Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Ajay Pal vs M/O Finance on 6 September, 2018
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
OA-3108/2018
New Delhi this the 06th day of September, 2018
Hon'ble Sh. Pradeep Kumar, Member (A)
1. Ajay Pal, S/o Shri Ganga Ram,
Admin. Officer Group.B
Age 51 yrs.
R/o House No. 446, Sector-I,
Vasundhara, Ghaziabad-201010
2. Neeru Sharma, D/o Shri Madan Lal Sharma,
Admin.Officer Group-B
Age 42 yrs.,
R/o - Flat No.-50D, E3, Shatabdi Vihar,
Sector 52 Noida
3. Sudeshna Bhatnagar, D/o Shri Prodyot Kr. Bhaskar,
Admn. Officer Group-B
Age 52 yrs.,
R/o-E -367, Mayur Vihar, Phase II,
Delhi 110091
4. Rajiv Sachdeva, S/o Shri S.R. Sachdeva,
Sr. Assistant, Group-B
Age 41 yrs,
R/o H.No. 323, Sector -5,
Chiranjiv Vihar, Ghaziabad - 201002
5. Dheeraj Singh, S/o Shri Ramchandra Singh,
Age 40 yrs.
Sr. Assitant, Group-B
R/o -I-34, Srijan Vihar, Naya Khand-II
Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, U.P.
6. Ravi Shankar Thakur, S/o Shri Jagdish Thakur,
Age 40 yrs.
Sr. Assistant, Group -B
R/o SK-76c,
Sector -110, Noida 201 304
7. Kavinder Singh Bora, S/o Shri B.S. Bora
Age 39 yrs
Sr. Assistant, Group-B
R/o S-224, Pandav Nagar,
Delhi - 110 092
8. Mukesh, S/o, Shri Babu Lal,
Age 42 yrs.
Assistant, Group-B
R/o B-366
Sector -19, Noida
2
O.A. No.3108/2018
9. Chittaranjan Singh, S/o Shri N.C. Singh,
Age 43 yrs.,
Sr. Assistant, Group-BR/o. H.No. B-94
Sector-71, Noida
10.Kamla Yadav, D/o Shri Ganga Ram Yadav,
Age 38 yrs.,
Assistant, Group-B
R/o - H.No A29, 1st Floor,
11.Bhagchand Singh Rawat, S/o Late Sh. Ray Singh Rawat,
Age 53 yrs.,
Jr. Assistant, Group-B
R/o A-8/21, Sector-71
Noida, UP
12. Ram Bilas Chaudhary, S/o Shri Brij Lal,
Age 55 yrs.,
Jr. Assistant, Group-B
R/o -136-B, Rajiv Vihar,
Khora Colony, Ghaziabad
13. Rakesh, S/o. Shri Babu Lal,
Age 45 yrs.
Driver Group -C
R/o-B-366, Sector - 19, Noida
14. Shiv Kumar Sharma, S/o. Shri Ram Prakash Sharma,
Age 45 yrs.
Driver Group - C
R/o B-17/13, E.W.S. Flat
Shiv Shakti Apartment
Sector 71, Noida (U.P.)
15. Binod Das, S/o Shri Kali Charan Das,
Age 48 yrs.,
Driver Group -C
R/o A-6/15, EWS Flat,
Sec-71, Noida (U.P.)
16. Dharam Pal Singh, S/o Shri Keshari Singh,
Age 51 yrs.,
Attendant Group-C
R/o H.No. 491, Inder Colony,
Vijay Nagar Baghu, Ghaziabad
17. Ashok Kumar, S/o Shri Bhoop Singh,
Age 47 yrs.,
Attendant Group -C
R/o H.No. 491, Inter Colony
Vijay Nagar Baghu, Ghaziabad
18. Ganga Ram, S/o Late Sh. Ved Ram
Age 46 yrs.,
3
O.A. No.3108/2018
Attendant Group -C
Chirstin Nagar, Bagu Ga;on, Inder Colony,
Vijay Nagar, Ghaziabad
19. B.K. Ray, S/o Shri Vidya Ray,
Age 47 yrs.,
Technical Assistant Group-C
R/o 33A (S.K),
Sector 66, Noida
20. Shrinath Singh S/o Shri Bhagirathi Singh,
Age 49 yrs MSS (Electrician) Group-C
R/o 228 A (S-K)
Sector 66, Noida
21. C.K. Joseph, S/o Late Sh. E. Koshy,
Age 59 yrs., ASS Dire. Group -B
R/o B-175, RHO-II, Sector 37,
Greater Noida,
22. Rakesh Mohan Goel, S/o Late Sh. Jai Prakash Goel,
Age 59 yrs., ASS. DIRE. FAINANCE GROUP-B
R/o F.No. 112, Overseas Apartment,
C-58/21, Sector - 62, Noida
23. Subhash Chand, S/o Late Shri Pitam Singh,
Age 55 yrs.
Sr. Admn. Office Group-B
R/o H-283, Beta-II, Gr. Noida, U.P.
24. Shikha Gupta, D/o Late Shri Rajendra Kumar Garg,
Age 49 yrs SR. FANANCE OFFICER GRUP -B
R/o H.No. 335, Overseas Tower,
C-58/21, Sector-62, Noida -201 307
25. Puneet Gurmukhani, S/o Late Shri T.C. Gurmukhani,
Age 43 yrs., Purchase Officer Group -B
R/o Nil 3A, Iind Floor, Back side of Sri Ram Sweets,
Malviya Nagar, New Delhi - 110 017
26. Kaushal Saxena, S/o Late Shri Rameshwar Saxena,
Age 56 yrs.,
Admin. Officer Group -B
R/o A-270, Indira Puri, Loni,
Ghaziabad.
27. Anil Kumar -II, S/o Late Shri Devi Ram,
Age 50 yrs, Secretary Group -B
R/o R-23/2 (Backside), Ramesh Park,
Laxmi Nagar, Delhi - 110 092
28. Suparna Dutta, D/o Shri Ajit Kumar Dutta,
4
O.A. No.3108/2018
Age 47 yrs.
Admn. Officer Group -B
R/o P-805,
Anupam Apartment, East Arjun Nagar,
Delhi-110032
29. Murshed Zaman, S/o Shri Ashrafuz Zaman,
Age-51 yrs.,
Admin. Officer Group-B
R/o Flat No. 67B, 1st Floor, Shipra Riviera
Gyan Khand-III, Indirapuram, Ghaziabad (U.P.)
30. Karunesh Kumar Arora, S/o Shri Jagdish Chandra Arora,
Age 48 yrs., ASS. DIRECTOR GROUP -B
R/o Flat No.-376, Overseas Apartment,
C-58/21, Sector-62, Noida
31. Sunita Arora, D/o Shri Jai Prakash Sharma,
Age 51 yrs. ASS DIRECTOR GROUP-B
R/o Flat No-376, Overseas Apartment
C-58/21, Sector-62, Noida
32. Bijaya Kumar Sahu, S/o Shri Hazari Sahu,
Age 48 yrs., Principal Technical Officer Group-B
R/ o 3/7, OAK Road,
Shipra Suncity, Indirapuram Ghaziabad-201014
33. Tushar Kanti Patnaik, S/o Shri Girija, Shankar Patnaik,
Age 51 yrs., Principal Technical Officer Group -B
R/o Plot No. SI-144, Sector 4, Vaishali, Ghaziabad
34. Bhupendra Kumar, S/o Shri Mahipal Singh,
Age 37 yrs., Principal Technical Officer Group-B
R/o D-9, Street No.6, Mandawali,
Fazalpur (Uncha), Delhi -110092.
35. Mukund Kr. Roy, S/o Shri Nawal Kishore Roy,
Age 35 yrs., SR technical officer Group -B
R/o Ground Floor, 0-48
Sector 12, Noida
36. Deepak Kr. Arya, S/o Shri Girish Chandra Arya,
Age 34 yrs. SR. Technical officer Group -B
R/o A-37, Ground Floor, Street No.2,
Guru Nanak Pura, Laxmi Nagar Delhi-92
37. Babita, D/o Shri P.K. Saxena
Age 35 yrs. SR technical officer Group-B
R/o C-3, Om Darshan Aptt, Sec-5,
Plot No.1/9, Rajender Nagar, Sahibabad, UP-201005
38. Paras Nath Barwal, S/o Shri Bal Mukund Barwal,
Age 46 yrs. Associate Dir. Group -B
5
O.A. No.3108/2018
R/o Sahyog Sahkari Awas Samiti
Plot No. GH-3, Flat No. B-10, Sec.9, Vasundara, Ghz
39. Rishi Prakash, S/o Shri Ishwar Dass
Age 45 yrs., R/o -A-7/10, Sector 16,
Rohini, Delhi -85 Joint Director Group -B
40. Gour Mohan, S/o Shri Harish Chander Sharma,
Age 45 yrs., R/o 2/9 Sector 5,
Rajender Nagar, Sahibabad - 201 005
41. Payal Saluja, D/o Shri A K Bhargava,
Age 41 yrs., R/o 28-A
Pocket-K, Principal Officer Group -B
Sheikh Sarai, Phase-II, Delhi.
42. Aparna Ramamurthy,D/o Shri V. Ramamurthy,
Age 39 yrs., R/o - 209, B, Principal Officer Group -B
Gaur Green Vista, Indirapuram, Ghaziabad
43. Anshu Jain, S/o Shri Subhash Jain,
Age 33 yrs., Technical Officer Group -B
R/o C/o Shri Praveen Kr. Jain, C-122,
Gali No. 6, Shashtri Park, New Delhi -110053.
44. Vikas Bansal, S/o Shri Satish Chand Bansal,
Technical Officer Group B
R/o 620, Sector 14-A, Vasundhara,
Age 42 yrs,
Ghaziabad, UP-201012
45. Sanjeev Kr. Singh, S/o Shri Prem Pal Singh,
Age 48 yrs., R/o Flat No. C-220, Technical Officer Group B
Gaur Global Village, Crossing Republic,
NH-24, Ghaziabad, U.P. 201009
46. Mukesh Kumar Singh, S/o Shri Rajendra Prasad Singh,
Age 42 yrs.
R/o B-3/Plot No 151, Gyan Khand-2
Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, U.P.
47. Nishtha Jaiswal, D/o Shri N.K. Jaiswal,
Age 38 yrs, R/o -Flat No. M1OC , Plot No.41,
Shalimar Garden Extension-I, Shsahibabad,
Ghaziabad, UP. Technical Officer Group B
48. Praveen Kr. Srivastava, S/o Shri Badri Prasad Srivastava,
Age 50 yrs., Ass. Director Group B,
R/o Flat No. F-11, Sahog
49. Anuj Kumar Jain, S/o. Shri Amar Chand Jain, Age 49 yrs., R/o.-A-187, Sector
17, Noida
6
O.A. No.3108/2018
50. Ashu Krishna, S/o. Shri Hari Krishna Sravastav Age 41 yrs. R/o.-Flat No. A-012,
Kalyani Apartment, Sector - 6, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad
51. AmarJeet Singh Cheema, S/o. Shri Jagjeet Singh Cheema, Age 40 yrs,
R/o.-M-1304, Homes-121, Plot No.GH-001, SEC-121, NOIDA-20301
52. Devendra Rao, S/o. Shri S.K. Rao, Age 49 yrs., R/o.-104, Sector 11,
Vasundra, Gaziabad, U.P-201012
53. Astha Rai, D/o. Shri Shiv Kumar Rai, Age 34, R/o. B-14, 181, Himgiri
Appartment,Sector-34, Noida
54. Priyesh Ranjan, S/o. Shri H. S. Tiwary, Age 36 yrs, R/o.-B-002,Crescent
Apartment, F-2 Block, Sector 50, Noida-201301
55. Umesh Sharma, S/o. Shri Radhey Shyam Sharma, Age 38 yrs., R/o.-C-430,
Sector -22, Noida
56. Ashwini Mishra, S/o. Shri Virendra Kumar Mishra, Age 34 yrs., R/o.-Sigma-2,
C-60, Sector 43, Greater Noida
57. Gaurav Gotra, S/o. Shri Kailash Chand Gotra, Age 34 yrs., R/o.-158/4,
Sarpanch Colony, Mandavli, Delhi-92
58. Pragya Sharma, D/o. Shri Vijay Kumar Sharma, Age 36 yrs. R/o.-H.NO.213,
First floor, judges colony, sector-12, vasundhra, ghaziabad, U.P-201012
59. Amit Kumar Ateria, S/o. Shri Daya Ram, Age 36 yrs., R/o.-Rana Niwas,
Room No.1, I Block ,Sec-22, Noida-201301
60. Garima Gotra, D/o. Shri Kailash Chand Gotra, Age 36 yrs., R/o.-158/4,
Sarpanch Colony, Mandavli, Delhi-92
61. Siddharth Srivastava, S/o. Shri Ashok Kumar Srivastava, Age 29 yrs., R/o.-Qtr
No.10,Sector 01, R.K,Puram, New Delhi
62. Sumit Soman, S/o. Shri N. Soman, Age 31 yrs., R/o.-Flat No.176, Rail Vihar,
Sector 33, Noida, U.P-201307
63. Alok Bharati, S/o. Shri Narendra Dutt Tyagi, Age 42 yrs., R/o.-B-107, Kalyani
Appt. Sector-6, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad U.P
64. Hem Raj Balwaria, S/o. Shri Manohar Lal, Age 40 yrs., R/o.-F-763/12, Marg
No 5,Raj Nagar-II, Palam Colony, New Delhi-110077
65. Devender Singh, S/o. Shri Narain Das Pal, Age 51 yrs., R/o.-DP-
261,Pitampura,Delhi-88
66. Varun K. Jain, S/o. Shri Amichand Jain, Age 45 yrs., R/o.-808, Royal Block,
Supertech Estates, Sector -9, Vaishali, Ghaziabad.
7
O.A. No.3108/2018
67. Amit Kumar Singh, S/o. Shri Chatar Singh, Age 37 yrs., R/o.-DD-163,
Avantika, Chiranjeev Vihar, Ghaziabad.
68. Satish Babu G, S/o. Shri M. Govindarajan, Age 37 yrs., R/o.-FLAT
222,ORIENTAL APARTMENTS,C-58/26, SECTOR 62,G.B. Nagar, Noida-201309
69. Tarun Kumar, S/o. Shri Nageshwar Ram, Age 41 yrs., R/o.-A - 2/25, Gharoli
Extension, Block 'A', Rajvir Colony, Delhi - 110 096
70. Abhay Pal Chauhan, S/o. Shri Ramesh Chand Chauhan, Age 35 yrs. R/o.-
D-506/3, Street No.-03, Ashok Nagar, Delhi - 93
71. Anil Kumar - I, S/o. Late Shri Sita Ram, Age 53 yrs., R/o.-21, Sri Nagar
Colony, Krishna Nagar Gali-2, Opp. Modi Steel, Modinagar, U.P - 201 204,
Distt. Ghaziabad
72. Rajiv Yadav, S/o. Shri Babu Lal Yadav, Age 46 yrs., R/o.-C-403, Aditya
Garden City, Sector-6, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, U.P
73. Srivenkata Laxminarasimharao Gulimi, S/o. Late Sh. Devudu, Age 43 yrs.,
R/o.-Academi Block, C-DAC, Noida, B-30, Sector 62, Noida , U.P
74. Ramneet S. Chadha, S/o. Shri M.S. Chadha, Age 43 yrs., R/o.-Victoria C-
501, Omaxe Grand, Sector 93B, Noida
75. Jitendra Singh, S/o. Shri Mahendra Singh, Age 44 yrs., R/o.-A-406,Rail Vihar,
Sector 3, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad-201010
76. Sujeet Kumar, S/o. Shri Babu Lal, Age 42 yrs., R/o.-104-Bhagwantam,
Behind INMAS, Lucknow Road, Timarpur, Delhi-110054
77. Ajay Kr. Gupta, S/o. Shri Jai Prakash, Age 42 yrs., R/o.-C-68/A, DDA Colony,
West Gorakhpark Extn, Shahdara, Delhi
78. Shamshad Ansari, S/o. Shri Rahmat Ali Ansari, Age 44 yrs., R/o.-Ist
floor,11/413, Gali No.11, Lalita Park, Nr. Ek Minar Masjid, Laxmi Ngr, Delhi-92
79. Priyanka Dutta, D/o. Shri R.C. Dutta, Age 39 yrs., R/o.-A-419, MEA Apptt., C-
58/29, Sector - 62, Noida
80. Ranpal Singh Malik, S/o. Shri Ved Singh, Age 50 yrs. R/o.-H.No 110, First
Floor, Block D, Sector 41, District Gautam Budh Nagar, Noida-201301
81. Udai Singh, S/o. Shri Ghan Shyam Singh, Age 36 yrs., R/o.-Flat No. K-705,
GOLF GREEN APARTMENT, CROSSING REPUBLIC, GHAZIABAD,UP 201016
82. Ashutosh Pandey, S/o. Shri Suvash Chandra Pandey, Age 34 yrs., R/o.-C-
360, Omicron-2, Greater Noida, U.P201308
8
O.A. No.3108/2018
83. Jignesh Jayendra Modi, S/o. Shri Jayendra R. Modi, Age 34 yrs., R/o.-Flat
No. D-503, Prateek Wisteria, Sector-77, Noida(U.P)
84. Balasubramaniam M, S/o. Shri Munuswamy D, Age 34 yrs., R/o.-B-855, GD
Colony, Mayur Vihar, Phase Iii, Delhi-110096
85. Partha P. Chattaraj, S/o. Shri Ram Chandra Chattaraj, Age 42 yrs., R/o.-F-3,
Flat No. 174, Vaishali Sector-6, Ghaziabad, U.P
86. Abhishek Verma, S/o. Shri Rajesh Verma, Age 36 yrs., R/o.-Flat No.2067,
Tower-5, Block E-4, Crossing Infra, GH-7, Crossing Republic, Ghaziabad, U.P
87. Sushil Kumar, S/o. Shri Lakhmi Chand, Age 31 yrs., R/o.-H.No.7, Gali No.8,
Begambad,Modinagar, U.P-201204
88. Tejaswin Mohanty, S/o. Shri Pramod Mohanty, Age 42 yrs., R/o.-B-416, Gour
Global Village, Crossing Republic, NH-24, Ghaziabad, U.P
89. Savita Kashyap, D/o. Shri Ramesh Chand, Age 42 yrs., R/o.-Mayur Vihar Ph-
3100C, MIG Flats , Pocket -6, Delhi
90. Vijayagopalan K.P, S/o. Shri V.C. Kunhirama Menon, Age 59 yrs., R/o.-Flat
No.201, Block-2, Express Garden, 6, Vaibhav Khand, Indirapuram,
Ghaziabad
91. Sourish Behera, S/o. Shri Gangadhar Behera, Age 47 yrs., R/o.-58-A (MIG),
Madhuban Aptts, Swarnim Vihar, Noida Authority Flat, Sec-82, Noida Ph-II
92. Rajesh Kr. Kushwaha, S/o. Shri Sharada Nand Kushwaha, Age 42 yrs., R/o.-
Shradha Niwas, 1/336, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad
93. Kumar Bhaskar, S/o. Shri Sidheshwar Prasad Gupta, Age 38 yrs., R/o.-House
No.A202,SAFFRON, NIOH SCOTTISH GARDEN, Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, U.P
94. Manish Kumar Verma, S/o. Shri Karan Singh, Age 35 yrs., R/o.-V-220, Sector
-12,Noida-201301
95. Chandan Maity, S/o. Shri Madan Chandra Maity, Age 37 yrs., R/o.-HN-
577,Sector -2C, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, UP
96. Abhishek Tiwari, S/o. Shri Santosh Kumar Tiwari, Age 39 yrs., R/o.-H. No.354,
sector 1, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, U.P
97. Brahmanandha Prabhu .R, S/o. Shri Ramasamy M. Age 37 yrs., R/o.-C-301,
1st Floor, Sector-121, G.B. Nagar , Noida-201301
98. Adarsh Pillai, S/o. Shri V.C.A. Pillai, Age 36 yrs., R/o. -P2-02/c, SRS Pearl
Floors,SRS City,Sector-87,Greater Faridabad, Haryana-121008
9
O.A. No.3108/2018
99. Himanshu Gupta, S/o. Shri Pradeep Kumar Gupta, Age 34 yrs., R/o.-Flat
No.306, Fortune Residency, Raj Nagar Extension, Ghaziabad-201017
100. Shivraj Dagadi, S/o. Shri Ratan Lal Dagadi, Age 33 yrs., R/o.-A-14, Sector
22, Noida, U.P
101. Hari Prakash Srivastava, S/o. Shri Jagdish Lal Srivastava, Age 52 yrs., R/o.-
189, Sector 2-C, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad
102. Dr. Arti Noor, D/o. Shri Braj Nandan Prasad Vishnoi, Age 54 yrs., R/o.-C/O
K.S. Noor,249, Pocket-V, Mayur Vihar, Phase-I,New Delhi-110091
103. Vinod Kumar Sharma, S/o. Late shri Mitthan Lal Sharma, Age 51 yrs., R/o.-
D-125, Sector - 55, Gautam Buddh Nagar , Noida
104 . Dr. Sunita Prasad, D/o. Shri Tapeshwar Pradad, Age 48 yrs., R/o.-Flat #
1928, Sector - 37, Arun Vihar, Noida - 201303, Distt.-Gautam Budh Nagar
105. Ravi Payal, S/o. Shri R.S. Payal, Age 40 yrs., R/o. -B-441, ,C-58/12, Salora
Vihar, Sector - 62, Noida
106. Priti Razdan, D/o. Shri Ashok Kumar Muttoo, Age 46 yrs., R/o.-105, Gobind
Apartment, Vasundhara Enclave, Delhi - 110 096
107. Kriti Saroha, D/o. Shri Satya Pal Singh Saroha, Age 41 yrs. R/o.-House
No1103, Sector - 5, Mohan Meakins Society, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad
108. Navneet Jain, S/o. Shri Rajendra Kumar Jain, Age 44 yrs., R/o.A-204, 1st
Floor, New Friends Colony, New Delhi - 110025
109. Munish Kumar, S/o. Shri H.B. Singh, Age 49 yrs., R/o.-Flat No.102, A-Block,
Foster Heights, Crossing Republik, NH-24, Ghaziabad, U.P
110. Dr. Kalpana Johari, D/o. Shri R.D. Gupta, Age 43 yrs., R/o.-B-160, Surya
Nagar, Nr. Amrit Plaza Shopping Complex, Ghz - 201 011
111. Dr. Mary Jacintha. M, D/o. shri M. Maria John, Age 45 yrs., R/o.-64-D,
Shipra Suncity, Indrapuram, Ghaziabad
112. Dr. Lakshmi Kalyani, D/o. Shri P.V. Seethapathi, Age 43 yrs., R/o.-D-101,
Designers Park, Plot B-9/1 A, Sector 62, Noida
113. Shalu Gupta, D/o. Shri Ajit Kumar, Age 39 yrs., R/o.-GB-404, Assotech
Windsor court, Sector-78, Noida
114. Sanjay Saxena, S/o. Shri Man Mohan Lal Saxena, Age 47 yrs.,
R/o.-H.No : 7/15, Nova, Cassia Road, Shipra Suncity, Ghaziabad
115. Rekha Saraswat, D/o. Shri Jai Narayan Saraswat, Age 37 yrs., R/o.-
89,Nirupam Vatika, C-58/14, Sec-62, Noida (U.P.)
10
O.A. No.3108/2018
116. Santosh Kumar, S/o. Shri Ram Sabree, Age 36 yrs., R/o.-is C-116, Ground
Floor, Brij Vihar, Ghaziabad, U.P-201011,
117. Ashu, D/o. Shri Chandra Pal Singh, Age 36 yrs., R/o.-706, VSNL Apartments,
C-Block, Sector-62, Noida
118. Dr. Shalini Singh, D/o. Shri Gulab Singh, Age 47 yrs., R/o.-A-203, Park View
Appartment, Plot No.-6, Sec-5, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad
119. Manoj Purohit, S/o. Late Shri Anand Purohit, Age 44 yrs. R/o.-C-42,First
Floor, Street No. 13, Shashi Garden, Patparganj, Mayur Vihar Ph-I, Delhi 91.
120. Amrita Wadhawan, D/o. Shri Ravinder Kumar Jaitley, Age 49 yrs., R/o.-A-
223, Gaur Green Avenue Abhay Khand-II, Indirapuram, Ghaziabad-201010
121. Neha Bajpai, D/o. Shri Shyam Sunder Kapoor, Age 42 yrs. R/o.-F-901,
Neelpadm - I, Sec-5, Vaishali, Ghaziabad
122. Kanti Singh Sangher, D/o. Shri Madhav Singh Sangher, Age 38 yrs., R/o.-
Varun Apartments, Flat No. 472, C-58/28,C Block , Sector -62, Noida, G.B.
Nagar, 201301, U.P
123. Astha Gupta, D/o. Shri Rakesh Mohan Goel, Age 33 yrs., R/o.-D-105,
Aashina Heritage, Vaishali, Sector 4, Ghaziabad, U.P
124. Sanjay Ojha, S/o. Shri R.K. Ojha, Age 40 yrs., R/o.-House No.957, third floor,
sector-15, Vasundhra, Ghaziabad(U.P) 201012
125. Rosy Verma, D/o. Shri T. N. Verma, Age 49 yrs., R/o.-F-172, Beta-II, Greater
Noida
126. Uttam Kumar, S/o. Shri S.P. Kureel, Age 40 yrs., R/o.-C- 12, Pocket - VI,
Kendriya Vihar-II, Sector - 82, Noida - 201 304
127. Vineet Kumar Birla, S/o. shri Sanatan Birla, Age 38 yrs., R/o.-Kamal
Residency, Flat No.SF-1, Plot No.A-2, Sector-5, Chiranjiv Vihar, Ghaziabad,
U.P
128. Nitin Kumar Varshney, S/o. Shri Pramod Kumar Varshney, Age 37 yrs. R/o.-
C-2/3, Rail Vihar, Near DPS School, Indirapuram, Ghaziabad - 201010.
All working at
Centre for Development of Advanced
Computing, Anusandhan Bhawan
(By Advocate : Sh. Johri Mal)
Vs.
1. Union of India
11
O.A. No.3108/2018
Through Secretary
Department of Expenditure
Ministry of Finance
North Block, New Delhi
2. Secretary,
Ministry of Communication &
Information Technology
Department of Information Telecom,
Electronics Niketan, 6-CGO Complex
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-03
3. The Director General
Centre for Development of Advanced
Computing, Pune University Campus, Ganesh
Khind, Pune-411007
4. The Director
Centre for Development of Advanced
Computing Anusandhan Bhawan, C-56/1
Institutional Area, Sector -62
Noida, UP -201307 ...Respondents
(By advocate : Sh. Y.P. Singh )
ORDER (ORAL)
M.A. No. 3475/2018 & M.A. No. 3474/2018 which have been filed for joining and condonation of delay are devoid of merit and are dismissed. O.A. No. 3108/2018
Learned counsel for the applicants mentioned that certain recoveries have been ordered for certain excess payments made against some persons. These persons are not included in the present petition. The petitioners in the instant case are, however, apprehensive that similar recoveries may be ordered against them also in future and this apprehension is the grievance in the present O.A.
2. Learned counsel for the respondents mentioned that no such recovery order has been issued by the department against any of the applicants in the present petition. Hence, there is no cause of action. 12 O.A. No.3108/2018 Further, the case of the present petitioners is also not known. Accordingly, the OA is not maintainable.
3. The matter was heard at length. The argument of respondents sustains. The O.A. is dismissed being devoid of merits. No cost.
(Pradeep Kumar) Member (A) sarita