Delhi District Court
Civil Suit For Dj & Adj/13/2003 on 11 August, 2008
1 "! !# $&%' ( ( ) * + $,( - . - .
/&
(.0, +%1( $2
354 687&9;:=<>9
? @,A=B#CEDGF#H#FGIJFLKMF>N APO&C FGARQSF TVU ? D#QWOJX.O*U&DGF>NZY&F [
7#7 B \>B ] <#< \
^LQS_ `>Q
7 B a DVObUcO*U F>NdF>e eV[*Ogf1FGAPOgh>NZi : U 7Gj>7k4 l 4Mm O-[g`#_ n IkARDG`
F>e#eG` [-[gF>N A m h>Q
m O-[-OoNGHcAPDJ`pU1O Aq` eV[gF>Ndh m ARDG` e#Qqh>eG`>QrAsI
O-NL_ O*U&eVi1Aq`tB1a DJ` QS`uU&eGh>NG_#`>N A m O-[g`#_ QS`>eV[ I
AShLARDVO*U F>e#eV[-Ogf FGAPOgh>NLF>NG_ h>e#eGhuUv`#_LARDG`pUvF>@L`tB ]>B a DG` eV[gF OoN APO msm DGFuU m O-[g`#_ APDJ` e#QS`uUv`>N AwU2i#O A m h>QxeG`>QP@LF>NG`>N A O-Nzy{i NGf|APOgh>N } O ARD,ARDG` m h [-[ h&}cOoNGH e#QSFGIJ`>Q~UJ ) q vVsvs#M&vv2 q q 2 vV b2 V& v G&'& s G && s2 sV vq v bR&S)V sG~sJ*2b ¡q v,&vsVvGJ&qs¢Gg|*v ,¡V ~qq V £vV q v¤1¥qJ*2b v ¦§ q ¨ vV© .# ª «¬ ¡ g s&2#( 2V v¦®¤* s2¯*°q vd| sk G EJ±° Gq vd2 k 'c¦²s¯*¡v£vV2 v q vL JbS VJv & 2J* &q v,&vvGJ~ ³ 2 w V b1 & v ´ &G'&8µ G q&q vV s&V*¶~Vs2V±8G¢ v·&·V, s¸R1S ¹V8q v·v±Jv vbs &ºvG v&q v,|&'# 9 B a DG` [g`#F>QPNG` _ ARQWOgF [»f1h i QrAT#Og_#` y¼iJ_#Ht@k`tN A_#FGAq` ]V½tB 9 B 7 ½#½ 9 _ ObU&@¾O*U1Uv`#_ ARDG`¨U1i#O A=Bva DG` eV[gF OoN APO msm¿: Fte#eG` [*[gF>N A e#QS` m `>QPQS`#_ F>N¾F>e#eG`#F [¿B´À i QWOoNGH APDJ` eG`>NG_#`>NJfI h m ARDVO*U F>e#eG`#F [¿ÁxARDG` eV[gF OoN APO msm¿: Fte#eG` [*[gF>N A @LhGTJ`#_ F>N F>e#eV[-O f1FGAPOgh>N»i : h¨Â 7 QPi#[ `Ã]uÄ"Q : }ÅU`#f|APOgh>N 7Gj>7¨4 l 4Æm h>Q5[g`#F#_ OoNGHÇF#_#_ O APO h>NJF [ `GTVOg_#`>NGf1`ÈO¿B¿`tB f1h>e IÃh m [ `GAsAq`>Q h m À°À 6 _#FGAq`#_ 7 ÄuB 7#7 B¿½G Á f1h>e IÃh m fJDG`#É iJ` _#FGAq`#_Z] 7 B 7 ]>B 7 ½#½G F>NG_LARDG` fJDGF [*[gF>N B 2 Ê Ë Ì ÍgÎ#ÏxÐ>ÑSÎ#Ï>ÑLÎ#ÒGÓqÏ#ÎxÔtËqÕ#ÕGË ÖV×#×GÊÙØ,ÚwÛgÏ#Ò>ÑPÜGÏ Î¹Ý#ÑSÏ#Î Ï#Þ Ïuß1ßvÐ>Ñ ßvÏGÓ Òuß1ÍgÎ#Ï8ÓRàGÏâá{ãJÎ#ä>ØLÏ>Ü ÓpÎ#ÒGÓqÏ#ÎåÖVætËrç ËqÕvæ#æ>ç8Ò>ÜJÎèÎ ÍoÑSÏ#Þ|ÓqÏ#Î8ÓRàGÏåÛgÏ#Ò>ÑPÜGÏ#ÎÆÓRÑWÍgÒ Û Þ Ð ãuÑrÓkÓqÐéÝ#ÑSÐGê#ÍgÎ#ÏëÒ>ÜxÐ>Ý#ÝGÐ>ÑsÓWãuÜVÍ ÓsÚxÓqÐÆÓPàJÏëÒ>Ý#ÝGÏ Û-Û Ò>Ü Ó ÓqÐìÛgÏ#Ò#ÎëÒ#Î#Î Í ÓWÍgÐ>ÜGÒ Û ÏGêVÍgÎ#Ï>ÜGÞ1ÏíÒ>ÜGÎîÓqÐÈÎ Í*ß&ÝGÐußvÏíÐGï§ÓRàGÏØLÒGÓsÓqÏ>Ñ°ÒGïsÓqÏ>Ñ ÑSÏ#Þ1Ð>ÑSÎ ÍoÜGäîÓRàGÏðÒ#Î#Î Í ÓWÍgÐ>ÜGÒ Û ÏGêVÍgÎ#Ï>ÜGÞ1ÏtË ñ#Ë ò5ä#Ò ÍoÜß;ÓèÓRàGÏ á{ãJÎ#ä>ØLÏ>Ü ÓéÎ#ÒGÓqÏ#Î ÖVætËrç Ë¿æ>ç ó8ÓRàGÏ ÑSÏuß&ÝGÐ>ÜGÎ#Ï>Ü Ó Ý#ÑSÏGïqÏ>ÑPÑSÏ#ΩÓqЬïPÍ*ÛgÏíôGò²õ Õ2ö÷¼ÖV×#×tñpøcàVÍgÞJà ø ÒußpÎ Í*ß&ÝGÐußvÏ#ÎÇÐGïsï ù Ú¨ÓPàJÏûú Ð>Ü&üoùVÛgÏ ú²Ígä>à ý Ð ã ÑrÓ+ê#ÍgÎ#ϨÐ>ÑSÎ#Ï>Ñ.Î#ÒJÓSÏ#ΤçG×tËqÕ#ÕGË ÖV×#×tñ#Ë þ àGϬÐ>ÝGÏ>ÑSÒGÓPÍ êGϤÝGÐ>ÑrÓPÍgÐ>Ü ÐGïtÓRàGÏ á¼ãJÎ#ätØkÏtÜ Ó+ÑqÏ#Ò#ÎuߺÒuß®ïqÐ Û-ÛgÐ&øLÿ ! "# %$& %$' ( & ( *) + ,'-
./ %$
021(1 3 4 (56 ( 7 98;:=<>-
@?BADCFE 0 1(1 CG H
JI .K L?(MN ( O K P QMR $S
2 ?'TR U B V:W XMR Y$S Z U*6 [ (D
( \ ] _^ $`F a< 4 4 H H
&
:;
%b($c d e[ $& (fg & ( / &
J (f
h Y 7 4 4 H fD
% /b( %$%ij$& ( %$ 3 AG8kb H
0!l
m n:'oQ:p H
Z 5Oq Y Z$& B 4
( 5 ' r $& ! c & %$s
r
!D U[
t u
( f5 d .G S $ e BH B UHe 2H
d S
$& v L" f H b B
2 (
% !H ( % f5 _ w PO!"; Y J.G OX x !H H
a ( x &
4 $&
( %b f5 @"
(f
V 4(4 ( BH ?yo#
' %$'
G$& .G V ]fD !6 z
{ $`F a 4(4 ! BH
%b H | }$S B$& H O9 ~ $&f U6 ( 9 [ Y 9fD $& } B ufD b5 !?u<f5f5 %$& BH O!"
4 $& B6 % P w 4(4 ( BHa UV BHUH ' ( X [ z _ $& fg % 2 !n ! % B %? 4 $c Bw & 4 4 ! B$ S $& } ]^B $`F R< 4(4 BH He S |:;
%b($c
A 0 +
,! (b B$cO!" 021(1 )@?/
\
G S fg `K /f $&f b(.wF S f5 !K
/fD (6 @"6 Y %$& j [ UH HD u
/
%$& ( $% (W S
/f5
!F ?
ÔtË þ àVÍbß Þ1Ð ã ÑrÓåêVÍgÎ#Ï Ð>ÑSÎ#ÏtÑÙÎ#ÒGÓqÏ#Î ÕGñ#ËqÕ#ÕGË ÖV×#× ö Ò Û-ÛgÐ&øºÏ#Î ÓRàGÏ
Ò>Ý#ÝVÛ-Í Þ1ÒGÓPÍgÐ>ܬÐGïÓRàGÏÇÒ>Ý#ÝGÏ Û-ÛgÒ>Ü Ó5ã÷=лÊEÕ ÑWã#ÛgÏîÖuö¤Ò>ÜGÎûßÏ#Þ|ÓPÍgÐ>ÜûÕGñ>Õ¨ýG ýåÒ>ÜGÎ
ÝGÏ>ÑPØ¾Í ÓrÓqÏ#ÎMÓRàGÏ8Ò>Ý#ÝGÏ Û-Û Ò>Ü Ó ÓSÐïWÍ-ÛgÏ8Þ Ï>ÑsÓqÒ Í-ÜðÎ#Ð Þ&ã ØLÏ>Ü ÓWßðÍ¿Ë¿ÏtË Û ÏGÓsÓqÏ>Ñ,ÐGïv[ò®ó
ÓSÏtÑPØdßÒ>ÜGÎëÞ1Ð>ÜGÎ Í ÓPÍgÐ>ÜߢÐGï Ò Û-Û ÐGÓRØLÏ>Ü Ó ÐGï¬ÝGÏtÑPÝGÏGÓPãJÒ Û,ÛgÏ#ÒußvÏ àGÐ>Û ÎéÑWÍgä>à ÓWßGó
ÞGàGÒ>Û*ÛgÒ>ÜâïSÐtÑ°Î#Ï>ÝGÐuß2Í ÓPÍ-ÜJä¸ÐGïcØLÐ>ÜGÏGÚÃø Í ÓRàEòéÒ>ÜGÎðÓRàGÏÈÞ Ð>Ý1ÚðÐGïcùGÒ>Ü@|Ï>Ñ~ß 3 !!t#BRy @2R Q s!!RUx hR #¡ ¢!Q£v & @¤ ¢¡U@@R #¡ !¥%U@R!2¦§¨ (!@Dr!©}ª! @@!t£uR L!9s!R @!©& Rqª!Rt!#¡ ¡UR !«!Q£d§!@¬{t ®¯`°m k wR§±Z²{@#¡ §!³´® P R sµKR£}£uR !U#¡¶(R!Q±=²[²m® · §¸5#7¬;@@Rr²{#¡ %B/®k¹¤º!}s@ 9 J ª!2w h7B 2d!«BR£v§!@» ¼ª! (!R!@R ½ ¾ ¿W( Àª!nR@!#¡ ¡UR [!*£u!¥B@nR!!ª!R'R@%¡ U !UR\5ÁÂzº!ÃRº µjĵ¢ @Q¸ §!³Å!R£v 22UR Å%¡U@2ZR\ @ R >ª!x2 Å%¡UR>!©{ª!x2@ @ R!R&¼ Æ s!X!( hR{!©R@!#¡ ¡U! Z #k Z@R£v K@t# UR!#¡N!¥%U@R!2 ]!§ !t£d BL »B@ » ¼Ç@ !¥% UR >!©/Èu tRKÉmºËÊK@¡UpÌ ¾ µjÄ;µj¯ÍU7 x!! !! JJª!!NR ¼v!©Qª!q2R §!³@R!D¼´£uR UR!@´§vR @RRÉmºL@¡UrÌ ¾ µGĵ n©Lt¡ © ¡ ¡U@ §Å@ _ t» @#BR uRt%¡ U2!URÎ5ÁÂϺ!ÃRº_µjÄ;µj ÍU} Ç!! !! J>r n 7 ¼zª% z@@!t£uR ' hn!!a© ¡e@_@RL¡ URªÐÍe9 ]#¡ p!! !! J>r z 7 ¼X2BB>Rt!Rt% ¼ h\!B¯ ¸D@>© R¯!aª!>§£ux!© £u!¥%§!³_@RL¡ UR[R@%¡ U2!LUR> 7%U!_!@Ñ»!tRV© ¡e@_RÇÒt º@º! Ì%Ó@ÓRÒtÔs! R@!#¡ ¡eR * Rt!!*»! !R£v & @Ô ¦¡U@@@t# UR!#¡/!¥@U@R!2R%¡ ¼ 6ª Q!³!ª!R% }2 QVs%%!±zª!zR@%¡ U2!eR r¡ UR»%¡U n»!z# (£v 2 @Q s!q Q£7| 7!R R» ¼# (£v 2 @Q Õ Ä;2=t© R=ÌRÃ@ Æ Ì%Ó@Ó Æ © R!¥@U@R!2!©NR@!#¡ ¡eR ; ©=R ¼ }!R R @R#@! @º!Ã@ º@º! Ì%Ó@Ó ¾ Ö ¬®jÊ[ÍUN®×WÍÊ×Q®j¶(Ø ®¯²kÙPÁÚ²¯Ûm¶@Ü[Í º@º! Æ Ì%Ó@Ó Æ 4