Karnataka High Court
Shri D H Raya vs Karnataka State Pollution Control ... on 18 January, 2012
Author: N.Ananda
Bench: N.Ananda
IN THE EEEGH CQLERT OF KARNATAKA AT GALORE §)A'i'E§E1 THIS THE E8?' DAE' GP' &AE\§§§AR':"
BEFORE ma HORFBLE MR.JL:sfmf:E: N.§:§§§A§\{§}A "' CREMENAL PEZTETEGN E\§:>?.§';j3i'1'~{i}F'1'£%C3C1 '? Betwean: : -- b H Shri E) H Raya, Chief Qfficsr, V ._ . _ V Team Municipai Ce3u:::;i';£ * A} » Chellakere, Chitradurga 'D1{si1f:c{{:, New --» Commissiamer ' "
City Municipal ' Petitioner _.{--By §?'4i}%?3;§'EtEfi1'§f§ Aé5'3.Q<Eia:€s, Advecaiegfi And:
1 Karéiafgaka ::::a;:;;:J Pgéiiutimz Centre} Bsaré, ; '$3? F§s3{>;=', A§"u'b1§{:' Utiiity Euiiéing " ' {(3 Read; "B:1.ngai0re.
A V B':§§§fS '§§m7ir0§1m€nta1 Qfficer State Peiiutisiz é3€:fi':«i:{s§V.T"":i%a§aré, Sgavaxgagaya 2, '§'§fi%"§?'::v'§V'/fijfléfiipéii Cauficéi. §::h};?,E%}§{€'T€3 A. CE'::1if;:a§u§ga Eisfzécé Eésgeaéezzts VV ' {B32 83:1 G:a.1:g£:d%:22.:* Sarégeiii, ?:i§'a!€}{?8if% 552;" E1:
8:": 5% E25: §%§{§22§p22, f3;§§'t£'{3i?§i'§€f fair R2} 4 exercised due Cliiigenee eemmissien cf {he Qfierzee gfeirzg <1 L?é'?:I:,5--.,_ '-- Eimiieci seepe jbr meme F861 Cz'ea:'i::g e. on szzeh head of {he éeperémené :53 p:*c:ze.e"
he had ne icrsowiedge, whiie. _:;n&e'rM§ee'e.§e:"E' Zeus ii is far the preseeuiiezéel to:-p?j<3sz:e,.§f1<:':- fie' A' ie prevent the had knowledge fie eezitgmii i.e.,1 " «. meme rea. Except these atieferzee 'ihe of the department had.----eef-Qi?2er dej?e.r':.Ce~'§te eoniend either {he failed to prove {hag the Aqifieer .v eo}jzce%':€ee§;Vv..EV£aeZ any merge re;<::'CzsjVf?~1e Obéairz {he previeiiegseiniegiezz:_;bejb;f'e_ ieking legal aeéioe eencemed had fizei" _ _eE2;e'«..:v"€3I~ii{§,»fefaee ie preven: {he eeérzméssiezg The provise :9 Seeiiorz _4§(1,'?"£he'refe';feAA:?§§§ffs {he eniire burden, era {he ~'~§'.:.efik":ee;* ee%zee,rf_2f;_eei and discharges {he Board A gigging the said preeisee 'Te ihis exzierai' 2325' re" isfe'-.€5i;Q9€ire::i eerzfliei zeiih reference Se 4, 5 fifid E9?' C!'.P,C, eenérarg is Seeiiees 48 azzd 429 ef {fie Waier X-ECE. Eimee " ifieee is a €3G?'2.§?'fi§}€?E,{§$§'E; S€C{E}i}¥'é §@ eemes 533:3 eiezy ejfzerebg; éhe eeeeieéeee ef {he Efaiez' fie: has geé eeeeriiéizsg efiee: éheejg {he g:?§'{)£2'3:$iQ%"%S (gf {Z'::?€fLi, V2