M/S Sathavahana Ispat Limited vs The State Of Karnataka on 13 April, 2012

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

M/S Sathavahana Ispat Limited vs The State Of Karnataka on 13 April, 2012

Bench: Chief Justice, B.V.Nagarathna

§§

 

IN "mg: §*E§GH' CGURT Q? E{ARl'€A'TAK.Ag BAJféEG£'aLQR}Z
i)...»'»%f'i'E1§3 THIS $512: 33%; may 0:? §%E>§«ZE§,, 2012
P333323'? 

THE; §iS?=éE'BILE2 MR. '~£'E§{RA1isEAJi'§." SE2»: CREEE' 3:j}s*'z'%§L;:?.T}§";, ,

gr-.33 _ ._ A  
THE: E~IQE\§'BE.}';: MRS. JUSTECEZ B:2z.:~:éz:.«a:;tj»:;:;:';:':[ra:;:§

BETWEEN':

E321/S ggmgxfgmawg ES§?*AT L§?§!_'£1'E'§j1§}, 

3259x595, 5%: Emaea BLQCK1,   -

D.E¥"Yz%.SHAK"£"E QGMFLEX3 AE\a'IEE'_,_§;',§:E;'£2«.,

§§'EDERA8A§~5GG O18,   ' "  jé 

RE?RESEN"§'EB BY 38 E§'€j'.§.;%§;'k{:T;€:*§{,'v , A 

?ERS®::~s:.~éE:L AME} z%DF;E1NiS§?R?:TEC:F€1__... ' --  ;.;._ PE'§"E'E"§0'E'£'E';R

{E-35%' SET: Easgzaiﬁéi ::§;::3g:g:::g§3;%;:a;a:?:;f? zéiigzzf 22%;:

5&3 E2q.Ev%§Vsi%EE€;f%;V;§%if§F..f§§;E:§§;(L_}   

:  'Fi--.jiE S3"'A':":::V£é:%* Ka€%;E§;'§:'?{_.;'?==.E€J£,

BY'  $'E:C§<§';"r;:'R§f *'€<3 jC}Q'v'E;RNFvEE:§\§'E,

EEEIPE, GE' MINEZS ::,s;-;:.I_Ri & TEXTILES;
DEE>AR;iE'i\:§E§*§'E', 9;? {1'€3§\sE'Evi{ER€E & E?~3§}{§§'E"'§€.EES,

;::zLS-8m:;-:>;:;x:"<;";¢ '
j °?§£§_§$§G$L®RE;>vE.§%} V 89 1 .

3 ':§':%.: ;i.2§::;E:CT0R @?' M3333 & Gagmei
T " E}§P3?E'.. '<35 RENEE & 3301,8592:
 2<;§4;z%';ze.%,:_L:z:;VV'gaéégémazaée

V  RACEE': ~%iZff3¥UES§Z Eégazx

 §§;§:%a:La;§,$§{§i~5{§$ $9 :3;

  :~;:§';:. §3.§<:§;'::;:;:§z {";@2s;::z;a

  EZEWB, L.B.C8L€3N'1C
'*8,-?:£'€E}UR '§}§¥,}{3§€,
"E%ELEfxE€"z' §}ES'TREC'E'~583 1 2%

S§§\§CE SEAB BY HER LRS:


*§V§P,N9318'?'68f28Q7 €€;1s:z:ae:1»x--:s).. "'  V  



 

21} B'Kﬁ?VfAL?z§/EMEK.
W / Q . B ., 'E§'Ej?'s:'§£a§{z'%. G Q'&z"I)£'%".
£'aG'E§'L) ,§%E§C}'i.§'§' 56 YE'Z§§RS.

E3} B.NAC:A?sE§'€,»§§ GO'x?££}g%,
SIG B,KU'Z'v'IARé§ G%'x?i?I}Ag
EKGEZEE z§BOU'f 52% YEARS.

C} B.K.BASA1%'AR£;J 3
3;' G B.E{UI%'EAR.é§ GQ'*5vT}5§§
EXGEZE ASSET 36 '{'£~ZA;RS¢

GE} B..:'iUDE?;A Q'{}'$-;£s$"}r:§'j:{.&§gg . 
SXG B,§€¥J§\e'{ARA ss*é.wg§';~~
AGED ABQUT 33 YEAE?;S;__ ' _

e3 B.C§iANP%£E.§srEiE%g'§2?*::_f"~..

9 ; 94 m<:U§v:;:§zg%.* <;"2«s*3\?;7:;}gi; ;
AGES ABGEET =;§_Y:::A;?.§$. j'

Wm
'WV

§,%uS§((:§.§-'$§.'f;:§_)KE')>'é-$:.}??'_%i;'V#i'.i _ _ ~~  
§},'<;§..«%;§€  v_ _;%Rﬁ;_'f§%{}  ?Z}--Ea,  V
A339 :§:?@1yE:;g_RS;"-T.'.'j '   V

 

'. AL;:_, .'§é§Eé';i.§>§:~:fI' 35:9; 2. ;»:5,/B;
i,..«B,CO1L¢iQE'sfY; .SP;?§B{}E3 TA§;£.3§<L,
B:3}1,LA.EY'=§}§:E?T§'.,_  '  R}ElS§3*®E°*«.;?'DE";'\E'§S
{By 33:: R,'<:A§{0;,.:;&§:§ '2.5§{7£2'5': mg: RE 221% R2; sRI.s.@AN£s:~L
SR,._i§jO"¥;§T_\ESE§E.;' .§§©§2; s§::.§§,NksR§:xz§:?As., agar?' §<-'QR 2'23 Eafﬁ} R3

'"'«--_€8;»&§;°'SR§. »EV§>RD?€;%EE*:--,~'SE{,CGUE'sESE£..3 "FOR Z'~§AEE£' 5: P€AIE{ Lzxsvv

  §<'«:.s;:xz;; 3331 _R?.:";._ {M};

.  .'§:'§v$'§'3af¢%§7E€,.§7§" E-}§_f§'E'.§§€'»}?§ 3% ?§£.E:1E} §;§f"éz'§3€;§% z'%,E{'T'§{fL§EZS 225 5%
2:2? 38%? '§"'"£*§E .{:GF*§'S"§'§'§'7U"§'E§G.F¥§ SE3' EN§_'§E;"--'*a. ?'§$;'3?'§Ef*§{§ ?§ Qiiésﬁii
'§E§§<£.. §E57E-ifzéffiﬁfﬁ E}'E';2'?,,2.2{§8§€ '2?§§}'§?; §aZ'~E§\E~§'2i §E§£5's.S§"i "§§""§E3

 ::x§::a2;:'<.{; §,§;;a3§§:. E3'§§f;E:§} iE§§{E§€§}"§'EB EEE' ?§T§;~§'; S'§"'ﬁ;'§"Ef; €:8'if"'§'. E2
 -. "§:;a:;@:3';>: GE?' "FEE R3,; '=£"E§E.i ;='a;£\E%{;'~§--' ;:>-'_§.:::,3.@5f :s;2:J,:azG,251§
~;;:%»::_>--..;g::'g%;s§§ 'E'§'-£E- CQRREGELNEEEEVE m'.2§_:z<.2a@§ 3.233%: A1"'é§E\E-Qw

2'

5:21,



 

"FEES P'EZ"E'E'E'I0}\5 BE§'.';3"~}'G E%'.EZSEZR'v"E:Z§} AN?) COEENG
SN FOR PRGNGUP=ECE3M.ENT GE? QREEELR '?E€§S Bﬁfiﬂ,
NAGA,R.éiTHNA J}, MAEEE THE ?'GLLOWE?€'G:
Q R. E E R

N§GARﬁTfE'v§?'§ 3.;

Thai p€3E",i"{§8EE?:3§', Wh_i{t1g  5; L'§ri9i§ii€:;3§'j  3Ct:i_:31p'£:§1§*',. 

Encarparated "made; the p1"G'%Ji$iG:§",%';'EV§  "
£¥i.{h {he abject sf aarrying  @f:@;}}€2raii:';={ 1
and sxpart af m§nera§;.éa has  ﬂjp's::*i§'r:.'§<3:§;§ a$SaiE§ng
the ?§{}t.ifica€,iQz1$ ﬁaiaé' ;'S'}';'2@§§ viéﬁ
A;n_'::e%:u:"es    as mining Eeags

executeﬁ Egg? .§':*--:".;f{:ji'€,E;9%'__a:§V§°"§'E'.Sp€}I'§'§€"§§i _?E@.%3 Ennexura "P'*E. A

éi'f€C€},§ﬁ "V:-1_1S{§'"l3csa:gE<zf{, fer cezzsiéeraiisn ané gran: sf
mining "i§;a€;€ £3;§1:€é2<::ii£__"é}f"'th€ p€E%1'{.iG:':€§' p«'E);§"SE,i&l'i{ is its
a§pii{:a"§t:_ien id;::i_e:d  12/ Z §§2 {.»inn€X':,ire "A"?

  :3 {he C336 9? 'she peiﬁianér 333.1: 2': bag

53$'-:'g:.b§£'::';%f§$§_§ 2'{'§,:«'i:'g~ir9:: §:":2a.§::.,2§a{:'i.:.zri:1§: hnié. in 2235: f§"€£%.E' Z§§2

 ?:z:3,ez;é€§§§,':%;,::" Eﬁisﬁrécié ﬁgéhrza "?'z"a£§€:'~s§': i?J§:§{EE% ES abcségéz 253

    $321.}? ffiém Exaﬁigifg', "E'hé3 raw zzégﬁariaé ii}?

"'m}é:.§f§uf2:{:E.urir:g §§g--ir<m ES §E"€3£'3E,1Z'€f5; {mm Efhés Eeagees, xxrha

 ""§T2aA.-*5 mizzigzg Eaases in the Siam sf Kaznaiaka, Thai SEEECE





 

m:¥«I»:-

me p€:f;it.i<m€1" did mat have any m.£:1i_ng; Eeass for czaptive
canssumptiamé :3: applied far gram: :3? mining 1€§:1S€ ever' an
mien': sf 33% f31C?$$ in Sijbbaragrarsahaiii V:1§ag@,,Sa:':é%;:r

Taiuié, Beﬁary Bigirict am 219/12>/E992, 

app§iC:ai.ian wag h€>'4.mVe:2 :"eje{::'.e§ E'3y.--.4 '0§d;:é:*§ "~ziéiéai

69/861 1993 an iihe gremise tha:-ihss-2;.rez¥_ f{s?;5ffb:f1§§€; n

peémaner wa.$ incissdeﬁ in $39 '§ea§<.§<j g5gz;§ﬁﬁi{§ég:§:ﬁg
;/S,§'s*'§.}fS{}Z'€ Minéraig 14i:r:if,:€'*a;i:""?§f§€  '<:&r;dj§:fV':*-$315' és$a§.§é$
in a Féifiskkﬁ befaré    §§go;ar:3':"::é:':;«"5::iV: which by
Qiféer §§_aféf.é%«:§ E?;'®5;" %;.<i;: 332%: §€:.a;?{:=,

Government §€1'*E'7'f€§CGfi:$§é€FQi1§}§§'~%§~:§_ Vgévéng an Gppartunﬁy {G

the p7sii£_ir3aAééi"_...V_V':;'i1i:1g;3§~.ﬂ.¢,£}:§:j State QQ"~3€I'I.'1§"E}€§§§: diﬁ ﬁat

seaside:  »:h€= . §:a€%:i~i;i5GV:;€':°*$ appsiicaiiang Saverai

r€:§:f5.§S%2r¥.{21E.§@ﬁssa__ V V §=;§:re maids zmd subgequemiigfs

2Q@§ wag ﬁieé Seeking a éi:"e{':€:§{;':': $10 the

";"T£%*ié~&_::: ;{:§£Z'=3£{".,§"E:"ifE5f§:V€§'§'{ ta Qﬁiéﬁiéiﬁf tbs p&ii§€,izme:°*§ a§§§i{:a§.§§:1

fag' tggraiﬁi". %:§§ 'mining iaaswss E{ea§;$*<;£:'§ SEE: Said E§£':é§ ;i3r:::§éi{;n

., :Sa;2a:a._.§:3§€}::é.&a:3§ {:22 1 §;'%Z%?;="2§{§8 {g%::1§1%:Xz::°%:~S}a

:3

;,s. ;%£c9ré:§'::§ $.10 Q36 §>6E,§'%{.£::>E:6:" Ckizégqg {ha p%3§":§€L°ﬂC§/"

Ref the Saié wrﬁ péjftiéiszz, 2: itasaeaéc geﬁtien "'J:,-""3;S ﬁisd by

fj,"



 

m:5:w

regpﬁndent E'«50.a3§ <:<";ni.é::1dir:g that {he Siaiie Ceevernmani
had e:>;ecu'?{.€d 5:, mining 162136 in big :fav0:..:a1 (we: an extent 0?
334 Acres; 21:; S.M.B§s:3g:'§§§ Sandra: "{'a§'u§+; Beiéary Eisjtg far 3;

periad of §*.z€.:ent§,? jgsara. G13; the basig {)5 {he 3.}épETie:¢€i.§iQ'::S

maﬁa: under {ha Right is Er1f::::*mati{3;::_  

petitizmér simght. <3/spies 0%" £36 »-.3A.§:>;:%_'§:rc~<f,=;t'i'1:'§§";  fﬂ.i:ifd:' 

ragpgndent, E¥E'{%.3 far g:*3.m €31" miﬁzég E62135 gs .:3,:€§'§ a:;$»VV'ii::e
Nafiificaiian ami ihés Gréers:. ;:;1$S€:CEV._&;a§:;C'§;§<§':<;§f§*§§3; xmmifig
368;-Sf: ':0 regpandéizi ?'*>30'.;3k

 ii $3 ihéi £?EiS§§. ':;:%°fEE"::;.é j:>;:f§i=?:EA§;yi:::f'3":§::* ihgai while ESE;

apg3§3:ca'{i%<'§r;--.<;{é:::;e5:2?}fE--?;'f-E9§i§&:"fv% gram? 5? a mining Eease is
yet. t,0 :be-.Ce1:{§'E;'3€.>%:f§ék.:§,' "iE§€--. a3§§ﬁ{';8;?,'iQ§i £3166 hy regpenéemt
N63 éatgé  §;>:"aces3€& 331d Natifiﬁaiien
da'{e{:§_ 2'?f£??;§'2f§}{;:g; .;§;a5,": isazzaé wit.§1 re-gfard ta gram': {)5

 mimiégig mass. §%~:>{:j;>:i'é;§__r:§§ ta ths §;€'{.§f:i{:::€:", abaué 4% Agfrag

 ;'s;:?:s§§é'S<:§"' iii}? "33; $23 ;3§eéi":;E{:»ae;"' %:r"€z'E2a§s§ 'a¥'§%.E': '£325 SE":§E{';§;iOE'§ gf

 

 ~..§":V'E.Ej'i;'."-1§§"§§§.t§::'f;", ia%:{:=1::: £3»? f€.'3S§€}§7i€iéf§'§§'. ?€'<;z3' Eé; $253 E2263

pe:%f,i'%§{;:1§::9'S  ihgii,  $E;a€.:{-3* $:{:2%;€§*:'::z':€:':€; Eéaﬁ iii}

j j'::§§$§§t%;§V0':é is giant sf' mining E€a§€ 3:}. .§a2--*su:'° of reéspgrzésné".

 i:'i"'1*esp€c'§. af an appfzicaiian fiEe& in éiihf: year 298%

5

j,»;a»



 

~:6:~

SJZEEEEE the said appiicatien wasg as Ecmger aiive far
C{3'nSi£§iera.t,:0n, Hmvmser, éhe St:a'£'e Gmzernmsmi: E2.a& in an
:an"bi"i.rar32' Eiﬁé itaiﬁicms manmzr, g:'a:z";;t,e3é a mining Eeasse in

{airway 9%" ragpaméent. N133'

5. Respgndﬁnts 333,1 and 2 hava [email protected]_§'afs3§§§*;§§i;i of

:>bj€{*:i':.§01r1S seéekizzgt dismisgai of the writ pé:i§.'i#:_;iV{>:i'_"i=:'§' Exiérzifm,

fer the rézagsn. {hat the pei,;:E,§_9z1$f }::~,3Qs§":.:5s?,: apgsfe-asviieﬁ f:;"1iS 

Caigri wﬁh C1555: héifldﬁ a:1&,'z:as S§2.§_§Zi§°€$S€§} .'ﬁ3'?,§F§§§lf2Z'i{f*{S.
E': E3 séazigd fiat: ?;'.§§€ ;3€t.it:{}§1éi'=.f:i2:£§ 21p5§;:~E'{:4§.{:%1€€,§", {E6133 Cant?
ézeeéiing a iiiffi-{E'{.ii}3'i E18  8f}1%:.s:_ }€;f:::3:é::?*::a:§"§':zT::§1': fa? ::<::12ai5:€r§:r:g'

ifs mizgizrtag' Egizé':-5e:é  ;e€p'§ii'::;:f;:0r1 '{:§"-3:35 2%,/' 12;' 1992 zaﬁzich had
bﬁéﬁ :*5<:§e{:¥;::ii_V V<:é::. "{;7>:.{:"'T>5;a'§'z"~;,€f52':;'ZE.{;r'E -vidge Aiznéxure "R~ 2". Priar :9
{E13 Said' .1j€3s:{:§':'<;;:1,'-..:*;;r§€i:;:_ ""»,?;?a;3 issmrd "£0 $16 p@i:i'{.i@r;e:' an

:2,::Vzt:;2:g§é;2 gméeréggié 26:2; 9%" EM: :2g:¢,cW;zTu%:e:;§ s;i:a'z.ir:§_3;

 "=ﬁ'zEi'§; a'€.E*:%:? észrafa &.§§¥:'£s;'-rd by {he §<--:E.'iE§ar:a§:z' {2vez'Ea§p€§ in

 _ 

 

,3;%,z' '  zzrﬁa a£;:"$a::§}; S;':"i}:3{3§'§§}§§€{§: ES §¥§;'E%.Er'§}*8€'s§'€"3
'?€§:é..§":%;*raE§ E;%:;%é§§'E.s::§E aszﬁ €.:?:22E: *'aE§e.:"€: wzzés "EEG 8:'§'"é;"i8; ;é.%Ja:.§E;1;'§Eé% §§}E"

  3.2:? g3§*é",i§4§{::::s;:s:° ::§§{:E §""i{}§. 2:°<%:&=s§}<}:":.£§ Ea ihs gezid

V "§'§§{:iE§{ﬁ$.,=._£;%gfé":£'Z':E=3€ii iihés 0:59? daieé; $5 ,1' §'? X EQGR éihéi §€i§?.'§0ZE€'f

'* £":.as ::_19¥; ﬂied; any revisiau petiiien as; £3 waﬁ Ruie 54 0? {ha

i



 

~: 7 i-
?*J£.€'Ruie$ E'/W Secfsﬁmﬁz 30 95 ihe  ﬁe: Further;

'az'£7.P£.'x§§.5383 ,1' 2.90% was fﬁeeri by {me 8:: Venkanna agaéngi
responﬁeni E\fG,3 hereizm s£:eE<:i.r:g cguasiiingf  -"<3? the

N{}'aiﬁca:§{:n dated 2?/ZXZQGS by wE1i{:h, ihe

W213 grargiied E0 §'e5sp0ﬂﬁ€§:1'é N33' Tbs said v::i§_{ ;3{e*:iiia:'§ was

dismigsadi by Qrdsr éateé G4/Q8  

5 Ths 3?" ;r°€3p 8nﬂ%:*:._§ V.  'a.n§ f'_    n  
Repragantatzivéa have fﬁﬁﬁ s{::€§'me'n%. '€2.15  'Vraiaalﬁg
{':€§"?:a§.:'; prelimiziary aE?;j:e'Cf§i«::::'Vs5"§f_§%{  é%,;:'§*§= p€ti'i.i0::,
E:  éiﬁniﬁnéﬁd ihai.   maizzmirzabie ag

the §€'{éi3'.V€§T}.":€:*.r.:f"jL-1%:§sgA~'V~:'::;:mL é:£.i:;é*:rnai:iik'e* :¥3me§y G? a rm-Yisien unéer
_?:i§.C.R%LsV_E<3a 'ffiié'}SAée:§f:{*:r; "'*f3E;"§' sf ihe ?¢'EI%ERB Am 295?,
Further;'?;he:<~: :3"a:féé§';3.3}"é;'é fﬁing ihs Wfii §$€,iii0:': 33 $316

impuggﬁﬁd é:§:'d1ers'VWé:ie }§a_:§Sed if: iha year EGQ5 whereagg

 A_ §Lh€ 'aiﬁfii:§;€f§ii0f§"i'3;?3;$_'bﬁfﬁfi 536$ 3:2; :E*:<::= year 28$?' E': ﬁg aisa

 S§f.&§f.€{"é _V?.E";;t-.4€;f§;:§ é%§§§§{f::?i§{T2E§ fzfiairzgi ':23? Ezhé §€:€,§€§~:;:'§53:" &;:z':,:'::é

 .i:+22";¢:$ §'%:}'e£t€:::-{E <31; {}§;"%?f2§§E by $216 2%?

:°€$p§:z§35:%::§'j,:'~V'5§"E':€§é:§%:}:"::;  §}é§'{.]§§ii§€}E"§f3E° 'éiaéé :35: 593355; :§§.Q:2d:' Ea}

"-p:m3f€.%:°"'*:v%:'%2§ writ @€ﬁii{§1? a_SSaiEi:2g;? 'aha m%.§".2§.'3:2g E6336 gramjed;

 L:'€t.:> :9é:'3§0::de:1i. §'~E0£§., ii ES 3380 CGi'§E€f'§§€3d ma: apaft. fmm

ff!

ﬁzz»



 

there being gzmsss @8133: and Lacks:-:4 in preferring tha WEE':
pe*:i.ti9m§ EEK? Same is; prérdécateci an $33.85 stzzieménts and
supp:"é3&«;s§0}:3 sf maieriai f"a€:i.ss. Th€:r'€fe:3're§ i.he"§:aé'§--:':i:i}n€r is

digeniitied {,0 any relief 22110361" A:'i:.i{_* E%--   'éihﬁ

C;0nst§"{.ut..£c::1 sf Enéia. EEGHCQQ .a2~pra§2"€:7 fGv§%"'€l§8U§iS£$:fg1'}V"f}f utfzzé'

writ yetitéan baa bean maﬁa
'f. The pétitiaygef  ﬁiésii .551 ':".§§@§ri§§éé':""'ai0ng with
ce'r§.3.m documents.  .

 '$53 ha':?&° ?r¥:::1;'»i§: x E§%if;2*'i3§";i*:€%:"§ ::§3'a:::$@§_ fa}? 3261a':

pariiﬁs'  H

 é  __§e.az"neé Samar Cauzasei appearing
far §'€s§p%a:>s::_d»2i=::;7:t~_ ['{:3;;7§.®.~~"ra§s6d preéiminary abjecﬁﬁzza with

 Sig €Lh é$":22.a._iz:tainab§Eity 3%" this '£§*§"'§§ pﬁiiiiﬁﬂx ii was

V  {§9?;i,'€::éié{ﬁ ﬂ":a§ ﬁfiéi writ, §}€'€,i§.§Gﬁ has is be §iSiiﬁiSS€d féﬁf" .r}.::}€{

'A§:%:§':au:,zs'§i§L§fi_;_g5;'£.E§e §%:.a%.s2,:;5ta}:°3? §'€35E'§.€d§" {sf §.'€3"'"5§.§§{}§}: 2;:s'2:§Ea'3':& unﬁﬁr

%';'_E':1e3~~g%?:.é:§: 218$ ﬁzzéasz S€'C,{}§?:{§§; am: wréé, §€:i:§%:§{:=z: éges £118:

v {§f§1:_"%€§'iz'€'. {?{}E§§ie§i§iE?§"E:"{§.{EE} 6? i:%2%3 i73;=':'~:-S €231 '3:'z::€:§'Ei:53 :<::§:1:té=: §'.}.E§'3"§'%;' E55

 izzariixéiiatﬁ éelajq in fﬁiizg {he 53313, E: wag, €:§'1i:"&§}2

caniended that there has bean suppregsign ané



 

mis--$t;aé,€~:mr:n€, {sf maiiariai E2:{:t,ss anzi fhereiere, ihe writ
§et.itie:}n has; ':0 be digmisaed in E.imir*:eg Agari ﬁat:-.:n this,

a1f10€:hs:r {E{}fE'€€'i1ii{§.'fE raxissésd $3}: the: t.'hi:"d :*e:*;9p{:~:;{ci€-:'::;':'f{:Lisfsaith

rszgard is the {cams s£a:':d.£ <3? {he p<:':it.i0:1e§ ':7.-::_ H1j§zi:s.":'i'::i:; *£§1€*._

'wzit. p€.§it.i<>n, Eliabixrating the sgiamé' 1*:ifh r::§.E§:'3_;3.;i€'"t{;°i:,he 

Siataméém, 0? <>bjez::€i0n3 §E;§€;:{L ii;--  ﬁzasa 2:»;~.g3;1,2:€é" i:Ef;:§;£ the
p:5§.i.'{i<:;:<3r haé fiksd az: a§L'_p§i<:=21é.i<>:::"~.:ié:£{:§d 395 E21' ':9§2
{,%nn{3X1:_r€~§;.§ far gra;3_i;: x:sf 'ra.'éir1i:1§;:g--.':§§2;§s3--«s3 £}v€--:' gm arﬁa Sf 35%

hectafﬁﬁ in S_u'®bar;:}:é:1a£:§:§i;E  Sandm" '§'ai":;§£§

 

Etéeiézéxjg §}§s:sj€;§fj§<té; § as  i%ii::e%:z:_'§'é;%%?'x---*;9§f:§.{:E: é,3;§}§J§"i{,T£:'§;%(}§1 was
reje3<é:T.::d 21;1ﬁ.'@:}3§: sfc3:T";*::é.i"'%.%-*;'a:.ss?"'{§@:r:_:t:uni<:3;i,e{§ by Eéitiiéz" éaiéé
O9xO6,E:9_93V :=9i':§s;V_ ism 't:7i:E---.,._g§r{>;1:'§1d that the ezrea in qzaﬁstian

'23,;-gg r£:::;ui1"ed"'--b}%  ,3}?-;{é;',Na§i0na1 fs'Ei:1§=:':"*aE £}£=:v€'E<'}p1f':':€:':t,

€gzf§§é:'zi.t.i@::(E\E1%z§E}CL§ E23'? €XpE<21;"§:a%;.i<:an in aha pubéié:

. jsatéezfi.  ,$>;.:'bs€q::€z1*i'Ey.; ihe 'p€:'é§i',i{msr had prefamrﬁd a

*--:*€:f§.S§§<§§:"_':;a?,E:i;:§§ ivgaa aEE@':>£;:a~é and {he maize; wzzg '§*€mi'ifi':€-id'; far

 ".s;:<§§iséc§£e:>'§:a$.§:}:a5 "E'E"::2::"s5e:E§:e3"§ 835: 3.p§§i€a_'i.:§0':3 ¥;2::"s;

AA§d:§f§§f:{f§£.§i'{§ 9:"; %5i;"8';«-""2%}§E §§;:1§.':{-;*:>;':;:":3--E{} iafhisih 2%,§E§%23{f'§, 

 fQ€f;EA"':ﬁ Saipgreggesi by {$35 _§€*:§,i'§é{}}:"§€3E",

Kiifwfﬁaa



 

-: 1Q :«
1%. 01'; the ::}E;h€::r handg res§p<:~1':d€n¥; 310,3 had maﬁa
an appliztatiégn far gram' -sf mining); E63556: an 33/G'?/1988
E£3;!1§1{3XE1f€~?¥i}§ whkth was pracasssed arid f°s§{>i:ﬁca'i':i@n was
issued an 2'?,i'82,!2GG8 {Annexxzrwﬂé granting §{;':9.__3€ in

f3;'JO?;,§E' sf rwpandsni {$0.3 as per £:'xf}:'}.f3XL1i"€S 9  is

atontenéed that {hang}: the appiiiéatien ﬂied  r::5;ﬁ;'>'{:'§;:e?:.é'f;:':'~.

"f§\§0,3 wag as far back as ;§.':: §}?,'€:3WVfjQ'3EfE,'i'E'ﬁ '--,E§.:fE:§€"_§.V,"' 1ha'«E3i..é2;':e

Crﬁvﬁfﬁﬂéﬁﬁi did mat take up the $3.r_n%:__f<§:' f3€"')}j;f}~5;3'§df:f1°E;L'i7§Ci7i'.'§;fT?,V

View 05 21 s;%;at,ut0:'3r' pr<}hi'Qit=i*@:§'~uﬁth  'is: grani sf
 .'§€»:3:.$s:=. z4:§':ii§::z?'"'~..3§;;g;§; *?;*;:3%%;;~;§€§§t;s <35" ifiige Fﬁrsast
{'i30§1s@rva'i'im':} ASL EQSCE §~'£j_w%1}'é ééni-.§fVVix3'.:'ViE_:é: year QSQS éhai.

the ianéis in q9a;:'%;":':::fa.=;_<>i':":z 'W€:£;%3.,.{§Ot1fi€C§ for giant @fmm1Ez1g E62156
anﬁ 'iihéi s'3;;~j:_;C:5';§§*/;vi:.i»:::»:V1~--.;s:':s'§'ﬁ1§§ :'e:éSp{3§1c§e'nt N<3.8 Waéé iiansidarsﬂ.

5%-3 far: «.38 §'h5€._:5a;pp§§€é:{,i:§§:: if the pet§.éiane§ is %if{}';3{3€*{'E'E€&%

 '«--.:he:?é"':~:%§a$ an i£§£'iv:£~3;§-«'re:§€c":,ien an §9f§§/ EQQS and after

 :'a§§f:%¢:.371£Ev.';éE1f.§*2M.e3"'maﬁa; 13:; this z'ev§ai{:«r:a§ au§.Er1<>§'i'5:}L Eiazere wag

2%~.:%§_§;:{:é_%$%f;vv..§:ég"{§5§Q?§2§%Eg *{.':r:eé $233323 £3 aissaaéiési by E238

. §2$i'£é'§€:s§};:%§ iv:"é §=='f?,f§"s>=§8?4~%,f2{}§§a "§°'%.'.:.s5§'%3:§{::'€g, 253.8 53:': $1336

.  , é:;--:5:}"r:_ 0?  {i<§:"z$idera5§.i0:: sf ?;§}.€ 2::ppE§€:aii€:»::a sf z'e§;§{:}:";;é€'::: E'€{:,3

"fQ:*--.§;{:*am: <35 3: mizzmgg E63133? the §[email protected]?;:T§{;:n€::"'$ 23_ppE§<:a.%.ia:§:2 waa



 

~: 11 :»~
"ﬂat généing cansiéeraﬁan, Unésr' the CiE'Ci;§I1'2.Sf3;f}.€€S, the
pe?:ii.i0:1er has ':20 iaécug séandz' to cguegiiorz the '£52356 graiatﬁé
in favsur sf :'eSp@:3::¥.e§1€ $170.3: Hsraceg ihe petitions? Qaﬁﬂﬁi
siaim any §riarit§; {"}".;"€i' respsnéent E\E'09S'3 a_p§§i{j.i;f;.§{;n fﬁeé

in the yaar E989 and thus, the peE,iti<>r1e';fH.1f;3§;~§' f;;{§"-«£§>€us

siandzi {G aassaﬁ ihe leass g§'::m*£.ed in §a%s{;é';-3?: <;f'*§?€:Sj:a{:£ide §z.t

$0.3.

:1. As far as; i:.h€: dg.z':*_£ay   
iésncerzaed, it 3% {:{>§1f:<-:n&€§¥;i§::.lE§f321"{. Vt ¥:E';.é_ Wiéase £3933
§_.§§°8;.'{'§j§L€*f-{E E110 §§%;2;p€;r:{Ev£§::§"i(_ i.},',¥€': §§v'7V §3E.a*;:. $326 123:5:
§€tiéi31r3n 13 fileﬁ gnﬁy   fhﬁfﬁ is a deiay of

Ekbﬁéii 3:163  3-95::-}::j_ "9 mV;€3'§m;'_E";S [in agaaﬁiag Ehﬁ mining; Eease,
during; fgvétich fii§1':ﬁ {:'., V:*:=.:_$3§;:::;i":é€ni. $9.3 haé maﬁa exczorzmms
inv$$'{m€':::€$.f' _ 'T'm'r_rE:'§l§§'é3, Efhs wrﬁ peiiiiaa has is ha

 G1: §"'E1'1§___;§§@un& ef éiaiay anﬁ lache-S, Eiabgraiing

.  'i;§:2.;;€ $a§«§~.$&§m%s§§Qn§ E3. E3 siszziafzzsiiﬁd Ehai §§,ﬁ:2§§:': natéaﬁg

 . *e;.:»:~%§-,=2.'i$"'v§§€5;sgu<s:$E="'§:':: Eivao ?§€a>;-ac-2 §a§;:£3r.5=2 :**:%§g:j&r€Eé'§:ag gyaggzged

ggssnivzzg  $.33? $1232": {}§'€3: §§':iE"2§3E~§ in §:2_:m;:§as~;a§;&m§f Eianga

 !S&§:{i:,§:§i 'E71::_§'2,:E§ 0;; §'?;€i8,z'2G{}3; by {E16 §{'&}Z°§§&§".a§:E?; Siam

_?1éiE.ui1i0m Cenimié Eogzré ané; fZ,?§+€'E°{E wag a §:.,:§0£;i::% heazémg in

,5

éére %



 

~: 12 :-

'éhaé regard ami i:.ir.1@ faregt, ciearamte wag 3;pp:"0x:ed :9 an
extent af 83.62 He€:i;.2u:e$ an .13/E8,/Qﬂgzi and 3 Gazette
Eatéita granting appmvaé zgzzdér the Ferersgé {€g§1§;:_3 :f*~L:.a:§@n}

ASL 1988 far min.it{z§_;»; apsraiiazig in SEE,_E§E{:éc:E«:_;v--~..:S:<:,3%:{%;,1r

Taiuka, Bssiiargg i3*is€:., in §35:<}1;rV 33f :*e;€a*j:s{§':';d}é";1{""V1?~3t:.A3,%;§?as ~--.

rissueé an G':/Q9/EQQ5: that i;vE%-Q ;3%:*:%:%i<§';¢;a:é'r'héiéé:';?;Qé: _;:§1}3f'--.A I

iacafted 1:8 pigdron i'act®1jéf__v:§--3:;.V *:E'::<é'v-%%§a"#§1:ié§;.f7  
Eﬁaae but hag aigﬁ .b<3§::1v _.§§§s~;'.:j%.1:§iiv:'1§.§ }ﬁ:g% éiuaxztétiag 05
p§§,§;--§rG:": fram feréié; 3*' E:}::$_V§*i{:§:2it,y mat, $;?n€':'€
hag '§3§%$:';.   in a$.%a_§.§§§':§;? Ezhés
m§n.?nf:g'    §§g;:~§§:k%;'%.V%;§;€r:'?:. 'f'*$§::$3 beiataéig.
'E'h€r§{-:zf:}:*_§:%A  tirzai Wm: p<r:$:it','i0:1 has is '$6
éégmiééegé  aiséay and Zashes. in supgeri GE

%:§}§%$§é "$"i,?t1D§7I§f';§,§f"§€§;f!1'§§ .§'€1i8,§i£"':€ hag been piaced an sﬁéferaé

. ' ;§A.;eci$i<:';-;':::.. ' ' 

 E: 3% 333:} <:€;§:§'£32:'s§€{§ §,§.':;2i {ha 1s;:*§.':; "ge"€ii§{}:: ES

 A 'p'§°&€:§.;j:éié.§{f: §-:32": fgziisse: 3%;a%,<3m€§:§: <3? §2:{:'€:$ ass; ézzstéé as

 " :«.:.:::§3§m>:$s;§{::": £35 §°Ei.{:f§.$g i3£§':§{',}"Z: :x3<:%.1§e:§ {i§s€:§2é§Z'i:.§<;=: éhat §;a--::i;._*;'§é<;§":€:"

 5:012': ;>m§; reiéaf. EE: is $€a"{.§:~«:E 'éE'12s_i; $36 pt:':i%:i@n€:':5 a;§pE§ca'f{§€::§

daitieé 29,»'12:,/'EQQZ w2:s.s :"'€}€$€'.€d by aréez" éaéiﬁd



 

~«: 13 :-

G9,fG6f19Q3 £:1§Eli§"1E3E'. which, 3. revisiem peti.Zti:::n was fiéad
and the matter was rﬁmazzdeé for freak: cengideratiank
Theséafier, gm <>£'da=:r éaieﬁ $5/$3,/2GC%E was §::1SS£3§§ a cap};
0? which is pmducedt 21$ Axuaexurss "E9;-2""  faﬁtﬁ

hava been supprssgseé b£3f~f3'}:"€ this Caurt. 

E3. 3: LS gigs 5ubm.§it€éé:§:éLft.«:he_ f;::c;t "%§r;f€:_§éfai:€ia{;:";%:§' "

has filed '=§!¢P.?\EG.E8?45f>?; GQ9V':§s§é:=:§§i§:§§ _'é_:A§;g§». ;'3%§:§:~*. éa:e§

Q5;'G'?f2Q8L, wauld make'""§§[";mparé';3::'"that;nﬁhﬁ pmitiexzer
Wag mat iniezresmai §i:'*$€€§ef;§f}§§xa~ §;:1$§§.:1g k3a$%: $1' ii} purguéng
ﬁiés gram: Q5 5: minisg   fiieﬁ ihe p3°v&Se:':E

writ, §€€fﬁ§L§1  'Lhé3"~;_éj%a23i 9? a mining 363.36 is
réspéigﬂiént   is :10: Gniy friveiaug but aiaa
v€X3:§i0u¥s;'<«,, E?+e£y'§r§§§, \01;:.":EIi1e d0{:2;:::3.€n':S fiiad a}€::'1g Wiih ihe

gijgiegmergé, 0'5 'éisjé-9'é'.iQ:2$ 331$ 93?: ceriam d€:<::§§§@':1s, Eezarned

V  S%3'3.i%3:f_ éZ',§e'Vuf:;»:;e:'§ a§p€ar§;:'2§.-7: €93' '§'€s§e3'r"§.dE:1i E*i£},3 has Sﬁughé.

':,£ééz*;';*;$,;<s'2"£?.;:}§ $239 2?a.r:§€. §3§:"é'.§!':§£:»§: in §'i::3.1§:/2.95

" _  $63 {',{§E'§§E°EL ésézzzézszégfé 3§;'§'}i{§E" C-{}E.2E'::S€E§ 3;@§§é;a:€§;.g

'Vfaaﬁ ihé-3 §:2€:§itie::zr:€r has drzwm 9:2? 3.£:i:5n'i,i<}n :9 §E'€i€E' KEV

E1316 2 3f {he $5516 af SEW? ?:'0£:eé=;;§°e EC? }, ané h&f§'-:



 

m: 14 :-

wntexzded {hat there is :10 bar to @r:is:r€:3,2::': thee writ petitiaﬁ
02': mexﬁg as it ﬁg 03?}? when {}'}€F{"': £3 .31 quegﬁan af
juz';%sd%<:t:"{}n 0%" the cauri $0 ~€::'ﬁ'€:'ta2Tn 2%. praéteedmg G3' E'%§'§i€£'£
{T,h€§'"€ is a bar "£0 {he If§.l'§Z'1§§,' sf 2: pmC:€:e&§;:1g. '"§:if; which
Circumgtances aiomi :5: p§*0ce3<3d;§.':ag CGEJEQ  an

pfsriiminary isguees ané 110%: athemvige. f' _i;:ﬁ;_"€:?1s; m.«::,:g;:s:.

{€3.39 {hare 22:9 ma such isssgzes .E'?;§1.{f§;"4_3E}I{Ti'€;{T€Vf:{}.}f£V"§:f:€.  xargifi "'

paiétisn. has K} be hﬁarﬁ; gm VEfI.1€ :'4i%'.:$. :','?}}.:.%:.:v"e{<:'1»V*é*j:'. :ééi.:"n£é
Sﬁﬁiﬁf Caumsai hag :'a§$e'§*.:§hﬁ§§3{:i§{§::§'_"' raising' Sf
§:*£§'§§3z§::2:r§F  {}'§i"»§J;°i§
Pﬁaitiars. Shghas 3.A§_S{:f:.':;?QE;a'i:;("%1%%§é('?2VV 'f§£E§§: .~é€ is {§~j(j_§§,? {E18 Légfai

i?{epit5e$f:_:@§:$.i;i&;fe;3_Vinf '§§_ép_;:ﬁ&en% Ne:3..;3§ who ilaxne raised. the
issuéxzéf i:§€i2:5:i__.:é:;§gV:§. »i'a€;§1e€s'": that thig zarfét. pﬁﬁiieﬂ is {ﬂed an
2%!  1 f s,y§E;.&t€aS;'" §he W'Fi§ p€"£§§Zi£"}§'1 fﬁﬁéﬁ by %;*'$.J.SﬁEéi

 L:mii€t<§,.. ____ 818% as$aﬁ£§1g ﬁgs gram: 5}? 35336 :6

A   'W215 fﬁeé Gr": i4i!'ELf2%§? aségé éhss saéﬁg

 =*i§*§§*{4 as?-Se genéiing :::<>n3i{§eYa§:,§{2:: <33: :"::€r§'i:S; ihai

%';;j%;:3:°a§.~.i~§é§z{ie aéséay £22" Eachsg in 2:25»: fiéézzg ef ihéz 1%.-%*=i§4 §::é5§i€i{:e§1

a8 ~§E:%:;. §€'f§'€i9§1€f' 26:33:22: aiseut; the giiiifli Sf ménizzg E6353 :8

 ':':*:.sp§nde:<2z;t, N0.3§ aad maﬁa am a§p}icati:::1 'é.,1z1d':3r the Right

xi"



 

»~: 15 :~
T0 Enfozmaticrn Act on 03/G"?;"20G'? and f"€{":€i'J€d capisg 0f

the reievani des:':u'm€n'i:,S on 83/ C18;/ESQ'? and the 'i}§?"§"i'i
peﬁtien is fiied an 24;'1.1,i"2iGG'?, Thareiwerﬁy {E16
i°€S@€}'{1&€1'}ES"3 itamwt prxzawzmpi the pe'{'i"i:.£@ner fz'{};?ﬁ3.'ja_rguing

the €8.86 an me1".ii:s§ She ﬁarthﬁr carzfgemis t'V.1{3,§:.VV1'**:34%Q-:§;7;:3 G*:r*;.de;:'t

N03 had nlads an appiicaﬁen 0:: 3% ,»'S'?;' Qf

21 mining E6356 but éhe 3212126 {S g§*2:ﬁi,€d z-1f%'§':'<.2f3 ";f€aii$ én 

2'?fQ2,/29063 Therefore, {hie g§ré:'::.:{;%_;'Ativiizisﬁéfgg.%°éi'g>Q'ur
$3? :°€S?8:':d€:1':t E'€0.3 ES  ;:€:§,{§:<§%Ei:":§ie  Eaixs vémé
?::€§":{%{: IE5': 3/'*;a;E.'§.§=::'v  ;1"3é?§"§§::?~.: E3:
suppeert. Of ﬁg:    '§"€§§€§ an C€'FY,aiIi

p5I"€€5'€d€3.'¥3",€~§§   
ESL», ~ in 1.'Te':?z.:9§:s3{§. Samar C{>:m$€}. apyearing far

r§":;§%p70:?:dé3::€" E'.-Tf;c%,3 wh.§£e _mit.«3ra"£mg his gubgxiisséimg haﬁ

' ':§§a_:§::v.e;;z;f--:2z,¥;":e::é.ig:2; :0 {ha WEE: ?i{'G{',€€di§Eg Ruéasg §_§'?'§' and

' _ £58 V$®'$L.:':i{'}§'_E'_"§%:§£:;.€/Zéiéé 'éihzaé téégr pE'€E3:E'§'§iT€EE1§':,; a:;%§§%{:*é§£:;:"s§:. 21%: 9; '$33 'gig

iééﬁ }:;§§ €;:§2é$ E-EfE'§§ p:%Eé€.i{;:2, Es: §§g:{:é3={§ réséiamztﬁ 0:: C€f€.§£iE'3;

U I.-mg...

It

A' '%::§;:£:{:§ss§§';§3;s:; {£2 <7:@§':.'Ja',:«3§::{§ $513.3. $33:-3°: ;§E%$§'::é<>:2{3:'  §}€3i'3§": :§_§":;%.bEé3 

 sxgiaig ihﬁ may in asgaiiing éihe géiaizéi {)5 £1 m£'::ii3g §€8;S€° 3:0

respzéndant E093' Enfactg Eiihe §e§:2iﬁ:.i<>ner hag aisis beiaiediy
/9

«£9»

&',.9«**'':_»



 

$ha.i1e:1ged the rejectiazz 3f the appiicéatiazi for mining £6356
made by the getiiianer by fikng the 'W3i'i_t  Peiiiian
§-:g(:8?.»;5/23% Gui}; in me year 293% a§a.:«':Ci:i":'.::*:t*:.g the

presenfz §€{itiQ§'£; that infacn the 'p€i:i§;[email protected]

'Q16 interim Qféiﬁf §}8.SSEd by the1.#:4arn._€5 'Sif:g§é .;}'f;1a7";§€u0.:i"'

38/81/2888 in viéggrmgg/25?e«;G€§'MA%ATg::$*-gyf g%é1jeg§f::,'gate$" 'A

§2fG'?f20G& £136 appaai "'cT£.§_f§€3?'%ﬁ,{ié:€;§_.: é'::1éE"é§?§'%:« i'n€é§§m
aids? staging {ha ,--§fgj,aiI:§2j}g'"x§€§aS€-»_ gr§13}:t.z:d  fawsur of
:*&sp0.:::de;:1i; Eﬁaxﬁ §1§&1$' §:*'_;f€3E".Ti" ':§::§}LV'vVZ?§':é:::.f§;::.1;'a,:$ii§'"ie& jg Eaxan as
$326 §€'{{é'§'.§{}E:'§_€'i«§~':   fczeie iiagé fer

gra,n%ingi':3f §5&i€.i'%*§"f;;,_:1: i::;~:f§_£::"-- a;%1_é§"v%;n..i.E2i °22":i&w 0f the maﬁa: the

wmt:;peii?%.0:iiv."h.2;S*4.?;<}*.¥:§é-.,§§§:nE.z§ssseé in famine, an preﬁmiﬂary
Gb}€Cﬁ{;n§ %raiS€>;d""bfy,.§§::--%: 4§p:€~t§1t,£ene::

 Eﬁ. 'V Qﬁgvfgilﬁﬁvu  appearing an %ehaEf af

,' <:{f;€s§3<C$;":£;::§f:§':'::;; E'."~3§>,}. anﬁ 2 daring {ha §:@2;,:r3e if $15

 ._ "$3__3;%3ﬁfi:%:§:~:..z'.,e:}:=§V;'"hag $a:_'@m§§'§§3é ?:.§':2§%.: mfémiiigg @359 {$3333

E?4§f{}':§,f§X{'§§§ £3 2; 2-*2:§é€i é§§§E"€€EEE€£"§'€; 2:93:33}: :3 2:: z2.§:<::&§éa.:1cs:

" a2:éi§h §2s;aa2' azzﬁ fag? ?::.'?::é3:°€3§@r&:, gzéziggizé: éigméggaé 4:}? ééga zagrréé.

"  géétiiiaii. 

5;.'



 

«~: 1?' :~

E?' Hézving hearci the Eearrisstd iraurzsgesi an bath Sides;
and on p¢3:m1S2iE 0f the rn21t.s3:'é21§ 0:": r:%{:<:;:'€i, We are of ms 'view
ihait E:1§'E1{"2€ this is a pi'{}{?€€f€§i'f1§__§ fiieci gander ﬁ~,z"ai<::Es*: 22% of the
€<>nstif.ui,i0n of In{i_:a i:h.6ref::sr€; 212} {:{3:1":4e:ati<).:};':a_ 'ta the

mainizzinzabilivg emf ihﬁa as-*z'i*'a' p<3ti1f;i<>n as 2iEs;{§AV.w:'§:}1:"régggézﬁjd :0

the hﬁéifiﬁg sf '(ht p<3{:it.::<";1:1 an ms-srﬁs ha 2f€"s1=.::} *»:f&3;7Si~c?:f3r€:si

at $25. (::1zé:s€i',. Fer {he 'vesrgg 321353 réa':<:{}§:_€ airs; ._:§:i;3§},_:é%.é;%.€¥7%;.i:a.€{. "

:21 pr:}<:::<3&§';1g fiis-id a;2{§e:».A::'.é:7§;:--. LZ:'.2§  {Z<g:1§';;é 'i§iV:.§;i':VVi§}:*;
aazzizat béi' :::L::°€,2":sZ'ie@é by §§='h%i§'."E'.ic1§' h€{3:'~:V_ KER?'
'E§_'s_2_E§=, 2 3% Eiirzés:      %:::xs'r<:_i$i'::g gig
digcreﬁanargr gioxxreraﬂnségihﬁg praﬁygérs saught

'by tivzg ;_:>e§.i€.§c;::as;:".byr,éx§:;<?is:€: of exiraardizzzzry §?':_::"is;dic*t§0:*:§
the p3."@§§;r:§:.iV:":9;:%jg'cﬁj.es:%'é=.s;{§i::§ raiié-:.€{§ by re$p<}nd§3::§ N03 wozzid

E:a§:§3_v €10 {:V{§':1$Vi'€fEef;3d5'2"é§: the §i:*$§; i::sE.:3.23{:.5a We finé fhai. iihs
p€§§ti0:3e'r h3_<:*};_.:::a:<:§§: an :a;ppE§ca§.:Z{}:3 iiaiesd 2€"§;'§?;;' EEQQ; fa»?

V' ._;§':'7a:1§:"' {;§  ;:¥}i:z:.§§;g;§; 3:22:56: ears; an. §:%:§~:%:'.€:r:%:, sf 35$ 2%{t;°:<:$ at:

'V'Sfiézi§3T*§§s;:;;é.'3;é%;§:;§§:a§§§ Véiézagﬁ, $£iﬁ{§i,éE" ' 'a;E2:%:.§ B€:'§§g1.:*§; Eﬁésig 'E'E':§:

'E:"-§«é.:§'§.é: H{}L<§';;<:%r::::2e;':€, §"é'j€€if'5{.€i{§ ?£:E3._€: i-:~:2::'{§ :&§;;3§E{t::fa'£;E<>z2 an

®§g'{}§;f E§§3 zsggzgénaé. v;h:'<::.E': 2: Emrigziegz waﬁ fﬁéz-zé 353% an

 ~:s:*:.:fBai"13«:i,, ﬁ3"d€E° daiaii G:§,f%'?f2G€f}§ E3225 '$893: pasaad viﬁe

Mr" / V



 

-: 18 :~

Annaxuze "RE  regeéttiﬁg 'aha .a§pE§cat}1<;§'1 dated
29;' ':21/' EQQE. T 11%? said cryder is asgaﬁad in
";£?'v?.?€0. };8"?Q§,f 288%» Th:-zrafgre, the appiicaign daiad
29 g' 12/ 19$? has cuiminatﬁd is the 9'55   _ §at.€§

35/ G'?/' 2681' /{he Same wag :10:  mg

Concsrned 3;ut.h0rii:y W§':e'§f1 the a~pp§:icaiieT}a Qf %€:?§jg>Q":?s,d€':3t:' 

N0.3 daixsd 3:/0'?/398$ waé  gg;[:me;%¢;:%% :5" 'A

exaﬁutien £2? agrwmeni. dat.§_,?dV_V1z§;'{;3__,f2é7}AG'€E} V7ia}W 'a*n Jexisrié: af
IQS Acres azzé $ubS§que1T:i;1}H "_":°eVCi»%;cé3é %.{:--..§i.;'£§§9 1%er€$ viﬁe
{i€§'E"'ET'§.g{%§1{i§3_f§} {i21*:;5>d §LC¥;_1;'if§:£L-,5i§;{3GSf~. fS;§:'-*;.<:€:t '§',E'§.§ff §3e€,23§",iQ;":t's§*'.s

appk(:ai;:G:": haiéé-bee:{f§ <:§>%j{§3:c§.g:Aré%§i.._;2i' ;<;a.':..:v eariiﬁr point as? time

azzcé Irejecf,et§ :»:§;_d" ii-:>;'fi §;€nﬂ.i::':g Cansiégzmiiarz at the time
01? §r{>::::=:§::;Mi§3_g*- agﬁtif ..{§£1'%1':Si&€I'§n§§ the appiécaiian fﬁad by

§°:%:§_¢Qpi'o;§ée::t"?>EQ!& véiz {had that ihe pe'§{.:i;E.:<3z1er has; EEG Eacus

. '2Es;§§a,n§E7iV.3;;é 'z>;sS3,i§ iine mining 1€&S€ granted ta §'€3$}3{§1"2d€E3E

 1:; 513253 C€}§1?,{i3{'§g ii: '§é;':::2E{E Eéﬁ zﬁiéxraigi fé} :51}? $3

AA §i§"__1%;'? {7§€':{';§§§{§=i§§ 55  ;%_§:;€..:a<:. *€§€:}%.:§°€:  §'E'§%.':': {:fa:;<;§§:=. {sf Jﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁg

7 §£i§éa:5'iiﬁ§:ai ﬁesai gs Egshwz Kzimaiz Efﬁji §a§h§?° ;§§zmg&

 and Q£§:e§°§ Efgﬁffﬁ} 1 S€€ 6?1§,. in {ha Said Cage, it hag

é

.r*"r&"



 

~: 19 :»~

beer": haééd that". the ;}r(>p:*i<%mr of 21 crinsma €.he21i:.re braiding 3.
Ei{:enC=:~3 £1131" ééxhibitmg {:'im3m21t.<;«graph fiims was heid {.0 be
met f3Z'}{iT.§{*3{§ Ex; §:1:?<;§;s3  c<3ri;i:::raz'i§ §uris;{§i::%.£0::1 ex e:iebi.t.G
v§:,1s;<:.1*i:'.iae in get, a. '?\Eo--<3i:>_§r;=:<:§'.i<m Cﬁrﬁfi tatgg-2*. §_§ra.r;?;.-egci under

Riﬂe 5 <2? {ha Bzimbay Cizlemaz E11165. 1§5é';_bj§f3§}t*;§é':.i3:Z$':;*i{%é

Ev'Eag§s;'{':*ai<=: in §a5;'{}u:' 05 a rivai in the €.r21de§-?:3§<:;::gh'§:. up a.E::.d

q'L:as"5%:&{§g

E9. in the SE"ii{§.  tézss ..'§:i£v§§'g31;t:;é "vésfmrt
C:21t.€g;s:>r'i$€€§ Eihéf :;:_§3'§§.§c:22::t;  ei " airgfii, :.V5(}i"V.':<ﬂ*f:iV;:%i§1<2':'3;:"§ i:n%;a
%:i'::°::":€: €,':'ci§.é3i§§€}f§€'E§.%Z E3  ii}:  gmsé iii}

bL:s3r'b{"Ri§;;2:;r :f::*§g§;zi§'t3.si3r::23§:':é:e3%§s:;p<:ra i?J'hi.Es~: (§.isti::;_:u_§$h:1ng
"gzargsgiﬁ. : a1g§g:*is:?t>,df ._§4"3'£,s_§:'3;-. ":;':;:'a:1g§€1"3? aé, Paragagﬁiz 389 the
f0iE{:*».a>"1§;.§§ '?E§*3SS?': $'~héﬁ.%€ _§%3--%?j§i Eaééz --

 .'Ti3'5§V..  '?§'- e§€s:"i:';g:z€S§3. Siiéfﬁ ziappiigtazzég fmm.
iséziérzgefé;Z----------:*;.;m:Q:'"ag :'E':em;, games §3:*§a,=:§ :'e3§is mag;
--.v_§:%<»?"5§§::3::1Z_:a:%g>aE fmm 3.3%' {?Q§'é8§:¥€{?°§£éS made @5839'
'£"é:?§§'s (2:23 210:' absaiagize aizd a:£§::'s:r":m""e, 'E'?:€:':'
V_vz-,3;f;s'}"%£:}éc5st§J; va;'€;3;<:; {"£{3(.'£?§'€'§§§'E§§ 3:} E323 iffifsiféé§'§ES€I'{§¥E.{f5:'S Q5"

" _ 5'1-"as ::?::z§€, z°.::{?f 315$ iszg $5259 3::z2::'a:§"or§,;' ::?a:':§:exE' 5:: :,g:§"a§:%§2
ifze §?3{Zé;Z"§%'3§' jiaéézg E10 7&9 :75:r':;$'z°és?:"€3&., '_?'Eze§;£3 are:
E»¥f2e€'?:,e;" SE26 0;§;;>§z'::raz:E' is :2 ;2e:'sar: 2332335 Eegaé
:'ig§"z€ has been irgfriyzgedi? E-23,3 he s:.;,f}'7ered a

.-"§
,3

3&9»
,«-H"/~')'



 

---: 2&3 :-
Zegai wmzrzg Q?' izrgjzgrgg, in the S€i?,8€, Ehai his
inéereszi recogrziged £35.; {am has been
prejudzlciiaiigg éifid direciigg qffecied by {E28 523:" 0?'
Qmissiaria cf {he auifzsrézjgg, saniapiained 0}? is he Q

persan whit: $135 sa§f}'7e2"e& :1 éegai g:"i€z:a:1<i:€«;._> Q

person "againgz wham :1 decis-rian %aa:~.;f

prozwurzceé w§1icI'z has azérarzgfuiégg de;:%fi:}é:i'v1'f*:ii§*-5. .

Qf' sgrrigifzing 9:' Lzsrarzgiziigj  I~"7.*T.7f:fi/__i$.cT:'dT*.  ??é§:nx '

Sameihirzg, C3?" z:;>§"0rT:g{i;€5g;} 9gff'3e'c.iéz3i ~:h:'--5;:__" ':::,'fgE;é"'?;0 

S@m,e€'h2ir'ag? figs he 9. sgséégcigi zarza?' .§;iub,s§'a'2:;€ie:;Z'*

grievance G5?' hzis ou?§ﬁ._?):3y0?2d"~.:§9r:2e ;;r£e§§§'C3:2C<§ or
irzeezzuezzience sz,gf;'F:2redu Fgiﬂz 5:": ,.C€§%?§??§§?§1 waif:
{he res:  :':?':é__§;§;%}§i::Ef? §_§5:3_ 315- .€:z:'z",::§.£5§ E9 §§:;;'€<::§;

and be Eteard by aha':::;}ii&0:i:i:rAA_'£;%§§}§:}re if; :"«3@§<: E529

 '£z*r':p.L;§j37;e§A'fi.;<3i:?€€:3.n§E?  was he prejudiciaééy

V7¢%,qf§/e'c§:éfa:ﬁ~.iL§:.. :§f}V;5:'4é5.1Eé'z"«:::3?€ cf that régﬁzi by the ac: of

iizainérgﬁaiiagz'"«:»§§;",_;f"2:::§§;§§:iic:ien an {E26 paré sf 518

-- . a:i€?€<.>:f£:§;?7§s*  ;¢?:é"s{a:":iE.€., if: {he g:?9§:Ee,>::' af w§%:.éc%*:

 5csV"é'v~--{:--?'«°"€he wards " ergarz ?"'i€L-'-€§" is
 , -- 3 J ,3 G§§

 gcsnsidereé, G. sﬁciai weifare measure

"z:§7€S;fg:?j:e7§ E0 Ea;/g ﬁazasn eﬁzictai 9:' profegséerzgi

 ;§:':;:fi;::Eaz'§s GfCG}'7;§?,£{,'§_f§}§° 331:': {:0m:?mr:€:'yi3' Q2" 21% if

" _ :52': $€'{2§,a:;§:§>; §£f{1i§§:'§.§  §:'zi:;::a:1:3 rigfzzjs £35?' gagwigfzgéar

ir:dé.vidu;g§s=;?"

At par3;g3"apE2_ 439932 E: ﬁg Qpizwd 22$ §°z:>§E{;ﬁ:.:v$:~



 

«~: 21 :~

""49. Whiiz-2 5: proctrusiatm appraagrh sftozzﬁ
be avoided, as a 21:56, £518 Cam': sfwuid moi
:'.rzi.é2:j"€re at she %'z'z.${.a::'a{_re sf 5; 'gircmger' zmiesgs
{here are ex<?€2;::{i:z»:'2::z§ Ci!"£?££??2{.S{O,f'EC8S° irwaivirzg {Z
grave r:?;isCar"r2iage Q[_ja:s:ie*e havirzg an ada:e:'-rjse
impac'£' an _pubZic izzierzssiﬁ z5§3§z:z?'z£:2g A'
appeiiamf €55 Q, 'sireszngsir', :"m.a:5' was a.  
Shéerz a£..s;.::: {here are :15 €xcep:'.:a:1a;E c:i3r°:<:{é:?':j;,S;'EA--T<ﬁ§;":::%':;€§v' "
in {E18 preserzf ::?C£§§v3 r;;.:§:;ich 'é:§§:£E:,€.h>§;};$'i"gi;'§;.Ti'}i3Vi$:%;°i:e 
af 5: u:-'mi: Q?' <:er*£:'.ora.r:' at  «. _C?§f:" 

€0:f:£.mrg;; ziw reguit _§c>§'f. {fzeA'v-ex:3rc£éi.e -..§}1:'3.§;'e
&is€s"e£€0na.r;; pazverg, *é«:?f .-3&3 fa--;:e:,ja:%,, ::;,:z'£E§ an

§}(,z§{:;§'E::é%,_ 5%? v{;;§;{;§:':5j;'§:' "~.gf30E.§c§.;' H H 3:: z,s;4:E§E§.

€§§2';":i:':(1£€ ?1;e£:E£?1g;;_'s§:«::'r';'%r3{e'{£if{}f':  'sjizis busfizzesg

 :;:1jé?'a:'«::V?A:"£:;» ' :44': 'f1; :30  -- .i{;ls;:ée':*éf:€:§*  is raise camntereiai
VV'.._A:n@ra§.i£1§};'fr. --- {end is perpemaze the
&;§§€EEﬁ§'E§'.*$ sf cingama §}££S{?1€'S$ in {fie

-- . éT'o:,:/ﬁg a§:3:,?éé: 5&5; ii'. 2.5555 $3, s;j1f}'E"3<?z':. s~;€r§@:,:s§§;
 K1? {are 555' '_;*7':--:--::&an:€:':£ai rfghés of respazrzdeszés: 2

 ':1cE. f2§. _i:,;,:}2;£cf?; 329;; have zgzder x%:"£'i:?§e E§{E,'P 59:} 8f
"":;??;:z;2V___i'§.§r;é;*i'iz:'z:;€'iQ:*:, Ea Cczrrgg 52:2 2i.re:za'€ :32" E3>;:;<;:°s"s.es$
 :§ ':"ea:$£r:':;a§3§e :°s3;<;{r§{3§.§{:z'2;<; §.§'s':;'3a3s3g:§§ E11;

" V §.{;;:,:,: 

2% §>'E:;-§:::i:":g;; E"'€§§Eji§E{.*{f an 21:": #a1%2«,::°Ei£-3:3' e:§é;%{Ei;%;i{:2§3  €319
%  .V saga caf Egagar Riga araé Fimggzr Eéfiﬁis an zﬁifeﬁasagﬁa £53 §?§}

3 SCR 846}, the Supreme Ceurt, apizzed €:ha"{ ju§*£sdi<:'{iem

:5?
Si



 

---: 22 ;--

zmder z'%.r':i.i<:Ee 228 in gaaneifal ansti {:€:"i:i<::rar: in pa:'t.iCu3a'r, iS
digsretienary and in arcier' $16 imzaéae ex"é.i*2:{>rﬁima:r§r
}Turi:sdie::i.ign,, E90115 saianéi :m:ss%: be §'s':::~:£3i.:~3d up{;::.,

21. The ssaici éecisian is Sqtmreiy app1i{:a':;~T§§ E0 the

pmgésrsé. Case. Ti'1e:*ef@r€:, we held {hat {Em pg;i%.§_§t.4£:3;:11':::s?':~hgas rm

Imus siandi '£0 asssai} the ieasse g;"3;::té'&u  fa*=r7QL%:f €:*s§

respondent ?-§0.3a

22. Sagpiisz '£316 g;fié:f§:S21#iéi_i i'f%23r:éi::;§-7. A'pV14§33:§3%":;§.:d§"'L.i{3 iTf€E'§"£§3«§§ifif %i.'E"z;€--; {}§Z§?.2§?E' §.'§€;§€'E. i3GZ1E€E'1{iQ}'} §f§ff€Y€€§;:'_:§:373 I'%o.;3 gig that ihﬁfﬁfv hag; AV'b:§:":Cr1__ §>§£°0s:.$A'"-{§§§.3.'; zmé. iachés Er: fi§:1Z':1g {he writ, pet:i?£i'€::> '§;9 'F:':.:i:;r: an rscard, it is naigﬁ that. gm @?'/'{'}8/ éﬁé: §'§ir§.F£E '&ii{8;E§8; Sitajis P@1§'2:a'I;i§;0':3; C{>:1%,m1 Bsjaré iggigﬂésﬁ. 3; paiénéiﬁ nﬁéice puiaiiahed {:1 'Indian Expresa' and ' 'V'E*2"a§§i{:;':§éi5'$913253 ?2:§€:"$,, §'€g§a3;"d}:2';g §fi'}§}{}$:E"5{§ @'§}e:.1§::':g sf {he "§.if;{§'§';.~'{§E'f6 .. ::z;7:§1%;':g§ in Eisﬁiiaagﬁg S&EEd22E' 'E"2:§'L':EL Ebyﬁgé ";<"5i€*2':r'21:2:-3:.%i{;--- 'is:-; an :i*Xi,:'@3L/3:2. {sf §%3¥§2 E€:;%<:€{.§1;'§3S 'WQES ;§:a"'az%§":.a:E£ {K} 13;' R-'V§A/2¥:'x,§.Q:% 83353 a €%E£Z€ii?;€ E%EGiT§.§'§ca*i{'.i{§1/2. g3*g::1f;.§n§; &§§}§f{3V8;j£ .A ';;né:-:':=*-- 9€.§%1€ Fares? {C0i":§:31:'s;21:i@:1§ Act, i§8& fer miming if ax ,I .s=*""'/Q'

-: 23 :w aperatwgzs :11 S.1's!E..E%E<>c:E:, S.':i.E'2§u.E" Taiuk, in faveur of 3"€s;§<>:':d€:"1i; N03 wag isguasrd an Q1,/Q§j'2GQ5. Fu:'1:}:;e:', the p€3f;E{}';{)'n€31' has aémié.-Eeeti that abaut E.'?§ iakhg ienneg per .Ei11E13.'§I'Z'fi of Eran are was being: purchased f:*:>r:1 '1;;Etf;e mirzeg Eocatﬁd in BeEa,ry;'H03p£3i regien, smite: had epenaﬁ a: pig iiren faaétary in ihss ysar §9§2';,_ Vi1§'3€'%'€§G?.%é'9 §;°E2,e p€€§t':;1§:'§1e;* {timid mat; grefcésnd its ;§éMig:z_<*);r;.~m'z:; ::f"t,h_<«aasi&*§'a=:::s. E:

is aim geen 'ﬁat. the p€"E,.i"§,i{}§§€I°'7§T}8 ;:':§_ $:3u§§§;f $;.;;'~izygzpiaifz-.:7i::ae ﬁeiay in fiéing {he writ pefiiiéa by S3§_8;{Iif1§? aha: it beartama 8;Eﬁ§8;1'€' :35' é:h%s:~ ggazzi: véfi"~~§§:_:i3:*:€':?';§;;' 'Eé::-:::4::~:e:3:' 'é:::§; réégpgéfgééﬁgzi §§§';,3 anijeg after it raceivad Cgpieg fkfﬁéthfés' {':@{:--%;1:{r:'€%§2€;é=f--~ &;{>u§ghi by it undér Tfi in' the msnth Sf éuiy, 2861?, The reagan gs'; :0 's5?§;i§%V_i§:f:j%r:3aii9n wag Sazight Qzﬂy in 531%: mid 28%'? am 2315);? -__e§é:ﬂ§':2:.:ﬂ hag Emf, "bseztg eX:p}a.i3".:ed by the p,€.:%ii*£.£02n€r. %si%§'{2'are_r3'f the view {hat the §;»€"E.§E".§{§n€r Wag a.¥:€E£- ' a;%.".é,:-»':;;§':i'€ :é3?: i.§'.};_€ grazzé; {sf m.i;1§;:.:g Eésagéi Ea regpazzﬁeiﬁ whg haé ;i::iv:- 213$;-zﬁ {E25 ii} iigrzs. '7§'E'1€%§"€f{:':'€§ t.§*2€:§'§ ES " .{i{-5§a'}: éiziéi Eziézﬂxéss ii": fééiyagg iihig :%;?é": §;s:":§':§en ::%'z"Ef§ €736 §%:?:.i§i{}§':

{:eé::'2m' >§ $5' haard 9:2 maézﬁfgg 0:: {hag S£IE{§§€. /,./3 ": 24 :--

21:3' in ::hi.s:~:« ct:0:'2i'<3>:i;._ ii; is; 2*:-':*E.s*:'a«'T":»2";:1E'. '€19 {'.XU"E}{2'€i iihe <>bss::?:'v:;:*£'§<}:'";s; m.23.{i€ 15)}: 2m.<:;i:E':§%_z* §;')'iv§:?:§§s:,:+§: Eiéémth 9? §:'E'i:i$ C<)m:'é. in "Q:/'.£~':,E?'§<>.§}2;'2{§{}8§ :%;E':§{7E.": a:':'3:-3t;é {'r<):'s:1 €.}:i.:'--.; *w"§§i: §}€:'i",§;1Z'.i{}'§'3Z- "26, E3': jé:7z<:£,_K_ {he remanzi. arder d:/zzfed §?,f5,f2QGG pa::;e;€d by 5&3 r:'J€r:'§.';*<).i €f}OU€?ff'E%:§'2£?4Z>?"{§_ :.:>§zi::??': is ;:3s'0ciu<:{,>:ii 5/3;; ifzszt §3e:'iEi{3r':e=r A' 5§;'2:*:a%,:z°z.:r°e>.~§{3 :s;§:a:.g.:s iézai. ::.'e§":s;%r: €326" §.'{zi€::>;'2 up. 5:328 g}::?§T£§i:3:':g2z° :4;.,%;:$A":'2§3s;a§:':'.:. :.:._:E';:é§9a*%:;%,§§: vi"-.'.?é;.s::: Séggigz {}@:%€_ri'2§'?'1€:':§:' £,{i?{Z$ :":§§?g2§_*€%:€;é:'€::e%:§" ?f E}a'§°=ze:tz"'§;r' Q? .Z%:f§%':€.:'":§; C::5'E.{;§ €3e£§£;>g{:.; V v;,§j';g_§'§:§';1:e?§9% :'%:::§:'s:%g:'5i 5:": §'§'za':% ;;s:z.§s£ {};*":§.s3:9v'V?:;:1%r;*_V':.;:::i.§g3:9§' é :"2{;§::5 'é;§'.:_z;:£. §'.E.'r:%g?% ;r,%'§§:.:f:_'EiV§§:*:g::" §§é;é;§;§2i::;%'Vv'§'?:{s:2;§:2,§); rs-waived. EEK: :';£é§.:;f€ §':a:~,: ;'%_{>E"

:' :'€$_;29r52.':,iz3ri_Er: :3/:z'I1._:}'-::<;5:rf:§:€:; 320.5" §'1Ca:-.3; EH2 :*eq::.ga;<3§ed j?e{° :2r§§{§2;.g;f:ig:.éiég>:ifc:i»?:.$;€§£(2:r€:£.ia:'2 0;? fzés {,'{Z,§§€', E--3'53 _ :15; i.§"::-§rgf§2:>:"g%--. S:'*f._ éjziggarza :";§;§{"%E,"§,.?;35U£??"e as 3'25 O§"}§?Q?"§.E§.;'1f.i§§ 3,3225%: {€55.59 Zﬁffﬁ Q?" _ .j';ez':"/z.E iifgséafszéssfwz §55:§§€ffv% W963 Z.i?{£;'§ §;:*::é';;%€?c§ %;{-sjfézwg? ;;:s523$€:':§g £,'§':e :3?'€T§§a'~?E° zxzﬁd 5&8 E§§.>:z§;:>: "'iTf§{;i:L:§<-33:2:§':%;a%:'s§' §§.$é?§§ :§:.:§,}:s'3'2:'§':'::?a':§ §.§'%.i,"§.§ £5', §:',.?{T§f§ ;'f';??"a"5§}{"§§"-;{?:'T§ 3:; {ZT€§?'Ef§f{T§{?F' {f?§§,.f§€" <:::'2. E'?E§??"§§:i z.§:::'% §'?'3:{'.€ 5.5%,' E" E. 5. -"{3.i€¥ 57$? §"?'3{/E3"? {§.2E?{f§. ) E}? E":

9-»...

is E'§'z::.s ::;':£a>;:z:" 'i':'§'::2£' Eiéiéﬁifig "E355-Esi Q: :2:-3v=é5;i::>:': g9»:3zi:'.:'.€s:}z': in ihéi gggaz' §§}§}3 {:§':.52;EEs3::§é::g £153»: -: 25 :- rejectiiarz 9}' {he apgéieafjion made an 9/8,? 2993, the peiiiiamer did 329:' chaase £9 aygear befare the Cerfatrai G0¥}"€*_f°?'7£§"ﬂ;e2"':€. The C£2n.:':"'aE Govemmeni hemezger remanded {he nzaiier far fr'es§2;

cansalderaiiorzfézirgg $1 iime iimii Q5" ihree ma:':.2*;hs from the daze of {he erder wfzisfz. was E ?;'5;'_'2@G€h There::gi%£:r {he Q:"g?.+.?§' ' _ 5/ ?/2932 has $69.32 passed 4:; ~ appizicaiisiz. 'f'%i€ p€{'£ziaz':§e5%V §°z::5$% Vsfzaé s§v?*§{3_:;¢3z*;--»V«'ii0"" chaE§e3"z;ge :%z:';~:«: ardezz Net ;é§z§;;; p?éti€:fér2;é;+;faQ€;ii{$7-1 pasrsue the rev§3€0rs§:»€:'i:iarz 'zasféich z1:,§¢:§:;i.;g2€2j:a'zZ%Zrzg fram 2993 21552092 bz,;:~-.;::* {£530 §E.'i:;*§ ::z;i9§E aagzge pm is': 5:325 _pra£e€éé';_§:2§_$V' *:ie.:3:a:"'s§, E363 tfzeréfﬂgf E621 ééii ?:?:é.T §;é'ar'E";?§QA6 -zgzfii p€z:':"§era€r

--aii§; ' ;6-"S X ..E'~;;35;:f;A""j*'onia {E19 afgeva Ehere :13 a _ déE::§.; 'z.:3fQ:;:e ~§;'€<'::?: eigfzé nzmaéhs {nﬂiing ihe u::*z'§' V§€ié£i9§i"'-ffgm {he afa:'e> 0f the impugned zéyéijieaiiafl aizd {he {ease &8€{é. ﬁe zzaégfisaiian T' -. %;:::gs":,;;£.%1ai,?zas bees: gzgzieiied ané ihé rzaééce isﬁued _:g:::;'§3§:§4 §:'§".s:€ §:§'Z§}i¥'9§"{f7.-?"§€'é'?:;§ €'§3':»*"{;%§;'Q<%{€a3:} ;'%a:?§:, are .. "g,:§aa§%3§§is:%:a>:3§ €132 €335 Ezéizziggager, if :'§':.a§ ::_sgj%;;::£§ ":3 §,€f"£:§€§'S§£i:'?§ 3205:: 552,53 _;:2€¢§i§"€§z?;€s* gjaazéé. s::§;1?:€::§ iffzaz ii" was' gzasi mzéare Qf €336 gmizz: Q3" %"}73:§§'E§§"§§ E5939 5:: jazéaur of She aypeiiscmi; €336 wzzduci Gf {ﬁg pei"ié':'0;':e2'° QEE iizraughaui Q3 ﬁdveried {g .6'.

,2 :

é::~~ ~: 26 :m Fzereirzabeve siearigg ghaws that ii' has 210:' came ﬁ3¥"{.{§C2',f"0§ wiiih {E29 '€mefa3€f.'$. {is Q:-;§S{:'°§"Z"iG?2 {"3295 ii" had 520 Ecrzazsjfedge Sf {he ::i:';<;m£5:;5;a€ of {E3 appiicaiian and of {he grant of zszirzirzg 293,353 in famw" sf {he SW3 respon&em" cazmoi be p:"':Zr_§":a jicgcfz? Fyeiieved. 1:': am" E}E:€{Lﬁ, the iearrzeQ';«_'S--:§r_"::§}E€., Jzzdge aazghi {as have ::=an,s;i&ered. z,:;f§€:}é:.3.i'?'7;é'§*?V:' pe€iE'i0n.€r had m;a&e Gui" am; pri:?za;.f:§,{5*£s3 532;' §"€'S§€{'.{ cf "his; ciaim §:2e:§'%$:*€»"L€€a€i::g .:i;§.:§z ":i*?1e vaiédiégg Qf {he {ease )gmn§""§'L-'*;:i f0.vG*:;:§f Qii" €E:.£3.L:3f€3 'V respsndezzz;

E3. .§.€QQ§..:Cf'{a<?;<g_}{§'?"QVV§'E...Q5 5:1? 'z:.;~;*§':€€§':,€3:° EB? €£§§§§'C{Z§§Q2'7ij'{§€§' E;«%;;.i%:e: :%;%:';;::;s'?'e5§1_e§3.i éamizzg 3326 year 2999 Sé'G;0--:;?;. rezgjeeied "bf:/a:é"'-- Egg?' the deeming pm:}£éi€a;;..¢§@:1£:a{$§;e;§ Er: 5;;ub~ru§e {3} Of R336 24 0}' z:?;e"Miz*:er:;§'Sézigﬁéggioiz Ruées, .E§5S prim" {Q izis deE7€~§:i9f2:. afrizd caurzier srgzzferfaiwn by {he 3% §"'t3:*:~§Z?G.?"T:,§,3&L'3"2.?§_j____§G;"~:* {G E.£}§7i€f;§'§€§" an accozxni 8f the _ :ﬁ§;§§éiion Qf {he pmvigisrz; €%:.€s'e was :10 ﬁeemeﬁ T' vv..v4;fa:§v§Ve{,*§§i:::Vr}s are .m0;i"ie:'s {hail wiii jétzié fer vggrégﬁeraiigyz 9:23;; 5:5" $28 peiiéésnssr £5; e§':'{'€§'Eé3::§ E5 .. :rj§aaé::§ai:": ::%":€ :,:.::'€§' g§8§':éz'.i:'_>?'a E3' ?.z1?"E§§€'§Z ::§§':a;§. Eiﬁﬁééé §?":e z-,j,§f?e:.:t§' 5.3;?' §':§*:€ $€'0:.z"::i{"s§"g.; 3336,?" a:§;&é::5s?: {he Séﬁié €§§:;{3:'::§ne>;r:§'%;'5a;°' {:s}:z3€a'.z3ri;2§ éfaf {::;'}g3E:'€§~§'4i§z2;L,?'"£§€:::§ by {he 3"? §"€$pGEEd€§'1i§' in zjészw sf £339 pr£2a}:'3£:3:§§ af S{£§3~"S€C?.i0§"E {2} Q? Seaéian 2 FGF"€S§ § '?g'i%- * ~«-: 2? :~ {Cerzeenzaiien} Act, IQSG, whiek was iﬂiféf remeved if": {he year EQSS, {viii else wise eeig efier {he peéiiiener primafazjie eeiabiishes éhai hie appiieaiierz was pending a:" the iieze whee the appiieeiien jiéeﬁ by {he 3-*6 respe-?2&e_m'fV_:'£:§E£2S mkenfer €€}?'ZSi&€?"€ZfiQT'i. As if: is prime A' ihcai {he appiieaiioyz j'§e& ey {he wriéi-._§e§,j:éier:e%--',: -- was rejeeieei in the gear" "Q1333 V' S€'§'iG?.£S deubf regarding p7eiiié§0?%::er's3».€e'e?4£§§ :§:{2;;:2,&i1f.: ﬁe rrze.£m"e;in {his wri:»epe:€:€e?::..V_ 2': is §i§::s;:g;;e$§£o:i which is jiirsi req:aired'V'?é{}:°i3e a?1eeia2?;e§E§ieje1::e geing I énie the Eegaiiigg er Oi?fE,E?'::1*ni:S€€VVé3:fV ihe gé"ani*'ef {ease ezade €nj%2'ee:gra':;§V3" §%.2e-- :.e;§:;:>:§:::e;e;2:; *=eje:a:§4' 'C?;s:;3:'i?er;ie"?:ez/;;€ has ﬂied {he V'r._As:'a£ee n1ez*a'i'-.ee?Eg;7e£':£en;s and Ezee supperied She a§:;_3e:f:iéra§ 3"? ?"€SL@Q?7£§.€f1f; I5; :25 me: in dfi€g9Vﬁ:',§::e.v"Z%ie.§ respendem hag eaée a :_.-8i;£;*?.'."§A ej°§§ES;'*£*;38,Q§§8QG;'~ Zewerds {he eaiue fer

-v._v§:'§:e;;§7§é%e${ sane es.45,32,2ee;~ éewardg {he C93? VV"§§_'~v':?e§é%§;}erz$e;:er§; ejeresiaiiee and §§s.8,'?:'§,2§G;'« ,_v§'e:,::¥:'e;r&$ ihe eeeé Qf'ea;§7e:'g zeee. 'E'§1e§"e ée aiee es " _ gleréees e%§,s_;§u.€:e ijfzez' ﬁze 3'"-3' ?"€S§L38?":§€?E,§; Ewe ieeeeéeé Emge ﬁFE'EQ§,:?'i{i §§§£§::E;§"'&S eeeeréreg me.e§':£:1er:'e3 and had esaréeﬁ mfrsezg eieeméieev in see}: eérezzmeiarzeee. ifze balance ef eeeeemlenee {ﬁes in ffaz,>e:,;z' ef {ﬁe 3": fegpendenz '5;";?c. %' {appeiianzf herein} and 31:35' in "flavour of {he peiiiieréer E,U?'i08€ appézbaiigzz has been r:2j€ci<e:':%';._;i?2 £18 year 2963 and Lgrsha przima fasée daar,-is have any géakesﬁ '§'§*ze ggzgeﬁian wh:éf€'}:€%».'_' Eeireciar mag cam;3e{"er2i :0 ' :§:.:§r'(.if_es"

rejeciéng {fie Ciaim sf' £'§:.é"m::§§"§i;«_ ':;}€§'c"15'§;Q?;'::.':':"';"VVVV<*;Ié:§:? L. remand and as $0 whetfzeféi aisa 0; maﬁa? whisk rz o :=. f:>:e Vcjoiévgéiéziiered -3;: % this siage 35 {he i:3ei£:'§$fza:>ﬁ}f" has cégasz in ?:i.:*«; Carzduci anfii' §;©r"';§5t§{§g¥;;}{§;;€.g}ré£g% éjérpiﬁin {he ﬁeiagg in; apﬁroaéfzirgg ffizé-36%?;é_2%§'$:?;:§f§2::;:gEar£g/g in She Céféiéfﬁi Qf 3=*?5"'r3esg§§§3%;é:£€§2.:V a:%§,.ie§;€%€g his pasiizian :3 §tsi5;4_ " ?j;£?:§; ' §:::§:'_c§ga gum ::*;;"° gstaarzegg ;}ag'§3"éé2°':€s made fa {fag f§;31G%J'ge'i:f{tz:e2ié§{:'I{:1-Ejﬁwjfﬁis vaifibas charges. " 24$, "17h§2;g§§2' ':§7§e'---.._}.33¥'i';¥éi$§c@1': Bench in '€x?',A'N§.§2/EGQS ha$;'s€;;i@é.V':1§§a'€"§:hé 0bS€2"va"{§@r;S maﬁa in $136 arder am " :':Q§5i:§"'%[:1f£;-iéj'; {j§3IESid€Fai§G§'1 $5 the interim i:€h.€f Saaght 'ﬂy-" the p@ijji?.;i§v£3é:f_V_ E"éf?$:?'£%i;"}., 'W6 azra af £316 *<;Ee':>:: 'Ehai. 'Q36 Said; £::bS;<4:r$:»3*{i::rr;f$ aazeuid Sq2;;:z'z;2"€E§_; agpiy avhiie sansiﬁﬁrzing zizia Z%??".§§i gééiﬁéazg Qéfi ;}:"€E§r:::i:2z:§:; §;'E~§S§,éf3$ EEEEEE i:,§f:é5':'§%§33é:°ax am £2?' SH: "'€Ji?3%§;?' Ezhai Ehs Same 22:23 app§;is:~:'@§€ 62:63; at {MS siagﬁ 9? {ha 2 fprsceséiyaggt '§'he fG§G'é£*'s.z'ii'§;f§ éecigiang Qiieé with E'6§&E'§ $0 the aspect Sf deéag,-r arid iaighas gm 3% feiiews:

2:?

-: 2% ;-

a} Em the ('R56 Qf Ramana ﬁayaram Shetty 9, Intematiaaai Airpert ﬁutherity 9f frzdia and Sﬁzers {E §?Q} 3 S30 48$, the Suprems Smart, heidg '{Z§7;;'a:1:€L'.T';he writ p€i:i"ti0'§3. vsras fﬁzsd. mare: than five the ac€:epta.r§c€ sf "me tandezz daring _%a;}§E1a7}*:' ::pe§:';5& _ ﬁiﬁé; 3uC<*;eSSfu1 tenderer' haé incuréjeﬁ $::Q'§:.Si:iei4a'b.1€'--§:%§§égf:(i'i'§.m*§ 4_j and haé maﬁe a3*rangsmer;§t$ :é;;'.3§¥"'*?,her&'f£*}:j%:;'Hit §z{3{:£v{d%"%»be mast iniquiieus is gsﬁ, C§ﬁ'ifé.C§S. it wag alga ctlarifigeé ihaéi {ha beegi Véiffereraé; if 316 ﬁhﬁﬁgﬂgﬁ $9 .v_§!-333 §€'=I"5 §i"' Emmﬁdégiaéjg.

'§'he§z;'fl0*r3,'ﬁtipgﬁizae C'u::§'{. ﬁeciimed ta mierfare ané gz'a§3§'£_§"éE§€f if}; %;:*:§§%:--.§@_§iti0n by :19': exerciging éiscretiam anger A:"é:;Z€§1:: Cengtiiutigri 0? Endiia, Sﬁtaziiﬁif in {he C8;»S€ Sf State Qf ﬁffs ﬁnd ' Déﬁéfgegﬁg §,;._;::"§§:a:z§§a§ Jaiswai mzﬁ ﬁtﬁers {£33833 4 SSC " 5§£§6§§ €',§E§:é%j_;?§1i:pr:3:1:é3 Seam. hsié ihaé. the §{1*§§f§f €§*f3{?iS§{}E} 123$}:

*;'$ga§*§«;_E:£:e E316 §§'EE.,E":?. of §.i<:a--*§;;*::% fa? ::{:a;::s'{:"u:::*{é:>::: Sf ﬁégiiéﬁﬁréﬁs _f{¥:ei §ZEa.'E'1{§fEz{'i'{l?:.§§"f: :3? {Z{;:_:::iry Eéqzzgur :5;a$ iakﬁn GE: Eﬁﬂﬁf éggéé argé the firm zazréf, §e€.§€.§§:: was ﬁééd an ,:§:;/XL

-: BS :M 28/11,' 3985 abmzi, 2}. menths after the 1?mp:ugm&d pglicjg ﬁecigimz faiiswed $32' Githczf Writ §f,'E}:'§§€§1.'}E§5 Unﬁﬁr the €§r<:'uznsta:'§§%es, {ha Suprema Cf3E,§.I"'E heid thaz. that--éhéye wag gmss deiajg if} §.i1.i.r:g§ {he '%f$'§'i.'f p<3éﬁ.iar2$ and was unbééiievabie thai: the _pa%;i'{i{>:f:€rs {iid z1G:"~. §ina<é{:i£x;? ciiStiEEe:":ea were ﬁeing CG§1SfP11{f{5€":V§"2E§",'€ff§€_:1¥1§i'i?;§_$'§f€;§§' E:':§§;% ihkfs ;'§éiC{'3€ESS§E,'i§ t:end€rer;<5§ ma::1e§y' ':sj§%s;§§:1c§é§;»:E;g;A'».LE3 therein, The 511$-{EH16 CGV1i:*i:"g1§gQ :0§:-§:f:§,dV §0§i€y éesisian damd 3%,? iQ§~3é§ b$ S7¥£3S':" :2m3;:L§€ at ihe §:2s:~'?{an<f:s:~ {sf £1335 "'§%:"€}E"§§ Emmaags haréghip 'ﬁg 'f'€:$ _}f§€}1"1:zCI.$I},"{S;?:~': themin a;:& Céiuﬁﬁ grawii :%n¢fz}s§ﬁ§:':«:§...f{:s.ih6:f§i.,.._ Since enormous amauné sf time, 3;"I1€}1"1€:,7 .HE1d €"§*:_€.'*:'*.§.V§:~,*.-",_ ?g--}}€1fz€, by {hem in seiéing 221:; {E26 ﬁisgiiiaries s¥':3§%;_:VEV%i§ beégtaiéy '«ﬁ§8;S'E.€§. . ".z§3Es0, in Eifeéai Eag ﬁﬁﬁ Qﬁzers an ﬁtate Qf §;l£f§i€¥"'$ §§§§§§§ S SSQ 353;: S3:.§§E'°€iﬁ°£%E Sazzré. {:'@' 'se:e»:::<:s:%d'v'é;i§":2z;?:. i;*':a{:1:.§{§:': :3? éhs ;2pp::=:§E3;::*£,§-:» in app:"'Ga{,:%.:..§§:§§ {E38 *f_7,'.<ii;4§43r%'i4;"t5gE.';:*:f:{:eé;?€. a;:f*i§::' '£:f§:r€€-: gesarsé {>15 'ééééi impéjggnéiéﬁ §{:a§§% éﬁézé is $3": aéd§'i{§?.0':1s§ cirazumgtagzce 'E8 ﬁssszgbi tiiaész" bama fééas in Chaééenging {ha impzsgnsd aétienh it was 9330 gbservsd that éw ~: 31 ;~ int.erf€ren<:e 22%. that Stags Wiii I10: Gniy adverseig,-V aﬁéiti; this bUSii'1f3S~%S of Rr'3$sp«:}':1{ieE"1.'€, 5 but wsauid 2113:) fiﬂidfji' a Ea:rg€ m,:mbe:é3:° sf peapie Lm.en1pE032*<3:d aragi §f§§3i'§17€' the Siam its; {E§'}f3'§"'§S}.'};€f€i «ziesgire of d€'».i='e:*:.E{';pi§:g;§ .ir1d:2$tr'i2ﬂ grGw":4h2g '*. é} in Chairman 82. gm, EFL {.3133 ' I;;"§$5.;3_"@j{?§Vii.;%9i£raja And ﬂthers {(2083) 8 sec 56?; ihé: aagégt abserved éhai {E29 iﬁgh C<mr{=__ "had? :E@uz';f::*.:2._i6*£€,---s:&= 'a~__I1u1;3zr}.ife§;..A I ermr in Sf) far az-3 ii; had.»'fa,.§E€d %;:::_ fake T..:'z::.:;,::0n5g§§éem€,i0n ma: 'she dsﬁagr in ﬁfge ssaid {iézgé hezd 'ii:-:é"€§2i§§3d;fg equity: '"§h€ é3.§§{}7iEEE€£',E}€ if izizaﬁ '2-:r2_3Q:i:; _::':_g:é;§ . __§?E.3';-"ii" E§9§9 {he w:*'§é: p€f,it.iv:}:ij'*'Vz?L$ ﬁlVé§§£"0:*::: 3:<e21:"°A '£i}"1{;':"'§af':<:=r 'By the-smw T 316 ailoﬁtéze Ezaé izmi 491:1}?i:éi§;e':2.;§E;§ég§:sssi0§;; GE' the iazgd but 3.130 maﬁa SlE.ff§.€i€E}€.".,§§7£V€S'§IX§AF3§}§I;~" ﬁccﬁrding is me Supreme €au':'?:. .iC).E7__i:.hi3 é":i:;:';;i-.m'1t ghouid haw: §:;e€;:"; §:m:1Side:"{-zé by {he {%i.§g§§':V'€§§:éiA°€T_%:.{3b€ Sf ar-'i"1?.;3.E :§.::",a§G:"{.a31€:;e= €§2girma::§ §i.P.Ja§ Eﬁgam and ﬁgzg: :2 §a.§!';;§<z¥:§§ Sigizgh am gar; gggmsg :2 $53 %§§§§ gm V xSé,€§re§3;:€ €{}'E_E§"§ hag quaméi f§°{';E"?z'1 ?E2:}$§3:2:;"}:"§ Laaarg Q? 83'?

3.,

-: 32 :w Engianci. in the fI".%:£1§§'€*§.' sf qtensiéering the": case an the qg;:<3$i.§«:;«:1 Bf {£63.21}? and Eac%1~s%:'~s, Whiiéh ES e:>;'§{:1"*3.<:'::,€{§ as f@3§{;w.s;:J "En de'£ermimIng 2;?-?*2e£§2;er {here has been §z,;:r:h deiagg as {:3 amoami Ea Eaches, {E18 ::h§€j"p0:I:1is 50 be eozzsidered are:

{:13 a{'.'€fEé§€8C€?2C8 on €;i"a{3 c£a.{rrza.n€:':;§~. ;3a:f°:a, % amei -

{ii} mag; {3?'7ia?%.§€ Q1' A§{:.;:i§:i;;m.. 9 €§"ée:::' §*;€.a$'' "

&C{7L£E'§°{:*€/"E 0:'; iE1eT'e:ig{?er1a3:;::é"'s paré'; A . 'V . Aaqzziesseiigfe ira {'§2i§____VVS§:;"a;e:e d§éf5=.i__ N955 mgan :;§{;;:§:';r?:§ 53;; a§;::.§"éf:fE-:2 Q3" 5:. :'€§§:€' £5»: :32. Aaragregsg Em: c:s$r3n,:'; cégfifef i.E:.e"'a€:;%ZQ '.€iar2 has bgezz ?:%§T;:"z;§;E'::i:e:§:fi2;i:*"a§; :f*a5§ ¢?é€:'na:}?;§' has became aware ';_Gf--i:. .,'&:": give {he ciairzrzazzi Q. remedy ﬁ§>vf:;s§:*€, Egg' he Ezag dame {hat which

-. ;f22€g§*§zi..,vf%;:§ri§g; '£3e :"{:'gard8& as equivaﬁegzé {Q Q ;_-wazéjez" or zzrfzare 75;; $2315; £az":d§.:cE' ané

-v._V2€egVEvs2«é:¢,._ ijfwugh, :%.0§':' zaéaizjigzg £315 rsszneﬁgj, he has _ @3252?" parigs in 5: _§)-0;'§iE1f:{}§?e gig: :_:,:?zi{:Ez :5"

$39: '$55 ?°f55§.:E>'5*?"iQ§'}E€ £9 péazfe Ezim. g' 3329 " .__§°é-,%.:?:££§g; §;§f€§'€ a:,§T'§s?':':,::{z_:zi..;<; '55 Ex? 52,3rs£;%r§.§::§.¢ 5?': szzgﬁ; :?::s,§;a>§ §.{,::§s€,> 53;" :':':?:<3 {mi Q2'-,>§a;,/g are :':;:@;<=;§: :%::>:.§.£:"ia;§, Eifpsii {E2836 {ia:2s21d8s'a:§a:':s; reszg 532.6 ﬁaatérirze Gf Eacfzeg, 5 y :='§*/ X" ' -: 33 :- 25: L-é?£:'i§"I'E(E€i'§ .;'j«<3:z':§{,>r {fﬁ<."s:2:":sa-"seéi. 2r:_p;:é:;'-z§§:_':;'.;s; £5): Tiihﬁf §}f;?'Eéi',..i{Tl3"}&'?i' has}; ciwzi 31¢: faiioz, rang; <f.§{;?€§?§.S"-§§{_}§'}§?_%TW 3;} §§§}E%'f} 2 SCC 10'? -- {i<}iE<?<i':{{:;:°, §},..:;'z:':u:i ;"%<':q:1:i-:<~T$if;.i{;}'§15. .§m;f:r:§.:";2.w;g.; g-":r;s:§ ;'§_z'2<>If,.'}z<?§* -- V. ?&/i.ss'£.'E{e1§:§j% E%.n{:§"~Q€:E2s%:"ss;, 3:2 £19538} 2 SEC 142 ~ <2.R;;:r;1£:g{>w§iz?:';_A' ..A:3d {}i:2.":€::"$ V. Sgzeziizii Egmd f§,g::;7';:~#i.-:<-s§':,--iA:§z'34 {§§E?§;;?:e':}_ 2321.2': §g;§2:%.E<:> i.''{;? K :3 ugga; ? §«:~<:{:; _ :_2::§-- e NTV:e§'--a§:gg:~§§;§';::g:~; EVE . §i.ri&:h1.'1a.mz.2§"¥;':"3};, ' u 'A 4:: ;:2::>@§,:; M» kssggm E%2:2::: ?%§;:.:z.é; ;?€;a.§':

Axzgé {}'*::E::%§'sé; :2...{';==:':%7%32aL§7<§E%12€%:'vVSé{§§v§'£§':=:£ {}*:;§:é:%1*$. E";«§__ .«m.E§iv:£s:;i<21':21§ §r'E£i.Z"§£3.§,§€i§'; ?§a.s:1i;:;s:é;.§-0::

Eiiiézxbzgr issééazéiiiss Y. E*sf§_am";':.;.

{_;éi'.E1{;%r$g 'ESQ'? Sfzkkizzz 3%} -- Eiazm K::_2"::a§" Gzéjgﬁi & {Era E. V " ' T E': $31 gh E3z'2;:6;§221:':.

"-~;j1z*§a.§' a;E:%=sa <;*:.E":<t::' {is%a.7§§§.§=:'::35:e 2:sg§:E': :°€g;:s::'{§ €253 EZEEQ " :;:=s:--.>aj:":{E<é:':2:§:;%.@':"2_ 02" a'§&'§é,'i§Z if Es": EE§§;'"_:_:{ §.h]:;':-5; *::a,»="::'§é, §;:€'§.§"%;i'{i3§'L 'E53? :1<§ié<:a'* IZE12,':.i' e;j§:-:%<::§s:~s"§::>z:.:=;; 2::°:':: §"é'ii7'2{"§.€§'53{§ a,m{§:%:" §€3{'f§'§{)§}. 3% <3? €:E*;€;*: §,in";:'é;2:ii§>:2; £:{:'::S EE%§:§§ m:£§%3;:° zﬁsiath away \ «: 35 :-

BE/'Q'7/'E_98€3 .h21v&2 3.1.} been $i;.a£'e{i. 'i'E1eref{:xre.; it is (:{}:1i€3.:1de3{i E,ha,i;. E.her«3 is m§:§~S§21i:en1eni: sf §'2::{:E..:-3 as»; the §3<«:i.§':.i<:zf:e:" $2213 'éé;-'EH E1'WaI'{E <2? the ggram. ef miyzizzg E<3a:':s€ {:0 §€<35--3p:3:1{i€z"1i: N€3.3 f31V€:?§1 1E')€:f{}E'€ nzakmg 21pp1.i<:«e1"£:i§:§::1;§'--gzzkder Right. "i':': infemxzziioza Aci; It is; a£s<} . '£§i;e1t?:..{:Ei- 'the §e:i;ii.i<3n€r 3:12:53 E'i€}fI a.ppr<>a{:hcd .*:%:i:;.;C<"::1;'¥i. fé;?'i£:V}'2 <23:-232;: Ef12mdS" in as mzitth 2153 E3 E12155 <:h{}5€:": :'.{§'.a-éﬁéiii '::Z%_i'€_g":a.§";€: "<§§°«."_i:%'21sé% as' r€%$p€;n<E€e:2.i: §%I{}'3 at :1 *»&2:i":.%3::_ 'if ':>§;c3T§:-:é':"1':*{:!c'i i<> t}n@ ps£:§':'.§{2:2€:° Eihéiil $1453 :-é:><:,p2%._;'1i.<;=<-":'-;::--,2%.§*- {§E"«'.§§€f g.z'°a;2A£:§:»:§ is EVE/§,JS'W :';%%:,::é$§s Eémiiaéd ax": ;'2{}§§'?' §:f:' '3f»,.:.?;§'*\§'<;;. !?;'2§{}? zjszzg Eibﬁiii Eli} 'E';;,:_=%.--.fa2*v:_:21té:{i.: _:'}E:1iE23§{:~i; Vii." 'i:E1:3 filfihﬁf Cafréff 9%' §$sp5=<:}§:1de2:{E." ;E'€§s,_3.:.E*:a{"-$36 .g:re':§€£i{>;'1s:r hag heen Se: mg by Mfs.§SW {,0 fﬂfﬁ thég writ; p@§i'§0B xxshem ii b¢g:i3;'E:§{:% a:'§€':s--.A§f_ ':.ha€: $121452? estxgyzgisst i§1{ifi}'T§§£'E Gzﬁer zaraiﬁﬁ bi; =:«jfa{;a'i£:.c§ .aé§*-re$p{3::de:1E $30.3 Erzaci mgved &1éi£(.'.§'1 an a;::p£i<*:a'{iGz"2 . %:}}*.";,2%,3 '§_».§.__g"'§§'{§'§? in E»i?ZE3'.T1"~E{}, §.:?§%£¥§!2{}{:}?, §§'"r§3:~;p€:3E§'2?€: 9%' 322g» §g§{:§: 242$ i;:'a',é '¥.§3"§€§i§i"3€:',E' 'the: §3:%'?£:1§§'.%s:>:':@':' §'":eé3:*<;°:3?i.§2 Z"12~:§ '§§§=/sag; E:%é't€ 22;; E3: " $=£$Eéf' Eistﬁég Lifféiélﬁfii is EEE: 22%;"; %:':@i3;}€:2_{Ea':'§::. p:=%%.§'€:ie:§:1 '£5; 213823;} '§.§';.& mirzizlg 2921538 §§E°é£i'.i"§.§€€§ Er: §'g:a:*<;::r {>5 :"€§§§3{2:1cE€3:*1E. E\§<;.3% what Fﬁecaézzzese &£§3§£%I"€3fE1E. ES the fazéé, :E':a.'§, féiééi pésiiéésaer J' 'Z'?

2;,» ~: 36 :-

herein had {sat aggaﬁed the Fﬁjﬁcﬁﬁfi arder dated G§jG?;'2G@1. gassed in {be case of {he petitéansz' fiii the 35635 EGGQ when W.Pﬁ:\§{é, 285?é'£»$/$2689 waa :f1"§.e& £5571, after the filing of the presem writ péiitien in N92#¢::{;:§;$:2V.vVA2Q8?. Tharafare the §€'{§?1EG'i1EEI" was di.S3:f3;i€T€S§€{:§-- i:j§"'-::%ﬁc::':riﬁgg a mining E3336 in its mama §\v'EQ§f".€€}f'§2'@§', _7i§9.:é"g:¥.f&:1i'{ :=§_1i1*:3Lnga_ 162238 is respsméenii {$3.3 in 3:?'§3bf:f€12i.:*3;*TT'«--"'§%E§35j€:%?_;"~,?;:éC'%58 $37' I asgaﬁeﬁ mg; in Ngvemb;:%:A:V%%'2.§0%,'*- ";fi3ﬁd %m the Qﬁiiiiﬁfiﬁf has $;1;.ppr€§a.s€;i3"j'v::r:a§:;A¢:"'i2;:;?;"faﬁts. %*hi§e {ﬂing sf ihs E-'€§'§5'€, §e'*;§iii9:: E35: 33552:} E3}; Séggggesééng that E": had 53:}: of mining £6356 to 2*€s§};}ndj€%zxﬁ'T'L'¥<§§:..,_ V3§<{iii..g}"2;:§§; --2;Q@"?1 We find that the peiiuener $3 rza t=._ §a» Se':<§_;0é;':6g ,.}f:'a?'§iét%:3é€§ :3 3:16 ieaga graniaai {G R§js§s3.:2é@3§1'{' V. 3:130 zzaitice ihgjé {E25 paiiiimasr has ._ éé':,:§;,3§'é:*é'$v§§5<§;"£;:*'é;€ fag: éhai. 2:33 aa§>p1§{::§.¥.:.§&:"; daéeii 2%,? E2; E932}; :' ;

:%E§éT§{:§*:_A wézg §€§€<:§®:§ GE": §§f'€1E{§:" E§§3 W223 Szzbseagzésﬁéijy " <i§4_:*<s::g':§'fé:A:§Z ii} gm-3 §"{f{3{}E'§;":§§§.€1i"'€'3§ amé 13:22? 9:": 53%; 'Z?;'2§Q§ éféer Was; pasgésé rejeaziigzg the &}gp§i{:aE§@:2 éaied 'T 2%/E2/1§92 Viéﬁ Afilﬂéxéifﬁ "ﬁmi", Tbs: facé Ehai: the

-: 3? :~ app}_i<:a'£.i0n 3%' the p€{it.%0ner deﬁed :23 X 12 /' £992 was yejecteﬂ prim" is the <:*:<}:°:si&€rai£@n 0? ins appﬁcaiign ﬂied by respenderzé: $0-3 Weuid impiy that 131% getiticfzar wguid haw: :10 29515.8 gzarzdi ':0 3333.311 tha miﬁing £0 fegpendant. ?'§G,3. B}; supgresging z3;n'§;_e:5;-:_§:r€: A_T'*§» '§"" S5;'®'?;'2Q@E, the pei',.£t=im'.:e:* §é023.gé";._{ ~:"£'haf:,*3.V»':;:;.._i_V;§:1'§'ﬁVVg; ?€aS3§: giramwé '£0 rsgpgndém ?*>;'{>..'3 aSW.%_f"§t$ ap§§E§.{§at,ia§:*. Q-*a8'V.I:1st canaidered befare gra.ﬁ§:§23g""'§1f3§%;» mi§:§f':g§_ .?€&i1S€ to ragpandent 530,3- 2%}, we aigg §§:':G%lw?%'::}é mining Eaase £2':

532233;:I"é}f.§§§§pGi%:ﬁ'eriEt.E"~€*9.3§ '¥fE"';;v: p€'{,§'E.i@n£,*r has faﬂeé to bring . to E§":iV{",' i*1§ti;*e3 {:§% AB1':e:a:u:'e--RE &ai5ed 5;*'?,f2@G3. andf 'g%§}$.§.'€:X:i';'%3¢VE§3A ~?ﬁa'Eé§d 3,f'?,/2G§?. Thg Saiéi éﬁcumenis };§a'€;r'&;»_be@§ a<i*:%éri§dV ii; abm-re W§'E§{3§"1 Wauéé {zieariy bring out "$216 peiéiiazzer has; no {sass siarzdi :23 aaaaﬁ €326 ::j;_§z1i§:V_g.§%Ex:a:;%€ gragéiaﬂ §é?."%!{}E§E" :3?" fespgﬁésm, E'~£{:a.3? 2:53 ﬁfsﬁ §s:§ii.%.;§%;e:"s a§§3E:§.<:;«3§§<>31--% $223129 %s;>*€%:: E:":§5»§e:f:é€§':iEjg; " 'V<:;e:35ﬁ;*3;ée::§€§f"€s:E <:%a:§::i;1';::a'§§:"§g $12 {Egg {}:"é:s::' iiaéa-Ed 5,31-?'f2$GE amﬁ; 'i§'1e:'efem, ihe {:{;E:€€::::;,i§{}n sf the Eeayrzeé: €:su§:$€§. far a:

xv' §'€S§(}{}§(ﬂZ1i Fig.3 that. ihers has been E3'Lipp.E'€S8i{}2".}. Qf ma':ez*'ia1 _f'a<:iés has; is 136 21<é<7e§>t4@d5 35b in ihig {?€}£'if,ﬁX"§., {iW(} déctégiwzas i.r:"l£§.;,§ﬁ§;'-3??'*zuc:jf;':'r2a. :3. $teel Authority of India Ltd,.,~~an;£ :':£§:§:?;:%,%;»j*:;r*'M";2;ai9é' gag} SC 5?} and Prestige Lights L:i:+;i.;._A_:z:3;' J 3293?; 8 sec 449} ara';:.~§p:;s;:T¢;" §3_¢'E';e:Ve.:eiﬁ4"éii§ég2':.'{'§0f: 9:' $"uppr€:S&§§<3I3 had; ?J;€€3I"i C032: affaer eiuciﬁaiiing 01:: £1.58 {:<) f:;€:§§g;:%'Qf*f§:"a;%§;. "Pifgzra, 2&3 amé 2% has heéd; 23$ :zr:c§<::=:sr".: -' 3 V' T§f'.,'f"a§ '_;§:;z.:fi;%;:3f;'%1::iié}%: af 5325: Szzpreme {;'a::.;r§ "ié?'é:d{fF' !;:7ziei":.?;:«. 32 ajizza'. of €319 E-iégh .~€'e:)u;zj:' .'F;£F?,CE§€f'--;""' --,£'1é':;€C'§€5 225 {he Cazzsziéuﬁon £3 _ Ye;2;z.r5c:crdé§zCi:-r;;,-- f eqaaitabie a:':& '{_iési:7_r€£i_0::s::%'y, .§?§'e;>,;f95;:a:E'£vé3 wriis menéianed E}:-.9r<2£:1 Lzré" .:5s3zf:'<~f:d5 fer deirag subsianiiai jus{%Z:?>e," E: 'is? 7f':f'zé:*'le;f70re, of 2,:.§'m9siT necessziigg siizaii :?;.§;__vp€{é£T:er2€r a§p:'oa€E:i.?zg {he 'iifréz ﬂaw": rz"::a_%;€w::'e:>me with cieazz fzanés, pm:

'}'§:+gzz;§,2fa:f;0i aii {E28 fazﬁs bejare 3&5: Cauré 'V'E;¥jEii§?,C%:§ff'%;§G?E,{i'€G§€EZg or szzppressézzg agzggifzing Vé:;zé;_:i an a§p:'Qpz°2ig2a€e reiiéjl if ifzam is 22?} ;fu3;%2:"§£§ §§.E§{f§$SE§€°€ Q3" §'°e§s5z2a:':§" 532$.

":::a::sé:':°aE j?as:'§'5; 2:}? 533.9 _;§e:z':'i0:3e§° :23: ggzgiiijgg sf " .:':é£s;t§:?{z£i?':;§ ihe §_'ﬁz:%a:;*':,. Ezig pe§:"§E€@:z §"'f§G.§; §:se §:§i$3i:'aEs::su.r55aE :15 Size ::'}::'es?':§E§ '§.é'fi§§"£GZé§ {:0:2:$:'§£s"€;2§ zifze ::ze3*;'§;<§ <35" éfze {,f§€§§??'E, 25% xi p:"erag{2,::'ve remedgg 53 $39: a ??'2.{}:§E'€3E' of soazrge. E/E/7'":z'ie exercigézzg exﬁizmardérzargg pause? 0, '§?'J:*éE' Cam": £21'-=:}i£§O§ E .

-: 3% :~ e.:*eri'ainig; bear in mind {he canduci of €516 party wﬁe izzzgeekes {he jzgmlgdiciiarz sf the Cami, if {he appiicané ?'T'éa}{€S a faise staiemg-:":€ O?' 5-guppresseg nzaéeriaé fagé' 9:, azfempis E0 mislead {he Court. 5326 C0u.r:,_ " T. may dismiss the gciian an ihaz §r0z,g:ﬁ::ai?»._"'*<._ aione and may rejiise :0 es/zéer if2iQ""'E?1€~--.._:' xneriis of the cage 53;; staiirzg "We wfiﬂ 529:' iisien :0 year appiicaiisn, because».-::,5.'_:?t;3hai: _ you have dsne". The ruZe.--E1'a.5< beer: gsjdéesgsd V .] in {anger pubiic §:F7£faT:f'¥'€S5.£.( L §::;=, unsampuiazgs Zii€§0.?'fiZS j%'%3:m'-._a§bus£f'zg ''if§'i€ " ' progegs QfCGii?"i' %g {i€::Eeiv£n§.iZ."°'* ' ' in the ;'$€CO§£& ('£38, Eh'e«.;§§}gx C.{§i&.;f_€ haé: 8%S€I"'§-'€§ as ':;::'1d:€r:

Si ";";»'?;a§" itheaggfz {he ﬁ'§g3é'3§§_'a?7£'::f?"{fQ:"§fg§}a?';§;; §':§§=;:"ii..v:;_,,%31§;'T$2{2;{:§2.5*a? 3&5 Efégﬁ Cazgzfi : a::5é7'€;'*'.;-Eriigj ., af 5315 CO§ES§f§¥,£§?:O§7;, if Emﬁ :20: carédeidigg sia.€é:§ is {he Cami; ??'E€ .»E§£§*h,_ 'j;Coi£§:i'~ '-.s3x€rézZs'€ng diserefianary and ex_£r.a0?~a:iV§n.;¢§*;§_;L:r£;::;';:€$€i0n wider Azﬁcie 225 of {ﬁe "Ca'nsi'€£v;€{:3fr':«..V '{}j:;':c3?:j ané abave, a cauri af Saw :3 @230 «:3, ::*{}m';".q{.éq;:i:'g;¢ IE' 5,3, éherejlere, of uimsﬁi rzecessafy Eizzzrf 2:L~"-her: a _par:;; ainpmcsgcfzes £3; Efigh ' " §§39:,s;r'§; "E:e_Vmus§' péace Q55 Z?16j*aC:"S befere ihe Cam"? ;;.:;i:'%:0§,a:' af?j§}"'§""é'S€TU€i§§GfL £3" :'§':e;"e 53 S§,.{p§§"€SS§O?E 3 :3:§::-éeriaijfaﬁig an {he par: 53;' {the appiéeani' as' T. :iTr_,;j?1.a°iVie:»:§j;Z<,<§;:::'s izave 5389?": gassed b£,jf@;'€ {ﬁe Cami; "é'§«%.%: .'1C9§,.:ri' mag; rgjfézsg is €:"a:::3_r':f'airz {he peégééian Q?zaf*§"§'i§:?:i$5 is: :z3é§'§":<:e:,aE €:2:er§:'2§ ::2€::% _?'fE€§'°§§$ sf €326 ':--?f::::£3€r: "

C3}"idi€§}-" 0'Qs€r=J:3*d ihat §t2§ga.r2i$ Eﬁﬁiié raaarf, 3%- 3:: 52:5 {T'.::E;':§§:' 5;? §§§£§ Sigzgft £2 Siaie af §££ar ____iPra&€§§: Qmﬁ atﬁers g'{2QE§} 2 SCC :14; E: has %ee':1 ¥F*:"$%»s ("P 0 2,1nei§1ie::3.§ meang by giating faisehoaﬁ far achiez-ring their geais Gughi is be depre{:3i:€d..

32¢ hi :3 alga :1®:i{%é3d {hat 1%? irzgg =_/ filed by the p€':i€;i5ner S€€§§;'if{}£_§ a d;;::*%::7'T£§§:.;._i'AVm». £1336"

3"€Sp0ﬁﬁ€§1£ ~ a:.1i4h@a"it:1?€s is {:0fi=:s:'5;.<r:¥i" 11Es"'a_pp1i;éa'i;i;éz; iiiagied 29;' 12/ £992 The pé"£:?*§;Z01:--": '":'éj€€:*:€d 0;':

E 3,! $2?' 1' 21G@8 Wiih the#5013013;:';g':_§3?3é€rvaiiefr:5:4 "'4' II: {he <;'ir'{7':;r;*:;e"Ea;::*s3;é;, "z§?.{$ pefgéifeien is rejezried AbasedA,.9r:_ {he-.s;;b:°fz'€s3'é:2:":' of {he Govt, Aézsaaiﬁvaieg £5'-1_a;:' iifzezj a:z;r:"::2'g'{;I;?§" yassed by 5&2 are $37/"§'f,:'°'2gZl*'i'}.'..§ _r§:§§€';f§§fz§<_ £36 laggaégiiaaééaﬁ Q5' E§E€ ;}£,>i§.':'l£§@"éi::?r j'§*;%s':__g:'ajj':..sj 7¢j:"__ §1:£r"2§3's.§ Viegsse. Q2 30 aisa ihe €L§Q%;*i,:'}Adv9ﬁcai€--'isﬁrireézed {9_fu:*r?;,:$§": cepy af ;€'?fz'e ..Q;%r_i€F" {'?:;3"';3e£i£'§éf:ér wiihin 8 days jifam iccfrrygg." -"fE7_'§':'e:"e{:gf'§i€«:v;rf,_ -is'! is far {he gezfééieaer {'0 "C?2QE_ieng€'«§5'i*a€2j °:3,aj1:':":g.--~€2": axfcordarzee with Zaw. if azéy 2*:a>z}i$€0zi'.fs.--'_fEé€.d, auéfzeréiieg carwerzzed shaié no? %'5;;iSe.:§i:;:3 gj*3_,aes"E':'erz sf Zimiéaééan Siﬁéfff FQ§€€§,'i9E'?; % . afgfzé ﬁigﬁﬁiicaiiaiz 5;; R42 an @5f€3?',f2§SE has mi ;}:>gea§.;€m2":,z+k2;:;s':"x:t:;:*ai::a>d Ea {he peiiéiszaen "

,3} T. ~ "i?f§:§:§fef<;:"€§ 'WE are {}f 316? viﬁw éhai; the §§°'eE§::':3E:r:ar§; {}§:;__§€::"é:1s;:*«z"2Sj_.;'3:$€*{:§ hf}: E'z'i$§}€§E":d€E'?.§f, $30.3 hm-*9 is 50%: §}.€i€:€§E €§. §§{i{?{3§'{i__?§'2§§§E}?; ?:E":é% writ: §:s€i,§i§{3:: £3 €:§.E%§§:i:=§s:'t:E 339%; {}:::§3; 92} iris ',3;;j};f{2j{;;::{§ {$5 §.{"}{?E}i:S giazzdi iii' §}€f§éi§.{§};'i€%f €:::: m.a§:§§;2:§:2 {big i?¥§"iE ___§e€.:'?.é0§L but 93,135: an €115 g§r<3::§:§§; {if §%3*E3;},.---' ané iachea as a-156% 5,/<~ ag Ehﬁ guppresgien <31' maieria} factg 1.-ivhich thvaari the €:<:zzs.:';d€:'ai;§9z1 of the {E315-363 <3»? the p:§*:ii€:i9:1€r an meri?Es;_. ﬁ_ *r"nz}55 frzéex: '2'";'_.?"¥

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

M/S Sathavahana Ispat Limited vs The State Of Karnataka on 13 April, 2012

Bench: Chief Justice, B.V.Nagarathna