Karnataka High Court
Mr Guru Prasad vs S A Rudraradhya on 1 April, 2010
Equivalent citations: 2010 (4) AIR KAR R 772
Author: Subhash B.Adi
Bench: Subhash B.Adi
'V V' {imfiéfi {fits fgaéii ES?
';§e3;.<:€i{3§: 38 53:?" Ehssé Ac?' :»m:'§ m9,3'%;e , ...:¢\ §fl§gr<_f§>/}~é£_;3g WEEE2. tfiszfi ' ;1es=:;.::fu3 ;3{>s;§;«:1s3£§i::v:'€-«:42§:.£§ §:33'<:»§,?:"u«;t:1% 21:5 suit. s«:7};:€€§;22.§-:3 ;;é1*::s;:v:::*€3Z€:§ E}§§4"9g:*:-ztgiézéigé s::»:%:::%a=:§' zztf §}€IT§E}.££}1€I'§'§T é:.:§12:1{:::Z§1:V.57. ._ 'E.'§::€: ail {'34 girmgwzrftrzée in Eizee A2134;'§:T;i£$.'VL'-ifalézzéifirfin fi1{:§; §.;9-$8 6470:' $E"1:3z"::3:VV"1f3"1=&';i%<*..$'}_ £:§.:¥§;i' {"f'..>'a3 $ sf R3,"?":':":§;' -1 i"}efa--":11«:£:«1:t.11:4s3 §i§<:*.:*§. '§E:.::~r.i:~. T21;::*§!:f£.§€5§"é;_%'~ v«1fi:»a3°!' fmm €§¥f:.'£":'§JL"}g tb5=:
gsiaiigiiifs §:§.;%«:i::i=; $3261; A2:§..;<_«*é<:';r":§1:£:~";%:§<:::3<:{i 'ha %.:aE's.:aét:L,:"2 émafi ' £1 fiizizsvyizicéza a§s:;=3€ tg2§,é4.i':§iff. SE3 rfiguéi, L-U4 .1 gm" :':3g,;='3;1.:§$ >V{€&%3;£':::£:--:i:.ig::2. (sf C»=:::m"€: éka far Eizfi fmirlfif $<:;=z,2g%:¥:: in :§::i€£.;:, En '%f§:£:s:§' :'«:g:~.'a:*§§.5 tazz :a§:§rsii.:3ié§3:: fem' iiiraaféémz ':5; gag:
{'19 . firm axfag 3&9 éiizrtii 3:13;" aka; aiifigézgg 2323.? iii;
éé'i':i§:..§~: $35 022%: $3? <?fi§':C{'i§;§;?§§".§{}§E <12'? e:§$s:%.:::v:e:%:§ 3:2. ? §"§7§§ 'z;:3£;§;:"
E 'a?:«Ii§'i;';fi E-:'::9;§ 'ii, 22;: sistaraéézzgé us; $32": £33 {£383 :>f $231; axgzii saisag %.:§.,.::§§:";;" $§i€f'?E0};'} ;E§:§{a} 5:? 31%: ?s;»;":'§..
t:'§":e=* ";:2i:a:i;1¥;§.'E§ §33':i.i';:.f'§7§§:is::1§E3"' 1%. 'k§€§'iiS€"§iéf§'t3,§§;' '$31932: 6:5! aL'--.§23"v=;:1izx:§§3..%a2"§-* iSSL.€ azxai 2,";
%"""n :4: hctlci $3333: $135 {f.'>::s":_.:' W. «4 L;
Mm ";§7§'.i'§ ';%%:§éii'3'§2.~5; .5.§.uo\§{% . A 43" §;:~i:::t:-f:€§ <:=::=:m$§é§ fray ?eE'é.-ii;=:::ers;'§§&:f€3":'3;2%3:?;s§ "2, 5?; &--;
_§éi;; "i3':2?§~i. ;}:aa5: .;53£"'§L $5; :3 §f::a.¥.uf.f.§: ms-{E it Eizas Esq: be E.§?:'§{§{"$i'§;':'g.}:5iE"§"§.{?'E1§?1§" °g>msé<s§'*§ 3? {:22 :'%~:7§., ii: .?§%_'f:E3€,"}§ E3: §'3I'*£3"éi§.§£.'§.§Z, °:.§.z2§é%:,é." genizmi §}§"{,'fi.?!:§fi§3%'§§ m":x;§::':3' gzizftéfiezz i.2'--'--§{:§} :2}? tin aC§,. ii:
€§:fr2;§.s3 ::'§:g2§.2re:§§ he $%§i{}§311:?i€{§ '§§;:»:é£., saciiasx 33% Sf $3.6 fiaifi éE§}'§:*§.€$ $36. aa:,:i:::.r;i'%:ti:::%{§ 'iT:;2:»2E tgige 25,1; §;§:3: sszrugghi. 53:" §:§t; £25 g:;€i:i?;1's:::.:2£:«:$ <§5'»""'§ 2-r"":
"3;.'1:3::: Eaarimzd {":€'}"'.lI}.S€} far §2€{.i'fi()1'1€}','i~'; sazbmii. ' E11314 k»E'}.f-:3 E aliegaai aiieeii éatésii 3(}.€37.2€,3C*<'%, t.i:%:€:*:':::a&; 131:3 :~?-,:,§_i§$,s*:: 9,11% fslétri in $336 gem" 28045: 'E'?m:: €ffi:;}'L1:"'{. E3:::': is 236 paid is 5:1 E1115: ~.,:9.111<: :3:-2 £31': ifiim fiat" Lf 5-;1_3i's'. zgad n<:3'i, 213 e:=.: :" :'*t}.':{:_ '£3.":'5E1S~i-1{T'£".3,{3fi. ..
'E2. {Eu thrsr ether 2:312:13 1c:z=.1"f§3r.:':d £§€Z""¥f£Y.'1&;s€§ f?;$';".. gagbmits tizza-1., 31:: $;,1§ts:: aréi :1§2?_._ §¥::-3; ~:ta,u:£c,*::-:_EE23tie:':_ -;V¥f_Vééi"§; 'Vfifififii " €,<¥is?*?:":7::::.:§ f}«:=*z1:*:r:-2}.
3223 {ha 31.3%; 935 931-2: ,. W ,_A §3C}'é$.7€?}Z'§3 cf A1:"£91;'s3,ét3g :32 §§§<;g(§gg!_§_,gi 1;"; mg gzsiaitztiéfié; :+::*«:?; 'f%}'.'T3V§":V§3?;;Z1V'.{V?%r?:}7g§, ;¥'~:2°2>«,?§3rs; <:{§._ A.-£'h./._ z5«*'§e3:5v=m§'. i§«:. éf:@i;. Eéfmdizzgk E1:
§2:2E3;¥j;33Z'£.i§.:{€ £113?" sgémiiic z»1§:a3:*:;1&::% is mafia 31:1 'QR? pt 5}fL*;1'E.§ ?.E:.r«,2_:', §§§§'.§;=§~f:?ii}.§3Lff8 Ezavas: ma: axecutecé Pewerg ef .--3€Eif.3£'§1€}=* 3.21%.
' 2.13:3; ii:
:3 H4.
v-we _.~ ."<*5 :2?"
if?
:3 < 25% ' m{ mg. . "
pad I rm?-
1%?
smut {:12 Wk W 33?, fig fan! 55?.» ('1:
"E It:
('X3 "E ém E €33 ta} (33 he M WW 'yunf ('S in We !' ' :,~:aZ*"3::§:§V"§a§i Lmgiar 3:3:::':£_,.::z: 24{{§} sf ...,,.5 kit 3%»: :13 23:3:
?. E6 ,s.u'tf:;m* s':1bmii1:{*,a£ firzai. {ff-r::-mft. fafi 1r1.9a.3"-.f::'si:?;&.1:":
r::§:_E€.:u.Ea1.ed <31: the Eyzzséis (3%? cgizsésifizfiaiien 'i1I1*£§*f:"1" -.:_;§i;*.»$:*§ and gsrapaér {f1r..m:'*i.i 3712?. has E35231: paigi.
8. Reatifixg {if §3Z'§§§-'43}f'§§ ciaarigf ':12? 31:';-.?%;_.,A' .}.:_a»'§£:' _i}2~:=._ am Sfifikiilg éfflflflfifififififl «sf rfigsiéfied ?{i"2'-:-i€x':~:: .{>f'-s"'s.fx§I§:i*§4'I;£€?<~,: ii; ig "
:s::~:§'f;. ifl s:iis;1«m:€§ ihafi. i:%;::,. $316 :;ie::¢c:_¥..:'fsi*:~.«3é_*~;--».}3<:§:I;'1 £é:i:%t§::2.:i§{i E213; the allegad Rswers €31" .!3;§iQ1'Z£€}' .2§3v:Z .'Vé«v..,>,V 1:313 piaénti 3. HI" it iggae," "§§?'hf: 23T3;5:31' ?:'i:;:§:.V 3:*:§sii.v.:!.5;i'f$ :3:=;:3m3-§::d ;3:'Q":%?'€1"?:i§ (if Et;'§*:fi;i":2€:¥' w fcfiis 'it;§5§;eV":*égiste:2*§2{E 3:315: sziged €33' mat is 1n$a.€,.t;é:5_ if} 3:'sea'«v<'%:{.:>2.::i=':v.:3.,;};'§=;" $9;/iai, H':§'-.£?Et"*.?EI', {E162 :r~;':_1§?§:s; «:'..£a:'§:s; .9 %. Eh?
§.;§§.{§.3:{':£%'§'i€ ¥:i:l2;:;§. $352!: §2§:a.$:i3L§7f*é§ 9:55: fiestkizzw ¥'?§:<;:§:2:'at§€3::s '?:.?:2_at .. .. .-:-';~:«*<_§'r:41:""¢.*:§.:*::e<u:§ fiVXEi{:1E;:%<""§...?3:?A'€;§".§€'::§,}Z aiitzgvsrii §9'02=%:*:~§ (3? fi"§f§'.m"11&y is 239%, Eéiwzsiimg iimm, '"§'§a€' §if}§fi&"E1€§2?;..._,i1'E 0:" zzaizare ma be €§,7§..;?;:i"<%r:":§§. -"_'"?§::€i>: €§'€«:3"§ {}f m:«::%: {§e:5§a::'3€"é~:}z1 amgugztg €:.:::= a::.a§y:t.r;§a§:L<'sé: {sf {'§§§{§ 39; agaéiizsi. ';}:.2.§ 33:5 gégzzsameék AA§§'7§"?.EE'*--,? zbpézziegg '$5: méééf i;{:s!;:g§'£ fa: §.::'g E335: gzséaizsiifia {t§§:2;r§};
"§T%.§§;$ ififififif asariian 3-8 5:25 §§}.€ s§<':i:, as '$1345 §29;itz%%:i§§3 "fi1&§E$$§'%.3'€S w'a7;':%i. 1:11: fgéti. zié af $16: 331% aieeeri azzrzi §3{)5'aE-'€E"'§ <;f.fi:§§.s::§";:e§;, if §f}&? $w§.£.5; fiéi amtciiiz" S§€':{Z'.§'§;€)E} 3% «:2? {he ,5a{';§,, S&{",'§',3;?Z}1'£ 38 3":Eq:;;:é:'s$ '<2.
"'M::>{%:s.i>1:4;ed on bshaii' (3?
Q r':"'"'' EE E::2;rz::~:-<3 a:::n.3:/33:21 Em" siaixzzfifg s~;:';bmi%"£s3si i§1:«1¥; time g':V2Véfi..fi.§E:r:s E31"? §:{;=t §€i§L'${,.511§,€ awiziészxca fer fiat: p1.11";_:x<;:«3€ cs? «:1$€£:féii£:1.%;%§2¥:§xé ;:3f'> $3.:/2;§1;:a:».s!:2Z{3:'z ami $'s.1§;3:<nit'§=5c£ ma? it 2113 sifipaniis; 9.33, _{§;%: i2.%:%;mr€: {ff r3r<::§;:g:"i.y, 314:3 1~:>c,at3L-:: zmsi Ehasz ;:~::r;:«::»s@_ £51': 'é::§:iéh'«.;i€' £i$;;:_€i' an-zi 31:5; }:m2$§<:&€T traizzs has; 152:: hi? ¢e:£si.Q;é:'£€§ <33}. -71:31:91' }3aé:is k3§ .rt%1r::v2e;::1%; m:a.t,€:"ia£$. §3;*L",'t"iZEI:%}. v2§;"é12%¥'éf}i3»{)f *;E1€''f}1'¥:§}$é-:"§T§7' §1:¢3$ 1;, mi ;.
s:§;&:r::2"2:::inr:é by thg tzéai 's':§_}'t§.§"{."'V§'§3*"§§'£3;5i,, L6 gliiiécifiizzea may 1%!' §3i€€;.'e szzsf gzziziisziines J§3:'=:_"s"£.:'.¥:*3VAA'VVi:1%;:~'§7 13$ :.'%e:>:_s.<::11;asixg.3 izaiuatiazi 9:32:11 §.3.E--f3.fW...=.~:4fi::"i1§: ;}s£€§a:*5.4:i?i§i--i:a¥§e":tz:% adai 219%: mzagiaxiai :0 Ehe :'~:¢;a'§_i§~:i":ie::§1?'~:%z":«V._:fi°7 3&4':-:v_ Eriai --{ff-¥:2u:"§.' '§'ha gaziaiieiine "aé'83?;3H'§i€}"E1, 51* 2:22;}? *c":!.'~."?_E.*§'*i§4E53?7.3"£fi,."'EEA, éf.§*.>§::4'{:*iz*:%:1:1g<3%3;2:c¥:2;, E fazzei %:E:s.:~..1:§ {E5333 > :'€%é;§';1i;'e$ 2*s:{:a3::$%;§§.€:m§iQ..:.
. 1 Ti. .%=:3_%Q;fl:§5g:gE:?, 333:': wt:"§.€:T §€'E"}:.'§'i=Z}"£"}S arr: :«':§§0'§'E='€:{§. ;§§';§}é:g%:.:ec§ QE'{§.€"E" is fizmsitiegi.
:*§a.€t.$:*$ am rfimmiaiagi £23.: {E5 fizéai {ffi{;:;::": '2%s°§€.§iz :22 ' ;§£z'i:e;":"§r§3§§ {<2 .3 é3€::{3§;$§dm* £33333 34:3, in {'§.§.§*€':a$;. 'iE%§%§§12{}€[}€» : mi [E33L""fi.3I,€}6 33:25 isgiizi E'-=§f3_5§ in €3,i§.:5"§a:a§.:',~i§"?f';E{}{§%? {BE}: Egéxs ia:-"mils; sf mgisréaé 313$; a*;'%zi:i€::€::::*€ §H:<3e:%::::tae:i E22? £335'? §3E§;E'§§€3S; {:12 ms $a'£i$f:«:cié:;fi;'1 s:\.-ii
2 ,«--~ kw of ?f§.'.3,€ 33%.? €T>:3:2'§'?;., A' gzzzéfijfiiéi 11::-.:i:.'é.~::z" 22;; cm thif "
§€.";?;'"{"fiiE'.§f';E{f§ 5.3%: ::a&1:;:> £fi§f'2§:§f;?{§éiz'3:::i;._ ::f;s::*' 1;l..€ Si:2=:i::s:% xvzfizim »m_1.«:f "s.%?€€§»{S"f§€_1*§£}£E'§Ii.:{§.E§:§~é§' _ ' :53 retgzariig m$::§~A'k§§
-'*3 .' E? @513:'u1zx:3::.;§.E:ara§sa§i:« '»§€2a3:1:€€§ Wit.
Fudge €'"?a:>2a:'§, E-'&§":fi,§L, €§€?§;.€3:"1':}§?:}€ 0:322':-*::%£._{?<::::"§ 'fir<_:€ --.§;~§:;;;;:§7.{§e _. £12, §~§.{ff.€.f%.?
fig §'€::"~:fig2(::.1":«:§&::t.~ 'I