Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Milind Dinkar Gaikwad vs M/O Defence on 28 August, 2019
ct
= Rm
ra 3 a *
ci ed 4a
" Sd a
f, . ¥ a
2 2, a
3 3 1g 4
% ay «rf i Oy
g a ost £4,
a A Aig co
4 re ta & 3 com a
i a & a Q D
mt we g u
PE § 3B 5 er: 6
we oO a or ca a
mL. @& @ q $e 8 is 4
a mn ~~ | 6 ~ o 6 2 £3 Os
me 2 wy 42 re Ui th
Le; ™ ;
ES eg a4 id Q 03 oI « a
ae . ~ me @ O mane '
I iG ee he o. oS Ina * " > S4 Oo e ged Sef
a . + ae = m Ss OD a oS OQ tr +
He oO AG cD , 43 Aa a) 3
as ot Bf. Goo os oO fs Oo ret sep CL ED
a | i QF "eed ed "et « He a ot ©
Gg mn Ae bed 43 xt rt tf ~« D ot $4
a g cf G red et He ct Cy Md sod Gi 4) Oy <>
% oe, 1 OF fe & ha Choo» gue &
pf & a te i Chk) 6 2 U3 6 a Ut oe i Oe OF
4 ' ma faa OF EI ri ge O% 2 &5 fra BE
mB 6 By He OG @ OO ort '
ei . '1 ~oe yo vB Wi os Brac OM
fel : Mi. Sw mat OO Eta oO FM ©
a A 8 Ge 8 Oo0 98 BE
of Wo ok tt © Be G Cw Hh uM OG = w
de O in C4 Oo ed st p C eh my 43 a choy MM
a ii ve iss a i @ Oe tS bo wt
ae Ch xed { €h -et eG Coen & Oo @ sep hE CR
GS ¢ LOB aA & my pe RE CA O Cb rt
g sg aft ON G b Th bog
4 Mi ed o Mw ra]
at °o vet OS te TE DS ' >
Ch oO oy x i Ou Ls 9 is ro merit wa oad
anc :
Ne ANAS AE x
Leap
ty
ey
¥
*
10.06.2019
28.08.2019.
*
a
Accounts
.
a
wha So. ote
rote
eaneral
COTTON
~
re
Vw
*
( By Advocate Shri R.R. Shetty }.
Order reserved on
Order delivered on
cst
ORDER
Member {A}.
i, De. Bhagwan Saha Per :
233s sof Pam 2 rt O wa wt wea be ee 3 x dee Yo TTA MoT Ne ae « ¢.
tor os rey f 6 tae Nt ment 8 ted Ms my See chk wey A y 8 pee aoe n nm Oks wT $5 ah 4 6 et oy TO od ped ref weet wy Q +.
ee Ty oe oh roy 167 fet iis} qt @ 54 yet whee , wt i i rp = we Th 3 ct Gy $4 me i » bet a 44 G n oe o C oa : gt iS ka " in in 3 4 Oo a 8 4d fn @ ca ; 5 c oO a ® ve ord uf ns 5 ty oe i ed oo o 43 u oy y 3 e r 4 onl Oy bd cond foe a ot in % " tex ped ca ot Cg "th 4 $4 , o Be a At a . 8 , ° "4 bd " 43 [ 'CO @ o3 wg m ad "4 ony a) Red rn io C @ . 44 ind i cy wh - st et vs rt fy w 'a + rd c a tS "Ee a uy rea) a oH '2 co . st ce) ef' A Ma ' haa Sa * ct ee a8) ay gerd 4 a ded orf
2 Ss 8 ts a vl ® wi oe . goss yO <A ° Oo Cag ts {3 st 4 "3 jt oo ps i A hes iN 3} " we wn a os o 5 i ng cs i 4 ms G ot @ , Gs Or ol et a 5 O me wu » ib © 43 rd 3 a ei i : 7 ' c os " iB eo me oO wi * he. ca ey wp ved is ert agert e ' "
£ : a we r : : . ¢ oe ao 4%. a a t co 1 a ted La ve " a & 3 me 5 "4 oo a ose ert B "t 13 Os i} ' cs co 0 @ va a " hy a a ba bad we a ts gs "3 Ca oA e 4 beg ; 1 Key iS ene . . " € > |. " oe 7 nt vee 4 a hg % wl BA ~ Bo Ba S ' s " * - Ci t om kg "G tt mn 8 & 8 2 BP Bp BS sr sO Soa i . Goo G - BD i bet wo Gs nas LY 5 wa 2 ma i , on ; ~ GB 4 oO $4 a a 1 ~ C m2 5 4 wef - "3 $ eZ te ¢ + ct 3 , st = od Wy ef ord 4 he fa ; & Cy o> iis 1G ch tsi a > % st oe, a CG 3 se et if} va eo 2 7 ' p ie wf yo US . om & OMe oF 5-4 ad ed $4 6 4 a CG es 4 B a ery ee D f3 ' & 4 ah ri * Ad orf i
e) "~ ign vy a) rt % a4 shee Q : a a a wy ao Ne a id in . ip S4 G | 4h 3 oA " i "4 aey a ae + LS qh a awk 4 g Rt G Ps @ as nw uy % 3 uw & cA ws a ra e SO a om ws ;
6 @ : d fe a E :o7 NS bd 3 SE eet we yp c a m8 tO ie ¢ Y @ a : " es oe es 44 2 ~ a ae: 3 is 6 es) at bes ies Ep 4 fed G as a fs fad a4 os us & ee 4 bet eh ms es © boy % '? x ina o . w a gd ti oa? @ ee ha a3 ° re my ~ © 8) x Q co » gt m Sa O He 3 o £3 OS a wd a5 Q 3 cA oe di & a) . 3 @ ed ue rd uf i? Gh rn, " rd as 3 Ly. . en fxs O i wD 4 on ,
75) as "> ie i a5 aoe 7 ae nt Q % O 2 o +4 a3 ip is rad 49 Co ma _ ry $. 3 423 % ss Di od os Ea wd {3 4 ig * D xo H = a eo * 23 O a So wh ny te & 2: ad e a Gs, FA mw ane ~ " mM 8g a Pp GO ~ & Go © oO" . fra ao Om fe . (2s ca KD mo 4 2 Sg 5 e 9 & iA 8 ol o " wi t? i 4s cs Q bed ig @ ) ; i oo MO o 4 : 4 . Dy . 2 om ox 19 wo OU ci E GS CU ond 3 x Ro , GB a "ooo 4 ry op 8 o Tm FeO qo. uh 3 oO @ a a 4 . & : tf c @ a o 45 4 a G ae ~ "ft a ay FS $ Ret Bic ial « Chg : reef 3 og ot i Og as SG ward rai Le we ; . 4 th 66) G3 n D i . . a Pe oo qi wy i " *O * ea 4 ne, ' GC 8 Um US cl GO tm ¢ a . eo BOS s 6 & ao 6G , - od $4 f} ts mo - 8 & & oO a "a Pe - Se 5 OS 4 « ag A % 3 be} f se) set & " ~ " ;
i) tha Cy t » © wr ' Cr ar w a Fy © i C % ea a a Ho 8 S . 2 " & ee i 8 be ved a} ey het eo i re ee od wo . u & a a 4 Bis . oO an a NS m a a he 4.3 O 3 RG et * i z 0 w ' :
¥ ot a oe a a ey ae i * wigs : . O 43 i % os i 3 a 4 ves 8 vf * co 3 0 ' @ fg 4 he % i. 25 ved a ed M4 i a Fn =) ?
t $4 a4 'S) y 5 ~ "CS i) " a hed ep i oe 3 de x LA . fe hy et ¢ gt z tt f ry Q a 4 a k ¢ = a as eI ap O as ve ie wat fee 3 & 0 ox 4 Oo ie et a 2 &5 ry ings a a G i o a a ® 8 g rd rio fg ft OS ae Hoe x" 3 4 qt as 2 Ae 3S for rd & wy a S wm '4 43 ht 43 gh t " ee " ee ccd Fe v3 GS iy is u % tere i 5 cs ras » } a c vol 6 re) es tong in , + a ' bf he "Z aa i : Na G ced . "% " 7h . cre ut Be et red "cS 5A iy Oo w mgt ihe 4 Sy ° 4.3 Ft O ' ! an . ay v * 2 y i ty, bs 4 ae @ % oy 1 pe ie Pa 4 et o ~ 2 4 @ 4 4 wy reat th m3 ns ts , ij O in - » ; é & % | a Ps iQ } . 5 ad " f : eet mr £4, th - f a iG + 4 on a v4 1S "s 4 4 " a 4 vo ord 3 " , a mG Z ! : Ey bd 3 a wo 4 o g fa ' mF o a Wore tf Se ZF fo oR OM Mm te Og Og, Se: ¢ wed rea 7 4 oe} - a ; ASD ~ $4 sans ed 0B 5S on > "4 wy, ey L3 ; 4 on Gs a ted @ fi 54 cs ea ER Oy rt at o te wd 3 « £) * i 44 & awed 4 2 ne) > ~ 3 t 43 ed 3 -
8 B "es ay % M4 3 i ih sy a o » pt go St i Bo gg ne) : oH rm Bo fe :
s © an ed ved "ph Ou Le ut wu cs 5 "a = a ° oe ' % g & . 3 : ws, Oy % ve ad 4 a og B ge & a o 8 . ac "
i a ne: a eo . & 2g g el Ad 7 ts » on " 4 3 :
a hy 5 pes vee} wD ee wy « 1 " iy : vee ne ta a es G A o uy & 3 os os of o 4 im ee G & 4 ht i 5 3 % i ee. ard wee A * of Ch, c © 5S 8 ©& fc o™ SG 3 ed ep ¢ ec a 7% © oo Oo $4 Mo fF OM a e ® 0 RSS he Yt att ey cs 43 a &) ' 4 6 o c CG ® rad o a res wee rt cot ory oO ved 14 sre} $n ro w 2 f . x ' eo & '4 6 PP -y & e 3 om © 9 Dw 6 3 as rs ai 42 Ba uy en ow 43 t a ww beet ek > be "4 oe RE O oh O "rt A Q aA z 4 ng fs ed 2 4 " a an 42 fu oy On 7 a a ty o ry Soa von ~ Hi GY os es ft } % x " @ 4 e w @ hy % 3 : Se 3 me Ee 3 w te het hay ve 4 1 es ard As iy i w ao "G - fe eo ify " 4 o vd o ef 4 Fes a a a mS is 5 es ts Os \ +: sd 4 AO G3 ny ws o . a ' -- o S fa : . f+ . wy age4 43 eos yt es ws ea at @ Seg 3 cet @ - ® iD % i ~ i CQ £5 4 Sa ) the ve ip '4 . Ba « : a3 o - 44 a oe ee @ ® sa re Bo sy S De ys a oa @ DB we? tm oS 3 c a (te UB Cs mn © yo i we 43 eed Oo Fo! ae os a . a iY > ri ae gs " . co 9 eB = wt oC s @ ®% 4 G 03 wy sheet + ot : fra bor th, nyt "4 ad a det "wk ° a ~ a v "3 OB GH o . Dg og go & "ay O . aq S nw 4 oa th C G 3 vt hey . mt ba yet zt 4 ry} rr} Q ies fs a4 at iN KG a ed 4 / ton iy w 6 a ef Re C 43 % Soo OB Oo gg & wt a) es oO S we wet « " mG ; & o a ect oe Be w « weer "yt Ch 4a Ch ® ies 49 1 Be te bd & ee a seek oy ay he "
uy 1S ws "ny ® & me mF ard a tS a3 sa 4 oy a Oh e a ; c he @ Q " C3 me aed £K, = oe ry " 04 64 '3 i ©. 'th 4 Gi Gey 4 4 ia *: : '5 ved vet Ml 3 Hi a Gg 8 Aa me gy Me is gs ct & Q i cg , o Wed % o o wy i OG a B eo "S Gg 3 ~ é wn id iH ee ed G / £3 vO a ay wy Med SG 4 Cc om % a ro} o a4 g co 4 us gs '4 oO a he DD a "4 OS : ord Sta Q Q ad % vy w 33 . Ned of 3 bed 4 wh re Xd vd rede OY * ® $5 42 rl Qa . oS at "c iP 6 "3 eo om fi 5) ot QO fy 43 on, Q bs od xt "4 fe 6 ' 2B ag aS & ie 5-4 u wo '3 BS) o Shs ay 1 fa) o 3 et iH '4 Q AY 3 G m ~ 6 to Che oot ee 4a O ras) m) 4 kp mt i 3) Tei at oy ef oa iw ted 6 sake Ne NR oe an ws ' 4 Sane he Se de ~~ = o wan he MN A a ee & oN an St ae ae AF
-
tet 4$3 ved oO 4 x weet ed fs of ee w & Ao he 42 A mS j NA o are os Nt o> 6 os aPy n ma a o yred hd % a3 gy 43 wy £> wg «4 oo a4 vote ey Wt a Cr fy Sry Caden x s 4 Rhadki, 8 x GY set a on ref a4 ko RSS 5 a oa 4 i} ~ P , % & a ea > u ie 3 i ed oS a) uw a3 ie @ Oo w G a © iG o 3 mS te "e AA od wh ted a" ce wa w 0 sy wed 'y "G Gt "3 A "4 o 4A red " " ' Ra 3 an, Pe eb a qoeet ' Bt we§ eC is , my 3 if , 2 Ag w ua ¢ a 'ep Me : © a ox eg he ie 3 ee fe a TH gg o 2 s on m4 bei ; a , a tt 6 3 ma F "4 F, ad "sd " iG Q oe Cr 43 iS Ct , + y eed i bes ¢ af 3 " Bed ; RA ¢ ~ a @ i cd 4 re oe ; O : ee * © he i o , " "SG wo ¢ gg yg At m Oo Sw we : ' 3 he ' he wm et a , A oa 6. bs 4.3 4 ' bf ap 5 a vi 4a ie me ayed . ti a AR AA "rf Q @ o 4 s ae aes gt i . 3B es Fy Pa ny ra G a a fs fw 5 "4 @ ae a ee ' eg Mong - 2 2 4s woo BRE ao £ os gb hg a cA RY t wed gy a 6 oye wt 44 ? 44 Pa oH a of wn : ue te a wm i w y . i 8 a be ed o m o " C 1 fk rt i a a a Y Q o ay a8 a mo RB GCG BF HR Bo | » fe MM ri Fy " n C " G§ 8 ww wy bed A $4 Fee] in 4 th i a eS G a ig Q G f coy oe et 4 c De gy o Y Th ': «ond gy © & O i ef ) ? Cd Go } Ka .
L t A a ed ws ~ ; me GS Yo qd m& " 9 us a % ved « : } a 23 At Q wa "s ° é Bd : a ot @ a : 3 : 5 cs its © ie os & ' ms Ke 6 A 4 } e E33) mh G
- gy Coe hp sige SF Rn &€& oy pas ols th . o ig wn tS hy FS FL, C4 td + ts te 3 3 << ' a 2 G CG od ws 4g c Ce OB ma oe @ 8 & 2 if ws be at 2 oe a on * oo ay ra ' © ed @ be SA che . . oo es o a a mB 2 ba +4 2 42 wa 4 st iB 4 ' vs, og ved SE Q ed ond a7 ur Pa 3 Ad ; a " S4 : O my ' 7 oO ca cA we " H 4 Ss ® ° os 42 he wD '4 eS 9 Oo a 7 wl ey 13 " 3 _ eh "6S al 3 wi 4 mks , oO he a @ is uy Me rn a wn if on ms "A if a3 e oO ra ed i a % 4 on $4 <4 wed ae Qo a ty ¥ th C4 a] $4 ard Q . 4 wed ~ cat & 4 'h a eet a , G a i a : aw © 4 ts % a ad , (8 wed my 7 4 a mK 4 vd * a. KS ot oo - * ' uo a. g @ bot i 4 } - Co i MM on} rd ie) * 5 os} in $4 ao uy 43 m2 » at . oon «g gs & 4 6 o wa a oa cS mM g 7 rd od a " 4 Q 5. i @ > i Sh C3 "UB UB @ a i f @ 3 <a cg re Oo ™ a ' G Wed " Css ' Me ' ' o tH . . . oad oj a i 5 > : - 9 % ® OU 0 ~ if $1 vend ore] " ee. ' + ek if qs ve i # : 4 3 2 mm o @ 4 , 6 a mn 2 om 6 OH we © 4 B " O&O Gf GH & od re rel ' ng oy ved --~ . "4 wt & cy Q Q {Fj G G a 44 aot a) x 4 4 OO & Ww GW ¢ Ko o % a OAAN2O12 oO o , xe $4 8 a % - ip o te 44 e 43 4 p Es "Dy ; gy D 3 si, ee oy ot 7G 4 ap ih 43 $4 o O ihe Q Sa fa 5 a 3 4 ved * ts O #3 Dy 43 of a ct a ed re a) @ a) res syed red > oh ord & ce: we fs C3 H ce tes vet ay " a Ad het a a red a . a a O SY 9 % o 8 «oc 8 Aa 4 3 & ha it ce 5 a3 i: a3 a ky Co ra we " ved at bd 4 G C oa i * a i ES oy ome 4 a a : @ ; od 44 ad as ne 4 t tA Ft sd v ca w " tn cy et a 33 c e iS i Ss / a red ig od ~ it 33 ae ¢ wt 3 Mes mT & wy co ee 23 ha a He O a mt rte 6 3 a & 8 po 8 ma p G so ° cy Rh we cA ce: aS Ad 4.3 3 a od "
' a ae " ae o 4 a % a . g 2 ie So eo @ 8 %@ --y © 8 i Q - oe"
" 3 ty 4 : x is nS Oy ag te 43 uy fe ro) G . C3 'n > t oh os td , oe o oo &" os gM eg = 3 Oo woof 2 ei ' G3 . aed Get me, oS oO aS BO 2 oes 3 "t vel ed ace g oe i Ot Ch o ug 3 i a 8 e e , oo het wy rs a, Lg us fs 6B cA « ® os cq a 2 Ad oH ty " ' as 5 Gt a OM Ch iS . bed wi « S an 44 3 cod 7 ae a oy go ie 7 ° Mt j "4 ti h4 » yy reef a } Oh oa ALS my Of C3 ' fd a} ~ at v3 £23 ' na a wd a e et od i fee : we te4 e oy a rf Hy 6 > 4 "5 iL Y $ By mg bn So a = o © he co mer , D i o w a 2 3 ' we OM ne HS ra i Mi rie a 4 fe % ao :
et 4 os od M4 & cs J oy 4 / te - 4 4 u. i q He Th 4a cs) 2 , + : " ; 3 wd + 3 Po «tk Gs Ze i) w aed ci an va " ' "0 vv c i tS is me ie Ad , ; "s Joa oe ves ' "i " Gh wie eG oC 4 51 @ a fe "ed as fa, my 5 © he thet 4 « 4 43 3 © a Ct ' a3 re : ced 4 ret es Bo wo 43 C ' © eo OP od mm «A MA ke om OB 6 0 Q Gs @ ay 5 $2 } @ ' * A wn cs ie he +s ahs ' 'S w Ve * 4 et " ved wy Sua 3 Q c vr od St Oo ve % 3 Gg od xy ; on oa red i ued rl @ a 4 ® saad oy ry or & ae 5) & GC et ag " Ne " me rt A gs pe) oh ta a3 L ver} en okt a vend C "ee o on «f, os G3 "4 © ta. fs oS vcd '4 8 . led ry 4) XY oe 6 ci eS wy F 2 6 > is fi ° w ° ° w a o baa Sh +4 z 3) fe ga eo cd : oh 4 Hn Tm et fa ar Se my be ng oe hs ee as G "% "rd ae rs : ot mt re Bo o 43 os me ad . 2 as © A a o M4 Be i ceed TG He Si 4 ot " " oh "rd a D " 3 He a : hes a LY Bs
--
c a ry ze "athe Saat vt i, © ime 4h er wo " w "cd " % be gt «ed ws 2 + = a s o ah > w "A Sa R oe 4d , y : > ed ard ' w a J CG eg os toe & 44 = "rl orl ~ wr a o hte a a a ne $i a ci 4 se $4 ne we Sek M4 ae wa tp Het 4 6 at o oy 3 4 (3 a 'ig -- @ 4 tet 'et ca @ @ ne ad ey aD 3 uh @ et Aa ed "ef vet ths a m i} M wy wu es Cr Th eS be 3, oF fs QO het 6] D. 4 wm aa ee) mt ne OASP20 i ~ A q td os @ vy ti bd Med 4d 44 4) i we 4 2 b tc ies re Pe Pe 5 3 Oo 6 2 2 a t ua Wa vB rr rs a "
a3 cn oO i x OD on a ra v 3 & " "s 8 SO " i "rd a 43 5 th $4 2 ped Ww uA a 4 SS Be O ot «6 C Ch Cra, a ha D Os, a & ow p os # wa OE a. us ' ia | red is) ig . x ' iss os et 3 / ca) . Co we 6 Q ne Ad eek Hrd ¢ 0 hf Dm weed 4 y 3 fa c tes we "9 4 Go ey t ed ai a GB. e im iS cs Sag B o® 6 © Oo € 3 Oo CG : 4 4 re % "
ho w Q : a £4 @ ce y) & wo w w S 4 " ae, - eg 5 be a Ee i ved of wo . a4 74 vos a ne 3d cp oO m os 2 (4 '8 G * G4 G bo ns rn? , c cs by a "e c y a C3 & vd ~ me oS @ ae " "4 0 oo uy 6 wD 43 PS Be " oe m ' $4 Q $4 5 i a oak a ¢ oy ry th $a wh on 4} he . we "el 2 O a . cs ' es 3 bet & pet ey ce rt % % Get $A . Oe oO a ay eg € ws oO o > OR os gc ge 8 & Oo . 8 & 8 ee F poet % OQ ef GE & boo 3 6G '9 fs 3 i cd ord } oO int 3 3 Go @ vot % £ nS E c ws a 1 C cs a G e "3 is . oO " we a 3 71 bs . KG - . . 3 & - 12) B a we os me ts an a 3 " , ved SG "4 ny 4h 3 Oo am oe 8 . a 43 th art Fe bi vod det 5 :
G as teed a in a wD ood Q Qo cb we ba ve bd B mt ed . D > 5 ot ae i wm : ie O 6 G a" oD we Pe . ¢ . t : ; o rs
4.3 aS a * oa rt "¢5 os as 18 os w ey " u BS E a da en OO os W 45 42 foo go . @ ved o oO am et we et PT boy ct QO cd 7 on oa) 4 ' "th "eq . 3 hae 3 ~ a:
: mi | OT rt a ty Oo 6: 8 Bo wh Oo wb 7 fat 5 re3] wed © vet . chet tf ry w ' Aa tok a 5 4 2 x 4 C3 44 O ' ae ew a Mt 2 > OO Bw - ej cs os 3 , «a 2 6 "Deh Oe fA ae 43 o i & " ; é wn @ + ced eo G © oO @ et ord ued bf os vt i iw ved B rorudo @ 2 S dD ak 4a}.
g Oo.4 10
. ; i : : "4 : a i ' i ad © re 4 "4 : * fey a Ut sf 4 3 v3 wD a at 4. ved q i a w Ss : 2 n a 2 o ce th ee ib of} ha HS id cot m & ca sort G cea w hee oa ue 4 a 's % a a e woe iy ord 4 hs 4d 43 = ae mS if 4 2 2 & 4 ' oh - os 2 o ce OG G3 as ei wef ay as ~ Ge rel fot {B iw Y eg vB ely 5 ud sh gt y £ ret Soa 4 iy Gh on " 3 va aa i i nA ' fe 4 ned a Ch Sy ee sok ey w fed ' dd * .
© & ~ HL S a oo @ 6 4 i Boe '4 oN re4 « . eo td tu} wy sre} to zy et oe) om 4 tier! vi » oy : . . . a . 3 ed ot e ws a g co fe rd . + @ i wi "e 3 v4 me a ia * @ id bts & at xt i wm "we Me aS ® Ma ba Be ed Se ~ oO a 5 OS Oo ea od s fe aa iy G + ® -
a Net £ p q 2 a # ne Ss a in e 4 oF ng * oO is Gh & ort pa a 4 * ee UD as o r - gs 4 @ co agg rep ee a y fe ? o 4 $4 a 3 oo ona th Pe Ce n 44 bo iyg ; } 3 t : . ra Y 4 a 4 ' "4 5 A" , te g @ 4 ied aS oy e ME +4 gt a 8 , g ~ odo ic Mo rf) a 2 O O on £ 5 C3 p C2 "ed 6 é oe a O 4 wy 15 4 n> is % ; > it 3 tpg a 5 i C3 a} oh Gy 7 5 ; peek sa 3 oy a . oy et & " aa 43 $4 ut o . o hoa uy (2 oy 43 ' ff 0 wh Oe , in ft bh , # 4 a sg YF c Be aed wh ~ ° ® " hd % % * Be Gh « Dp ? fhe eek rx wy a7 ie ' a ¢) tw ® ey "ws ct bs B ao Pe ~ 3 me © Par Soom LS : go "1 54 a C3 a cs) ' Aa vet a3) Q Ma rg ce) o ad Q} sig - 4 Oo 4 e $2, : * oA Wo rl y us uy 3 in Th $4 D ws aD 02, CG Ww ts on Le @ wae a ort w Oo : ey 4 4 os oO oa 4 tt a8) 2 eed ot 0 ted bed u ved JG ae ed hh 3 aS wa 3 be @ * a ie 4 "
as a ies Lt wa ie t eh Fy) a wy ard a ' : C3 o i 1 3 tA 4 tr ; pt ct 3 iy 3 "eg . th C . wad 9 ie wy ay C3 red iD) * G am iy me wy O a Bag S th A a nn 3 OE , s 2 AM thy ek mn 3 * i moet 43 { Gq n i & ; cae ~ " 43 f c wD a} os . cA oe 8 4 oS GS go G B O : 3 xe A ue ts a . q Mj 3 tA $4 ss 3 6 thet + 04 ~ mg ee ee i 4 6h 9» 8 yO rf BU © a to, oO 7 & Tr fon OD et a e G mw ~* vO 8 Bo is Do a Lt oa Bi x te es 63 us ~ cs wy. Sey 3 id wt G 0 'a uf be OS omy BG MH eA hg a fet 8 re oi re a) vd My Le Se 4 gs ted aA ae
34. 2 é hee = x < he + :
Le 2 es 3 Nat o y = £ xr Pest Ant:
n = cK ' o E Sal 2 2 a 3 i e AB - , ei & , 4 ip ag ci oS O Q 4 ort a qe es = i G w gt 4 t mR rainy Yet WwW "
ua an 4 bes 4 SA & 7 A 3 aL de.
wi 6 rn y.
a 2012 ;
CAA iy uy gee ree F Mn a os Lae Shae C f tee By Met '0 4] E-+4 Ad Sef Damedar Reddy, B. Goud Vs. Machuri et het iD & ie eed 12 sce 683, 24 (2012) ii et & w> rt tS oor 4 we C ard "© +f 3 ee S33 et oy ns ies 4 wt
8) rod ® G ct oes 43 4 ay sf 3 3} x3 Saee! ob el eo a
3) Ch > @ a a i oa <> aged aan = 2 ty 4 a wo 8 GS oR € 8 & . a a fe 8 8 me * ; wh Es "3 oy Ps ord 4 " Ae a uD 4 oe age ioe 9 ' biog nee KS = ig . oF et = R oes u a * aa 3 0 "rt a 3 or - oe hen £ ; wd «ed rt * wo oe ie 3 wD a i, fe "| ef re 48 oS i td ty, = 3 Q in c z 6 o a9) es ty Ee DB a Q be go Bo E oe fH ® ces 2 . 8 ae et a we ; O , . aa os. % D ape ei » b 2 ans nk nO Oe ns 4 a C i ; 44 co F iF) ty t ;
i ey rP) a 5 us a e 4 2 m eS cH y . uy j So 4 ; oO " * " ced © . « Pm 4 x 4 iB > q ot a 5.3. hy Wed At 2 6 + ® st i v re & i oO Sa gp Ci Li Oy 1 o es 4a me Os ts is 1p oo ay 44 "4 » eyed o, a7 « "3 O in a £3 44 ie ot oy £ Q > ts u Sa 3 M4 3 ro a a os ; os a ed 3 re a cd : oy = oO ry ! a 4 es % " be 3 ae io) Shot a wp ' ved ai sy i ta D As ed oe ce 3 He " ' 44 . « ; i 6 ot f . KS &e on & df 4d 64 ae "ed pe if we ved to 3 m4 a 43 i 4 . , i G ; +e o Gh 4 O @ e 8 8 G wd z4 mS th ay apf a7 Cr 'Ot ey MG oO 4 o o : ef 4 e 0 wv & 3 " vd C3 ' ns A 0 mf y i a het " co work Ci o "s : ro et yo ' 2 , * * % Ct nm ay be 3 vd '4 +4 a Q 2 G@ 8 . Beh a 8 B oi cs Bh g 8 # Boog eB ® 6 gee Lar vb eee ca t. gw A go As Bo Bt wg f 8 4 4 es $ 2B Ss Oe 4 © a 8 £ rp i mn ot CQ tm fa a ot oS 6 o Ba 6 ei 4 v4 Fle neo BY ey % oy ~ ® @ + oy 3 wt os mA 3 a a fea 3 Oo rf ft a S&S o uy Pe a a 3 . o (3 43 2S is % co @ sy wy a o 5 wm te a * be p os & sy x . 2 sh oO 43 Set ee 8 tt a4 ap OM ad Go 3S ih 3 9 we 54 Pe by i cs Bo c ef RET & % 3 wv a a uo . i '3 o u voy fe, ret vee} a ye. n Co nS " - . nt i * 1G em . Ch, nw z. "t ; U3 od @ Ad & i oe o Yet 4 ay % a sae ey Cs eat . od vod i yr os} '3 G "4 . a4 a } r at * qi x as $ hy m ¥ we A Ot Po QE 3 : 44 Ad v4 mt if wet a a w _ a wee eo wrt a fe 7 ot ce ve a sod oy ch i v 3s 4 a ov at 4 $4 AG Pky fx3 4 5 bi mr id 4 " 4 gt Sn aq. wn in wed Ad TS 4S i ry a i w mY ne wo 2 £ 03 KS ; ES bt o SS ad + ° cA 4 oO aS .} if 7 fa nl G ra rad 2 € oO ae q 43 ved + ae a & > os " hd ty : 4. te 4 a Se we o 4 o naft hg 4 ' hig + oO K ti sre} ' a o a aS 4 woe f a ed gt . 44 2 4D a ™ ws it rd a aa Ad & os * iB ad "1 : wey ve Or Qo » m4 ee) org & <3 " ™ co oe FS ee & . Dh oS - ta ae "4 = a ad " a as hd 6 who ; a> m3 G u ' cs th _ Gy hd 43 reed os as ce : on = rs oO a "a ; 2 3 w 2 oe a the a y 42 fe o gt iy Y os ood a) it ce wy 8 8 : cd mg o "h ee ® ot nt " : fa am os Ma ie) . oe io a ~ te be ¥3 " ; x £3 us 4-4 QD ue wD g . vet ie a t 4 seed x a . te 63 e uy Sade rind 3 hg tp . 6) mn ay th ty, 4 Gg tS " nt om @ rs) 4 "74 a 3 2 3) , mt ue e 7 ov ye B , ' tg Z i 5 UO bot Ud ke Ci B " x 4 wD eed Bet hay ee $ cs co ay Ld q io i, @ & os ng ng 5 a 3 bys - Gh @ . ms 4, bes, a @ a 44 j a SG a bed Cs ' & ey a ki gi ot Tee, red - ae) ct ose end 'n ot 44 i} Peg 3 bee "ef oa r ws . Ne C oof oa ©) a
-- ' mt a 3 ct od ¢ Ls 5 wged £ a a uy i a Boe sg " Ks as moo wy ' . w< ™ w a be a @ a bt ; oS a 9 cd oy $4 ; fs oe i "3 u £4 Bea BS 7% od @ C ° Cs fs 4 td Ch re ns Oo ay vet ay 3 _ "4 2 € . os AF Q ua + vot os 43 fe . i} a C a i . ard ort rp " a 'ch as : n ad wy rs ky a i 4 us eek as s Dy we ue of in ow ha os ° in , t $3 Se 3 mW é be GS Dg eB Gy ve fs " 3 ord ce a ' a Qs wv oy & bt "et a c O oe wy UR me » ah a ha, rh G UM Ex a weed Go eg Pt teat ue re a oa bd fis a 4 $4 oS BQ a & G Fre] 3 a ord Pe & a4 4 ced co) ted . af Me mn ae = és vd " a ee uw oO G ~ i ret bes aed 3 oye es ~ 43 By» Gs > o SG O wm wh Tn BO, e Ge :
vs x3 ra $3 + ref et rd G aa 54 ot wd "te cn bes ord u Ms a fs a : @ + 4 A 3 Qs 4s " " i) - o 8 i ad « : 5 7 Oo. 6 ye wu ord if on at us P a 4 a 44 Med = eat 3 . a er a mf og oB Oo 8 i i wy, ky by ta i} 4 ne ny A . . x k a > D a a C3 ip 4 € @ a et ms 43 2 ns oS & "3 "
- 4.3 nm x fet £ ro * ; 'o oO a mo ' ms i yi ' . > mo - c toy : ud x a m4 ; 4a 4 tC D in my ny wy ts wb un ort bi Bs ae te + ry ot "4 "4 * te, vet sod
4 a 4 an 43 1S: od at so baa = - 3 ¢ od 5 7 iD @ tf © a) @ ay i OG 4a A a 4 2 i eo % n ted Ry goed oo G rod xed it) 2 Ch Sa an ae ved *r 4 © bE re ; 3 «f Gi, 5 'x CR et a8 f As ae = i, ify i oy 4s & 53 oa Se bo © + et 3 é LLNS 2: @ / ch th wp om ¢ , 6 © wo» 68 6 & EB 4 Cc 8 8 8 ~ @ 4 rs) D 5 a ' $3 my OM a xy x rey LaNAa we hee ae hee om ' 3 £3 a G ; oa "35g a 3 wD / a Pe ; Co 3 } ved ry cs Oo gs Y @ a 13 od oa) I tS 4 wo oO " i whet 4 he 5 5 ee * va oe y ' * hd "se a 4 os ve . n oe. t o ' 8 Th i Ms ar ra ane eo 8 Mos gy 7 & 4 5 a a i + s oy 4 ' 3 Oh, 9) By a OG a wa we oO @ nes tl or oy ¢ C2, G) 4h sheik
t) we ht A L go of " ea a3 rt C "4 " iis "a © i " o 2 & r 3 x i oe ; i 3 3 fs o a oO CS un Ct Oo wt Me bt a 6 i Oo & ms ui got
-cf a vgs, BA gS ka 4 Ee @ a a a ¢ "et 6 BS 3 ut t n ? » & 4 of cad 5 rod ES aed / 1 it ce & a al 0 ws a 3 a "3 . gs . tha mn w® 3 ¢ o Of z wy " Fea 4 He) . £3 4 3 ds 2 & ee ary ' G3 . hes i 2 * " aA ga . ie c 4 bet q 44 ed . hea f go moog 9 8 as Sw "et ow BO gO & os , q 3 i a on cy a ws . v3 Ad e BS a 3 OU ie 3 oy "oO So gow ee Oe at GC GU gg 8 a ret ae rh tt D a . an A gt Ly ao 3) roe) yee hd oot 14 4 i) C 4 4 'ie 4.1 hee * , oe ved AE us e4 4 : os ay wa id 4 re iB * "3 a « 6 % of ; 5 3 "a a 4 M4 ort is , "pry % +4 i a oy oa 43 ed o * a bed Sa ts te o ai 0 % c te iD a #4 & vd O ea m ~ i 3 o "ed OQ ck ht a aad as @ Q iw 0 @ e "3 a Oo % o i 2 fp ba i ' : , " , 4 v- b 4 - i fo 3 Gi 4b cS ay @ a: v wo 3 3 ts a, wy u i o 3 £2 a w uo % 4 o i Ma m G ; # * " a 43 us rt Se G t % aA © L te tgs i c 2 ae 4 ss ved : ve in hi me A m4 " th z 4 ed ai KS wa ud t z © peed oo A 13 '. o ms ; WG 1 a + be Ae a 4 os 2 I ' ; is ee ey a eo «© ie > Oo eH SB ¢ 3 a) Fo o tht ; Eos o 43 ~ a G a bay 4 is ~ Q by G g 4 hi it oy Oy Wa ; bet ot o et, bet ad tg * Deg " o hy 4 oe a 3 ay GS a o z eo of oe a 4 fA ad <h @ ay w baer 4 fe 3 4 ; g re ot a cs ey - 4 a - g v "
D oo " mt " , ' @) . fe Oe fe o © .
4 wD 2 QO cs ag Q) 7 ay Oh , rs ® oo i 5, st os A UB a ES os, . or & ° . 74 Oo ; " Work RS a eh uy ued Ce eg oO x a rt oO ued " it in ut Pat ye) $4 4 or 5 aan . @ at ~ $3 pd seks Bw Cr ho wet ga 3 / 4 D Wh BA eet Os " aa fd '. GM f C 4 fe 5 2. aw . 4 fi Bd a oe 8 G 4.4 at m4 > p i ea ot & x ont D if a ot wed ard n
4) f f3 ot G x ce G fot ww ras} "o4 ao cy a, (hi ES 1g Le Yay we a " " wae A4272012 O wy 44 "ch Wy ® cS Years, £2 Cc it @ i $4 thd oS ay 43 Ae 37 G Ke 43 sre} nS * 4 is 4 :
YT BN pat mam whe ro wk aS is) 4{£).
Std th 3h ard be it st ow (Dr. Bhagwan Sahai) Member (A).
ingh} .
Member (7) (RUN.