M/S.Golden Gate Properties Ltd vs The State Of Karnataka on 13 July, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 2]

Karnataka High Court

M/S.Golden Gate Properties Ltd vs The State Of Karnataka on 13 July, 2011

Bench: B.V.Nagarathna

K»)

_g_
EN "E"E'"Z E51 E-'--{E52}? Ci®E§§-9?'? G? §§1%E%'N.!7%."§Z%'§'i£X EYE' §§;"§N{E>A1,G§%Ei
E'}:'7'z.'§"E'-IE} TEEES "§'§"i{i iii?" .{}A.'si' {)1}? J1} E}??? 20} E 

i E3{iE4'O§€E%: :

*2';--$3 'E---;<>m3 1%: was. JUSHCEE :3.xiNA<:«A:§:*r:»~;§rf%;.5;"   =

w.z»>.1\§G. 12689/2:: 'H .:f:=3§3;s_;j " " 
BE'I'W'EEN: V '

M;s£;0::,':};aN {};'¥E'E§ z>R@PE:§-2%:'H.f;s gm V _
BY F18 E:X£§CU'§'m-We: §3:RE;c'£'«;>R,_  "  "
SR1. <:,;>° SAMAY Rj\,.J_,_ E'\JO.E;%2_Q_, 80; %'?'%f%%"_3£:i':'
§e.@;u3? 8"E'§~E §3LOCK,_ }{(i}I%§;'xE%ri;'§NGE%{.;zi;,  - 
BAN@AL@:2_:i~5§0 {:95   '   .A 
   PE§'I'§T§ONE§€

{By an. S2JT:;v;::§;igggtai--3.13 5 ii--{i§.E':{E'€31?~zf£3§f!f'fi'3,V_§f;'if§k?,}

AND

:( TI~i 1:; S'.{.'A'i"E*T--«.;O"1F?KfER?*EA"E*:'XE{A
3:33? Yrs 3-':33§}~ET'IQ§'~lAE;..CE§.1E? SI§C§{E3'}?%.R'{ &
::€3::{{::$«i:%ss:'{>?~J'}::::z,»_ U--RI%3AN §}E§V£§LGPM.EZN'E'
::i)§«;:PA;§§"if;vr§aNT, "azxivszg-XSA s0z;I:>:m
; 'E3_f3?JGAI;?}§R%:'%58€"- 00:

;%3;%f3~::<:;::4o§a«:; :3 :::v:3L<;:~.>:x«: 2.12%' ;a.'::*:'§--§_<>:z:'r':i
* ._ ;£;,%f~g":fr€::_ Cvammzssiemzzz.
 '{:3{:g%;ra:;;»;;:;;x_:TT: §«2:<}AI;>,
g  KU;ur§;aa.,R2f:: 'E*2"»£{§£ 'ﬁx,--"§E.S'IE.
 E}%15:E\.7{;A.LG§-1?<E3w56Q Q20
'  '  m=:,s:;;>@?:\::>z_«::'»:'§'$

,, "~:z:s;,:§;»;;.-:';'§<:.$;2:/ijzaéjrgqgxggjz;:\s;sg;a,:A»:. E-:<:<::r>. ma Em
*  '§:,§€a:A.'A:a::.31::T:;>s»::;s§z;>a52-«»1_E~;y_.gia:zfa Eeagagzsaa A.§j}'%:'. §<='{}§¥3. R21}

"§'E"'IiE';'",€~ E-'x-73} E'?-E.§x.tE:::'E-:} é§§'€E}§§;E{ E-'i§{"E'E{f%.Ei§} 22%  22? SE?'

 'E."'.i--i§:"Z {?{}§'\l7§§§."§"§"'Z.§'?i{}I\E OF §F\§£i}§;'-'Fa §4'§'%:"¥°:"E?*§i} 3?} {"}ERE':ZC'E" '§'E"§E

§§"E'}'1'{§"§*§ €:}€:3="v"E5?-€?'~;E§VE§%Z§"E' '.£.'{} E885 E7: §"~;'§¥Z{f'E§«S§§}'a§<E"{ §}§E%E';§*ZC'§"§{}?~5;%
€.§"§'-§Ef.I3§'€E.'9§ ES'E§{I'§'E{}?'\E {£5 (E? 'i'E"§§i §§E}};'% .5-'-':C'TEI §§}?{*}. 375} "%"§"-'EEC Eﬁlﬁfi
E-3?'? {fi%'Z}i'\§f%:E'§"f}EiE3~iEE'€{% 'E'§'§E%', .§%.EiZ{Z€}E2?§?%z'E§€EZ'%£Ef.}51{E."E'§}?'«§E?} 5}?" §i3ET}f'%

_/ 3.



?»J

ET}f§'E"E'§3 €152: Eifhiii} E U SE§§'3?\£§E'§'ET'E§-El} ".570 "§."'E"§ E {E{}'€'3E'%.?€E'\/.§§€I'£'§' E153
E:3:'E¥T;¥'€'; ANNEX, ii faﬁff} E':?71'C.

 

This; ps:%i.3i':.§<m {*:<>mm;§ 0:': $32" §}i.<?'i,:3:'E'.E:1;g {}§'<:Eer:e5.. 
ihéi cﬁzszxﬂ. :':':2;1{ie i.}1.s:: §o11:>xx;§::;;j: '
Q' R B E R

E2: E'§2i5--:*-,4 wm, p~::*:'i,i¥;.i0:1 E'.h«::% j§}E;%§;.i'iim';.€*'3.f Ej::4:i3_si§"  é;:w.,§lg_g§§5_;'i, :1,

€§§re::3;.i<m in re:-3p{:I3<ieI1i. F~E0s,E a=m<i 2V_?i.<3--_pe;"z'n§i, .i.h'e:2..§?2§:"iV1?:§{;.:2é;<_

E9 §im*e'i<>p :E':e:>: ('fiVi(3 a:1":<:::1"§"é.:§g' E1T€&iSI?§€fi'?'}§(§Ii€d in'

r'eEin.qu.i3h.1:ie1"r%; deed aimed 2513'.i..2§}é3'E_{A1"1z1Exu.r°€¥C} 21:16 '('0
haxzdmrer :.E1.:*. same is €hci%' j."'3€*'..v§ﬁ:'§§;i3fE1('§'i""-.E£;§1{'3 211E5{} gtzamaﬁ: 'iihéf
petiﬁorler is H1%:3.;E'11.I£7{i1"1:"{(h(;'.'p;€LIfkS.. ',£:.§1€C:'{§'§}{§E1 areass. in the-1%

:"'€ég22z.;*éi_§ :§ev€:f;':g§,_--£ii:;°<£{%Limf:.S'ha:v_<3 be:-er; 8c)2.:g'_§h.i':.

£2. '§"h£>.«L'pet;1':',i.€§t:éf s:s:a{<;:s' in the Writ Peimon that it is-.; 2:2

;i}mg_§§§:"E,'yi :ievé%1:3_§>ér 21%.. E:§a.:1ga§0r'€: and Hy«:im"a%3ad Eiéféfi is

A §:ng_§a:§§,é{i.A&§:§1:E::3,1EEd§.ng§ §'§{"31§-';§€f*§ at; 21§fc>;"€§:3.§3E€ pmtes zmej is 9,.Es{:=

  »i'§-r<.;%1p §'Em.3sim_g Pr0jez;?i.&--}; in a?;3.rE<:<:.1:;2; §<>{:;-:i.i€L%.€s=: in

E*32is'--:§:§21.E._;:%a*:%-_.  'E"§':a§: 'ékﬂcisizl i§3§s:§s$<m:' 2:53 .2: ;g:*»:3'L2§3 h(}U.Si§3§:{

.' .:°:?$i.s:i&;";--i;:§21i p:'<:s}eLt%é, ::(:=n1.p:'i$§n;§  fiziéss in  b§(}{:.k:~3 whiciz

'AA§12a$A"b~:%€::1 (.§.€,*=.,~*<;=.I§(.2g:>%3{§ by' 'i':§*:£% p§3i.§§£<>1*wr {mm }:--;m§; ii": an gimzéa :32."

v,,}'

 ;iiCf3f"€E-.':3 53%} §§.§L.2"£'%§.E1E5 sf "E2-zzégi sa£':,L.:a£.€{§ in S§:,';'~1:35és,2¥§'E'",/E. a:":€E

e

 E£z;::?t:,2;;z:2(TE§ 'E-T'i§E;':,,_.;?§::*. 2.1%. ER-'E.':§E£:{%Zs=:E:, §{*3:1§':g;§z1E<:::":3, aim:

573%-13'; <fa.r='3:«€} <2? i§::Z%s3?E§;'z:':§": 'tféiizlzgéé. '§E.';12:'% '§.h<=% :*s:%§e;§}s:i3:'2:E<:=.:.'2.E--



Ci}:'1'1§";'1§::;&;§<>;':er, 332%}:-*z§'1 §.}£:"a-"c%§<>;3:::e§§§l' if}:-3=paé.:f£.m€§'3E: rs:%Q:,:es;*;'.ii':gg
'E13? ::<-:{*.<';:&ss.sz1z"§,/ {ii§'€'.'.(".'.{§(}§'} $10 EEK-5 E§§'i};5': Ea 1"€§::%as;e 22:15} ?:.2::fM§:w€::."

{'.f§*v'i.€;.f 2::m=:§":i£:}«" &}Z'E?Zi 1:3 €..§3a% c;§c*:\..»"€;E<;%p<3:*/'apa;:*{,z':1.e:1.:.'  t}i*-sréers'

213s{:<:§a¥i.i.<};';' CG§3i:%:="«; of '§l"1.e sgaééi §=:2§3r<~::'~;e;'_1£,:1tﬁgs? *

§.'?I2.2GE E is pr=:3s:iu{?e%d as §}';EEZE£?X{L£E"§f:;§ gmd K.i9§:§§:s'}3T%%;":t§'¥$::*1:;:,V E33,' V'

§c:3E.*;'.er <:iai;a:e:i 2 1.4.20} E, :"?:2e pe1:i¥;:i:>i'1{3:z: 7;-=é::»:..<.§ §z.ii":>z*:~':1é:cE  31.13.16

11:21am" is»; :"i{)'~.i-' in ihé.-% 0i"fi{:e' <}{'---fgize BEDA «'.-1I1{;£ _E.§E§E"€'.§f()}'*Ef, 'i:E1<:.--, 

p€':1't.iOI1<-3:' w{;>uid haxre Eta 2:;}p;'{;_:;{£:Ef;_ E::4.E_{;', 8:323. in i.E": :?J£ r€g?.:dK
Undczz" {he {-EiE'.{.:'{.§_2'IA:S5':.V.Ei.'§'.].'::.\:i:)"E$§"' 't.I;:j_1§ "'§}ei:iAt'io.n.e.z.' has sémgghi
a:iir€.€.i;;1{>n53 in 1.€IT'§";r}§F': G? 2i%e5,_;§1141::i,.£:>n.$".L1?1 §:>§ ih':é: Revised Masha?

Piaf: E{6g1ii£1§§.;,%§}S'%:--§2{:?)3  . Z:

4,  h;ave V§~"'Ea;'.-i?i_1_"Ei'. '%;I;E::: '<i.€_:a.--r:é.€d Senior C€§U.E"ES:'vE'31 for the
§>§:i,'§t.i@n[éy._21:';~d 1;hr-3 §"z:::Té1'£":e§c:§,_:é<>L:;/2%} for ss:<:<>'ncE r<--:--s3p§m<:Ee::m. as

weii gag {he Gg'w:;":'::':2<::1"f:T Pieadezs' far the fiysi. :"'é:sspo:1s:is:":L

re

.' 31., 2 {:3 is; =:t%< > :*ﬁ:<;*17;£ie{i on beizsaif {if 31%: pe%.3§*£:<:He:* aihaé. '::he:=. E%§f)A

H€£['sLE'§€}§.:§E"§€fE1i"_v».Q§i:; §:i'J§{f E§};"E':t'.I}iE_}? Sifaéé} E'3<';uE€$9 198% {;'aE':'3: not

.21p§§i€<:a.vE:§i::'v*::z> {he §i'E§?£{21E'?$£Z (rage Sifliffi Eh: §}é':éiii{3n.€;%:"S am

   :.°c%E§€f in §'j€I'EE'3;'=-.3 5}!' R::g':.:.E;1§é<§z1 '?'.§ sf 'éhe R€;'.'J§:'~,§€€§

"'51€::ss:i'fm' §3§2m--2{}.E Eé gmé i4§§.<a2§"<;%i%_:ra: ﬁgs? z*<":§"e3re.:z:>:'»:r  magic Eta} E1339

' ~::&;:1.§€§ §€'.mEe:3 is; :"2{§E, {f{}1"E'€3(?L it is; 22§.5§=;<§ $€.;a:ﬁs:*:.§'%; 'ahaé. 'i,,E'::3 EEEEA §":»:»§s:;

Ea; §_;':%_.I%§.€?' ::§<*.t>i5;§{m w§"é..E.: :°$§,§2::;ré:'i ii} (3% «:35 :.%:€: §:_-ma'? vg.-"E':.§<::E'; 



 Per {.:{'}l.'§_E:\E'.:/-.--'§._é E{a2::.m.<:%::.i zjramzzzestéi fag' me 3"<:s;g'3<>:":{ie:"z.é. v::='h%Ee;:>
§"{T§€?i'I."i§}§___§ Ls} Ehéf ${,Ei§§;E"§'!'Eé'fiiEE, 213.? :3':3"§e.<:3i§.{:;1'.1s; has s,a1,:b:':::?i.ij{:'{%_ E,E':ai:

Eﬂhsst .B§,}_z'§ had 1'é;?quc%s;E'€{§: iéée {E-<>s;€rz"m1€é11I;. s;2mz::é;,ic}::  21 i1:>{r:::é':2é.

G? {Ii\fE{?f 21;'1':e:%r:;ii,y si.€'.<::<:s is {$16 ;i}fEE~'c£i,s';" cE€:ve§{);f}£§2's; -2:;;€id   V

:"'€{§u{fr$f;1 ieE'ie:' sf ihe ;>e£,ii.1'::=:2cr W213?' 3;}:-s(-->. 1a;}.{fc:'1_§:§§'i:~:*:_ 6).? '§«:i; E1192:

5:033:22un.i<:2:1i'.i<}z3 sgeni. E10 M16 €}<>v€é:':i':11e';'M.A' E13}; E}:;:é Eiillzﬁ 

2?acE';:i{:::': {:¢u:1n<}§ be E:ai~:e:'1 by Egilé---Ej3£:ZiA §3s,.az*ss2.;;1:<'::: "£12; %,h:;€"Vié;':-a{::ai:'z<:&= V'

sf gL2,id(E§§I1€'.S by {ha S'{,fc1§_E*. GQv@r_§£':31.€f'm_': andW;E<2.€:*'€3§br<ia umiﬁ
the S'F;:aJ::€ C}<we1°:1rz1e2'1i"' 1')<3rm.i:?;,s§,;--. ﬂhré'» ;;%i;i.E1g>rii'}? is take 23.

s:ie:%isi0rz in 11.19 zf;1g:w:j,'t'.m' 27:5 V:>:;'<:'i§lg3n.'{?<§é;:_i£i bi-3«.:i.23;ke§2 3:33; the EBEEA .

s:ﬁ)::i:i:'€.s i:E_1:-it  {}c§'<./ermxlenl. E1213 by £€i.'t:::>r dated
2:w:;'201';V._;m si:a_:.e.:{'g-:a'§--s. :it,':s {by 3.1116 BEJA {.0 :99}; £213.53 she

z11z1£';éz", if 21 dir:=g:_t.it>é': :53 .i:i~:s'2.:ed by iiliss C<:::,:.ri.., the <:;1sse of E:h:':

g><:§:z°%:.£f):é'2_:{i"::_'W§>z:Eci E36: e":::3:'::'~sid{-sratii in {E163 Eiggfzi, of R<;=v;'.sed

 1':/Ea[:'€;i,€%:"~ §.>§:3.§é~i?;.xQ§-V5 azfzéi in 2.'a<:{:<}.z':§a::u:*;s*. xvii}; E21133?" Azizzexzzywi" E

is; '§1;§,1€ E§%;E;:' <}§~V'C,;§'S§%'.€%$ whi<:h Ezgwﬁé bsjeia raiiizzzgazifaiaeci by i;.h<:é

V"~;}:*iv21:.é?-§§%wE:::§>£;%;'s and S€'3E'i.éi§ N355" '? {:3 E} in %;.h.a: Séiid E13:

" --A;.:2'<::":"§V,;?;.§§2 ii} '%1Ef1a: "g.}<%£'Eé'£€;-m;é:'.

8; .%.ﬁ';?'£:Zi§'E'"£{'f{§ {§<>ve:*m:r:z:%z;§. E3§€fE1d§;'i'E' has; s%s'£a%i,@d i.§:.:'ai 5?;  {ii}?

%..E'::i= E§§}s"%, E3 "é'2=2E«§.<-? £§§::{?§s:ie:>:': in ms: :1'":2;1€..€<2r GE" §,§"E'%,§'2'E',£§Tk§§

§'2é:*::*:::":i;*~:;s~";'é--:m in. €::%§':'::55e £35 E-¥i::22jz2§.2.§§4§:2:'": '?°f§, "§"§'":a3:'§"<?%'§'£:=;:°:';":' mi:

, r,/>/3,



Cii§'<;':{%'£'.i:?;:': «:'%0:2Ed his £:f~.;:%;ue;?{E is é..}1m S{.at.c C:{'}"\-7E?i'E'1§'E'1€§'éE. £1": EE'2.;t:i;.
zmsgzz Hi .

§. E.---§a.v21ng,{ Zréegzrd 31:": §€:;::':'1<3::.i ::t:>:;::':=£§@.1 fem' 211$..._;3:%E:§i,i.a:3§r:::¥1":g;

zmd 0:} pé:%:'a.:.$.22_Z z.>.f1;,E1€. z:'1zm:*:1"£ai on 2'E',{,'.€}i°(§.3 it i.<'-;--__;#3<>i};T<::€:éi E.£*:3. § '

ifwrs: p€:':.1'té<?:n:%r whr} 15$ i.hé:% CiEve}:>;}:i€:: h€1'¢2 '_{§§:?v<3.§:}péd  g=:'<2z.1'p

h0ussig'1§;}; 1'€s.i{ier:i.ia1 §3mj<;%{:z. <:z1ii§%{% 'i{3€}%_<;i€:n B§§}SS{}I'§'~§ V é.:"E'--~ .;£1'1~ 

zarea Q!' 8 E3.£3:"t':35:§ 36 gu:.m;.as~.; (3.? .'1;;1;:'."g§:§"'ab'z'. E§2z€1L:g{;:iAij¥{TiHé;gé.'" in '€h.€5: V'

szaid §;I"{§LI§3 0%' E1c)azsa;i:3§; §.)?{.§j'ti.Q§_.:'* 536 if§£1'{"SS'~ fiaézvesr E3e€;1

c{mst.m<:t.c=.d and fiat 0viréw_5r's'L.h.i1xg*e '£'é:32f.:i*:::::'i«.t.E2€m.s3e§ves Ema

 

"Gcziéen }E3E{:s~3s<<.>:.:i:v.._ A;j{e11"£i"rit::.:1:._ '  ..:~_;o{r'ia;'.i;i¢3:3' w_h.i.ch is 3.
:z°eg?i$E,ered 1.-§:>?T(;»i€}:   {jbrv-€i_:'z1ré;1e:12%; has app1*5'Vr:d by
0rde:V':da1.;<:.::i V21':VE3V,20Q?"v~._t:?:e:_ 'Re\r'§s<--:d Mastar P'Ean--2G35 for

E3a'r1ggda>rc3.E\f£e*ETr<'}§5<:»§§i;i:'1  Tha :3bj«:*.ct 0? 'ihﬁ? ssaicé. E\iI.21S{.er

Pielzsj 35?; to h2«1v€: 2'2, ﬁiiaziizisci g_3;r{>wiE1 of the ctiify. "Fh.e.:"e aré-2 Zena}

'' §%g:gi:.§e1€,:::';.1.s"@125! {he §(:»<*;a§ pﬁaszifzézfzggg" ama i.<::..§ §3.£1:'i§__§£1}€}§'t;':

 fs!§':¥*'fé~::":.f};g>'«:é§:'i:s;3E1;>;§aE§€:€:::": aiivideai %.",:':'i'.() 4'? {:»1&..§T:}{Ei§'.1§;j {§i55:.1"E<:?l:s; bzlﬁﬁd

{2.:1."'e:faz"§§3L.::;.g:,e'£az':n%r1g §}&1E'EEI}'1€;f§,€'.I{°E§. in Ehif R€\?i$€{i Ma:-sﬁez' }¥'ia;.§':..

'' fj%:1§E1.<3:"§--i.f;-*' E55 de'§'§:'1s3£§ En'; r;':Ez1:'3 iii:-2.,'1'1g2:.i0r<7 E'){§v<;%E.0g3;:12e3'1':.

' '...,:'.1TV3.\sVkE,§=.",'f5_TE"C.}§"§'§.:,.-"'

336%, <T1i'":2?é,.§3':€::' 1?' <3? §l:'"§{". 51;2E.iz3£{i E'§{i','*.7§;¥%iTf{§ Mz2:s=;'§.<%r §>ia:'}«2{}3 E"; {is:é21E:%;
2-=a:"i§E': Z'i?f55;«§{'§i'?E1'§,i.&*2.§ <%:?*:.?€E:'3§:2z':'1£m;é' ;:}E2?a.§':é.:--~: :-3z2'::'§ .:'T:<:xn~:*:3§;i{i6:'":%§23:§

§;§€:%~':=:'.§:.};.}'§'§'2€:§':é'. ;}§:;::'%5%:L E¥3;s:-?i§,2;:,2E.:.: $122: Z3  :'<::I:€i5=;  }'E2§§»:§%-'.<~.';:

€'
55¢,/_
xv" ;



':"?§§ Keguiafiﬁns far Resider:ﬁia;£ Deveiagment
Piarz:

.3 , 353% aigf 5.3%:-> fang? s§'T:s:2£E be re:~9erz2ez:fj%:vr 
C{Z'}£'?'E sapace, "f'}':€ aperz. spézc::a<3 {pczz*I<:}__s;?::z:f§£iAE"  *'
?°(£{§;'z€'{l.£f.£§'i'§{j£Tf, {.0 {figs S/[:zz{.§1;(3ri:43,;&]'%°eé_:;f'.

{"516 ;'«;ams-.> mczgg be e::;ZEow'é5V ii} 93¢'--;m.s;ir1T:§z§:';<%;i" 
by ('he Eocrzi.  A' I :Ti:'$,;<.jAt§;:iz'.;§i£.zfoz*3:'«.  TA

{z'e>gisIe%r'e»:1,?. if Kim A 21' z'.§'_1.or:' zy ' 5:0' a:fe5§ §.z%;%S'. ; V V  _

2. A z':"zZ.m'm:.{r?'Ei3'3é; q_f ..§.',>:'rZf.Aé:":.E._ pa): aI"Qd:' v€9f'1Q£..§'§ be

;:m:-zsicieci.jkézr».ﬁizgig:*1'a:':{;:3:"iif:i~is3::A 5a~:1_of Elite owrzer
OE" developer' 'T'sf1.d£'!_   _ sé-5.26%': civic
az'::§>,:.*i§i:i5?$ z.::§§éiC2fé  Shazwieai, over'
_::e::* .   £<;>c§;:E__ I  _ejesi:£.e5§§;i.:§ :5,:<V3socicz{:iorz _/Tor

Vzzigozin?;e:§rzaf::_fe.,_V '~f£'?:é "mach sf sztcfz. §n:me:fing

._ €)::é:<":7:.-'agffiéVbé~<;{éc£}~:{.s?ci by {"318 c:z.zz,f1ori§.g;.

3} ,_£F'?%,?{ is «;:c:§c::,:'£qi&_;=d on 5319 EGEQE Eamii area oﬁer

:EeC§.:zﬁtii'z'i:g C_'1}€C mn.em'.{.3;; size.

9?. .P:e.rici:zg; (gram. re{gz.zi2'e:?'2.e«?n:s s;f':aZE be as

 "<:_,§3T;;a§i%z:=:a§>)§a> if-:'(£.e2 'f"aE;>§£3 m>:2:§

~E~%;"<>ad$ as; 352522;??? in {E29 §%3{;>a:é§;€€§. ii/§{2;s;:r-gr Piaf;

' 9?

:25} shzzié Egg :'_:2::7z>r;3e:>:'a:ee:§ :.zs§é§'i§§f: P5552 s::.n.c§
5;f'2{.:§€ %;zz;> §?:e:a:':5§€c£. £2225-5:' {'5} 52325 a;,zE§2<}:°:z.g;',f'r<3.:* 53,!"

57535: 

-"Sn :5»: §'€;T:z":£§é2':;_;: if 3332-: ::;2;:.§;{§ E"€:?§::':i.é§.2'-i§.E€'}'£'7i' ié: §f3€ff{T.'{f§E'E'1f:i%"§ éiiiéééér 'é.E":5;'{'.

ni

--:E;::.1'2 §':;~f:s%3 {<3 E32?

 .

E5}?/E; ii}? %%:,.{=. §2::;':':{i .§§'} 25: iTt?55§d{f§'§£..§:.§ <.ic::*£'.§§:s§32:'§s:%:'":i.

-£62» :*{~.*&;e:'z:*e%s.§ {:7-2* g_:em*Ev:-; ;>_21<i 5339:': s'~s;}a<é:~:: zmii :"3% 0%' 'iéaér é.<}'é,:1§ §£iE'}{§ 212:':-3:21;. §:a$ 3:} bit I"%:$t%:z"v€-ii Fm" <.*iv.%<t*. a§":'1e1'1it:}; g3'm'§:>:}s3€: §:'1é:s::}€%';::* 22.5»; Eh? E.{}% 0:" é..%f1:=: imzd :*{:s~;€':'ve{i Fm" §3£iﬁ"k 2:115 <J_§;'€:';:« 3 <:7<)z*:::%{:r:':'1<3£i, {Em ssemzsts has; 30 bf? r:::iiI:qa.zi§;§::t{i_ .§';:yV_ _:$'i'Z:1§;% '§i§év§:1::§§:%;., u '£9 ihe ;'7§1,1E.hL>:".%i:y .i.e., {E33 BEEA zmd ﬁle »:s_5j;é :1f;{{'::21§:é_' he---:':_é= 4§3::"Ei§f§"£15EV.t'_g{'T is be: I}'121§Z1{'.£:'s.i.I'1€:?t{i by me E<)c:a}TV 1f€?S§i{K?i°';i'.55.§" '-5_?iS%E-3{)(7',,§v;E'V?.'.'i.A1'(}'ZV'§.. §f'is-s{§'f:-"u:" é as 5% Of {he £1E"€{:-1 pmvitiséci '221::1éé':'i§_i.;§'€s.V-is {:§<33'1:{t::33"'r:<L3{ig ihe ::§eva=:E0_pe1:' E1215; .,,4,;f§e:"ar§:'iV'<§'}:V: '£'ﬁVE..3:1t';';,ﬁi1§"i€:':':'s zmﬁ ihe§"e21fi_e1', ';.he Si£iI2'"i£3 $0 {he 30026 ;'e':sssid<:n£;ss assz;sc.:'é':;f;.*£',1i':::1 mode 0? such handing <)i§,ré1~':.E?12'3;§" {he AL1£,h0r'i1.y ihe EDA. "'Th<;%:<é:f;:';'z*6? "f€'é;f219«E5s§é';:'£,z1i.§.L:iV:":'é3V halve 'wean. made in that r€%g§£t:'c¥...'s)e.'£.h 3i}jQ"'HIE? €3§ﬁ§?C}7C5'[}.€f as; well as; the Assecigliioyi to §}€:3§'§"£1I§§, '£{}%.af' 'é,E1:2."~p;1_r9£%;:.._é:ﬁd <3pe:3m spate whigéiz hag been §'Ei}§3}€§E..E§$E}€{§ fig} 1,%1e".E{§§}:*: far pem1i.é§S§{m E10 m2:1?m"gu':é fix'. sam.£::~ .. 4, by:_'_z:'%2§3;;??:s5<;<7ig;>.€:ia:}:*:'2zr;«s:£ '§u:*ihs3:" .27: :"€:qu€3s3'§i E1215; azissii bean. zzzaée:

,:,%:€5_ :§~*;:*ﬁ;.-"iii%i§;)_m£:::':E. of :.'3% 0? E1326 Civic: :7':m€::;:21?'§ji{~:§ Aféféiéﬁ SECS j'i_'.§V'15'é'.§':£'.ﬂ§i;E $%€£§1;%j"igiisiiiii be hE1§}{§é3d {}V€fI"" E0 the §.{><j::-3.2 ,z'€:'~si.::E€3'1ts' E%§35§€}{If§£?z§.i{§£Ti"_..§'{}E" .i"_fEEi§E'1i.€E18.£".'§I;'ff5t. 1='v"h§§«:% {?::>'§'::':;%d§%1*§'ng; 'ihﬁ i~:=a§.d :'{é;:»§'e:%:%;é;%:';:§:2.a:E<>:':sa§ tj§';e Eiiﬁﬁx hsss; 2-::.§.i>pE:::::.§ {Eric §%a.:§:;=::'=:; 0%' E989;

, %;a§'1§§;':*"; in £223,-"' *=:§«;%%,%;: are:': 30:. :;*a;'}§'3Ei:'f:»;:.§i}1.é:x §':2a;z=°§:.";.;; 2'e<;:;;ja::':§ 35.} mt:

.§éIi.'{I'E M"§.::iE $25: :':¥:g§z3.':::-2i.i<>z'19«: zmfi §i§€%,%'"U§f1,fE§£i;"E§r' E-[€£>;;§°:§T§2*:_'%,::',{:>:": 33% :«'.:§°é;°: ._ ..r:€%€:2.::'§§«-' :Q;§}:;*<:i§:E'{'= zsamé E.E":<:=:}g Extizzgg; £:i§T§§}E°{}'€,-'é3{i §i:sj.; ':.§'2é3 -E%3;.Ei§.%? xi/./» ivy/X':

_§ §~vvu {}:}w:é1.':é:3}€:'1E': wmziéﬁ 11.2-:.ve 2:1': <:»*~.:*£é:*:'§§E§':'2g;j ziﬁéécrii. <33': Eihﬁ K389 E{u.}e.s§. Ths E§3é:%%§§ R:.:?.::':~:~: <.k-_%::'-#35:»; with 'she a.i.1{>¥;,m:ién'E <35 Céﬁaiif ;-"-'m1.e.r3i'Ejx;* Siiﬁe Ea: va;'im.1sa c:;1Eeg<>:'§es af §}€§"S3{§1"iS 1z1.r3:1§',i€)_§*:£:€§in {he Eiéiid R{."iit'.'iS an E€:a$e basgiss {ms éiim pu.:'§3c}s§;% *<>£' g3:r:>:€;*E{{f§:*:§.; Civic ;'7§lEE1{:'E§"ii)£,iE*.;'_%' s.:sa.:bj<;cE: to t:e;~:r*é,2.2._i;°:~ %'.«::.:*'::1s%: a1:9§:i* :.:::3:é'd.§'I:E:>r:é;; u r'\ . R A . . . 3?, . g ' --~ 1116 €:><:§);"{"3€-§§%:<>:3 Civzéz.' A::r:€:n1t.y Siiﬁ? '-is €_i<:m1t?:€§~.':.n. Ciexgza-36*?) =02' Seciiogl 2 'L9 r":1.ea:1 an a;'é:~2%; ?::7£2':.;'1<;.<=:c§ 'E:*::" c:i_vi:.:.v e1:3_'::€:?2i:§,y': in 2:. ' }&};{>m .i'0;':'r:€:*d by :-m2: __2:;L1Eh£>r§._i_,yies?sr1z1;zrE£<3ci"~i3_nQ%5 21 §:»'rive3.£,e Ezzjgmaé. ap§>:"<:va»-'ec§ by i.h.<~3";:sw;:E1<§:€i1.j; £:::%ii- §f'23i'E:':€,;»L1is§E1€:«*:i £0 £3,

1. Tlrxe c)bje%{;i' of ﬁﬂhe _V§€z;:x:'a§;:ka:' 'E':;i,>m zmci Cannery Plamiing £§.€éL"'1._91€§ii~":;js i«:;._V;-3__19£>m'VCL'$% Pei" :"egu.i;3;i',i<}n sf piarmed ;__§r<:=w{h of 1_21ii§.;4_:.§é" «:<'md_€§<3y'c3.,0}:1ne111, and. far the making and a'--:xe<7L2ii{22f: "(sf ':Q%.&~'::iV. ﬁizsgizziizg 8Ch€f11tE3S E53 {E16 Siaie ef Kam8;i;.2:kz:;"~. {j1':,ds';::' ':?;é'~~§4§::§; what' 13 s:;wiseag;;ed is is create §':g%3~'a'§::'é._1%'f;%§'§;1<5% <éc>§;2"d.itj_;}.:f;,:; ':0 garavids fuii <ti'vi.{: and 5-L3{:><?::ia.§ '2:.:_;1€:;1i%é»€-:5-=3 .§E;i;--'. §:E":€ p:%{§;,:>Es:: <3? iégié Siexe élfid {Q §mg>:*{>'v€ ézxisaiirzg :°€{:;°§§2::§.i«§;.;;é;§ -§£?:'?(",?33§§_.E('EfS:§ 8£.Z?}C§ €3E.hé3r a:§wz'1§t:ies C<'m'L2"§E3ui.i:2g '%i1{3"§:y?21r{i:§e. '§:>§.;t::::é, 115%'. {§£" Ezmdéis .21:':{i it} g;§€%2":«s:*r3;EEy §3rGm<}'é.{-E 5§.2«:§":éa':2'§E$ {>5 E:'s:i:"z;§f, 'EI%m:'<:=:§<:s§>z:<§.é;%mi.° Ezaf-3 %::€'€:': {§¢%{in€=<§ in S22-§:3§~'C,i§z?:z.§;s:§t {LC} sf' Se::;:'é.:§{>::1 2 (sf é..E:t3 f'3&éZ'?§.' Eincéer S&<*:i.§m': { £2} P§.a.:1' §;<=:; ~'C4§E.{§E}.fi?{§ ii} §EE%'3£iE'} :1 p§£1i'"2 {gr %;,Efs.::3 {§£%vé;é§a:--p;1'u£:.:":§ .31' E."é:E'""ai§€:?¥€i3E{}§}E*£'Ié?§"§E' 53%" i::':':<% ;::r<%a:z "2%.="§§h§:.'3 'éimgz "§'1.EE"§~:'.-is'«{iiL".3;.§{I}§"§ er}? me':

g§I§;1§'::T§§:':;:;{ :a:::'%;. 2<_}z°§1.};. °?§2'1:2:'2i:'1;g ﬁ_.::é;'E':(3:"i§.f;f E9 <T§€§E:':<+:'§ £2":

':4, .§'Zl"§_.i:E.§3'}.'§,€'E1EiE'1{TiE?., "E'h<'é%..':g;{i*: ¥l:E'2€: €.'>§}f3.Z': -.':%p?;{?€i? mlii gi:s.231:"k; §.1§'°€;"t2".iS 0:' H16 ci2=§{% 2m'1e.n.i.iy ssa§1,e:s:; may be :'€.Ei:'1=:g:,.:is3he3<ii '{3}; {he dex...»'<2E;<;:"§.'2;_<-3:' Of ithté pm';-*z:.€'.<;*: E21j;<>1.1i. E.'§1r<}z.:g;§: {he au.E:h<31*iE..§-2 :1&v€z°i,?:€E<§43§. "xg§;:aET arfi . {G z'€gg2.:E.23.1,i.(3}'1 urzciei' (3hapi'.r;%'x° 7 §J;'€rss§:.1"}'.."§3&-.'.<;3 E55. {mi}; 2%;fi'£.h;T.:,' ihe ma"1iz";£,€:::".z;1§3.{'.<3 of 'the? iisaiii €iE"'€.'8.S.-* "'ET'i:1.e ssa1--'i_.d ;f€§§a;.;.i';1'i':i€;§'1$. do f§20'ii dezﬁ with c§§Sp0s21E of 5.-§a:c*§2 335231;. ,:?g'{ifi'ﬁ in"éE}A€-.a.%:§3e'.zﬁ{{:s:. 5:35. :i§.s:;pc3$z-:1 ai.' i,1<1tsr ssaaid :1re.21..5; byﬁgéf ~»:7;z2iha;'§"£1_}~*.' i §"1V<~::. n"1'2:i'f:'¢V&:;i'21nce," <3? ithes s-mid <:i£.y can Em. h&§I1dCdL-- a:';5*<2<s%,;""'$";::: €,E"1e"r:+.gissVt,.a%red Ema! z'€:~3id€:m'.s' E1E§S(}€3i£i'[.i{}Z1. ii; .<.21--23y§';--.'®?~.héVnL[VEhé 'SEX-'ii? Eiiiéﬁlliiiy sue is a1k>4.".t:ed ta s:2pc:.%i.fi_<% ce1;i.'e:¥;_§G:"i.€§:; £'is;'7.f;.£:1"s3r:$.r1:--f»«'fhaﬁg. the Eﬁaxlgerdcrra §Ji'3%'€§()}}11'}€§1ii"»;!§§1J5%:E}{§.Tit:J:_' {E-'iH..{}i1"};*1t:;¥;'L€. Of Civil A111€r1i1::y Site) }'{{;§{3g'* }'g8QA Viy{)1:'§§f: 'f'h'e3"éé21id 21i10t:me:'1£, xxmuioi be E1a1xri11ggV"A:eg.I_§zi::*d to~variéijL:;.s§--..g::';{'.e:ria as s;i'.21E.ed in Ewiuirs '?' read with §'€;3;11:f:s-3! 1% and E_0;'._é§f%*1,£::§"&i'(}:"€; when E:'§1ez'<=, is no ailomzem " '~ ._ 0f"V_:i'::%i*»{§§:' g3m.<::"2.§£,j,>' (>313: the mainE,,ena:n<te :2? {he $22312 ' i.o~béa:§m"i'si.§ierer:E, .R€gz:iaE;'..ian. '27 of she EV§21:~:«;?;'e:' P§2m~2QE5 ';:~;=':>:3%5ci 2~::§::;:.%'ij; gijﬁcf zmé. R:_:Ee.s:~: sf EQ89, IE: {>:':E:y* when 2: atizréi :--:§11s:':3§i',§".§.=:ﬁ.e is; Eat} ::%§$p{3$&€i am t:§1<--3 b23.:~:i§ 0? :3, Ieaiaé is $35 " .. é%;:{&.¢;:.§..:¥;:«é€;§ ?>§»* E236 51 ::z'£'.E1t?s:":ii.§;' iééaé. 31%. .1989 Rui.€?:=;<; ::.«*{31.:'§€§ 21§;p3§;, in Ehrs iI'2§3'i.8.Z1E, <?af:s§é:z {E18 §3&7'E.Ei§{}E'i€5?S are? ssatéifiéiizgg a. ¢:?;§'§f<;%<:i.Ez:w1:1;. $.23 {he I§.'%z.mg2%E€>:"é;: E:}é'."<,-'€?§{§§}§'1'1%1?i'3'§,;5§Z.Z1.?1O§T§§.'§i ii) {:<}§1s:€i€:1' ?;.E:::%§.:* z"::e§>:°{:é$enE':.2::.:<3:: 2:.-Y§=.§§ §'E'2%:% :'&%§:}msea<;%:'2E.22.'%.§.:}:s m;=:éa by ";*';r:% 2:.s.:9;§é;§::{t=§211?j.:'%:>:": in <2»? {fi'hz1;:3'%.§'i:';<:;«: "E. E ;.1:'2<"§ $32.; ii}? Eézzizissﬁi 45¢ Eéagésg' P§3.§:.~2§E§. T'§':€§? 9.1% :30? Seskizzg any gziiotzfraeni ézf ﬁns Civic a:':1enit3? Siie wh§.{:h the}? have reiiizquisheﬂ €23 ?cV§2*a 8ﬁA. Therefare, $89 ruies pertaining ta 3;,}i1G¥1i'£?.€%}.?.' j"L:'-Civic Amenity S3665 avmﬁd {mi be E?.§}§HCab§€.

15' Eiezzcﬁ, éhe EBA hag {G C€§;'I1Si§;:f§i".i)'£1_€ -i'r<3;}_u1¢cs';e§it3§.t§0V':1 maﬁa by the peiitianer as Wei} 35 by.7€heV_A$s0¢i_:5,'ziGvn'* in'=--:é12rn$--.. sf Reguiations 'EYE ané 'Z2 re'Sp§:é<:tiVe1y i"a_f§:'@f .tH a.§1Mféferring V the matter tea {ha S¥.at€;"<f}_eve:#;::?f2e: éé; r;s§*"by stafzévrig that a 16356 hag {G be executed by £Eie_VBf;§§E*»,Vith"f~é:gai'<§ £a this park anti apes: Space 333 .'<2é:jéi§as ihe":CiVi<: Amenity Sites.

Hence, a {f1::i*c €:_f:31Q{i1v' _isSi_1érj '$19 the resp9:1dc':nt--BDA {:0 001183381" i'5&'}'§?f§$€nia%{iGZ} made 'ﬂy the p€ti.'t1'0z1€1" as W61} 95 {he Agé;-3oé§.a'::£an V;z.%Ef;§c§11«_.;iE~3< Annexure~F in the cantexé; of R€gu§at1:<f:e;3__'§'.1 df_i§Exe Réigigeti Master P£a.n~29§5. Mereavezx. E316; 'State 5}m:€fn'§t1ef:t has 23159 stated that it is for the Bv,é¢i'iga;¥;.§1"€.,V_Dc:-vé§é3§--m$ni E§u€:hari{}: :9 iakﬁ a decision in me ~ V::£;,ii'Ta':%.;§';V"E€:C,'.?;'f'§":'f'I-, 'iéﬁfais 05 Eet'é.e:° éaied 2E'%.28}_ 3 which :8 fﬁeé aiezig ~v;%::;:r: éaied :2,?,29::. The :"&ss;e$::§%::"':'£:~B§;% 32$ 1::§1é:7€fc"::--:i€ ":§{§mc'€;€@ ﬁg s:0:*:3§.§e:" 231$ Cage 55 {E125 §€€i£";i§:':e§_g in "t§;§:'_ ugh: Sf Régzgsiaiisn 2?' Si" aha Razzésﬁé Eviagégar P1;3.3::~2i$}.;§ . "7.§a:izé§:n::s: zzgrzﬁéz' {E23 1§8§ R3183. 'E'he Saié aansiéaratian ghaii .V ___'§3€ maﬁa wéiééézz 2: ﬁﬁfiﬁé =;>f {Riff} ::':§z::'£§;$ fmm. ihﬁ ﬁaie :31? gm

-Eff":-

:"e::<?{~'ipE; 0? i.3E":s.* ::;i:'_-3:'i.,1*§'.'i<:%<:E <?:i>;3§; 51:" i;E'1Esa {3:"{§&>:'. in EEK? .2"té:a;%':.:EL {E166 'W:"§{', §>e:*.E'.iE:£<>:'1 is; {§§&'~i»§}{I§S€{§ of vaiiii éhe 2:E3:}'2«"@ {§§.E"€?€i?E.i€}§'E, E5. in zihezé E£;;§h€'. <3? '£.§"i€'f £§i:.~?p{>safi Gf wréé .§:vc€.:§§;.§.i}_::f:,V.T :AE':V.é-:3 a;.:v§3E.i.<:23;%:§02': far eezﬂy i%3.€.*.21ri:1g; w(}'a.2.E<§ §f:_<_:ai '~--..sa;;--zf€;r§'ef§% 'Z'c:'Az_" ' ¢:o:1s3§.c§e;*ai,3¢:3:z.

S$

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court