Karnataka High Court
B S Suersh Babu vs The State Of Karnataka on 7 January, 2009
Author: V.G.Sabhahit
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit
{N THE HEGH comm' 0? KARNATAKA AT aA;~s;c;A:;;;§.:§E; A' %
DATED 'FHiS ms; 1% my 09' JA:azUA_1;>;.Y j 29¢?' _ 3
PRESENT
'ma H{}N'BLE MR. 9.3 mwA£<AR7Ar¥é','«Cz«1§E;§?¥'.;:i§S*;?%{'::_:»2:'"' V
Ana?
THEE H::~:~s';3LE :2s§R';J{}'3f?§{f::%-V_m';ssgéaggaag'
3;:-,§:;?:1'§5A:§§¥:P§:§§.;i,1:s:{';s.-.ig:?;;§i8; 2933
BE'rwE:;E?¥: % %
3; BS SURE'?7§H__EA§1§_ -- '
A¥£}E}Z}_ A;B{}¥.f1'i"'~:'":S5 .ifE:A,R,.<.3
sgua S sR.E:§;N'wA8_A' SASFRY
RA1:..w,AmV 5;'-:2ma':ss-~ ROAD
;_'<:Hi:\zTa.;<e2AN£' '
,3'=2.<::§;:c§<8ALL;a?i".T::»2 DES'?RECE'--€$é3 125
* £2' " £~*%v.»?§§*i§*;?eri§¥E?ULLA :<§-ms
;«.<z:}E.:;j Agem 35 YEARS
"--~'s;C::;;s'mé: SATTAR Eifiiaéé
:31' CROSS, CHQWDARBDDY PAL-YA
§§i1NTgMA;¢: COMMQN
<;§:;§=<:KBALLAPUR ms'r£:<:'r .353 i25..AP?ELLAI'«§'§'S
PE.§¥'E"FiGE; R RAMESH j:
1 THE'; S'i'£'{}'§2 OF' KARf'%'ATfi;§{A
BY ITS PR§¥\§{3¥?AL SECRETARY
{"3 K VENA§§ET%ZSE~i§¥A Raaafg'
PRGP: SVMX "
VENKATESHWARA E3XT,ENSI{}£'€3
CmNTHAMaNI '
CHECKBALLAPUR' D:sTR'i*§<i§'£'» 3553 125 T
BSSRISHAR
MAJOR - .A
MANAGENG ¥'AR'§'?~¥Ei5%,,B S'3'RA?%.$??}R'f3
3sKCHom::'RYA'"""' ' " 1
PAVA(3~A£3'£'««.. _'-- _ g ''
TuMK1.,r;2 D§;s*;éR§..,j 551 2_{.3Z§ V
E) L SAQRSEQVA RE'.§'D'*¥'__
MAJGAa'::,
£:us_ :>PEI%ATOR .
N{}'.6'{}?,'1€}'¥'H" "C1R'Q_S*fi§_ '
?'mV.._BL%0c;;. s.s;4§:;~:::':' '
JAYAN£%{}AR -_ ' '
'3;z§€GAL;:%g£; Séé $9}:
v3"Ai:;:2:§:;iATAR2£§ziANapPA
" :%;s¢>':«z ._
?«R,%:;~.;1=>'; S'£, N MQTQRS
- "V RA{i§5iE3'}f?=TA?{ALLi ms';-
CH§§~¥TjE¥AMfiNI TALUH 5&3 1:25
' {3EHC§{ABALLAP{}Rfi EESTRECT
§f§LINI S MARE
MAJQR
' " BUS GPERATSR
22, 3'7'I'}~§ 3°; SGRSS
SR8 MAEN, 8TH BLOCK
J;%Y£'§NfiG?:R
§Ai'¥{}A;L;ORE 56:7} 811
12
13
14
15
N RAVEPRAKASH REDDY
Mgwfifi ~
BUS o?ERA'mR,2A, K C Ram fr
BELLARY $83 10 1
K 81} RYANAREXYAEW:
MAJOR
mus OPFERATOR " " *
M/S KUSUM AM{)'}_'{)7?;;S ::;E_ E;
XXVI, BELLARY s33'1c::;£ .'
M §RSE-L429 :%z;_a$HA_
. 'V ' "
BEES O'i?ER'éY:E?{)E V - *
{}'PP?'o's:'fjE '§'»:é§V §:AY;:a§%;A :s%Ai?§;é;*:"r:
{3VHA.LLAKi:§3E;A"~ _ _ ' -
c;}iITRAb:;R{;;_=a_n:$ *-123:3? 3?? 522
S B $I=:AE.na.;§$2i;a1éA~«'51éEuaY
4 MMOR %
_'%B§.ES fZ}PERA'§'{~}:¥'; *
S/£3 S EBEEMANNA
" ». K'v§§[PURA--MOLKALMUR
;,:'§s:*;'.g;«.QarVRGA DESTREC-'T
16
V' "if?
Y 3,2 ;zA§'HNAM camw
3'..v'§AQ-'OR
BUS GPERATOR
" * BYRAGA1\z'APALL£
..=lE$Rif€£VASAPURA TALLEK
KOL-}§.R EEESTRECT $53 135
S SR£D§¥§'aR R331»?
MAJGR
SUE QPERETOR
39
20
2:7,
_ i{';aa'A2éT%£Lg§A;;:u
3%: ME§RUGfiN "§'RA?\ES?0$R'E'S};. _
GEETHA RGAD ' "
ROBERTSON 931*, K G P' 55;?;..,;;2::::~ .3 '
3.3 A EVE MENERATE-ififim M¢§£2a5,IJEYAR"' V
%viAJ()R '-
3:33 OE?RA'§'OR'
SR; BHARATHE MQToR.$'ERv'§:§._.
# 1998, DR RAJ1{U§aiARR{}£%I)'~--.._'a_
BANGALORE} 560 01$
M/S M G B A:§'£*:3;*z'§«S."';:'1vI§i§ PV1* ~i,*?9 %.
REP BY M RAG-H§}EIg§T'_H;~ g:;s_,§)E.i>£2'a;r0.Rs
MAIN RC)AD;BELLARY----'§-831!)1-. '
JAYAMMA "zV:AJ.C.:R "ff
BUS OPERATOR'
D/0 LAT§si;_BAN:~m V
RA.GHUTTANA;;ALLY _
C%~£INTAMANI"TAi;JJK'._ '
cH:c1gfaA;,LAPure;g__Vr>§s*r§2;cT 563125
930?; M;'. S"--Pg{ifi{}i.fSUDH&NA aziemag
GUNDLPET =
" I«;QLA-g 553 1;c>i11
"'.__VENUG€§?£§LA REDS?
;sa2m;:-§
' fi{}§--s.O.§'ERA'¥'OR
. ;RA'J:AJ; Rflfifi
,;SR_Eii'3§VASAPURA
"~ §{ GEAR EKSTREC? 563 :33
"K S SYEB AMBER JAN
24
225
25
MAJOR
?ROP; {W13 8 N' MGTOQS E<i§'fisLAE'€QRE';
KOLAR DISTRECT 563 191
K R MURALIDHAR
MAJQR
BUS QPERATGR
REAR JANBA KATTA
GOSHALA ROAD
RA§CH{§R 584 1{}1é.3~.__
13 M BASAVARAJU '
MAJQR '
BUS GPEE=iA'1*'f_}R I
S/£3 1,,A';'"f.I§i (§Hé;%E.§'é';%BASAP_PA '
OPP 150 sfiT;':*rL?:_._wA£<:«._E,f 'i«§Q:_is'E: '
Bansdazém R{T:P's}.3 '5.' ._
BEL-~L»f:\R5*;.' 58:3, V193.
SLiBBAr»41§§Aj'-~ "'
Maxofa
?Ro?..u5'§:;aNALA§<s2§.:a5§: MQTQQS
_ -N, R E:-§';';1?:3~e'::§V1--:):~:
. c:HIN*i'HAMAN:
"c2:isc;<g;BALLA'§5L%R m:s;'mc'§* 353 :35
/. §i:'.
é " ' Iv§j"i?v:GA'§¢.<§$P9A
BUS OPERATOR
VI3NI<L?§TARESHVJARA MOTQR SERVICE
*2' VWSHWANATH RAG ROAD
was HAVANAGAR
, "BAI*€GALORE 560 cm
ANANSAMMA
MJRJGR
29
39
8}.
W] O LATE K G JAGANNATH
PR()§'; S N MOTQRS
CHECKPET, DODDABALLAPURA
BANGALORE DIS'Y'R£C'? 561
E V MADHSSUDAN GUPTA
MAJOR
BUS OPERATOR
M/S s L VTRANSFGRT' A1
48, PARK RQAI} * '
'E'E,?.2V/IKUR 5?; 1:)?"
T' V D.A*mNz§;§:_if>A _
MAJCSR .
PRQP;"'SRiS«HAIL..,_"i'»i{}'§'{')R_SE%i?"%'§CE-
<f:HAm'?$AMAN:§}AHIH_ALL§ _
€3}%§TRAVDi';?§E{}fis~ 57:?_ $0 1- -
K z§«1:a;HA.B:~I;afi';é'a1?P";z,""V'
MA;J€J'R 'V V 2
PROP; M;s:.1,m<:AR.5L§NA MOTGR SERVICE
"<.@3ANa%_H;NAGA--:~;>----« =
é " clézgi, M45123 %
" f.'Z£HETRTA§E¥.RGA DISTRECT' 57? 522
" P As: :ém:§ANATH
MAJQFE'
BEES QPERATOR
SE%.§"HAN{}MAN MOTOR SERVICE
" ._ S§RA, TUMKUR msmzcr 572 13?
R P ABDUL GRAN}
MAJOR
3:53 OPERATQF2
# 7, W . 9:0. 15
PROP; BLAH; MOTQR SERWCE3
34
35
36
.37;
BELLFRY 583 19}
R VENKTAESHAM CEEETTY
MAJOR
BUS OPERATGR
M/S VENKATESHAM MOTG§T:'SERV§€§.T€» .; V
GANBHENAGAR
KOLAR 363 10}
MAJOR _ _ . »
PROP: H'AI~3'?i;?MANi_M€)'f'OR"SE;R%'fC:E
SERA_"..-T'Ei4MiE~;{§'RD§$'Fi{iC'? .
R;éG§£UT'TA§'~§3§LLY ., _ .. % 1'
CHIEJTAMAM .
_C§~IECf{BA'LLf'il.1*Ui¥§' ?;}~§'S'§'R§CT
fix; SHEV}§SHg'---'é§KAR
' MA;3€}}€«._
" " --- Tsgfi !'~fiNJ-EJNDAPPA
3%,: $38313-$--v'BUS SERVECE;
. ' 0913 --3j;+.L.;sL AUTGMOBELES
NEAR 31,33 S'I'2§§*€D, <:H;mTHAM§a§e;
'V V' .. 38
'JHEICKABALLAPUR
ye SARQJA
1..-'MAJGR
W} G S:%.THYA?§1§RAY.f§§'§Et BEES O?E§?A'§'QR
PROP: BALAJ§ T'R£NSPGRT'
MADHUGER
TUMKUR' DESTRECT
39
48
4}.
42
M S SHANKARAYANAYAWA
PRGP: BALAJT TRANSPORT
MAQHUGERE
TUMERER DISTRECT
V VENKATRAMANAPPA
MAJOR
PRORS L N Mo'r=(3:=2..sEI~i2V;_(;&:--.._ .
RA(.}U'}""I'ALLi ' ' _ 1
CHINATAMANITALUK i ._
CHICKBAIJ,-A?UR"£§1'S"£TE!{C'?{:363 ;3;3"»'
UMADEVI 5; 4 _ -
MAJ(i3R .
22:;/0 291%.?'-'C';ar.;axN;)_§cA 'S;-§§,§:A¥e,.%MU R'?HY
#S;k;:H.1;iRc:H::Ag :'«:r3A~:")"- '
£~3HA§ETH1?€.§£{}§%R _
B}';1'%§}ALO.RE.i"2650Q2-'Ef
H H5§{§§ESH A
; :¥iAJGR . '
_' ~''<.;~z{>,bér9f::s§+:*4;12;A..z2..é« Bus
" H'Gj§€N;a;f-%U:Q, MADHUGEM '%'Aw:«;
" " .%:*:,.I_zv;:<';:;g1§' Eiismim' 5?: :32
43.
"='V,¥'E'§Ni{3$E';{_i1I'3*VAL mo
MMQR
BUS OPERATOR
BEHINB SBM BUEDLERG
.. " * MA§}H{}GiR£ TALEEK
__-'E'L¥MKUR DISFRECT 322 232
R V BALAJI
MAJQR
Sm R V CHE???
mop. VENKATESHWARA M€}'TOR SEERVECE
46
4'?
* 48?%f
'58
GANDHINAGEAR
KQLAR DESTRECF 5&3 101
ABBUL wszm
MMQR
BUS OPERATGR
PRO? SRMS, MGLAE{&L%¢§¥;§§8U _
CHETRADURGA D,:smI<:'f'*E'***:*:;--'.?'j;**-- 53.5
RATH?*§AMMA MA.3{,é'R- "
EUS O?ERaT{}R
we 9 RA_;ME G§'§£f§§¥'~
BOM?vL%;SAi§ff3RA _
M N HALL: z'?.s:>.m_; %.}»I.¥,_J"z.»B&:3?A--3,; 1*A:,u§;
KOLAR EjESf§'Ri{i'§? 5%;:5;.;':5«2..V' '
3'Im'2APz:%A
MAJOR' _ ' --
PR9;-'=,«SR1 ~Si§}§}E;'a-S'Er§%u7A§€A ?vi{)'§'QR SERVECE
B:*3:'€:a'NAKL§::2K'£ »--
V%mMxUR_"5?.2V-.29':
3 P N xB}"%G'E"HERS
§9RAC}?.' CEOPALAKRISHNA MOTGRS
' " V Bus' %ai;3§:g:«:.;3.Tc3R
$zIz%.§I"€,i%{};=;.B, TUMKUR 5?2 :0:
4%
LEELMATH;
Maqag
W'f~G K 5.: MUNERAJ
n 'T §'RQP.VEiERASAI MOTQR SERVICE
.. KB MARAPALLI
SR§NE'VASAI3'i}§ TALU§é
KGLAR $I$I'RE{Z'F 5&3 13:3
P SABASH§VA RESBY
51
52
53
TE":5A:;A*;§.;swAMY
' _?v:'}ۤJQR AV ' _
}**i'?3{}«!? Ii~§;é;P~§-UMAN MGTGE 8E:§VIC£S
11
MAJOR
BUS OWNER DE}V1'~iSA;M{}QRA
MOLAKALMGRS
{f3EfiT§€3§£f}{§RGfi 337? 53%
N M DHANAPAL
MAJGFE .
83$ OPER.fi;TOR'
mmg E3§¥S'?'REC'T' 3&3 :22 j'
vow;
MAJQE$,¥,P3UASV_§51i3E¢E'$.'£'f3R--.3' V .
i31§MBO€3-"EEAZAR. [email protected],=t:H§r;'i*AMANi
C§:§%;_e:I{:'$A';,mE_I3 'D.;ST'5:%3_3 1355
Rs §2Az1AL;1:{,S;iMAN:;wa -
MAJGR ' j
BUsv.o13ER;2T€::?: .
_PAL'{A'i<E;'RE, ' .BA€}£P~;§LLi TAEAJK
; CJEIECKBALLAPUR mm' 563 135
. 19; ;:.23;§<: R RQAB
ow mwcmmugzyi *rm4m.._s2":
E{C}f§E{C3'§E 562114
.3 if 'JEKRAM
- ..--Mg&{:R
35$ 8 G VE;NK}§T'ES§"§
PR6?' SEE V3§3NKA'§"ES§iW,fi§RA Psi{)'F°{T3§3 SER"x+'i('3Ei
NQ $153, R C RQEXD
BA§'~I§AL()RE~{} 1
338
< C4!
gaffi _. V
?2
VASEEELLA BASHA
MAJGR
s/0 NGOREELLA BASHA
BUS GPERATCIR 5
Bgmrm ERAS ms? <3;<'*1.1iI€E:
GOWRZPET '
KGLAR 563101
M V £eUDRARADm"AT-A '-- ;
MAJOR " ._ T
BUS oPE£:A3f;:>R
Maianusfszifi;-' 1 V
'1'UMIf?UR44B£SfFf_RiCT._5'?2 :%.32;< .
B y_AS::§Q'K«:.,__ _ _
ssfo 5J*:}fvEN§{zm3$'H
MAJAGRV " _ ' -
BUS GPERA"EQR
PR8? SRE VE:N'z<;2a3'§:$;;vmRA MQTQEQ gzawéag
_NC% 9A<,.. RC. Ram "
_; BAN GALC2 R3» 1
' R'iI%;aéi-.
A _w;;,;%<>':;?;%k Bug oPE:R;s;§'0§z
N"€Z§"i;'38<§'jvE5; SHE}? N0 1
. SPF'?-?.'£'Lf{ABLE SERVECE STATEGN
§vI§z"Si3;i?;E man
" V. 50
$iég3NNA?A'?NA 5?' 1505
{§M&RE§BDY
..=MA.}OR
G/G PRABHAKAR REDS'?
B33 OPERATOR
M,' S DEWAKAR RG2'-'iDLIE'~¥€S
T£DAPA'T"RZ
ABJBHRA PREEDESH 5 E54 1}
61
62
63
64
33
G K VENKATASHEVA REDBY
MAJOR
31,18 OPERATGR
CHENTHAMANE
CH;§<:KABALLAPuR D:sTRICr;,5V§3 f'- 'V .
P S S!-12EE3I'éA'I"H RE..DDY,<""' --
MAJOR ' ;
33:33 OPERATOR, G'FR"?E€£.¥r7§51LS " .
PALYAK§?';l?ii§_, BAGIPALLE TALJ..If%i"'. 1,
CH¥C1I{Bg5;I;Lz%.PU E1' DI$':"}Q£{jf:*~.§~' -363 23.5
A M I{J31L£¥A~1%H;aMM&L _ H»
MAJGR, --?i§ ;_0. MU;¢';%£;aT'§r1:€A%g1 Maafaazag
'
am. 1898.; .DR ' RA'.3s':¥_%_MAR . ROA3
f<f;z?s.JAJI13€ACj>Eij§?" _ ' '
BANGALQR3 ~{f?=_6£}C§ 11:":
5; H §HAG';A'LA§;.s:éi'M§
MAJSR *
'BEES ;:>PERé;'i'{;»i%'
.'*i§'s1'.€E§E\?'£2'¥gE'é MOTOR SERVISES
.__«'§'i5E\:[§{§}R;'i}ES'¥'R£{f¥' - 572 13?.
6i':S "----
C§{IN;.f£;RAMU
MMGR, 8:33 OPERA'¥'{)R
NG.1-43, 13?? MAIN
'-3&2} (mass, K 3 B CQL,-Q???
-- -7Bfi,SA\?ESHWAR£~1NAGAR
56%
BAEQCEALGRB ~« 5fi{1G'?§.
{Z SR1 N EVASAMU RTE?
MAJQR
6'?
58
59
'E4
BUS C}?ERATC"3R
R P G TRANSPORT
HINDUPUR
ANEJHRA PRADESH 1- S153 291.
R V saeaasacaarmm V' "
MAJOR
BUS GPERATGR' '% _ _
PALAMA?~IER " '
ANEHRA P_RAnEs;;,'{'5V1?;"f_4c§s. .' V
N P Rgcwufigzraisé i
MAJQFR "
BUS <:}PE:R'A'r<}'E:» 4
cz-i1f;f0':3.R' '*-2,, . "
.€;;NaH'r:A;' P;2A':;3Es§;fH..V,}' $*?1 i§é :6
33.3' 3 S 'réA$;js§e.'é*§.."
BY ITS PROFRIEGTR.
sHIN:3{:PU.R
ANADRA Pzaaggsa ~ 515 291.
'§' :'é{s§§2:§§U§;THALA J Rmm'
.Bi3$~.QPE;:éATO§
MA§;;EéAPALL:
A?.!;'I5§§§%A PRAEESH ~ 531? 325
?2
$32! ;RAMAMG§L%E€A {3?§{}%éJ§}§§é§.R§
» V "'~._MAJQR
- gays GPEFEATQR
DE'~§&RMAVARAM
A§'*s'E)§°~IRz's. PRAQESH - 333.5 %'?E,
3 MB ASHRAF?
MA-358
73
P34»
M
an
'£5
BUS OPERATGR
DHAF€AMA'.«'ARAM
;'§3'€B%§RA PRADESH 5:3 13 6'? 1
SM'? V PUSHPAVATHE
MAJOR
BUS OPERATOR
EENGENEERENG COLL,E';€'é:E'.'<--E?_OS'E"
PRASANNAYAPALL; " '
ANANTHAPER _[)ISfI_'§§'E{.3ff' L' »
ANDREA }"_?RA DE&}2H 5315 as;-__
K NAQr":V't3N.1...'f. " '
MAJGR 5 . ¢ r
aLIs_G'§>,E:R£i=?'?§9.5i ' "
1;?AYA{}¥J§?_GA _ ' _
A.:~:Aré?HA::u';R '§3:STR:--53%' -
A1'€BHRA ?R7A£_33€1S§{ 355
Y SUE'E%A}vI.A§*§*YA"v_ V 'V
" _i Ma,JaR ~ V
'~B§,I3 QPERA'*E'®'£E'
PE}§?U.§{{3_NDA
A3s:.{}%£Rg PRAIEESH 53:"; mg
76
.3Afi*;.;s§I§1SH REDS'?
M.5'iJ{*}?€T
QPERfi{i'Ql1'
MESANAPALLE
A' ' A§'»iBHRA PRABESH 5:? 325
H K GQPAL
MAJCR
BS8 CJPERATGR
GENTAKAL
ARDHRA PR}§§ESE~E 51:5 831
78
7"?
88
81
'£8
N V,&SUNDAP-HERA DEVI
MAJOR
BUS OPERATOR
ANANTHPUR
ANDHRA ZPRADESH 515
M/S VENSOR TR-géréspcsmfi 1
BY ITS PROPR§ET{}F€T--A '
BUS C)PER&TOR "
BYE PASS_R(}AD :<;:§~11T9rjc>'{)gj.__' ' . A.
AND}{R:';'; PR5.'DES.H 521:1 om' V.
A RA;:gA%gg:s;m-%%<j: }%*r13{i~A"'-:.: '
M,zf&q0R;. OI§?E?£§'i"{}R._ __
My s{'3Q:-;; B::"s:;"s;E'R.s{1t:Es_
i¥:U§{E:--:%PA'F}:..A;'~%b %
PU'E"I'£'iPE-Z'Tf~I"'{ "1':e1AH_€ mm
ANIEHRA PRAD$3}i "' '
; J C: UMA'§3.E§fiY V'
_""«:.Mgg(;_R " .....
" BUS OPERATOR
L ' % » ' fI"A,DiZ? ATR««f
';::s:;%;.g;;a*.zX-5¥>»RADEsH 515 4: 1
82"-._
E1 V1§;§2:sf.HNAvEN1
§v£A«.}OR
Bus OPERATOR
"'<_ANANTHPUR
_,5AN£}HRA PRADEZSH 535. am
N SHASHZBHAR
MAJOR
BUS OPEREXTQR
ANIXNTHPUR
84»
85
86
17
ANDREA PRADESB 515 091
3%: SOWMYA
MAJOR' :
5&3 OPERATOR
ANANTHWR _
ANBHRA ?RA§ESH 515,93;
U HARIi<IR1SI~}NA R'EiD'£")Y'._
MAJQR " ._ V '
BUS OPEEATQR
*rA31?Av:-'Rs"::~[.\_V-'
ANflif_{RA~ PI§';.;';§L§ 37315;,
_ 'L5 4.1 3 V .
RV MAHESH"s;a.tAR: ..,m:__V; " « , _
22zAJ€J'R~,IB,Us1"{>'PERA*i'QR .
PROP'CIii'}70f;}R »pU.3Lzc TRADING COMPANY
PR--AKASHAM~ :;§:(}1~§__ 13:32:13
CHfiTOOR' 4 .=,
V ;§NDH'£%A 'PRA--DE:3H 6:7 1 00 1
v _ 8',3'v.f SR1 Vténismgsawakg BUS Umimé
' " ~ V ms % €} i?ERAT{}R
.(:HI'i'f1'0C:R*'
ANm:LimT1'PRADEsH 3?: am
as
" :4 VQMANNA
MAJOR, BUS OPERATOR
A' ' c:/0 VENSQN TRANSPORT
V' "S9
JBYE PAS8 205:), CHEETQSR
Al;"ǤIf)'I-{RA ?RADESH 5?1 {E61
P A SRE-ENA'E'H
MAJOR, BUS GPERi'§"§'GE§
(Eff) VENSON '§"RANSPGR'}'
?§
JUBGMENT
These appeals are flied being aggrieveé
passed by me iearued Sixzgle s..,'!u'dg»r:A af iii.-
W. P. No. 1353?; 2003 dateé 3.1 1.25087'.§séEiéréi13,_ '::fi.£ _
Single Judge: has ordezmi Afacis Vtiév-Vréfiéif' gaizght " V
fax" in the writ p:; "tj§__<)n :§;é";:"V:;£~:'3i'~§s,z gfiérgagzaxi ijslief but a rsiief in
puhiic §Ri€;T*f':Sf" .fi1€er¢ff§:fz:., nzaéiéx" may be rmiassiféaé 22$
'?ub1iC §E3:V.E€I"é'S:.E'. '§2<Z}$_§l£'E7;§ fiefsrfi {}i¥'i$§3C}3;1 Efiizcéz
fer fazrifi er._o1fifii*§-,;:r.,»
T135 a;;pcf;1a5;.:_:s"~~':gm§n {tied w.p.z~sm363?;29<>s
«.V_se€§f;ji':3:g;__ ii-tar quéSi1:23::'g of the agreemant ;:e:f€:1'r€{i it} in
rar:={ificTaiioQ1fi { 2668 in Se far as if: relates to Am1exur»::s~
VEEEV into between "(E16 fimt mspond€:1t~«Staie of
and secenci re:sp<:3:1de11t--Stats=: sf Andhra Pmdesl:
V' '.. *:3::Anc;£"'fQ:* a Writ ef maméamus; ta mspeuéaggts 1 and 2 t0
' e:'sg.te:* ifita an agmemeni strictly 3'21 accoréazzce wiiii the
K95
22
respondents as rfispondents were fiat served fiéiih 1:,:;g§ti%§'€%~ : '
the impugned girder data} 3.11.2_{)Q8__was}§é:é駧fi:;i E:§,? !;hf:._V V he-azned Single Jud gs.
6. Learned couzisel ap'§z;§a.fing f«":';»rV_ éigfiéilants seubmittad that the avsrmgnts .itié£i§€'jin "'£}::§: writ' gzéiiiien iisekf wcsuld Show Canéage Permit holdars 3.11 the rsguiét {sf £316 in the wxit peéiiéaia;
that t%1:%:'--¢p;€?i$ion VV zhiic interest iitigaiiian and in View of thflsajiti .a§éarz§;;ei:i"¢§, {he iearneé Single Jmtiga was * _;::cst.'j§i::;sii_i7{i:.e:i in <:>£fi€::1::x'g Ehe registry to rsc}assify €113 matter Litigatiozzz' anti past it befam the §§.visi0I1 Bénéh for I3;i f£;}f:£?e:* araiers. L We have given careful considfzmtimz :0 {he (: u*3{)1i;1'¥"fi.?xii'§LiGBL ef the Eeamcd caunscl appearing far 316 VA agépeflants ami scmfinisefi {ha avsrmenis madfi in tha writ K35' V ";£';3;;1é*x* 24 W.P.N0.13637/2688 31:13}! be pestcd bef01*c»..4_£'§;€: W Sing}: ducige as per the roaster.
Accorciingly, the writ ' ' .' « i; 'Chief Justice Sd/--
_ _ . . Judge