Income Tax Appellate Tribunal - Chennai
Anish Govindram Tibrewala, Chennai vs Ito Non Corporate Ward-7(4), Chennai on 29 August, 2019
आयकर अपील य अ धकरण, 'ए' यायपीठ, चे नई IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL , 'A' BENCH, CHENNAI ी जॉज माथन, याियक सद य एवं ी एस जयरामन, लेखा सद य के सम BEFORE SHRI GEORGE MATHAN, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI S. JAYARAMAN, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER आयकर अपील सं./I.T. A. No.315/CHNY/201 9 ( नधारण वष / Assessm ent Year: 2015-16) The ACIT, Vs Shri A. Muthuraman, Cuddalore Circle, No.4, Reddiyar Street, Kondur, Cuddalore. Cuddalore - 607 006.
PAN: ACMPM0715G
(अपीलाथ /Appellant) ( यथ /Respondent)
अपीलाथ क ओर से/ Appellant by : Shri AR.V. Sreenivasan, JCIT
यथ क ओर से/Respondent by : None.
आयकर अपील सं./I.T. A. No.83/ CHNY/2019
( नधारण वष / Assessm ent Year: 2008-09)
The Income Tax Officer, Vs Shri Kesavan Venkatesh,
Ward 3, No.128, Anna Salai, Kanchi Super
Namakkal. Market, Rasipuram - 637 408.
PAN: ABGPV 5739A
(अपीलाथ /Appellant) ( यथ /Respondent)
अपीलाथ क ओर से/ Appellant by : Shri AR.V. Sreenivasan, JCIT
यथ क ओर से/Respondent by : Shri G. Baskar, Advocate
आयकर अपील सं./I.T. A. No.1482/CHNY/2019 ( नधारण वष / Assessm ent Year: 2014-15) The DCIT, Vs M/s. Equitas Holdings Limited, Corporate Circle - 2(1), 410, 4th Floor, Phase - II, Chennai - 34. Spencer Plaza, No.769, Anna Salai, Chennai - 600 002.
PAN: AAA CU9126C
(अपीलाथ /Appellant) ( यथ /Respondent)
अपीलाथ क ओर से/ Appellant by : Shri AR.V. Sreenivasan, JCIT
यथ क ओर से/Respondent by : Shri T. Banusekar, CA
2 ITA Nos..315/Chny/2019 and
6 other appeals and 2 COs
आयकर अपील सं./I.T. A. No.1032/CHNY/ 2019 ( नधारण वष / Assessm ent Year: 2014-15) The Income Tax Officer, Vs Shri Rajesh Kumar Goel, Non-Corporate Ward - 7(3), 1290, Golden Colony, Chennai - 34. Anna Nagar West Extn., Mogappair, Chennai - 600 050 PAN: AAJPG 4727F (अपीलाथ /Appellant) ( यथ /Respondent) अपीलाथ क ओर से/ Appellant by : Shri AR.V. Sreenivasan, JCIT यथ क ओर से/Respondent by : None आयकर अपील सं./I.T. A. No.1473/CHNY/ 2019 & C.O. No.69/Chn y/2 019 (in ITA No. 1473/Chny/2019) ( नधारण वष / Assessm ent Year: 2015-16 The Income Tax Officer, Vs Smt. Vandana Anish Tibrewala, Non-Corporate Ward - 7(4), No.1570, 13th Main Road, Chennai - 34. Anna Nagar West, Chennai - 40.
PAN: AAAPT3350N
(अपीलाथ /Appellant) ( यथ /Respondent)
अपीलाथ क ओर से/ Appellant by : Shri AR.V. Sreenivasan, JCIT
यथ क ओर से/Respondent by : Shri N. Gopalakrishnan, CA
आयकर अपील सं./I.T. A. No.1474/CHNY/ 2019 & C.O. No.70/Chn y/2 019 (in ITA No. 1474/Chny/2019) ( नधारण वष / Assessm ent Year: 2015-16 The Income Tax Officer, Vs Shri Anish Govindram Tibrewala, Non-Corporate Ward - 7(4), No.1570, 13th Main Road, Chennai - 34. Anna Nagar West, Chennai - 40.
PAN: AACPT1647C
(अपीलाथ /Appellant) ( यथ /Respondent)
अपीलाथ क ओर से/ Appellant by : Shri AR.V. Sreenivasan, JCIT
यथ क ओर से/Respondent by : Shri N. Gopalakrishnan, CA
3 ITA Nos..315/Chny/2019 and
6 other appeals and 2 COs
आयकर अपील सं./I.T. A. No.555/CHNY/201 8
( नधारण वष / Assessm ent Year: 2013-14)
The DCIT, Vs M/s. Vital Industries India Pvt. Ltd.,
Corporate Circle - 3(2), No.172, Luz Church Road,
Chennai - 34. Mylapore, Chennai - 600 004.
PAN: AANCS 5930K
(अपीलाथ /Appellant) ( यथ /Respondent)
अपीलाथ क ओर से/ Appellant by : Shri AR.V. Sreenivasan, JCIT
यथ क ओर से/Respondent by : Shri M. Viswanathan, CA
सन
ु वाई क तार ख/D at e o f h e ar ing : 29.08.2019
घोषणा क तार ख /D at e o f Pr o no un c e m en t : 29.08.2019 आदे श / O R D E R आदे श / O R D E R PER BENCH :
The above appeals and Cross Objections pertain to the appeals filed by various appellant Assessing Officers, call into question the correctness of the relief granted to the respondent assessees by the Commissioners of Income Tax (Appeals) concerned and, most importantly, the tax effect involved in each of these appeals does not exceed Rs.50,00,000/-. The cross objections taken up for hearing are only such cross objections as emanate from these appeals and are broadly in support of the orders passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), concerned.4 ITA Nos..315/Chny/2019 and
6 other appeals and 2 COs
2. The CBDT in its circular No.17/2019 in F.No.279/Misc.142/2007-ITJ(Pt) dated 8th August, 2019, has further liberalized its policy for not filing appeals against the decisions of the appellate authorities in favour of the assessees, wherein tax involved is below certain threshold limits, and announced its policy decision not to file, or press, the appeals, before this Tribunal, against the appellate orders favourable to the assessee in the cases in which overall tax effect, excluding interest except when interest itself is in dispute, is Rs 50,00,000 or less.
3. The above circular, only enhances the monetary limits and gives further relaxation. The old circular, beyond any dispute or controversy, categorically applied to the pending appeals as on the date of issuance of circular.
4. Thus, the circular dated 8th August 2019 is not a standalone circular. It is to be read in conjunction with the CBDT circular No. 3/2018 (and subsequent amendment thereto), and all it does is to replace paragraph nos. 3 and 5 of the said circular. This is evident from the following extracts from the circular dated 8th August 2019: 5 ITA Nos..315/Chny/2019 and
6 other appeals and 2 COs "2. As a step towards further management of litigation. it has been decided by the Board that monetary limits for filing of appeals in income-tax cases be enhanced further through amendment in Para 3 of the Circular mentioned above and accordingly, the table for monetary limits specified in Para 3 of the Circular shall read as follows:
S.No. Appeals/SLPs in Income- Monetary tax matters Limit (Rs.) 1 Before Appellate Tribunal 50,00,000 2 Before High Court 1,00,00,000 3 Before Supreme Court 2,00,00,000
3. Further, with a view to provide parity in filing of appeals in scenarios where separate order is passed by higher appellate authorities for each assessment year vis-a-vis where composite order for more than one assessment years is passed.
para 5 of the circular is substituted by the following para: "5. The Assessing Officer shall calculate the tax effect separately for every assessment year in respect of the disputed issues in the case of every assessee. If in the case of an assessee, the disputed issues arise in more than one assessment year, appeal can be filed in respect of such assessment year or years in which the tax effect in respect of the disputed issues exceeds the monetary limit specified in para 3. No appeal shall be filed in respect of an assessment year or years in which the tax effect is less than the monetary limit specified in para-3. Further, even in the case of composite order of any High Court or appellate authority which involves more than one assessment year and common issues in more than one assessment year no appeal shall be filed in respect of an assessment year or years in which the tax effect is less than the monetary limit specified in para 3. In case where a composite order/ judgement involves more than one assessee, each assessee shall be dealt with separately"
4. The said modifications shall come into effect from the date of issue of this Circular."
5. Clearly, all other portions of the circular no. 3 of 2018 (supra) have remained intact. The portion which has remained intact includes paragraph 13 of the aforesaid circular which is as follows: 6 ITA Nos..315/Chny/2019 and
6 other appeals and 2 COs "13. This Circular will apply to SLPs/ appeals/ cross objections/ references to be filed henceforth in SC/HCs/Tribunal and it shall also apply retrospectively to pending SLPs/ appeals/ cross objections/references. Pending appeals below the specified tax limits in pare 3 above may be withdrawn/ not pressed."
6. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of the Commissioner of Income Tax-5,New Delhi Vs. Keshav Power Ltd., in SLP No.21497/2019 dated 16.08.2019 reported in 2019(8)TMI 811(SC) has also applied the Circular No.17/2019 dated 08.08.2019 has dismissed the appeal holding as follows:
"Since the tax effect involved in the matter is less than Rs.2/- crores, going by the latest circular issued by the CBDT, we see no reason to interfere in this matter. The Special Leave Petition is dismissed, leaving all the questions of law open".
7. In view of the above factual background and the concession given by the CBDT circular No.17/2019 dated 08.08.2019, all the above appeals must be dismissed as withdrawn and the related cross objections must be dismissed as infructuous.
8. The Learned Commissioner (DR) submitted that liberty may kindly be given to point out, upon necessary further verifications, and to seek recall the dismissal of appeals and restoration of the appeals in the cases (i) in which it can be demonstrated that the appeals are 7 ITA Nos..315/Chny/2019 and 6 other appeals and 2 COs covered by the exceptions, and (ii) which are inadvertently included in this bunch of appeals, wherein the tax effect, in terms of the CBDT circular (supra), exceeds Rs 50,00,000. None opposes this prayer; we accept the same. We make it clear that the respondent assessee shall also be at liberty to point out the cases which are wrongly included in the appeals so summarily dismissed, either owing to wrong computation of tax effect or owning to such cases being covered by the permissible exceptions- or for any other reason, and we will take appropriate remedial steps in this regard.
9. In the circumstances, respectfully following the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax-5,New Delhi Vs. Keshav Power Ltd., referred to supra and in the light of the above discussions, all the above appeals filed by the Revenue are found to be non-maintainable, and the related cross-objections of the assessee arise only as a result of those appeals and merely in support the order of the CIT(A) concerned, therefore, the cross objections filed by the assessees are also dismissed as infructuous.
8 ITA Nos..315/Chny/2019 and
6 other appeals and 2 COs
10. In the result, all the above appeals of the Revenue are dismissed as withdrawn as well as the Cross-objections of the above assessees are dismissed as infructuous.
Order pronounced in the open court on the 29th August, 2019 at Chennai.
Sd/- Sd/-
( जॉज माथन) ( एस जयरामन )
(George Mathan) (S. Jayaraman)
याियक सद य/Judicial Member लेखा सद य /Accountant Member
चे नई/Chennai,
दनांक/Dated 29th August, 2019
RSR
आदे श क त ल प अ े षत/Copy to:
1. अपीलाथ /Appellant 2. यथ /Respondent 3. आयकर आयु त (अपील)/CIT(A)
4. आयकर आयु त/CIT 5. वभागीय त न ध/DR 6. गाड फाईल/GF