Karnataka High Court
Commissioner Of Customs (Sea) vs M/S. Jay Engineering Works Limited on 13 April, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
IN THE HIGH CQEJRT OF KARNATAKA AT §3ai.e::i i':§":i:~: she 13"? (my <.>§Apr°E§, 1. V M §?>.£{E§SI§l§f€T Tm: H{'}I'€'BLE MR_.3;¥}}STIfIE ref ms H()N'BLE I£'{xi?;._J';1'IS?;'iCE.I§&iai;V*1.MAIIIMATH 4, <::s9'1i;gf§::. -1G~~£:if~:z.{}0'g3 A §31«:'rV»-I'£«:';:«:z\;{ <1 C€,}§11fE1i ;'SéSi5:'§1€E' Q5 C:§LI5~3i,€>.I1jE5%"-.fSL{$z'7£} C2.:zsE.:)§1:sijE<):,;£--se AV 3 ' Chexinaé v -_ ,HAp§:»e.E.E.:m1fi {By ':1 E--E";-1:'§pr:2?z.ss;'«1:§. Advzyitzzifl V _ é §'vE,.r" =j.aj§*' «:jFiZ:z":g,.§'1?mr_-',c=4z":"':";§7_? '€"v'<i2i'§{:-3 E.,.€':{§H "§7{.{T}, E-'3aE;'.ma.;;;2:1" '§'+:wa.r'§'1:€;hz"§",§ ~E--E3,-?c§é:-sfabzzzd M 58$ 03?' .,AE¥;::se=:;mz":{;E€:2.i..
{ET§j; f:?§::*§ ii .§32.iEkizéi'1'1é?-:*E§§'iE%f&'iZ."2'iI1, A:.§a='<';§<2ii.{:%} V ........ ..
\:gs§// '§.'}c"1i::'«.: CSTA tééaci §.1I'1r:i<;tr 5ssé3::'{i<}:'1 E.30A 0!' Elm _€_3L1sst{:ms gm, 1982 a1"isit1g out of <}2*ci«:>.r d31'::*ci 1215-0?'-2903 p«;:L$:~;€.d in A;_)pea.1 N«::>.8j'2{}O2 [E*"ir"1.ai O'1'<:§€r N£3.95Q,/O3, pr;2}E'ir_1(g_;_"[--:> (1) f0r;*11uZai.r3 {I16 s3'L1}3&.§ia2'}*;.ia1§ c;uest.i{>n of Easy stated 1;«%1¥::j<:s§;{¥:L; f{ii}" sgttt:
E21-S1518 the ordesr dates} 25;'O'?/2003 _p2.%-SS~3&?£'1 in 1£\I.".'];):'~'('-.J.':'}.l'Iga ; ' {Fhnfl Ckder Bkx95§/2003) pasfimfi m:<:ms:Ag; again gage» B~:'::1'1n::h, EE32:r1g;:{é;%.lc3:'€. J _ 'Fh}Z:-3; CS'f?x e::<>'mé:3§_§ an :":,>:'."" i1i::?:_£-1A§: .'£":{?[2»:z' i.1.*;§g; «. N; KUMAR J" deIi.ve::"ed i;:1"1e f"::§Q_wi11g:" ._ ' ' M JUn&E§NTg* 'i."'his apgzseai is ;:sv:#:€.§;*:;*:_z"r&%c§A E:=§;A Ehfj. .;E~§€:Vc*r1:.;<3 iihé-21.1engi'11g the <>':"ci6:" 1f):1$So!i %3y {Kg-?,?"'T1;i'bi:1'E1£?.L'hiiifliifiih E1213 grzizfieéd ihe I'€1i€§§~ 1,0 {he-% ass%v:':s§:=;--r:é £'1*<:§:§:f}=:t;i3;:1§€%:%_§ {>f."' <:i1si.<;:";:s <iuI':3: on Ehczé 'ijassig 91' {he :1£}i.§ifi:?21%,'i.£)E:'_ E\§r)V,2V€3'4,./""';',7? '7.}i»-- E91-31 1\2'Ez1}-* IQQZ gmd S':1bs:%q'2.:e%:'2€' i'2<3"€.§f;i{t:1':.§'jf:ms~:s, 'E":"i%'.:::.m21§ hzm heid Ehai. 1.2%": E1233 V."~,§?i§_E1;V§7§~}E:€f(§»-,""E13?f;.E'Ef;? ::«{5fi'éi§§€'i0§'1$ {sf 'Lime 11{>iifi{:z:ai:im:'1 N03, ,?;@4»/92;'. €:35},}"*§3E§ 95 .>;3_n{'E %i:h1.:;=s E16 isézs 3:13;' Eézibie 'L0 §ji:s3.3z <:L1.s.~;Ee::1'1.ss " 3:3; :.h<§ 'E7'2-'fi3:,;1'12'2E§ ax-':¥:::Z<T:}:"z. £5; <:§':2':§§m1g_§<:+{i "in. :§'.:§;<; 2:_;3§.§£:z1E. \ {f'i**a,1?;4f§,=*.71.z;:'1{i--é?%i;-- €}=}f::.c"-: £7%..:s:»";'i.m":'1s:; ziirt, .§.§}62 zzndaézr 2i'.h<% 2'ifa:3I'f3SE1i€§ :1{3i.'f2--"%{:22;v:iE{3z§:3': 1.1;. is; élm {'f£}E'§"{i{?§.i'.';€iff:§E3 Q? Ehtf Szaid EE2*;<:§§:1g_I§ 2"'£3<:<};"'{i€%d. KM 2' 'i"i':<3:"€§'c):'cx fhfi? q:4:<:>:se;E§z;:1'1 t.If'::211, .21ri'$€% far 0:;r1:¥;.§;ci:%r;2:1.i«:>n in {:h.i.s appeai is:
W%2<3£"E2er {he z';'2{:is3rprez"'a{ic>:'i. }'){{"_£§i'£"£;?,},. I the 'I'ri!r;:mr:1.!. on 5:11;: '€Ij'i";'~:~"£--?§3Ci;' (i _ {}*'z;V§~¢;;;> ' n.::¥Zz_'f'€c?af;{0r'2.s is pr:)pe3r ano£;.__ §'h.;;>" T Z emiziecl Era ::>',\;{:%z'r?;[3!.i<>z'2fium ;;3a§;In_é:t? of {j¢.z;;§r}Q:%1é duly' in -- * V' ' " "
3, This 2-xppeal. ire f1A?V<:=ci.. "L',:r1éi<%r S::r{?i;§'x3.z1..vvf£8G of Line i::L£E5§.OI"§"iS".}'3s;(i--';... "E9621:".'£11é:»9£1-z1Vci 0{:é;§'tfi013 st: umwszl i"z:ll.<:: withizé the .V ' 'V .1 ,_. an o'rr:E{*:z' nziexiiixlg', am.ong :";1e21::§n"§;%_ (if i.E'1=:%_ VE,x¥{")i?{i§S',. {€1§ (>339? £.2}i:i.1g_,';';t«, 't';::?% "£.1"1gEt d§:é?;f»33*i1231z2afim'1. 0? 331},-* {;:.:€&'-3§.iu:};": haw-izfzgg 3. ~ V. «_ :'<:%E2}:E.:{'.i>:1 _'i.é:s Ehfif :"°eé{E;a:s .<:;_§_"__{3;u€:}»-* €321" €X(E'§S5€ or Eta {he vaiuczz HE' 5;-§{)G€}E§ fin" p_a.i"§'*;2{>ss~:$".A:}:£f_ °a:;s;€sssm.@;'1i':'*. '§'i':€::°e§2>1'§:: ihiés Ccmri has-: :35; _; :'.s:f"i:§~:€E'§<:i..I1€3:5é"E5 :::§'iéé:t:"%.2?gi':'T2 {his a;§§)<::ai.'§ mlcissz' Se:':£:i{3;'1 .E3Q»E {'1}? 'ih{-3.
--V :'4k<?:i':.. ;:i.§~; "§'v";:g*.§i{'i V§:=,:g '£'.'n;Is.~; (7/<'>:.3:"'E. is: {£16 (22135? {iii C3{}f;¥_Z¥f_§SSf{}P£E§£'E OF éi::e:T:s,%f;:22z3§';: :~:X::;s;:: .EF§';fi£:gi1%E{::;;%'?§.EfJ'{}}F€E(£f §>,%«:*:"';2:9c:E--z:§Msg:Az5 E,1?"£L?,5 2;.-1 %§?f§;"{{5;f'€}? :::Ei3;§:*:<:::~'-,:€=<T3; 93'3" gm E}§<€}:'}é.2{}§€} am} the $a:i{:'z sf;u:és'§:":.§<:>:'": E aw' @335 wt 4 £3211:-'<=r E0 be z1z:ij1.1€.ii(:%21i"ee:§ $3}; £136 z'&p€:>i {I<)1.1§"t, 1.1:1ci«:%;" S¢:e::t.i{>1'1 130~E§ sf 'tiny: Cusi.«:>r;1s+.a ;~'xr;.:[..sa. H362.' .§"E<~::3<::<: z--'i}'}}'}€fai {mi mg-1}:i.f_;1'i:'§a1't3}<::. }"s.£:a?01'{ii13.g1js_,.2 we passsa 1.31:? f()U(}\':~'§E'}§,; ordex': Appeal? is I'€fj€(',§.ff:d 213; £291 I1::a1i.:'1Ai:;1;'"2':aI::1::f'"Ei2f§$ea?e¥'e;*; _1ir;_e;~'z:,3,:*. I'e:Sr31*v€£1 to the E4i<%v<3I11.1e €10 }_):"ei'{~::' i2'.:';"1--.;éi[J=§§'L?£1§'--.1.i'}iT£déf"~-$€3;i'i.i.GZ} 13$-E 05:119. C:ssi0r1'1s Am. 1962..__'L'c3 't',1r1Vé: ._sk'§:c>x C:e">L {r1{.v.4_V O§'fi{:e:~: is ::1i.re<:I;e:cI_,_ :0 :«e>:,._:.;:':£~._'i:1rx~:;:» ::e1"t.i'i?i':{i cg<pEe.:'-3 01" the @3"c'ie:'s pz'c3ci'u<:€»:<:L M} ifzeffiéé p21:3=§'.:1'1%::'11.; ':C{ ';}r'€f.?c%;' {Erie appea}. "*7, g 3"
$3 'I .....
fiififiég »» . V nu