Delhi District Court
Criminal Revision/127/2008 on 6 January, 2009
1 CR No.127/08.
Tajender Mohan v. State Govt. of NCT Delhi and others
! " #
$ % '&
( ) * #+ " , * %-. 0/1 3254768&:9 ; 3 ,&< =
>@?!ACBDACEGFGHJILKNMOAQPRATSUEWV3X.B0YZKJ? [Z\^]`_a\^b.b.ced f FhgiK Skj=AlE.PmgnAogpXNgqATSJE rO\.\Ods[Nbedt\Gbub.cvd w ?yxLXUBzKGENgnP"{^KkFU?:| SUEDrGb.}edQb~[Gd\ZbubJ~d ?|.KU?|.KGH AoMGK.?:Kk| SUE'rGb.}edbe[Gd\Zb.bG~d ? d.FaKGEG|.KJ? SU{ZFUEu USUEShj ? d!Fkx.|LAQP`{z>~{GFJEG|.KG?3GFU.?yFZ IeKZP`AT|UK.Ehg3Skj}_:[h]~[LKkKhgiFz>USUHTSJEk. f KGHC{OAT![.[NbubUL[Jd)d)dd)dd)d)dd)dd)d)dd)dd)d)dd)dd)d)dd)dd)d)dd)dd)d)dd)dd)d)d IeKMJAQP`ATSJEOAQPg_>USUB .HTFUAQE^FUEhgmd M.KJ?PRX.P ^gFhgK^SMZgdZShj3V>k Skj f K.Hl{OAZFJEZ|WSgn{GKJ?Phd)dd)dd)d)dd)dd)d)dd)dd)d)ddCIvKuP`ZSJEG|.KGEhgnPhd w .^KZFJ?yFJEGKuPkrILK`M~AP`ATSUEUAQPpg ACE ^K.?yP¡SUED¢"Aogn{zRSGXOEGP¡KGHQ ?!d £d dC£v{^FG?¤gpA d % $ ( [Gd)v{^K ?:K`MLATP`ATSUE.AQPmg:_aZKNgpAogqA¥SUE^KU? ?!doOF¦K.E^|UK.? SG{GFGEG {ZFGP §{^FUHlHTKGEGxUKk| gq{^K SJ?:|.K.? |.FhgiK^| O[GdCbU¨Odt\Gbub.c ZFGPRP¡Kk| YN 1 of 4 2 CR No.127/08. Tajender Mohan v. State Govt. of NCT Delhi and others ?idUFGEG|.KkKJª©«Fu|.FhM HTKkFJ?!EJKk| K`gq?ySJZSUHCA¬g5FGE FZxLATPpgq?FhgiKu f K.Hl{OA ¢ {GKG?:KGYN®S^xLEUAT¯FUE^®K°¢±FZP EZShg,giFU²`KGE³F^x^FJACEGPpg,gp{GK Fu®X.P¡Kk|´FGEG| gq{^K ®SUBDOHTFJAEhg FuPK j ACHTKk| YN gn{JK ?yK`MOAQP`ATSUEUAQPg {ZFGP YZKuKGE |LAQP`B0ATPRP¡KZ|vdd \Od)v{^K gp?!ATFGHµSUXU?¤g?KkRSU?:|°¢±F^P0P`X.B0BSJEGKk| FGEG| gp{GK°EGS`gpAT®K#¢¶FZP E^Shg Y^K APRP`XGKk| gS gn{^K ?KZP`GSJEG|.KGEhgnP FZP gq{^KN {^Fk| E^Shg YZK^KGE P¡KG?aMGKZ|·YZKNj:SU?:Kgp{ZK HKkFU?EGKk|0gq?!A¥FUHhSUXU?¤gd ed w ?xLXOBzKGENgnP {ZFhMGK YZKuK.E {^KZFJ?y| Fhg HTKGE^xZgq{ SJE gq{^K ?yK`MOAQP`ATSUEed FNgiKG?!ATFJHµSUE ?yKu®SU?|L ?KGHlK`MGFUEhg .?ShMOAQP`ATSGEGP Skj H¥Fk¢ FUE^| gq{^K U?yKkRKk|OKJEkg5P±SUE7gq{^K¸ZSUACENg {^F`MGK YZKuK.E0®FJ?:KjXOHCH¬WZKU?!XGP¡Kk|vd ¹ d)v{^K SU?:|.KJ? {ZFGPYZKkKJE'{GFJHCHTKGEGxUKk| SGE¸MGF.?ATSUXGPºxL?SUXUEG|JP ¢"{UAT{'FJ?yK KGHFUYZSU?FhgiKZ| ACE gn{JK»?K`MLATP`ATSUEed= E gp{GKµZKU?!XGP¡FUHSNj<gq{^K»ACBD.XGxLE^K^| SU?|OKG?<¼;jACE^|µgn{GFg$K½uRKGNg¸j:SU?<gn{JK+BKGEhgqATSGE¾FUYZSGXhg gq{^K´FUHCHTKkx.Ku| x~?!ATK`MGFUE^®K SNj#gp{GK ?yK`MOAQP`ATSUE.ATPmgn0gn{^KG?:K AQP E^S |LAQP¡X.PP`ATSUE F`g»FJHH ?:Kkx.FU?:|LACE^xWgq{^K xL?ySJXOE^|JP7SGE(¢,{UAT§{¸gn{GK'?:K`MOAQP`ATSGEUAQPmg¶{ZFGPºF^P²KZ| jSU? ACE^¿LXOAl?¤ XUE^|.K.? P¡KZpgqATSJE ¹ b >~?id Àvd>@d Á`½Z®KGNg jSU? gq{^K HF^Pmg P¡KGEkgiKGEGRK Skj´ZFJ?yF^xL?FU.{ EUXUB0YZKG? ¹ Shj#gn{GK ACB0.X^xLEGKu| SJ?y|UK.?y gq{^KG?:K#AQPWEZS°?yKkFGP¡SJE BKGEkgpASJEGKu|1j:SU? |.KkNHCACEUACE^x·gq{^K#.?yF.KG? Shj3gq{^K ?:K`MOAQP`ATSGEOATPmg FGE^|+EGSg7®SGEJ|LX^qgnACE^x´FUE´ACEZ¿LXUAC?¤¾X.E^|.KU?<P¡K^ngATSGEµ ¹ b 2 of 4 3 CR No.127/08. Tajender Mohan v. State Govt. of NCT Delhi and others >@? d ÀvdQ>«d ¨Od:VKGAogq{ZKJ?gn{GK xL?SUXUEG|JP {GF`MGK'YZKZKGE·|.KkFJHog ¢"Aogp{ P¡KJZFU?yFg5KGHo·E^SU?FJEk ?:KkFGP¡SJEGKk| SJ?y|UK.?#AQPªZF^PRP¡Kk| ?yKR¤K^pgqACE^x g{^K P¡FGBzK.d,L{JK HTKkFU?EGKk| KNgp?ySJZSUHCAogFJE FkxLAQPgq?yFg5K f KGHC{UA.PR{GSJXOH¥|1{^FhMuK Fhg¶HTKkF^Pmg |LAlP¡§XuPRP¡Kk| KkF.§{¾Skj<gp{GK»xL?ySJXOE^|JP³YZKNj:SU?:Kª?:KkF^{OACE^xÂFJEkµ®SUE^§HlX.PRATSUE¾FGP gq{^K >USUXU?¤g°ATPµ?:Kk¿LXOA ?K^| g5S ZFGPPF |.K`giFUACHTKu| ?KkFGP¡SUE^Kk| SJ?y|UKG?WFkj¦g5KG? g5FJ²kAE^x AlEkgS´F^®SJXOEhg gp{ZK´K.EhgqAl?yK+BF`gKG?!ATFJHSUE»?:KZSU?:|vdv{^K%FGP¡K {^FGP YGKkKGE |LAQP`B0AQPP¡K^| SGPg5KGEGP`ACY.Ho {^SUHT|LACE^x¾gn{GFg gq{^K ACE^xL?yKk|~ATKGEkg5P Skj gq{^K Skj¤j!KuEJ®K FUHlHTKkxOKk| gS {GF`MGK YZK^KGE SUB0B0A¬g!g5Kk| YN gq{^K ?:KZP`ZSUE^|OKGEhg P FJ?yK B0AQPP`ACEGx Y.Xkg%EGS ?yKkF^P¡SUEGP+FU?K xLAoMGKGE FGE^| AE P`X^§{WF'P`A¬gX^F`gqATSGEGegn{^K1HTKkFU?EJKk|'gp?!ATFGHJ>USUXU?¤g KG? ?:KZ|³YN#E^S`g<ZF^P®P`ACE^x F¸?:KZF^P¡SUE^Kk|WSJ?y|UKG?8F^P"Aog=¢±FZP"?K^¿LXUAC?:KgiS ZF^P®P±FzP`ZKkFU²kACE^xWSJ?y|UKG?nd }ed:ÃÄEG|.KG?'gq{^KZP¡K AC?:§XUB$PmgFUE^®KZPR gp{GK xL?ySJXOE^|JP¾¢ {OAT{ {ZFM.K YZKkKUE g5FJ²`K.E YN0gn{GKW?yK`MOAQP`ATSUEUAQPg ACE$gp{GK¸?:K`MOAQP`ATSUE0FU?K EGS`g ?K^¿LXUAC?:Kk|Wg5S YZK |LAQP¡X.PRP¡Kk| Fhg»FGHCHDPRACEGK gp{GK SU?y|UKG?|.Fg5Kk| L[JdbU¨ed \ZbubUc Shj#gq{^K HKkFU?!E^Kk| KNgp?ySJZSUHCAÅg5FJE F^xJAQPmgq?*FhgiK(FUE EZSg,PXGPpg5FJAE^Kk| .XU?yKGHo#SGE gq{^K+?yKkF^P¡SUE gp{ZFhgWAogWAP³E^SNgDFµP`ZKkFJ²ZAlEGxÂSJ?y|UKG?FUEZ|µgn{^K´xv?SUXUEG|^P ?yFJAQP¡Kk|1YN gp{GK¸?yK`MOAQP`ATSJEOAQPg;FJ?yK ?K^¿LXUAC?yKu|¸giS YZK0|.KkFJHog ACEz|.K`g5FJACH d ]ed)v{^K E^KNg ?yKZP`XUHog Skj gp{GK FNj:SJ?yKZP¡FUAT| |LAQP¡§XGPRPATSJE AQP gq{ZFg g{^K 3 of 4 4 CR No.127/08. Tajender Mohan v. State Govt. of NCT Delhi and others FkjSU?yKZP¡FJAT| AlB0.XGxLE^Kk|ÂSU?|OKG? |.FhgiKZ|ªL[GdCbU¨Odt\Gbub.c¾Shj±gq{^K%>USUXU?¤gSkj gq{^K'HTKkFU?EJKk| Kg?*SUZSJHCAog5FJE FkxLAQPgq?Fhg5KZ f KGHC{OALAQP<j:SGXUEG|·P`Xjaj:KG?!ACE^x j ?SUB HKkx.FUH=AlEj AC?!BDAog! FJEG| gq{^K³P¡FUBK³PmgFUE^|GP P¡K`g$FZP`AT|.K FUEZ|³gp{OAP ?:K`MOAQP`ATSGE(AP<F^®SU?|LACEJxLHoDFJHCHTSu¢¶Kk|vd ced)v{^Kµgp?!ATFJHÆ®SGXe?sg ?yKkRSU?| YZKªP¡KGEkg·YZFu§²µFGHTSJEGxª¢ Aogq{¾SLN Shj7g{^K SU?|OKG?µg5S gp{GK H¥KZFJ?!E^K^| K`gq?SUZSJHCAog5FGE FuxLA¥Pmgp?yF`g5KZ f KGHC{UA(¢ AÇgp{ |LA ?yKkgqA¥SUEGP¾giS ?yKG{GKuFU?·g{^K FU?xLXOBKGEhg P Skj·gn{GK ?KNMOAQP`A¥SUEUA¥PmgFGEG| ZFGPRP·F´|.K`g5FJACHKZ| ?:KZF^P¡SUEZKu|ÂSU?:|.KG?SJE gq{^K´®FZPKh±|LAQP¡XuPRP`ACEZxµgn{JK |UKNgiFUACHTP,P¡KGZFU?yFg5KGHo¸FGEG|'ACE^|LAoMJAT|LX^FUHlHoLd ~d)v{^K°?yKhMOAQP`A¥S.EUAQPmg"AQPz|LAC?:KkqgKk|°giS FJ.ZKZFJ?
YZKjSU?:K(gq{^K HTKkFJ?!E^K^| gq?ATFUH >USUXU?¤g SJE [Z\OdQb~[Gdt\GbubG~d [kbLd w j*g5KG?W|.SUAQEJx gq{^K EJKkKk|uj XOH YN gn{JK w {.HCB F^| Skjzgq{.AQP>USUXU?¤g5,gn{JK ?:K`MOAQP`ATSGEzjACHK YZKD®SUEGP`AxLEJKk|DgiS ?K^SL?y|1?S^SJBWd w EUEZSUXUEZRKZ|'ACE7gp{GK$SUZKGE¸>USUXU?¤g ÈqÉ<ÊËÍÌ«Î ÊQϧРÑ7ÒÊÓÔ;ÕÖÐ×Ø ÐÙ SUE7gq{UAQP b.}kÚTÛL|.FhDSkj.!FGEUXZFU?¤.e\Zb.bG~d w §:sbe[eÜ1KZPmg5 f KGHC{UA d 4 of 4