Competition Commission of India
M/S Vindato Investment Pvt. Ltd. & Ors vs M/S Vaidehi -Akash Housing Private ... on 29 June, 2012
Smmyatitimx Cmmmissian mi' '§:'a§i:~s.
Gama N9. 285 af 3% 13 we .
»w.:;.=..-r;.s.::2§f:..:»§f=3 3;. i\»i;*'s Vixxiiatsts Ezwestmsxmz Pxzt. Ltd. ...3ix£§°s:3:'mze2*.'§; 'i~Eo.."t SE: s:i Ashak Vijizay Jaina ...Es:ti'::«r::mx1's '§§<:.'.3§~ 'Y0 Evifa Vaiéahiwkkash finuxing Privaciaas iémited ...Q;1s§}e;'.-Si§e §"*m:%y Qréer unziszr :§§:<:'s;i::3n rarsgm mi' ma Cammtfitiaxz Act, 2€§{3:3 "'§.'.he p.re.se21%; .'a:3§'<':r';11atis3:: 'max: fiim. ':;=.:1<:ie.:* 3;:-.<:r:i.cm. 'i¥3{1}{a'§ er: €'*s:
.§:
Compstiiisxza .<°s.{7?., 2332 {$33.52 Acfi; 133* 53 '»"im:ia<:cs 3'm.vs:s.a'%.:::<e;';?; E-'vi. ?..'ii£i. {"th<;~' infaxrxnami. No.38} mad Sfifzri; ?sS§'i<>§{ '\«"ij3t2.ay' Jam {'i:§*:<z i:1§':';r3.nan2: :'%3;>.,'2'} '\»'aic§&'t1i«,-'&3e:aa&;E1 §{cm.s:i.r_2g 13-':'§vs.i:i.°.=. '§.,inr..ii:::<'3 {'%;3m £.>jg3pa>>;§i;a ;3.a.=."':.j;'}. At the esutsa-tit, ii x.>2:s3';;».§. be :a.§.:.gm;3r§ate m ::-:;«*;e the mafia by infm*m:«1~;':§;s; '<.>2-*be::*:2'§>y ithe §ks?.E.<>w*;:3.g }-4' A tiimaztioms l1:a.\:a': 336633 s:.:m.;g,hi; aga.i:ms*;: itfru: :>_;3;3css:i.:ss: *'a.z*ty: {:1} is gay -;:\2.-*.*:.z~>.<.zr.:.'~:<;:;*l€;;m in} 23.3':- A. eao.=mrn.é~t: a:§f'e:2.c;¢$, _;'%*:;;m:3;. «::.'..e:<s::*'.in§~}3 Lé.::fi'2.ir mszd-3»: _§3}'(.$a'.??.it'.'. is'-.£'s;:3':.:t".c:s.v1.-:2;£ :n£s.n:»':p:"s,ss<: :*z:.2".z'.<;-:1 :.:'.>it§'; i..m:'.e.va:«::;£, its peer; :~<>zn;:>en:::<s':'.i<'::': tics 2'.Fu..e z'.»':f'o:'232.<.zr:.2'. .z\-E3. .3 J{_))" <::o::sz>€r«::.<::;. M...' ~ 4 '-'-
W <»=?c<:m,>r.rzic <:yffe=.n.c:e~::.<.~:_. _','l*r.:L:.<3., ::.'zaa1€i.n.='v rm.;';<:.i;s' frmirs ;'~s'acf.'i<,=e::; awsf :13 5 ' .
€3'e.;*.-:?.>':€ioz°u:z.E mi:9:"r3_;;::*s33<mL'{;;€'tm2 wit}: mi"-°;"<Z'S§'. n\ s . ,~ v \< ' . V' '. . V. . 4.' '7' £0; 20 <:::>:':.<.£u«::>: *;r1.:,*e2s;£:g;s&zs3:': ='.2Z_L'_;'s,"<f-£.*'i.S§ L.£..e"':§-2 ::»;.>;;cssz.ia: ',t3c<3'<',<,-* ff}: t»Ci-== Q? c::}.*L>._g3::'u;:§;, {~_?§,'{3,f1,i_e.;i.§.C «3_,_,?sL~'.*2.ce;-in, fuuu, s..32.c-x.1§§.?l:-.3; <,£?>,,a:.: .*.2'-.'2c»<: ;2:'{.:c:i"£e«3s czami i22.é'«2::7.f.€.<.:-s':<:iE m.€:;:*e3p:'es»:>.n.{ca _.;.g..3"{.S 321:.
'2. }'3=."i<s:§E\: $<:zac'.imi, the $.:tt:.€<>:':.:':2m.t '.=\'='<>s. 1. 2335:} a':;>p<éa_:' ta ';:*..z=.=ve3 ';3ur<.'*'=='>3r:a:'}.' <>'gi':i ~ 3. &\~\ \.\ £8; arxa'. imzs' {4} iiszaias rs::;;:.}e<:t.3v<:i§.r \$a.'s'2a::';»:*e\:~: {'3:'>';m1\',-*' §.<>:_:z'~;ie<§. 8.': ;."-\.Y.'~.{'L'_;' §.z':,i'm""1€z333'. :>'-..'u.'<t":~,_;=.:>:a«:'s;i me: :;
?$1.QE¥.T2{3§";€3. "'h:.=3. ini"m*1:123L:..t Nu.' ' :'\\§i»:::;1§3;3;i. it 221*'-=e:'2' ~€' to $.~'.«;«'.:if3 dazittai ~;':;';'i.i'3$',>.f»:¥3£3>;'> \ - ~' ' 4. .» y:.a«5- a.'s}m;me:1'£ .::~:iu-2;
is :"'¥'3_ in 'I ;_ amtead ts.) .§<3t:k 3§?_<.=:::% £1' I _, '§}>w.
; _ g-.'}*".\3f}.:2%'3~{.':?3. 'Y'°:':e. 'mfi'::~:r.:rs:za:1t E\'::s..'.'.>. ,,,»"o
- \ \'\\\s~\\\v.\
--' "v _ -...- I\ . ' A'. 'M 7 ,_,\_ , ;,; ~ . . . . , , R10 czmxrusn. {Bi we 1. .10.: :.;;am<>:1 :52 me: a:1eg;_r,§::'E 1I1i3:.*{31:1£i'£€? <is.2';.e.v m CI°Z£"»C:g;'{i}3_g *' V' ' W' "V: .. 3- - '- ~ .- « .-« « -. .. . '. »- - - ~ i~"*113i~.>'- x he ;:;fas.3::rm:2:2o.r.a« <21-.'.'r:'.«{'?. t that éiizev weras er;1:'o:.is::c: E' ' <1-'9' '."'..}"'c.\~- ~'--_.-»\ .' «- . .+ \ .. 2 . - - \ . .-.3.\C 311': 310. K'? ...'(.{s,..-,';§..3.\.>:":<3('5. 6.33;} *J*":?3«'.:. \.}3.:.E: €3};<fi,'C3§;{j§};_§;\: :_:,\(~_1§~§{~_5~:»v§-{~'.§;§~§_ the {;\::}§}(~_g~'<"f~,!.:_ gexriiy 8.11:3. the iii} -cm': E.iI1'?.S, 51?. m.af.e;r.i.~:>. rim. ?:< 'C.E1~f.? $611 "'1 jQ,I'{?gj€?C?. 2);; 'that €:';R§";-f3<%§.'5.'.€ . L. r«
- ~x'\-'€= Etziiézii 2=.::tuf§. :'e.e2::"2v ami \.x.-";i.;;-. «" . , ' ' ' -' ' ' " ' - :1:
to ;';e;'.i'0:'m th2':':r ;§a'u":: of '£?'=<° 3*:-M ' M. : b. :=:ema-. 31.3.
4 ' F': ~< -cm"
«ta -Jae:-, g:*i:;\-'a::>.v.w3 has {ween 2.13 'a §:~3.= i11§Cs}'§r1§3_:j1§§; gggbgu 5-;m_;w
-::3;<3..::.i:i1zamf. po§:§i'>§<'m. aiwizreci iixaat =;'}'.:e. o;:§>c::3§:e .E'i'.§~' baa': i:::z:;os.<.=.zd< .c :25.'-:'r...>':'t.:ia.z'§.~'. 11z:1.f'ai:' >:m<i 2; 211'?" ~"<311£:';)}*° .« r 31 >1.» ~. V J. . 2 7% wan ' ~ - s
-»"~-> x- ?».>§3.€.=.=h=.-<I1>: s :1 1.216 x:1..iu.s..=;;a.:;=.:<swémth mac! '.2 mm
-.42.: . ~' x saw .*"{i.}'§"{..-;§?.Cr1.Z'£:.:!1 0:3. tfzw: 115.5' :3; Cha i;i1if.'1"i'£1&Ei3'3§.:§ ';.>em.g in z;:c»:;:i'.:<'&:\»'€:1::.:m of '.u:.m.<:~:z,<3 stcztuiés.-3' " "' ' - ~' .\. .. . :~ -' " .
£3. *..:.-*.1e.*.>:a.z?:<:e m exiae Am.-.r3¢ an the 'M is. 1 that the 0;>;3czsi=';e. parity frazzciiiiziszaiiy'
-;';<'mc:t32i§:3-;i £3-SS€§1§.'iiEi:i .i3:1§{3rz:1:>~.*gis3:: wf:si<:E1 kéii the i.nf<32'::<:.ant'; ':23 <':n*;er i::c.*.<.> $33.6 .~3-.gr§.2::m.2=:ni'.:;. "R3.-s: .%nfcs:?::1e3:';is E13223. <3;>ti.cex.1 'Mai: to a.:";:';-\~:§3'f. in £{'_.='-fig'; and give 2assen't ts:
§i.'.:e. z3.,<;;rer3me:':t; s':v§;'r1 'i:1*.2<>ug.%tz the i'.§'3.<%E'§i§..3. were :33:1<~:.mu;~;, a1r*csi?::fa*y 811:3 e.r.:<°..~ sic mfi. '.§'§3tt: aggzrecmewts vt':Si'.§:{'i fizz-:-. ogrsposm: ;';a::'2:j,<«' em :.«1E:ss:'332.2::': rigiizi'. iii} or v «:3 ).\./.{-'1-§.§.'\>{:j in ax:~::":u§:¢': ié.gY{'§€?3.'E'.8';>§l'{ wi'?;§*:m.:i: ass:;g:ni.;1g any reagmz, cs: e:<:;:}.a:3at§:m. £é'L>}<;'.<:ti0n is aim < ':'.'.« i'.Etz<t :2;3;3<>si'-:6 * sa:'§:y's.; ai.a=:a:i:«:i{:m§ i:a:> a<f;»;e.;*tis;§: and :»3mmun.c:e z'.§3.ee s{;he.m.e; :a.'a.§oi:m«'3::t }zi~;':'.'ix'3>:'i%; :'::>'§k<:'t. substmatiai §:i.¥fl{.'s'£1I.'3.'§C(5'< from <°.::<ce{:u'£:~3 'c?z§§i'f3t'i¥. ienisg e':m'::*y Gut. <:tcsz:e'§';1'1:s:;ti¢'::1 wi=th:2u*i' a;3;3=..*z:3':& -:35 1£:§;<.:'u'i 333.3223. ass 23:31' the €;'JE{Z Rsgxiéatioxas wizixsh s:-;t1*§.03.3S i'sLi§ou'I;a zsuxi far '»x-"hi $33.3 §:n.2:i:'r:
1ia';.>i1ii§;'wa.:§ e;'ni_fi'.e:<i 0:2 =;'.h<a :.a..i'§.o\:ite:3s.»
6. It is; f:.:1*€.}.3.§::f aéiegmi $33.3)'. the ;32:ac:':§.<::e 1"'>31«3v»'e.<:{ by "t':1<=: :'};}§msi'ie gm rig.' in §$sm.*lng
-:'ax=e;"<iss§::23e:1ts far isxzmziaixzg ga.mje:::ts w.i"thou'<. ;3\:.:"s::i1~»3.si::z;; tbs: Eand am-;'s 11:3:
''.1\ {A \ cicgsixzg t'he=.=. f.0i:a1 ::m:,<.s. of the ;3:*<>;3«3:"€j~,*, data <3? <i€:§i\«'t':'ry {if L>0$sessi:.m. amfi. ?33.r~\ i1:3fi>.r';':';z=.:'iic3:1 r£:§e5xii:1.g iii': =;'.he pm '§:"es.<.s {if \x:u:*'§.< to éihtit fE>u'_<,-*<-:1'& etc. W(;'-fat': <i&tz'i:§1e:1'~:.a': §'.-:3' the in¢::~::':3sts oi" <:cen:'sume1's. "flay: st;p;x>:;i~:.:s: ;:3art.j; ciéd n<.:i' {ii§§.}{">:'~';§i'. m€3.m:§._* c«:>3.iec':.+::ci fmim.
} £2 §3uye:t's in am s.°..°.:§<::;'=32'« a-::€;€.n,mt. t':.:'.:'s..i:*r': px'<';~:':e.S:§ :w:1~--"ra:z1s;::s;rest3.t. §:>22:'§'.%.s':\.2};~.s:s'1;g«' sx<.>.ga.:"{§.'§.mg s::;{::a_i23.i'.i<>;1 V-$7 §::'i.<:'.€-.3 ans} \ apprcsxsz-LE3 {mm 001.. 'gaestrcxxt $9.: ?.§1:'31'.§ 'tie S. ;"'t3.§: ;::s:ese.m'. ix':-\'i"<.>r:nsitimiz :~.s.p;><t:.2.r.<_: in ':'3s.=: an a'$.'é.en::;_'_}: in §<>:"».n':': >1-*=.:';'s:>'_g:i;': >' zmd xx "E'}iu~: ':1*§:3:':'s.:aa::i'.:x' §s:imi'§:£<~t<i3.3=' .':'.::~3'»'e §g.:*s':'«'§o=.1e§iy mo'.-'ed €316 '§\?:;1";<3:1a1i {.'.e.r.z:m.:':3.r'::.' F.}i3;.:':.:ii<~::; Redfwsazi {I-€:.:';1mi5;.;s'i:': '1 '-.1:1<§ :3»: §::§igh C<>u.r: of 1'3€.:-n";3:.s§=.y .r<:cir<~::::saz': :2?" *:.':.:s': g£'§i°.i'sf$i§1{C{')§} : :'i;i':1g (mi; =.=a{;_:'ee:11a23'1;s% w.'m'.<.:'s': 2:373 .::.3§*.>j¢z§.:~: .m.a2'.t<r:r <::~:-mi; i:1~:;'-;>>m.ao:.icsz3.. .:*.:<3t C§::'.£';i' f3'(}f£'3C3. "im Iv rsf 11hr: p:'~:< w .A.v f'm.f<:sr:m=.2.$.i.:'m a}'.:<:=..2i: i'}'.:e 'fzizie. of m;<:'h :i<:tia>:ti:.<.2..
.im{::.:r:n;.m~:$ iizava. n<:§.i"* . =1':-16 dcsminszmt p08i?Li<3':'; the <.>p;3<7e5si'5;.<°.. ;>a.r'tj~_r in E.i'i'lf_\,*' :"e1:3\.*§m: ~'i.i::§m3. 5.85313' am sad. 0* 0*;}';<%.:r»>Ji$¢ a.r'i&ar': §§'€,ei'13 tiiztr i;3.§"o:'.t2:3.' .cs ;.:s.>-~;mc>; =;L'z';e nix?-Saar <17'; use-ri f{.s::§'.'*m:'i in '£<~>:'r2';:'s 1' .x\..« M...
2;
cc «<9
9.
'Km 4 m.
..x . \\ \\\~ I»; '.'.m.-~':-.\~\