Karnataka High Court
V Ramesh Kumar vs The State Of Karnataka Rep By Its ... on 28 March, 2011
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
EN 'FfHEi H1C%}-{ {'I(f)UE{'"f' (L) F K;XRNA'I'A.K.A AT 8 AN G ALQR E 1:a:»;r}:::> TE-I"iS "mre: 2.;;"" 11am' Q14?' :vm1::<:L;~~~2:i;:;j ' - "
I3 I67} I?9(})I3?. {ES mfg H();N'18L,}§%I %\--'IR. .ILESTIC?Ei 13:'i§.,»5§'i3i:E£if}:E}_;'i'~:» wkn' Pl%;Z'l'I}'I()N Nt;-144-1 921 m4' 2:1¢}4 BETW_E1E;iN: 3 A .
V. Ramexh .Kurnar, T . A.
$10 Late Na Veiakatz1:'z1vzzggzg ' vv
Agedahout V_ .
BurLrdz1gunte
ChiEakzzEztnézifguii_~}~ji{:-17;}??? " '
C'hinE:».1m21ni a=;:1.w.11::;A,? ' _ .. A 3.
'K01mg1j5§t;~'ic:;}+~ 135;; ~ j A . , ._Pf}iT_ET1{)N££R
("By Si'1vvf*i.«A .. :;i\L(;1§T~I§C£1iC)
AND: ° '
$112-lit? Of"'~--';:m2:1:;t]~;2:
._¥%§';c5p;f<:§:;;:.;*;i<:c1 by its SEi€I.'€1L.£:£I°}~"'_. T. EZi}.1'€$vE:i'{i.{'}fi Dii3]T}£;i:'{E1'1(3BE M EL « ?';i'.§: B'L§fidi1"Jf,:§, _'£3:,1ng;1.--§€$;f{: W itm Oi} 1..
'§7.!'aj€ Ce.)m;1'1§.s;::;é.m1e:.1f mi' Pzélbéée:
§':2..<;$;m:a:i£:'x::e:; in f<:.:1E'§32:Eai§<;;1. " §3::.%>E§s:: {}f§'Ec::sa {:29 ('J NI'LI:£}.:i[.h{§§Eg£i Rm;-iii, Ii3a11g2:1<>:'e ~ 560 002,
3. The mix]: {7)i.::e::t0;' of Pzibiiic E'I1_s'e;t11:c£i<>§2s, Bang;=:10;'<: I")i\/isiam, (M) Cf<u::n:'nis;>;iL>m::" m"PL1%>1i_c I.n;<;m1cti0:1s in K2-tmaitgtkza, New Pzibm: (_)f"fi<:es:;.
E\E:'upat1H1:';g:;1 F{osz1ci,;
8;.-u1g21l<.)rc:. ~ 560 002.
4. The Dc:.puE'y Direciou" of Pubiic I'11§t'1'L1cii<'>:::§,*..,_ K0131' Distyéct, "
Kolan'.
The Bloszzk" 'Ei:~11gc~:-Mn221 ~<3:'i*i:;:%j~ AA Chi l1E:'-&i'IV1'.'§'i«1]i1:?-£§j}V11§§,<.__ __ v. _ 'J1 Cili rTii':m.1i31_1i _, "'3-EV " _ E'*{<>E2--11"E3i.>;tri§:-E..,A ' .
6. TheVV'E3..:;Cx:3ta1:'"}? _ . ' E?i;2.1*z:] I:{'i_g11'S<;5E_1c2<'xI.;
' ' B_L E.i"L§(}.a1gii§;fi(f',. .. _____ .. s . _ C'h{i:3t_ii::n;1r1i Tzzhik, " » T%%1<:<:;1m#'::zVis:;m. )' §RESPC)N£)I:iNTS {B};Srxét. R?:=;.2~'é2t}zi A<§ir:;1i'I§ N;1.:"::1<::._ Higgik Ccmyt (}<:\::3:'1m';er1£ P}:-3:ié;§:z1'v'«f'§:..:t:' 'E?;::s_s;.:<>:1:§:3:1£ ?\§<;>,i ta: 5} w " j( .:{}§§§§§'.§{L1{'§{.}§é of E'm;§§;': gm-':.yix1g {£3 ::;a:21:';h tile :"};'d€.':" Ligiicii 23,} §¢3{.}{_}€_} §,"}§;}.3%fsi{fd E33; _¥'{::s;;3<m{is:;2: ?~«lz;_3 wEf:i::E.% E'<':rm:12:i<3cE K' {:2 'Efii.<.; \='\=":'ii{ Petition is; §31<:d. :m<_§e~r g5\.;'t'i<.;:l{:s:; 226 :-md 227 91' by {her 4"' E'{:3$:;f><'s;'";:.'i€::£' 2:5 pass" 02"d<:.::' Lizzieai (){_}n{'-)1:-;?x(}{-3f vidzc A :1 11:: X. LII'€;3~ :11'1<;i eic, 5 This Writ P<':ti.ti.<m is c:om_ing on Em' H:::11'ing;_ tl1i§i'«:>l.;i'3,; 'ii)t:
C('}Z§I'i §Ud,€1{'3 Eh:-3* flyléeiwizég: >' ' ' ' ()RI)ER The ;;>1'r.:s:<3m pc:Eété<)mt1'>'; f;1the';.j x\:;_::';T ;j£;>p<1:.i11i<2&' 215:' f4-.._C'iA2;;ji.% Tezicher' in the: s§E.>::h :'<:sp<>nda=:n1: 4-.g:du<:z'i%;v§0;a.a}. i1'i&;_£§:~:;;tvi«z}.1'1VV $22 year E991. It is an aidcjgd é;3stét_1.r.E'i§:'i.3_2171;} &E(1l1§.i'{:I.€:(§ §c.;§ g:'21ni~in' aid. Tm: s<31*\:ic<::s of the 'i"'a1Vt1*;€:s.'"ojffih:: ;5é:L:'Vit»i.g>A1"1e;- wemt <:01'1fi1'1ned by the imnfth_:':2§p<an<.ie§§'ét éieiit-£1 26.7.1993. The ;3€:tii.iué1e1i'--.s'i";1t}1t§:'"'E;':g:§w§;ismf"dim"is"; {Em ;x'e:»,-11' 5993*}. immcciia.tei;,-I t§r1e.1'<:=:2i1'tr::f'».§h£:, péi,éti:>.1'1'e:i '..'i1a1d :11:.1d<': an appficzition seek_%.ng :tpV;;f::im:}é.e1jt z.}i*::"*' «mgjwpas;s«;.%0n:-:t.«3 §;1"<_3L:.r1d:s wiih the fmmh V :::::=§ipLs';_:1'«:1:;:iit » 33.16 §3:':titi0:ar:::' we-2:5 Eh<:1"<:;2t'£e1' app<.>i:1t::<i £0 2: s;;:;_z<fti<_>:1g:fi';§.:§s'i <3?" g;:"<..>up *1)' C§"I"£}_)§(}:-,«-'£363, which was mcami fs'iI1{3't3 §'l"1s:3 };é:a:tf7~§994 a-ind fizz': ;}<:i?;i{i<}';1<,2:">; ;1pp:':%11£.;m::'1£ wags; S6111 'f€73£"
A' 2:;'s.p;f:5:x~=z:E %;§; {has <:<:»:."n}7:::3.t<~:ni; ;'m{§1<")1'i'{§,«*. "Eh: $2113.25 E1ma;<:vcs' 'W218 3 $.10: gxfzzzéienl and ii is that Mzich is :~;<'>ugh¥; :0 E35 q1.1t3Er;'{i{}i"I<;3d in the
f)I'{'3-S€'31'i{ petitirnn, 7? "Fiat: .r:':s:p()11<§c11:s: h.2we entcmsd azppearaziags"-u--~.' s:t2:te1nc:11_I <)1'i.>b§c:cii<'>:as. It is £3€)I1i€-§'édt'3£i {h;1.'a~--.i.r{:"::¢1':*11$ 0? th£:.~.. Gm:e.1'mmn£ C)1'd:31" dated 2,2.'2('){){T3. issuefi-d? j§:z1d:§f A£.h€:- E<:ixf'23;1m~};"
E,<;iLtC3tic>n Am... {he s;;:111cti<>nc;~:-dT_s§Er¢:1gthfi"sf ;,;;-«imp A'E7)'««&3Viffl.f3;E.(Z§}f€3€-. ' is cmly 011:': in.<;'0%';1r as the V1fé;:s;T;";<_>._::Lié:;:a{ 11<'§.~*'?:~,_ir1§€imti<>n C()I]C€i"1}£Zd and since: it \ix21':; é:L§__n%.:a£i}-' 'gap by {he fe1,1r{%"; respcmiient, ihe,. pt')::{ h{:fl_d .by..:ti":§:-.";§t:--%;it.i0n';:::V'was an addi£i02';ai post, §,é'\§*11i:iV}1" ;s§z11_iCtAi.:<"'h'I&3d ;£fii§'t11e1ie.f<>:'e, the S"'ai§'fl£':3 11:-as not bean ;1pp:j(3*a='ed by ilicw.rés:.g5i?:»nr;i€n{s. It in fine with the abm-'6 axial.»'C§.c>fve1*nii;sn1' C}i'd<=:i*- gmii §'1e.1'1<:c:§ EIh<:":F€ is no i.:zfi1'n_1.it'y. 'I"h<:: Ee.a:"rié'§'lA c<:»uns.:cI. far the petiti{>ne':", or; the Qthczr h£2;:_:z;i ; v'a.:~*'.é{f;§:v1'V<,¥,.TE.:.}:v*'way of reply :~;ubm_%i: that {E33 {§mie:'2'1:11<zn.t 01' Kéi?-&Ei§2.i1i..2i;." 'ET}}' its n<>§§'£"is::;1%§<:a;": aizxéeré E_€}.¥ E..2{}{)'~}. has; fyaziéfztsai ':':J;:::~; ::;iM.ed £115: K£iET¥'i;iE';1§{;§, §id:;z<:;'z.Eé<>n.z:E E:1_ss;1;§_:u:%_<m:-s {Re3a:ruii:m<3:1'£'
--;::1s:i"'§':3s'n";s; aiiéaé COE'§{§§i§£f:sE§.§~: (:5 S€:.:"v%<:@ 2%? €z':2.;3§«:}§r':::::s; $5: p2:'%v:1§e 3 (3 I?-{air-:.<«;. :2g">{wi§;%.":s;;£;1:'1<i$3155: ibail 111:;-::":: is; no mc:;1n<:§r in the:;'. fc"sL1r"§E'z r::sp:>1z<§c.;1:. M i11stii'2.2tion and iiéii 1'c:;}1'{::§t:1'1té1{i<")1':. 01' ihf.' p€:£%té.<m<:.1"
shezll ha: <:<313s;ide1'<.,:{i cxpc<.ii£i<_>L';;xl}; by {EC {;<>1'np::i:::;:i :2L1_{%3:'s1'ity with r<3.f<::'c':r1cr:: to the :m1er1C:ed RLIECS am} in {Ez«c"V..1f1':a11'1":1e1f prcs<:::"%bed Ehflffiiill in :%cc<__>1"da1"1<:<:: wiih Eziw. A 3? V