Karnataka High Court
Chandraiah S/O Channayya Doddi vs Mallamma W/O Basayya Swami on 27 October, 2010
Author: Ajit J Gunjal
Bench: Ajit J Gunjal
N % 7 IN THE HIGH COURT OF' KARNATAKA, CIRCUIT BEBICI-I AT GULBARGA, E'}A'i1"'¥:":E'} '.E.'HIE-S 'mi«: 222% iipm' <32: o<::":*<>;3§~:E'~:,..2:?$'1%. 3 BEFORE imE«: E-{()N'Bi_,E; MR. JUsi:*1{::'§ LT<:<:J~1%:;§;:s,:.,VV' REGULAR saconzn APPETEEI3 NO;? i'.'§54 013$ 'mes {$3.} "
BETWEEN;
Cheanciraizzh S/0 ChEi£1.f71éi}{'y'E1' _ Agst: OCC: Agri{:L1it1,:1'e__ _ ' -~ R/0 Kainkot, i'I"V€':;:a '??_2:11'1§1L,1r. ' '~ {By Sri.§..ve¢:1?e§h ; 3:: Pa*.:i1,V._§id§v:3.ca;tr$} ANI): = % it E':{E'::iE21.rr:fi::e1 'sz'J ,5 :3; B';1s;é1§:j,?'a Swexzm 45 yeéufs OCC: H<:2_1::-3eh<)k§ and Agri " Rf a::_--'G21':'§21pL:r§ 'qg CE":.im':h£:{ii " » 23153:; ' i}i.1_§E321j:'§ga a A. E§3*12::":bi§;§;izégzijagya f §7.,_'{} 13 :=i.1§fin,g§.213Iy*22: E'xrE2a.E',;>z2€.% .._f£;,§:;*r: '{%fi 2:} 0.11 53:73: AgrE{:z,:E €21 rs-é V' n ,L_E§;'ié'*s_}:%:2v:::z§;;»;i {}<?:§§.i ix.) "§'::;. C}1§I'3<;'§'1{}1i. ilfiissé. (3-:,1i%3211*g,;a:..
... pm; <:§<--j;:1.i.s:;' _4 (By Sri. Prashant Kumar S. Gotur, Acivecate fQr§V_:I§;%1'»V:' _ Notice ta R-2 éispensed with} 'Phi:-3 R_eg_:>;1.1i21:* S<3<'?«:):'1<1 Appezfi is3:_'§'iE;:%:i iflzgadééf E'§':§§:?:$_._i<*;r;;1f~ 100 of CPC ag.§§21i1'1s5€: the _'§1,:i<:£gr1'1.¢:::'m_ 'émd t,'§{5fV'§f;:.';'..f;V'§V€§: {ii-3}_i c;%L*1 G6iXl2OG8 pasaaiin RJ§fifiL6§f@5 Gm ug:§fig"5f:he Civil Judge {S1'.".1:)'Ii.}. {§Ir1.i:1c}1&£3'i'i', :.5gE§€§t§?i;1g 'i}i&:v--23_§1j;;;e211 anti setiéing aside {he 'j{1£3§:§1"1;ii%:ifi..€iE}§13';.(i.Ef6E*§f§f:dc?LT}€E€§ 034092005 passeé h1€3§iKKL%5/Zfléfizofi {he fikéfiffliuai/c.AddL C§:a:flJ1;d;gs3 'i"E§i_§§ ~ z1%§irg1iss'i(}z1 this; (12132 the':
{3::>1;:2~i. a_§ie:1iv§;%'re:fe;f§. Vf:;E1:€:2£§'i;1§g: . *"g§§éMENT '§'E"w ;;1;3j;§s'e:;e:_«VE&.i$ 2:cin1§t'{,<2ci 'ziei; ii<>r1s?;§d:3:" $23.9 ifaxiioxvirggi » és{:i:';s§§t.;1V1'1'i;'i:a§4Vri;z.:<3~si:i<>:"::%; «:>f mw:
"§i).~ ~§§5§j:ei§':a%r 115:6 §.<m;;€:" Aggvpg-%f.£5£E:e Cfsmri. wag m§2.rs§gj§3"'i€.0E 5:1 rev€rs;i:'zg 5.319 ja.:z;E§gme%;:§. zmgi. €§:'3{Z'§'t':?€.3 La.) passezi by {fie le:>.a2r':1.e€£ Tri.cz.E Judgge ci.e<;'£i.:':.izz§; Z0 grarz: <2 cie?t':re{3_jE:;r §:~:;}ec;';"iz:t {)8{'['i3f'?"!"£{12"1.{1?é;?? {ii} Whe€§'i.{?r Ifza? judgI?'1er':z a;.r'td ::ie«:::'e€ "£?:.éi' *' lo1.1.7er Appeilzfzie Cfami is vi{i.a£€€_i.
car1sidez'i:'1g zifm SCOpe3 0f .E3vec£L'£;$n 20 ':§';¢:3 "' Specrg' is I{eiir;}'A<:'i.'?" V . ' ' 2,, 'F1';.e i'a::t:s_; _£§€:1'E11£iI1€ f{}'i7.'_'C:zi5:§}3()St&i§. <3i' 't".}1iE:§ z1pp&a:sE €211: be smnamzirized :a_':e:..._f'<'>--'.it:>\;.L_::+:: V I)'L1:*ir1g§ ithc <:<>11:is§j'_ {if §ii;djgf:1s%2'1t. the part.i€s::
wouid be 'r§:f%;§rrc;¥T{i _z.=:ts :§.é§Q_{fii<-tr f'11;§~\/ggxgziéixlggsg in '{.h<:: '1':*i21I §?§a:;3':{:i§'f"' it >:s;._:.:i--E'_: f for c>.r;f'<>r<.te;:11&n*i. of 2:111 agi"ee:me:":--*:: 'if;-'TE s§;'e:i§" £11.. i'asp€{:t: sf an z1g--§ri:?:z1E*t2,1raE Ezmd m:;:,a§$;:ri:1g 2 éiieitcss 26} ;_§u11i:a1:'§. "i"i3.e: {3é§L':3Ef. Q? t:h<:% pEai:1:;ii7°f 3:'-_% fh;-2_fi; <ic§7&:;.:;«:§:mE: $123.} is:-; ?;'l:"."l(i'3 ab:-3<3§'L:"é:e :'>wm:=.r (3? the Eéiiifiw :s_:A'h§<':}i: is':-s '_jg:»;/3.:if§::"€}f 22. ?:>§§;;;:=3:° aazrea {Bf i§ .:~'.1e":.r€;>ss 26 §;u:1t.2*1T:-.=:a §i}é:%§;"§:3F::f;<'Ef':;;;'1:i 4I'€::aE $.93 n{>z'2_§-,% s:.}i:§':é:*;:* i;:_'E':.22:': "%.§1<é S€}E'Ew§§.'1~§E£E¥f {>i:'%E1<~;% » '§gA3'£'T2§3'-§..;.;1_'£:.i;i':E. §}€rf<:::'1<£23:.:1i, 'Ne:>;iZ is; EH63: se2er;,sE}:9e-§qs.:£:'z':'z: §):.:§"<:h.23.;%~:' ztxf E'h<:? s:';22.i.<i Z;m.<:i. "I'ht?: <:21s:;<:% Qf i:h<:': ;::£22zi:':t:if;E' E.E'z21"£:
c.§<::§%:%:'1<ia:"1.t., E\?<;}.1 is ad{fEi<rte{i 'hi? '::>z1<:i }"§'c:"1bit,.$,, §'i€rI'}{'f€ {<3 C§E.iE3}'1{?}'1 his}: iilséggzzl §.'ni:*s5t; {i€i%;%:1<:£27::'1:. ;.'\3<'3' 1 112153 m<}rt.g2zgc{i (the: pr<?2p:;=.ri:§; ix} 50:11.9 {:>i:h{2:' ;3<;*.r:%-3::;s:'1s:-;. H.aviz'1;_§ 1"°e,<[j,§fz<2V1[;*_<<:i".{:.<.> iihe fanziii t:1"2:«.ai. 117118 :;iiaL'1;;'E":t,::%:* xx.-'i1i be };<:t'f3{. '2.x«'_i.V€V'_§'i'{3"i;i..'1;: _ pmpc::.ri.'y. Ehe p122r.i:'11i.if€ c-:?11t.e;"<:a:i §1":'t.ci3 ';'r:;": z1:g§z*<;%é:i:':--3.:v§%:1t1"130vsésifg' wfih the }"irs3%; <iie:f<:é:";c1a1'1t.. "i"'h:%*: .. --;':<;=I':..s:sidéé:'3i:ir§';ix_ 321.25%/~.. it is her ct2f;és_é;"-~.V..€.hat."V.ii: "A~:i1';3a,-;31;3i§11€% de§end2?u1'£, Nix} i.:"ie<:i €' :,:« 21.ii<3:1;;_1;,_<§ fl_1::w _p21:"i' 0f. this _§:>r£}pe:'{.y £15 an €:>s;t.re;m' cf 5 a<é:r€.é§;' £7h{2'-- i;>E3§:1.;1E':'i'§"f"" ;:;:.'1;r<:E":21s5ed an area sf 2 21<f'r"E;?%§<s§T'f.2;€3V i;;_'§'21;'1_'t'}':;é:; t}'1:2tj<§'11gi'1"2i";:'égi8t.ered sak: ties:-3d ewasi du.2"§.1":gV"€_E:€i* ':{'.E'L}%i'1;"iiV'.ii'ji,E'}'. sf :€',E'1?._i3"'EI}_E1§sfi me:>;"f,g_,§21g<::. Subsse,q'L2e:1i:iy E1§S<i} <i<;':fe11':*E2m: N:3.._E_°;,azé':1¥;f't>:': s2:>;p:'e::sssin§;' his ('BE-§;§§€'3f11{if:§S is &1}i<§§'§§--;if4€*A~TL§'1EE :*é:':2fiu;'1i:1i:j.;;; 2 acxxes; 20 g_._§m":t:a$ in '§lhI2i'.' ijhimi .p1<;::is;<;3:§ f:?i:::i'€_:% {ie5::fi%2:r1<i2m§j. Ni). 3. {mi mm', {3{}f'€}{i §<}rwa:rCi to .'{'?}ii€:{ZV;f£.'€ €':' «€};*2.e:';j :i;3§x'§§<?$:%21§"}* sgaziss. {:§{:§{E{.§§ $2.21!: is fiiééii. §3<>:ih, the s:.is:§7é':--:': {'§£1§'i§iSj% *'§':;:%.«*e :;:':':1;49re<i fc.-'i§}f§_}€3Ei:""27:I"i{7§'?. §'}a:%E%:mi;-1.3': it No, E iiiii :'1<,:'i...-- "'E'iE:';': E":.i:=e2 :::ri'::te§:: -':'é3'ifi.E§'L€3"E"3.i?%.!':'i'j. E'fiS:%p§E€.-E 9%' 5§%E4'1§"§§{f§€'iEE§"
€)pp£§I"f.E,11'1it}f ;§ixr<;:=.'r2 tr: E'-iiilili DEEf€,'I'1(§.E13'1i' N32 has; fiiecl 1*:i.;~:--; wr'it.'ée.1'1 st'.ar:.<;=..r::.1:;~:;'1E. ::?<):"1.t.est.iz'1g the su.ii:. Tha 21i1e:g;§e:éci 21gm€r11€:.1'1t. for :<%;21_i6_*. «::%>:e:7z.1i.ee:i by d<?::f%:=.ndam't: E\§<:«.1 has E3e:e;1 aicézaieci 21:5 f2:§.s:sé:. -Sui"f'ic<:: it to 5522.}? that {$16 i<2:::;11*1'1<:-id»~'ff'i"i;:1§. Juezigge on Ehe: 132133.33 ef t:he €:vid€ém:::* on :'e:c*.::.n'*ci..3g.?é§.':s§5€§€5. film vi.<~::*.,>s-* t;I*:1a'{. t:h.r:~; is; :10: 21 (:as<:->. urh<31f<:ha (i€:<1fEé't'3"'--§7i}r éépeeigifigi ';3&31'for§11an<i%::t is; reqziixweci ts) be gr2i;~:1i.e::i'.T A.'Em._:1'::=:$}%3r'iiEi5e1;%*'S;1sg' hams mcordeci 21 fi:'1«:ii11g._3j "t._E."i:3_t d€%fs:::1d21I"i€; -'has execztfieci the zagreenmxlt. to V.s:=<-%}"1v.._e1:ra§i h21$'--f§é::g:§V-'eci the C€}¥1S]:d€."E'E1iIi()'E1, h_em':c3. g;§r;1:1i,e;:'3._ 'éfifiéfééi for 1'f;':fiEi'id sf 'ihtff &:a1':":1es"i "fi1i1}Ifij{'i'}»'. "if:-:'_}."'1r1é'.,§§2:ici j'i:1dg*1::1€n'%. and dccéree was; c;21es€:i§§n.é<§. 'by. E3<:fc>r::3 the AppeEfi.2:.i;'e Cm1:°L 'Th<:% V§;€:v211*':1é€E» z§ppt;*E.12£1';;r: Qgfizéigté Ems ;'€:v<:3rse:{§ iihe jzzcignzerzt, '~-,21:1'4..%. d§'::1:°:;::e:; 2mCi""'E'112:$ ggrazztml 2: d;€"':(3i"€3€ 1&3: s:--;pc%«::E:fict ps:::"E3{>T:*r$:;:;:":s;'é:;._ ";'E.g;;g:'i<éare{}_ by €;E'2{=>: $222319. {§€:f_E:~nd.2mt 1\.?i},2 £3 b£3£§;}:*:=: fjhigé 4f:£;f{> 1; mg (75 13' I have h:;:2;1:r<:1 T118 1€'.*£,~£Y'I'1£Ed e:.'.<i::T:1:'},s[-3&1 21;:}f3ea.:*i:1g;;' for c1ef€,:'2ci2z1'1: Nillg as xareli ihfii '1ea:°:"1<:é€i <'<)1.ms,;&?i 21p;3e21:'i:1§; €01" thee': 'I3-lazixrxéiifi'.
4}" W':it'.h(:L.a§. ,Q*<:>irw into i:i'1£3 Ear fer' '}€I'S 3Ef.<;',1;i\»-'ft',* i3f'i1'i1z::
r1'sa:£:t:<':t:° ir":22:.31=mz<%'r1 21:23 wh :3'€:he1' E:'m:~ jL.1{i§_-,§2"n€r1t: _zi:1'i_'1':;'§g§»:i§;:; 35;?
of the Appe1121i::=% Cémrt. xgtan be susm._i--:1<:d__'f'~r)t,E2§:rxv'i5:,g§
-;',~§L1ffi{."€' it E10 2': 01:6 i',E"1:aa:. the: £<3:«,1'r'z':e_§::i ;."3;};}§}:"311'£?_f{L<>;7i-..:,EI' 2.1i1g;fe:-L%,__i1:2:£s.A EEOwh€I.'€ C()£'1.S§.d€1"€d ihész e':1c;«;}t% (3?-_S.€*ffiI.i{}fi 'f;j",O._,_0f thée Spsécifizt Risiieffiett. Izagieeéci ta of of the Spemifiezt Reiief A<?:€:, x;ie'm s;13_c1'--.jirjtiviCé1_ . i}3a1i. ::h<:%re: E55 21 <3:is§<tr§="fi§<)12_ f 0f 51 dfiféfféiéi' iébr sspecific perf0:'::1;;;:_:t,:&%\. "'E.'hVer-..f:3c?tL--iifizfi 'the: pi21in€:iff has; p1'()V<f3{i i',E1é':
zxggregzamegrgt; .VE'1.E7E<.Z§V'€i;:§S(} "ilhtif i'e£t<;%§g:»é:, of U516? e;:%<>11:e;%(i£;%§*21'£.i<:>rz. *;fi*1e ii: %3Vii';.%R5r:rEf' UV-'iii 110:: be 2%. "?I'{}'L£}'E(i 'E0 €r;an'fi' s5LEC:§'2. 21 §"€E.i:3f . E V . E» é;
E."§}ixi*?'§°s'.E?Ej;_;7".§§*'i§{3E2§l~§5Ef ii? is §2«mr'§':..s§ '£9 do 3:}, '.'§'§'3.<:3: di:a;<%>:f<:2::_§,<};": <3? ;;;a1i:7£{~5'c§ _'ii=;j§; _§2,a{§i:::iz2:f§ pri:T:<_*i;3Eé::~9; 311$ <:2:a.;}%.;'1.%3E€ 95 g'::>:*r€:s_=,ié<:z:": ?;.§':{i.__ €3::,f;_:::;%"%j f:';'sss§ Hi}? a:*'E:;§i.;'2¢:.:*f;; %;ve,.:ET :=i--;<i:z.1:n.<,§ ami rs::;:s;{,>:'1;2§3Ea: "Ni ':33: 2:1 Cjcmrij céf a.pp<::aI. E:'.1<1<::ed I am of 't:}1e= \~'i=E":\7£=' that 1%/E};>re §__§§I'aE'ii.i1'1§f; 2:: ::,k=:c1'c<-% far sspecvifficf p:=::'f<:}r:*:121a'1<:&%, {hes It"3E'1E';i}('3'Ci Appeliaie &r._.1<:i;_.;"c (::L,:;g;11i E9 hzzvea t3e:s;%.{)v;*:%{}. E':is am=:.z1i.i.:;>n on t_1":ist~; E1S:{f}€.'{?T.. of t:E2eé n1a_t.i:er' 'i'I'1.23.f. 1'TiI3.'{. '{):;ée:'t: cicztne. E arm (bf ithe Vi€;'f'.\'\}' 11121:. 1316: E62-:;;':'1a:>-,df~;%X;3~§§eE1af;:€' Jucige: £5; req1.1ire.<:i is t'C¥€1€}!1£-?;i€}.t%'I'?.__ t:h_:="-. apperai is'; '{1} E36: remitted 1::<t>"t'_ir1<:~..V ie%2:'r'm=%ti Ap'p};é51.;xt.<;:VVJtjgdge: {>111}; ta) EEXE,-1£'I1i1"1£3 the sctjzper c)'f___SC.::_,t:'££.}:1 26 vi 1::}":ef%S;3t3c:ifi(: R¢EiefAc*1;;. In 550 fax' éi:+:v finé1ii1ig:: £."'€C"{).IA"d.--§:{?'1 on i',i'1€ <:;i:h<:):* isagsues are €i{?€§'fi€§i, i:<:«'"}'_i;:s..*r,-€A 'r3'é:«::§"t.=.._ <:<)':1,¥,°i:f:"£1<3c.i. 'EAIe1'1ce {ha f<>11<)w?.':3g;TV * 1 . 75 {£3 '§"E1r3V:s.;z>;:':*:f:'2>g.i ViT£e.LVgiIE<}x>veci in part 'E'h<~§"'m.2itii;:éz 353 remi1::*i.«::d E0 t;':1<3 Eerarrieci A §\;§::'E3€EE;1§'.£% Judge {mi}; ti) {,'.{}i'1Si{§i"%3;" ihé.-3 0%" ESe<:1;.i<2z'1. 29 sf '$316: $p{'E€'.'ifi(? R€?§ifi'f ~ g3;{":i; 'E."'h<~:= rzssfi 0? $319 £'i:'1.dmg:s; :f<:;g§s1:'{ii:/lggg *:;2;:ii<ii'E:j; G5 ¥'.§'IE' 2zg1"€mf:§aé':'1t. 2:.:"y:i :*i~3z:e:=:'ip'£: <3!' §:<):'::;;i£i@§'g:;i:i:j;>:": s'»:et",zme:E <:{':er1i'3;::*'m€«:<i9 {iii} "E'he'-3 g:pp<3*.a1 s;§'1g1.11 be t:iis.s§)<>s--s€:i of E133: ifze App€:l.§::1t:c:?. C<:n.1:f*{ wi"é:§'3i:'1 2:1 pe1:'i<>d mi' ta-*<7: :";'1«:);'1£h:~:-3 f:<:>m ¥3'ié;', Ciéiiii? sf ':°c':{:€:~i;:»t. £31" this; <7':*£i€r:z S;i_:'1«::£3 Eacatih <:iefc23n{ia.r'1t: N02 z1z'1<:i *£,i1s-3 g3E21i1'}i:ii§f" z::'<é b€'f(}I't'3f tiziéa Ciitifi', wh(> are ihe {f€)I1§€S§iI1§_{ p;:E*t'ie«S;--..i;E%éiy'v are c§.'i:re:<::t:ec1 H} be pIf"£:?.SI3}T1'€', before iihe: 1_*::nves-'*._:£f"~.Ap;§e'}._Iat;vé Ccmrt: (311 22.1 IPEDEQM If the 'r€=:t01'd$ are §<:%<:%*:_ii2'e:d3 R€gisi'r§; 'i;_<3A :s;a:.r:1;cV§ back wwé <;::ZfZ w Q Q:
Q} ""
W3