Karnataka High Court
Sri Sridhar V vs State By on 18 April, 2012
Author: N.Ananda
Bench: N.Ananda
EV) §§z:1L§~Za:::1y2a C. W I :1 S:"i<iE:21§ Er', D,/9. :E3ri (IE22?:13c£:*a Rezizijg Agaéi aijtmi 28 'fégzrs;
R521': 2/}, 2% {Tress ._ Papaiaiz Reiiééy Layémé :
Mans:'2:y22r1;1§)a.Eya, R.'§.Nag'2::' 4 .. * ' V * Bailgalem ~ 5611? G32; ZR&s§a:';e::§e:1i:g-, ' {By Sr: V:ija§/E<;m11a:' Mzzjage, HC«§}§:'~,_§7G:' §,3:__ Sr; 'QNV§'$?é§i?2:1;€e:idy, V Aiiifocaée fer R2} Thig petiiien is E'K§é'{§.."~.i:l§iC§.f;;E:' S.éAC'[i¥Q=fi, v<§82 praying' :0 qL%;as1:: {E16 praseégéings ifi ii:§€.:\?La.i3333é:§,{'?Q(}E}, an gins? €116 sf X Adrsiiéianaé C3126? Metrapeiiizzrz.Pviagig::*at,$,_B;a§:ga£g:I*€e 8: €29. This gésaéiiizsfi agd é;hi§:a;:é1};, the Caurt made §,ir:s'tf0i§o:2,r::1§§i " ' . . "
"{7} .fé€?€.ii§.<§'::;_e.rs '~. E13.V<§ "-----8a..2;'ght fay quashmg the proceééings QQGQ, gending tried fez' Gffenesg §;:,__1;1V:Vs?{1eVfl:;'i_€ V'§;r;:f3;§_?: 'S€C7;§Q33S 338?; rfw 34 §P{§ and 3iso.}:Cfz:'>é*'~:3§§6:r1§::*$..§Ln':3};%%:abE€ uncle: Sseiégzzs 3 & ii 0? '£16 . . i}@v..r:';; _?:*Q§2:bi..é §<3:: ACE, VA¥i'i*:A5e:: V:A%_é'_.ma¥::€:* is iakfigq 12? 5:33: :'E€<",%.?§§'i§; §e'é;1T:ii0::€:' Vuég/'ms {>5 '§--I"€S§Q§E§€fi'€:L ;>€?U:i§oI:€§ {easy ;;=,€:§"=i'%;<)§:€:" 253$ §§»:°€s§><::1iE::flé; 323.276 fiéésé 3 G? fi~§£:s§i:::d€::é}§ gfiiéiiegar ;\5@,2 {m9fLh€r--:§n~ 'Sis? 9;?
U} M4 :13: ::§é:*me.::
I <3?
W \ §*g%a.d§ng as; haw/:3::€%s:*:~ vuw §;§\ Va » ».<f"'~/m DJ p€13i'ii3::€r:?; Nc:,E it} 3 311$ ':§"}€' %€€s;po:1d6r':: €\?<).2 subézzzit 'shay; zhésjx a1'11i{i£':1b§j,? se§;x;i;§€d their Eianziigr d1'spué<~::~; be:w~:3:é::: "'<. {E28121 3.115% §'::fih€r ihé' §::eii{iener N9»! R€Sp{}!1{§€I}?; E\7<>«2 have aéw fiisd §i'-fG£"C€, 'sabre {E16 Fggiriiiifi/*. &_ {i§eL.2:%; "
M.C.Ne,2924,/2C312 azid ihs an é8~2~2Gi2 éiféd s.:1:::__ $5 §a};%i?é'V_:s§z§s i"€C€§V€d by {he :\E;{;._.2""Té£>\:é}gj&s peymansm. aiixzssizg and. ;é§;r:E§"-»¥/hey firayf ehjaig, éhis Herzfibie Csufi;--%;iia_j,2536i;§§€é;3%'e:¥_ «'L::_ quash "Q16 proceedings in €{'3H_ V_l's:fov;,23'f33§/i§GC1§i~:V..'péhding an the {£6 Ey'Ee'L_r<"s,§C>ii£;e;i': E'«E:1.g§§.:rair3 Cam':
Banga1'e§*:%., '.%i(:f~g'§;.¢__ EE":e'--« 's;e:.i;i€m€n: arriveé bstwéfitz €'b<§.;_paré£$'s§ iii é?i;é.'1;r::é::esi afjusiice azzd i;qui::€."" H '
3. 1;; 'xrieéxsé Q§."=.ii€*':e 'jggjfizfiéizéme, ihfiféi' is S€?;fl€H1€:1'L' sf ::13f£rz';ffisr,'{1§a§ a'§»*¥spé;:é1€ 'be1::'a:v€e:;; p§:¥;:§§i>n€:" N211} and Q» V':"€:5§§E33{>r:df":?§;%TgVA'~TT{"'§%:€ Eéazafid czmnsd £'s§}§€€s.i"§I1§ far pa§'i:;€$ a-2:;:§;}:?1;%T%:4é;V§i3.;:>:"{>€::3sé§z:gs '§)€§'§§iBg in C.C.Ne.23334;'2€}{%9 ;;§:':«--j_i:1g{_v'§:'€:£:E§'f%§:'" 3:: ééfiéiézse §3u:r§5§#:ab?1€ uirzdef :=,&:::i;i0_r:: =i§Sfi ' "'5/'W 343 E;?C and a§:~:<:a fa? {>{§en<:s:3 gunigééabia mzdéir S%3{':T,§@§3S L; 3:}? Bééwry §3%:*s::E"z§:>ié:€;:*1 g-'xiii 11:23.3' '£26 eigigaseézeié.
'""'"~x égubrgzié éha: if {he Ciaszzii :1-:«2:§?;s=;£'?ié*/C1 'EE3;;zJ; $338 §3?e:-'€::?:édif:gs Ekéfivsi 'L0 be €§?.3£ES}"§€§Zi u_::£%€:" 5=3:?:c%;é@;": C:'.§3'.€, E?-35. itensideraéism ihe géééied p:°§n<é§p1€$.;:>;i §:m' '-;;::>::' .é'<é<;{p€ s;€<:?;§§n 482 Cr.P,C,, $26 faéti. $112}: the <:§'§§%::§c€;s._a1}iég'f:¢i impugrzed §I"QCf3€d§i3gS are :2br:<+.¢§n3pi;a).ndabi%>;_ i»iiUu.1;,<'i;H Corgis --. L :32 {he way of quaséiifig the pzracséffingsg 5, "fine Eearnad 5393::-Ssixé wguféi thaééii' C21-Si' sf 3513: aims Pappu ané anafhes' {a subsequeni juCi45_;:::1::r:i},:"{?1'é'§u§'ra%2ia.§ 'has. referred to me eariiesr SC 428 {in {he case Q?Ni§:hTii._Mé:.;;fzaz::_'¥«:;9s'-- Ceigirczfi Bureau Qf fnveséigazion and a:€Q:E:€r}: {in {he Case 03;' B.S§J<:»sf2z' 423» 3335? Q3" }I:?.:§a:3,a§'--a2€e:3; .L25Q8 SC §L§::p;::} 32?? {:32 §§E€ Case Qf Qéégjcéiésgf. S%:a%;n}g¥V ~2;s'- S3:a;§e azzd others}. "E'§1€§€§{}:*€, ihai E@21r:%:eci"'{7t;::_:é;--:.§E wetféé s*:fsi:2§T;1 Eha: noizixrizhsianding $24: 5223:
éiafers 'aha {imzré 'beéazv émfgivss new cgizzgggurgéaizie G§€§E{i€S 'éézéirs is EEG 13666 ":0 Ce;':E:§z:u€ with '$136 'g:;:Q€€€fi*;§§gs as 1336 j;;>a:":'ié:s §}8.V€ 5&3/%;:'§€e:i :112:€§"%:'::0:'2§aE " f__§v§':1§-§}é§é'LE%S, 3 .. _;::::"gs%;s:§€:2zé§::>::
£".7'~ 'E1 2;: 'iE1x;% €§€'E{?§S§€§§"§ %'"%':}§€)E'i,€;'iCi 5:: 253$? A234? 86?? §é'€}E§ e"G*ica;'2 Sz';%_§;%"s'5 s:£a.<;€,{ (#22553 gs):/zghi 2:9 be qzzaséaeié ir:x;'{'2§2;«*r:4€§T._;m Off€,'f1C€ 1111533" 3G€EiGI£ E2638 EEC, axfiéich ::0n1p<>L:;1Ciab1€ 0ffe::<:é€. Ths acitussd had $3693-.i:§)éz3I§{t::é<:E. 21:16? the appeai againsi: }'udgm€:1E sf §)z.:n:sE1r:.:e4321;"Wa$ before the Esgamed S6/SSiQZ3Sfs}'Lid§.:{€§ B€f§I'€, {:%i.€3 &E:}péjfl§i5 {EO§iI"5L, an applicatien was §'iEe§;"V'i'::g*:::on:p:§fi;y§i:;§ <).'i:V':§:3§;§;€1":£:€s. Thfirsaftay pemilien se<:Vi.i'{§:::::quasE1i::g"
ihe FER was fiéaé gr; partéeg have
iéompeurzded TEES sscfiesa 482:
CI1P,C. waéi ané Ehfi Same was
iakem Z'3pL§..€aV€ Apgzssai {C333
:a:g9828;z:?;::§ gag
I12; ihe :é1i'ii2,;<§V€i§V§:€r§":;¢ j"L1égf?':%§E§ :"€§{}1'§€{§ E22 2532 AIR SSW ?:%:€::::<:if:as€d anti <:0n':§}§aéz:r.a::% were '::;h_€ Ci1é.fiTi€€§°§ 05 'L326 :§:fa::;'pe;*?;i<'/gs. 'E23 fézigé, §§";:w§;Y§I".§2i§Gf} wag F€§iS%%3f€é £8?'"€}§€§§{f€:S»'§}LifliS§E&E.bEfi 'a,i{'§§$i" séaéliéims 353;» $3 3%'; ELQCE A "'§%3:§:i<;::'v..-eéygsiisé s;s5C§;§@2: C;;:?.Ca zazzas; ééiad {§i§f::<Sb me '§}§'{}f'i€?'%€§§§}g;;%,' zmgfi wfiészé figs §>s:?;%é§::m was §}f3IEC§?:,f}g ms pafiéées;'appé%%i.2mis 21:*:*§a7§3{:' 235; C{}E}3§)E'{}§EEZif:%t';"E 235% 2oughi2 €02" Qaagaghézzg: <3? the ;2r:3:':€€c1;i:2gs, ?he SL1pre:22€< C{}'L3.I'§, :re:f€:*r%:2g {<3 Ens: saziéer }23:éi2_%;:z.1aé:2is rsgwrzed in:
2} 222 2902 2:: 8?5 :2 2:12 322?? 25: 1422 :2) 222 3988 SC 202 iv} 222 2022 SC 2} A12 2222 3:: 4:? _ _ V2 2:22 2:202 202: 22.8% * 22; A12 2222 SC' 2:22 my A12 2022 SvCV--§Supp}*--§i_f?
E123 'V vzté'-";*i;gnz;,f}:*--$:"~§Efz<i:: ':'{imp'iy b€Cfi££.§€ an V0W;ff{§?3i:'&? "£s§'«1.;fzgg under Seeiien a:32{},_' 1£;Eifj.V {§ :v§?fy*.§[€'S€§{ jag reasozz far éhe Big}: Efeizri 5:3. VrieffL;2<;«év«.<92}é;<:;%c.:3€2 Qf 5:3 pawer urzder Seééifiz uC:"."§?::_{.'f; 'E'§2aé gewer can in 5222* ' 'V:?§Q§F§§€}?"i."'§?.£fV Vekerééseé {:2 cases sjhere ihere is 2:39 €'§'2c§:'g:ge Qf &féb%i'>%'Vdi:2§ a: canviciien agairzsii {F25 A azzd {ha-3 erzifiss €'}<;'€3?'C§S€ 53;" 5: ?::"2'a§ is}: $9 :22": e8Xé~3§'C§5}f:" £r:j":2f;:i5:':g, 'E"?:e:"e is Q; A éisiéaciiags bszftween CG?ZQ§&§,§Tld§?7:§ Q5' " ggjiézzcés 33;; 55:22 §ar:2ié32 fiqjére {E16 'fi2'a§ Cami 6.?" 53:22:23 0:: 52229 326225 552235 £526 €X€}"€§§§é'3 £5? Vg/223:2»:/=«3:* .2232 5922 Effgfz Csjmri 53:; 52322552 5:525: pr::2$eC::§,:'0s2 2:220:92' S€C€€G2'2 482 Cr,§3i€, (222 £325' ?} Q2255 0:25;; in stages 2/:>fz€z'@ s"ejfz,:sai is a:<e:'s::*:.L<;<-2 ihaiq ;;<}a::e~2r may 3'esz:§:'; in éfzé 5:532:36 sf :,Fze>f " §3I'%I}C€SS Qf 5631?./2 3' 51:? Hz'g?24 (tam; mafia; §?;ej:A:s£§}'°?;€3.}i:iV in s;§€5Zz'm':<ag {?13l'€3;*'jE§"€§'3,C€ gf 2': is Caiéeci :Az_gf,2:;:!.§": -- /f V Cé§3}3Z"€:'L'€Q§I€ evidence, "féf, 2': carznoé role Qf an appeiéaiié Cour": -12;?-:'é:§;z'«:*"_;V " VV ggziisiegz under Secéion 482':'.VQ;': :<';":*:;:%z;--:fri;c:i PE"'0C€G§l,é?€ Ca&€. Su:bj€$:' f.'3i€"C1L:?}V'Gi3€, :i*sV}é ;A':i£.i:;z.,?_;_" Cami: wiii 526.56 £23 {IQ C{I'C{é2';"Z:3$Q§"?.C€S V<g_,'7._ eczcif fig} d€fer;%'§z}€e wheifzer ii is afi:
pawers mgg be i§?,i?Q.5;",_é§'{i"§ V' . ' 3 "E316 ;:e.cis;a§§::s:p~egf:¢§2 in ..;:0ij;;: 31% Saw 396 {in the @6388 sf _S_:jc1,t»:=..[é"' f§7§:5¢rfaI g';'I§;'Rk:ti@efl§was renfisred $5; {he iwe §adges:'--:;:1 3; E ~€_§Té'e.i;s;§3r§ r€p0:*i€é in 2312 AIR SCW 44$ {in '£<§:é~ ca;€--e ..S'Fz.;::"iJ afias Fappu and Qrs, -:is-
R§d4§;1;'i§'aa, a§2é";'§§iéi%;e%} was; :*€13é,er€d by ihsi iiwe guéggfis can _, .;%3'3§% .93 Eél 3:: z:.'5é:.:a:§'$§9z: f€§8:"'§;€§ Ea £33 §§§§ {£32 iE:;e f:é§s§§ Gf Gsvigzéazrzgiéa Géfiaiaghaéigi »=;s§- Wgsi "..flf95§'t£.§«2: §res:§ Qgfgég mzé &:2:§§?:e§',i Eufai Beacéé 23$ $213 €Z".;>22f% 'gas E35335:
531$ :3, érizazé is; izeicé :E:e:é:'é: :a:"<3 as <?he1r:::%€:%s 0? '§'€(:{3?{§iI:g :2 {tomr%e:':Ei{>:1 223251 éihe €:§:ii1"€ €:>:€§:;:is€ of a ma} v;<">'é;::'Z~§.:,V'*'?::>:§:" :+_m'= €>:€r::§s€ £3 faziiiiégyn E2, "i'h€r€f€sr€< by ibllewing ihe d!3C§'S§Q§1 1?'§§;>Q;:9i€{5i"éfiV Ziiivié 9 AIR SCH? 445 {in the ease sf :;€"-ghii i T 'aiicis _v Papgzs _ 'a;ii:i .
Qthers =-vs» Radhika and anzztfiarj and Exavirzg-vrégé;32;éw:é ihfi "
facis anfi ci:*<::u::1s?;a:1€:§s Qf i'§";_€?",..VV:§A-!'Z\VS'E,"c"":-1,3; CE'L5:"}€i:.,._§A ;;5<:€g:»'£ the peutiaré anfi quash ':h€"";?*fg9§:é'edi{:ig;s"xiii: C';C£\E0;23334g'2i'}GQ an me me er}: ACMM ' ' §'i§$§§§ SNN