Gujarat High Court
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL/502/2010 on 5 April, 2010
Author: S.J.Mukhopadhaya
Bench: S.J.Mukhopadhaya
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK ����� :?u??vk?????'4RLF#?D???v2{Ys?(h?* M? ,\?'????u-]#?W,/%?? y?
??@&?? tK??? ?e?? �6??6???ecy*%?V???9 ?7,?q???s??\y9??03? =)e?*? ??zCW?>?p!f!? ???'a??8?[???>?Id 2.L ?A? OT?Z ?>?2 q??0w??`R?
?? ?&@? ?A1?Dd??1V }?,?A?(???e?F$? 7 ?M? ??? ????B D?d (??9 N?d: ?V???G?? ? ??? ?? ?'fl?x`$ i???6?>?m? ?? N=?D8?, T�U,ho(h?:?.?(^z6hz???.t??+ ??]?P? ?? ?|???4??k ?v?F< ?QW?3 N? a ?? ?? L?kjE ?? ??Cf?, ?}????\? TCz???tK"p# ?? ]YP X?9,? ? 2F?< ??R?? ???1] Az?(??/]??'7j Z?? ?{vD:?? 8?\S?*??"o Xh?3S)??]?
`'?0r OV?%?|???u?R?!???=w ??#v$ nX= ?a? M? ?4 K2????F??:???:????????<{ ?9????e?~�? l%???N??$H0>g?% ?() q??-?!^?8p? 0 zLy?$??p?X8?r :?F???G??Z+K/ .??%??????dkS?TH?? ???B ?O^?? \@sf???c ??Q ???? [?? r???Cm? ??|"?? ? :?9?
????o??e =??E?????E ?U?U?oO?K?? P? ??Y ?n[?V?? ~2?C?^?l ?Zr[?? ??\J '????~?S?????? ?k3?*??? ?
? ?9?8??
?iq???i???N???N???cW??7i ??1&? ??Q?2?S?A??? c??l:L? ?nA?x?3??5PS;A?F'???0$pSTNp:?u `?;?6 ??A?
?n?]?T??e?UB??:3e8d?f? 0?] e?sY?g ???)??8??O hj? ???1@???? ? d ?
?w?= ?/? ?`r ?P&???? �?i~ 2(?Xe'?x3_{ ?\?to??4?7??? 94+?o??N ? ?????d?/> ??:I???F? ? ? ???W?W?l " b }f $?????A0!R> ????? ???;g-D~?y4? S??B??=??)'?Cx?0p?wb - -??V ? ? ?%�?a?KZ????x;Q?`>?{~??Q?? ]B???x%??*\^?D???? ???^0 ??E? y ??i^?(7?o?? ? IF3???y?w???JjQ[Tb?[�?4?23?T??Z?pJ~?! q[??S??|?3$?P? ?c?SZ M?8?Ky?E??
? ?? NQ]?1? ?1? ??"??j N??n32 g?D?F? +?K?P.h??:j_??j?n?K? ?????)?! ?)"?+;T??�? |AxO? }?? ?.(? ??? ????K?~?.????q?
??b-/ 2??-?\F??3$J?X??? W?8 ??u???? ??????`????vS2y`4 ?00Z?xo??? 18;?K?*o???YP? T W?c6??["?n?n?=??? +???: ???V ?f?TR?? ?=?;38'???}q?
p?s?[ ?- ???Ow? F9 ?9- ???5w??*p?Q ??????P ??mx?aR???t?? -?? [? ??I?'j?? ??]*Rw????^??D^? ??yG ??? e???(k? e??EYssQ??.a?EY ???9mQ??%?"? s(?R?
? ,v e ?? ? XU????? ]????g>?J? g?i? ?%F??c?T[Q?U[???7?'J=? ? ? ?2? U V??~??~?? ??D? ?0 ???/e?3|???V?/@??n\ ?M ?ej? =????%???: ???C? ???0 ???p> �???? ?? *YG ?fD8? ??] mR P? sz3 ?2?M??s:?H??l?? ???6?_ ?T%?c?? ?;? 4W2;?? 5E?&? ??? ?b??k?j"?q ?HiA8?~�U?????c??#k???[^?^ ????||?M?? ???@s54 W????P? e1\W &k?s ??IC??P?>X???*?}??>????+?_a}B5R?? ????E????~??v? [???n?? PK O ?? ��.'��PK ����� :?<8i??? ��? �� ���meta.xml OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 das 2010-04-07T12:46:39 1 PT0S PK � � � :?<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png?zeT???&?)n? ? -?u ) ?? ?} ?Hqh)E? (R(?E?? ??|???Y?]wfM?$?{??g???Q{? ?9?s$$$\??, ?]??? ??Ap ?m ,+??s? 7UK?g? ;??LBB?@ ??X???????C???r???]???v ?? ??$?I?3????,f# ??R'q V?? y?? Gu???!m??s? z?]^???}?2p????? ? ?? ?a[???o?#Yu???i?R?_? v}?Q??k??O????6??{?w?W?Q?9L???/u? ?Nf?mVm??K?Yg????$?;8?? ?? ? f ??9FX0?w?"q9cQ;??E?^D;?Ua? G07"?w?to??#??"?W? ??,,X??y/??m$?9??y&F?b???
?tr-??r?? j?*???2?O?Gh ? ??>?i+ , ? ????w5?W6me??]??^t|kU??? ?vm2??C???? &&? ?u|= $N?k??|>??y?? ?&? ??A? ??> ? ? ? t?
? ?pL ?!{'K_??J ? ?% ??6=?x ??,? ?X????X?\dj0 ????@ ???{?xQ ?{J~??>??3J?,*? ???K.bU??:n? ???q%N6?
'4?%?O??!-uTI???? &?7I ?x ?g?[ q??u?H??M05^??
?vX$????? ?VF7?:? g??? k?{??n??6???# O? ?d1QC? ? ?9E?'?? ??t?? ???y?>??1?Brw????r ?u?Tp~?z 0??v?)???*????(Hp>?Jp???<6g?i?R???/8t?? p? h ?cQ?8??v?h.?2 ,G???V?&???P C? ??Jc ?r????v S.?w?? C E???? ?` ?8??9??????????(?
0????3 ?w?Oqi??c \ O?ic?
??R$?~4?M^??q?????R?? ? ?? ???V?Q???%?#? ?g?????
? L\$Onnn R?x:B?? yr9?sy??n?~:?*??\?u??M?????? ????=?? nc??g?iJ?~?1P71?L5?????? ? ?J? ?wj?? ? Hr?(- ???S?e?_?
B%[ z?? ~?? ps???h??|o??
a ?=?G?y??v ?? ?S??T?Y ?F?h? ?9?K??d? D? B? * ??? ?#- J??\?? ~?a????p??>^? ?`?}?j??yF(?U?s? xw?,??+???Y??`l;1?n} ?/?7K????l??;o1 ? =?P(???~? ? a???? ?h??s? ?~ ?:.??X `?me;e????x 1%_#}Rv6 ???k????f?m?.?p?? ???? ?GU%]NuJYv?@z??Nv?+Q?f? T 0??3???x?!??[?!???>? ?l?QPjR?{?c:? c ??E???�?'??2??-?Ng?? P?q ???I???^k??? ?[`6^#?m??Mp ?? ??l??: ? $~ :bJ?l ????[ F(??p'e?x? 7?w�??!Fx?=[E? b???]? q&r??e ??-?_??u??S??,? ??_P\)?K??(r?b1I> Q? ?2?AQ?? ?V? tv??]P?? ??1?>0%Aw????} ? e ???t?????
~??`? ?z !A??o?=l h??*+?(?*???"hz???3?? ? ??? d?? c?? =Q??3 [???? ?[?9???}?? |?s5:}?~?R3#7A ?,??F?B???|?1?r]? ~aZ??u?B?L???9?> ?c?l?1 ?CAtw???? P?.? ?�J?,?g?Q?#?t# -??q????eh,G??I?? C E0?D?? ???J >??{?5????G?A??\ ??d??jsu^" 6| ??!_ ?? SX?qQvR?,???? ???$8????Y??O? R?Rk??jV?y? ? ;?V? 4?[?{[b ?????X )??n? ?~G???$" I?/?T? ??G??N&?jM%?3*?M[?g??o??1s??`?bk`([p4???I?8?{ T ??~0i?? ?i?H]??? 6?[5?~?-?????9.n??ML?'?O?z?'?
? ??Ha???H~X@2 ?T? Ky ??[?? *?k??0????,?w?a#t �?IP? ?_?Yv ??(??.C?+?3??+??'??2?suU@O"????M??Z?t ??2?/do?A ??? ??
.? 9? _?- dV5?M\ ???:s? ?`'= ?@??|? ???R &?? ???D`u?HQ/w??#?h^?? ?? ?}G? C?? ?s?p?6V? P?? ???77????>6?u?`0j?fj????Z �Y?@(?T??~ 8xcct L?? y??5555 ?j??? 2?? n&?3X?
c??V? 9}?J?T?g?? ??j?? zOA?=|?)?ZY??=K?{V???M/ d8.?y?wA ???D/?z%cQ? x?M?[?$??<|??Kq??l? ?[?QQ ?~?s?B8??????\?J?l??X????w??+?? (? Q ???????~?N ?ln?O@\?Y ?| ??!?????&8?_? U???? iC?N?G??LX?4? Z?cZ?"$?V??i? ?d&?6 *K?? +?{? N?V?f?:?x*? `???/?N?X?96D3I?D?? Hc???]L ?J }K?l???; ?A????@ M?C?0]ey?t??s???? ?c>( ?? ??7?-?K?uAUF_/???O?2B??y@???0 ???di?kG?????C??F>?d? ?}5"J??7 Df???o??k??v??,??? ??5??cA d??W?C6?a^?? c$??8? ?<>????4t??6|5h ! ?]j?r?&-"? L? J L?K4y?p?L?? H B ? "@?g??? ? L?F 3*1? .???F? w? ?$ %� -R??y??+? ???p&/?? ?3#????cg?H????,???e F>? ??? QCD ?$5s?ge?? X_p? ?F ??WZ�; 2?? ' ??M?t????c?9 O `???4?)"]t???x J???# ? ?? ??.?&?????X???nPjp?.?*0 ???
???5???y N ??Z8\?4Aw'R)?*? 2QYm3 ???? ??/ ?9+< H?kPg??Z? ? ? ?k???&? ?? ??? ? ?? ? ?2H?xb&*?D&*?m3? ?ZUtg? ?? ? ?U C??`?!?k???xO????j?NeY?[o?;? 2? '? ?? ?1KJJ� {??'?} ?y?C??JK[?1??????%?:?f?(???? ?M?i? ?+K??R??D %?O??? ??8(*J !(? t ??9?8?????eC~????'? ?+??MG??iF??? W?K??a?k?? T?c? MO O ????}?Ms1??? ?<]T? ?wm?
?%?O? ???J ?+ Mz T?*?F ???
? ?)? ?;c }I ???vd???C?!v????? \?Z'6 X?m?c ?wk!? }???V?J???i? z???j???W?% ? h?? Q]x? ?>?LE? atV?Q?4 ??aK ????? ?m? d?O aY? ?U ??Xt? ? ???? ?h???h?\F,?V5'????zt 8xZK??`? a??7~# ?f:??????K?m)?E' ?L?_ ??z? ?? Ir??H?pyjj? ???.&?>?& ?? ??`??9?4?tX %s?????@j??o?????>??:a54 [??P??e0?L??q??�?Z?Q?"?? U ? ??? ?Q??>? ????* ?? ??.mH???}t\D?? ??N????} ?q?b?W? ? ??|-????o ?/N/?W?;N?Ot ,??or???>?I5 ? ???
9L ? ?60 ?bT�W??? ?m? 3?b? ?? ?n?* ??>??9!? ??I?~2O? OX???[?r??r?
iF? ????y+?s?~My% a?d?q?? ?5?$^???k ??}??s6?,??L#???^a8%K?:??? ?x??_o^? ??( ??? ??? ??? F| D�rvLz?$kb?HMR???2?@-???7?s??? ?IX S=?. H)}???x ??1 ??eL#C&??3 ??? ?H &a?C y*?? W ???6~??/?W;?,ql?mSh(AVa?P j 8?? ?\?w???O???IY? �?h?2J ?\ N???r???0?>???`?,??gDSy?(??A?!?j5J??XvP?s,?*??T :??gU??$V ?!???>= ? ?? ?t7 ?R?U???=p ?`D| x?t?w?+!b?h???K?G? ??j??x????h ?yu##( ? LJz ???????l=e ?s???{ ??)g??G*?w?,f* F?J M]?2? t???NJ9+1? JU?C MGg?A:'?\?J?R?FJ?g? ?oU ???? ]=?Nd7F???] ?B ??On?/ ? k]1[on7?STL? ?? CZ@??Z)?$13a; m$E??d&????@??Z]*?(e ]?? \?8 ?$????x? ?g??G P]�L?Q?rGt_?p, F?? h/ T& ? ?? &???p?]?I?F? ?8??? ?^/k??
?9b\? ? ?* ????~? J???
?~q?L? &? ? 4??????V?4 De?? ??$??#?cePT?
?(r) HfGU?;# ?t/??{??k??o???Q$????S6?y??n?caO4Z:??[?0d?L`9 ?? H /@?0?o2?vI?1? =??K????YTf??(??? ??
c?k ?qZC?Q< ??1?P?dXJ:? ? ?? ?! 3r?????"?I?3???Sj ????{ >?Z?? ? ?1F??9]CN3?K?h? ???? 1??1P~? ???v??2 (t? ?? ??/q?d? 2?? q ??H?J?? ??W{ Mn% ?{T \? ?f??)?'D??V E??@???_?DM~? ?wa:?K ? aa9_Q?I?Y8???f?? ?#q?_kv?
????a?? ?F?I? ??~?sg1??q?? _ ?x?Z? u? ?[o}??{?
Z?,?Pg?Q s?o?Z??�??|?3?)?? ? ,?>]H"H??A????W?+A? Q??3?? ?wh? ???^?? ? $??_B@k>t ?FfhZ? ???? ?? f????R{ Z}`?b Qr??S?? w??R 9? SG??NI?WZ?`?? ??3? ?b?>?W ?w??mu?d bS ~??? ?????u ??? ?(8?=;l\O???TF n~$?? ?l:?Ws0?!??~#i??~ 32?????V]" ?????8?? ?m ?RT??? TI??@S t???r`??? Zc?'?Q]???tI??3 Afl[? ?? ?? ^ ?7L?ZCv ? ?O??|a???W5d ?? $???�? gqB?T?K1?;?? ???"& ?%? ??>g??D85?6Q=E?j??X??e)P??5 ?x??x?!S?jU?>????q?d, l? $ ?s?n? c2?ot^? KA? \:?7t5^p??kJ ?{??J???yt +E?' ?o ?m > ?>?a?l?x?? fee5{??g?K??$N? ?@?? Y ??G?0?&?I???:??? ?w ??-i? ?P,??^3:??4 )%}:??{L???(?B2 ??L? Q(?2i?? ?????~?a?????S@?????m-??T?A? ?+g ?L???oq?7=??Eo?7???3 ?@??H? ??z Y\G??'? e??&BD?1?F ?6 % ?^?X?~ W????M o ?iq5,d????? ?d?T??T???y???vas?? c%?!?R-m?TD {C 6z'?
?
9C?[&??? ?JN+?? =]?? ??Iv A&xW T!9?JqO??M? ? R?? ?o/??i;M{.?? ]=!???v?I?f?? SF??g??b???N??& ? 2&M?? ;J? `?5UR??h?M7\???'S! ??;? ?t???w?M?A?c??? I 2?z ?!??? ??? &?? 1???? _?4 ?z?p? ? 58 ???-??? ??V? ??=?~?V ??Q9@~4Mm???+t?1?? Dnw??C_?l?T?k??S ??L !???| e??xe ??@V?=????h?? >3 ?9??CD\?p9???? ? ? ?Z???T? ?v?? ?? ??A?u?s?W? R ??m �,???qA?Q#tZ??o?Fn>???nN??6??????l?&8 #?G.f?w??5F1?.?? ?.?
?? ;? | [s 9 CL?e???c G?y !A?{,? ? ?$?z2???J n?d??G?9? ? ??
?$ ???Z? ?^ ?? ????Q?N??? ?w ???~*]0|.?D i??I ?,?7 ? A :?-zv&??� ?7?O?$e?zF M l7????? ?B? nY?b: Y1???????#???u??3`??? y???R???2us?GL?^+- ??-?t?� ?*f ?>7WV??h@1? vQ }N?z-? ?9?F9?h` ???` Y 5?- ?9Hh??? ?" ? ????? Q???w ? ?&?? ?]? % lK??Z$?Y? V? U??9Fd?Ig?&? ???xt?7?]???"???"?9`e~??a ^ ?? m?(? 2????m??? >?L???A?i ? ?'? ?+ ?KL /T g???t 8?a7?T. ??x?c?5? ?g? ? ?8? ?T??4??.?6 R?VP' W8 ?:??????R?-D?7E ?9?4? ? ??X?v2g?qFA???.9g 0?K?*?m^???}?c?4?? % ???>tRw? ?}?+ " ? ??Tk?B?H ????- ?p7?3?N?D??~}?!?b~??m6W?]�?F9 ?T??JX'?&e?i??d?1?f?? ?? ?s?? ?O?mk?????y%FZ? ?d,i ? v"fz?G&?K]k=??7?????1 ?? i1??; ?4 ??H3[??Fq4?JP?l???N?5?`?{l??a K.?? ???6LZ?/_??F?y?)?(??gd??C?pW E??\??_??$????\[?6?y????? ????k??d?K ??O??w??I? l???~?W =????Z?~U?E9 ? ] }Q?\ ?)????~?V ?_????c??5?H? g? @D! ? SP[ ? 90?5?L?=nEK?B?=F? }?: ?2gI% ,!??Uq??w(9??0??F[GUZR?zM ?%?o_?}??J??I?s?? ???1 ?bq]? ?K?z? ? t ??y??????? q>"??h??$?#)?vX?Q ??_? ?UC? j?:??8"? ?|??? ??^????0%?>??i??HR E}&HQ &89O?`?�???6? G?o?{?6O%?b?`??Q^N?M?cg?n?Xj:?gC?N?^,)nC? ???C???Y??5Ww~ ???
?? PK ?EI?? ��E ��PK � � � :?<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ??? ]??S??X ??A ? ?k H??\??? ?? ?~]K??? ??&?ZF;?Nh??~?c ?L?B?)? ? 6 ??????m??j?D???m ?6??Y?b??A?, ?a?m 0_???\? ?,b?$?? ? ?R??? t??? ?z}h (:I?? ?"?u???15 S??"? ???? ?U B?w+ -;]*????T? \?qY?iU????l7�G???r?
_H??D??F ojT?#???n9??;?Ik? .j^????? ?i"?O_? Iv ? ? ? ???r??? g Top