€;%'.?:."_ .
gassad 53:' {ha £Tﬁ{§"',, Eaézgaiaré in HA,%'-3§k<i§6i§;{VBa§':>gfL'iéa%§S.T
ﬁaied 2'?»»Q2-ZS{%§ sanférméng §§':S_§f'§€%' :?;'E"'%.'%'zza>;'_~£:§~;:se'§.Ea'i:£ 
C<:zmm§$$é@n€r & ianfirm am §?Q:":fi@*':* '_ ;,--%a$§&.é;"«.§;*y""ihé".
é$$:,€Qr:":m§g5iGnr§§" 3? magma '7.§3}é_;'-..€3é:'T:.%:;r*;3.§£é":"§:Li3«'§f§;

ﬁangaéigreﬁ

?§'E§S$ IT.I1as camimg §':*>.:_ '»;'?@:' §'é':;2a::*§'§2g,%-I '§§f}§§ ﬁﬁy,
:""»i,Er<E.,Eg?'~r"§,»-'fa? En; ééﬁéa/Qiﬁﬁ %;j§'z5 f§E§§:;éJé§:<;.,%:1~V_V_ " 9

   %3;éu;§€s,»m_%?*'% 3&1"? h  
'%'%*:& Rgaggnw; §"":3:s"§':'e'§é?i§,%:';*'e«é>._:?:§V$ «$;:*:'_:§ea§ ahaiéengémg
téée 85°63?  by: __;§ég T:"'rE:E:§u.:';;:EWVhcsiéing that $23
€@:'3":m§:§séar:  §§:*e€:iaz~ af tiée aggaggge

Ca§"r:;sa§':*;z a%§V;3-§:%'a1§§é $§"_ex§e§":é%t:,s:°e amzées ﬁeaiéez": 3:? Q?

a
  M§7§'§§ §§§E§§€§L §v"§;'§§ iénéiea? Braweréeg 23$" ﬁg

_ '::%*ee.;?;I-9: §;*'»;";e "?a§%:";f:;E; :?:§:x

 a";:;-aﬁaééaf,"€f§ém";:;g.ﬁg, gamréng an §%.£SEE3€S%S Ea Eizééan §»€a:ée

§""a:*€:.%_g:*':V_v:;,§:§§,:'§;:%: ?%2§ §S§é§'E§S1€€ ﬁéaﬁ 232% reéurn sf imaging

La} ..

3.~.~.;§;':~§.§§§ é;*§€€E§§'"%§"E§ :%:£:= isigi Erégema sf



%'§§

"._::@%;%:§r:~;;: :32: ?:':§:'% aégrzaiurgs {rm :"§<::£:;:":'":€§"2§$ am as}: baikééi _

§:$,:,32;3éE§,ﬁs§2,?-g ";?"§:a mﬁstum ef §§':£f§E"'é'E%Ei' wag Qrsgﬁggéaf

unﬁsr Seaiiagn :=é;3{i}{a} 3;? the Es:::sme~'Eax 

{§'E€§"€E¥"':a?E§f !"€f€:'"§""E§ {Q as 'the get' §':3E' 

érszémaééan ﬁaiaﬁ 3C's~»éw::§%1 wa$;,§A5$_ased _--:é":'§':»:é%j'aé'€;eSsea: 

Theréafier the assegsmenz wag %._aé<g;'s*sT..:;§'=s.m:§_é§*° "3€:é::i:E"%.";sr_s:

2433; G? mg m by %§5a;%r:7:g <--;=:__ :~;o%:'::::e" siateé" :%.a*:.?4V::.1g9:;%."L»

zmder Seciisa 243(2) 3f 83% ;€x;:_::,°'-:3cg-;.s_Ve$t§?§'rs«-:':g§_:*e féateé 2%-
é~1§92 wag ésgased. "E*?';~é:%"a.SS<a5s:j_{e1{%'€;%s;.}3;";. :'a."3,§r&$€s'3€eﬁ by $133
EEK Cgnguétaniﬁwazéwo §uts"r:§§f%*:é:%._:%i;e§}_e§'u1£"réé éafarmatésny

"ma éésputa4_::x}«E":'§§E'€;: §_s isiiez _§a5_§j€§--i §%ji2*:i§t::i:}'e5"é9'V'@f ihe greceeééngs

is g2.53?a_:}_';ee*~Ljéni:'2j;_§ss%§'s*: L§;;3€;¥i§f._%{.:Q SE"; véjaya Maiiya. He wag
we C§*{:e3_§rmaaVQ§.£:'%2_»é'a_§se:§g-3% iismgany. E-m hag men gaéé
guaéra§::ée_  <;.":::2a'*:":rt:3§:§§.i :;::f§"'-£35' '°5Rs,§3,,%,,:S8@;'v far the 33%;'

a:';é%§f:g_ 3E.,5'f""§'*f§a;r::;*;z._,'.'--1§'%§"§::»g ma aggegaeex Thég ga:a:'a5":':§e

£§:'%r%;:%é§:15ﬁé':;;rf;% ar:;a'§":::s:::.:%§a;eGT mi GE'? %E*:§ geigsﬁai §L§5§§"§§"§"§@@
_  §:§f;s'«%?%_ %;'.§3_§§§¥% %"~*':aE§'y&§. ifs '-».:'§§'§€.Tsé£§ éankegg zaséih %:i§§'3%C§'§
'-%'é:@.*_§TSsé'3§ée?ff~<<3~;*:§s'~g$ tééa geﬁié facéiéiéegk "'§"§":@ ea~:':@:;%r%g

reéw-;§§e§?..%i§§'a%é3,-- §3§':~'§:3;"':aE §:;a§'a;:'2§§@ 9;? Sré ijéjazza §»*§§§§3;a age



by $233' ggaziféz: ESSQEE' Enfacé, the game E3 éghe g:$:s%é:§__;;n ES

mggrés am <§'é§a§'§§"E§Z€§S %>(E€i*E"E§E@ by him is @i:%:asi.'§§?':?2.4§;?@.;fg

vagﬁé"; 2:-sham 252$ C%'E:d¥% faciiétégg have meg': a:";_"fe3€¢€§"'E;*g-

Camgaay méer Ezig mamagemergi gjamgéy,'Mfg§:'_§*~*E§"'{3V{;:;vexE§ "

& Cm: as: LES, am §v§,.»-'$, §<§§S&ﬁ:'--?é'£'G§3A.fV'§$"§...i€§~., "'TEi€_%"*':@é:<2jé'

sf such guaraateég g:va;:' _i::..__:?':é"-v.%:2é;1§<:a:°§ A~:f;':'1--..,a§§.5§%:é-- '

Ssmgamieg i_§E'":Q&i'" mg :"'9.a:%.age€fa_;é":::,i:_s;m:*i<s éuityie $;7§,:1§R32
Qmreg, GE": the ab::;£'=s-$2" §:;:;a:<:j3g;é€éE2§'- ms éameé a

Cémméggiaa 5% Ra,1;:5;E';':g§'5§g*;"'.gt'2{h,e 'i*23"{é 9?' 1%. E: E3

gem Eiéaiz $3552§'..:2e:fi}g_ea.¥€iw_Q:-é§ﬁEa__ré§§,§y; S%': Véjaya Maééyaf en

the araE:i_;a;_§§0§':.a§a':'é?§ %3é:%;3{:9€53j:A%s £§iis:?£3;4v$7;2§G/W my, the

gz,:az*ar%:'--f;ee._:€.>§i*:E's.:é--:;$'%'z:%s:'f2"zfétéaév-a§E& is exaéudeﬁ ﬁrm": the net
weaithw 'fwhgsafasgég %§f"%:.%'2;-.s_1's":::2::::"$Er2g guifsarétgz was Q? 329 View

zééaég :he;=*e wag 'v.nsé~--._ S€'iér:i§;Fé:; wag §@r {Ease hank
gasa,r§r:te*<%§; f§:§":"«.:%sn€*; 5%': Egzmargtévg meihaazi as' éizéeriéng $16

VEs':§é%:':§§Es"{.fé%:'fI._iéza §§§"'@§&.?'é§@S zmﬁe? hég E'°E";$§E§§§iET'i€§E§k Tihg

 .;:"z'é':~.:g:e%§::%:§":t_e§§é§;§:§:§ by aha aggeggmg &ié§."§'i;'}E"'§?";r' §%g<:2 d%$<_:§§3%a

ibsaégz :r»:%:§£és;§s;_:*:%;=:éa:2érag we amgsmg am? creéit §a€%§§'E§§.S S39

Q b&ni<:'s.. §'%;;3:»'% ggémazéiy gaczssaé "£§'"%€ §G3I"'i§ 2:?-g asasréeug

1.

5%;//' é% meiéseég sud': §$ amairaérsg §:@:*:r';§§§<'}r3r mteg, §"'i'§;"§%G§?'i€€§§I§§§"§ gf m&{Z§'E§E'%€§'§%S, ﬁzguééabée §::2§s'*;gag;$ {;sf:°:ff?_:% iaans am §:;%§§é:":g$; qaanier éﬁéemnftéeag $e§:.zl§{§i'*:"y'§_'§;'%..__?;§*.:§E"'_ farm :3? bsgéé ﬁebig eta' $9329 af ihesa Q-zsareéiggﬁeeéé "nass,_e' mag': exetasiéé ésng sack §u§8e:g~8sATe:%a'%TTjA'::;%c:*:':e"V¢2%.%L:v§r:;::A E§:':":E{$ sansiiwed have :.:r:§e:~_¥s~g;_::s:*";e 7:55-'f;a "s':gesT.'h'g§:;5:;.;;§§S;%:;'§:'£E:':g tiéa renawai :3? ihew §uara§:%@:§s«,V"V§f§svsfgexéé:;A_ t_§2%s§e f§:;e$ :23:

agpaas' tg be any %:?;f;éf$§é&~-.._g.:/;:'Ea~:°,a::'§':ees.V ?e:~§':a§$ 353 393$? W9?'€??¥ﬁ&$s $15..ésffﬁfahﬁégisgéé._ §§:--.é<j:'--;§'%: in ﬂaw? was the Sﬂﬁii ritmsg iii? :%:f"'V.:a5'$'3s:e':€$ <2?' Em Comgangr are guf§é€§e::::.: §§§rr:@n%: Envséaseé. 'REE a$$e$$%%:_e aécertaéneﬁ the reqasérerreenm 3? zézegé'"--g;,3a§3%é'téé':s§.,* §;-5:4 mg éean gmyérég regeaiaé :::}rwf:fe£$$E€;:3§ afier yea: $3 éiig §E'E3§§"E'%'§§E'§. "§'§s@ &$3;r%53»:";e'.{f;a*3;ré'ég.*2a§*:3s ¢s:m%@§*:§ed $328? €j§'E§E'€ is an eiammi: ef by 3:"; 'zféjaya évéaéiyag aha €7:??§§§"5E'E§{"§ ivy

-V axieéfwﬁérég §?"£%§§ émmk gagaianieeg is tha §an§<§:*$} "ﬁég ' .;5§;§€:.i§.$§::g §€.EE§"%O§"§Ey §§%_§§'"%f§ ééeai ﬁéﬁ gesuzéiy afiereé in am

-- ?%.;--§*:é*°z€s:F agaaig af we iemgany '§§@::;a;ai§§\g agisfereé ééée zégk §E€m€§":i grad '¥:?h€s'€ %3 as €V§{§€F%€€ 1:0: ssgggasé: ihai; Em §5?"s.£<&?$ érzﬁégiﬁﬁ $23 the gerganaé gagaranmasgv»,_}:,:»f ~..§%:g ﬁééaérman, E"'§E wag aésé :3? the véem: gm:

gemsme mgénegg :%"§€C@SSEi3;' $5 V;gn%,:§§m.§':é§'"~§;;%E%i"~. t'h§@g.e guarantaes, "fhaé they have met §»§e:7f:*T@séeva:$é~ é?er§i:%f§é--§;a:§'I§s; ﬁn Em Eéghi Sf 32% aciisaé ut:'§'é_§a:§a:'*: .5? tits £';%é{§}E§:.;..f§;§E.§i:éeS, "E'h§ref§re, $97? gargszgryai g§,;aV;_'_;é.-€§**';t;:eg.._»%_»$ Avvvééégnatme given Eang mgia '§%':eV;":."«*;z;§i;r§E'é.V_§:€2.:_'s«';§éﬁ'%:vs:,f§v§:§e':¢"-eff by hséééng thaé {here is :21; genuﬁmg serjv:--::~§. ifer1§<V;:5§%gefs:;':.é'%:§§Vfti:§'f.:f.w; gﬁgmgany. it is wmmanssgiﬁaté u;é'ri;@:':zE$s%en made, it $3 an $59 the CE"'§aEE'i'T%§§'§ Q?

am 8§$€S.&$E3A€¥';V é:§'?°!%%§{*§§'§'§.f>./:.:'\§*'i'..§°E§C§'§ is wéwéiy €}«<C€§SE'v'€ am :5.!",:§'&a$Q=:F%E':2'?'b_§E',V §<{&ég;§%mg; "'_.%»n véevzz Em Eegéiémaie basénegﬁ :*2&a::i_%;; Va? t%:é'a';:§eS§&§: the $:2t§m §::a:*a:"':§ee camméggéan .a§':e.§_Vu;'%:E;:.g --i§§"~;Q$§:3;§é,§8§3§~ wag aﬁégaééwzeé, ﬁe &E$$ mﬁk ";'g:§ﬁ:."~%..V':::1;'*">'z:§%':i'_::.>._Eiéié iééfaé ééze azeiggggigs garméggésa frém 2:528 §;§Ei°'a§"'~'_:;'és:;:,:§:&:.§ unzjér FEQQ wag rm aﬁiaémezﬁ am ': ,£<;::":f:._2f':'%?§3'é§§:'*; is am; gayggn reﬁzﬁjégég Gazigiéa Enaéa £55929: be é':";a§é§A§5 "ﬁg amguni Er: quﬁgtéaa mg 52%: §€§:?":é*:'-3&7? %§f £f';g'Sia§§§§Eé §¥'"s5Zf<3 magma bu: E3233! are $3": ma gizasegg :3? ﬁccmaé, The ammsné in Qiiﬁﬁiiiﬁﬁ has met faeéama igiase and gayabée. ?'§"1&mf'02'e, the gaymgni sf' §%.§&§'°3ET§€€ mz;":§z:E%;.¢§§9;z atarzmi ﬁe azaéied as accmad Eéabéééty and at 333%' igmeé a§ 3 mniingeni ééabéééty Lvhéaés i;%;§i:._§:éfVbéVé<i;é":'2é:_& pagsabie iméy an granténg §e;':*r:§ss§éfr:é é§'r« £8? a'::.§§:"%;?;:;~'%§flé§c§"e"'. 'J?

ii @363 mi: requére any §r_€;v§s:é4:;+;r}$T'.. .§n %:.§'L'E'€%1:."~;%{A:'.::.:{%§'««:§'.§L§..E.t Hmzsevezg we agsessee has éc¢"£3:,%.;:E;le:% §a}at'~a_%3?t'eéI=§;§:%;}:§é9§V§$sé<3r: éveﬁ €':'éL%£§'1 bafsrg ihe ':§§'ab2§Et§:"'?§'af;é'j4;$Vt;*L;.e§, "?§':é%éf§§"e ?1='C;' éésaiiaweﬁ me said e><'p'eV::-%.'§:§Vt'i§'§é.f §3*:;§g¢;:,§v:;'é":§:'§";f":§TZﬁ by the Sam §5'°€§€E" the a3$@§1€ee::__;3;::§féré*:s-§§ '--i_"-avsflf'ameai is {$39 CsmmEis 3§m:'eri %:§€fE..{é:::}>%:2vé}5'?ax(§;ggeaégﬁl)Bangamreu The 4% pgiéﬁe "{T§r%:"smV%V$$§'éA§'é$r."%i§wE§m.sS§ed aéé these uagtémsg £2 _ . _ Q _ §"':§§ {>;%?;:§§ér*~a5 U§'::.Q§'%;"3§'§~ V Z ﬁagmgégr E sxmggazﬁsag affewgnge Q?

gagargﬁzée C$!?'3f'??§S;§§{}f? gaygbﬁe 50 SE25;

' .. ':,{3j§ §y F'-~'?§§f:,»'§ gm?' gmsmé f"?€£f'?E*§§§'° 2 ;"3g§;2::§;=;";g §;i;%pE5§,1%i*i0:i: 9;' §8£'§§£§§? 4§{:;} $5 gm £55 we §§S§f€{37}x'° sazxgreﬁ 5}; 555 §§};}8§§§§€ maﬁa: sf 5% C':*;s:?m'§§s$§@:3er Q2' §}"'§{Z°§§'?'?E ";"a:< §i£;3;:§§§§}~§§§ §ua:*a§"2%:e§ far téze :"&E§§*3'S§€§ Camggarrg 5% :%3e %ﬂS§§§E£%": $5 iifze Qemgamg, §'x§®*{"%€ :35 am C§}§'%":§a§'§§€S Eégve €§§i€Si§C}§'§§é the sagzagiéty 9? §*--<«'§;:§v%aE§'g,:a_, W?'%;€f§'E€§" ﬁe gar: wpay *zh§;¥"-igan amsuﬁtz in mge $2' any ﬁefaazﬁ: €39: the gag': of §?§.:éf%__§:;2S S;'€£~i';:§7€ﬁ Qemgany. §*«*";<>s;§: :3? the a§':f3£"%£€S, Eeang, §:'e&§'i-..§aa:f§é§~§§é§ %:a:€_ 7 ﬁne gggessw ﬁgmgamz wage f;i3}m'%\§'a;%:E§«::a-Séséﬁé._B§'n"k5g7 gevemeé by Rgzigg 8: .¥%ieg:s§a§:*G:':s§ ~._'afé!"%':ez% Si§ <7;=§?'?; W§;EQC¥§}'§§i:';V' 393% were axteredeé $3: t?2"§.>,.VV""§3anks %_Q"-:t %*;e '"ga3se%:..see €§E':'3§§§'}';f, ii §$ mi: qz,s.%.':":a;~':..._{2at:.3V%° a'5% aéésagme %:§r9§éi"§Laff%r::ée;"%t {are simzzéé hava been ':a$<:eA :é':>:,}; :§:§§ﬁ.§f%1".AA§§'§M>%':G;.fﬁ aaceémg ':9 the as5essee'$« ':*':~"2«'::;§V:'_':--@si:,:. E5 zeéiff't§9§:;é{.'%.:'we§§_¢Té'e:'1cg: Wiﬁijié be at the §o3<3§"Sf.epV'e'7%.'jtV§§a 'amé me}: with the assessae C::r§z§ar§gx="'-_E':%:rga:§' 1€:§'€::é E%e'i§_;e3§:me'5 £§.¥'"§€§%":E§QE"§ iha': Eésara W55 :13 ,;§"~.§1{:§V&§2'?:§%;':§C Vﬁaggég far 323 §«3';g'i'?"%E§'%.§ 9%' ga:a;'a:":':ee § e':ai§r::fnEg$E§';;s--.4 '§~:*f: d ii was 3:233; an érmszzaiézxg maimé $5 '§§:%¥e§%§7§s":V%_;§ %é'f§}fi:$E'§?§ frag: tééa Camganéag is E¥'é,fg.§'v'§{: $§%z'sf€§§

-- n*'z§z*:?5{.§eé--?:f2@':*:%, E?' gag me Reveﬁue shauéé ﬁave mma ax; "V.VL.;fa:'%:§';..§c+§'é;me::ta5*y' axsiéiaréie 'Ea ﬁ§'"§3!& hgmg é%::<:: aggasmpiéang Ek,-gifégiéséézg ég fsriéésssrzéag. {En ijééﬁ ather ﬁaﬁﬁg Er: éése am/"' "--«VV."%:3§viLé%a:ié':::-{$3. Evﬁzzkfigagsa §*~'§g§%=;,:& Ema $334"; §&§§ Rghagﬁ

-5--sﬁ'/$954» éﬁeﬁeraé §=::>§3z Eiessténg mg S§"':3E'€§'§é}§{§€§"$ Wm am we §a£E< bane as?' any §Z?'%§é§$Ef""§,' fa: agmsvéng the §aym§:r'.:_§'~._$§ gaaranieé mmmisséen svhém E3 iafaigi beérzg yeays, "$238 Cemgaay Law Eaaré §":_§s aéscs"§'@'§:.é§_:*a'{§3.:?i *étimé "Ema gagzmwa sf guararzteﬁ :'::Qm;§=;:.s;'s:§:; «£5 "'n'je:;--%:« remazéeraiészz iifiééi' §€£%%a;*: E3-%Z"§9 G?"-v.¥:%1aV€<:{h§::i;2:v;:§,g5.ﬂ&§i.--. " "E'"h€srefQre Eééa "§"rE%una:§ was Vigvfixaranﬁae mmmissém gaid is §%i§~--:§'aj_a3§--Va %}'i;%£§'gsgj ff¢;".,»:f:e agseggrrsmi "y'@3§"S i9%--9:f. ..1;992~*§«Z*'Es'x.:.a.rf§«: é3;;'§E.§{':;:;'af~ji§'§';eV;.§}i'§éndéEure Ufiéé?' §@z:€§<:::": saié Grées', Em V. , __ :"§;%§é.'vEeagn§:%. §:;s,.;__r;§e§ a§Qea:"Eng far the Revamse as5a§%§§'2g'E. ?: é é:'*;'€;::>€a.:;;§:':é'§,.'é%'s<§'é%Jcmteﬁés Em': Em a;:"sd§$9::teG* mat1€;r':a:L_§:{V ééségéaség ma: E'vE::§'v1a§§ya £3 3 ?\§Q§"§~ ":i;:se>;g:%1::s<~2_e'»;":;':r:%'a?:g;«;g sag me': wﬁaéih gg 2ga:m,4?f2@23,z>. "me a:°:3é,;g;1:;§?:'€,$m:§ga~v€%%§s ¥'a£?'%§{%"2 ééa F"€§T€S€§"§€$ ézaazg barraewad a §2;:':é:««._ a:és__%5"-.§1i's,§.fi§.x.32 §%"§€'§$ fram azarésags ?E¥'%§§'EafE&§

-é 2//_,... .

%% W33.

Qfﬁsfﬁﬁ as §E.E&f'E3€EE€€ camméggéwz, ag agﬁmsé: 'ma net waaéih 35 $3 3E--3»3.§%€r £25 a gun': cf RsJ?é3;é%?,2§G;'~' "ﬁherefam ii: $3 5 ﬂay ii} ééveré the énwme :;r§§é.%"T.%:§5 §'E'E3¥'%§§é{"§"§€§'§€ anﬁ E: E3 & cafaurabm égvésea ﬁ,é§~?:rs§?;:E§::§f_E§«97,;__viA§~.% ﬁg mg: a ramaﬁeratémz Qaié :9 ihe E»€ar'2:<::«;}E_:§'<;;V:*}§::'a%_C:<;§";' ' Therefege, {ha gaymeai mgée "ﬁg :39: E_&$::f€:;"§'.T a%é.ad5'-w{;u§§V?7:€>f.' faié vaséihén ihéﬁ §"'E"§éSC??§€§ 9?' ,;;'~'~§e§:€%c§":".'_%",£4"* am' é§»'"s'feégA%§c§¥ jj""§"E'é€ '*. apgeéiate CG§§"§i"'ﬂ:§SS§Gﬂ€§" ag E.-»2:éV§"§':«iz_é' 'me "'§V"":"§-b':A_é:§*:%a':§ E:';*:'3a:*d&r ﬁe aggreiégte iihege z;:*:$i':~%§ia:«£:&§."VAfa§C;:t é -4.§j;a$§€e:=.Ve:*:*a3§'1e®:.2s%*;;2 heéé thai the asgeggeg E3 '$n§it§;e{3 __égf; .-{%*:§v..I';'471I'.3*§4;;% exgenditure, "1"%'*:@:"ef<§re; h@?SgL3%Lﬁ:fl:§7'?E'§§E§. 5 €:aé$e fair'-E--n~:erf€r9nce ﬁg maﬁa ﬁg. Per --€§:*'%§,f';fg;"§:__?§&.E.;%&§'f'%eﬁ €."$;£§""a§€&§ aggeayéng far the a$$_}€$§§é";%§.,VivE.»'*§'-7»'\§'éh.E~"'§:é1£"i§ %.Er'sé émgugmé {}%'€§§E', The aggcseai is ' '«aé§:"€}%.%%;aa:§-%..:a>'»~.;&;25§V5é§*"*:§":e faéiayy-§_:z§ $a;?:23tar::%aE questégn as' '~'*"=%,;%5§éa:%L§;e.éTi' éhe fémééﬁg sf 3% "é"s=*%%g:':a§ gm: E5263 §é';.2a:";'_éAntleé €£é§"§'§§E'E§§§§Q§'% §3'g'E?":$§é? ataéé fgvaur 0?' g_/,.

a>

1)' 3 "Wm ".32"

we £é':a%:ma:': af 1':§'%$ §§E§E$$%€ Qﬁmgang fer extmééng gasaranéﬁg £:§ 2&9 fmarsséssi §£'1S§{§§;",i£§§$E"i§ $3 3§§§i;'sFab§$ §'3i'.'§Li€i§€".3§i urszfaz" Secééan 33:} sf {ha Ag:

am net ﬂ§'V€§"E;§GE"; sf magma is gerzserse, g:'*bE:;'a:*j§;*._V am gétmrary fﬁ Egan; ?"

$1 ﬁeaftim': 3??' Qt the ACE rsaég 33 V 3,7, {2} Azsgx e><,a@f:,:Q'é€z;;.rézf}g'§;--s3:i: ,§§$,?;g:%f-.,__: «.»TA' €Xg38f?§i§L£f€ Gf we 5:33:39 §es~:7rE£:2;5a" é:';_.§*.g3{;}z*;"c2?? " ' 39 :0 36 [E arm' :'205€=€§é~;'_s;';:g 35%" :55? «§:§a~"':f::§?:'3V4'§:§f*"

ziapffaf egzgrgeiiﬁffusfe G?' p§;i;s é2:%§z*'V£;<,ae};s€5V_Qf_§§f7e 35$e5§@@}, iaia' arf a§:,:?,é;2g;:g:§Awfsaify any' @;z'Ci:.:5;'v§§;/ far {ﬁg §a§§ﬁp{:%$!e:§?:Q2?«.g§}2;é.:'_£f§»;%.é;i:3es5 G!"

Qrafessisja; . s*;':z§ii {ﬁe :é;":%;:;wfe"9'.',L";7z3§ CQ}%'ﬁ§;ifi}"?g we ;'§§c.9é§%?*?§..a§f:ar§%§é§:¥ié'»;g%k:{!@;'_Sféé fread' "Pmfiig azsé g;:<;;':"z5 @f'§;}§f§? SSS V_0§%T'T.;§?'g3f€Ssi§n: '' g"E;<§!-3{2§§§G§";..~°E"é;fff;*s remﬁaxaf 92' 5{3i§§9§£, £5 55 ;§2e:js:*b;/':§9;§§':?§eQf é'?,2§{* my €;%;{?€E?§fféi!"'£ ;'r2::::2 $5 5 . §;»::'~-,a;s-.A5s°s9s?§§é§"§bs" any pwfgoge Wﬁﬁﬁf? 3g 3:'; ..§;i%"g:;sjga.§;~.._;«:ri?55f? ég §r@§':§bs':fsa' 5:; faw 5325:?' ,f"}'§E «%i_i;:2.$;',:<;;é$f is @3225 ;:3*€8§'? égégyrzaﬁ fa: 55:5 "-«4._;3a:{,fa';::;§,é:*' af i?€,§.§f;'?€'§§ 52:" grssfesggbn 553$ .99 n 'T «..;f@::§e{:i' 3? gazeriﬁ ex,§@:'§:f:':*:;;"8*__§ 1% ﬁeﬁsgcifsga G5" a,éz'sw5;"2s:e $555; 528 f??§{§€ 3;? §2;;***;

%,:§% {(23} Nséwifﬁgiaaaféag §§?}fi."§'?;'}'"?Q* €3Gf?E"§é§f'§éZ3s:§ {:3 §:;§~:*:e:é;"a;3 {E}; gm giisavvarsxsg $332? $9 maﬁe 5:':

raagezgf 3;' eX§@::a';'§"ui'e fﬂﬁésfféﬁ by 5;? 3s5@§5.;?@e__ on aﬁmriégemmé 5:": gay gaawﬁisz §r§i:'f2:;:%;5;T 355:", pgmgﬁfei or 35% éiéce gyéiisheﬁ gvaiééimi ,$§rEy,j 53;

{4} !§£ozw;'i§2§:§na'§:zg aayéfying £5ﬁ:f?.fT5f§f?i€*f2g ":55: §::4:;:v{'~-.,___V A A' gecéigm {3} 9;" .;§:;£2~5@::£°f::r; {j:?},?. "

'Mmw ff, gf my §xgena?i§i.§§e__ :';'2;£z;:;".Eé{;:" .f,2§_;/ aggegsfeé, 'f;-32'£*&%Vr é§s~..__'»,,,§?3?'5 day a' ffebragary, 2 -;??z;?,1 ' : %i:_?:3;!_%~;€@n§r;5:e .;e£.': A afzjgx :fesi§e';3z£§§"~.Eg:cG;rz§:::'Qa'a£ion in . f':°%j2e {sf § W§?£.i€S§"§?G£.iSE {gaah ' 2§e;<s;T§a;;*::§»3f' ';3_::::}@mmsQi«3 {"5}??? beisg * ff:e}*@§é'2';'fe:= §f?:"s §:;§~§e::zfi0:? rafeizraﬁ V 25?; £323 "g:;$sf~!?§z,:5§"},' _ £2; 3*é§§'f5i§;? 55 5&9 &35@§5::rs§:%€ yagr ::"&_mm5n§§n§ :25': She 3" aﬁy $5' ﬁggrii, gr aw §§,.i§S€§§ii€_f?§ gggeggmarsz 3 $9351, :39 §ifQW§!'§€j$ gﬁaff ﬁg ragga 5;';

f"&;'§;'}€i"?f «:2? a'e§:*@:,"§§€":'@:"; <3? gay ésjifgiag éiﬁﬁff 35 3 g:;§§§"~f?{2;ss§ gr :§§;%;"§§3a§s$::

sf 552;» aggeés 3;: g g:zess;?~f?:":s;s:,:§,.' as gfiawance §f§--:§}'§~~.be rzéafifﬁ' .556; ijeépééf' S 4wnT0W¥'""(w \\ ﬁrmsiﬁeaf ffwé 524% azfggrégaie 0?

£xg::er;G';'§5:z"@ r$2%:';"§::? 39 5:? <:§§c:;§e {Z5} §f"E5'5 gmszxné as' any ﬁgprecéaéiasn rafarreaf ::i§:,.;§§ {E5} gﬁaff, for 5326 QZJf'g3c'3f£8S 9:' 5v;{§9.~ ' 5$:::§'im,. be rgﬁsgceﬁ' by é"f7§=:»AA»§::+?.:?7;;a:,:;j}:.§" ";'%"' ~§;*r§{, 53595;/$5 fmm gergms z;;§ir:§?=.._{f';$:§:;és§v§f§:>é§§§::~3§ Frayfdeﬁ fursfyer {"?z§:»:"_ r?aé'.?:';i-f?_§"--:'::> 35:53: :

sszrfian sfzaff agzrgiy 5;? lrrs-:ﬂ2V:{§r2 fa .3:':=;{ _=g:§€3$€¥ fzagzse mgénéaéneﬁ 33 a_.§::§{:'i::f§3;r..LAf2Q::*:7c%°'if gsfakctf? §'&@Sf"f?Q{!S€""

5'??:€---._ (3) 2,%"':;j:2:;;:gf::}uz'i;:'i?g,-; ' g§:"Sz«f§§; §;~;3*~. ;»f§e3:;~** ézrzgfawd 30$ _.i{:i<;§:u Gff3@ §?f:::g;j2fc:';*§§' wim;'e~2'fime carrigaf 9;? $3.99 f?;"m*,'*5%;2,a' 7': ' {b} 55 snfeﬁdea' }'°Q§r'" ifffsé _e5;<"<ffa;sEy;e'T'[*--;;$g§ 9;' ﬁifﬁf? {:9 E, 5 } €§'?'§Q§G}'€€S wf?iié§;': iVea: :»'.5. "

£e*,zﬁ§§s:§§§§;§,~g'"§-Tassf ff_2@"*;7r_s,§3;§gasa¥.s? gf $55 $535-w agasﬁziésé,"-«=» A A ?'@$z:.;*%§";'€ég:'-g2:A::i@:3i§s":'::§Q'a5§ar: in 5% zgaifgiré as' §a';;<%;~;f€--'§':§s;;.§e ggéaif g';'::§a;§e V V' 3j<.'<::5>r:ﬁ*zfz@Qi:;'%:';%:.:r:"' fzireé 53;" :e3§;":re§ ﬁg' £75755 ~ '.j'j -'«»§_§;§e§§$§ " .;'_?é 5; 52955;' far a Qerim' _s;::}::§§§§;%?;:jg: zzzzég §?€jf?§:*°"§{§ 5&5? esgéséwévm :;:22:v¥5';,fé,:}*§r:§5;x' 552$ ;2r::,w§a:;s~" grew; gzﬁ is ma;';?ia;'nea"7 5:2}/."_'a::2 --§sS:e.§§@«é mrfm has" €,2g?2;§:i%.:2j;,;eeér' $5-7.a Q&:;5§;*?@s$ 9: prgfessfmz» ' *"':%: 5si the {?§§ﬁ ég €:{?21f€§'Eﬁ 5?}? g Eaégmgni :3? éhe '§":~§§z.zr":a§ £5: 5&3 gr; 55% i'?"?§§f'§{"8z'?§;'?{5:? 0?" 5 gszg-,==;§*§«~f%a:;§e sﬁaif, 5:'; a (55; §;:§§:9§';':*;;;°@ i;?§"::.r:"€5?

€559 asxhere 5&3 re§fa"e;?§_§§E éccfgmmgsfaifssn hag 5938;: fz;'i'e§" §:»i. 5§23&*,_ §Sf§9SS€€, §f?Cfé£@E 3259 me re:*§§..~«;:°=.3;';:f'__'_£r%j' §"8.S}G€C§". $3' 5:25:23 a<:mmmQa'§:§a;':'5 V' 3% garuaaé sf 3% aferesaéé 9rav§é.§Gn:-m§7ké:T$.'%:"iré:*;€f-L:;§e:aVrA 'mat am: Qxpandimre §E£ew<;éa.:i.___ Q?' V?c:~:<;_§%::s"°:§7e:,.1T""=.;3.§§%Q_§Eg;garsé e><§§u$Ea,sg§y as' am mrgaase af ;:!§:§s§f:E':::"--f=;;ss §E':,:§.E¢_ﬁ§;'i% avéiéaweﬂ in aampasténg '(£19 érzcemel..;'§f%:-arg-eaégéé '::..§';»%f;égr_t§*:e was §:'::,>§'%ts and gamg sf §3i,§S§§'I€$S §sf...§3.;r9;:;--fe5$iA<;,na "?'§§§§si.;:%p§anatéan is ii"; a@ﬂét§er.2~€@ #é';75§§a;2§§:.;z"::»<§'i§»::--a'iéﬁéég'wfééaéa are gmvéﬂeé unﬁer §eai:E<3n'g.3:3 E<;> it Eg mt En éésgute that the exgen§§€:::"é.._Vér2V:*::,;;':*§éI_"E:;«3:~7' way sf cammégsign is {he

--=.é_§V§a§f§:a:5;;_¢§§r';gLf' §1f§é§*${::€:';f="s"v§@.:«'%2avEm;: gtoaé ag gasaraniee far thg §c:.:'3§?rw';;';.T§;*>.:?,.*4::*;*s?3}v'2:*=:é<i---_ by Ehe &SS§S$€€ is @223? we éf Size &X'§e":*:§é§iLs%*éig!2:i}é'§c%"; §aE§ a:%s%§%'%%§2 geazigns 33 is 3%. Tééerafere Ii: ?"2&"S.. faéé :A:é:§"2%:': Seams 3?, Yhs 'férgﬁ aggeiiate ..fa:;é§éz;:i%;;z get agééa {E25 gggagsmgmi: méagg $5'? {Em s:;?@;2:"*:::E % /1 /"

(<3 §'v'E_,2*'§"§*»"E: Dqgwgéi ijamgarzg :__m,;, §&é'"E§a§Q¥"&, W?§@§"2'B 2% vary §'v'§;:§v"§a§§%;a, 'aims ﬁaié egéxaraniée £§m:"r:E§5é§2m "§"E""2e gaéé Eméjgmant £33 exiracﬁeé E2": the "§':*éb:;§*2a%"s Qrdee' atvV.§'%%.%g3%5.6 wﬁaéch reads a§ Uféﬂaffw ' 2 é Efife aieém ,5: sggrggziaie £205" €"Q_.<:*::.:%_$w:;§5z;VA.T.:f£°§*:£ s;i3§,§8Si"iQi? at' far: gm' r5m5'sé5' "2i*§:sg f§': ' recgngéaﬁerafiar: 59 the ?_f'f'f?£.!f?é)i'\5{?;1..A_A3ii".'Gz';{}§:3%?C§ i' 3525:, §r'§f;"Ef§@ 4;/:Gr;$:'d&:"5ng, §'?;@..§"r§§:§;*:.a€ ;'%i:a3z5 a3£:r;;:v...e?: e;a'r.;? :12": mind Sim eariéer orcfe}*'L'V.§f§?ii!"2 ré,f"e~rséf":{,é 5:595 greseznz" 59% 9f fa;:~::f__ §r2§?V'7éi'$.§'j':§§':3i";;;7'; ré;é'ia;*i*§:_%-Q' 5:"; 25:22': 31%; 255 3;? 595:3/5,%z5~"5 gym, :6. ASS§§§31§.§g'w?"'--_A:1'fQ'f?9?;?é§fE§f§fSf\§Es? 0;: §ﬁ§CSﬁvf£w?',ﬁ§}{fg§'<1'??'?%{E;?§';a;€@'.::éf§éV@§}';§er ;:}:"QC8@§ :9 gaagg mg,-5 ":}v:<e.--;f@;;E:3 a:::g:;::.;i;iar2;i5 Wiff? fa W, .5: éeaééng' €2§'2?%§:'a=Va-€"t$ir'<:*s1a:é Euégment maéms E': dear iésai: ..§v:;'3: %'vE<: ﬁeéazeéé-'s gage ﬁﬁiﬁfﬁg E3 éeaéﬁeé, Sn Em "a:::§2;€'iL':"*§s**;,i+"L§Ai §'¥s.,§x§re§§i§«* giiaéieﬁ ma: may am $33: anszrgaréyzg L~f:E"%e_T- § a;§';@%.é.$?:'éV"r::»§}§a%:ss ané iézerefera {ﬁat ﬁaﬁgmemi ES :>§ ¥'2§ a§§i:*:sf:a:'2f;":&~= §'"h§ a§;':§€%a:& €:§mmé§$%er:<»":r £<:}§%"'s?':'":E%?:€§ 3 K '*.__":3:§;:§9:;§'-aékar in ggétiézég Bﬁééﬁ i§"%§ eréer gﬁﬁﬁﬁff by %i::?2;e nOGGhE.§}ama agmééaie gasthsréiy é"8§";f§.?E;§ ﬁn ihé gaéé Ezgzjgmené: 'iﬁ§§"§§C?"z ciagééed nsiééing, 5 féze agsgggee giaaed reiiancé an Ehs $2': the saga af very S3838 asgesgee irr, Em géésgageé Q5? :35': 2:" ﬁagréég, 20%;'? ff?e 5&5@';:;:f.::j;<;=z;§3:éa:;;i£¢3'f E Qs.:e.€a:i:i0n as' 55 w wf*:s'C§'2 is framea' :19 2:35 ;2:¢:iér:'~._ " £5; §z1ffz§:?7@r i"f2e_1_:""'{:_i£:§g:?3f wagv right in &?if§W;'_:'?g gL:§;:{§a;?:?:'e@ €Q::%';:<z_{;:§E<:>¢i3 ggéafd is me Chaérmaﬁ sf me I;.éS.é:'~i{ef3§é?e53 _.€.;'_é:%?{;?§§s_:y, Wf?€f'§ be wag i:§:r7:' evéski 7 51:1 gffard gucfiz 1 " £g7:;;mr2;r;_t§é3:?"

it ﬁg angvwgfrétﬁ a5s.._:.,§::§'&§f§?=-«.._ "

'i"§':is §:g&s:£;_"E::V?§ f:,;§§3.r gsversaf Sp' 335$ Eaﬁgmeaé A"%5,?s:§€.reE?g':é :g'E§¢'% 3&5/;>§§§ ﬁafeé 2:1 :2: .2935, f7:3§£a:2ws;?g 532$ ?3*§§::%_ja£€f;:3%':3§r;§f;V'~;'§?§ §{2e§Efs'::2:'s 5":!:1g'.3;'} 5:3 §s"§;§é'v'€f'§{Zf 5;? fesxaggr 2:22' 5%? gsggfsggiésk WZSW (Y \IV:\, in EYE: §'~§§§iQ§;-"":§§§ ;*:%z& $%£§§§Z«3§'§'EE5§ §L£&S§j§€}§"¥: <3? Eaw wﬁéah gmga ﬁg: ::@::§éé&;*a:%¢r@ $5 ag am@ar:»~ "§z'&'§z5é:«*:e;" Eire frfbzmgi wag r§gf?«;%....'4E;f; : ~ %_29!ai§ng afeieiiss? sf gugrazsfea 5@mm£5§ia;?_§';35;:§i fa éfm msirman 5;? we iighf ;¥f,V;Sf 6c:¢4¥.i?%:;"a;;é:;*.§?§'~ me fs'gf§:* cf ,§em§+,4(2,; cf zsrge zg:.:;g;::%eJJj%;éx%-g<:2%:%5 ,__ ' ' j 5;? éhe given gérzjzzzrzsfmzgiss ?'"'V._ The answgr ta ihesaéé age;-a..§§'§-:§é'~-5}? §aw :'$v--asAv'é;:nﬁ&r:

"Eﬂ./e 5;': .mr":?e s;1{ff}a~:i ;§er;§f:;§'f;i*;;r*:g:;"%?3£*an£e3g in fim <.fa;»s;:s:z«.._3§"« 5553 533:5! aF:?S:€:{§:FS8§3__§'§3%f§ chosen 53 ag;é,5:77.:;ag 2;: %zz:e arﬁer 5:9? s~§~2§§5 fgégeé' --§%?' §f"§T§{'Z1.:Eé.~z339~S42;'§Q98, Z?T»'3€ gm j&§_g<:_%2e~r;£f :f¢ai;;f};;f~...'éé§:;§fi;/ gpgfy wféf? regaraf fa ' 'V E356 %§é;<.%_§ _{'§2§;:3$<;*§ 3?' gggeggmemé year 3 §88- s*€..:.__:':,'::E@&:* ihaé ?'T€§i§"E€§" £338 iﬁég ﬁaasri: has 1§'%§é'§£:;éf&?:*i§~s V. a:'zS:---%§'§re':é'A éééé gaésj §$§a;§. Refégnsa 13 waged ii??? zﬁxé »,3§£3§va_;,':.{f§é€§:'V°:i:§ $5 Saéirzé ééégﬁ Cam"? m the saga sf aéaggggag TA~_"§'§}>:§'T;:§;E §EﬁR§§\§QS ;:m; @452 £i??%~§E?;S aa wmgaég 5:323 3/ // Efaémé ﬁféﬁ $":"%%ERS regariaé in {:<f~§8%'; $5 €Q?V'§?;5*a§'=é7':"

§§§§E§ ﬁ;§2': {ﬁE§i~£§} miiaére we Q%£€Si1§Q§E 53:' ﬁarzséderatéarz was 'K';-Eggarérzéeg :fGf??f3'§§SS!§f? gaia' éy 3 m:?':pa;;t::§+_«i5 fig S:':"8c€z3r ft}; gfgndfng gzsreiy far !§§--.ei§§' 5;r:31{§"'L-"

sreaiif faséfiéiag fawn éy $525,' »¢Gm;:'3;:;:;--- f5}'?§:'?C_f§§ érssfizufians is ;?af;_re§::z;3:f2é§:3::;95f2'--. sarzzicgg ;'e;2a'ered w':';f«'2i:§ ﬁ'2:e:"--._me&?§ff?f3% ' G?' A' Seciriagrz 35?? af 5379 Cafragjézvgées Qéczj, 'ErV§j§7§§f""._; ;}4;;§C§V agpravgf sf we _:Tfenir3{.._VG<;yg§nmé::*§.Qt_§f"2@ Camggmy Law 8§33_§*5f is éféﬁz'; :?é:;?;es$&§r;z. ""

Aasweréng fzhe $a§.:§"§:;é$:E<::i}"»L§: éa.}a5A %'":'éE'd that """ sh é5??s§sferaz§sn 92*' 52% gieéﬁgifzg 9}' éegsuming {he ;'?n§;§§§a§ i:'§§i§§f;x" af§Qvé;;*f;g:' §?<_3f:""';'?% remzmefaféai? ma fer ;;<s{3.rg;'§a'é$ zéfééjéreﬁk' zréiéiiiﬁ {ﬁe me§s':§:'§g 9?' 5.3§§5 2,.\~-z?:'re::i0z"V '55'§,;é"" ezs:"er;}?g Erzéa 52 ::@:':§;'§::" Q?'

-..gaz§%;.%§f:'z."§&--._a?@e5 :23: gig gay mazggzas', Cierzzaﬁ, "' ..._§§V:f§;:7f__§s:§';:"'$;;:§§rvi§ar;¢ :35' §Q's3?§rs:'5i:"§§°§:x§ wark. é§&___v'§:3ﬂ:{:§Af?:5e ::a:z2::?;5s:'ars fsr 525% ggfeagg 9?' £223 a:"';:"§§é:'-;"s=," $855 FPS?" far' 35%;: §es"w':e§ ,r§;2s'§:'e::f, lfisaé AA '*--..§:zas'§:3§"@§ {,'£"}£?'}'fT?"?§§§§Q?3 §§}ra?§3i@ is 5 §":':aE::§z§zi, "§?:&»°*§f@r5f E5 529:' :"§f}'?é§f?€§2f:?§"5Qf"§ far 5523 s'$:2.r:'::'§;§ =:% Wggm s'e.r2ai§=rm' 3&3; Cé:i!?S@$::2§{_3f:'}»', as ggygrsazaf Q5 552$ Saaszs' wag rgqaireaf, ?, in $513 C536 mi £Q§'»'§§v%I$$§$?éER mx 21$, ?vEE"E3£%iE2E§'s§G EQL}1P?\'?EE\§"E" £04?) m%g%,%%%:gg%Wg¢Tm zjzaasjz 223 am; 35@::aa;%; izhe qzigesiéfm §;5~._{E"":i1:;f:%'; _.:a*':".g;V5;,:;é'jgfgf mngééeraiier: wag wﬁether i:?";ss~'3_ba::§<'----ga§a;*ar:teeT.:§'n§§2aé$s.E"<m gas E9 the éérasiarg and :@Ea:Eé2'::§§;'A%§ §§§<,*s'=s;%2:'~§i§'Ee- -33§e®<:%£m under Sectisn 3S{:}{4')': ":%°z_é"2-'i_:9;A€:*.-';._"§Ee..sai§ Vsgluévgtésn was aaswereé by the Rajagthagﬁ {E§:L,s3:'A;i3j'V_'v§;§éis«Ea:r'2g that Ehég agpeat Q? iheg 't';:§.:§I%'--r@x§§_:°§§g-::§:a'n5$\ff'aéééédy csixegeé by a ﬁecégégéigf mg 'vcéééi v§'A%'uRvE§zC SEVA§H.ARA€V§ {9} Lmig. ée.;aér%e;gﬁg;_"{:_:§3;'z:.§.; :59 HR :12{Ra§}, "E,/¢i'z&;"@!z2 an fafgréfg 35$, :°%?~a'.;3§;s'e-31§§§"$s Camgany 5&3' gaia' gﬂﬁfﬁﬂfﬁé """v.:?9;";é£%§§;§§,€{2z2%-Ea if?é""'%é§3iiv$s sf éiise Sérscéars, ygﬁa f33§' .§é;:;:f::%:'§ "f§:?a34;%£@".;: far Zhé €:%§f'?'§§é2?f3§X 535' if wag fsgmﬁ éifgaé §i2&.._Q5'€G':g;':€§'Js<}+f::'E?§§" re§;s!§"eQ' 3;: ;'§:zz:;;3s§=;a€;?;m ﬁg ifse miaffaresf "-.3?" 2';*§':§,%__E-3§s'&£':"é3r3 3? {ﬁg CQi?'{g§§f?}ﬂ ﬁe gzgérﬁrséae V' "~'§:f:E.::::%%:'§s§5a;: mga' 55¢ geaazrégég 5&3 ?§f'E3.é"§£°8;§,. 352$' éﬁagg hyfafgféﬁzzgéssﬁ iifﬁﬁ :;;:%§?§_§£?'L :22 asﬁamzggzamzra g? E§§C$%?¥§E E 7:3':

%>/ W '§"3'i'aX $5' ;3J':"i.§%3';¥E§'§€ SE\f;i§%%§a?;A%'»*% {:3} 2X3', §'@§£1%E'i$§ Er:

iigﬁéj: 1%? ER E12:j§a_§} %;§:§ quagiésrs ﬁg: €GE'°§S§§*e§"8{§$E"'2 wag %ﬁ!?':z3§Z§'%€§' {he guafaﬁiéé £§§'ﬂFE"E§§SE€}¥'Z gaéé i:}<§*-_i%:e zeiaitéxzea; :2? Séreafczsrg far geczmng fmagéceg :9 %hée.._,§4'3§}e'§§;:?&'§V. 53 ii Er: the naiure 3%' remméeraiéen fw §€:'vE:&:V$ 'E'%;§f§3é8¥i'€'E§ "

aréé E5 savaged unéer Saaiim éiﬁqjija it wag heéé ihat "'.§§:€fm zi:."§g*"1%;.:§ 5;_§p§g.«i :}::..V_:=§;Véi'«{2§y:2mn$s 5::

$0 far 55 the reiaééa/81$' <;'-xffzféé Z,}.,€;§7e:?§e:*:;f,§;:, .§eci';'on 4@A{2j, .{:.'.Te'3:'{,iSf€§ ( Qr:;«:§xgeaﬁi€3r@ £:fé§'$§fre¢~:9§iVf;3}/ :§:%éj§"a§:é:$s8e '._é¥§5z'Vcf? Es & camggrry in z5é:$§?€;f€'@§"""§éE§;~;€§_*b»§&T:§§f?;:é;%.:" hag beer: 9;" ;'5 Sa be s*;':a€;i'::+%_ §3?;?}«:'VA§§'Ere: ':1.§é: er g refaézws <3? 5515?? ; 'a}';i'§C€:_>9§".. __?"1%'? 7:'§ §}'fg3:ssa, 325:5, ymggia' aﬁparenify §g3§§§£§i%fé"""§é iﬂe gagzmsﬁés 532' gyaraniee g@;§é'::%§'§;é§°§:? 53 5&5 re§§Z"§2x§$ as' {ﬁe éiracéarg me $553 manééaagd a;'35r:za 8&5: Sim §:2::;§zks*"§$#5 $9 Sséciiaz: 4GA{.2j wfsicfz :;":;2:tsz':'@fs ff ﬁg;/§ ei:'s}ﬁéé=s3 f§E§§.' 533:3 ,::,>mw'$§'a;3§ 555255;" iftre §§£§§§{3 A '"-~.$§?a:'E f'§'£}$§ aggéfy in 595$ ::§§§ 3;' 3:': §S;'3;@§;§°€€ " wﬁigé 55 § :'ss'?%§a;'2:: s"$£§§<:é :3?' gr:

« Ww,.w v.:Lf':%:V%2§%'-Eng? {he §é§&?§ﬁ'§€€ C§E"%'°§§"T%§$S§Q§"§ 3%; 3%;-3 gram 3% 2 if:i%:i.:» Wggm e:«<§ez":s§'§'::;m is vazfifsf? .§§€€'§<f")'§E é§{a;E{:'} §§§;%'§§.,___ E5 fafiﬁgzsg 5§'E§E' if 5% §;v<;:?§::a':':*':;:2:3 f§i§§ :;rz:;§e;¥.._""'T._V ::i,{z;> Q?' ﬁgaéim éﬂgcj, Shag m><,§s:m"E€*z,:;"e €33 smsjgbf :;z::a'@:* Sezttfcm «$§£{§} 5?" 5:25' .§§a:€s'9n <r§§{<:"}{'£} 02*' @528 AC: :'$,..a§pi:'c;;§ié" ifge e:<ge,r§§;'z';,;:"e rgszsiig §i3§ ;;:r§t:.T:7/§%§j:C:r;§ {"€'f??é1f?8F§§"fQ§? :0 g reiazgfve 0f"::",»'}é'zf}re§€s§é;<_A':;>'f'vz?%e'V V' ::'§m§§;":y. A aiassé 5;-§,><..:1§§;f:;f:'2§i§ic§:<:__ 'Sé$:_§j:":':z~:% 4ﬂA('2} arészi .Se:*f§0n ::;{'_29w}39 ifﬁagx' are :20: a;0pis'€§bf:e:"':f::?« :;'_é @ a§re" rm:

;'€i§£*§v€:3 wxithén éfé '.€i%.%-'a;€ ¥€?i;'EL'i_'J(.3{AE 2&3} af£f?e,zi¥§.,5" " V T"'§'2ere;_f€?'<:': 'i,.'L',.:::_f:«_;g?';i:;*}er:_'{ kezadered amdes' Saciian éﬁia} M¥if§:':e }V3T§t§ pi.'%::K2§séGn E3 no mere in the §Eatuié' E3f;«:}E<' 33'f %'5. ?;3$*--..§§e;'*; mieteé '=.,---¢§t§*z €§§€£'£ §;*em :2,-a;w:989;*--,__ * V' ' ' V__"é;"%2$é9é"%:¥g;§...A%2'aas@ ﬁéée Euégment 9;? $aa.:§2ai§ Eéigﬁ 'C.aé:§;:%:_é':?3 "t§fé@: '::a$e sf {:2} maamg 3: £3, E aim egg ?IL.iZ?;?'?§"??E§SE}§E'%§E%EVi*;§:I§# 3%: I?\§€%:_'3§~'§E m>< iggaféeﬁ sn {::*§$§} :24 f_i¥"§"§ 153.8" QSAEEE, 'sz"~--fi'°§§§§§§"§ the §ii%Si§§§"E fag" aamgéﬁaraiéaa was I; ' "..fﬁ;?ss%i§sssr{:@:':i 53:' §.E.-§2; V mggm paéé by the Cﬁféﬁﬁaﬁgf is the %'*«€a§"2a§Ez:g §:'}§§"€C?;I{}§' far hég §§§"${}§'§&§ gasarazntea $3 éaéuatibée ainée? Sﬁciéﬁﬁ 3?. §, 'sﬁsa have gage thmugh the entire §:;.:£§g}*nf_€e::fet§ Na £3252; ig Eaiﬁ dmgn Eiéerem. Tézéy have the arﬁer $5 the Trébunai which hag '§e>rmE'::i:&5ié'{E--éé{<;§uét§e':;, 1%, A g&§u$aE Q? the§'::f;§ug{ir1€=, éV' <}réé?V%*"Sj§*:.2:3§.g'\:Vs_:3:h$i., ' EEEES Cam: get agéae the ea__;4fuE"§'<=:a,::"_ -€;_Vrée%"p a}'§$e§E% by the "%""rib:;nai_, faymzséaieé V i:--i'_'"2%i': _A§s:_s:sg:§ fr:';};*: ::e;>n§Eéera§§0:': and rémanéeé the .F'F"%3E?Z8E7-V"$€-."3€;:§<» EQ'1 ?I§;§'év_Vf§%§v§}{J{E&§ fer frgsh C0nsédegraii§é*;';7?'fE"%';V@¥§5$;;é;<:;.9;:which the T:*E§a::'":a% wag caiéeé Upfjﬂ i§ i'5E--':{_.Tﬁ§'3_ éizg"=§éa*:§§§.ﬁTg" §.$ é:a::;§a§r:e§ Er'; ﬁara 2 N 'me Emgajg s"1eé"Q_§2*é<§z*° 33$ ﬂag "::é%é'§:iar:

£a$geé:§?ss"':'*:e::§ V &§r §¥:§A?f:.:

"=.§§}~-_..:?:?%2.Ae*:%:%:e§ :he"""é"rébun§§ W32? rigéﬁg $5': 3§§£3w§rs§ ' V. cemméggian gaié 'ES {ﬁe Chaérman eé' ézhg A'--..;a§éé'$'$::':_e",."is~;:m§&:":y; zzssééan ha wag mi 8226:; '~.§§§z.f:g:ée§:§~én: m affaré gzgah gaarmiee?

mgém Sb} %£x§%'se:"§*;er 223$: '§";*éb:,;§":aE wag righi £22 ﬁ§§{}¥%='Ef'E§ 3»:

§L£&€'«3:F3Ei8E sammésséam ggaéd E9 the C§'%&EE'"§"?"i3€"': §?--':;=..se agaagsee cémgarvgg when ﬁe wag mat %T{}ET°E§E§Z8?"iZ in affazﬁ Siiéih guaraatea?

»'""''''m (""3 '~..._..«--

15'*f§'§@t?3&§' the Wébzmai wag Eéiﬁiiﬁéd E::_.§_§kE_@?:§s*1§;;4;§.:'*t§}a1 3 ﬁ§$aE§8if\:'8§"sC8 9? 3 % <3? €xp§_:':§Et':;;:'s r:s§r::4E>_i;':Ts_:::§; 72:9' Mfg, M: ﬁaweﬁ S; Cemganyiaéén 1¥i*_1e1€;"(§§"&'~.E_Vé::'..§§s'ﬁr'v§Fi:: --A maéﬁtenancﬁ?

{S} Wheizher ihg Yrébzsnaé v§'gg'V:"'%;<sqh: 'é":~:.a3T::3:;ze;s.;4:3g the Erzteragi: an mans Vigsgen b=;"'€E"2éf":"é§;>Qr':ﬁeAré:"a3'§4es;see ta set {:9 an érétéééégf-név_gf'§_i§.;Ef"'{,§}If§:§§:=r;f2a Sévésianﬁg wétheut §§'2f§?E§ a ;*'aV:?-*::e.,;a§ f§--.z'2A{;¥.§n§{;«"'%:§9§'5'1':'."§é.§:%z ac%:§v%i:y ::0:§s§§mf:€3d §;.'§§L§fi' e>$i:&n$%'<;§n '9:h<:~:=._....%:%é:$Erae;<:,3 Q? the resm:'§_.»j--2e:*::__ 3-$.s;j§$$$§3.?_" ' Agsegséﬁnerrt y.e:a ;'.

{3} 'J'\f§zéi;.§fE$e :", €:5!'eé'* 5§':'°E_5a.§§§§ was: fight Er: §§§§W§§'¥§ ge,;a;'as'1'€i%:¢>;=j £s:;.:'%:rr2E':;s§i?n gaéé ES $328 Chaérmagé $5 the %_' §:*;.$$§'s:.=§a C'§s:@.;':a«;sy,. asaghan he wa§ mt avg: V _é:Z=C'if"%"':§1%€§T§§":"§T__§@ affaré sasch guarantee? '--§§j§-.f "§"s*%bL:n&§ wag gasgééféeﬁ §§"i éeiﬁégzg thé W..4 @§5a;£§.$;é-*§'aé*é'€e sf .§§% 9%' expgnéiture s"&ém§u;*§&é is E*!%;'$.'§s'Ec:BaA;e§§ 5: Qamggaig Es réégarei is aircraft ' *».4;jz2av§V%2€§naa:a?

5E5§§?:€E§"18i§" €533 "E"":*%§:;n5§ arms righi in géégwéng £329 %§'"'E§§§'§Si 52?"? Seam iaken %:sy Egg zeggméaniiaggaggeaa a§;// W35".

:3 3%: am 5 %":§':ﬁ£ améi wéihikégi: §§"%E§E"':§ 3 f5€?U§§ §§§"i$%__€%§ that i--3é§€?'E aciévéty amgiétuzeﬁ an exiengiayz buginegs gf {$39 regggazéﬁentgfasgﬁgggaé?

Engefar ag guargnieé :am§%éissé§n gaid i@_?:§a-:3~..':::é'3 a'§'::f::aAr'e Eé iassgerrzeé, iii the Smpugnea Q§"§é=.%f if':-§§5.fiv§1:;2Tag e7A.fs'5E2E"am-L?:__ facts <3? %.:%:5:~ mag, ihey haz;e.»;s;1::.:j:2:'r:aV:'*§2f_é:f :E";e';.":a:i,V;f;i%e§{2%%e;f;n c:f_ *. bath {he partéas, they haw aE§b~« v§uim:aé'§Ezé:é 'ihe §::QnEent$ Q? we arznexazreg an r-&:_e%£s;_:i§i:e--..;'a:,%'ﬁééced. They have '-5-'; "J. as?) $9: gut the @2*de;f€:Zé§L,sd.g:'":<:sAe:f::3?'&"§§%:""--é3;%é'§:%2 reﬁianae ég géaceé ané :*$§::aré}ie'5:V 'aEfs&§é.%§5w§;fé§;..§éé§::::'és: "£5 :5 V --§z~s'1?..'g»;;m:;<,:9z;z:"é:2* ..zfas'$z ﬁffrai many baﬁizing §;'2$i€"f:";éf§c;:z§~:*_Varé £n§':5.§f§'::g fafa parsanai gasarantee asVar:}3_af5f:€:§ér§g>!.Ass;%:fi3;r{§}¢j_. far grarsfxlng Joana In She :ia§faf%::4__t:a5:?V;' _;"'?2's;;%»?§§ff:;xa smaaf §?if§i"§f?fé;?§ fan?" {#38 ;;?e£i§E° faC;':'§z'j;}*"3éxai§'3a* by 5:923 aggeggea mmgsany far

-'.,._v§;%2;i::f3 ;§?<:;,fv?a§;'i;?§V hag :':2s;'§:*ed' fa §£.,,?§!'§f?i"€@ ' - *:?a;;;:;:@i=§.%:h«3;jé'z:--$ ﬂag gverrssa' ﬁg i"'§".§€ émmeﬁ Aﬁvgcaée "Qf:>:"" aT'§':::'g:§._ Egéﬁrsue 5: 5'3 59: we §§:?§<@r 59 gggags "'44s«*§zésé;Véff2er:"' f%%::?v?aE!ya 53% mikes' 5;? £33; £253 gerganaf c3§'::.§_?i§ arm' éfse g2..;=~;5§§§§§ ::"9:3'2§a;:}r ﬁgs gﬁf §'?6§??§§'3§ A '§z._} afa Afigr :°e§%;2r§;;=g far :56 §'€§"§§§"§§ fiarm Q? ;a;t§§;*a;:*:'@§ $3' 555%: §f ﬁgseﬁg, 3:" £3 aégarzreﬁ iféﬁi" $2 ,1 Q // ..

wggw fvfrﬁfaffyg ;<3*'"33a* g:;§r3z3£*e§ far' Sim §s:5e$§e€ €G{_??;:?§;'E§f 4",??? {£25 §:':5§sz"€s?€@ Q? me ﬁamép .F¥@:?5~'-_::;f €326 éaakg have Qagegéianegf Sim c3§asi3§i;i:"§;=* ?»?';:fv?af£}f§ w§?e§i39:' he Caazéb' f'€L§§§f:../ 551$ iGc'§{E§'_'éf;'%a';;~.£..t3:j_§. 5}'? $5333 {if §§"?}f afefauif 0;": tag para' :3?' ;if§fz,é"'€2ss§é;s§5;e€ 3 comgarsyk M35: 5,22' éfze 33-:;'z::s;,---' &!§;'.§i" f3cii;'i";'€s $9 the 55se$5é'e 1'_::o*:?:z;:§1a._:?32',_ ' éi«*:'§i*§; méigaaiézmf b$:2§<$ §_?{§'s.r'T§:'"s"f5'é'i'._ 333/ ;r§:;i:':":;::__V_ 5535' VA reg5;§a€§0:':£, Wfrar; s*:2<f§*;L»*?ya!;0£ar,a§;:.g,2V_' "'*;i.':--;;:3;';.§éT aééérs éxféﬂdﬁﬁ by 3&5 é$:}k5 fa"':f;--éVL_:5$$-sgseeé' :12;-"r:g ai;2y, is 5:: ;3@é"i?f;?g but éjiarsfe. f?j;3:3§%:;.:é?'-- :i":i'§'A =.»3_'SSU3"E'?E zffzai" Ssjfﬁgienf 55:3 <:a;,;£:i.:'_§é;av§§ :.§@%.é';'; "5;:%.g'<e?7;'; by éﬁem bafare 3;:_:::e:;;€{;{é';.;: §c%._ {fig- §§§e.§S§ée~'S..§%:égue3$¢ if 30:, {ﬁg daf§:§%3«3§:'y 1V'_;{s;éa;%i§§_ 'f;f:.e;;_ " ~_:i:§ ._:2%i2eé ﬁaorséeg ef the Bggséicé am: ;;a:%%%;¢,::5:%?.:;:g: aféihe €z'S$€SS8€ mmga-3s';y, ff ms _tf3f<3*_%*g¥é%::=*;?"22;,§LV';§A..ggggamfagnsim éhaf were W33 93 ;§;if;5é3¢§":i':;;'f}?'éV":';;é:~:}fs" zifm §§}«"§?'§Ef?f af gasararziee ;:j;F9:"r?L;:':§§$§<3:§__V§?;§9' if wgg mfg 3;? §:°'§{?§%«"3i"§i«"€ mefﬁsﬁ A :if§.2xe*;r:f;'n§ 5f;¥é";i%%:§me frag? {E29 mmganigg azﬁéar ' mazéagemenﬁt if ga 52% §"§i.«'8:"'§é£€ V" -.£¢?;$'::;5%i?5'»L-E?a;;:?é §<:2m§ gas w§§§§ ﬁaaumgazgzy évédsrsge Writ: €§E'§Er'-§ "??é§f?'?€ 55$ ggsamgéiga. fémzzezzer, r2§:*§'2;';':g 31$ 2'9%:}'j%3'€:3;§:§;§g, Sr: §§?€ gséfzeg" !';3;*:::":i, 552 31% §'e;?@r§§ '§?;§a"}«' :*»<?@§:f"z;:2g, fjfga .§§'§§f€ §2af§§;:§ {wig gm £255 '§§a:§<~§;r:2z'2e§; sf §!Tf§./ 5::§a;£§s';/} 535% aggzavaﬁ {E35 W2?"

gaymenf as' ;f§§,£§f§i?§€§ wmmfggéam wéisfgrﬁ ;'§ 5:2 E355 gﬁezlwgs gggcf far yegsrga-1 ?"'_?:9 §Qs'"E'"§,E?£f?;f 55;»? 53553' mg $53311} ;"ex'5'er3&3a' {mi 55$ gag»/me??? cf gagaraagge aamméggim :5 {mi g remgjagraéiagv 25:2: 33% :35 C'@;"27pa:2;'e$ A55' "' "§«%E€EA€f@§Pgf {ha "§"réb:_::z§E igmsgeedeﬁ i:3_--%*;~3E-§€:.%§3i:éraiitsé ewraii €3E"%S§§€.¥'§€§Q¥% <3? {he facig §:3;_r2d :C5,§§L5ET°3,S1?_8j.§*§'€,é$'G5 égsam gm? aim reggécizfaéégz féi-%._§w§:":§,:§"%e dé:.<,:'§§§_:;:»~é1;§ sf %:?'se. » %é@r's'b§e Higfi {;oa;:"%$ ef Ga:.§E"4'éa?T,:'V%' mg Ca.Z§é:'t€a §refe2*:'e§ gzmra, tizey aye <3?' «mg a?:¢f.6-:§giQ&;erg--;'§,L'%;';~-$:v;%§':a§ the Guaraatee Cammisgéens gaié :0 E'«'7.:%.,f25§%;axga--.§'«§,aE%'§}a §@--é%_'é:'%":e aggessmenéz "y*'%a:*3 ';,§ré':3'~"'§f9§;3'.~§3 am aééavsabig @}::§¥3§"é§ §"3°T_ii is :35 "'::§i:fé ﬁat ; '$313, § re:vE§:" as?' the ﬁébzsnai reaséaig ma? the §%s;s<$f::§%§*{%;: §§:;«§.§:erii;s 'haﬁ aemréed ihe siaiementg $5 {E33 '§'»'§a:§é_&§&*r9::4"--«.§%%*V ﬁank, ﬁaaéa Q? Bargéa am Qssggaraééan garéia. 3:"s.__;§ 9;";-.s;}'§§i: GE ihgér 33%; $3 ag améerz 9::;.a:'e <3?' iﬁe bgaéiaerg 'mag smmeé mes germ mi jmazg am} iiamigzées 3% §%%s*,?%'§aE§;:a $3: Emég aw eigégééa §:°:é%::-2;

mggm aéuazanzggs e:<e<:u'§:§§ ﬁ§"§§§¥"'i§§§';/ ﬁursng :§S;§~:£;§$§ were mi: reaewad tézareafter. in 53$ cage 9? iii;

Earzkf ﬁg magi: §§C§§§{§§S wem :'ea,:§&wed fmm téma to iéme am we maximum ares}: aE§Qwa'§";i%:

wag ;'edue.:e3§.

E'--%fs,E'v'E€Sa3weE! 8: C9,, {ha same SC .€'ré:»m %:£fe'-% beginning wag §aE§ even %:§"sgug_%z c;"ée;§vi€::'_§a%:§.§§t3i wag Eewered;

Eéené of 'aha banker hag ab§{a§§éé.;djA. tfzgﬁjgiaiég 53$-{eta am iiabélétéeg 05?:-§v?€"..§ U3?"é'E?§_G§"

Ag per the cgsmsars 3? R,5{E'~:§_a:.gd 27'9;:2,§{§¥@ aim in Jana, 8%, the w5{§?e enéégfé mat the graaiége {sf gE§?§;é.§V :}L';Q5ré:":':£e.7e§]'.:w.;§2as.S mt ugeci? by the Q;E%"es:;to%'$_"VV1a1§"§,% s;0=a§VL:*er:;e V-e:f. §*;em:;;:arai§@:": ivflanév 'zézé§a0:9é"{§wi.;i'g...'_'i1T<>e 353 the banks were aége aviévégafé'%:a éVE;%éEn._:VsT:;§%}_. an zznéeriakéng fmm Em 7% rr'cyg § :3 g ii;}_rr% ga pg} e>{:%'aa::ge Czméraé iviamgai, prim' §2zf.?--':"§<.r%:"*:E'%::..§;Ea;'; %3Vf"'?;VB§ was gaquéresé is; $51533: the " g'a2.¢'€3Vé2%:é§».g sf §*siRE$; arm ' ,.,E:rV9é";§%'§':?:_:?;:'[;;":"é.f aizaageé §i:5EL£S $1" ?%r,§VEgE§*;sa fmm Rs«:'7$%':.f4%'~"~::%*a: :33 §'é%;£_, tha §ar§§<§rg was mat aﬁée is é%:§_§~§ £3 :9 %r»;h%'§§":€§" éthe gzzgyaaéieé was $3 "'~ .e;*2*ff@s"s::@§ aggémgi §'v"::2§'%'%a§§:;& is: éhsa want 9? % H défaagéi, -' Hewevez; in {ha §ags_é. "'§:{f~T."'~ g_2§«.....

£25 Again 5: ﬁara 432?; we '?ri§::;§":aET'""'--.T§"éa§ gzgmmarézzezj we aimienis amgexaé i'<} me &§§3§.§.f.;'§fE.Zi'?;': *.'.E:;%'f:£i'é'."'V. ag unéer:

'iSf:2r§ izlfgejgx Maiiya, Cf2§ir3':'s§,»'? $3' :}§s"i»;>i;.s 59:3f:;:;g:?;;9'éSh .?i?§§£J{?f§?§} ﬁifsﬁfa Sogrsgif & €'::,, *-._£}.E£,£f?§':3' --~zas;5<S"

raggjeaf as" guarméeé ;*é;_a%;<:§r2i§si::.;3 :'.€.?.Ti:'} A =,%:>r...jt%;e asgessmené mg? 50 she :'u;z§:é'=.:§2'" Sékfpsg ifba AS an a.xers's'i::a:::'s;": .«,;§z"'..VQ'9{:z;:9;5§1e§2S{§ gééiffj S§f§§f€'f§ game m She :::3r::'f:.;ss'c2:': éz'?_é&:'f_§'2'@ g§§i:a?5%_:;2(§f;:":i* be éreafea' £5 3:'? giiawaafrie e;x{!aV@::a:¥;{£*5;§*1a:*._';:;/$f 52' 53% Aci, Tfze §rediE%_"faé:};§§;"§§as:3-.§%,r:§:'§éa' ":9.%':'a=---~v:":er<:':ga;"::'es were gecgxrea' by " 55§§se5i"$j'.-- 3 V":*§a:;;:§ecéiv&* {:ompf'a,r2:'ss, ?'§§"3§"g'L'§}f§j§?;i"ééf1.j&?{?'}£E3.@'*E£%S'?é£"&'§'§}:S€J' fmm 553$ §3§"§§<€fS weré f.?s,3:}§32 'sf: which M:*".;"»§a;'i;/a get $3,325 éiriﬁrég. 255$,/88 fa 32;i3j:'95 gagmrtssf §';i§. ms 4'%;e;3i:i?..'-52%'. 52%; 333.93 9? ;eg,.?"5,4? faizim; .5f§é%.:2; § ', _:'i§e ";!~'::,':!é. .... ..:.-='a'3§ 9?' zffze VESW were wag m A «§;ze{>§£é£%§.;§'233;$ far gaymeaé $2' $5 arm' 52' wag a gfgy V ..,ff? §::::s,m§ at»? we §§;:=":;%§n:é;3= agrgﬁes' féig ':§f%:3;2ajgée:;?::.::%éé§', "ffze 53%/§ $55? exierscfazii? faazsg ans' §;'£s;;':5€g_ fa£;'i§§fa§ ﬁggm' ::2:i: ;3f"§;'?"?§SS§€"}/ miss, * .T§2gg§§%€'fé&{,"§§';'@:: 9:' f?'?§C§?§s'§€:"§E$, ;:r:er:"§=ag;'z?g af §3.r§§i§,f§::;:"f§'§;2g;§; seam??? §§",?§€§'??§?§§"f6E aéat, Sgsargrgéae ﬁ<f:§asmes?{°§ were EX8€L'£,f§€§ ﬁagrsﬁg Z§84w8§ 5558 {:95 .M.3§_..,.

rerwgﬁzm' {fQf'?:§€Q£,§€s"?§ ifs; aggjwarg' Eiméfg <32' Ewrzg ganaziaaeé, 3&5 xiii') ma' C£}é,I;'"}?€:""§'a;C§ {he §§$8s:;ee'5 5355935333 far 5%? §fE§:»v§§§:':€';/ Qf SE1' 3:: Mzﬂgifya far an @Eem§:2£" sf :":'§E< €.,§f?ﬁ@§"€c§:'%'€{? by %%s';;:% 532' exzenafffﬁg guaranéms {"5 {he ﬁarziw, gm semriégz 3ffes%é_af__'§:? "§2'%¢3. farm 9?" asgeig af {ﬁe {:Qf3"?§6:'"?§€S have iQV€r8§ $95? no preef is sazggegijﬁaf :"§3.a*'§;:2:$?§§'<::=:"'f;w3V$ zrrségiea' far gersfmas' guaraﬁieéf af_§£'5s_; aiif23§éf:":?»§??-..:3:?5:é'..,T_Tf fwnge ﬁégaﬁimzvea' 5&3 ;;'3ﬁ;¢'!'?f?€f?fSI :§z;:{'§ 3;_f}'(: ) §:; ;'f':€ff:w:? ='ﬁsc;":?.; "

Ham iéw aferesaéé u:':§Vé.g--;'»§Z:'€:a<:i"--~%if:f:a'§e:*§a§v.{::'§..~§*e£sré; E:

ég ﬂea; Eézaﬁ Em agsesﬁéé E°g-as_'pf;3V§ a£ E9%§;*:{ £ZVVE":aém:a:1 §~»+'§;r.1I'é§aya Evéaéﬁxga §E.Ea§"3i"§iZ§."fj,':é.'_COFF?:"f%Bv§§$§:i)E"E.:.ﬁfé- EE'?€g§%?3S§S cf the war': which a_:;;§1ey_A§éAéT~9;€_«5 Q§iéIr'§753E'&*¥,§;€E :{';§-.V__%€'E"'§i'3_*'; {he ﬁamks, "me afsresaéd :z':aie:*%a§'.g§§45s3 é;*E§v$§:E':<§A'aa%;s§"---:Vh'5i ﬁﬂféé 0% the $ar:£<er3 has e§ia%;r:a:§_ zéiiev-»,;d§é'£éi§g ' the assets ané iiabéiﬁzéeg af"

""'§»'§f;§*9€?a¥§yé §§*:'~.§_z:§éa and a3u%:"3§éa Eszéég, B53 {get weaiih {E51 éxg.-"E?;g¢?§,£s? éakégg, %é@ hag Siam aa & §L;(3":«".a€§ii§.;':*' -iéé mggsecé ea? éaég iampanées am the tam:

E§§§*z$a-253$ frgm étéze §a;**s§<e:"5 £3 R§J;:5,32 €T€}E'€S= . §-§_é"~;'~":a§ Saga §3§E{.§ in aié a Sam sf R3125 fj§'Q%'§§ ag 2 H§_§_'7§§€ far 5:}? €$:"?$§§§?§§'§Q§'% E3, W31".

§§}§E"§?§§€€ ﬁamméggéan $5523? i}f:..€}5':§88 %:<3 3§;x§3,ii:§§§, ﬁw Cércuéar :3? R81 éaied 2§J?:';§§§ gm ﬁr; Same, $85 marzéatea mat the §&nE<;=5 wem requéreé ES agzszsze $%;é--?.Tt%se graciéae a? giving guarantées was mi %.§§$.§ >§:Y : '§7§"§€x §%{e5'£:<3§"§ as a Sammie sf rgmunaraiéw ,f:"»;::":"e the-ex b{j[:'*Vs*§?::s§f;'a§=, C%§?3i§&r'%%,.«' am %he éanks were a§gs;:5éa'E£;'é~s;ei§' me' a'>§'é:f:1j§iT? S{.§¢:?é5'« an undertaking fram the §ar_r:>w§s"£g.é{;.;;§;ga:':;§}%_;'_; '£vn'~fé5:{"':av$"--.. gar 323 axcééange ﬁcntrm Maﬁ--e:§5E',. g:"§o:'*;g§:*n"§i.=s§Eé:;n"5? QB:

was ramgéreé Ea aCe:e_§??c..V_'iE'2e" §--Li;<é-é?§%";'i9§§ @f E'éi§€.E'§. "Yéte Qagétéea Q? §'¢Er.%'v%aE§ya has-T.':h'3{'n5Egéé_.-.f}"a:}f:§ __€_§f2e §i:aia,s§ gf a regéémi :9 %*éR,.I;*..f§'f_r:~e gI_aygfmf~§.;*2%i:"<>€"'g;i;;--aVr§§§'tee <:9mm§$$E@:': ég mi 3 é=;_em.:mes?'a§'t.%¥{:r:1;4':,%.T:1'€Ee::*""$eci:E0n 3% G? the Camganiag ASE' ' E52 E:§"'é§e"'€i's§?:'€ 5:? {he afamagéﬂ G§$€?'xf§'EE$é":S ihe ._:_;'%j*'3}€»§§§€€"';:&'=._?Eé'§§»._€'§.§=i;'::S€?°: ﬁg gag: its iﬁanagészg Bizgaim" ihe a':as*ﬁe_;j:'2§$§V§:::s*f;'4:;c}:é iéze preiaxi $f ésés gignéiiég as a gL§&E"'§§'"':§;é;?' "-éz: ::a:2§7§<:%§"*€: 5? aim Eﬁarzg éasrrmasaé by we asgeggge fmm A V"'%{:::V;i§5:'s§;'3 §as*e§<§. in §§'§§§ £::;%t@><::, tag qusagiisn ﬁééaé: %é§{%L§§ﬁ // i;i?"é;€ g'a§§§'§§':§€€ §?"§a:"@ﬁ $3; ?C§"Z%§E"':T'% azéé wééers iééé éankg znsairé E} vziheiher we guazaﬁiea £G§T'§§"§'EE$S§€rﬂ gaéé :9 Eééa Evéanagérag ﬁiraﬁéfigr 5?' a Csmgamy £5; aiiawaéﬁe aa an éxgessééiazre under Seciéagn 3;? 9?" 'me Aaé"? . H} Ezzea E? ii: £5 aiéemiabéef in we faatg 3? the Ca§:€ _E:§* xazarranig gzzah aiégwanca"?

E4, in the érzgiami gage; W:&'"§-iE §EG_§: § §f3o'g.,,'~§Isf3<sé ?,_c§s,§"<3. mm ihe férgi qmgtéers as 222:9 ::au§:§ &ésTpf'::3§$e :.::f 'g.§:Ve..S2:{%f;e_;*é'é§»._ Quegtmn fmm tiae unﬁigguteé -fé"€.'%';._Mg.

13, Wha': ;a§__é7'~%§ z.:?2ee»V.<i§:a..;r:%:'a;s 9'? the asmpamg is a gaarantée eV:@é:":*:mEs;s§;<';i:*;.,V *§??:é§ %:;:§':a:a5§V'~:V§7:;;--r§"eur:§ mrrevged fram §3v»§'i§"'§'?7€:3;.:5;§§L;L':3 <f€};§re«;3a'n§¥@5 i:§"':;<3~~-': Ese extant Q? §§»§.3;§.3Z CFG§"&S '3F?{§_1';'§"%$ ~§;g"s.;ia§'a§%§§€E?§"_.C€f}m§'é'%E§S§€%§"s §aé$ Es Rs,:,1E cams §.e,, '--;'§_§f.::- 3}' %:_§":é..:5s't..«*3§L§ ba:':'ew%ng, Hég {set warm as as":

3§§._{§i§.s3;,E§93__§$ h}a7';@§.3z...F«:$g'?§.4? Eakizs. E': ﬁg 3 ﬂeas" 553$; $3 '::"§.«:;_3 §*'é%E.g.{ ---{>235 by Eha 5-§.SSE$SE?E§ Auiiéeriiy, a ;::3£§>';; ia §é\,ze}'é té:'§éf'j_.§s*%£ame <3? we £€'}§"'s"E§}§%"§§§S anger mg _;*:*Ea2*:age'é":j%gz::: 23.3 t§°*:e C§E"C§.§§§%' :3? 35:3 REE a§§§'€§"*:%:':é5eé ~ ";'é%:'%"éi«3~!fs@:*§tén3:2 ﬁzamg gaaié is zha ﬁérgcmrs 3?: 5% ésgaég :3? aavégeé 'Ea eiéégén an %.é§"i%§€E"§§%<E%"E§ fwm €53 i:;§:~n:w=¢§:';§ C€§?E":§8f1:E§ ma: am; wééi no: gay :*er::::;:":@_:"aié{:a§': a3 5 C{':.F'2§§§8§'atiQ:"2 far the Qéreaﬁwg gtandféng as guafaniggé'-agvhs S§§?"E§ﬂ ms? the amawni :3? ihe cemganyg the §§"'!EiZ§~*;€.gf3'_"%:§.S€?¢"V*i'»:% ?1S..' ﬁuagantae éjammésgésn', :6, "fézés Cam": had an 0%:-i:&:a§~;;'§'_1c>%§~'a" meaning of {Ea vsssré "E><§3§r'éiﬁ_§":*x;.gr@' 2:535 in ['3e<:::%:ji':'m...I':{}? in * ' 'size 933% sf Mfg. E.i<§Pa;_f2t?:ak§ \;<;a_:; , §n.:§m.e '?}§>< Qffémr is": ETA §\:a$,2.13 arzé 2:4';'-2aGf:§"--§:;§ . grader: 9, "EXpe;2::'E§:gre";'}{§"E§;,?;,}5f*.._:0'- fé><§e;:3e" $36 "e>;v,5>§";:::ié '5-V i3";i:':2:§;é'é;{'*- 23;: ::§é'<::.;E§t;'0r: aria' ;;3é:§n€;i0r3ﬁ. V ";?;'3¢;'rt G?' ".§;::e;'2a'i:?g" {rs 32$ $85758 af ";;§§%§r;:g' ::>a§2f" :;.<f4"a3;}%kaé'§}" mmey 5 me Qrzmary ,:f;*§§§r',%§;é§; ":i'T:><9;3s;9::3'§é1é}r€"§s' #2553 what is "gash? 53:15 _:;3 Ei5§}'" 3:*2v::.=;f--~';'§ §§5'?2?§£"§'?§;'_?§ ;;zzf?;'::f? E5 gms ;;:"§§:'f§;«§§:§_;{, "F23 :38 3;? afiawarzcje wféﬁia s:'°f§é£S§ ﬁr', "- _f,T-$6:"%5?:%'?§'ééf'~;j'§§C=*§ {>55 9;" away magi $9 {3} 55:35:33' 3:222' W._;,éz§§a§;'3r' §=:;*%a? axciaggéazafy far 52% gwgmss :3? 552a s5f2:.;$$}*:;£3$5 33;? farifser {$2 magi rm: E3 {5} {f§g3fi"8§ " *=.§A;<§é:';a'i£"§;r§, 55;"; §e,r§:;s";:5f s§:'.*X§E':"?§§ 52:" 5521?"; 3:? V' "§§fa§:a:§;?5& 53:' izfée :§:§r§::ie;" §'@.§{:r:*£§$Q' is: Cfééjﬁﬁté' {£2 5:2 {.;<;"v}< 853:" whgfever 5&5 azéargcéer <2?' #75' M34."

e,><;::£nci§§:;re, if mgjgi" $3 3 jag;/fag @535 gwgyp 35 gg" mi §£'?GE;i§?? 3&3: 62% a%'s§;;r§@;n§;';§§ we made 5:; éﬁg €§z',££i§€ 0:' gr wise aa: 32' G!' are {?i}f?C&f';"§€£§ W555? er maﬁa 95? 9f €325 §rafZ:'§§ $3 $536 basginaigs, 5&5" {'£'§é:{ mus? 53% Se Em 3&3 ﬁ§,.5f",9§S€ :3?" eamzisg :f*;:§_;?ﬁ.ré£":§;.<s. of we §u53:2a§;§¢ 35 magi be 3 mmm@rc;1a:«.g"}'05t$ §'E§e:*' ' 5;; :33 ngéazrg mass: ﬁg sonéemgfgbie a;::,f"sv:;;$;f;'<2.' "w.i§":":g mgre fagifi fféaf {he aggeéiseg» e;:€a_§i¥§f?é§'--.. 6x£5£°&r§:°e af gr; 5§f"€€f??§9!"?i" bvéizéﬂﬁn f:.W_~ Sniiéé? 3:55'-~. agenig maf we 53531" §}f"~..§C€"£.§'3i ;}3}9?F?€§'§_§4.v.,...£"§?j€ :1§s>':::re€i0;2 9f the fns0me?:'a?_>§ .«:2_ff£{:éé* «.525 soéygiﬁer whetﬁgr ihe e><g@vs'§ﬁé-§£:r5"A w;_aS';<?fs:.==:,§é:'e:aeX:::':.:s§v@£y far She pmjsase sf' the 51:2::;§%:s_§:*f:e's:§1'§;';;V519:5'-:;§£€é;;_away; M, """ e§E;:%e--i?:if£z?ure Qfzécyfred mgssf be far aeéﬁm-;9;"C§3§"=e%:<_;:>€(j£;e:=:3At';<.' 'fr; appiying the $355" 9:" gaméseéciaf §.>§,§3€?Va;;"1«'»,~<;*}*'.e'--:§/ ;V*.'*G:" aeiermmirzg ansfgezgﬂair 3:? éf?X;3€i?Q':€L?{_'g€ w;::s ;>rf2ﬁ§f;x and Qxafaggfwiy Egia' 953% fax ._f :}?2sE g§:;.%},5:.3sé'i2fv-.:f:§:? bzggérsess, seagorgafaiersegg 32' 5&9

s)>g;;;e:<2;§5:;;§;<s;% E255 m be aﬁjaségeﬁ ﬁrm": 5575 ;:va.ér2i" sf '«.T'__;%-szar §:£§';e."§3a2§§s*;@§5 5:23;'; gag 5:235 gf #29 .r°@ver3::'a W._f§'?2e, e,_><;::;r:'e§§i5n "C-:_'2mmes'5;'§f §;<§ea':'§:'"§5y" 21% §:?

e;a_<;:%§s_a*sia;3 $3' yvsgg impgrz $523' sncfucfeg 553$;

" *€X§§5!?C?Si§;§i"E £3 a» §;'a:§e:?€" éugiaesgmaa ;;rf;::;.;:"$ fer "-:*§i:§ gmrgagé af §é,;'5.5f'§€Sf§1 ?'}'7@ §:<,§@:"z€f3€;;s"§ may 5%:

fiéiif 388;; §f?£i§i"s"'€é égnafgr aria: Eagéf @bfég&E 'E$;'3,, $135 §:§aL:ja§s:*£a>& :3; aéegrziesf $5 a meamg m gay s"&n"%L2n$r§E%{3n 33 yea" 2'? 3'5 §7§Q%ﬁ2'§2f3§£' 3g 3 Si£Si}"§8SS €'}¥i,:'3€F?(§'§§"Li:"§,, if 3? wag ff'ECi£§":'"€§j 0:3 gzmsrzég sf 5es'2';me:z:*i§f exp§@'§$:::§%'., 2??:@ vmrg' "£'omm:5s:'a:3 gig:-cs fgfi far z:'G:'zs';,'§.:?i&?3'a4§:§*;*§' Er: €58 355$' juafgmemf gag? afsfar is Q'iCZ"f{}§?§;°'"}r' meaning if W35 f?s!5§J§sL5s*:rfj£'~.£' ~:' :6, ?}'::e warm' "C:::mm£$s:'m"' s'§"':s3:£?i§'§<::§s;2§;::e§i{;»f"

;'§':@§;'; 'ﬁigcmgnf', %r'%ff?aa" ':§§feé? ' "vrf:§.§r:2V:?"::';:;:}é§::3;f2v;._..§g° X3 perceséage deﬁucééa' in §f2:c5'e:f§5a<==;_ mg g£;s§§' are CQ§"§f§§Q'§"3@Q' £7539 :';2rgf3;:*?§ry §;'éé£§';'$_{75f §}*,%;e, §f"';5""§;*; éhg szsaéure Gf C9m;3enS'é$E§3n *;'T§: xi'¥?T'5jQf'I wfm has ffﬁﬁéféﬁ 38.31/£59 sszsééggi '95VV.;:é§§i:;§':fgéﬁuﬁeraéion, He frag §_,}éé'§E V7'p§f{! £o':?:§é':';ﬂ§3%iGn...»fén ;}€i'C§f'3i"§§€ 353155 a'r c§_?f;"~-;5}"';f;%§*£i'é"§g3§};<;,._ afxarﬂ "C9mmf$si9;?"

§?§§3";'§'€'f?ﬁf§:éEf::'.'%k"«;z£:?:£«If§:.?:"v'.§;;5f"%ff:LF{é!'%f"i"fG£'}3:'§QZ:"g3f?O!? @336' ;'§ £55365 a-s;§§m.:g ':;f§ji'?*a'§;*€i'.*_2gf' :+a;{:rms? 3?; in§g'V..§a4:f§<;é':¥a;.:g%~:ég :2' we :::;g:< we was facts :2? am ;g:faEg:«_*; *:h::::2»:_;§§;"t%2§ éihaérman 'hag gmaé $3 & §%Ea¥'§%"EEG§' .fEéE'$ §é3é§s2:1_%':2'2j_E_£a;§a ,i§';g. iha Barzéig 325219 éeni mans? 153i}? 9% :§§f'§§' _§3*§§"$'{§ §"§.Efl%_§ §;[:;:§ran:&§ bait 32*: {he &f>?§$'{E$ 2:»? %;he Caamgazéy :a;§':é%;<%: a:i'§@::.%?--%§*e:j?' ag § SE€%,£§"§i'y" tie the ﬁgmkﬁ ?§"':§?S §@:*3@%éaE ﬁg://",.,.

§&§"§§€%iEiE's:'€ av-E5 {hag E: E3 mi $:;§taé;"2a§§§, §"§€E'E{I€, we gags iha §:3%§aw§n§ gréer:

The saégtantéaé Qé£€Si§{§§ES <3? iaw is %%"§$W€?&ﬁ"~._§ §": fazzaur sf §",§"'2€ Revemga and agamst the A§s§5§@eV:H "

{E} ﬁggaai is aiiezwé, {E3} The méer gaggeé by §:%':'é £2.;r;3éa'¥Eat%_%';:%*§§;:r1-;§'E~ $3 set aside and the sréer gsaséésjf1i::_gk"f:hé*_§§.s~5&:;.g§;§§~.. ' ﬁxuiheréty ag waif 33 the A::*_§'&§.§ate :;'f}iQr§~§.g;zf%;§":=g$§'t;: é§" Sig regéareé, Partéeg ta bear 'ci*;&.§ii,:f§:ea;§:'%;@§>§:sf'~. ~ _ Café "

«c<\»m~.m~.o..w..m...,«............'m.......... . ..

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

The Commissioner Income Tax vs M/S United Breweries Ltd on 15 October, 2011

Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath