Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Saramma Kathirvelu vs M/O Defence on 15 February, 2019
sh epnbennentre eset:
)
i OA No 882014
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAT BENCH, MUMBAT
Original Application No. 85/2014
Re
zc
this the |? day of bebe . 281s
CORAM:~ HON'BLE R.VIJAYRUMAR., MEMBER {3}
Smt. Saramma Kathirvelu, Wife of late Shri. k&.
evedu (Ex-Machinist}; aged abouh G7 years,
i t of Flat No. 202, JayaswpnaBbldg., PlotNo.25,
Wimeco Goolety Ambernath(E}, Dist. Thane-421501}).
.. Applicant
(By Advecate Shri K.M.Prabhakaran)}
Ve.
*~ PENI y mom y a {tc} ~ wR em: een, + "ay M4 5
L. UNTON OF INDIA (through) Fhe Secretary, Ministry
ae Dade & } i a an aE Ta ot ; - mph i
of Defence, Satth Black, Govt. of India, New Delhi
£16003
ak AES
> om ~ * "9 ~ ane ; ary a4 we =
2.The Chairman, Ordnance Factory Hoard) Ministry of
ee at ~ £ a 2 tH Sard ~ baie 3 or Varnes ee
Defence, Gove.of India LOA,Bose Road, Rolkatta-
VOGSOL.
2.The General Manager,Machine Tool Prototype Factory,
Ambernath-42 1502. ; ...RESPONDENTS
iBy Advocate Shri V.S.Masurkar}
Reserved on :- 28.01.2019
Pronounced oni~ jf. 02° et
ORDER
R. Virtaykumar, Member {A} miler section 19 af the Administrative Tripunal Act, ZO ¢ Ye = a = tO = one y + > L985 seeking the Following reliefs:
ve wT = 34 5 te &} That Respondents be directed te ws * 4+ oe i+ a oy, = grant cisabiiity/family pen Sion in addition , ~ on = nt ta the requiar family pension, 4 Ta wy te +. ~ me OO + hb, % =
3) That the cost af this application be ~ 3 ps.
Da by the Respondents.
ae . 2 vi 4 43 Ch pes 4 3 Hed ft ded c a on bs o © 2 a 5 @ B i oe a te Cy a} ing cA a re) 6 it i Be "se had ms ag mT saa & - - a - ig *% oe "A a 9 " ae G ef e Y a as 3 " . w o aad . a a -_ me 4 a4 @ @ i "7 Sa 4 n @ os ed a 5 7 Bot Be wy 8S 6 8& & tow a8 a 3 E 3s OS Be Bg a "Oh wy ot is o ry My a 3 ro 3 Oh 4 Bee Ess 7 Qa a i} wo eS ~ Pe oA # 4 Os C wn - + 2 ht ~ ches os mn 3 @ * eon BA " on Mm % be beg wo ty on a I od , oS + bw beta td gt ron 3 7 ap B a5 z © Ht : Pa w ved - gn : wv oj im ww B Ls jon a ood ot te td a sf ot ay e 44 @ wD 4 , Fe mo ved 23 OG wy ey us e sc bi oy u a aed » ro 4 a pos ver * ft ibe <eF he io 2 } o ce ae 3 ed a re es a ne & a ee o % ™ Mo w a e w ke a YD ae i rea ai " y ue vt a 4 + ¢ a _ . ts] "th oe ay i . cae Oy es a a o rat we 2 a Bk | o 8 ° 3 :
r * * % 53 thy < apd 42 . id ved uu q& aA w et Oo : " ' in od "cs 4 i * C 2 pod ~ Be x Hs = me a co J fee £ ved ro) e £Y pa : oe) wa 2 be "4 hed wy a ws . . GS m4 a ie 4 ved "Cs & Ms, °4 a i s) we ry i 44 @ "
a) 2 @ Bort a ~ 4 3 Z "4 2 "4 ' ' SF 9 : : ' SB 8 BG Se mB Boom & G6 od moe od y 5 Ps wpe. f one ot 1h te ae (05 4 oc v8 wt 2 Bw 5 . § 8 C 5.4 a co 3 fas @ 3 O ui ; n Aa t 3 2 QB a 4 wv "omy hea o en $4 w te wd wea é 4 bed ay is oy rn 4 Lt ve "x @ ot by oO send A, 3 0] "7h of His) .
fe & @ 4 A 4 o gD iD & =m Dae wy ~ ay CU MO os veh Sa Hi we 8 ans, e 'es 'et : Met © . e € g @ 2 8 Pg 8 4 6 FS y PF a eas a od « mS a an G i ort * fa & be rst "4 Z "s ws 4a / ; ved 42 wt o a ao it BG 4g 6 9 ¢ sg @ a "4 a 4 6 2 a G o it it fae Ore ow x oe os o we ss fy £25 oh a ~ So a 4 He 4 43 sed (ol ; a Oi re veo gO Q ord a e GG & » ca) a oe bss oda oe nr hed & be @ ee in © o bed 5 or res! Hp, tei r; ned boo $8 & rr 4 ~t Pa " ro on " hd a , w ; si ea Ad ne 44 . au c 7 "S ~ as "
5 ge 2 oT co vt 4 vd * ce re oe - nh a S 20 ed > vt hei i rd od 5 rok a "eS 34 s 6 ore } a aA 43 is) o of @ ty 6] a Q Q "3 o a cs . aes G . ad ord * *} 3 ot «3 wpe we ved a + > oD es os t = oe ; ° i & Th ey "rd & #3 ' a & vay ao C% ot seed pad 7 ~ ; C ri 3 i "3 wn am * of P : ie a 5 Lon ta 5) ws % ~ to pan apt ed they Gh OnE i vee @ Ae w iD rt Ao ad o oe f i : ae 7 a 3 oy ' ko . y ryt it yt "oe aed hea ip) ks a] a %S fc uo a * on (EIT E XE a nye ain Seases pic} awnige BA co 3 x a a cont aye Ww ct reed hed ce wv mB "Category 'B! "
(er) sick uy at Mt e Rou + Bec Hh wW TLSS aqows z Ww Family pension - for catego x VY a re Me w x & LL et x LF S033 mea Sel a os phen, een Kes i183 feet Q & @ ont ie = € GELTAL <3 & % a ne under categories B and C III Disability Pension - for cases covered ae CaN SOY dG ie 4a aS w? ot "3 = j "
a : 4 é z 2 ' od i * ot . aed 2 2 GB oO 8 D ' a os a OD i Sat 7 @ is a '5 ov oS 49 & 8 8 4 ea Go « . " aa ; ad ed i at a ¥ . 4 a "
a Ge 2 gOS 4 vy 3 oS O % , x ; a rd o oO i " : of Co & Px u "4 a 4 . ad hy vel + < et S oe a & ot <r"
ey aod . ose 43 {g a ae Bo Pr i c ord w 2 od iB a Sey tng , a DU ved OE re 2 £3, a Sone 4 45 G ws 43 'bef 4a My 4 ay " ot 3 Oy ty HOw Oo o i oe 86 Oo. be % 8 3 28 ao Bo rs gy i a a a a oS abe =, i oes x - veged : wD o 43 we os wo oe A qt o a 88 ge 3 Go ee ed SG 8 ge me gy Be OG aol ' rt 3 4 " ; 5 & is t 4 'i i ie Q eet . Jann ' 4 pet fee r " Kh ke m8 Ba gy oa a i co 3) - of rel "yy et BY aah RS ge vt o i ue J or we ey ° ey . ol 4 Zz © 9 £5 ce & 'Ss a mM
- go tt he wm Fs =e i ek " . Be oc te 4 we. acd 5 " G ry vd a 4 OB et HE es OO ; 2 cp me i 'th " 3 : ~ os DA es he a eG oe os bea @ as al cy Ad oa oi 2 " 3 eee? ; " i : 4 ost et in ' nied 43 ed 4 wh x wy oo we a he oi ver} ~ © os 7) me Ht '5 - "4 "4 g voss 4 3 4 i ty a Go eed oe 2 if ma Be ae 5 9 Tow & . Go om BE ( #8 ' we re ih za Mg Pe ope ¥ vy on Pde ag BS " BBB eo ge s 2 8 _ re Ah Ae 0 a a R ; w ° on es ica) BE eg OS at Qo 5 cm a on 0 3 * eS Cha 1) C f od 4 chet % < 4 a4 4 " to " 4 wi & ee Ss oa i i ed oO ee . ia & 3 wy oy 0 v4 a 44 GS fe a i's) : (3 ar fet a4 . ry Bz] acd % e ao a & Pat * o 5 bos on "4 a be a Gs bh Wy Pe ; i ad o ted # . & 6 Q be Pe re a K ws peg Be 2B sh 3 ee . et 2 c £} a yey iG a we 3.0 yy eo Oo ER 53 m a ai mo ea a os we es a ort Oo 9 43 @ 3) vet 4; od , o 6 o if jot @ " Be vt w w Our ge ka ET a D os 2 { & ' » a 14 c 4 as isi ' wy Gh bo Ea vt c ; £2, ' 43 a et 4a ma vod
2) rh , fe £ + x ' C3 5 . Ct 4 4 pw con BD Fe Ks @ ne . a4 x ba oO a Go ra} 7) | ee CN Abe OE ct Tr i iB Ba Gy ie O oy ved w@ sy aa 4 5 Go "
et ower BS we ie a j Cy ond : 42 td * ret of 5 x f bel a ma 44 ra a i by ms 4. i io sed i Q 4 ; a * . "rh 4 wo oe a 4 8 ge g ee ew Bs S a Bo ae oo ry oe - eo Pom B ind o mM woo mM ~ ove ei 4 on 7 a 4.3 ne i) gb Q Mt w & So 3 Q ne 3 ' a re Q Ld os ; i A ; ! z he iy } & . Of A . i iD bea So ORs a 5 c cs ;
uw a ry oe " oy A YL 4d He oD oe * on ue eu " <i rr @ wo % ) ve cg g u io GON fe oS x wi S 2 fe ° i oS c a -- "x4 + a A us aw 4d aed dy Go beg di fod nt a * hee * Lf Qo D 5 wy a4 cS ta 4 ic wd 4 a i a gE "Ey eo be ay 8 vt , ih oF G Me a m Hg & B i $3 eg " a S Oo, GS wgy mi. ia rs ~ = . ce os o4 ' ey m A ed i ¢ 1 uber vont 4 3 " G e o es way FG a ae Bt @ ae he ' DB v "
SB wm Pow oo Fe a ¢ OO mG ee a £3 i am 4 0 's e 6 % a Bh ann , we " gO @ & wB ea wt ay ica] "> v4 oe 2 6) u goo * n rr ig "ea gL Crd 2 3 a " ¢ gp 4 ee gg AD an a 4 cs e ved . "4 eos va ey aed 7 4 rei) ut ' w teh age + toa an ses Cy Af gs ba ofA he o } a oF ey 4 7 is "gy ot : ct ty ut ; = oe at aed oid seh Ny ay hel Sa 3 ah ka o zi rales oh gO ay ue 45 5 ai ST "
sed A ig Boe jn oy o . < Cw i) or a 3p 3 a 3 woo B = <3 co ak fea oa a Bn Rad a oO a i Br Ned is El @ wa - . wD Sa oof c D 4 id Sa Pa & ty ~ " mT et & "a B gz on & abo a} nw @ a 8 2 a pe Oo dbo ay a a rw) 5 bed vend fo ER Cd vd 4 a oi mB . i. tet wy be Gj cs "Ch & ns, a o Qe o gt iD fs hy wt o o oe aa ue = f be us "4 " ra oh oe ied > ce Ch } 4 4 ot Pe 5 é ey Sk 4 my ay a} '¢ a5 ey oo © » a 4 oe ft $a & .
" . or ~ 4 te ~ vs ; wd t 4 ™ * F) oret wt @ Ch "
® a eo. iS me OS 4 ~ « H a aa Ge "co 5 ~ an oi 7 8D a C ™ os % " my fea ay a ed 58] ea Ch . : a hed S oT % oe MY Fi :4 i we oe Sh : | et EM + @ os " Gs a ae ~ re FL yes & hus ¥ ey no "S % See aa t wa . 4A wd . 4 ¥ fe = vel ed ay wt ep ® yd . no Oo . 5 ~ 3 od es & We sed o 9 2 a 42 ° Dua dt i et o i Cos 24 t% * ot eet so ree ot ai al eat road 4 feed wn ht {3 ee oa pel 4 Lt Lt a 1G om ! Ss ' mY e ao a Aad ja a) a"
12 RL, @ a) cy he Sh rps Me ; e my es , ie' ws a 4 os os 's "
: ws 44 G we Ae mc 4 bs, 3 rah me MA ome le QB ot aged dea oe hed 2 rat pe ae] 1 tad Fs 3 OR 44 a Re et " re 8 o 4 ved o a « o @ ct on ~ oe "
" uh ae; ms red Up ve "4 ay i im mG % ae 4 iD thy @ % ed e re v a 2 Cr G ech BD . 3 ats "3 i ie soo $2, hy reed G . a eat oy "4 "¢ 4 ' mo ~ 4
9. & g Oo ws wt : ed a tea to ot ot Ch By et .. = ox by 5 a & th oe LS a pa wt US a SS Se | gy = wt SS os Rid a 23 te + wt 6 ea Unien of India & Ors., veed An r seal 3 ved ie Mh a fot on In wd 1 "A i of Union ve Kamiesh Devi x at or iy day ext mark idm 7 oe nO rood @ m3 are wae & i t COr ort Tay, od Nar La & Ors. v .
F Ind RiLOMm & D hd a be au pot ha OD Pry > ingh , Dev § Singh & a ewd bee, od y Lf v. Ravinder Kumar, i & Ors.
ct "ri S fa 4 tha a a 9 g i eS mg ce;
mf x Gi wo 2 oa oe bs WS a yoke nce ny é nave Gis ant o.835/2 POX OA X i Nt he ' < EMO E .
se wSyc a by + EO ae Ww gravat aI wk et i, Lm oe > ent =} PAINS & A a ederi by 4 Sea y ende Ne nt o Mew f i c OF ~, 8 t a a fal oes ag wrk fess te & oe Ros be et LANA ae ey ak g x 'e 3 fae it a OND, Nt nsel Ad 3 ty & Aa heduds Pas OQ W3 seef go oes 43 lity Pension for Categories bi ¥ Disa We at PROS 23.
& Pas Ae ae mot EARS bed it o oc an aoe SOR ESS SES a ms % a
-
XQ ae oe bee ~ GBA 3) @ a wa 3 4 4 ae tO 3 sas 3 ' i : © a ~ :
be fa ty ~ oO + Pes ha ok a, od ied ' hs ~ @& « {3 o c ; ay o a wo wen AG "i g coe Be v ' "i wD 3 ra ii sy GO & BG aR ® "f x?
tees
- . ai ch, 3 " OQ +3 Oop i o sm HAS.
Ag re e Bn AY rok ery ons Gon Or eg ort te ed &3.
™ 3 a bed OD % Ra i fs ord O. es taeewaree itedeee:
uy wat C93 ed G } o D 43 i ~ oo BD 2 Bos 9 4 . on Au rm o $3 4.3 ae 8 Bo de 2 os) oF or Fea bed 4 q} oO Ch £ C a = * 2 Q Eo Pp ved ., '4 - oy bet w D RQ "4 "5 Ww ud wo . mw a n c we os , a - ok os ree rd 4 ~ i a cS Ae yo C : sais ~ wD be} ad , oy ci BB innermost! Fh Bos ae eee Nh i - . ° a £4 = " i eb a i ae WS ~~ ree we ed a La shed i) ree) = --s 3 ", " i & it 4 m ws So oo a a we me peed "ot ee o has oy , wo o oy me rho or a , a m3 fe wo an meh MEMBER (A) wD 44 LE a , erst oe a 2 ry g tg 2 he eo re cn 8 et (R.VIPAYR io or peat 3 eS is : a 2 ba om ru ao be . 4 rs @ . Ey a w " of wa oo & ; & it Cs "nt we ad i veh hed Ad ices US ay ey -
By ag ee poet NA . ve Fees 424 @ Gh 3 U3 oh cS word y oD % a me An 4 eed eyed oe ae hed wo ob AA ty bea nee, a co fey i ce aes tae uw o 2 ~ :
a o in o ay « iD, % pa oa ot oi Boor eG ct by ~ aed 1G a ae Ba @ « a 2 OG & gt 2 4 4 a? 4 2, iB 3 pe bd ot 4 ba ES es seed ha wend 5 fet c Oo a" Jn Q @ iS is % o ' .
"Fe ' = ee 4 i 3G Ss Meat so 4s Mm LB QO D : ety