Karnataka High Court
The Managing Director Karnataka State ... vs R Poovazhi W/O Late K Kumaresan on 3 November, 2010
Bench: N.K.Patil, H.S.Kempanna
9 'V f 2 3, 1' R as: Tag 3135 30333? $13' KAR§zs;:*A:§ 5:? Qgzsyga '€513 mg 3% BA?' 95* §*JGX?EE*s£B}§f:'€;' :PRESEN'I': _ __ F. 1 J THE 1-I01\:'*BLE if'g?v,1:?§? 1';'§§£'§;' 'V , gm . . _ EHE HONBLE MR.JfiS«'iiICE §g:§.;%., §\:g.€s:é 6 J ':>}'§"2{}a5 35:? M.?.;a;\2:>,?-3&5 8;: 4::
::x«ui:;g §\:Ta,8é2§_FQ§?f_2@§}'5 Between: T 37:6 M312:-gzgixégéfiéz' _*ei@r; ' . Karzzaiaésa S?:';4.?;;% 353$ 'E'ra:1sp?»::}::*: ={§0r;3@:'3i~i.9§»,. V V' ' §{.E*3Raa§§ ' Ba:§ga%:>réVi'~2f'?;
{R€§,§?/S " _ V -
law Géficeéf. & _ """ " ,§.,:%;;>§e§3J::
_ {E1 E~Z«:"'%i{"E:§L;%.§3Vé$;a'€h ,?£2::::az; ;'4':{:§1v@£:afé@} E .u §<}€,%i;'a:r:§.":2;
.A§'«:f={i §.%:3:2:.::'a' 33 yaayg, "*:;%';"0$ 'L3;§i€ Eiéiagfiéazsgag ié/Q. S.$:,::":§a§a Efijafig, 7 E79. E33, Qghgga Evifazagéazésg §X«'§§E§3r: fififssé;
Cegks "E'@:>z2':2* Z 1 f /V X 5 ' Agaai 3;Ef2é;s2;:"f;7*':;_'§ }r€a:?s§ B3;:":g&E@:"€~58G €335.
Baby fisighwarjaa, Agsié ? yearag 9,50. Lair: §£,Kumar€.sa;n, C/Q E:§,Su:1dara Ragazg N9. E83, Rahega Mansiens, Miihiar: Streei, 'Sacks Tsgvn, Ba;1ga§0re-56{i 8&8 > by R?
8¢A.Um5g}E¢, Rigger, NG.é§, EFEQG1: ..
Naraj;a:::ap§aA ._B:1fid§:2g; V. . "
:Saz2E{6:}3;§;':9;}Eé,_ . I B.'f,Ma:n E:c:a:i§l,"' _ V BangaEQ:'é~§_6Q"v{'::EL.§, ' TheVV§§ew._§:1dia V' ' ?u::a€ C23}? :E;'?f_£§,I}€£Ei~ E Ei}__1 , . _ ':?€€f--AS9:v;3r§<a:*' 3}"-jgfagé Eifgaiarz, E§'E{:sa:*_;%h§.Vaj:§.::agé.;: " V' Pu;::3~4?1_E_4 Q35" A _ "
3633 $3: B:*a::::i:,:v§;'Ea§f;'8;g€::
3.-.;é'>';.:%:{:::z§i;*13.:*:a.§':':3E"3% V' E?i?;'e::a_ a:;§"}5;¢:9$i:?;:.a::*;:/' ?§E§3;;;
._ §~§;o_;6;§?,' :iZ_€g:23:'"§&::j:,~§§§E Q5;
;71;':>;i;§.é£&r $33362;
é::1g§a,::@§ {'3{:?;};' '§;i;:§.5 A S26, E'€;'S;¢$a:a{ie§p, Exdirecaéei far RE §: E2; w§<33;:a_;§§&gTE €§§Sf1"i§.SE§€€§ {>12 £%%;'%2g'2%'}%£T§:
"«.}1isé:~ $lé3j%"<I€d &::§. §i§Ef€§E"€S€EE§S€§ _ ;§:f3:.":§'fi£',;1%h&i% Aévscgais 3%: R53 ¢.E%§;:§§a::é&:;i§ 'f'§2*§s. ?%§§}'5£ ig {flail if/3, Effiii} Q5 EIEEF £32': zggaéfzsii the ,3' 5%"
2/:
=:.fu:i§g::{:%::te2:; éfiwaéé éaéfii: 2§;@5;2a§§ §§8;SS€5;E1'§5C 5:3; 3 '?§3;'2{}@%§ 9:: {E16 fiig 05 'ziirgs Ekieagéar i'v'L%{i'E', ;?§<E3.j»;<> Ejisazfiijzzié, Bazrzgaiere {S€{§iH~2%3}§ awaréing a {:e§z3pe::';~3;:=;:id::: csf ?;};£}%$2,@GG,'~ with §fET;€f€Si 5;: 6% pg. frag: C%6;"1"i'j.2§_f§"i:..V:§EEA_ pagmsnf; 321$ ":19 $6': asids {he same. " - V M.§iA.N0ff8{}5 OP' 200$ ._ Beiween:
E. R.?0gva:»iahL Agefi sfseué SE ygafs?
2%?/0. Lair: K.%§::ma:&,~g;2§;
2. §'sJI§3s Aishwazfya, __ Eaged abcsuti '? years, .
fijaé Laie §§,;€§::mar€;$a::, ~. ~ {By Guarfiifin :¥'Z~€:é?3;3€i* E1;;:_;:5é1E3;;f1§.i's§':>; if Bath 1 ' ' £3/'Q. $,$:;zn::i_as;fia R3;§a1j:;'~. ._ V 3C36_'%Fa.:s F551: E:?:§.%€ .:5%§i._ E Main, Kée;fi{:;haE§§';.4 E~}1i:..EI Siagsg = -. ' . §a:i§;ai@:*€~E§€} (E3383 " V' ' " .mA§pe§a:1:s {S}; V. Ea i38:::;'é.:€;€§§ éézecaéa}
3.] "§'jé Ma,::'a:§g::gg §§:°eQ€{}::
%§'2;::fi3z:f{a§«:3: 338$? Regé ?E"fif:°§}}fi:.'*:"i Caggaeyatiazz, . .. §§.fi§Ef~§$i'}; Eiafizgmazzéhafiya Ragga » . f " _B3L;:§a§<}§§~§6G $2 3 eiaisé, E'3£h€§"'$ names 33% }{§"::0'W}": ii: apgéiiafii, NG.5§E, E Fiseiz Earayanappa Builfiing, Szfiziifizaahaiii, B.T.Z\/{aim R036}, B3,ngaE0re~56i3 {E39, ..
4' 'EEG Néw Efidia sigssurance CG", §;€§d',?__ T ?U.I}€ Ciiy Branch» 3 53 3. G 1 ' 'Veer Savarkar Udyog Bha?afz, §F'IG§1: Shivajinagar;
P:};fi€~4~§ 2 £365.
Sm? Arfishanainbai _ ' égeé éfisué $8 yeara V' ~ W/G, 832:'; E§a:_1daswfa;::::»;. §?:'EEa::.g»,_ Eféagfifix N,V€?§«§':,i§8{ET fitiieei, ' Q} ,,..Re:--3§<:x:1é€nis §Sr:§<Z. §:3;§1§:i§';3¢;'3L'5}E §,{i;§2;:T:3:: . ,s§t§}m<i5aIi€" fa? RE 3 SEE. §i:_E\E. §:i:§3v.as§,"Adv~f3é:a:€ :59: R53:
Sr: Sfivifiizafs; %.§:.ffQ"«:3.Eie R3 éfiééiégd Q2 fifikifié} ..«.{::z;:-,: E%2E§"§'§"§$«.§_§_§_¢e§.i $535 22%;; E:£E"x?' agaémzéfi {he éaisfi: Zfiffifi/2%}€}:§ 938866: is: §£E»'€ ;\E& _%2*si§:«;,;'2::%::%:e;;s,_'§:_§;g 2:255 525 S25 Memées, E:sE.%€'T, Eiéays Eafi ijéiéé," B3;§;g:'§_;':§€ {SS{f';§?§~2i$§§ §a§*f;E§; aééawézzg $323 ciziizn; gygfiéiézfi "--§@§' é:a:::§>€::3aEi&:: 332$ safiiiimg" éaéiafiasmém €23' ' -- .. ébsimgsgzszviéanfi " "}TE:e;%€ a§3§€a§5:; iigméng? 9:} £53' Efsargzgf 'ifzis fig}: Fg%T§E; £2 afiaEi:;&:'€{i £126 fsfiswégzg: "MM~ W 5/ 2/ :3 Thsse igwé appeaE$ by the C@rp@rat§;§1:':'- §.fi§V~7:§:$ Ciaimams §§'€ arising Gut sf {he sam€..§i;¢ig{:i24:i1t .. award daied 25;@5;2@»t:>5 pasgggd §§$.'e';--7?§v:5:;«?¥2:G{,§?} an zhg ffie sf the E'v'§.e:::i;éé::-:1? Ekivéisf 'f:'i§2,::'1a§, Mayo Ea}: {$§i3CEi-ZQL {§,'E€i"$§§18;f{€2" referred A Siféfilviga 23 Tbs'? 'TE_'i'3uI13i..::'\i§"' axszarfig fags awaréaé 3; f§;iix§éV:""":;nie?€s: 3i 8% 93.9 Siam $.33 §;:2;:j.3V 3;.ga.;i::?3'£ 'aha Siam: mafie bf; 13 }_:§E,§é;i'§§§,f ~33 8:CCQ1i?3.'£ af 2325 d€%{%::E;f;_ 'sf §{.§{1;§§E§8;1"€S83'§§ ifi 'iié maej i;§af§;<:'v:%§€§é.$:::%_f " A .
:E:"':_ ¥:::f£ei '£336 §&€i"€S 92? £325 995% am:
'?E2é'«::§E;§.f::::€é;§:: EEG. 21% $36 wife ané aégérzzagi ?a.?{}, 2 £3 ». }3:v3',:i*:9:"* fiaaghéfir :2? {:36 éacsaasd Sr: E?-Q. %?::.:::aré§a:: 3:25 ibfijg havfi Eééeé a siaém geiiéiag fisfgre $23.6" ".§'§§b%:.,13':2;i wider $€:::?:,§::::n 26% Q? siaigéigg 2 "%:é:13;p€:2ssa:§@:: agaikzsé éibs {":::;§p{:§&?:3i@§: azssé €}§?:%?:§S, 3::
,2' 5 E ,5' ,3' 2*';
Q5' 2"??? /° MW 2 W,» -""'""
f "M 5' (2 305833? $5 ifzzst déafiz 9;? $56 dscsiagsé is $323 r{>ad."':::3;§§ic ac{:§&€1,:'L €C?:'1§€§'ii§i§E5' {E331 escurrsd, 3? abeui:
an §.'?".E§9E3 ihé decéassfi wag tr§;ve2Ei::Hg»""ei;:1%: _& V' Cysfié beazirig :"'~§Q,KA.83,56?'C% ' Eras Sama gear' whitsfieffi ~L<j::§zI'3? ?s;'I ::ii:1é:u;°ia} Su:--§:<:€GE; w;E':§:i:1"»~L 33:6 iimiig af KR, Pumm, Ejgéagéizg gash 313$ negiigeni maansr hind pariisn G? the 3u:s":ai::e§ grisvcsug:%;§.:;%:~i';éé: 1&3 Ehs: Sam{-:: I: is ihg §'u:':h&:;icas€AAéi§§ *:Z§.e:V_ éhaiz, decfiaserfi wag ages} abeui:
:33 3z€az"s , éyea ?:r'§3.21ager in Eizifs, Eizfiégayzzi 1%:x:s:;::*" 330353 29.°;;§;:;§§; Ba:i:gaE@:'€, arid éfawigg Q16 saéazy G? 5136:' aJ:m2_::; is was haié 33$ h§a.E€E':'3z: Earfizsafl '"'€££§T"'§",':.€K:?' 3.525% figs is :22::'§}1§:€§§; éeaih éééfifié' irzave s'a:_f;'7er€r§* Eazséiéfz gasésléj amfi eegfisméaaiiy. "SE36 Sgifi, ééaérgz VL.";:§:TiL}Z%:i<3:':--fiagi; same 22;; fa: cezzgzédemiégzé §€f€1'§'€ iééze "7§'§*:i;»'a:::a§;, '§'§:€ '§§ibaaa§, Er: éiazfim aféfiz' a;§§§$£:§3fizL::g 'Q36 " '":::e:*aE agzfi §:g§:1§_:"2&::':2;:§,fL €'i?'§§€I1.{i€ gmé Qéhsitr gszzaézeréaé &Va%E3f§":%€ 3:: fish gfégf 5.S$€SS§"i§ ii/1:3 zmtiezgg}, Eggéagfigg 555 the cieceaxseci at ?8§QGQ,f~ par mgnth, 3 éowards his perssnai am Eivérig §}{p€IES.~:3'S"€:IT%§{d éL'€i€)1pii§.1g! Multiplier sf 12% hag azwarfieiéi égxararfis E033 ef éepanderzs}-r'T_ axgé a}S© a5.x;ar;€€a?«:._€1§.2g'EGG?V i;0w"3;rd$ sgnxfenéiegai haaflsfiiafi '§,_£Cs§fi%'ingiy?,.'3 afievaefi. ihs daim getiiiefi in .a"z1?3;§¥§_i:é"§°Li,:E3:é *C_Q1"E'i§€ES8Q§§GE71 Sf ?1G§%Z§§GG§-- agigsjer §if'fé':*et;;ii.'§?i.é2'2§Z$ V~:&i3'.%E: isieyesi at 8% 93,, {mm its =jj2fg"mVe»z:i. Being aggrievfié by '£28 Qsrggraiian has fiied tcaggézsnaézzg $133 §}€ '§"':"i7b:maE '§-igis» e§:2%€%i:§._ C zmé fixérzg éhs caniriéaéagr '_ §€g§§'g'€;:1§f:s: u;3;§a3:'§f:;a:*ig...f:.i%;;:': grin/3? gf {is méiafaycée gfié ihai: ':fi2é" 5§:;a::im;:;3AV.'§§ éggzgaengaéian azarayégfi by 3&3 'E'§§§:2:'2aE '3 {>345 E:;;gh£i:f__.€€%z§€ 332$ ii rsgairfia 3% $36 zeducsé 335$ 2:h§ 'v._»:1a:':§a~:¢'V; ";i;~;: Eaagns fiésd §\iE§*.;%,?E@,?'8§3§j2:%€§E agzyéazzfiigzg '*.*:§"33§é;"'_«%:%:s €§7:3Eaii§§:iE§:fE Q? {E*§:EE;p£:'};S3;fiQE1 aiararésfi E3}: Sis ?f§bGfi§§ £3 Ezégéeegzzais azéd ESE f€§;&i§'€S fig be $:1h3;::3.::$§7
-@% ' ~., ;' w' $6}? Iizaéifyézég {E15 émyugasé ;§'i,§fig:'EE,€E'/'Eéfv and awaré ;§é;:%s5i§ E3' '£325 Tribunal ,
4. 'We havfi heard learnefi caunsei--::,;§§;3;es:?i:1.g f_s§r'«V. the Cgrgoratiozz; and 1€aI'1'1€§:=.__COf§;E§7ES'€}'*,3;}Z%p€8;§"?§f1§ '=§;:;:;~ ciaémanis 3: sgnsicierabie légigfih A
3. fifter carsfzfi p€fL:S$%§: 37$':.é;€'%}f':§%£A§SAbfi§;'i;g;,§&'Si€ 9:: ffia inc}:/zdizzg 'g:;:;i}g;=.:¢g: 352$ azaaré pagsed by thé {ha accarrezzcs of ihe 3f ihe deceassé are mg)»: sinergsg fiat? Eh:-:=:
éecsasgsgfi }7€8§S? zvgrkéng as Ssném"
Area EV§a:€;:z.g 5::, $3. S.. :'§;u§§§ar:3i Pgway @3923 Liséfiifié, a3'::.<v?:'i::§rv e;i)%"§§V:g% 'é§"{€'S%Eaf}7 sf ?:,§:3§E,f~ $85" §¥"if'Ei§§'?2 33 gig? E;§§;';§;:3g§~§s8;iz?%fI':;?"§$'3}f"§§fi€a§€. As gar this §E'§.i'§€3§§E$ fax gfafi far 3:316 ?:S$$§;%:éi:;é::;i "€63: §§§8~E§§§ sézzce 3:6 aaciééiixé Esazag _@f:{:2.2:"L;t$€i'«;_:%;': $335 jgéar §§§§§ ?;6§5i§8{},/-- :73 §}§;€§T§§3*E€'£§ ifmfii '~ "':?::;és3 'f:5:§ éiag, E? 'aim :~'§{:3'£1'E€ is §€§3;E;C'{,€§ am 35 §E,§§§:3§'§,;"~ ieéaé camag is %.'5§§3L3§E,,f~ 333:" fififléiffi» £33}: 9%"
éarhisfig if E§'1%i ETEEAESE/~} éedézcésfi Eewayfigg Ezzizazgzs §§&i5§EE§ rsggffi 'Ea '%:%::€~: §a§:s $315; <{':iZ"{i'z§_§E:S'{8;§}{3€$ 5}:
9,1';
Taxg ihg i1"i€3OI:3€ aemsg ta: %'LE8§2i§,:'~ fig t§:";3.,j§ if §@8§$GG/'~ is a&ée<:L ihe égiai §i'}€§I1f1€ %'i,'?8$218/~ per &1'}E'£%_3H"3.. Gut Sf zafhizcg '§?j_;'f§$'§ fie::1§,:ct«sd 'icsvsards ihe p€§'s&r;a.11;.é;g:fi::A4i;:7£rgg '1 '<f33T<;§é:§;§;e''é' VVQ_f'« the daceasfifig the 25:6': §::€$:::€_§:@:rié:~;§§3 3} , agpmpréats Efiuiéigiier ap§£:c§b§€* SQ thVé'~:?§isz$': iéfifigafzég fig in visa; af $336 E3$€§;f':M§ai:i'_VA é{;~'§;7§§;§/E~.VQ:§:§{%..'§f§T1§3 Agszvi Cami in Sarla. E?erma's__<:aseA,..§%épé;:*:§éVéf.»L AC3 1298? instead af fl;-.3' afiépigé §};~.:§;%é""i'":*3Zb*a:1a§ sémcs fihe sisgsaseé :aéas'*~-sggged §_£3@i2--éi ygarse '§h€ref0;fa, ears :e~ éséerrfzgrzs --§§:€§,§Q4S':§"€>§"vv--§;i$§3.%:::d€:'1c§' at €i§fl{}9§?§,z'- isssésad 3-5 '€'*§,6§%;1:§'i"}§L¥;" :fl"".aé.7es'a:'§€d by fiaé '§':*i%z2:":a§ arzd aQC.@;fi°'d5§:3;;{§ja;: 33;. %W§.§'5;§§. éi"
':hé'=<:'a$%;':; -€%§:$A'T§§€a§é 5. 323:3; 5:2' §E€.}.fi3i}§;"~ '§{:;Wa:*d;$ 3933 :3? §::3::S::§"§§é.,::§:, §§§£§{3@;"~ 'éiGi?'«§&§'§S 3833 $2? €§':3::a %'é&%§Gg'~ » *é%;;*é;i?5,..§§s £333 3? Ems %':E€§ 5ff€§§i§Q§§ aafli %E%§§§{},f'- E§"%i«'3;:"{"§§ §I"&'§'}$§§E"§3§;§G§E and "m:aa::"a§§ €}<::_§}€'i"§%€Ss Z3 89 fag' as {he Sp€{E§f§{'f ground ta§%:€',?1.Vv_:L§f§%%T~..:E"ie Eeargsd mzzzzsei 53:' the ifarparatisfi ihat, might {(3 have: fixéd the eentrébzgiory n$g£1gé:;éé"~a§:':.Vi§<:_¢ ' par: cf ihe driver 35 the maio? czggcii' €é::ée:i:3«i LL:é:§1{t5:€. is EEG su§sia_::c€ H} {ha s¢:i:%.._Vsubfi:iss:snT' Vb}? §}€ Carparaiioyz azzd {figs sa;33$___;Zu§"v:§§3;%3_}ne ":€:;§e£?€€é 232:: ~{§,)1§.€Sh$;¥&§ fgr' {he réa-:..=;é13 '4 3;i1é3_''E'r§bur:a¢3 fits: a;s$ess§::g me 0:33" EXEE ta ?fi €$1;i§}§€d svifif: has rscordeé 131$ fizzding .Gf.%%:§::' ' *gharge~sh€&i has beer: éieé a,:;g.'_ai::s§V :_§;:e E123 beiangizzg £9 £38 {f{3:°§@:'3;iié:*s.3 €23 §E2_€73é;§;:§7 bag 3:33 fiasézesf agaiéggfz {ha Eiiniifgggriéaa e§"*£'E";,e.___:;3:;>i€_>:" c};€fi€ bearifsg §'§G.§'i?§..§3¢§§}§43 ;*r;_:'s.?E::§$%*;V "§E<:$-.:i8€:€3;$§£:E Was; 3 fiééiaz: rééezfz E'*:;:"£*":.§r, EE: is Sigfiéfiéazfi7f;';:;a.5'::@?£€ ihaa imsgée Q? géafzfag gufféséafii {}§§8§'§':;§§"i§§}?; 32$ €@r§0§a€:'@:i: has fgiiaéi '$53 €}:8£i§§E'i6 $16 ~%§E*zi§*é§*"~«§§ {he gffsmééfig Vazaizicés $3" 3:533; Qihaf §%:'1§€§€§E€§§}fE§ .._""'?£§::%2e:3s€8 $0 aé 53:2 siigbgléazs GE" rgjeci £333 €3<;'21'Ef§1'E§S sf iésas V , : §i{}€%.iE'§:€f§{af':s? eézéaieacs pafiairzigizg :9 {f:§é§"::€ fig, 3:35;' E§§§ ,,~2.
§\E'::s,?§:E§[iiGG%3 ié hsrébg? gnaéifieég 4.afia%§¢?§ifig ,» ,' Qampsnaaiégn Q5 %'E9,é1§,!976/~ :§r:si€a§ cf ??i.§;'§'}V2f;é§}:€§%;§.g~M.V awaréed by 'ihe Tribunafi. "$126 s§;}2a;3;€€:'C§""c<§é:::":,§€;:sg:i€}:i"
CQEIESS is %'9,383?5;- 'With §23té;ijesfj"z:.%f:'5%._§;é;;$ éais of psiiéimz iii: big reaiéégtilga.
E336 Carperaiégn ._fiS;:::0s:'.t {E36 snhaficfié £s3:33;ae::5éL'i£;§1§., xzséiéféin {Gui Weskg fmm "éf;«:~;i1;$€6 ?§'3i§ judgmeaé $52136 awaré ' ' éi<;1;::%.p€:;:3$a:i@:: ef ?9,3&§'?§;_§
3. .as:€r:;€§ Eaziareesi shafi E36 §E"i'€§3S§€§ wig} :§2€ '§%'EX;s3d'W«§E?€§<>$:": :3: 5:23}? Y'*§a§§9EE3.§§S€é $1"
Sgézéjijzéiuéfi«,..énvih,€ §£8;:'EE€ $1? {E§8;.§§Zf§EEE}§£ Ewfav 2, ii}? 2:i::2:%;S':::"a§«Q§§€§;§ .;"§£E:': Eéééséégf is 'ahei: SE3/imgm'; Ezfaé fig a2%§*;§:'?:iifa:%f i'Ei€§§E§£¥E'€S§ 8;€:€§"'£;€:§ 3:: E1; §3€:'§:3é§s:;§§§§,?, 593 $36 ' V 17%f€§f8;T§'€3 9:'? daézzxazié Q, E? _ V 'cg gzgm {E5 §3§Q§§{I%{}@;'» 253:3: assmjiaé ézzéeifisé siizagéfi fgsé §§:::?€:<s'f{§i§ ii: 31%: ?§:<;§§ Ssggsziéséfz £3: 8.§}§£' §33;fi.:T@r:3§:*$€é :33' §'%dEdB ii zééifis asféézzzgééfii 'S 531 a 321% M__M.,..,§2\ §€§'§G§ 92" §:Zv€ }*"€3i'S azéé £"€}":€'i«'§8:%§E f::>z= amaihss fiv$:_ §«*€a:*s észiih §§§€:'?:}' :6 118:' to withdraw 'ihs inierssi g it, perisciicaiiy, ; E 5 gzfiiafi 4% ' 535;: 2253 V}: K, ._M >'°-"*--'""""'*->~/-4~>»»~ The rsméining gum.
grepariianata }::fi?;€I"€3S§ shaéi-.___'@e :**:éIjéa<;ed.'Vi::._* v§g;«*a:;';r £35 2 isiaimafié, EEEQQL £:n:::edi&§€Iy';. {3}}, dé::§é§§§ by the} U_#M_M_MN»b_M _. ..V 'v_______,_W,,_,V__A~.,_ ___,,,w_f.., E Corperafien. 5 5%' "WWW;
'Q26 statzziory {Es§;<:%$}*;%ié::;§g:d:2"vg3:¥,?"'~,{i?1€ Caygeraiiem ghali be _:%i=fanJ$§':f:f3_ii:V£€}<§_ -z:j<3 séiicsraefi 'E'r:bm:aE I:iEI}i'§Z€{§}:_§S{§'$§§a'e ' 19' C3 *''""'1"":
W' ('3 ("in § Q".
W W} ('3 C" 'V ("TI m« \'"""i*' .
mfi ., M_ W 5% ,4.' W"
{'0 53.3 W "*3 55*"
$33 {"3 ("'33 C?
'''''i fl» fiwflm a?
«W *3:
%%@§i§i@% gfggéigfigfiifgéiga gégi 22% é:%2% £°%§§§%;i§; 32% 53% ég:%:§Z%%§§?%g"w§ 2 «, fig? $§ gm 3 zg"§?;%: =;y%%:::z"%i::;::%:% igifigggé: fiééééi . g 8% "Q, § fig gt: § k W Q49 ; ay %% i,§:,%§%;%€:%%€§; 2%; %§§;K§§a;'§ $3; zgw Mmzvfi €V::'.§'2:», ax? 3?: & §%§§%§%§fi% % %%:%%§ @% ififi §%$%§$%£§ ifié 6 y5V'"% fig %%§§§ g§&§%§ §%§%%é%E% féi %$ &@§ aw % % ,_ ,3 £35"! é gg %J«Jér.z- :3 y/«Aw 3;
E .9, ..!..
3.551. .
ea §:§§{§% 5
4. .,£