Karnataka High Court
M Shivanna S/O Late Muniyappa vs Devamma Since Decd By Her Lrs on 12 April, 2011
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit, B.Manohar
4;:-y A
ix.)
M I5}'L§ES}'-'Ef1';'*1R:%.} [11{.5'\I\EA§<LA£%z7%.g} U}
S/' O E.,:'~'{E'I:I I'~'IUE\§I':';'\§3'I¥'fi
37 '2"R-3. R/fa NC}, 3 /4
BE CRC)Sf:3. £i3')r"A§'I5'ANAHA'i;LY
ZSXTEQ.
E3AN¢:}2'XL{3Ri§~38
{RV Sn SR§%:?iE3AE'§A, gaijsv §«'<>R ?:~«z;ss.E*2;%;:§;z§ 2?:-§"§a:a?:' '
sR5:£;£>AI:>A A-E3S'i.'S., 5331:)»-';€s} V
AN 13 :
1.
, ;§';-$:~:é';%\;x;_?»«%;?a._ ' _ ':::s._/ <3v,_m;: E%zELIE\§§";';7:.E>E%z-Ta Sm: :'3i::'x?i2x1~.«1'Wa SINCE m;c1~:As£<::3,' ._ E'{E€P BY 3--£zs:R L.Rss 5 éizklig - ' €'»IAGA.M.MA. ._ 1 _ I13/O E\xI'Lf'N§'{Af?'"?:_£; =: _ 5*? * BY2'\¥'PAI'»§AI~':iAI,,§;'r' » ' £m:\3s::;;é:;J(3~.§;;%'1?; _ , SUS}_4-_i.§.I.£i§\/EVE\A;?%.A ' _ - -
:3/0 'I,1-"WP: rv:.LJ:*v?;Y;>;1>i9>;xT'~-
83 Y'i?%S;,i'~'-';.,fA Nf}.5Q2;§.. "' ' ::3Y;a;>:»>iéxP;2§..:»»:;;:.:,[X ' §3..»;i§N€}§ki,€)E%:E%IZ.+fE¥8 ' ' ..g21'[>Ti::;'';f,.v ';«:,:j;r:_I%.«s'<>_ E ;'2.
'-- A :::-R-ii-> <:§+i:>:§:'aS',:=§em1;>E:>ANA:~:;::;.,;; zggmzgt:-m.:.§;:~:T%§§--38 a§;%{}4$§f§§§§%;8§'-'E21 x '$33 ff) 1-'§%ZN§i53{'E7.fi\,E.3E13A I7}§i'€z7'{R!I?v'E;"i V' V. _;§;<;§; *1-R3' ' BK AP9£s:.L1.A.;w';'s:f{ T
-«2 =m\% .?kz'f'z,§I.'1i3;2a}:'}pa and 31.116.-?z':;Ef<31.'t%, pi:-1i1'11,§§1fs 2121-": 11:31 CE'i'1E.§E §€){i to 21 s;;}127m;+ in the .'~_':'<-iid p:'<.2;'}€:1'£.j;. If 15:: §111'£}.1e ' av6:':"17e<:§ (2121: the p12::i:'11,i§"{s,'-s aye? >:';<>i €iE{.iU{'?d M3: 2111;; s;~:}12>m:t in {H67 s:-;:c':§":<:%c3z;.:._1é%* p2'<f:pv:%:°t:'.e::-3 z,:1'11:;-"$55 €.}.'1f;T*.§"€ is p2.m..ii..i0z.'1 £-;1I'£1(f}§'}§.§ the b:'<>'i.]E1er~:s.---- . V.
4. }.~i::w.i:'1g t"eg§ar«:.§ to {he z1,%3m:<': .".T?_'g'1i'tf§._ }__31c%z1ciV1':'1g'3, '~{h=:§ «' {c}E§{>wi:r1§§ were fzarmrci by i:.1"zz;%'--«.i,f§a?1.I Ccm1*--fg V {i} '«}'€ht:tih<32" thez; p§z1i1'11.;°fi=3,: f?;';f<}v<:L E4h21%;:fi $1.6: 5-i:,i:':'. &'.--3c.':11edL.1}<3 p1'Qp'é:1_r'1.it:'-5.3 x>s;_(;§1"i::--. 3,116" 361 E' aCq1,1ir€<:i p'r:::p<;?:"t.i»:%.s5; c)f'°§:'.Lt<7.I\/;i;1I't'iyi21p§32i'£'i» M ' {2} Whemer E};~c~. _ :';31é1:'ut.iI'§'és."v_ ;§'I9:i>;?:-= that. ML;.':::i§;_a';_fs.p21 £:1ie:*.d 1jI,7§i'€;fS§V?L&'};§§:'?u E3] '.-1"x\'f":3',"{;"'."'£"I,1f1;?';ZI"-'jV~T.h(?.: .<Ié:§=k§11L%"g1riifas UZ'(}'v'£3 3123.1. the 1E11'&J}_ €i.f3.f®.2'E(i zx";_1'*t.[A.ipg:.Ai:i ~::$ai€é5 «:§br1S.ider2-u.i<)1.1 fog' _ .... _iI'.}é,%;f1_1' §"\§3,._'I._ 2»;-11d._pu:'c:--Itf:a1$::.é:i "the pr<:»p»erf:y in V i,§"r€; *:221t".£:Eij {bf 4.§é;1«s§, §a,%.§'1::?'r'? ':31;W}1r;%'iEf1§:%;:': ifiéé.__ f;§a~ir'1.i:%.i'£'s :2-1r1n<3E. ci<3m2md "'--Lp2:1'§(:i¥;:i{:-:1 gofw ' :~h{3 r:1w6t};1i11.§._§ hamsse as {€<>2j:%@::{i,&~;§ '{3}? £21163, ::§efe1'1(£2u'1E.s'? $5} :3.-VE'1€iI"E:*iz%:"?. ..... ..E.:"xe {i@§"tt:3<i£m'E§5-5 pE"£'§'~f€'. 'i,h.2:£. ' Q§E§E1.i§'E?i.§'}§Z3E1i has;=s d?ifE%'p(}E%3€C§. :2? §§',€f§TI N32 of B16' ..g:>Ez1§::%i[ $<'h<>.{E§,:E€-: §:3:'<.>§>€:'§,}; Li.I§'}{i-81' 3. 'V §"é7§i'$§€i2°{§€§ SEEK? (Eeed {i;El"§'.i'?{§ 8v6«-- §E%§?i§}'? J{ii}.%?§;'§'1<eE':§'1m' ma? <§c:f€:=:'1:;ig1;'zi.:§ 2i<;:q':,i.i.1's:é£.% imzfza " E'€{>.3 91" théir pizéué 1'1': S%{f.'§}§%€.§i,.1k? p:':)p€%r"i':.§,-* 'i'":"<,>m ifmiz" {f}1?ii§.'} fi.E£'T1{i§f:?
./5 SM s+:u13n":iE.{:::%(r1 §..1'1z:'i i.1'1.:as0fa:' item E04 <':c.}1'1:':r3:'I'1e{L the {:{>:11p@::.:-.:21i,i{)1'1 z1z'1'1<:>'z.'::'1t am.-*2m:ie:ci is in :*:=::=:=;;3£*{ri of {fie £1.I'1.Lf£*,5i :"::;i"._ ;:>2*«:>;f}€rt,}-' 3.1712121 X-721$ a1<::q_2.;i1*:3.d by i1§"3{~* E:'%£I}:*\. $2} \vE'1Ej<'f*'h~ . .f{:E'1<_;'f Ci€3'fE:':I'1C§;1I'1§.E§ 2-Z1i,'::'E'-' are <1-éz2£..it,l<3c:i {.0 <':{31'13§:>€:i252;t:i<>n -f2?{tiC§"--1:*i_'(i?.i' "%;"i1;t3'i. §}1E-1§.3}§,iffS.
I 2, 'I'}1e .1e21r:'2e3ci ccm1'1:'~3e§ 23pp'ez;*{i'iM:'1g 33:31' ----i:f1a'>.§t:s:":%.E5st:i§ég :'c:Sp<J11(%€°r1i.$ -- p.121i:2£:iff":~; #2 3 2gu1'ii -:'_,;.';'2s1--.91" p§;1i "£":'i':if'E7" Na} :3~;ub:11if£'t.eci Ehéili i.1'1.s:{:sf211" as'; if;'<:§nV1_T.C'sZc)'.:s.V.'3f;C;"> <S'2z i1§. fc.,:'[ §..}.1c*; s3Ched1:1.s3 _§)I"(}§€?1'f,.§£%S f:?:1'€f* <:«:};;.Cc:.r.ft*1e:~*.£1, i.Ij.ie3;re 'iss;:1.<> 'mf2»1.?.i.€.=:z"'1'a'iff;«xsL?ha:.s<)::ve1" {(3 hgid 1':%:21i,.' §)1EiiI'1?.:§.'§1.'f:';'V;?i.'E'%:fw.¥"E'§'?'{'. €it}I"iE.if{.:€?C§ 'é-5) 22'..~'s5h;1:'e ass i.1'1&?~ ::,'£afi"::;'2::e 1a}~:,em by EV,.V1".:c:._{ié%i'Tsji*1{i2i:§1i.§5 .§_';.{2*L '};:*.r{)fwé;€i 21r1<:i finejr f::11.I"1<:rI' E\*§1,§:'1ij;app££'.._?"t2a;C£' :3z._1.f:§f:s{24;:;i'z. _iI":EV'{'?_g;}.E"17'§.{?' '15:} §}ilE"{fhE3;S€E Eh:-3 p§"0;:r(;?r£:}---' zmd he W215; .2?s.EEe;r.}_ ,:'e.rv;::c*,2'R;.'i1"1§;;A£1=';:t€5;1'1e §'1'<'m":. mhez." pz"0;}c:z'%;i€s:2 and §;§f]€§'é?f'i€}ijt?_§:3.§:§(f"'§I."'ié2.1 {i'm_;;"?;'. 11?21s.s§é:$§i.fi.eci in g:_§3"z-}..1'1E4i:'1g{ E /8"' E-,§hE;'z§"€', in 'é'§1t'~=.:§;:s;."? :§ai}i';€:§{§'a.-é_E€;? pf£*c:s;:v<~>.:"z'.i€:xs; zmd E,i1:? a;pp%;%2;1E is {£<*;x»=°'<}§d {Ff ma': ;§%'., v3{§§°"
1?
E2. §"{21vi:'1§;{ IT'«i?f,_{E}.i'(i 1:3 'thté <':<::r11e:"1ti{n'1.-2:; :'2.1is:iae<.§ '{3}; it';%£:'L}'I'1é'.{i i?{)L1i'§E.§t?1 app:>.21:'§:'2g for £1":-:3: §I)E"zI'U€?i"3n {ism p<>im:'~i«,: i'.h2"21: £ii.{'i.S{3 ff}? £3113" diflE3I"I"§"iii'1£%.i.i(}I£': Elflff E1} :2';%%% "
1V1i1c2¥;}.1r3:" 1; he £'i11.c§.i§1g Qffg'.§;€ '£:*i:,:,£ {:23 ii§<:z1":.AV r23s;:w«:>:;3dagi-s%:«~p§a.ir1t,é§f:'s' }:_:.1.*a§:%' }\:§T:i{)v+3d' i'.§:{;'1Lf__ item '§'xE0.E <>i'"1}"1;r';% s_s«<:_1:1c*{iL1itt p:'<>p§:r°£.:i&_§.s§ vf;:3_éi.1*1§»% a12C.e:%st1"211 p1'<)p€:x't::{;'._ .2"U w11.i'<t.E:z_ "[§'1€'f}---'i§ am:
e.1'1£.i1§c':*c"iV a; :=:3;'zV3;:211"€:_'»._emci i'.':";21§. fit':-31::
ci<:1'{~:I1c§z1r11,...1";é1s3, fa_i1e;:i 'é:'.{>V V1};-.~=5:;:->::% that" iisrrxz
3._.N(>;1iT'i»V' {.35 V:s.Ef1.e: V S3::§"1<: ci:._211é-:°pm1")e1fi.y 153 21 ;':§€'.1f i'}_E{,'%{§LlE..§':€:?fi .}\}Vi"é1';[3::§:"i3:-*; fi1:--st.ii°it:;ci £31' xiiaiiss fbr 1A' .iT;f1i'.£ifI"'ffi%§'f;,E'4}_{5r:i:in this app mi'? Ami fiticiiiég 0'? the trial Couré. 1': h3g1.
p'Ezi.i11E'E£'£E3 Ei§2'"{;? e1'1i,111.§e{.E 11$» EH8" sizzzzws in "~--:?1,e:n N"c:>.éE of {hes s{:%?:e«:i2;T:Ev:~:* pm;}€:*i.jgg 259 '~ §§,:éi.i.£."it?{§ or "$1115; Em" i'§'"i3i.E3f'E"€€fE'§?§'};{féf in €'hEs:'--s ;?t§'§}'}€?21.§'?' 16 11:3 fiecuméifis :0 Shaw ma: he was man'L1f2c::£u:'§ng the Cerzmnt rings zzear Baiaji "§'%2€atr€ amt} she dam mm: kmtmz abauf; the incenze {$0121 the factargg arm ssh:-2 dams ":2-«ii: i"
when the factory "i.¥2":S 'sstaréed by E162" f'a§i3.er bu'§"'hf;--:E'_i"3;{h.erAV wag r2.3.r1.n.iet1g E13716 fac't.cn"y %;il..i 2.215 5563:' ;_'3}8i;'_-Z2, 3E3?i€. $956-::*~. knew wlriaher her faziher has .;x1.a'ir1t.a«if2:%. d:" téqe Sf; accaums. She has deziivaci a 3ugg€:éLiisg;: 'WELS maintaining his ilaniiiy by 'w%?'(j'1f}{' has stated that her faiher was Whfifi Shé was greung. She §?';'e.'.2.$ ';3'»§:-',:-:»0 é3€3ni3d";%;11é;i'A:é.:"4"h€r.:f'af;'mer was :19:
fining any zvarif, 3~2j§"d._». was nzanaging the affairg GE flfié' Jthé jgéar Vonwards.
13 P£7i{'.f£ 5- 'RV.-.§}C:§a.'i§S°t.*é331zjg' has deposed in {ha affidavii §§..E€r:i "s.-'fly' Si" E§§a:'.f§i.natie¥:~i:2T~CE2§e€' that ha knew a 't;hs:: .pa":'"::ié'5 31:1: iii»: gait aiid Rziuzziyapgga was awi:1:?.r1;_2; a car and was f'iJ;I:i;::%3";;§'§5l'1s:3 s*$:.1""é:i.;=3*::%: §:1a5:'a&r.iaE §1a:':'m2'*j; near 8h:%V'a§E "§"a§§€i€$ s,a:";é 5:? u$_re::§"3 _7:{3 nzanufaciura C€:::.1en.t rifrzgsg gtamem:
g;e;1fii§a*€ar:"s~, v{'3A€?§1'}6fi?,' as;-*"imi«3w$ 6115:. and wag earning sufficiemt 3_;;;:%:":<E%3€ é::2.<:i {mi 0:" 123:»; mam fiagrzaingfi he puréihasefi a 8313 at .9% z?\.<:<?01'{ii11§:fIy', xxre §}2»1:~%;se; t"E'm ib11(>\x:§.:':;,_§:
€73§%I}¥%£i'*{ Tlié? ap;.)<;::z1E is dis3;z1':§'se;s2€-xii. 'flit? 4j1.1dg_;;.1'1';c?:'2i. ;32:5;.:%;6%{1 by 1LI:1::=? XX /X<§{1I.Ci1§«* éfivil ',I1.1c§;_;e:%. Ef3:::1T15g§2i1§{)r'::* in {3£S.N{).8O9i;{i.'~<}TE}i?. '~V_ §1;1i:%{i 13wf2--:}Z.O{33 is :'r{>n£ir3;'I'1z:?»:L {}€<'::'&?{=% sskz.-all E:):';*--:__ " a1c;:c<:>3"Ci%:E 5,133'.
"":':'sp