Karnataka High Court
Smt Suhasini W/O Sidhalingeshwar ... vs Shri Nagaraj Mallikarjun Chonnad on 10 April, 2012
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, Ravi Malimath
E13? 'SHE fiififi SQEIRT QF KéR§§A'§.s.%§£é CERCUET EERCH KI' EHARWAE rms EAY THE 20%: 9.3.? 3? ApR:L_gb:. 2f ~ PRESENT THE HCBPBLE MR. JUSTICE 7:'«:;':.; "1§£Ab:gi::¢A:#:§:'V" T_
TI-IE I-ZQITBLE MR. JIESTICE iaaiéz Mggimafisx M,F,A.N§Q216£f§'«?2flO9 gmvi J_ BETWEEN ;
L 33:11:. Suhassini Wig. SifiZha1'§r:g63h%afa§ ' §--{a:npan:1a<:ar, Age: 24 ysafsg' ' " _ V _ £3263: HGuS€hQ§§..E£"i:1.E;"§i_}- Z: "
r"€;'<:». Chikadi, Tq: C;j.i:':ZI£_<.G<ii;« _ 3151:; Be2gaL:§;r€. V' 2, Kama? S;fG. §§ié%za}i:gg'€.$E12zz}a%:"Vvw'- E~§atnpa::navar;2'i.g5: 5'3y$z§3fs,'«_ ' Oats: N2;};__R;'--:3; Qhizgssfdgz * ' -- Ta; Chiks-"ii, §}i$::'BV:e§a§_v1:§:."'~._'_ z%§§~:3§a:1i ééérzg :
Pie £3 .'f€§}:"§S€§3{€{§' by 3&3 , i'€at1:':*gi gzgarégéarz é.g".'a§;::::E£am %§(}a§ $3;
' \..
fi§8.£1Efi£vz3.:f§f3 Ag:§:.~ 4?? ysarsg if)c_c:E-{_::use3:.s:%Er§ 2a;{::>:'%<§ Rf :>.{"ZZ%:§E::::&§g Tag: '{§%2iE<;od:é} {LEE-§+;:: Bsigaizzzz;
2 vffiawage Efai>'eraxja.S§;?j_Cn $E:a&3i<::s%:a.:*a§§a ' ¥». Sr: §§:a;::;;*%E<:$§*::a§;_::a Sfeg C3a.:a:1r:35.»%ra§2§a E%'8z:'::;35_n:i1a¥a:; figs: 58 yeays, ..%3<:c>: 1%-:'.§,&§ Riga}, Chiézzsdi T 2§'q:"::'i?:i§.Z§<a§é§ iéisét Beégaum. , g;§y?s::;,gs,§a:i: and §.':f,?a{:ar, z5a@i¥3,,} m;%i'3?ELi,5i?€'E'§ "<5 §%BI'D:
Eu $31522, Efagargg Eafiéikarjzin fiéxeginaefi figs: 28 jgeays, 00%;: 5533133633?
R50, 338.2% Gail; Chikedi} 'E'q: Chfizcéag Bis': B<:égau;m§ 25 T5516 Evianagéig The Nsw Ezisiia Ezzszzrance iloiidw Efsivisienai Qfége, Eeigaumé .HR§§?§§§E§?$ {E}? SE: Sachin 3; Magaéum, £5§4?:;~~§0f R3; 32% _gRE:;:fi駧t:;§; Advg' 2%: 32%. Eajashekhar S. z'§ra:1§§ §§dé%';L; R2} This appea: is €::ec;.;;:;siey'Se¢:§:;n ':-trifsggg af Iva!' Asa, E988 agagémé; the judgment a:::%..§a$:'zaz£i_::£g;.';:::»:€ 4;:-:"i;v€}?"L2;G§8 §assed in EXIEVC NG.938f2€}§5 0:2 ths 511$ :35 :56 Ei=:;:':?T§E3_ C:v_2éJ1gdge {$213213 ami édditiezzai E':fEAC'F,,, §hii{odi_,V_fpa;:i:Ej;*._agiowifxg {Em 'céaim gaetitiazz Eb:
$G§'l'1§€;?1Sa'EiO:'i anévséekinig $z:h?2g::c§::2é1'>Lf: af éL;:2fi§€:1$a':2'§:: sic, TEE;§@€Q§x£fifig@§fb:flfi§§a§3K£bMfiflJUNATH3§% fieiiirered, ihé' f€}§§.}"*'{'*f~":§3§f'V" ' Ygfiggmgyf '§'§:«€: g;§.a;m.a,;:e.:V§;j_*'§::' =§\Eof§38f2{}€i§ an 1:325 $5 $316 éiiivéé --,§udg€4"':f§§;?%::;§ a[::,{§"éé&ii%o::a§ §x:EAC"EI; Chikkadé :"§8Jf€ '"~._§§€:.§ sfaé b%:*§::'"* z":.G'£ gaiisééed Wzitim {E36 CGECE sngaiies _ ¢ _g§ g 9 %g:af::i»e5:"v-v.:%3.V":%:é§33 by 'ilzfi gzgégmsgzi ans? a'%3£?E'§ e:§af:€d 2:§§i:§§$fI ° j '' "?§:a§3.=::§$ ihés sags are as h€r'§u:2{:§s:": _?;f§aé:"r:a:2?; ?*~§$.3. 53 "E316 wiziexzsg sséaiizzazzt R8,? is $25 , zgéisar 392:1; aiaézzzazgiz §'--£:2$':':2 33351 5% are {E36 agfié gfigrsfiis 3? 93:5 \\ 2% .3 %%& E 3 CM Shééhaiéfigsshwaf W333 was & $235596 :35 Qhéééaéé aizéi zgnaémg
3 rszaéi aim 'éfiiggissaie msdésai 33:9; ané 933:3 bE.2$3:f1€SS sf cgmpuifir gtegyamming and §j'"£8.:"::fi€"$'i'€%_:$".S:i$€} p§:*s<>:18£i§; Su§€:"vé$i::g the famiijg ag:f;}::L1E:L:ré}"{3:3:_"3.§}3.';2.§{3-S, u ha was psoceedizzg ffém Ch§kod_é.'»,:<);';%;g::a;5§:a"~:é:':1§.i§.%§2L"--~::::7T.a fzempa Era): béariag Ne3.KA~23;}'C'.:j9GfiG ;-.. E?%'§'z€::zT' traxx ' 1263;: Bhavané Msitur vEE.'iiC--3:€ 3'?3?§ with 3::
aacidezizz: daze :0 head%:_§fi':*c;Q};§%s§s:;§5: u '?:err:§;>a $32}: and T,Sf§',C. has beajfizzg was sfiifiafi to haspitai and T326 Cieceaserci was 38 ységs heider 2:: somputer sci«:"r1c§VVV€'5'::{"1V«fi1"3'il'::f:f,§.V an i:(:C§m€ 1:313: 38368866. W3,3za1.$'{>' E§::*;E:*1§VV:§;%:,?j¢;i~::';'y;$'§'«,,:§E':»i:"'agricuitzzraé Eaziziis gtaraééng in {he 33316 G? §a:i<:€r."- '§'E%x:: '§§€b:,mal cezzgiésreé '{§f}€ éncame T335' C§,._i3-f3{':&§§€§ af "3R'5'S;§;f?3?23€} per azzrmgm 33:3 iiaézzczimg _":;'"3?i?""?;§:2:is;:*ééA.§3':;3 ;a=3:§$0:25zE €X§§1'§Sé?;'S 'W§§:";Q"i.Ei C83?2$is'i€E'"§?2g iéae afgyészgétégfgzé émcgmg &§:3S€$$€':§ 83$ EGSS Q? §€§£EE§;§3E'EC}/' 3.:
xR:~;.7}é%~ 23:3 by a§pEy§:;:g maiiigééez 95 £361 E; 322322 {:25 " §~*ii3,eVE$';'§E§.}?\};5» is a23:§::*:§€:§§ égwazfis $935 $5 €Q§'ES§Z"€§":E§I': is f»fi31,E1"}g ""§:é;'é<?,§2ax* gfid Rs;.iZi;'3,§£}§/L '§£}K3§a§C§S 3933 9? fave 5426 &ff€€'§1:€}§E ta 3 "m:e*gtrs $2» {E28 miner 323:3} §5,x2§Ca§§®f» iawarég 3:233 0%' sséais 332$: §s>§2§S{}§,f~ tawariés mfiéiacaé. €X@€§éiEaf€§ éow 5:313 téanggzeriatian sf éeaé bed}; {mm Ezaééfi . Rs.5,$€iQ;'- iawarés fuzzaszzaifi §X§fiE1Sf3S. in .éi§E"' '"I'i:"§1i':.;.2:2af"' awazfisdl 33:33 Qempsngatésn gf Rs,v8,8-ig?%%2;'} at,::T<'i §és;f}c--:j "£26 tsiaé Court haying sems i:G7i:h€ :;T§":r1-§_:E'V'L'aSi';iG:":v §§i.§ii.._iZ3§;€%'€ is, L saisuieatéen ezma m@di§i€d: téfi}ai=v«.V'.V.:2r¢;:?;s_&:"€,§V" _§ §.5;51%58%;'~. Bsing ma': gaéigfied 3":E':s=<:f'§'1A'*v;--:_§§;i:1€ agpeaé; is féiéié fa}? szzizancamfing H V V . » 3% 4». """ H fgéflé'}:§.f;:§Qf}T;€i 'C§f'{£318-.,§5§é3;€8;S¢3fi fzszzz {E26 ::1€<:iiaai *5"
«,2 stare 3:92;' £3: E19 trig: Cauf: fiié :19: C{}f§S§fi€3Z"'€3é E236 agriczgétuzai §';a.c:é:::si;;:§j=g an $36 grszzné iha: rezzsnzzs ':'€<:@:'~;:§$7 532% $f:gt':é§;r2g '£5 33326 91:" P'%Xf.i fa.i:h.€3: G5 ihs %ii::<:§i€a::€é§.. '%i5h$:: ihe §;s€a:ase§ was mzijg am: ta E??? Ev as Earig :13 ';:2.'€*:V$:s*V..;§3'".a§%x;@§ ihe ffivfiflilfi E'€€:Q".€'{§S E?%?§";i§§ afawajgrg '! s:.2J:'i'::? igégmea <2? :35 father 2:311:23 iézezxs is a §8.Z°§§'{§{}Z'E.. 326 .A E», €x'::"a€';$ 32% S§8.§'E§§fEg iéiaa 323.32% :35 faihsr aazzrzst 33$ 3; _ is :'§j&:<:é: {Eris séaim 05 31% e:§,aé:::ai'::;$. Z?'%:§%:'§f@:'€§ visa 9.36 a §::fI{r:é: aréasar :33: 3:56:23 if via §Z0§':S$I§§tE3§ E335 $E,i§§Z'§°V§$i:%'§':--*' ethargagg , CM 332% minimum ifzéiéfléfi fmzzx {E36 agriczgkzérai Eazzds aoggia' me: bfi 353$ 'shag'; Es'33G§8g'~ 963" math 533:3: Rs.3§,Q§{i%'.:"'§€r angrzum. Ceizsicéering {he agziczziizgral §.f1'£€G§fEE€ aggai :§;é~§.é*:€c§:;$ * {mm the msdical @1956? £326 §:1c<:::'2:;:3_a § Lie d3éé'2E.3«§_:1. C%;:11i<,% nix: VV bfi 353$ zhafa Rs.2,}G,€%i3€§/'~ gs? a:'2.3:12.::_j:°':; ..*Ex%:3:3"~€f%s,zé' R$,3$§8{}§/~» tewardg the ir1{*i§2::i__€ iax;-..n€: é:1é:'§f:;§'v«ax;%::;:3§C1 bsv Rs¢1?8€%,G§€}/» per 3.1222333}. };1m}cE:,' :5 <:§:§7':afe§ 4%uc: 331% {ma-rarés his gsrserzai §:f'§€p€iE§£f}C§«' Wgzfizfz 7:26 R33 E,2G,Q8§;f 9%: _ his age éy f{3§QW'}:T:ig £16 Saris. Eferma asaci aihem gfjs regartaé in AIR '.2089 SC bf? a§<:>pi.::3& and ihersfbre 33:6 Eissg fi's.::;:saz::§,Ve5:%;.%;f3; 2%23t:;£':i '€36 R:$§2Q£~@§{}{}iZé'f ~, Er: zsfidiiéézz is £322.: Q§ai§{*§;;e;,:*;:V.:é;:"5"-::t:"2§§%:E§§ far a 8131:: GE Es.4§~£Z::C%§{}/- V' v.:esz;*ar§s;i,_'-E.a3§;3A. 35 €€};?;'§§'éE"5{§§.11'E1} RszE2,{}%@;'3~ iawarég zzéeéicai ;e::';3§:i33é;:4..&Va::vA':2s,%}f}::§d6é. §§' 2:326 '"§'"':é?3z.2;2*:aE 3515: ?;$e35}$S§/1 Was axisazfiiéii by {ES 3 :
25229232463 :raf:g.;3sr:a:é@z: £5" égaé §€}{§}?' {$55123 finds £33 Qézééééio 2 "E" '
4 1.
:'§b'z3;§E&§.
,f»%~/' 5' ?§3:,z;$} £3': 3% daimanig grs Sniézéad f@:__a miai A Csmgjsngaéiéazz sf R3.2i,2'?,G€f§Gf~ 2:----;£':E%: §§:i€E'€SE 8;.7£"w.f5"i.'§:_; '~f}€E"
armum, EL in 13:6 ?esuE.*a 'iihtff a s:::éf2'$:<:9£1C.we:f; 3:: %:3aVrt;"*"E'h%.=:
siaimazzis 35$ €I'}£I:'fi€d far' a '«2:::s'£;3,£ C3m;t>e§:se;~,§é0;;"«~.55, Rs¢2i,2?',{iGGg"~ xx/ifi: ézzisresi péz'..aV:*::::tz1i;:r:1V:%1':5Vr3:,1: 5%"
'aha? €:::ha':1<:€§ C$m§ens3,:§G:; ihat' §:::é::é£.'::t $%3aI%§E:;::: égwzzesiaé 1:1':
Fixs-aé Dapesifg in any ':;'a;:i:3:':a,f€ii3§:fi flat: name «:25 at: sliani N<>s.E;" . 2 :'é%52dI"~ vz'*::}':'::}:":§€::1s;§€ :9 the L ' : ._ L ' .. 1, cempengaiigzzz*aW$_:fd<i:i% €853;-S «:29? appa:'Ei<:>nm€:1€ maiie bf; E}/:5 '§':"EbfL2A:;Ttaf.f" V " 5%.; .. 3S ! KW» .§§ .\