Karnataka High Court
M/S Sanjeevini Medical And General ... vs State Of Karnataka on 29 January, 2009
Author: V.Jagannathan
Bench: V.Jagannathan
'A Hfisggzgjt-..
E»? TQEEEE E-II€}.E%§ {3{}§_§§~2'E' i}? §{51§~'%N£§'§Z%§{!:
€.'§ER{':Ui'§." B}%"}§'~§{3i~i , §;}E%;'%E%:'§'i%¢'2%§,} Daiiéxté. ihé: 2%: {£3}; sf ;§:;«::m_:aIy 2{}€_"?:§"' ' V1» _ :B§?@R§:
?HEBQN%MEMRgBSflQE;%d%§®N£§%§fq cfiafiwaagwSKH¢§3?§§§§&;:§£gQ§§ gawwagw:
E. M /'S Sazzjeevirzé EQE;-V:{§,-if;::~:};_ } $2. £T§€z1ez'a.E$t<::r€sV,H_" 1 Emma }2§fi%,}§@E§aHL2j. , Niléxflcfifiyfiafixfiogdg" *7=w» Eri{>s§_:f:'i;~ " ' » » 12$ {f§~.ASi,:{§a1'$haf:,V V. §'r0§::*i=?:i£}r"r) f {.53 .'g€:¢:'vi1'1i _ Eaificiiiaé G£me:'a§"St<}r<:-:~;, ' _{ {.0 €}.E{e::3;3;2a.§;:"appa, Ageé *-'E3 §?f§E}§';"'§, V R-,..f;~3 {Egg Wa;'{;s::::* '§'a:{.1§{, E'*~E.{I§,{i@§§::j§,>', 6 , ,. §'5?"{.§?;i{}§":E§{"S 835; S332 {}.E_}e$u. §%{:{§:i§*, ;%{§'¥ms::aE§:. E faN§{1 . V' ' - 9%' Eégrzzatakag _V :*£;3:*€s6:'z:{¢::€§ §}1*i:g£:1$}g3:E<:t.e:', Efieééaxy, . ' a.%:%§':::§§}{)1-.Z{:§€:3§}g.
{ E53: 83% ?.§*:§'.,{§~<}'§§<§"2§:":d§§ 7§i!$C§.{}.§}. E Eu) {:}i§EE}§i"Efi} §€€v§sia:': §3.{-:.§;:§E§:3r: faésii 'a.i:'2§{~:%§ $€C§i§}_§T;£'--§5§{;3E, (2? ms: Crfiyil. _g:x'a§;§;":g 'ii; Sari agiée $26: _§::dg_:'::_@<:§; 's:.5;§.'g:22:':::'} ?.§;2.g::><;:.;3 §3a3$€:€i bf; €3.35: ?.{::,§ §"'I'{"'§mEL EA2.::s%pé::§.ai;"<:;:f;g, §'=€<>. £>6,'2i}»{}s-"-§ zami aése fféfi jz:z§g::3,:€:3i. d3;{!s;'<%""
§3a«2.$:~:;€é ':33: 132:3 fififigkgvij-I {i.;:=,§>:;%.; &Tg;s2a4:«fé{:; a:,::.%s<;; .3;é82Zi":99§, ' "" " " "
"Skis petiiiam Gaming s3:é'=f;§r ;1eari.:3gT_ "€his}{§ay, aha:
agurt, made 'Q35: fafiexzfiizg :
Q' §3j.;::
'§'h:s::' i*esé'i3Ei<'§:f":._ Jpe;:§:i:;::,'j_. Es';-._ diyeciaci against {ha cogaczgziééizé [.?'1:;dim'§;;S6 <§f't:{i'e aaiifis b€i}{"}'i3J iziagmuch a$ 132$ <:0:1v§C€;'i.=f}1:: .03? €316"§réSz%g:ié:..pzétiiiggixfiérg, wifaa WE'§'°€ An} anii fin? _b_;ef9:"'a{i'= § i"1<~:*. ?:I*§Z*é..'J; Aéouriz, far 3% afifizces uzzikir 2i?{c} (§} of tha Smgs & Casmatizss Act,
-- far}? $12921} 3315} the Sfifitfifliffi passmi i}"}:{":.'{4§€)3'}V~ :9 ha cemfirfizfiié by 3116: 1<3w§:rr appgziiaie
-».cm3:'*i: fiismisaifig the crimifiai agpfiai fiiaé by iizzzse gpsiiiignerg.
VA V. 'W26 fa,{:'€3§ Eariefiy aiaéiiéi, am ':0 £115 afihcf fisai, V $3.;-123:: {E36 C€}1}7£§3iQ§f{3;3§'E€',- végéqfwzi Ehe C€}I}€fi."i"fl mi' A-7': sf évhich A»? Efiafififiléfi in be 'me grczprimer :31": E08, $988, if, }"
,_;
wag fozmd {hat A-i;2 had smckeii and was exhibiiifig B{;:'v::>}én€: smiiaaptic ifffiaifi sf Baish Na. 106"? , w%1%{;if:.[wa$ fauna £10 b6 of subsmndard am? the Same wsrzfi.
by A-3 911$ 2%,»-4, an c:omir1g is know tIf;.a,§ _"_'é;T?:e A§§:§§s_§é,:.{:9:., that was suppiied by ihfifiiff p::4€1.:';i{§':15i3;§ "'e'*w§£i§'§?k'V'.{§,';}€ purperted to be the g:>.rod:'ga_§:€ 0?." .G.=§).PbV::i*"§;1.§é{:z:%;'§daE§"' , L€<:§., Ghaziabad. Sased (sf tins coglzpiaint, 8. case :«aT§;§§m$t §$ai%i:i:}n$1*$ 35 well as tvgg {>%i}1€'£iS..:'%i}'€3(#§;',V._VVA " f}'i€ §._:;eti*{:ia::aers déziyilzg Eh? iéveiéeé §f;.2;,;;is:%51j:;';x;':"i:"':':';@r;.};, €iVi€§fi§"1C€ wag Sat Er; '.}}_}"-fifififiiifiiilg R"éz'$¢E arid 2 3.116;
i§§ gicrciiiiiifzfizéis' aéorlg Wfiih {me Eaf':'.{§. .%5{,:/K53 Berg;;;§T§:*;€; 'E':_:z'::%'c.. "'§'ha:,é accusszd denied $21716 case": sf ms:
;}FQ§€€ii§iQ{§'¢3§i{§ 166 :13 eaziéemte in their defancsa. V.Téé'~.,,t1"-i.§;EV"'C9:~3:'%:, an apprecéaimg {ha flvififiiifiifi on i*aC€;~z%d,--._'§'1§€§§ that 'aha pragfisuiian baa? Eiamughé: hams ézéize , g"é}駧t éjf' iha accused §3fi§,fGE"i(§ aéé re;:sa:":abE_e {§{:'::i::: gmd 'iV1:f:aSs¥<:;far as that p€§;i'§§0n$rS §'}€1"€§E} are CG§}C€f'fl€{3.§ {he}; V' %%am~e canxiicéed far {Eras ififfifififi muzisizabiii z1:_:€3;§:r Sectiams 2?{<::} ajné 2'?{d} mi' the éini. and A42 was ,9» ,.a 4 seniiansad :0 uzaéergs fiimgis iziiprissxruzaerxt far '£h:'€e year$ and :0 pay a {ma sf Rs.5,00€f)/- éifld {$915321}:
Séfiflifiilfifi af {me me:>m§'1 sizmgrgiez :1:§:p:*i$<3;1::3e2a%:T <:~r<?i.€.=:2"€:d and this 21-35 in §'€3$§}f3{t§; 0%' the <;;.§E'_is'::z1.g{:;%- §'7g.':§2,<:'§g:?.;f ;':§€:<.::£i0.:z '2'7'{(*:} <3?' 3:353 As: smé, _:i:$._;f$g::{é%:§é" umisr S€{'.'{iG?€§ :2'?'{d) 9:?' Km: Ac?"-is1'{:0;{*mé:a":";é%:§;» senieraced ta unaisérgz} sim§;1g""}r§1}3ri§0m£:$191:§€;2f"zs~w~p%:ri@{?;" af same gear am} is pay 9. ;?,§;z3€:--of-}?€s;--;..},QQ{:;....,W'§.:}"1 siétfauéz", $€3i3.'E€}'1{3fi 0%" flfifieifi {1*ays%A S%3:{3§3:iva §3{i?3€}§1§:§&:1§. "f?';'1;~_*~: iewer fifigjifififliéi:C{3'§31"{:'€:'£2;§}.f'f'i%;%?Xi}.§i{i;.»VA'%:§':i€§i.E£§gi"IE$fCi'€ <3? E.,§*:€: ma? cfiufif-E31 aié zfég ' ' _ " ' ~--.
4%. E 31336: §1§e'a,=:°éf§; §<:az*:';e:i <::a:_:z:${:i Sim' €;§¢§}§:$*u for '£§":§é" §3${§Ei§;}.§1€?S afzai the §$a:':1::<i {§~{>v{:§*§::":15::1§; . Féeaéaé" 'Si:§§';?,_§§.G9ikfi§:£ié 3'31' {E25 §'€$p0n{"ia§;i~S*{;aé:& ami p:':§'-'s.:$é:i§' gzsgagmaz §}§Q{3ff{§ Gfi :*::{:<>r::§. an ' .T?E2§: V§;é.:%:z:':;§.s&~;s;%.m1 af {ha 1633166} <:<:«u:3.$e2 far {ha '.. > f;§é:i£j<>:3.§:rs £3 that: "aha jzidgrfiéint. of {fat CtZ§1.1FfS Cfifiilfif. E36 égggtainfsd 32;'; Eziw as {ha §I7"{)Si:";{I%.}i§OE"}. C838 sz:§7;"€1'S fi'*s3m v31*i::::1:3 imfxrmééifigt '°E'§:r: Saki irzfzrnaiéiiasg a::<cs:'{§:§§;g is §'1i2'::1, am "éihé f£sE§_{:sw'ir2g: }' _/ xv . ., p@':i§i:'i{::?:1e§*.;~- A. €413 §'i:'$%:? :19 z";@tif'1€.at.§«:3n i$ ;3r<.::€i1.1c€<:%. is Si"1%3¥§?. E1'1}§;'i. f§f}€: §}€E'SO3fI£ assha xrisiis-:<i the §}."E'€I1QiS€'E§ was 3.-A4"gQv§:}fri€za§ i1€ ' aziaiyfit am? sesondijax, the pzlblic.am::§§%$t.--'_:{{3.§i?';.--?i»} %'g";'a%'j: .I1!(:)§\, V' examined 'wafer: {ha iris} €:o";3:"t°'a3:3§£? "€319: '::a¢ x$,V i:1fE%§i1r;i:§;f. referred ta is 313%., A» 1 i13.e:i'--fr§:;i<':~Vreqi;.i1'e{i--..Ai%éj€%::;£€:"mic? 523" was $3, 3 mtailer 39;. $31} ,;.'+;S; ifiigf {§i*?".§f»'{1'i*§?;1'{i3i".~"Viglii, E3516: trig} eom'i:., far the rea§ér;§ :"'ar-'.__§§., hex': izhaf, {:0 licsneti: W33 '.;3*f3'€§§ff§i§i{>g1er. 'F%;.€ 2263?. aiefect. S.%:2:§1}§}§fi§ that was Eiaiima fgra"
€xa§::§':*isL%;i'a:.¢;.:é2§§§§:;:7g§.::}t: j§;a§f{;%"§:.:%ié§;" éaffire 5:315 e::s::::%i in Qr€ia:* is §::'a:9%»;?-:=:V":§f:aL1. Fihéi. was €.akz:z"z was {my} '§h{~': a»*s:ry_ $a3;;i1§%'::*: V_'1iE';a;i--. .§;g?'.é%S .'S::E§§;Zf§{i fmm $16 p:'€m§$€s sf $36 fa' "?;%3%§;'_~%f_1$':§'%;i'VSé3'@misSi:m mafia by {ha ifiarnfié {:€}1m&;€;§ ES €§:"ga%;_{§§$ abcrve defects in the §}}T'G$6CEfi§{'3fi €é3;S€': are " .. 73.ga_§:2si aha var}-* pravifiams 5}?' the Aat. am: againsi the priiécigalea iaié ciiéwzz $113; E3516 Apex ijlmmi, and Q%:.§'1€::" -:f:m.1r§$ in {$16 's2"a3"i<}u$ ziésitigiazm *:"€:f£:r:'@(§; {G izjg him in {he £§1fi"8£'3 {:55 big a3fg':.1m€r§%.$. Laséigg it is i3{}i'}{€3I2{§{"§{}. by Eéim 'aha? €326 saxzafiarz {}I'€1€§T" tiws §::§"<}d2.1{:€:(}_ at E3x.P»§8 15% a .2' 6 siassigt axaxnpiéz 9%' §"':<::::-ap;:s§%{:3%.i<;:§ <2? miaai by time: auth<3r§.$§s° €1{}"§"§{3€tE'*§1€{} %$€84%\}8@§ ;<2ai"§.h€1"' "i'.}"i€> se<:€i,<>:':z:~; :33?' '£15? fag? wixich have hem: ssntravenad by the ;:>€':i'i,:<j:§:=z.s:€:;i=s§_T'g?1<3r the oifance that is CO}fi1'{I},ifi.f':d by {Exam is r€:f::'i%::%§'L:"::f3$3.:
-the sancfian {)F(i€§I' and §:".::}:*e{>\s2_'¢z;;, ,_:h<3r_5 "is? -$*:.;{::':""r::*s;*e::1 3; " w.E::i$7;.m" in the S:':3.1".§C'i}:(Z3EE e:**<is:1' 1 §:::« $fs:;=;s: z}f§a_€:'-. f";E*§.[e sa;1c§.ieI:.£:f:g azitheriiy p€F;i$i:::§ 31$"-?hé;. :r§a34t€:%if:213;...':3?e§'0:'é:'V.' acccréing Sanctéen. Eéhi' '€§";i;§R éaieagsgza a}sc;,,i§h::5sa:z:_c€:i{s2a 51:16:' esmairi 110?. hams E§'a::i<%;z-1 11;}§f§§§§.d ifiész ifaréai {§G'£_E§'"§,. '? E '%"h5:1:" 'zissigtisieéiéisi :_4:>:f;{éi:ir§:fi'_":€§ V by $35: Eeamed {I€}':.£Z1S€:§ fer fizéé'--.§:€:'%::i5:§<:3i1s::5$.f§{>v«.$%;:g;§a:3:*€, ihéi above axgzxmezzta am '€h€VO1f'}.€S f:€i'§?§§3€§{§; if; Brugs {E3363 3, §'i}9§ Ekugs a.;'i;T¥:4,,'~- A}3§38:§§;;':*':"*:':g$ C8333 49, Bombay High {$01}??? Briggs {Eases E56, E38} Qirugfi {E33523 Sasea 3, ?m1}a'%3 High {3<:>urt»'?'?, 12994 Efirzzggfiiiases 1, E998 Efirugs Ca:E;eS S8? QQQB {l';r1.§,»'J. ané AER E??? SC £863 Qt} 'ins other ham}, aha Eearneii §fiV€§"'§1E§i€f3%. §'§€9.d:zr sugaported {he jugigznams cf the semis beisw by submétéifzg that the <:ei7'£2{;:3rr€}"1t findings are z'é;:z:{>:*ded bf»; 9/ 'gr '?
the ceuris §.3e}.aW and E16 €§'I'€§E" car: 336 feaméi £2': théi Viééw Eakaiz by {he warned jmdgss 9%' thfit camrts haiaw zgtxdy as $a2s::}:1, this }'€Vi8§.{3Z} peaiiian is Eiabjie 1:0 136 {};;ié:1f:§";§§.§é:§. Gm: {ifizer $':_:bm;ZsSi0z1 that ',1.-as zjmazisii is '€jé%.;fc3§.€;_, p:"*€$€:r:t petiiiafxérs have $011152' "é;:}sC_i:+€:f&§§e "i:h_:$V '5,-é3*:,§.L:*: Wh€f€aS tbs Qthéir a<:{:1_:S€d , 2vE1%i:.__1fi:éa§ef: béilmi"€<:.e;"1'és':?;%éi£:s:§%',~_u have :10: chasm} ii} prefer a:'1'}sL»i*<-:=¥§1$i0I;--.*;S5€'f&:):j*:?~: f{§:%Tié {:{3£.s:'§. V' *3. in tha Eéghi sf §;i";€_:A a§::>ii}%"{§£;§£i:§é:::'iie:1SV§;wJt; f<>;rwarc§, the 0:33}? peim far <:<)A:":::L':'a'§é:'é,>£{.i§i1"2AA_ j.ES}. £2-ééleéizter {ha j¥,N3.dg'I§?i€i"}5'€~.".'iA _ 6013:;-"t.s '§€}<;>év can E36 §1e:::i<:i :13 be 311s%gi£'3_3.§fz§€: in I _ x "
Efi. it 1% '--..:'::;%'. ii} 5.iSp?2i%:6 that as gyubfis a;::zi%y$'§. wafi exvaifiiggéé _bsc€§.t':s;e,___E?'.§1!.4'% did ms: fifiiifif 'Q13 Wiiriegs 'i}:>X. ' Séc{3§1+.'i,§§§} ---nstiiécaiion was 3139 pméused :19 Shaw "§}i:.a;€ €138 §;§é§;E'i§(}E3 <_:e:>::<::fe3"§:a<§, wha vi;si.is:"§ "£215: ;;=rs::2.§s:a§%s 9%' aha §::~€:i:§'i:%m";&:*s, had the raquirsd azxfizority by ¥%r%.u<-*3 sf 3. " :7;-é>£§;f_:{:a$.i€3z": isazsed appaéntmg him as a pubéic anaéjggst ' 533:: {Rugs iztaspesior. in the face sf such evidefica 03:; yecerzi, Whathar it San be said that tile vigaw taken by me {:G§}Z"'ES baéaw can $6 justified is the gzaoim ii} $3 ,9 ',1 Cozxsiqiézred. Tha answer is this szsriii have :0 b€ i§2: ihéi negative for the faiiawing raasaziis.
1 E. in the ca.-S6: af M/s Gabe: 4_'_;;~§~.f€5é,fe 2 of AP, repeated in $30'? Dr{:gs::..'.A_£';'§:séS-
Anéhra Pradégh High csgmggag %:.ag<ep;_ j::;%a;:*% ¢amy%% 2232::-_"
11<m--c9mp1ia1'1(:& 0:" S,:<s2§:*€.i<}n.:~3-"2{§:_ 5219ié_ 21 {>f"£'?:za=:V AC2: viz';
- x"
no: pmdazcing $ rgégifiggégfitiazi §"egar<:§iz':g ap;30ir;i.m€:1'?§V .<§f -_- ivairugs §Z§'"§S}I)f3{§i)€}§' xxzzmki rfificifiii ,5? £216 wig} ztoizfi.
:::1sz1s'é;2i§z;a*3:E§E:1r:%' égfigazg';-'. ;'*§;;'$A' é;§fi:::"'s§fa1::m 53i'§%;*:c::t: is €fi}{1*'§'§"i§3Z' :2? 'itézs _B'@:fz:?:.)_a§; v€::;§'L1Z{;'§7- ii: the sags: if Siam Qf Er'1aEa,_ar:zs?:§';frz"isisi' _.E§_;-%.C§"§a:zda::}arkaa :'s::§.><::r'ii',€€i. ii": '§9§':} {}£vri_ig$¥ffia3eS 9}'-¥%!.,L"i;:;§;3fizéf% E: 3:33 beer: {:§;2:":;c:'v::{§. is} {$263 Saiii _ {'§~ii*'.{_i3};r;';Z§ti'.V3';i';';:'.'§"§T2'.}*i?*fi,_?_?3§€ §3E"{}'J'ESi{}fiS 0.2? §€{":i§{}§"1 13%} are: :3';a3'a{§a§a:j$; 311$' Xhf. g"§;aie G€}'i»'%f"'3I'2'1f§12€f}€ Egszigi, _§;:T:%;:§£<: ii} gag: $§§§{'.?.i§E ga26€%;;:: _ 1§:he a§3p0§..r1:213€I:"i§ {if éihfi Crsarerziifieiif. ;3§.EE&'i}"E§§l :és;;§{%:é§;'§3:i§";g iézaraéga '£315 area W_h€:z'eéfl "§§T:€: £}<}w:mm$mI:
2 §§s";aEjgs'{ {:33} @§3€:§*at:€ arzfi 5330 specifying '{}f1{fI"€ifi {he §:sr::<§:.,1ct:-s with wizéeiz E113 ihvarnnaeni Analyst {:33 ?€€S§.
anti 8.E}&§§.é'S€E. Q. is fzfifizar haki in €:?:z{: way}? Séflfiiéf n £3 €§€':{2'§S§€}Z"1 ma: a§3p<>§m.z:2s:§2%T 0.? a Efirzig E::sp&{:':.{>§* 5&1; e21E§.,:
he éhmugh :23. 'G{}*»'€I'I1I§iz3fl?1 Gazette N<}':i§i<:até<>n fiifié {K}? ciniherwisez.
12. in a1}(}'{}1€3;I' fiecisicsn in tbs: 088$ af S?s?;:é"'%~:i§;---
86925232 Phafinacezafécai ififarksy }§fQé;*f aS, §j?x;éLp1'0?;?;i}c:§i'V'i:1V'_'"§,F§;%§" * Sings. Cases 38%), it has §;£@€:3;j"}*:~..'é}.r,iT !:.§"2._;fi;i', 2 iI1tC£1§.'1}b€I1'€ upam the pr{}sé£:1%;i0:2 h:_~>.;'*;z§%'..:@:?;<M%»#*.::;fer:%:fi $352». ' Puiaiig Ana}j§;S'£ far ;c:'@3s~$x;i:;3ina§;i@:3' "a~.f¥.@ Hfé,ii2M1;*: {<2 €X8.E}"§i}C}€ hy téézziifiz/'mg-- %;%;t3i'-- %_§§%}.V{.:r6s§f~§:§>::gaz.:11§§;:a%,i<3r3. s:%.2':}u.E<'i be a {;iél£'é'{:€: ;5(7;5ii?£TET},:5€3:'éf E;5:{ é3.§:2"e€% am} ihae": case: {:25 {km ;3ms<3{$:2.%.i»:2r;. hag: *%:{f,i ~§§§1?E--. :2. f§.fz7i§S sgazszfi .33. '§1%i:fl §3;st;. E;hé'v. E§§{:§:.n<:€: 3S§3€<'.I?'§i ES {?{}"i"2.C€iI'EEf:{i, 333%:
V' . }{=;g;r3*;£z=:ii-~. Cszxiasei 37:}? {ha ;3e'£i§:§m1€:'s has r:i::'aw2:f: mg:
£;'§:é:":A*:Vivf<:§z3;! iii} z§{>::u_me§1t3 §§'a<:i§_1§:<i<i Ea Shaw $1131: {he §€:%f,§.tiG§:::2:*s"4fpé:§s$@sssd the required Eicancs, *.a:hicir:. faci: is $139 ééffiiitéii $51 $16 Var}; Cizmgjiaint Eigeif. Yati, ifizfi; {rig}. .AA<:é)11;€;, far $33 I'€i&30i'1S hm: éaxazvzz Ea ii, i133 }"is:§:;i $133'. ma} ., __§_%§i:e:;ce was; pasmsssed by {ha g:6€i§.:i<:: * erg, '£"'h;§::=; §n.fé:I'e:1{:5 is §ac'§z:a§.I.}: w°:*ac?i: mid it 1% $30 agaizzsi E323 s..A if} very pE"0's?iS§O§'i 0%' Eaw m:2€ai:'.:é:a"§ 3%: 8€:{;t'£§0§'§ E<L~3{£3} _{§f i§'1:--": get.
14%. {:2 the ease of Madam Lexi V3. The?
rsportézil 37.1: $318} Drugs High Court), ii: has been éimlsfi §§1ai---';&"?;-fifsz Iii§::?{:% +:iV§;*§"i_g$:';2?€*::'{é'" , pu2'€:h23:-Ed tgizéaf a w&§Tanéayu_'"'f:"QI3;;. iiseizséégi {'§€£i}€i§', §'e<;u%:"$m6nt sf S$C?;§_9 :':s .119 af {ha gas: are E§ai§S§§€d am} Lhga pe;*sQ;:V:C3,nC€r':1e&'~v;:a:3:f:a~:é=:, be C{3f1'£?iC'{.€€§. T6 the $a1:m;:" eE§?e'{:: ;';é; a7z;éf.1':cé"=._ §***i_1i%"""1g' <3? the AEia}'1a?:}a::§ Evfigh V€Ti{§%;:fi. :§i_f{1 {ff A§?3;'S'V4Sanjay figedécgzi $39993} ££Ea?*@E;%aé2.. 'J3, repem:-:e:i 3;"; ?:§=?8 E}:*'::g$ Cassgs E. .E§._.f fax?' 337 iii}.-%:~'sar;eC?;imz oréer is c£::z'.:c€;i*:1€:<L $216 ':.;%.ib:33,%$séc::'~~ pet;:*t:ia:":{=::'$' cazmgai {§;€$§E"§£f3S in $36: 3{.:<:épi:§€i §=;*ii_?fw:_z%, a $€f{3Q§}{§ ifqzzmght §"§€C&iIS{i, %;"f:"s.a *asé::j§: c0§:t&r2€.$;.0f $33 sanctiag {'sI'{§62' ;¥f:':x:.P»58 E'€'":'i¥'€3§ iceégaé §'::3;:1»~ "e:%..}:,%}i:¥?;';§:§:a%1?@"£"1 {ref mi§3.fi= fiaéther E336 sesiiang erf €315: §%<:%. V' %?a§§3i.a:%.: 33% <:<;n§;r*a'a:€z:e{§ }'1£}§' §}'}{i' afféézgcézs a.§ira<:€s:a'§ a§z::é:'§§'€: E}';'3;€i p<€2'3£§€%{2m~:§':¢-s am }E?.é':E§i1§G§}€{§ E33: thié a§a.m":%.§{::3 ar:'i:--':§"' am}; §:':£::'€-izkveig rm: '5§§§§{§ {}E'{§fi§.' is Sfiziné. fifi {<2 zzsmzi. §'§.i&'£{i{'i§'§.§i§ % ,1 3.3;
Wag :*f:f€:r§"<:é m %;_i; $225: samttiafiéiig '€,-§'E,3'{3"}{}f.§E§" 'a£:f¢:>§*€:
&{:{:ar::fi:1g iF'3§v3.EE{7"§;§{}IL '_§'h@r£: is rat}: »::x:€23*": £3; :s:E":i$;3£::9~§_:§.fs§";e i3}.E?iI7'E§ <}:'r;i@r tfrzaé: {hit Sar:€%':§{;::ir:g a1.1':}T:Q:f:?§ij;»?' "
tE1z'9:.:g§'1 {ha §*€:}eva:ni Inaifizéai §f}€:f<>re €16" "
cancimsian ':9 gram: xascassary Sisgzcfigiazfiz. '=f'_'%:_"'§:,€:~:-'§{:;iz:*L::*...A "EEK:
sanctian {}E'€§€£' cazmet 3:-€34-.s;11sta'i:1€<;§.V 0:5; '€§{§€}E'€f.r. Mareovfir, E11 {E16 (fasfif at' Kzéfivzairgfsfgvéianzy Elk. Plifiasf reporisd iii $983 the {}:*;%S$:.~z High Cam": 7{;s$_E§%"' is '€.f}'{£~§.§ .z";o:1.., 3~}3?h-i7fi'€i<>1__'7*~ §7;:r'é;%§$"VV:C',0n:r0§}ar éid 110$:
app}§".§.is_ ___z;"w.,écha11§CaE maimer appmvaé the rec:é¢:<:1%x.1E:;§€i':=%{i%:3Vi.s:§§t EZ)z'ug:s §;:3pe:<:€.{>:*, Such :3; S3fl£jfié}?: 9r{i¥r;~';;<' .__}.:i;a1'2.'a.<)€ 3136 said :0 be a vaiiai ssanciiam ,' Qftifi". " A 11&;;.~ '£2fi"':.=;:§0:";'3,é1* dscisian in €312 Gaga sf State af G'-zzjamf 'ézié-..__ Prfajaggafi Amrzztigzzé Natzxaréai; f€§}GE'{'if3€§ if; 2{%€3$ :4~€}£">5, {ha Gujarat High C9221": hazi iaken the ' ¥i€:'i%?.*"tha'{. wfiere it is 3:9: 02623;" §I'GE}.'i {ha $a:";c*§i::>:': aréiar V. ..._!:.hai: ihare was a§3§3§i::a€:i.:::~n a? zzfxmd 9:: iiha 3333*: <3?' 6:15: }/ 9 . E2 Saz1ci:i{m§:1g si12:h{>z*i:}g {he gram" ilzartiiéz' que$t.:i©:;1 {:é;fi;.?:::<:'s. bf: heké :0 be a. vahéi samitizizm {;§'der., F3. in the iflS'f31'1€ saga, 316?: .'F3»€:£%.C§1i0IiH§L§§'%'I§{<§:' 9é"}i{é.a%:: is, K '' pm{12.:.<:e(i afi$:::.- sifiiffeys frem the '*:r€1"§? _f§ei%ectsV'L_L"é;i:§é%.g as such, the triad. 0912:': cm.3}..:§';";o: hays 'E:;s££_ $7igh':,~~:;i%' t3€1e- ' prin.<:ip£e3 Eajsi Cif)'£¥1} .~--%1.i;fiti1 'ta. that sf the sanstion srdar.
13. E11 E gmw hesiaagigrg ef the ;3€iii§<:>11<=:1'$ %1ereifi_ 'big; Z fazrzd ¥.:h€: seniencéz passe-<3;
ihéwstefi in Eats; as 'aha {1@£'e§::E.g in §L§"1€ §3r{};%§e£:z1¥,§G:1 éfisé amigo many anti, as iéghfiy sub}::2i1§'.$::{§ . E332; _V 'zhs;-V, Eésfafyaeci ceuzzseé far file §:3eE;i1:§a:>z'1€r$, 3.191}:
'§_Z§i'=;*1i:€7}¥k'iV{f??Z.'fn'¥?.i¥;1€T_i";;.§GfVf the samgk: xss}.1i:?.h wag sgmi. far €:X.éi;zzi':3:;a%::{§:3; am} géacing avidemze to .iné;.is::3§€ timt "azhiz .. 53%;: ssixapifi was faken Gui; of the samgakz that was geigezi {ha Shep eé' the §efi_i;i£;»I1crs aim gives rise :9 doubt 'mths presgsuticfi gage and, as saith, '£1116 daubt benefit. alga ghauié be, givfin :0 '$116 peéiitianem an t§fi;i$ score as 37 A I 13 wag. '§'3:1€ mat rxeszaii: E3 {hat tha hiuzigzuents of tha smarts bfiiovss Cafiflfif. be upheld in 13129, 1%}. Accorfiingiji, I pass {.116 §'<:si1aW§;:"1g e:>rfi@§':__ ' ' The revisicjn pfitiiiflil i3 aI§;::z€?'er}«a1}«i tIr1e T_}-:'1_<i§*;3lé=:I1%;:»f; 0%" the courts '£36201'; conVict:i1i'g.__ sezfiencéiig than as m€ntiar15;é'V.ear§€r. ars f5s.jet ':--1éit3;e a1f1é £113 getitianers am aCc;;xitta:i"'i9f €}§'§'€n€€§'S'W"§t§} which they steed charged afii lbafi .A3E;Q§r1{%s Shel} Stanié Sd/-'-
Judge