Karnataka High Court
Sri Chandrashekaraiah vs Sri Renuka Prasad on 2 December, 2009
Author: V.Jagannathan
Bench: V.Jagannathan
ER" "1"£~£E§ E-£E€;§}§ a:::e;::i,§m OF §%?{AE?:E'«IATA}§A 9:3: BANGALGEEE Dated the gm dag: sf December 2009 :BEFORE:
mg HC>N'BLE2 :vm.L:":;$-mzg : §x'.JA{}Ai\3'?s§23§i'§;;i}§}§:"' " 4% fiES€_TELi;AE'~§EJ_i;}Z.}S F1R:'.{§'1f_APPE;5§L ,{;;;;nj::3% {«;;::;><:f§ ' x V BE!FWEE'N' :
1 . Sri Cha11dra.s.h&ka3:'aiai';,_V_v"" ~.. V_ S/0 Late Rajashc:karappa,a._ V' _ Aged T7if2 years, _ "
R/3; {(331131}: '\.?i1;§ ag%?:, . _ V Eiagiigeiaaifi Pa11(:Ii21_i;,21€j1,%__ } Yeshwanthapura Hebij, .v _ .. -
'Vishwan6§;cEam Ptifii; E3;:211}ga1'i:};"@-' §€f3»{iii3'§i E.
2. S1:1:.i§121§:'z;.¢;i3f5sIi'., * 1.; '\¥,!.3L,3I£€'--; pa",-» . v Aged 50' vmage, iiédigcfiafli' Faiiashégigiiij, Yes%;wantI:.ap::I1*3 3193311, 'V'ishz§ifa:1ced'*aJ%:1"F?'é3:; Ba:1gai0r€n3é£3{}9 3. , A :3. ~ '5£Smt.Ei'$maVatii;§,¢ .
A V" E} }..;é:,Ez:: Gurumaiiapa, " Ag-_;='-5:cf'i~%:"3;"+'e fi;c>._a1"s, R/a Karmafii Vifiage. K<_}€iig;c:i£::3f;H3iv"Panczhayath, . ""¥'6sh;s%:;t2i}:apura fiabii, "-.._'v'is_§';*;a;-'.ja3*1e6da1:: Past, Ba1:1%}<:r€-;§61€}{}'}L K ' " * , L S§:"i'V§iédaii:1gaswam}=:
V "fa Laicfi Guru:;1aiZa§3@a:, figed 34 years, R/"*3. iiagmaifi Viiiaga, Kadigshaili Pa11chaj,:a*.:i';., Yczshwanfizapazra Eiebii, 'ifish:z:a::E€d3;11 P3315, Bangaisre-565%? 3,. SE1:/£'»§az)3_a:ha,, E} /Q Lats {§m:"mnafia;;3§}a_, 9»:
L ¥-mi Aged yaars, R/' 3%: Kannaiii Viiiagfi, §{<:><:iig<:3*1a3_'li f"'aacI:1ajs?a{h, Ye$§£"1wanti1apura Eiabii, _ _ "u'i5h*=.§='aI::2edam 1333:, E&':;*"ig.a:EC)!'§"5{$'{:3'{:}'§}};._....._" » Sri €3m'usE1anti18.;3;:)a.
Sfa Late Gurumaéiappa, ;
Agefi E51} _vear*:;, £3'./at Kannafii '%ffi£ag€;_ '7 v E<Z0::2ig£;hal1i §'a3::chayat}:z, ' ~ ' A €sjt"1wam':I::apura H::3E::1f._._. A .. . A . 'v"i3h2<:anac~:&3;n Post, E3a_i1;gaiare':§€a{§G*§l. Snmsiaaradhaznma. _ = Efiifa Lam Rajashéfizgragf-pa,A _. Since deceased 1:339 {Rs *7? {$1} :.t9""?iVi:ij:}~% via}. 3:3 1\f§;E€.Si1i'Jakufl3aiA,f.__ % x S,' '3;;::;;?;é%: Ra_jas}:£ka:ra;5;§a,_ Aged E;$_--.jsea:'$, /at giffld firass, i§,R.;R::r3Ci'--,-- }Eéa:éf"« .§:}€}}Z}ifi2 'Light, 2x!E~s;gz:::f§.§:_fE'fm1::*1 §€3:;"n.ana.?gara .Dis¥;ric:, ; V E%2E. E?;..~.§"ag a;{:i:§E:; S Q, Lam §?_aj.3;§;E1€i§arappa? Aged 9%?' §:€%a:'s, RA,/'at QM *-Cress, R.i~"€';.§éfeag£__, ifiear §{}¥I3;€ Light, Eagadi Towrx, Riaznazlagara Eistrict, if§9w1*i Shaniiar, '-§'_3j,»*' <3' Lats Eajas§1@kara§pa, ' ésgaé £8 yams, Rjat 12%" iimgs, §%,§.§Ga{%, Near Dame Light, ' Magadi 'f'0¥:11, Ramagmggra Eistricii .. .AppaEiafl:s { B}? 31% <3.P.§}%1a3}m'1ja}:a_, fidvetsata 3 : fiE*~§' 3;
Sri Reszuka Prasaé,
3 f :3 E<Iar§ba::3app3., , j §f~§-Eidéiaramailrga (Raid, 'f'a§'1S:Z§s:i3:i*§ §%.g€{§ ahcmt 43 jvaars. R13: Nafiéi,/4. I Masin, 3, Grass: Gppagiic Gavcmincnt Scho Kamakshipaijva, Bangaiere-5€5(}€3?9. Smt.J'aga§ambii<:e, B/0 Lattiz Siddagangappa, Major, E-{fat N0.€:34~'$4§, 1 Bahifid Munaipai Quarters, ' ..
Szibhashnagara. N'e1amangaiz'£._. V" « _ Bar;gaisr€~E>62ii23¢ T ' SH 1I:.Si1ivarat3"ma, D/0 Late Siddag3;a.g3ppa_, " :4 A/iajar, F1,/ai: i'\f0.7;E€:Ti; _ i ; Nethaji Féiagam, ChQ%;ka$3§;:d.r;=.;~:.,V " V v "E'.i3asarahaEii, Ba;':'ga£{ir$4':3§§j3£}fs'? "
D g' 0 Haj"; §;;é-zzsapgga, "i's-.i';;*s._"§s:;;--~--, ; <:;iqE:s::;a;::g:=:a ";§::id:a1fig;ia.«.M.&_%.,,.M 4-€31 €:'L::*t_;$-:f:,_ 'fifiégyakgizagafirag §*%:é§IE1§ii{'E';'§71i:}?if}§€A3L; .;B'€:Mti*gaE€>i*e--55€}{}'?'%3. S1nt.';'7.aSz1:1t§*:a. .. " A _.
V 5' 0 Iiaié l_b5a13a};:;§a-, Majm", A "~-.;§sT£?'o:sE<:i3agara, fiih ?§.:*§a;i.n, " ~ _2'}'?.i {:%.I'fl'.$$é',v fi'u::1ku:'~E§'Z?2 £33. .A ' ''-f§n:i;§i''(:z:ia§aiE'1ag _'§§;"f_Cs E 33336 ii: imaram >'a:1::.§; Z'~«i§:;3;§'<L3;1'°,Rj'a§; fiéafafiaiafira 'éiiiaga f€3;i.*.»:*Sa.n:§;"3. {3}}, Sam? S:.zb~«?o:3t, " ' =Ba::ga:er€--§52 22?, Miss Raga, {E10 133% I~<::1::;a;ra:3ava_z:1§,g §%z§7i;1eI*».§ jsyeara, Rep. by her maths:
Smaiiamalatiza ag E'é'atura} Gtzajrfiiazi, R13: féarasanéra Viilage, Narasa3::zs:i:*a {gar} S{::E2_.:r Sub--?{>si'"., E§angai0re-;'"§52 E12?' 8, ;ién1t..Efi:naia:'::bik&, D/{.3 La 3: Rajash€::§~:;i.i*ap;:ra, Eviajbz', Eéijat 211'? Crass. Rfiifieazi, N63: Domr: Light, Eviagadzlg E3aI1ga£01'€»~E>£5i3 E2131.
9. Si1i§.H€I1}aVa1Th.':, ._ D/<3 Late: Rajashekarappay _ Majer, Rijat. ;2f"i Grass, E?:.R.Ef<:sa£;.§ ; * N63: Dome Light, Magafi, "
Ba11gai0re~5§12 12%;}. V 1%}. S1111:.iI1dirag1i, _ _ Dfa Lats: Raja3h:%_k"a2._ra§2;pa,V _ _ M:«'a._ia1; R/at 2% arm, §%_,:%:..§2oac§;;, % Nazzar Dc»zz1<:VL-igkii, }'_u;'_;:§gadi_,_ L " "
Bar1g3i9r€~_;'3£E».f2 1;;;s:;:. " -
ii. Sri .
S/' §:*;_Lat:%a $c§23;j;_a:sh=-é 2:31' ?§};p5.3_ V Aged aifi-3;':.:t 423 figears;
R;'__at -.§€Q..€:;;",."'2.%i<i }}g£:ai;:';..2w3 (Xmas, 29¢? Siagcg Pipciifl-6, \z?§j;é}*;%;éf:;a:g*,"gLi'3,="Ba11ga}:>z's»:"}éiai)(}4£ZB., ii Szff. Nag8J;:1'1;a,.;* .. / ~11; Sri {Eta-Ezbvfigppa, "§{{f_ija1:"*§€jat §?\§0.Y§~£-éé§, 3" Flflar, , uBasa:;:+§::. 3"*~f}a:d$n, 4th Crass, Pipelirza, " Eizizaéifgsxfifarag §a11ga§<"21*e-56{)i;Z?{}:3' :3. -,_SI1;%:.E§;a§4%:§at§1Vamma, 2? fig Laia Basazrarajappa, fiéaggr, Rgat £*€e.K§«;";=-i7& E5?» B3903?
2. AA .._§_'§§"?1 Majiia, Rajajéziagara, " Eéaxagaéarauéééfi ii}.
I . ..E?€<::s§;:»0nficnts { B3: Sri i}.§~I.E*vi::2£(i1a$hig Acivscaite far (LE/E1. } Mi5:::€§ia13ee:1$ firs: Agapeai fiied :}:1::ie3:r.{}r{E§1" 43$ Eiuia §f::'j§ 9.? the {3E3"{f'i: againszr Liza <:r:i.m* iiatezi 3 E,,E},12€L}{}3 passed {)1} E.;%,§'%'3"9.i2: in i.3aS.ET"§G.?8%}j:2{}{)7" an the fiia the ?ri. Civijé Judgé {SI".3z1,}, Bangaiere Ruraj _3f§i$t:;f:ef:, Ba.r:ga3<:2i*e, ali<3Wi3:1g the EA filfiii unctier OrdeI'__:3lT9 and :2 0? <;L'§}<;: far T21, This appttai coming on fair':
court éeiivereé the failowixagz Heard both sides? p:'e;f€1'"r€{i by ciesfe1"1<:i21:1I;s.;m4<%§f:"3::}' the: order passfid by Aggfifivgd 5}; mg Ve::;{'}i§;"'cT. xi'; the af(31'6HI€I}UG};'3.€("_§ <:ié:¢fend$3--'1t5s4_h3vg {;%;{:11_é' 4:.;::r i:1--~ appeal __% ';£""§1<.% ict::a1V':2e:€i$<°:<3*::1§1s6:i far the 8.';if)€Eia1'£'{,S suimiizis Eliza '{f1T§fi;:i '~i:{}uft was in arm? in ganting an Ofdfif ef ;%:1*,.fé.i:i3~Lz3" 91° the :'<?:sp:<;:1:is::1i~piai::iifi" and if,
--V did "fi"'§;iI3.'7{Z1Gi'.€'§ 3f the eariier §mce€§:§;:1gs §}€E§E?fifiEE $325 "' ~,S§&i'§i=!ij:n pértiea in mgpeci: cf tins gains gubjfict nzattsr £121"
-- '€;E:ga Si1i€'; prepartg inasmuch as the piajfiiifif flied 3 Suit in .'{3,S»..E%§a. .£.E:{}€}i;'2{}€34 bafors {he $9131': at Pviaye Eiaiig Ba.I::gai::3:'a, 3:151 in the saézi suit, an appiifiatifiza was fiifié Lifiiififii' éQ§2:"{i€:"* :39 §%1,§%i anti ;.2 sf "E316 £,Z'i*§'~"AT:. £93" Q%3'a.*-:1': e:3f i§"ijL1I1C'E§£31"i arid tbs saizi app§;i<:at.i0::_ was 2"<:j€:{:§".5£E a}:3.a:E aggieved by the said ardefr. the piaslzafltiif pr¢:f«5,f:%;5€::i_:'j~31*:
agpfiai befare ifiéis C<m:"'i; in M.E5'.£%..E"~§0. . the said .¥'vi}3"',A, was aiscx dismisségi i"}1e:%el'L}§s' --- %§e1:fzt':1:ing tha er<:£6r 05 the Erie} £0231': .E'€f'L1S§fi§f', t5§"g;?aa1:1::.i1'1j:i1*:t<f£;iE::1."' if Aftfitr afi {base f':?V€fliiS.,V ";:t£air;5u5;£5'_ fiied the §I'®Sr;'§EH. suit ¥;':afe:§2;':.::4_ '~'.:2:i0fi:-- i:1" {ZLS.£\§a. 7'86] 200? and E516 0:106 apgsiicaéiizm unflltsr Crrdm' 3*§ E§ _:'4ies far gyané: csf .il'1j131ECEiOiI"l suit p1*Qpert}; and E1116: €:e'u§'€:. vEi:a.i's.,-.2356 said app}iz::at§:311. fipart §r:::m ihig, "£3.15 §:a'iéé_ é::s.u1'ii;a"a§s0 arms} in aiifiwirag the Said appiidgaiifin wifirz §f:____f:3u11d frgm 'thfi pifiadings Q? the pariégs the gariies admi: thef: registfireé wiii §§2t;é{i..'1f§ , fixfifilliéfi by §%u(irsm__z_1n3Zja:appa¢ iijraéiegs {.§'12:%$@ " §:§§'Q§1I§}S{8l1CfiS, éfha trig} Cami: €{'§§_E§{§ mm hggva [1 * g3:'eas;eg: .:V;mxi%.::;,2;
€33": 33¢ afi;*u:::* haizdg Eiifi: Eearufid. 5393:2333 far 1315 A " fesgaszadeiltwgiainziff a:"gT:.:s{i that the 3331113265 E36 direcmd :9 maifiiéairz $§;a'm$ tgusk ti