Ram Yatan Prasad vs Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited on 9 August, 2019

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai

Ram Yatan Prasad vs Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited on 9 August, 2019

<s es om © rey m 5 © 0 od x evil, 2019 ord Go = g 6 i< ek a $ 2H ow 6 8 . :

arr, BR wd oa e nH Cy on tw $3 t ma} O wa it oe et t?3 we 43 Hi . > BY . - of . :

Fe ce o Lf Me ov eG ~ h4 8 BS Sy co a8 o gs oS . 3 4 oy eee wz ee ~ mM ot an TSS 5 te th Qt im ON g Oy Oo 4 M4 ; * WO o ee : re) ey eo OM Ke ° £ Q & sd ft sed : o if 9 4 -~ a ag Tn wa > oe 8 . Gt. 4

7 a a "9 ee is x woos 2 wd i uo i Ot 4 GE A nw OS @ fe Mel fd Sie % Gerd 3 Bo gt ge go 2 8 © oa Mel 84 Lied ag e Tg got areh ED :

>) St a % tid! Gs O Et weet 2 @ ved St Se eee A ¥ ord * $ Q g kyo 1 Os G ee ord at 03 oad Fra es ty & . 5 4 aE = "3 ed Giowef Wed sed my ob co a 2 * Oh cb : co eH Ow ad who oy 4 4.3 1 De th ' poof & O a god bt O CO OS ag ov Ee "" Po a tt oy ws uh ge ao~ 4 & 5 vet ied & At eet ee BO ug go He OG wom 3S fj ct op 8 OE % we et Oo fa OG Hl Dp vet a j Om 4a for chet et Dp 4 ot © i o 8 2S Pe mam fs TR Ors es ae day cA ' ec ' me at OF a Xe ™ g fa KS tw &: Coot oc @ ed a4 k s mond & % Ba EB FOG Sos oO gm wo SO Got oO @ 45 {% . et ard 4 us Oo 4 . t V ot ex] hE 5 Ea Et gs ct > Qo fhe © 7 fee 3 g Cee SBS os Y To % veg abe SS "oe ee x j fra Ga Eg aes ts me fh wed ' te 4 $4 et ft ; cod & 4 4 € 5 uy x PH $ iY & > Hoy © @ obs on ORY Bp ' ha TSO td we Ne Pcl oy w@ a bong ed Peek et 2D eed ed BBG ' z :

wet oH ne ' ed bo eal a » ih cs iS @ wh ca) vi i G on : Se oy pet "h i as "ot oot se ved w ct ws ws a wv o f- ES a x td ey Be O a) pn ug on) 43 hed mS of bei re hes hed 0 ig . og "e ei we ae a o wf 4 a Zz, C ge 8 sg z 8 Jd @ : oo, bea a opi ah ns S i * Cy a 2 5 ae a & BA 4 a : mM a ba ws C3 r 4 ohne ce me o = My U ry ie ' 4 cS ox or} ~ e oe mB te © " g 2 "i = ce nae Se $4 Rh on é 3 gs v. mo % et nf w i) a iN a a © Ch on P| a i ds a3 oy, oe : "a 4 oe wot 4 YY * ra ay bt En vn 4 op 4 G O a ie I Ho as Se # 8 & G§ 6B @ BB & : of c is '4 he . " '2 4 i in cs bee . " 7 es aped ae at C4 ' HH Y a a ret oy ~ Mo C5 nt 4.3 oe mG = it red 3 Cond x wen ed oe oo . "ne t a4 } eee en . oO ot es eo Coad - id 3 i "a : 7) , ery « ' x. © c Lg if te i 43 peed ar La hy f % " ht C . 3 a) ws Os o 1G ved ae 42 4 a ty og " i Ae Ca mt ; tng ay wf m4 : rd ' pos ai io oo rg 4 on BY) G a Gs mM % eh og" g they 4 ce 8 "ny "5 Ch Bs , ie % si i soe} : : & 4 oe sont Lf ; 5 eed at +4 ct oo bs Ba Oo og mm w ms $f iy oe od ot eh be Ly bee ~ wy a oo, eet! a £4 hn m he es on oe Se, a. cH igh . OG} Se c (2 ms 5 Ms, ae of srt 4s od eee i . Oo sg on Spe G yO Es et CD 6% * fey Ol -r td ca cod ret 8 - qe oo 5 he ow. Sok "44 4 (5 go te ot we ' orl "e i Oo yo " ; va aa ' rive is Oo it ry 1 in he -- a o aa 3 : t a aes o . Ren ch ghoN TEM NOY om oy Bg tho 4 uf a a oy 3 cy * erty oe TH. MG AF Cbs R. he 4 iss mo x Med org p oe 4 a a a Oo.

G © : aan 3 bY UP oy i o 9 sr * by te oO ~ « % es 5 en f pee wy @ vt = Sn + Ag ms GG Gop tO oe ht "5 " te QO tee as ty Co be SE xp @ oc GC es 8 ve: 43 > ced '¢ ot a QD (> Gwe ft a3 % of Mi 3 "i ay ae mS es Sy t i w ' 4g od e 4 9 a oe » aa rn rr oe 9 fe} os Gls hd adh g OG Ba es s 0 Bet j e s tS a ea Gb ha o 1 oO ' . on 45 we ~ cS @ 4 we Qa rl DO ss o Q@ bt vot 6 Ad ye "4 i D © be @ a wg 0) MOP " ~ rd ae os eg, | a my EY ki , . a ay oe o 4 hy £3 2 ) i ras of C AS et ch, (i arf me. or} bed wD G be a io bed Ba @ h a yo i w a) ved ma o v ° ~ 88 Order ey Z 3 S c 4 2 a £ gp a = Orde:

Cok . 4 "= % oe ce o 3 -

: aed Y qa ee eh red A . ea os 3 ae ce ed q x oe ' net fe ae! a 44 ta me: 3 os i iD 4 ® 3 x a qs ' ey ee srl co ot hy 'i £ gt 4 ' "4 Se O ed oN é 'a / r fe hb te sé a aed i ad s " ' . a « a SB 3 3 a © % é & 2 Q Sa a 8. gO iv moO x oe es! a vel we hod rt 4 " 4 So yt "- mM ay Ma 8 n« a e vcd w 2 es oe x * S oe foo OG CS em e i a i 43 % 2 vb Q o 7 fea cae " o ae * aw ne hs w ae, . QB 43 ( o a x os s) es my mo a 2 " :

ti ci mF o a ye "4 Es : nO te is rs ° » ia Oey - a Met ua af g " Y bb ve a) 4 pn @ : ci . wf pent bs fe ' rel « a os ny rot ce a et 1) et ne? ira . Mt tf bat Ch, a Sh a pet Ci phox oon * %) ee M yu re x a wel sa a3 BS "es Bi "es y 8 : su 2 os 8 ° x vot XG a 3 or Ww, mo 2 4a eged a @ Q at 4 a * Le f e) ~ i. 4 ted ov os i a ra i $4 a Oh a na ba cy 33 ard ew a uv a § eo 4B 1 3 cs "i co tbe god oa 424 e} at ard "

' G a hl a be n & ™ é ce ore! tee g 3 w Ae : a e ¢ ™ 85 cm + 44 ' " & ° Og wn ri Sg a ch Qu w A a oa i? a é " u at ed uo es eho aes gs . a a a Ce s o Co beg rs i343 @ 3 e , a) ss "0 & 2 x eC & o 3 4 oh o roi eo * @ a D 3 ae O - '5 a3 ey Oo od oy w 3 KS bs 3 4 Goo wel yi by ", 84 i rs 2 ved y a 4a oa « ; gm x o RO Bn ms ee eee o doo Sha bed Bs rt Q Oo om * rw hes. Sef Q 4} id KF 6 st Se eo a) , " o : es , BY b " i 0 oy ee eo im ae it r . cy o we 4) s os oy ae . > oS O ~ " ib i we mote a wi BE ; : "4 tt ees A a : & $ _ 8 6 a OE Z Oo 5 ¢ iy de ~ as 3h s gt q? ae CP Ch 40 xs 0 (3 i we 3 5 EB + aN tt " ey ' , a Bo B® i 2 YF 8 & SA Pr ° bod 2 . oe . . o 1 GR s S 2 8B Oo 4 bk 5 es c moe € 0 o FS Eom 9 @ » wed a a = " ™ my geod v4 dG fo ay OS fo ot S 4 tf ont a4 : 5 cD a i ah oF A, cee il , A ea wd a $4 a wu ea c a @ @ 4 Ct tp ane 73 Go o 'CG GF - 4 g a4 o on i iS io CF @ C 4 wt 5 i 3 it EE a Led 4 is ved © it is83 @ oot wa 44 is) as fd Me re re Pe ot ord o n . ve "ry @ heat Ud a Ar bee re - My vs eas is) . we os. . O a & 44 4 , on arf Le a4 Qo wh Y ried ed + Q ard ont y tee, 5 " & red bed. a Pa oe w Ae c a ved co wl a thi aed 44 ved aoe @ Ci "a Fre) w "3 ' @ oe " is Fe ai ne 5 ; at bee 4 rane <t rs - (3 2 me kn a a y el ae C3 nh seed fe ow fd c $ a3 Ne t, ay he " Pan whet es red 3 oS rt ore ver} pet aot ob a. os co a * 2 4 i, DB D oo 2 ee pr ord pa cy, amt Ley w 2 E3 el os = nh ee a (ts & as 3 D nA a2 of a3 ¥ Mas r a au ' 3 ai fo op bp Ge . os ro a 7 w i o é ia if 5.4 "4 a ae na a om Oo fet ve ved 1 Ct se "3 4 i a aA pot 'i ard os 2 ' ~ ' fe : oo bes we 4 grt u wy ns " hy te Gs at A, rf 2 - o ' ire} he i G es a Py red wd ms sy eu ved Q w Ge! Li ey "4 fog ay Us " on me e o os a B i a & be @ @ Ay 6 a oO © mo o oa % fal o oan an Gh fey vd io * 2 v2 te Ch fo 2 an Cy aay , be a o el 2 3 pa % is i) oe aa a a oe , : - » 3 wi yo G ed $4 ced G a a cs wn 2 A a . as Ky % 2B ss "a % : ia ran te ord ee 3 a a _ o 2 ge on a2 Ly ators ead bet ue Ld oe oy . engi, By hos 44 Be "y c a oo st ard o '4 we ved oF t oh i os o a" ae re is oF m oO 44 te mA a ff if ape : on 4 "ied a c "4 es BS , t . : 3 wha . wo f ¢ 3 3 iD Dy iy on we om x? go = o 12, i Ss 18 3 4 Dp a ot a) fe *. 4 sy re) o Bs ert . ee 2 . ie Gi on ri & ec ad C84 whee is aa} etess + ged oot vat i a 3 ae i Sk OS gp PB Bo a Soe

- "4 ae] ar a She iy w td ms ; my US ce 2 a oh} a 2 by a wae) fy 43 yi uy 4 $2 * mn © oS ES ; j « © a ryt 33] " 3 i ny i 4 te ¢ Bb @ g 4 ni : Py B Auk Ch Bi LB o co "eed oP Y "* a Be Q) Mh = "3 4 nm 4 so O rd a rs t a "4 te Ba gi - 5 bf © Goo Oo Lg Be aS) re a " % ~ ip end a 43 Mi a be i re os 2 oi C ° ' i cy "8 oe 4 fe 4 a & i a M4 th Be ne z os uy 5 "4 < 1% Fs id Md vet ce a o i o % ys oO cE UY oy i a G os S$ A a4 vad "

"r| c : oo C3 P- a ~ u re eh he Qh ~" OD ~ @ is i 4 M4 w 4g 4 a Be i is an & 2 3 L235 3 ta Fa vy fh Fy Me 2 mh ny og 3 D 3 Se x ye @ g a 4 A) m3

3 "D 4 45 43 ed a t 3 = C 3 iS ved me Kat Ck s * » =i he oy Ot ETE Pye s oh it G4 as ed 3 io8] O an x ih, ur wm Q on Eres a ca S ~ % a a Bn ® Gh as ce be a te om ; cs i a 43 ord rs) ; my co m OB 4. Um A © 0 Ga "C3 42 Bo 2 bef a wi 45% y Peo, ty ts 43 . th ie e

a) C3 o h oe ary bed mM Ge 43 ¢ rc at ae nv x * oe Myo ee a set 2 a, 2 . vA v4 a) co ts = o 7 Ui = CO fi ee © Ok na Mi * a Oo a a es ve a mn bed shod fs ty o OY © @ xs Bg fag mee aA ca = fe 6 oy cl oy a A oo nA Bat whe? fos 3 ba wt es Py a mh ss 43 oy w aa) co cy Say we ve ei Fad t at 4 ts fa o> ie @ ad a iF "fe "3 boy "nt 8 4 £5 co % a on , fog > x teed 8X5 O oO vee ' ne wo Oy KO ke ae oy oi , ' :

an ot an TRO a ons ag : oS ~ ' Ft LS * oO a ei ore GS 2 Q 4 oe 2, @ Sg Ne + on ge 1a & z a n 4 5 :

i ON EG 4 t h a a ° 4 i . ce:

a bp Hs iS as Ch a eg ee - c & @ ool oD ct = 6 fd a s Bots uy 43 nw ' * ; a a § : - Ad eS KG seed L > oe 5 4 v s eo sed - S a & on ee me ai a © a oss . Ne oF rs 6, ~ « a} = cs & M4 i Cry oe ON 3 G & 6 4 ® wt " ee z . aes i oh 4 S33 G8 * @ . 6 8B . & & wo @ fs oe 3 ; 4 ve 1 "4 oO Hee a ' vey o ' @ ep bs Dy 04 t 8 oid : hy rs) Qa n ES & if) ~ oO i os . £ 5 iy art os "3 bet es ~ ct ive oo 3 es mY nr) Ge mm 9 a ~ a Aad 3 a oD a a $24 3 ae Ps G or . oy g sot 'od oped ' an % G3 @ ib a "e '7 ao 5 "

be \-

¥ a b, Ae xe ae ae wy i a \ANNEKURE~Iit NR _ ri¢ 2a a Ne ', 4 * ik ry 33 od a ee wa 8 eke we ose a an uw.

v fe eS we n iy nd en Bory .. oO 63 ip ge (3 oy ma OG rp #5 or Oa ot Zz * a ; a wr ey ory "ef "4, wh 3 vy ry Si A. poy i | oe rs) OS sao g aes ' Z in eee tt AA a a ony a 95 cs © ct Bo £ ee od iN 4 CF cn => co ip s & oe G + vt i 8 wn ~ oN ms cot "ee EOS on " " A Co uk mo ei 9 mo @ j : $ " Ny we et 'A ry od eef C7 get ned ef & a SG a7 Bs * ° Se wee Ne a ~ a oot we a . a, - re ro bao ; o @ wd Lo te a tre Se Ps 5 nt po ped Co ind os ' ' SN a wl tt " . eet es : : b 3 me (5 omg me G4 on vs @ my v Se wa if : on 5 QB 2 oc 4 Sa c ba o a ae £ ' ;

. ed x ape ved det fs w ad 4 « i . 6 :

ox - © . gt O 3 g v4 a i wy 5 gy 63 G a ; a " fe 2 ane To fs the uy . and : set or} Gy ; a a ty pp & 4 O44 5 = ° t. a £2 ert fy Me rf) Ad ys : cy >My coh ' iS FD at t 2 ¢ WW ah ' mgt f .

es ' j hy ree wh be oe Be wed a 3 mg " 4 a 2 8 ot ip ° oO ogg oA ee § so tS 2 ts ged a ae)

-

oe "

che N

-

@ S SC a. my fut g sing % ° > a wed 9 as ay GE aE | ort | 3, 3 e 4 ane 4d | os Bo, oe, GE Sy e nn "g wy @ 66, Wb Bid 2 e oa x a e er

-

fae / € $4 ¢ 4 "3 Bim Oe Mm Gi sy my 434 O i oh Ct 4 iQ a aed r on tet gion a A oD | pet pO w@ Hipet | O My "4 a a) Gh ed ord Cy Ob bt ed boty re Opa oD wy & iat OD +y O16 Qi m @ | Gy © fh, DG Oi, te o es & bot 0, 34 rm Of Bm @ | O. © pei @ Das a OW = igi O&O) ee Oto Oo] w & ok poe Bey oe | Oe buy Me rs or no Cali 18 GB fei Oo om | O 49 | ae a al | Oa be EI + $4 eo so & G cy i ~ OS 2 G $2 as Ls es

4) ed a . -

--z- @ &y if ac he eS uy wy tS gC Q 4 ao nt vd Hy @ 9) vert om 6) ay a4 bow Be at 8) a fos G "

dd Shed sed) 3 a . wy de 4 Ep i As w 1G; Ay a 2 a4 £5 et . 3 " ny ie ry ved a re we G "A oo i he wi ty '. wy any oe ed god aaa! wa rc a A oe ae Man ae me, a aa i I i iD aoe i "n wel a } 3 3 an toa ra @ . et Me ra i 43 6 eo ee mH ms, ca oo ho eet es * G bed ne. ve rt iy ea "a en £ in ~ oer oe oo " we a oO fr rg aM ve 4 eed Oy ed hed wha i} ard : 4 a4 op cS cer eteattdatncscacddditd ce tees eee te bed ted 2 ie 4 ¥ gy bei 4 O a is bt 43 . Cy $4 KD a 'th 2 rs ve + 3 ve he ut C3 yea Aa 1 te os "8 rg @ . 6s eS od . re 63 im wd eG Pt hy & i cd G et BS Q +, RL £ Cs 5 ot " "s a mony Gh, ©) y 43 irs a wl At werd pet Ch uo Le " t let ie Gh tet " ~ Sos, gy Wo oe ae Che wee if oy yd KE toa on : cs Mae ut 4 u Hh 4 . me * a . oe C 4 ot ° Ces 7 wy a Me a WE {7} George ae oot aed a) uM 2 54 a es + ee oe Ad 2 a oa o 4 ry cei o ved 23 mA rt co a w * "A @ a 5 os we ~ 33 . . bt on a : a A . fot 4.2 :

4 et ny vt G on on fe va gt x 3 on Dh or sort us rant Fee "4 were, : oy $2 * tf oA i : a ot ab i : be : @ t "3

90) wy nit co 4} 63 4 ' ba wr on a) i f © ie sa . C3 bed o Hoy i seoeeed ccecesenbunosven Lee om i Od Q, 2, o ls, 201 OA NG 3S

5 é a od Ae wD 4. 7 be ~ "eS @ oS ma 2 oa ve oe i § iM 7 "4 4 "A v4 : B } bd 2) bet An iB vet m 3 % G x wD iD os mS La Q w Gi 4 : ; , * 3 a po oy th CC 34 + bn et & wend a Mee @ @ rr) CS AS a es t3 44 & am Ae e a ra i A 4 AS a) a 43 g? a vd i a, aes o mw ey ny ° ce 2 ae ty ead Meg a coy YD 115) "3 bs uO} o we 5 ind oof * rs 4g 1) hy " peed ae st rn 43 , a ood fs , , iA ' va Cn a rv rd $4 "% AF *, oe ut "S sh, C3 cod ree © wD , a v D i n We ms "Pe ed C3 . oO a ted ay wo a3 ae fet Ra ce Bom 0 <3 @ ow " s 3 4 Cs "Ch a is oa ben ° ce) a pet ot ye ; 4 oy ok; mn ud red 3 jet ied . ms A £5 ct Ad a y co re my a fe

- oe © oO gg 8 6 Gg & ® 2 Goo @ Gf ) is vt ved t eee Me re ree s ip o ia . hy o 0} a, peed wed wy CG °e fa} 1 Lg Q . 3 hd wt " rs th uy @ ved we g eyed arf o m DB 7 Sa ci a a Ad i ct 4 a bs Fy 3 x av Ls ra 3 o m 4 "r4 : ee bt os net ; ys ; ote *- 4 tl he an "3 6 & oY Sg BR Com fF 8M ow ae & ned te a KS 43 hd mt of iS nD 4 O 3 & G a Hee ri » G&G Q 2 G Go 4 ; :

bed a a mo mm as ha rome ee o © uy ry 4 "ee + i a Ls a} ~ 3k ae aD At ae i uf bos 59) ue vat v ae 5, ft ey ne cord rt : 4 Nt 5 3 te 2 w 5 ' 3 : a © tea if oS in roa fee * " Re u 4 my re) Ct eet wi ey oy Hi Py fe "4 2B " Y AA tt ee 9) th hy Oy a ip ry cB (3 y g 3 .

QR x a pny iS ay 3 4 "4 5a ost . . vy rf a y aw «8 2 & DB 8 BM o # 4 4 "3 " ws - oO on AB tf 4-4 4d Lf °: Go eG, Sg cs we " : a Aa @ o wy ' © i 5 Sn 5 ip uh 48; cea 44 C3 O io "5 +4 % a 3 G3 7 , Y iy St sed oad vel ra we ie) Qt on het A ted a % xe Oey es ma G & ' , - eG iene . "es veh fe 4 > +4 a @ HB BB og : Ho Bu CP ae EE a m mw OBO Ka BO oe Qo Mo ms a % ry tf as te ae 2 x os a 4 " G rc 5 A rt . gs ea) CO '3 2 as A pe Sod 2 . 3-4 i U3 ei Pa : a xed aD rf) eed 6 ny 2 ee a ~ : : : " by " af iD my L. bea ae a C3 og Mea re . - 43 "4 pet qb nt sD i G aa ' Ps ue we oe a4 on a £ a de o Qn a ~ we "a : Bw cy oy bord 53 es . ' o s} ° gy < a * a § o 5 5 or aon Th. ed art 4 . 44 ced nt : y €, a Bo ees a ae) Q * ~ a Be © 8 6% e a 3 ms go eo FO wy " . "3 OB =~ mS ~ os wg , © "4 os. € "o> y mS os ti be o . "s is , oS ; u i Ket 6) ih as ; nem x KS 2 apel -

us et 5 x " n we . aS ti 4A ad 4 aa A ue 0 on fa ie ao bs m4 'be te o 42 44 504 a eg wed a vd fg ee ane wo @ re 2 GC Yo Be & hed oo up ey es, ay @ tb 1 Kes rs ry tt 6.4 4 co 4 " Ch 4 ced M4 fa 4 td G ial "f nd es bet pert at oot O fa whet L SE Lt hf a ye4 ha ie "s £433 Q . © 2 ' : a3 we 6 o CG, & Cod i. ek be ap . thy ci met aa nA re £y % rn gt ws a cs ect ey a} oF & bee ~ det weet wt 1K ns wt Q at be ¢ ahd MA pan ' : nn a fi 3 werk Cy {3 40 £3 Q @ mo ues oS ed of C ue 6.3 $i 43 a2) & © + "

~ Ord Q yore oh ~ ¥ 2 a i % i oy ed oa mK eos hed a 6) rs 1S ea hs a ro} aS ; ' "4 ; % } re © a re) o © 4d 4 * on a $4 ao os bot 3 ry 3 33 aod @ tes af Me, oe 2 ' fo et ty ayek i aged g ed ea j :

"f a ie: si " mt gt rs Oo G) S & © aU Ce "

1 cy 6 ' ved 3 4 mm a 4 ed 4 ced . :

fa &s is o 4 Am 8 4 ; a oy ti} ads eed A id ry Be % we 4 bat ' @ fS os by sa so } t% £2 oa wy nA Ps te tee 6S el uy A] = SS " bof 33 + Mie Set . ; 3 ny id ci a o © a Ped " on 3 me S £5 hn ie} ' "ES nae hg ae a 4 Oo: O Q er Pea a a ved oy po 0 5 Yey tee tod @ ks 4 ee cs bs Oh v3 w an Cea a we 2 2 os 4 oe ua ay . AS ae weed, fea % G bea rted Me Sg +4 te @ a oy ee 4 a ae Me Q hg is 4d Me 7 ot fd 4 es 4 a iG vis , ~ os a 43 ee a v a fd WA 4 re "4 HF} 4 5B i . bed rh 3 , QB bata ah " oy So oo at co Ww apd 4 ' 5 ay baa i be wf £3 G Em hed Q BD = g "4 eR ie a wee re xt ref C3 & £4 ae ri 0 a ft Cy ab et see} i et pee oe ad A @ vs i ch res 3 wD Sed cf oS " . i H we 4 Ay ty 4 % Pe se fe be ad G tt Cy 3 a s Ch . vd E gd x c ae oh, i ord gs ' ad O "es G uy nd "S a ms we Be ra Ly eS orf . a i cae , @ Me n os, vs eq xf < tay 4 i - ed :

ay ch, A f a . at i ra 8 5 Ra my :

i 0 i a3 q@ O a3 : ; iB " is G of 3 % a py rns ha bed 4 a i Q ih on cy a £05 nee .

th wy 3 o 4 { 4 arf Ms = Q e ° 3 ord a ry 4 % a Oh, ant 43 oS 5 m7 os ond & 3 "

& ;

§ a # ay am $e 43 5) o "a uy mom 4a \ Ch, u i Oo a ee A OB «i @ kw o o Gy eM eS tR eo 3 3 ui & $e ae OSG im oo oe Oey wa & ws re A ny fo id or ve id 36. an TE a & Is a) eg "t ' Gy o p OD OS ra 2) oy a rh i we oy " + 4 a bee a & Fy 4 CA kK of ory Le) ett sae & Ee I an Bt oh z aren tr . a G a + oo ms sg FE % @ te , i 2 wy " in CG B to, He Pe wee g 9 © 5 ~ ro a ' ae PS a oe wy = 2 o A eo @ g i ye ra ia SS n

- Bs O TS 3 3 i « + sO pod ty oS an po Aa 8 .

: ge i q mt o 3 ag Soa , Co ta rq +e * "of ig ved By G - m Oy a be at eat ' te at raed ey t we wy tnd o B ha ©. b 4 ae 43 x. vot a od , & * < a a Se pod a fe = 1 © Ba a ; i <I ity my aes) Co an x Oy ras w 8 6&8 a mo A & *® Fo ie ny Fass i se vey Bo aoe © Ok S one a tad Ms, . on Neg O75 at "Ye te a us t} in a C .. a WH) a . ~ us o weg i' $ ict ra Gi 6 nh sp rr) 4 thet 42 Q "rd a ine we ~ 0 a | aS wed $4 Le eS a CS Oty © 4 Oey Al ih So '

e) 43 yp a ey . 1 O™ Fwy Hop = - f te GBD kiss v Bo Gy ya Bo, Bs hel pe os fe be oa he Q myo Se w Be Oo eo seed i ot " ad 43 "el o Cy Ga ONY aay a3 B Ee 3 o : he . mT * on % ce o 43 Dy w St 2 a he dos chs » te We a rn bts ped oO in yeh : 4 s Pa Cc ip On Sy <2 ia dai EE omg i a joel wr ; £ oo (ey Say v $y OY Cy Uy ney v AE ord mf pan gi hed Q $2 f ms is) f @ a0 oe Hs Ba * 4 2 ey ' ' Ah i SS o i "7 e ved 3 oe a @ Rs . ft 4s ah gc f B 3s 5 2 abe we ce % ' gs ra i i o «tt ae hi 2012 é "y ot G.3 AN = O ° 7 i & gD ean Sg "em "t Ma hd cy C bet TA Ss © me a "4 id Qh Meh tS ao Mt AY £2 oy i} et a oa g Cc Ne ia rent AS rs ted yeed M4 i Le 0 7 Ht iG on ws a) a tt ved " Ht as on S 7 ert Ms me is sh ( ; i ty 4 % ~ ¢ ry weed ' pee a oo a = ; & w Lv, aged > bea rt "y me ss oss @ wt a:

TS os "5 % ce ae me fs voit ve i Ue " + ree "es * een ae red . Lyd G if £3 bos decd £3 2 , a Ct ve ot 0% art Lr va 6 ip art eh Mert " . ob gt % o < nyt ve wa by . . Lf 4 re mn 4, / WD as oe ths es LE x 63 ce 4a Ad G} i be oben Le id a ae a ° a Sf cs + i beg a cy oi 4 on a3 9 rf ane G 6 3 % " 3 . ot 2 co ; . er a $2. re w ia ed gS ; ad a Q A "e41 : ae "

gy wef i ed be CG vt rh ie es B « QO Seg a os , vt xa 4 wh Sfoet 4d shed Ct @ x, Ck S St £2 a ; x ° cS % ea " ei @ me be Be a ' Q Q nA o - ae a 0 2) a an "3 a fs 0: v os a % @ 3 YD OQ: cy qy Fa - ae " & uo 2 in rg on Sef a te 3 het a B be j opt wD es, cr @ oe 8 a Qa 3 ved in 5 ij ® G Fa res ci "4 Ws ref a L cy pa ' i eS oe 3 ra go DB b ben ord 3 a 43 i oO D "ye 3 be '3 oft ay mn 4 a ; ry ad ne AS ni a fray et fe, ot its : iy nm Lae f Oo} ' reo 2 "f aa ~ ot gy BO Bg 3 5 OP 8 ee CS ae © " 3 a, © a ee ed by * ot wend hy ; wf i 4 . Si , bE wh rt bet oO 4 Mos 2 a . i et Q Mt . a L, i 4 ce ' wn a3 13) O g. 4 2 ot ibd 5 fal ca ty 34 3 es tnt A bad es tied tr $4 ue cs wo oO 2 g 5 7 deh wed @ ;

; co 7 vee ' 4 " my 3 o ue a oc oh, A Be; @ 1h Set qt set . Q 5 i * 3 na % \ a at ra ty 1 hee! ai rl ' a4 v 3 ; " og % ts "4 cet ef a] 2 te ae - o xy wd od EA wp bens we © yr x G 4 . ~ y : my Ad i Ma o : ¢ oA, pent 4 how td: me mS v Mi a Hy O. + st o 7 a cr @ D ere uw A iG oe i @ sf : 5 4 iy "E4 oy ' a4 Tt ; ot + See £ , We ra ce oH eo & = Hoot BS "| ie a3 G "4 4 va B co a B oe Ne ne . w ve a is) a 44 Sa coed ' fe Md " os wh a $4 aS rt ¢ i. bet " < wef ; : a G a ; é Ly

44 aa 3 M4 © wy hed 3 X i A : 4 ae GS oS fo #& on & ee § we hott bead wed 4.3 ae red b> Py a w ot cant, { 1 4 tt} af ot 3 veel fe <n} 'O 4 ut o See are} 2 £3 Liat NE YpS ik VY q £ A SP er pee we} at.9 £43] *.

FOr om Ne xe = + st we or ret wed

a) e x ay NMNezW Rh Pe oh akc x

14. ne ~ ae at rock 3 We 3 aw ae aa "i at ad i hf «gs "rf Le ard rm eye es Re AL IE y J $ a ad s > Eno ne tien OPES . wt 'yp ed ae LES > Me oo ne orf eo ee es a wt 14 Las + £ 5 A s wer ee Vy eat Ada L3 FY x eS en Fee KS s c hes 1S wt od J % Y = oe nther3 7 fe ue M4 g < e es 2012 oe S FO.393:

A?

* oO 2 hi G ee uD oy 43 ny re % * w is) ') 3 wv a4 4 " 1] i ro a w qs . .

ae gy our £74 eet x my a wi , 2 res 7 See avd Ae %S ' ' © be MQ a 4 ga cs hy roe se a ; 0 co 4.4 cy QB owes hs nt ot Gt 44 , He a) * m4 44 a 4 43 a oe s

4) et 4 44 bg crs ty a ck ht ref ry Ly d : ' , ~ Gy x . qe rs t Het . os a & ri 4 7h CY 4 Set Ky 'ng ie cs cn wy , ws wd iB C nf 3 ti oe fs 4 (a o c $i S ns ~{ u Bl 5 eed Q hea ' oe at ei Y oy eh O ped : a ® fen 'eel a " feel se 4 ; : o oD © 3 5 rt UM <f O bee, *y if y A uA ind @ me om. OD, 3 un G "4 1s Nl cod ns os 033 wet eed on Lo st B nf i y cog Boot ew Oy oO op & 8 ved wed @ iA ig 6 me a sean o G & ing ; . - Oo & 3a oh: 8) O na ot ort pe) Ct eC i . a ed Xd 2D ea os i th ry oy Cy 43 i . Qo re Bee yo ss ort: ed AA we "cs ad Cy "3 . i OQ in a QO ved * D va gt Q . oS i By es es : o ; oa " ved Oh Gh iA Pa no . Q L 2 43 5 th Cr. i g Re w a Uo & n rs Os & ae y i GG 5 obey AY th on a A 3 Se my 4 ff co , a "

non " is go" ag f 8 a BH

- mo : weed 3 rt gt oe a ge u r ot n ws ine a we Q 6 rt 7 OG, ty vd % Q os, "4 ui 4 3 $6 met gt ee ee ee a a td ; MH on) 2 cs 3) aT ER ah . @ mA yO * | wg ved 6s C wd bet 2 an 5 ed fe a to wi : . : wee Se re - ae Sy oy : 4 naa he io oe a3 er we = ves i od 3h 4 " wa "4 ws ® 4a a ie rm a es o ie o © $a ord ny a 4d Q, oy 3 ES ab arf ot wn sed Shy wa ao At rs "9 a &% a © 4 SE fy UH mS wd ed Bo ed m te et ; os) » ty ord oa 'be G be oo wv # fs " Y wa a ® a Pe ft eee = xed % . eo aa 4 wha fe ny Kn rey) a best Ae ip ist hd KE te i "4 hb hab ge fe fla a v a Go + 3 ci ' io ce) G m3 a 4A ing vy An Oy ws TAs on 4 qo cs TS a t toy i : in 3 fe, ov va a oe - in 5 rt m m3 ee a & ve cee my ted o & if a io

4 a ty ran en ce G 4 xi a % ved m s CS o rm) (is beg ie eek o "Sy eed sick GS wa "5 ss vr qh i set Py r+ ¢h aa '4 GS fd wy g} & ; bol Wee Ot ts 4 o v4 ay os 5 ad ms 2 4 *s os 2 og & Go . C4 5 i 6 ao RF ° , fe < " Bi] Ms ee . " . . ape tr) 6% a "4 o fx, 4 oY ss 1 L 3 qe 43 e3 , 4 a td rs 0 Pe a5 vet ot 3 tr 3 i ba G a) ke "4 B aS 3 Moot w Mi c G o od a 4 ® 44 wo 1} ny iis) 3 at os 3 & e 4 a 8 . ori aS a ' a nd a " es ial mo G wa i cn a A Cher re of : 4 " oo m4 oe q ce ry iB 0 os

- 4 : ie at eS C a boo 4 YH ~ z iy a i if ce wt & gM a @ wy i @ wy 43 rs wh d dt om tho 4 3 © La ao BS Mi ae y us o4 3.4 in C3 G SA G 5 wy Bd ad Ces det t na Ww OG 7 cn on < a et a op Fe 5 © fa 3 "

«. a) @ % mM SS Ga nt aed ws 5 bat n ' 2 " fa by ; re ' rr bes 3 a FB mR em om Ee ~ ea BBS cs "4 ™ ig La Th a cy ve La w 8 , = wh bea a % £3 "3 arch "4 i or w i Ss ert i i 3 " " he ot + aa tts ud 4 " ra & Me ey 8 Lea "eed w + wD Gs ee o & @ "4 ha '4 "eS L oes 3 30 A el ee OG ® , hed 74 x ee t30 sod "4 ' ~" oy 3 i is 4 a

4 - ~ © as: * i G r4 CS - 0 4 a aS bi fds aa . ts iy * % ne a pe a na 44 a i a "cd oy bod b G Sy wen MA hed is as) os oA t% x . "9 zy 4 G red ry 4 ae bee grok my hei i is a og oe ee ' 44 w as a Ps 13 4 CGC & ", 9 a ws od m OO 4 DG Fe 4d 4 . ny on i qi D pA aw obed Cs Ld ae it ' oi me 6 = ans % 3 6 i @ ¢ un a 4 ai G HS ; ix es a a rs ts ; nis o ' ; : 4 4.1 Ye rat Lo. i ty. "3 m4 " 3} ia n oy w cS oA "sed a a by Ms i i vt oy wo 59 -- 4H FS uF ved ved " ° Me : $2 Yet , er4 23 43 a ' . iy ce , ue a La wy . ae ie se a . pal ie yp red th * va u} eo net hal 5S j i 3 " wa no co ir a 3 i oy % o

-- uy : het = aha o aoa 3 "na a Gy nt aid ¢ is) of 2 3 bed ' Se Bw Ad as "3 "OU wn me ig "a Q A Lt °C (a . 3 d ne rel ae ih ne on 0 ne Ct + Sf oy = 8 Boo BD ar) OO FC BG " Be oe GR eo Og aye} "4 4. ct pha a! ped Q 3 as we Sony 4 #) ; a fea ay ad 4 i 43 cy t Ld 4 " LA re Ad & * (3 a 7 m ooal "Th a aed Me iD we km seg af © ny ue a or $2, 's } _ od wa 4 on - ft O ay Cc = oi rig ard rf a 4 i t ti a) % » 4 ce Med % . bs So OO Oo wo fy 3 : " : Cy . ry me ; 0 ~ ord yt os 4 0 { hy Me my 1 ood w 2 : ; a 4 aed o o i Ww ay A ay a) et rj We CO my ue ow 3 is oe OS Ch co 4 r ' g my vs t 2 me :

Bt be 'o ~ 2 a - Faed uF G a' oes 4d °F 3. Ch ie A , 4 > - 3 is dan reed, is q Le vet Q i es ° 33 g mA Q? f Wane a ¢ ~s ge ey uy a "e YY i os . & " " ad in i S B 4 v4 3 th ; ad Bt i own oS red ~ at. ul G we s a 1 it "a weet iy edt O ies sed G oa ka m A ae a aed m m at - . " o c Cc , 2 oa ; 4 ry ft 4, vB . cy a £4 het shee peak gt fe AA) vet a] i} Ae v Ct wh is Us C . x be a =e iy re) > 7 er 4 aw ; be La et x cs {hg so Fae 4 se Ka 1 why 7 mw 0 a 4 o w iB 0 i} 1% oY a 2S v 4 i de ¢ ie i j oo a) Be 4 5 { Cs oe a cm @ i) (2 rf es D ea cs , ped tA * ce co . © a ved Hed @ a Les "A th 44 th o £4 i ey w a 3 a . MI ict = ve Bi ve 3 oh ~ wt Sa a O @ o ' 3 i a Ch it ad 3 oh cS * mm ta @ "4 mt 3 . ® a3 * Hr O th 6) a ) o % GG te at 4 w Bo fe Bd fe me i © ved 4 or > o fe) 4. Q 4 é Oo 2 & hd rt m fo wes red eed 4 wy 4 AQ eg QO $4 yd SENNA 2G.

nm aye FH eG fa te s av ToS i 2 OQ vy ri mss oe he x ye ce SSS ~ Me ae oN at ate 5 we ~ he LLSecl on 4 mk ay y ry te hd + ct we oR ca a st toby Lee oe bef @ oO =e Sak 1 ey ah at m3 on XK 4 a4 OeeeE = ~ < ~ bob a 8 x 1o4 Se aror Q & 4 y i.

q + eo q a RAY 2 er a < ons oe Ne od Nath ey war ke Ke 2 ox ed oF Ve 2 Sew ae rae LLY evry Kae At Se = uy > ge chip Ra A et Nat Nae \ Ly rr 'f SY ER Adds J eA mil SN poets eres TNE M Ar4 bd I 33 Spa rvu eA od .

G x i perm PLL TS.

LE Re ed od A i wy caeee a Le CA ak na ney "

oO a a ed i x .

: : hd Q ' > et + mM ff be c eo © 2 Mt on 44 ea 2 y B hs i Go o im 3 a & D 4 co" * feed ot Gh ord mo rt es whee 2 a3 1 . it ry 3 a oo A whe! ee es Po $ o hk % ny mm, @ m DB wa ow G «a "a 6 +78 5 % chet tt 4 3 " Ki Pa ce * g se & Led bas iw wv Ch wy my SG - reel u wt & ib os gs wo "5 tp acl j fy res Saf 3: ryt i as we :

i ~ o "cS Mi ne hg a be ry a 3 " 2 & Zz 2 oD get rod * Peek aie 4 Y ht . 3 ot ert $.4 eg £ bf > © a {0 Pt ved 3) ot ie kg @ ' + ty) ; aa ' ; x ad a w eB od a ae Fred Fa GB i ul me i "ed nt "4 ; c g 4 Mt € srt on song -

oa eis apd ug Ma at " Poy ha ie; _ ES tal wa i * a " B i vt 2 w tes to fo! te Le wpe wa 7 ft ed va © @ "y © CG iy We ie DD o of * : 4 "G ; id : ae 7 $2 is , on > 44 3 Et 435 ve CO g " is be i 4 s ' 7 nd Gi a» 1 " " Boo 5G (8 ty seed o at * at > i . ot cet e a MY Met ¢ AS Beg w a) " wl 43 4 : @ Bs g a o A @ . 2 BN : CG SO G 4s Shed mn *- ve we ee a aC Cs v4 ™ LA 4 4 <4 ia 53 ge 8D et 5 wg 6 a $3] ford a abet 4: bg i "e 7 @ uj wD Me at iD ¥ _ ee hy fi oh ed ~ a of ot ted 4 Leg wd. ~ ae & - ~ oe en ' ; wf ok ME eS & 4 8 oS 2 ; » & m4 gS as ort ~ ee 8 aes "a oy ved ae . O oy eed o a tt OE fe ect e 2 rs] a ~ R a en rat cS e a ;

: $3 a wet , od : ee i a a ¢ 3 C 0 B o 43 G a on roy cot ih baad is vert Bo g SG ted fab " th aed Qa ® ore} . LE a 44 et . a ns & ra} ) . oe a 44 a i a wes rs) ie sf "3 oxy ee ' 4 ee a iS cs eS 43 St vf ay 453 om) Ae : Pha v sr cho be wr : a a geo we 'Gs os ord bl es eB wey HE eg : M4 6B 8 uy so » 5 Q cs cs o % :

wt Gy 77 Go Ch oe . ct rot va at s ap a Oh oot a "4 od be oot a " cet veel oa w Oa a es « % wD a4 ae wn 4. yo "e _ Pa x 4.3 mo kt i Shs oO 4 ct & fo ba g oy x 3 te 3 Rho a & » @ o one m0 8 is 4 iS < a a) mM wrt G @ 4 2 i a i ti c pet G3 a C O Sea big rss - : % vend Ce cy 3 5 4 é *) Ld > ry . Le £ @ DOM é a oe as 3 % = gh w me 3 5 od * ry Soa by c "0 ; ; 4 vied A 6 fe aw me Dt ve @ ~~ O " ae ss od 4 SS 4 5 wen x o2 2 Oo ie wt G ra 2 2012 "> i a3 x + OA No, 28 ay :

ook xs : w @ t 0 wy w D i vot ee J an oe ad ao ved a Y £3 ub i + hed rH oD rt ' be re?) iG cs 3 iG os w ood : 4 w sf ey ba ct re Le * it os no G hea 5 C2} G C i ey re nm med i i 3 + -

4a Med ht ae 5 4 8 i i ny 2 rs x q a G O Ct es f } at a , 3 oh 6 53 ee - ved Oy oO eg , Fa i vet be O hy . wok , ay ats ' ced a) Ad ot wD 3 : 83 ; oe € os ee " " Ry 44 "4 Shed ae 'a im & es % o oe cs 23 its u C oe be ts) 4 in 44 * L4 Be wn peed ed 4 oe d a 3 OB oo 0 a 8) vot ea Os ri ay st @ es Gi ho 8 7 a ~, - a 4.3 eet iy i} ad 4 * co 6 a a fs cs of a ry ce bi i} st 0 c be hat a bed a 7 a t ct co ' - in ba Bog a 2 ) « i as rd od G ws 'Be q "hs gt a 3 Ss i 4 a hes hed toe » iE ¢ - ' a : a D i Card io c ws if. ft a. st tt 4 2 "a a ® # £5 foe rs <4 2 4 ay wt At ad " "

od oi 'is & a 4 ot wea 2, & 5 ord mm " te, ip & o o ba a MM a ted C * 0 ' o hed 2 oot 2 bn us % Ae C3 o ra ha + 0 @ bea gt " £ rsh ve a feed a 7 ont " 7 ue as 4 4 ot *

-t 4 to pet oo An O TH '4 . 3 oe ts . F Kee et at eo oe ee me Oh oe i a we eas '4 ae ro B <6) "ey ref 43 ot " Ww ve iS a a4 oc "4 of cy pe rat nt " 2 We w i o uo Bu rm - M4 as wt aS Ld weed i 4a oO et 7% Be 13 = Vv ' v ns G a " $4 % iG 2 , EE se o nel fea oe a Ei & 3 fan be Med i a i $3 wD et a) ra os Seed + MH Aa cS : B a AS 2 ef; OQ 3 v Go ted ert Vp my w 3 o Dy wh 43 H 4 m 4 O oi AS 4 & q} i ws go 3 ka x i ws 43 G 4 oe uel ii Sa w ved ad i$] Th het tS a sacl 4d e4 : : 3 ° 3 a 8 a a sh OG 8 D "rt nS ob wy wy A a oped veh a ha ve fo oe bea ah re) e werd 3 cs ea oan G Oe -- a y : ont : vt ood St 1G iy Let : c {3 4 CC « as 5 3 ot v wd whee a ry ae iy sat * a A Get Oo: ce a4 3 oH ; tS as ~ ~ weed , ay 7 ty 42 % wo it wo vy @ = a f us on Ly g wo vf ee '3 Hed mn (OB yw G 8 y vA OF OO a3 sy ee) a 3 02 oy at Pe 3 ef @ vee - A fe xe oi oA eo ty 4 mf oy Se "4 ee 33 he th vet 3 ot " Ae " vr ved Q ec ve ped het a $4 rj 4a od ie g ww DB Va 4d A t oe . n O jt Ps) & 5 oO ao) a on au x x ve $ c CU ooo og SA red ct co " be Ey 43 & @ ee oe ° a ' ve was x © cy yr i] a we * o 7 Pe 3 a % fs it 42 & "tee ip OQ tea ha

- i ~ "

in ie "eo G @ ® : 1 ie ti oe ba aan bed | 5 D cg Mt "A a Gh "a 2 * ay gs 2 Bf i 3 oO 0 mF je a 3 BR i . ie oF ted cs vee "4 ns Lo ih & he Gog bef mo Uf os hed oy , eee O} b 4 t @ ap ay 3 o2 uy cj a a vn ed . Ra xn ee ° . Be GB 4 +3 qh sais Ta . TAY an veg te ie a ws g Gi $4 Ye @ a JS Foe 3 $4 oS a r vet oe ah £3 shed ra} '4 4 oS od bed . nee abe fae $3 et ~ oe ee cS we +s] 4 Set gf } 58) fea wd vit ts woh ' Js Ls 3 + fan be 03 G oe) "

a 5 of Hoo oD he sed ort aa Soy ta ae Ae 6 . w CH G ae) 3 reed o oe ae * c a On 3 a ~.

5 So v4 7 vy Q ved @ S44 Q 4 pe - itt he {3 i) int my i eid $4 ce oe 2 ny i DB as) a ay Be 4 y 0 bef ord ™ x cs sis) ra) GB Ww vet 3 i fy ay Od ed 4 O 44 {A} 3aykumar) ge 4 we mber x 3

- ¥ we 2 8 {BR wry wnt sear ey eT oy a a Singh) NW.

Member G7} ~Aet + 6 mR.

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai

Ram Yatan Prasad vs Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited on 9 August, 2019